Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 11thMay, 2026
Pronounced on: 10thJune, 2026
+
RFA 1050/2025, CM APPL. 72251/2025
SH. DEEPAK KAUSHIK
S/o Late Sh. Ramphal Kaushik
R/o A-36 Yadav Nagar, Samaypur, Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Sudhir Nandrajog, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. H. S. Kohli, Mr. Yash Kadyan,
Mr. Raghav Kaushik, Ms. Rishika
Jain, Ms. Mannat Kohli, Ms. Ankita
Singh, Advocates.
versus
1.
VINOD KAUSHIK
S/o Late Sh. Ramphal Kaushik
R/oFlat No. 343, Sangam Apartment,
West Enclave, Pitampura,New Delhi.
Also at:
9, Engineering College Lane, Opposite DTU,
Shahabad Daulatpur, Bawana Road,
Sector 17, Rohini,Delhi.
2.
SANTOSH SHARMA (LR. OF MS. CHANDERWATI)
W/O Late Satnarayan Sharma
R/O H.No.218-A, Shanti Nagar,Panipat, Haryana.
3.
SANGEETA DIXIT (LR. OF MS. CHANDERWATI)
W/O Sh. Rakesh Dixit
R/O P-3, Safdarjung Enclave,Police Lane, Delhi.
4.
KRISHNA KAUSHIK
W/O Late Satbir Kaushik
R/O D-46, Yadav Nagar, Samaypur, New Delhi.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
5.
SEEMA
D/oLate Satbir Kaushik
R/o 617, Malwan Panna,Jharoda, Kalan, Delhi.
6.
SONIA VASHISTH
D/O Late Satbir Kaushik
R/O 18, Roshan Mandi,Najafgarh, Delhi.
7.
MS. SHUBHI KAUSHIK (LR. of Late Sh. NARESH KAUSHIK)
R/O 45B, First Floor,Yamuna Enclave,
Panipat, Haryana.
8.
MS.MUSKAN KAUSHIK (LR. of Late Sh. NARESH KAUSHIK)
R/O 45B, First Floor,Yamuna Enclave,
Panipat, Haryana.
9.
MR.VISHESH KAUSHIK (LR. of Late Sh. NARESH KAUSHIK)
R/O 45B, First Floor,Yamuna Enclave,
Panipat, Haryana.
10.
SUDERSHAN KAUSHIK @SONU
S/O Late Satbir Kaushik
R/O D-46, Yadav Nagar, Samaypur, New Delhi. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Kirti Uppal, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Peeyoush Kalra, Mr. A Abhiraj
Ray, Mr. Aamir Abbas Naqvi and
Mr. Arpit Sharma, Advocates for R-1
&R-4 to R-6.
Ms. Faguni Katyal, Adv. for R-2 & 3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”) has been
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
filed on behalf of the Plaintiff/Appellant, Sh. Deepak Kaushik, against
Judgment dated 29.10.2025, whereby the Suit filed by the Plaintiff seeking
Declaration and Permanent Injunction,has been rejected under Order VII
Rule 11 of the CPC, by the learned District Judge.
2.
The Plaintiff filed a Civil Suit bearing No. CS DJ 679/2018, seeking
Declaration and Permanent Injunction.
3.
The brief facts, as narrated in the Plaint, are that the Plaintiff and the
Respondents are the Legal Heirs of late Ramphal Kaushik, who had expired
intestateon 09.10.2003 and was survived by his wife Chandrawati, four sons
namely,SatbirKaushik, VinodKaushik, NareshKaushik and DeepakKaushik
and two daughters namely,Santosh Sharma and Sangeeta Dixit.
4.
One son, Satbir Kaushik died and was survived by his wife Krishna,
one son, Sudershan Kaushik and two daughters, Seema and Sonia. All the
Legal Heirs of late Satbir Kaushik authorised Sudershan Kaushik, his son,to
sign the Family Arrangement,as agreed on behalf of all the family members.
5.
The Plaintiff claimed that he and his family members,as per the
wishes of late Ramphal Kaushik, in the year 2009 settled by way of
compromise, the share of the family members in the properties of late
Ramphal Kaushik. It was further claimed that afterdue deliberations,they
finalised theFamily Arrangement dated 10.10.2009. It was asserted that, the
share of the family members in the properties of late Ramphal Kaushik, had
already been settled by an Oral Agreement;however, to avoid any future
dispute,it was reduced into the Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009, in
presence of a common family friend, Sh. Rishal Singh.
6.
It was stated that Late RamphalKaushik had purchased many
immovable properties,under the name of various family members from the
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
joint family funds.TheFamily Arrangement dated 10.10.2009
was
essentially for recording the mutual consent of all the share-holders and to
avoid any future litigation. The said Family Arrangement was duly signed
and acknowledged by all the share-holders, including Defendant Nos. 1 and
2.
7.
This Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009, included an agricultural
land admeasuring12 Bighas 14 Biswas out of Khasra No.51/21(0-11), 22(46), 23(0-14), 28(0-4), 57/2(2-3), 3(4-16) situatedin the revenue record of
Village Bakoli (hereinafter referred to as „Suit Property‟), which was
purchased by late Ramphal Kaushik, in the name of Defendant No. 2, Smt.
Chandrawati. Thoughthe share of the family members in the said Property
was already settled, however, it was not divided in metes and bounds and
was agreed to remain joint.
8.
It was further claimed that DefendantsNo.3 and 4 acted upon the
saidFamily Arrangement dated 10.10.2009 and further compromised the
properties between themselves, on 14.03.2010. The Suit Property, since
inception of the aforesaid Family Arrangement,has been in the common
possession of all the family members.
9.
It was asserted that Smt. Chandrawati was merely a custodian of the
Suit Property,prior to the Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009. The
Plaintiff further claimed that he had acted upon the said Family
Arrangement and paid his share of money of Rs.25,000/-, for the installation
of water pump, in the Suit Property.
10.
Thejoint possession of all the family members in the Suit Property,
was duly recorded in theFamily Arrangement dated 10.10.2009 and the
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
same was taken on record by Delhi Jal Board in the year 2015, when they
started raising Bills for the use of Borewell/water pump.
11.
DefendantNo.1,who
was
elder brother
of the
Plaintiff,
on
23.08.2016,luredDefendantNo.2, Smt. Chandrawati, mother of the Plaintiff
and Defendant No. 1,to stay with him, at his residence. It was claimed that
Defendant No.1,had developed a greed in regard to the Suit Property, which
stood in the name of DefendantNo.2, and enticed her to execute a Gift Deed
dated 21.05.2018 in respect of Suit property, in his favour.
12.
The Plaintiff further claimed that Defendant No. 1had been living
separately since 1988, and had never shown any care or compassion towards
DefendantNo.2. Apprehending the evil intention of DefendantNo.1, the
Plaintiff had filed an Application before the learned LAC in regard to the
suitproperty, mentioned herein above.
13.
The Plaintiff got issued a Notice dated 03.04.2018 from the learned
LAC, in regard to issuance of NOC in respect of the SuitProperty.The
Plaintiff had also filed a Suit for Partition, in the learnedRevenue Court,
in respect of the Suit Property, which was dismissed by the SDM on
17.05.2018, as being not maintainable.An Appeal was preferred by the
Plaintiff before the DM, which is still pending.
14.
The Plaintiff claimed that he came to know about the execution of
Gift Deed dated 21.05.2018,during the pendency of the aforesaid
Appealfiled by him. Even though the Plaintiff has filed his Objections, the
concerned Authority is still pursuing the mutation of the Suit Property, in
the name of DefendantNo.1. In case DefendantNo. 1 succeeds in mutating
the SuitPropertyunderhis name,on the basis of the Gift Deed dated
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
21.05.2018, the Plaintiff would suffer irreparable loss, which cannot be
compensated in terms of money.
15.
The Plaintiff claimed that he had received information from a reliable
sourcethat DefendantNo.1 wants to dispose of the Suit Property, after
getting it mutated in his name, for which he has already contacted various
persons.
16.
The Plaintiff challenged the Gift Deed dated 21.05.2018 on the
ground that DefendantNo.1 had gotten the said Gift Deed executed in his
favour from DefendantNo.2 with respect to the entire land, knowing well
that the same was co-ownedby all the family members,as agreed in the
Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009.
17.
The Plaintiff thus, filed the presentSuit for declaring the Gift Deed
dated 21.05.2018, as null and void and for Permanent Injunction to
restrain DefendantNo.1 from selling the Suit Property or creating thirdparty rights in the same.
18.
The aforesaid Suit was contested by DefendantNos.1, 2 and 4 who in
their Written Statement, claimed that DefendantNo.2 was the registered
owner of the Agricultural Land,till the execution of Gift Deed dated
21.05.2018. She was the sole and exclusive owner; and was in absolute
possession of the Suit Property. It was explained that DefendantNo.2 had
purchased the SuitProperty from Shri Hukum Singh s/o Sh. Sujan Singh
on12.09.1988. It being her self-acquired Property, she could deal with it,
according to her own free will. It was asserted that the Plaintiffcannot claim
any right, title or interest in the said Agricultural Land and thus,the Plaint
did not disclose any cause of Action.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
19.
It was further asserted that the present Suit was barred by the
provisions of The Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 and was not
maintainable,on account ofDefendantNo.2being the registered owner of the
Suit Property. It was claimed that the Suit was liable to be rejected under
Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC.
20.
It was further claimed that the Suit was liable to be dismissed, on the
ground of concealment of facts. It has not been disclosed that prior to filing
of the present Suit, DefendantNo.3 Shri Naresh Kaushikhad also filed a Suit
bearing No.116/2018 titled as Naresh Kaushik & Ors. vs. Smt. Chanderwati
& Ors., for Permanent and Mandatory Injunctionwith regard to the alleged
Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009, before the Court of learned Senior
Civil Judge.
21.
