Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
a
[ 3488 I
OF TELANGANA
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE
AT HYDERABAD
FEBRUARY
WEDNESDAY, THE EIGHTEENTH DAY OF
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI
AND
APARESH KUMAR SINGH
THEHoNoURABLESRtJUSTIGEG.M.MoHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL NO: 51 OF 2026
the order
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Filed against
court'
in writ petition No 28608 ot 2024 on the file of the High
Dated 05t12t2025
Between:
wo. Mohd. Suleman, Aged about 38
shaheen Fathima,'Manyamchalka,
R/o. 5-10-296,
years, Unemployee'
BesideJ Veternary Hospital, Venuka,
Nalgonda, Nalgonda District
...APPELLANT
AND
1. The Commissioner of School Education, State of Telangana, Hyderabad
2. The District Educational Officer, Nalgonda, Nalgonda District.
3. The District Collector, Nalgonda, Nalgonda District.
4. State of Telangana, rep., by its Principal Secretary to Government, School
Education Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad
5. Mohd. lrfan, S/o. Mohd. Yousuf, Selected candidate for the post of Physical
Eduation Teacher (Urdu Medium), R/o. 1-54, Bankapuram, Nidmanoor,
Nalgonda District 508 278.
6 Samrath Jahan, D/o. Magdoom lVlohiuddin, Selected candidate for the post of
Physical Eduation Teacher (urdu Medium), R/o. 5-B-8g14, Barkathpura, NT
Road, Nalgonda - 508 001.
t.A. NO:
oF 2026
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court rnay be pleased to direct the
:
I
I
I
Respondents to consider the case of the petitioner for appointment to the post
of
Physical Educar:ion Teacher (Urdu) in Nalgonda District
based on her merit obtained
issued in favour of
inDSC2024'ifnecessary,bysuspendingtheappointmentorders
than the petitioner in the
the unofficial respondents who obtained lesser ranking
selection process, pending disposal of the writ appeal'
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI MAMIDI SAI YADAV
CounselfortheRespondentNo'5&6:Kum'K'BHARGAVI'REP'
GUNDAVARAM
SRI SAI PRASEN
SATYANARAYANA
counsel for the Respondent No.1 to 4: sRl SANTHAPUR
SERVICES-I
RAO, GP FOR
The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH COT'RT FOR THE STATE OF TEI,ANGATTA
AT TTYDERABAT)
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JI'STICE SRI APARESH KI'IVIAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL No.S I of 2026
DATE:L8.O2.2o26
Between:
Shaheen Fathima
.Appellant
And
'l'he Commissioner of School Education
and 5 others
Respondents
JUDGMENT
. Heard sri Mamidi Sai yadav, learned counsel for the
appellant; sri Santhapur Satyanarayana Rao,
Pleader (Services-l), appearing for
resp.ndent Nos.l to 4 and Kum.
K'Bhargavi representing sri Sai prasen
for the respondent Nos.S and
Gundavaram, rearned counser
6 and perused the record.
2' This writ appear, preferred under clause
assairs rhe order dated 05.12.2025
Judge in w'p.No.2g6og
learned Government
15 0f the L,etters patent,
passed by the learned Single
of 2024. By the said order, rhe rearned
Judge dismissed rhe writ
petition insritu.ed by the
u'ho had sought a direction
Singre
appellant herein,
to the respondent-authorities
to consider
I
her candidature for appointment to the post of physical Education
Teacher (PET) (Urdu Medium) under DSC-2O24 in Natgonda District.
Factual background (in brief)
3.
Tht: appellant claims to belong to BC .'E' category and to be a
local canrlidate of Nalgonda District, completed her SSC examination
in March , 2oo 1, and thereafter passed the Intermediate examination
in March,2OO3.
4. Appellzrnt subsequently acquired a Bachelor of Arts (8.A.) degree
in April, 2OO7, and a Bachelor of Physical Education (B.P.Ed.) degree
in March/l\pril, 2ol2.ln December, 2014, appellant again appeared
for and pasised the lntermediate examination through the Telangana
open Schoc,l Society (Toss), with urdu as the second
language'
S.Pursuan:toNotificationNo.24lRC-1/TRT/DS,Cl2024dated
2g.o2.2o24issuedbytheCommissionerofschoolEducation,
Telangana,invitingapplicationsfordirectrecruitmenttovarious
teachingpos;rsunderDSc-2o24,theappellantappliedforthepostof
PET (Urdu Ntedium) in Nalgonda
6.
