The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. The materials on record would reveal that earlier Smt. X was enlarged on bail by the High Court as per order dated 27.06.2023 in connection with FIR No.22(03)2023, involving the quantity of 55.68 grams of Heroin, despite the opposition of the public prosecutor, taking note of her being HIV positive. In the said order it is stated thus: 30. Accordingly, on this ground alone, the application for grant of bail is hereby allowed.
10. The subject FIR viz., FIR No. 06(02)23 under Section(s) 21(c)/29 of the NDPS Act, would reveal that the quantity of the contraband involved is 1.040 kgs of heroin. The impugned order granting bail to accused-Smt. X, dated 29.09.2023 would reveal, this time also, the bail was granted on the ground that she is suffering from HIV and conspicuously, without adverting to the mandate under Section 37(1)(b)(ii), NDPS Act, even after taking note of the fact that the rigour of Section 37, NDPS Act, calls for consideration in view of the involvement of commercial quantity of the contraband substance. When the accused is involved in offences under Section 21(c)/29 of NDPS Act, more than one occasion and when the quantity of the contraband substance viz., heroin is 1.040 Kgs, much above the commercial quantity, then the non-consideration of the provisions under Section 37, NDPS Act, has to be taken as a very serious lapse. In cases of like nature, granting bail solely on the ground mentioned, relying on the decision in Bhawani Singh v. State of Rajasthan:(2022) SCC OnLine SC 1991 would not only go against the spirit of the said decision but also would give a wrong message to the society that being a patient of such a disease is a license to indulge in such serious offences with impunity. In the contextual situation it is to be noted that in Bhawani Singh’s case the offence(s) involved was …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.74 of 2024
Shahid Miah on behalf of accused of Jaynal Miah
-----Applicant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
-----Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. S. Sarkar, Sr. Adv,
Mr. D. Gope, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.,
Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
27/11/2024
This bail application under Section 439 of Cr.P.C. is filed for
granting release of the accused person-in-custody Shri Jaynal Miah
on bail who is lodging in jail in connection with A. D. Nagar P.S. Case
No.72 of 2023 under Section 120(B)/212 of IPC and Section
20(b)(ii)(c)/25/29 of NDPS Act, 1985 read with Section 3 of Passport
(Entry into India) Act, 1920.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S. Sarkar assisted by
Learned Counsel, Mr. D. Gope appearing on behalf of the accused
person-in-custody and also heard Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta along
with Learned Addl. P.P., Mr. Rajib Saha on behalf of the Staterespondent.
In pursuance of the earlier order, Learned P.P. has produced
the Case Diary.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S.
Sarkar first of all drawn the attention of the Court that in the case at
hand from the contents of the FIR, it is not clear that the contraband
items was actually seized from the residence of the accused personin-custody because prosecution in this regard could not submit any
documentary evidence before the Court. Learned Senior Counsel
further submitted that since last 240 days the accused is lodging in
jail and furthermore, the prosecution in this case has failed to comply
with the provision of Section 42(2) of NDPS Act and furthermore, the
minor son of the accused person-in-custody is suffering from dengue
for which Learned Counsel submitted that the accused may be
released on bail in any condition. Since the IO of this case has laid
the charge-sheet against the accused-in-custody, Learned Senior
Counsel also in support of his submission further submitted that if at
this stage if it is not possible to grant regular bail so in pursuance of
the judgment of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court reported in (2016)
SCC OnLine Del 6662 (Athar Pervez vs. State) dated
26.02.2016 he may be released at least on interim bail for the
purpose of treatment of his minor son and referred para No.22 of the
said judgment:
“22. By its very nature, "interim" bail is a
temporary liberation for a fixed period of time.
It is a bail on pro-tem basis. [See Sunil
Fulchand Shah v. Union of India:(2000) 3 SCC
409 and Mukesh Kishanpuria v. State of West
Bengal:(2010) 15 SCC 154]. "Interim" bail
should not and cannot be a substitute and an
alternative for regular bail. It should be
granted for the minimal time deservedly
necessary.”
Learned
Senior
Counsel
also
submitted
that
since
the
investigation is complete and the IO has laid charge-sheet and the
accused himself surrendered before the Court so there is no chance
of absconding or to evade from the trial and also there is no chance
of tampering evidence on record of the prosecution by the appellant.
So, Learned Senior Counsel urged for granting bail to the accused.
On the other hand, Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta along with
Learned Addl. P.P., Mr. Rajib Saha appearing on behalf of the Staterespondent strongly objected the bail application and submitted that
this case was registered on 28.12.2023 on the basis of Suo Moto
complaint laid by one SI Sankar Das but the accused was found to be
absconding and later on he surrendered on 01.04.2024 and since
then he is lodging in custody and by this time, the charge-sheet has
been submitted by IO within time. So, at this stage there is no scope
to release him on bail. Learned P.P. further submitted that the
contraband item of commercial quantity was seized from the
residence of the accused and another accused was arrested in
connection with this case who was later on ordered to be released on
bail as per order dated 11.07.2024 passed by Learned Special Judge,
Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala. Learned P.P. in support of his
contention referred one citation of this High Court reported in
(2023) SCC OnLine Tri 777(State of Tripura Represented by
Ld. Public Prosecutor vs. Mahabul Alam & Ors.) dated
27.09.2023 in B.A. 23 of 2023 wherein in para No.17 this High
Court observed as under:
“17.