In the said Suit, the Plaintiff hereinwas arrayed as DefendantNo.3.
The Court, vide a speaking Order, declined to grant interim Injunction
toDefendantNo.3 in the said Suit. The Defendants herein, in the said Suit
had filed a Written Statement taking objection with regard to the Property in
question being a self-acquired Property of Defendant No.2 and that it cannot
be a subject-matter of partition, by way of the said Family Arrangement.
Consequently, the Suit filed by Defendant No. 3 was dismissed by the
Court, vide Order dated 21.04.2018.
22.
It was further asserted that perusal of the said Family Arrangement,
reflects that the Suit Property has been mentioned, as not having been
divided amongst the family members. Furthermore, DefendantNo.2 was the
registered owner of the Land in question and the same cannot form part of
any FamilySettlement and that she was free to dispose of the same,
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
according to her own free will. The Plaintiffthus,cannot claim any right, title
or interest, in the SuitProperty.
23.
It was further submitted that the value of the Properties being
partitioned was admittedly more than Rs.100/- and the Family Arrangement
dated 10.10.2009 was therefore, compulsorily required to be registered, in
terms of Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908. Inthe absence of
Registration, the said Family Arrangement cannot be taken as evidence in
terms of Section49 of the Registration Act, 1908.
24.
Another Objection taken by the Defendants was that the present Suit
had not been valued properly for the purpose of Court Fee and
valuation.Admittedly, the value of the Suit Property as reflected in the
registered Gift Deed was Rs.1,40,22,920/-, but the Court Fee affixed with
the present Suit is Rs.200/-. The Court Fee should have been paid on the
value stated in the Gift Deed, however, it is undervalued and liable for
rejection.
25.
On merits, similar contentions, as taken in the PreliminaryObjection,
were reiterated.
26.
Thus, it was prayed thatSuit filed by the Plaintiff seeking
Declarationof the Gift Deed dated 21.05.2018as null and void and
Permanent Injunction be dismissed.
27.
Thereafter, an Application under Order VII Rule 11of the CPC was
filed on behalf of Defendant Nos.1, 2 and 4 seeking rejection of the Plaint.
It was submitted that the entire Suit is premised on Family Arrangement
dated 10.10.2009 between the Plaintiffs and Defendants in respect of the
Suit Property, which had not been partitioned, at the time of execution of the
said Family Arrangement.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
28.
Defendant No. 2 was the registered owner of the land in question
and thus, the same could not form part of any Family Settlement. The
Plaintiff cannot claim any right, title or interest in the Suit Property;
therefore, no cause of action was disclosed in the plaint.
29.
It was further claimed that Family Arrangementdated 10.10.2009
did not record any terms that had been arrived between the parties, prior
tothe said date. In fact, the Settlement records that the terms had been
arrived between the parties on the same date, i.e., 10.10.2009. Moreover, the
value of the propertiesmentioned in the Settlement Agreement dated
10.10.2009,was more that Rs.100/- in value. The alleged Family
Arrangementtherefore,requiredcompulsory registration in terms of Section
17 Registration Act, 1908. Since the Family Arrangement was not a
registered document, it cannot be read as evidence in terms of Section 49
Registration Act, 1908. The said document, therefore, cannot be looked into
for any purpose.
30.
The Defendants have further contended that the Suit is barred by
The Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 and is not maintainable.
Defendant No. 2 was the sole owner of the Suit Property and any contrary
allegations claiming right in the Suit Property, is barred under law.
31.
The Defendants further claimed that the Suit Property has not been
valued property for the purpose of Court Fee. In the end, it wasprayed that
the plaint did not disclose any cause of action and is liable to be rejected.
32.
The aforesaid Application was contested by the Plaintiff,who in his
Reply to the Application asserted that the properties mentioned in the
Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009, were under different names.
Moreover, the said Arrangement was an outcome of detailed discussions
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
held between the family members, in the presence of the family friend, Sh.
Rishal Singh, who had put his signatures as well. The Plaintiff had filed the
records of the proceedings of the Family Settlement, wherein it was stated
thatthe Suit Propertyhas been put as joint property and for the maintenance
of this farmat least Rs.1 lakh, would be required. It was agreed that an
amount of Rs.25,000/- shall be payable by each of the family members.
After this, signatures of Sh. Sudarshan Kaushik, Defendant No. 4, Vinod
Kaushik, Defendant No.1, thumb impression of Ms. Chanderwati
Defendant No.2, Deepak Kaushik, Plaintiff, Mr. Naresh Kumar Defendant
No. 3 and Rishal Singh, were ascribed on the said Family Settlement dated
10.10.2009.
33.
Furthermore, it was asserted that a mere Agreement to divide
properties does not require registration, but if the writing itselfeffects the
division, it must be registered. The Family Settlement dated 10.10.2009 was
a Memorandum between the family members and its registration was not
necessary in terms of the judgment of the Apex Court in Roshan Singh and
Others v. Zile Singh and Others 1988 Legal Eagle 168 and S. Satinder Singh
&Ors. v. S. Raminder Sarup Singh & Anr. 2018 Legal Eagle 481. Even
otherwise, Section 91 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 is very clear in this
context.