District'
Computer
The allpellant appeared in the
Based Test held on
L8.o7.2024ilrrdsecurcdRankNo.4,*,ith43.50marksintheGeneral
During certificate verification
post'
said
the
for
Lir;t
Ranking
above
05' lO'2024' candidates ranked
to
lO.2024
0l
from
'
conducted
the appellant did not attend, thereby placing the appellant first among
the candida[es who ParticiPated.
7.
However, the appellant's candidature was not considered for
appointment. Aggrievcd by the inaction of the official respondents in
not selecting the appellant and selecting respondent Nos.S and 6
herein, the appellant filed WP.No.286O8 of 2024. The appellant had
also filed an interlocutory application in the said W.P.No.286O8 of
2024 seeking a direction to the official respondents to consider the
appellant's representations dated I l.IO.2024 and 14.IO.2024.
8. By interim order dated t6.to.2024 in w.p.No.28608 of 2024, this
Court directed the respondents to consider her representations. In
compliance rhereof, the District Educational officer (DEo), Nalgonda,
passed a speaking order dated 06.12.2024
rejecting appellant,s claim,
relying upon Guiderine No.S(c) in the proceedings
r'r'hich stipulated that a candidate
who acquired a lower quarification
after acquiring a higher qualification
appellant had obtained her
held ineligible.
The appe,ant accordingly
challenge the said order
thereafter
from TOS. in 2or4, she was
amended the writ petition
and rhe guiderine dated 30.og.2024.
the course of proceedings,
\
would be ineligible. since the
B.p.Ed. degree in 2Ol2 and
secured the Intermediate quarification
9'
dated 3o.0g.2024,
respondent Nos.S and 6
to
During
have placed on
T
record the lact that the appellant had already passed Intermediate in
2oo3 and that her subsequent enrollment in TosS in 20 14 was
contrary to clause 1.2 of the ToSS prospectus, which prohibits
candidates who have already passed lntermediate from enrolling again
for the se.me course.
10.
By order dated 05.12.2025, the learned Single Judge held
that the rejecLion order datecl 06.12.2024, being founded upon
guidelines issued subsequent to the recruitment notification, was
unsustainrrble. Nevertheless, upon examining thc validity of the TOSS
lntermediate certificate, the learned Single Judge concluded
appellant, ,raving already passed Intermediate
that the
in 2003, was ineligible
to enroll agiain tn 2Ol4 and that the certificate
so obtained was uoid
abinitio,etnddismissedthewritpetition.Aggrievedthereby,the
appellant h:es prclcrred the
present appeal'
Contention.s on behalf of the
11.
appellant
for the appellant
Learned counsel appearing
has raised the
contentions as under:
i.ThatthelearnedSingleJudgetravelledbeyondthescopeofthe
petition' as the writ
writ
the
in
sought
rclief
pleactings and
petitionrvasconfinedtoachallcrrgeagainsttherejectionofthe
Medium)
for the pos[ of PET (Urdu
appe lant's candidature
under DSC-2024, which rejection was founded solely on
Guideline No.5(c) dated 30.O9.2024.
ii. That the validity of the Intermediate certificate obtained by the
appellant from the TOSS in 2Ol4 was never the basis of the
impugned rejection order dated O6.L2.2O24. Thus, the learned
Single Judge could not have suo motu embarked upon an
enquiry into the validit_v of the TOSS certilicate and declared
the same uoid ab initio, particularly when TOSS was not
impleaded as a party to the proceedings and no declaratory
relief was sought in that regard.
iii.