From the aforesaid enunciations of law
on the subject, it is abundantly clear, that the
Courts while considering the application for
bail must strictly adhere to the two conditions
embodied in Section 37 of the NDPS Act, and
must record its reason of satisfaction that
there are substantial probable causes for
believing that the accused is not guilty of
committing such offence and that there is no
likelihood of repetition of committing such
offence by the accused while on bail. It is reiterated that while considering the bail
application filed by the accused arrested under
the penal provisions of NDPS Act, learned
Special Judges should be confined within the
limits embodied in Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
Procedural violations, if any, shall be taken into
consideration during the course of trial, and
not at the stage of consideration of bail
application.”
Referring the same, Learned P.P. submitted that if there is any
procedural irregularities in that case the same may be considered
only during the stage of ‘trial’ not during the stage of hearing on bail
application.
Learned P.P. also relied upon another citation of the Hon’ble
Apex Court reported in (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1751(State of
Meghalaya
vs.
Lalrintluanga
Sailo
and
Anr.)
dated
16.07.2024 wherein in para Nos.8, 9 and 10 observed as under:
“8. Thus, the provisions under Section
37(1)(b)(ii) of the NDPS Act and the decisions
referred supra revealing the consistent view of
this
Court
that
while
considering
the
application for bail made by an accused
involved in an offence under NDPS Act a liberal
approach ignoring the mandate under Section
37 of the NDPS Act is impermissible. Recording
a finding mandated under Section 37 of the
NDPS Act, which is sine qua non for granting
bail to an accused under the NDPS Act cannot
be avoided while passing orders on such
applications.
9. The materials on record would reveal that
earlier Smt. X was enlarged on bail by the High
Court as per order dated 27.06.2023 in
connection with FIR No.22(03)2023, involving
the quantity of 55.68 grams of Heroin, despite
the opposition of the public prosecutor, taking
note of her being HIV positive. In the said
order it is stated thus: 30. Accordingly, on this ground alone, the
application for grant of bail is hereby
allowed.
10. The subject FIR viz., FIR No. 06(02)23
under Section(s) 21(c)/29 of the NDPS Act,
would reveal that the quantity of the
contraband involved is 1.040 kgs of heroin. The
impugned order granting bail to accused-Smt.
X, dated 29.09.2023 would reveal, this time
also, the bail was granted on the ground that
she is suffering from HIV and conspicuously,
without
adverting
to
the
mandate
under Section 37(1)(b)(ii), NDPS Act, even
after taking note of the fact that the rigour
of Section 37, NDPS Act, calls for consideration
in view of the involvement of commercial
quantity of the contraband substance. When
the
accused
is
involved
in
offences
under Section 21(c)/29 of NDPS Act, more than
one occasion and when the quantity of the
contraband substance viz., heroin is 1.040 Kgs,
much above the commercial quantity, then the
non-consideration
of
the
provisions
under Section 37, NDPS Act, has to be taken as
a very serious lapse. In cases of like nature,
granting bail solely on the ground mentioned,
relying on the decision in Bhawani Singh v.
State of Rajasthan:(2022) SCC OnLine SC
1991 would not only go against the spirit of the
said decision but also would give a wrong
message to the society that being a patient of
such a disease is a license to indulge in such
serious offences with impunity. In the
contextual situation it is to be noted that in
Bhawani Singh’s case the offence(s) involved
was not one under the NDPS Act. We have no
hesitation
to
say
that
in
the
above
circumstances it can only be held that the twin
conditions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act,
are not satisfied and on the sole reason that
the accused is a HIV patient, cannot be a
reason to enlarge her on bail. Since the
impugned order was passed without adhering
to the said provision and in view of the rigour
thereunder the accused-Smt.X is not entitled to
be released on bail, the impugned order invites
interference.”
Finally, Learned P.P. urged for rejection of the bail application
of the accused person-in-custody considering the nature and gravity
of the offence.
I have seen the FIR and the other relevant prosecution papers.
It is the admitted position that the IO in this case after completion of
investigation has laid charge-sheet against the accused before the
Learned Jurisdictional Court.
From the relevant prosecution papers, it appears that the
alleged contraband item was recovered from the residence of the
accused on the alleged day. May be at the time of the registration of
this case, the accused absconded however, he later on surrendered
on 01.04.2024 and till then he is in custody. The IO has also filed the
charge-sheet within the specified period as prescribed in law.
Further, at this stage there is no materials before this Court to
presume that the accused is not guilty of committing any offence and
there is no likelihood of repetition of committing such offence by the
accused while on bail as required under Section 37 of NDPS Act.
Furthermore,
it
appears
that
the
contraband
item
of
commercial quantity was seized from the residence of the alleged
accused. So, in view of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the aforenoted case, at this stage considering the
nature and gravity of the offence, I do not find any scope to consider
the bail application of the accused person-in-custody. Hence, the bail
application filed stands rejected. The accused is to remain in J/C as
before. However, since the IO by this time has laid charge-sheet so
the Learned Special Judge, Court No.4, Agartala shall make all
endeavour to proceed trial with the case giving priority. Thus, this
bail application stands disposed of.
A copy of this order along the Case Diary be returned back to
IO through Learned P.P. for information and necessary action.
A copy of this order also be communicated to Learned Court
below.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJEE Date: 2024.11.28 18:24:01
+05'30'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review