34.
The prior proceedings leading to the FamilyArrangement,are an
admitted fact which supersedes all the contentions raised by the Defendants.
Furthermore, the Family Arrangement is an admission of facts, which as per
Section 17 and Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872is binding and
anything stated contrary, are irrelevant in the present context. Furthermore,
in the light of the specific terms and agreement between the parties, the
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
provisions of The Benami Transaction (Prohibition) Act, 1988,are also not
applicable.
35.
The Plaintiff has further asserted that the Gift Deed dated
21.05.2018executed in favour of Defendant No. 1, was no document in the
eyes of law and is required to be declared as null and void. Defendant No. 1
could not have gotten this document executed from Defendant No. 2 by
surpassing the rights of all other persons, who were the parties to Family
Arrangement dated 10.10.2009.
36.
In regard to the Court Fee, the Plaintiff submitted that without
prejudice, he was willing to pay the requisite Court Fee, on the plaint. It
was, therefore, prayedthat the plaint disclosed cause of action and the
Application of the Defendant under Order VII Rule 11 CPC was liable to be
dismissed
37.
The learned District Judgeafter considering the rival contentions
raised in the Application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, observed that there
were no documents reflecting that the properties of late Ramphal
Kaushikhad been purchased from the joint family fund in the name of
Defendant No. 2. The payment for the Suit Property was not shown to be
from the known sources, i.e., bank account, declared funds and income tax
of the late Ramphal Kaushik. Consequently, it was held that on the basis of
bald averments made in the plaint, it cannot be said that the plaint discloses
any cause of action.
38.
It was further observed that the entire case of the Plaintiff was based
on the Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009, which was for the first
timesettled the rights of the parties in the immovable properties of late
Ramphal Kaushik. Reliance was placed on TekPahaduBhujil v. Debi Singh
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
BhujilAIR1966SC291, Kale and Ors. v. Deputy Director of Consolidation
and Ors.1976 3 SCC 119 and Jagdish Kumar Sachdeva v. Subhash Chander
Sachdeva 2011 SCC OnLine Del 2275, wherein, it was held that such a
document where the arrangement is brought about by the document
itself, it would require registration, as it would be a document declaring
future rights and what properties the parties would possess.
39.
Similar observations were made in the case of Jagdish Kumar
Sachdeva v. Subhash Chander Sachdeva and Bhoop Singh v. Ram Singh
Major (1995) 5 SCC 709.It was thus, held that since the Family
Arrangement dated 10.10.2009 was neither registered nor duly stamped, it
was inadmissible in evidence and the Gift Deed dated 21.05.2018 executed
by Defendant No. 2 in favour of Defendant No. 1 in respect of the Suit
Property, cannot be challenged on the basis of the said Settlement.
40.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid Judgment dated 29.10.2025 the Plaintiff
had preferred the present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with
Order XLI Rule 1 CPC.
41.
The Grounds of Challenge are that the Plaintiff had never
challenged the rights of Defendant No. 2 in respect of her title in the Suit
Property.However, it was claimed that the suitproperty was made part of the
Family Settlement, which had been executed by all the stakeholders,
including Defendants No. 1 & 2,during the lifetime of Defendant No.
2.There was no occasion for the Court to venture in to analyzing the bar
under TheBenami Transaction (Prohibition) Act, 1988and the same could
not have been considered, while disposing of the Application under Order
VII Rule 11 of the CPC.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
42.
TheSuit Property was kept into the common hotchpotch for reaching
the Family Settlement inter se amongst stakeholders, wherein,the parties had
collectively agreed to keep it under the joint claim of all the family members
of the Family Settlement. It was never the case of the Plaintiff that,
Defendant No. 2 had no right of disposition,as is being projected by the
Defendants.
43.
The learned District Judge erred in trashing the Family Arrangement
dated 10.10.2009 and denying the rights thereunder, solely on the basis of
the said Arrangement being unregistered. It was asserted that Section 17
read with Section 49 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 would bar only
when the parties assert their claims based on such unregistered document,
but does not bar the Court from considering such document for collateral
purposes, as has been observed by the Apex Court in the case of P.
Anjanappa (D) By LR‟s v. A.P. Nanjundappa and Ors. 2025 INSC 1286.
44.
The Family Settlement propounded by the Plaintiffs, though cannot
be taken as evidence in terms of the bar under Section 49 of the Registration
Act, 1908, but can still be relevant to consider that the Suit Property was
made part of the division of properties, by way of the Family Arrangement
dated 10.10.2009, wherein, Defendant No. 2, who was the registered owner
of the Suit Propertywas also a party.
45.
Overlooking such proposition of law, while rejecting the plaint of
the Plaintiff by the learned Trial Court, is on the misconceived construction
as to the implication of an unregistered document for consideration and
adjudication of the claims of third parties.Once the Family Settlement has
been acted by the parties, such Settlement needs no registration, for which
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
reliance is placed on Kale and Ors. v. Deputy Director of Consolidation and
Ors.1976 3 SCC 119.