That the finding declaring the TOSS certificate uoid ab
inifio was rendered in violation of the principles of natural
justice, as the appellant was never put on notice that the
. validity of her TOSS qualification would be examined. Though
respondent Nos.5 and 6 raised such a contention in their
counter-affidavit, the learned Single Judge, proceeded to
record a conclusive finding affecting the appellant's academic
credentials without framing an issue or affording a specilic
opportunity to address the legal consequences of such a
declaration.
iv. That the prospectus issued by ToSS does not have the lorce
q[ a statutory rule. At bcst, it constitutes conditions governing
enrollment bctween the candidate and the institution. Any
e lleged
violation thereof may give rise to proceedings by TOSS
irr accordance u,ith law, but until the certificate is cancelled by
the competent authority, it remains a valid qualification issued
by a recognized Board.
v. T.eat the selecting authority or the writ Court, in collateral
proceedings, cannot treat such a certificate as void in the
atlsence of any formal cancellation by TOSS, as once a
recognized Board issues a certificate, its validity cannot be
questioned by another authority rvithout due process.
vi. B'r placing reliance on the judgcmgnt of the High Court of
Andhra Pradesh in D. Sudhakar a.nd others a. State of
Andln;ra Pradeshl it is contended that in the absence of a
specific statutory prohibition, acquisition of a qualification
sutlsequent to a higher qualification would not render a
candidate ineligible.
vii.
That the DSC-2O24 notification does not prohibit a
candidate from acquiring a lower qualification after obtaining a
higher one, and that the learned Single Judge himself held
Guirleline No.5(c) to be trnsustainable as it rvas issued after the
recruitment notification. Having recorded such a finding, it
was argued, the learned Single Judge ought not to have
*/
'2org (6) ALD to (AP)
dismissedthewritpetitiononadifferentandindependent
ground.
Contentions on behalf of the respondents
L2. Learned Government Pleader lor Se rvices-l appearing for
respondent Nos.l to 4, and learned counsel appearing
for respondent
Nos.S and 6, have supported the learned Single Judge's
order and
raised the contentions as undcr
i. That the finding recorded by the learned Single Judge regarding
the invalidity of the appellant's TOSS Intermediate certificate
goes to the root of the matter and is sufficient to non-suit
appellant. That if the foundational qualification itself is
the
void' the
appellant cannot claim consideration for appointment to
a post
earmarked for Urdu Medium candidates'
ii. That Clause 1,.2 of the TOSS l)rospectus expressly prohibits
enrollment for Intermediate b)' a candidate who has already
passed the said qualification from another Board and provides
that any certificate obtained by suppressing such fact is liable
to cancellation.
iii. That the appellant, having passed lntermediate in the year
2oo3, '*,as ineligible to enroll again in the year 2or4 and that
the certificate obtained in violation of the said prohibition is
uoid ab initio. The court merelv recognized the legal
B
consequence flowing from the breach of a binding condition and
di,l not usurp the powers of TOSS.
iv. That the issue regarding the validity of the TOSS certilicate was
sp(rcifically raised in the counter-affidavit o[ respondent Nos.5
anrl 6, to which the appellant liled a reply' affidavit dealing with
the said contention. Hence, it cannot be said that the appellant
wasr taken by surprise or denied an opportunity of hearing.
v. That suppression of the earlier Intermediate qualification
amcunted to misrepresentation, rendering the subsequent
certificate a nullity. [t was also argued that the D. sudhakar
(sup::a 1) relied upon by the appellant is distinguishable on
facts, as in the present case the very validit_l'of the qualification
relied upon is under chailenge.
Vi. That a u,rit court, while exercising jurisdiction under
Article
226, is competent to examine u'hether the relief sought is
founded upon a valid and lawful qualification, and that
the
appellant,nothavingapproachedtheCourtwithcleanhands,
was nrlt entitled to any equitable relief'
1g. we hzive taken notc o[ thc respectivc contentions urged and
perused the material on record'
Consideration bY this Court
L4. The main controversy in the present appcal that arises for
is whether the learned Single Judge committed
determination
\
\,
/
anv
error, either of law or jurisdiction, in holding that the lntermediate
certificate obtained by the appellant from the TOSS in December,
2Ol4 is uoid ab initio and, on that basis, dismissing the writ petition.
15. At the outset, it is necessary to delineate the scope of
interference in an intra-court appeal under Clause 15 of the Letters
Patent. Although this Court, in exercise of such jurisdiction, is
empowered to re-examine questions of fact as well as law, it is well
settled that the findings recorded by a learned Single Judge are not to
be interfered with, unless such lindings are perverse, unsupported by
evidence, vitiated by a misappreciation of the material on record, or
suffering from a manifest error of lau,. The appellate Court would be
slow to supplant its own view merely on the ground that another view
is possible.