46.
It was thus, contended that the defence taken by the Defendants
could not have been the basis for rejection of the plaint, as has been
observed in the case of Tilak Raj v. Ranjit Kaur 2012 (5) AD (DELHI)186,
Pawan Kumar v. Babulal since deceased through LRs and Ors2019 (136)
ALR
207,
Atma
Singh
and
Ors.
v.
Prem
Singh
and
Ors.
MANU/DE/3041/2022.
47.
It is, therefore,prayed that the impugned Judgment be set aside and
the Suit be remanded back for trial on merits.
Submissions heard and record perused.
48.
The Plaintiff has sought to declare the Registered Gift Deed dated
21.05.2018 executed by Defendant No.2, the mother in favour of Defendant
No.1/sonas null and void, on the ground of the Family Arrangement dated
10.10.2009, whereby the properties of late Ramphal Kaushik including the
Suit Property were divided amongst all the family members, including the
Plaintiff and Defendants. It is asserted that after the aforesaid Family
Settlement, Smt. Chanderwati ceased to be the exclusive owner of the Suit
Property, and thus, had no right or title, to execute the Gift Deed in favour
of Defendant No.1.
49.
It is not in dispute that the Suit Property had been purchased in the
name of Defendant No.2,by her husband, late Ramphal Kaushik and thus,
she became the registered owner of the Suit Property.
50.
The Learned District Judge, to buttress the contentions of the
Plaintiff, of the Property being in the exclusive name of the Plaintiff had
referred to the definition of benami transaction in Section 2(9) of The
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988, and held that every
transaction or arrangement, where property is held by a person and
consideration is paid by another, cannot be termed as benami transaction.
There were four exceptions recognized to this definition and one of it is the
property held by any individual in the name of the spouse, but consideration
paid out of his own sources, falls beyond the definition of a benami
transaction.
51.
It was held that Section 4 of the Benami Property Transactions Act,
1988, is applicable only in respect of the property, held benami. However, in
respect of the present Suit Property, there were no documents or evidence to
show that Smt. Chanderwati held the Property as benami and the contention
of the Plaintiff was thus,accepted that it was exclusive property of Smt.
Chanderwati, a fact, which is also admitted by the Defendants.
52.
The sole contention is whether the parties admittedly entered into the
Family Settlement dated 10.10.2009. The only ground on which Family
Settlement is challenged, is that this document required compulsory
registration, as it created rights in the property for the first time and
therefore, was non-est in law. Defendant No. 2 therefore, continued to be the
exclusive owner of the Suit Property and thus, was competent to execute the
Gift Deed dated 21.05.2018,in favour of Defendant No.1.
53.
The main issue for adjudication in the present Appeal, is:whether the
Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009 required compulsory registration
and dehors the registration, is not enforceable.
54.
The significance and the importance of aFamily Settlement was
highlighted in the case of Mathuri Pullaiah vs. Maturi Narasimhamand
Ors., AIR 1966 SC 1836, wherein it was observed that a family arrangement
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
resolves family disputes, and that even disputes based upon ignorance of
parties as to their rights, may afford a sufficient ground to sustain it.
55.
Likewise, in the case of Ram Charan Das vs. Girjanandini Devi And
Ors., (1965)3 SCR 841, the Apex Court observed that the consideration for
such a family settlement, is the expectation that such a settlement will result
in establishing or ensuring amity and goodwill amongst persons bearing
relationship with one another.Thesettlement consisting of recognition of the
right asserted by each other, cannot be permitted to be impeached thereafter.
56.
In the case of S. Shanmugam Pillai and Others vs. K. Shanmugam
Pillai and Others, (1973) 2 SCR 312, the importance of family settlement
was again emphasized by observing that if it is in interest of family
peaceand that the family members have settled their disputes amicably.
Insuch circumstances, the Court would generally lean in favour of the
family arrangement and would be reluctant to disturb the same.
57.
The sanctity of the family arrangement can therefore, never be
questioned and once the parties have arrived at a settlement, the general
tendency is to uphold such family settlements.
58.
The first aspect is to understand is what arrangement can be termed as
family settlement. Halsbury‟s Laws of England, Vol. 17, Third Edition,
defined a family arrangement as an agreement between members of the
same family, intended to be generally and reasonably for the benefit of the
family either by compromising doubtful or disputed rights or by preserving
the family property or the peace and security of the family by avoiding
litigation or by saving-its honour.... Family arrangements are governed by
principles which are not applicable to dealings between strangers.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
59.
Further, Sahu Madho Das and Others vs. Pandit Mukand Ram and
Another, AIR 1955 SC 481 explained the basic eligibility for parties to enter
into a Family Settlement, as under:
“It is well settled that compromise or family arrangement is
based on the assumption that there is an antecedent title of
some sort in the parties and the agreement acknowledges
and defines what that title is, each party relinquishing all
claims to property other than that falling to his share and
recognising the right of the others, as they had previously
asserted it, to the portions allotted to them respectively.
That explains why no conveyance is required in these
cases to pass the title from the one in whom it resides to
the person receiving it under the family arrangement. It is
assumed that the title claimed by the person receiving the
property, under the arrangement had always resided in him
or her so far as the property falling to his or her share is
concerned and therefore no conveyance is necessary.”
60.
The aforesaid principles were analysed and upheld by the Supreme
Court in the landmark Judgment of Kale and Others vs. Deputy Director of
Consolidation and Ors., (1976) 3 SCC 119,wherein, it was observed that the
object of such an arrangement is to protect the family from long drawn
litigation and perpetual disputes, which affect the unity and solidarity of the
family and create hatred and bad blood between various members of the
family. However, the bonafide and propriety of a family arrangement has to
be judged by the circumstances prevailing at the time when such settlement
was made. The onus of proving the family settlement, lies solely on the
person claiming that a family Agreement existed.
61.
The Full Bench of Allahabad High Court in Ram Gopal vs. Tulshi
Ram, AIR 1928 All. 641 (FB), observed that a family arrangement could be
oral and if it is followed by a petition in Court containing a reference to the
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
arrangement and if the purpose was merely to inform the Court regarding
the arrangement, no registration of the said Arrangement was necessary. In
this connection, the Full Bench adumbrated the following propositions in
answering the reference:
“(1)
A family arrangement can be made orally.
(2)
Ifmade orally, there being no document, no
question of registration arises.
(3)
If though it could have been made orally, it was in
fact reduced to the form of a “document”, registration
(when the value is Rs. 100 and upwards) is necessary.
(4) Whether the terms have been “reduced to the form of a
document” is a question of fact in each case to be
determined upon a consideration of the nature and
phraseology of the writing and the circumstances in which
and the purpose with which it was written.
(5) If the terms were not "reduced to the form of a
document", registration was not necessary (even though the
value is Rs. 100 or upwards); and, while the writing cannot
be used as a piece of evidence for what it may be worth, e.g.
as corroborative of other evidence or as an admission of the
transaction or as showing or explaining conduct.
(6) If the terms were "reduced to the form of a document"
and, though the value was Rs. 100 or upwards, it was not
registered, the absence of registration makes the document
inadmissible in evidence and is fatal to proof of the
arrangement embodied in the document.”
62.
Thus, the Supreme Court in Kale and Others vs. Deputy Director of
Consolidation and Ors(supra)created two categories of family settlements,
one being oral settlement and the other being written settlements. It was held
that the prior does not require registration however, the latter would be a
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
compulsorily registerable document. However, in the second category, an
exception was carved out, i.e. if the Memorandum of Family Settlement was
reduced to writing only for the purpose of record or for information of the
court for making necessary mutation, then it would be exempt from
registration as the Memorandum itself does not create or extinguish any
rights in the immovable properties.
63.
In Lieutenant Col. Gaj Singh Yadav vs. Satish Chander Yadav, 1999
(51) DRJ 240, it was explained that if a party had a share in the property,
enlargement of such share by relinquishment or gift by the other defendant,
would not require registration. It is only when a right in the property is
created for the first time by a particular document, that it would require
registration. Therefore, mischief of Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908
would not fall on an oral settlement.
64.
The Apex Court has analysed the effect of non-registration of a
Kharurnama (family arrangement recording past transaction)in the case
of Korukonda Chalapathi Raov. Korukonda Annapurna Sampath Kumar,
2021 SCC OnLine SC 847and opined that whether a document by itself
„affects‟, i.e., by itself creates, declares, limits or extinguishes rights in the
immovable properties in question and it is found that the document merely
records past transactions which have been entered into by the parties, and
does not purport to by itself create, declare, assign, extinguish or limit right
in properties, it would not attract Section 49(1)(a) of the Registration Act,
1908. Therefore, a mere recital of what has already taken place, cannot be
held to declare any right and there would be no necessity of registering
such a document.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
65.
Similarly, in a recent judgement of K. Arumuga Velaiah (Supra)
while emphasizing upon the distinction between Section 17(2) Clause (iv)
and Clause (v) of the Registration Act. 1908, the Court observed that a
document of partition which provides for effectuating a division of
properties in future, would be exempt from registration. It was further
crystallized that by virtue of Section 17(2) Clause (v) Registration Act 1908,
any document which does not in itself create a right, title or interest in any
immovable property but rather creates a right to obtain a subsequent
document which when executed, would create a right in the property, the
same does not require mandatory registration.
66.
From the aforesaid Judgments, what emerges is, that if the parties vide
an oral arrangement have agreed to a family settlement, but subsequently
reduced it to writing for the posterity, the same does not require any
registration.
67.