L6. The fulcrum of the learned Singlc Judge's decision to dismiss
the writ petition is the finding that the appellant's TOSS Intermediate
certificate is uoid ab initio. The admitted factual position is that the
appellant had already passed Intermediate in March, 2OO3 from the
Board of Intermediate Education (BIE) with English as her lirst
language and Telugu as her second language. Notwithstanding the
same, appellant enrollcd w,ith TOSS arrd passed lntermediate again in
December, 2014, with English as first language and Urdu as second
language. clause 1.2 of the Toss Prospectus, which governed
admissions in the year 2014, categorically stipulates that persons
who have already passed SSC/lntermediate from any other Board
shall not enroll again for the same course, and that if any person does
so by suppressing such fact, the certificate is liable to be cancelled
The Clatrse 1.2 is reproduced hereunder:
"1..2 Ssc/httermediate Certiftcate Holders of other Boards should not
enrcll once again for SSC/ Intermediate of 'l'elangana Open School:
Per.;ons who haue alreadg passed SSC/ lnterntediate from any other
Bocrd of Secondary Education/ Intermediate Education of Telangana or
front other states should not enroll for SSC/ tntermediate Course of
Telc'.ngana Open School for ang reason. On the contrary, if anyone
enrc'lls and passes SSC/ Intennediate from Open Schoo/ suppressing the
info.tnation that theg haue already passed SSC/ Intennediate from
another Board, their SSC/ Interntediate pass certtftcates will be
cant'ellecL.u
L7. The contention of the appellant that the prospectus not being a
rule or rellulation does not have binding force, cannot be accepted. A
prospectus issued by a recognized educational body such as TOSS
embodies the conditions of eligibility and enrollment. A candidate
seeking arlmission is bound by those conditions. The prohibition
contained in Clause I.2 is clear and unequivocal. Enrollment in
contravention thereof, particularly upon suppression of an earlier
qualification, strikes at the root of eligibility. A certificate obtained in
violation ol an express prohibition cannot be treated on par with a
qualification lawfully obtained. A document procured by
misrepresentation or suppression of material facts clocs not confer an
enforceable right.
18. The c,rntention that the learned Single Judge travelled beyond
the scope ol'the writ petition does not commcud acceptance. It is ncr
doubt true that the rejection order dated 06.12.2024 was founded
upon Guideline No.S(c). However, in the course of the writ
proceedings, respondent Nos.S and 6 specifically pleaded that the
appellant's lntermediate certificate obtained from TOSS was secured
in violation of the TOSS Prospectus and was, therefore, invalid. The
aflpellant, in response thereto, filed a reply affidavit and consciously
chose to meet the said contention on merits by asserting that the
prospectus was not binding in nature. Having thus joined issue on
the validity of the certificate, it is not open to the appellant to
subsequently contend that the matter is beyond the scope of the writ
petition. once a plea is specifically raised in the pleadings and
contested by both parties, it becomes part of the /is and is amenable
to adjudication. A writ court, particularly while exercising
discretionary jurisdiction in matters of public employment, is not
precluded from examining a foundational issue that bears directly
upon the eligibility of the candidare.
19. Further on perusal of the record, it discloses that the appellant
was fully aware of the challenge to the i,alidity of her TOSS certificate.
Appellant had ample opportunity to explain the circumstances of her
enrollment with ToSS and to rebut the allegation of suppression.
Instead, appellant conlined her defence to the contention on a hyper_
technical argument that the prospectus is not binding. In these
circumstances, the appellant being clearly aware of the allegation,
\
cannot be said that she was condemned unheard resulting in
violation of principles of natural justice.
2o.
The contention that the TOSS ought to have been impleaded
before any finding was recorded regarding the validity of the
certificatr:, does not merit acceptance for the following reasons:
i) Firstly, the observation of the learned Single Judge that the
certificate is "uoid ab initio" does not amount to a formal
crder o[ cancellation directed against TOSS. It is a judicial
,letermination rendered for the limited purpose of examining
lhe appellant's eligibility for public appointment. The finding
operates inter partes and signifies that, for the purposes of
the present lis, the certificate, having been obtained in
violation of the governing conditions cannot be relied upon.
It does not mandate any action by TOSS nor does it purport
tcr annul the certificate in rem.
ii)
Sr:condly, the principles of natural justice do not require
that every authority which may be indirectly affected by a
finding must be impleaded as a party- The lis before the
Cc,urt concerned the appellant's entitlement to
be
considered for appointment. In that context, the Court was
cornpetent to examine the legal sustainability and
evidentiary value of the qualification relied upon. While a
for.nal procceding for cancellation of the certificate mav
=\/
necessitate the presence of TOSS, an incidental judicial
Iinding as to its validity for the limited purpose of
adjudicating eligibility does not suffer from procedural
infirmity.
iii) Thirdly, the prejudice, if any, flows not from any act of the
Court but from the appellant's own conduct in enrolling
herself contrary to the express conditions of the prospectus.
The equitable jurisdiction of this Court cannot be invoked to
lend sanctity to a document obtained in violation of binding
conditions. The maxim actus curiae neminem grauabit (An
act of court shall prejudice no man) has no apprication in
such circumstances.
2l'
Furthermore, the reriance placed by the
judginent in D. sud.hako.r (supra
misplaced and crearly distinguishable
Division Bench was concerned
possessed a valid Intermediate
candidature was rejected
r) is, in our considered view,
on facts. In the said case, the
with candidates who admittedly
qualification with Urdu, and
solely on the ground that such
had been acquired subsequent
such
appellant on the
whose
qualification
to obtaining a higher qualification
"" 'it-*e or B.Ed- The court herd that, in the absence of any
express p.otilbition in the
applicable Rules <tt 2Ot
qualilication after a higher
disqualification' However, in
l, acquisition of a
quarificarion courd not
operate as a
the prescnt case, the validity
of the
T
t4
qualification itself is in issue and also the very foundation of the
appellarLt's claim; namely, the TOSS Intermediate certificate is uncler
serious r:loud and has been found to have been obtained in violation
of the bi:rding conditions of enroilment. Thus, the reliance placed on
D. Sudhtrkar (supra 1) does not advance appellant's case.
22. The learned Single Judge held that the rejection order dated
06.12.2024, insofar as it was based on Guideline No.S(c), was
Unsustainable, as the guidetine was issued after the commencement
o[ the recruitment process. It is well settled, as held by the Hon'ble
SupremeCourtinK.Manjusreeu.StateofA.P2.andTejPrakash
Pathaku..RajasthanHighCourt3,thattherulesofthegameCannot
has begun' However' the
be altered after the selection process
dismissalcfthewritpetitionwasnotfoundedonthesaidwell
accbptedguideline.ThelearnedSingleJudgeproceededtorecordan
of the appellant's TOSS
finding regarding the invalidity
independenr-
lntermediatt:certilicate,whichfrrrmedthesubstantivebasisfornon.
suitingher.Theobservationontheguideline,eveniffavourabletothe
appellant,d3esnotaffecttheultimateconclusion,whichrestsona
separateantlsustainableground.Therefore,wefind1o....o'inthe
learned Single Judge's vierv'
Conclusion
2 (2008) 3 SCC 5 12
,\ozq 'Scc oni,irrc SC 3184
,/
23. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered view
that the appellant, having already passed the Intermediate
examination in March, 2OO3, was clearly inetigible to enroll again for
the same course under the TOSS in December, 2014, in view of the
express prohibition contained in Clause 1.2 of the governing
Prospectus. Therefore, this Court finds no error of law, perversity, or
jurisdictional infirmity in the order dated 05.12.2025 passed by the
learned single Judge in w.P.No.28608 of 2024, so as to warrant
interference in the present intra-court appeal.
24. Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. The order dated
o5.t2.2}25 passed in w.P.No.28608 of 2024 is affirmed.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No costs.
:
I
I
,TTRUE COPY/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
YADAV' Advocate
One CC to SRI MAMIDI SAI
[oPUC]
2. One CC to SRI SAI PRASEN GUNDAVARAM,
at
Court for the State of Telangana
High
CES-|,
SERVI
FOR
GP
to
3. Two CCs
1.
I
l
HYderabad [OUTI
4. Two CD CoPies
BSR [t'
BS
tt
-/
HIGH COURT
DATED:
,,1810212A26
iHE S
JUDGMENT
WA.No.51 of 2026
DISMISSING THE
WITHOUT COSTS
""f*
+un'
c
i
(-
o
2 5 r'tAR 20?fr
*
*
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review