This is demonstrated from the case of Sitala Baksh Singh and Others
vs. Jang Bahadur Singh and Others, MANU/OU/0059/1933, wherein it was
held that where a Revenue Court merely gave effect to the compromise,
such compromise embodied in an Order of the Revenue Court and given
effect to by the Revenue Court ordering mutation in accordance with the
terms of the compromise, is only giving effect to a compromise, earlier
arrived at between the parties and did not require registration.
68.
Likewise, in the case of Smt. Kalawati vs. Sri Krlshna Prasad and
Others, MANU/OU/0045/1943, similar facts were involved, where in an
Order of mutation, theCourt merely stated the fact of the compromise
having been arrived at between the parties and did not amount to a
declaration of Will. It was held that it did not cause a change of legal
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
relation to the property and therefore, it did not declare any right in the
property.
69.
Likewise, in the case of Bakhtawar vs. Sunder Lal and Others, where
Lindsay, J., speaking for the Division Bench observed as under:
“It is reasonable to assume that there was a bona fide
dispute between the parties which was eventually composed
each party recognizing an antecedent title in the other. I this
view of the circumstances I am of opinion that there was no
necessity to have this petition registered. It does not in my
opinion purpose to create, assign, limit, extinguish or
declare within the meaning of these expressions as used in
S. 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act. It is merely a recital of
fact by which the Court is informed that the parties have
come to an arrangement.”
70.
Similarly the Patna High Court in Awadh Narain Singh and Others vs.
Narain Mishra and Others, MANU/BH/0106/1962 : AIR 1962 Pat 400,
pointed out that a compromise Petition not embodying any terms of
agreement, but merely conveying to the Court that a family arrangement had
already been arrived at between the parties, did not require registration and
can be looked into for ascertaining the terms of family arrangement.
71.
Therefore, it is abundantly explained and clear that an oral
settlement, which has been arrived at a prior time, but recorded
subsequently for record, does not require compulsory registration.
72.
It is therefore, been well-settled in the light of the Judgments referred
above that where there is a bona fide dispute between the parties, which is
eventually compromised by each party recognizing an antecedent, title in the
other, it is not required to be registered, as it does not purport to create,
assign, limit, extinguish or declare within the meaning of these expressions,
as used in Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act, 1908. It is merely a
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
recital of fact, by which the Court is informed that the parties have come to
an arrangement.
73.
In this context, it is also essential to consider the Rule of Estoppel, as
the said Rule is a legal principle that prevents a person from arguing
something contrary to a claim made or implied by their previous actions or
statements.Thus, estoppel prevents a party from asserting rights or facts that
are contrary to their previous statements, conduct, or commitments when it
would be unjust to allow them to go back on their word. The key elements
include:
a. Representation or conduct by one party that leads the other party
to believe in a certain state of affairs.
b. Reliance by the second party on this belief.
c. Detriment to the second party if the first party is allowed to deny
the truth of the representation.
74.
The Supreme Court, in S. Shanmugam Pillai and Ors. v. K.
Sahnmugam Pillai and Ors. (1973) 2 SCC 312, have empathized on the
importance of equitable principles and stated that certain equitable
principles such as estoppel, are not mere rules of evidence, but rather serve
as a very important element in administration of justice and thus, the courts
are hesitant in narrowing down the scope of the same as they have been
liberally relied upon time and again to render justice.
75.
While applying the principle of estoppel in the case of Family
Settlements,
the
Supreme
Court
in
Kale
and
Ors.(Supra)and
Thulasidhara(Supra)has observed that the parties benefiting from the
Family arrangement could not later challenge its validity.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
76.
Similarly, while relying upon the above judgments in the case of
Ravinder Kaur Grewal (Supra), the Supreme court emphasized that estoppel
is an equitable doctrine aimed at preventing unfair advantage or detriment
resulting from inconsistency in a party's claims or representations. It was
observed that since the parties having acted upon the terms of a disputed
Family settlement to the prejudice of the other party, it was not open to them
to resile from the said arrangement and they were estopped from disowning
the arrangement. It is noteworthy that the court observed that even in the
event a family arrangement has not been registered, it would not prejudice
its binding nature upon the members of the family and would continue to
act as an estoppel to prevent members from revoking the family
arrangement, if the members have acted upon it.
77.
Thus, it is no more res integra that the family settlement, emphasizing
that such arrangements, even if oral or unregistered, should be binding if
made bona fide and acted upon. Such arrangements would not require
registration if the same itself does not create or extinguish any right, title or
interest in any immovable property and rather merely create a right to obtain
another document to enforce their rights. A family arrangement is
thus,binding on the parties and operates as an estoppel and it precludes any
of the parties who have taken advantage under the agreement from revoking
or challenging the same.
78.
Keeping in mind the aforesaid crystallized principles, the facts of
present case may be considered.
79.
The Family Settlement dated 10.10.2009 read as under:
“
Today dated 10.10.2009, in the presence of Shri Vinod,
Shri Kaushik, Shri Naresh, Shri Deepak, Shri Sonu @
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
Sudarshan and Smt. Chandrawati the joint/mutual/collective
property was distributed as follows:Share Sonu
Bilandpur
20,00,000
46,50,000
Total
Share Deepak
Share Naresh
Share Vinod
GT Road
Panipat Office Office
80,00,000
20,00,000
55,00,000
50,00,000
36,00,000
41,10,000
45,00,000
45,00,000
2,98,50,000 1,90,00,000
1,41,00,500
2,25,50,000
+84,87,000 -23,62,500
-72,12,500
+ 1 1,37,500
Given to Smt. Chandrawati - siraspur Gd. 1,00,00,000/-,
1000 sq. yds. Plus A/36
75,00,000/1,75,00,000/-
As per shares each brother's share comes to
2,13,62,500/-. As per above Sh. Sonu and Sh. Vinod have an
excess share amount, therefore they have to compensate Sh.
Deepak and Sh. Naresh to complete and fulfill their aforesaid
share amount from their own and every person is agreeable to
the same. The present decision has been taken in my presence
(Risal Singh) with the consent of all the persons.
Alipur Farm land has been kept as JOINT. For the maintenance
of this farm minimum Rs.One lac is needed this time. Every
member has to pay Rs.25,000/- each as his share for its
maintenance and that amount will be spend only on the
maintenance of Alipur farm We are all agreeable to the same.”
80.
From the bare perusal of the terms of the Family Settlement, it
emerges that various properties belonging to the family members was put in
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
a common hotch-potch and thereafter, the share in respect of all was
determined. Further, it was noted that Defendant Nos 3 and 4 had excess
share amount and therefore, they had to compensate the Plaintiff and
Defendant No. 1 for the same, in order to fulfil their aforesaid share amount
from their own, to which, every person was agreeable. It further noted that
the suit property, has been kept as joint, for which each family member had
to contribute for its maintenance.
81.
Reading of this Family Settlement, it emerges that the Settlement
arrived at between the family members on 10.10.2009, wherein they agreed
to divide their properties, in the manner stated therein. It was not a
document, which was recording any prior settlement; rather, it, for the first
time, reflected the manner, in which the persons agreed to divide their
shares in the property. It is evident that this document was creating or
extinguishing rights of the parties in praesenti and not recording any prior
oral settlement. It also required certain acts to be done by the parties, to give
effect to the terms of Settlement, therefore, it being a document for the first
time, creating or extinguishing rights of the parties in the properties,
required compulsory registration.
82.
Another contention raised on behalf of the Plaintiff, is that even if the
Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009 was not registered,however, it does
not bar the Court from considering this document for collateral purposes, as
has been held in the Case of P. Anjanappa (D) by L.Rs(supra).
83.
In the Case of P. Anjanappa (D) by L.Rs(supra), there was a Family
Settlement entered between the parties. The Court referred to their
subsequent conduct to conclude that though, the family arrangement may
have required registration but the subsequent conduct reflected that they had
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
acted upon the Deed,which was a reflection of unequivocal declaration of
their intention to bring disruption in the Joint Family and it constituted a
partition.
84.
It was observed that family arrangement recorded in writing, when
relied upon only explains,how the parties thereafter held and enjoyed the
properties and does not require compulsory registration for limited collateral
purposes. Reference was made to Amteshwar Anand vs. Virender Mohan
Singh, (2006) 1 SCC 148, wherein the validity of an assignment was
questioned by the Appellantson the ground that two Agreements had
notbeen registered. However, the submission was held untenable as Section
17(1) of the Registration Act, 1908, required under Clause (b) thereof, for
registration of „non-testamentary instruments which purport or operate
tocreate, declare, assign, limit or extinguish, whether in present or in future,
any right, title interest, whether vested or contingent, of the value of one
hundredrupeesor more or in immovable property‟. Sub-Section (2) of
Section 17, creates an exception. One of which, is stated in Clause (i), which
pertains to any composition deeds.
85.
This aspect was explained in the Case of Govind Ram vs. Madan
Gopal, AIR 1945 PC 74 that a composition deed was a transaction between
the members of same family for the mutual benefit of other family members.
It was not an Agreement that required Registration in any Act, in terms of
Section 17(2) (i) of the Act.
86.
It was further observed in the Case of P. Anjanappa (D) by LRs
(supra), that the reality of disruption is tested by a cumulative assessment of
conduct that includes separate possession, separate cultivation, separate
residence,independent dealings with the lands allotted,and revenue
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
recordsthat consistently reflect such separation. An insistence on further
partition as a pre-condition to infer disruption misdirectsinquiry, because the
determinative question is whether the joint statusstood severed and
subsequent enjoyment was separate. Tested on these principles, the said
Agreement qualifies for collateral purpose. The long and consistent course
of conduct that followed the Agreement confirms the disruption of the status
since the date of entering into the Settlement. It was thus held that such a
document coupled with the subsequent conduct, would not require
compulsory registration.
87.
In the present case, the facts are distinguishable because though,vide
Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009, the parties had agreed for division of
the properties in a certain manner. Their subsequent conduct did not in any
manner reflect that they had acted upon the Family Agreement. In fact,
Defendant No. 2 continued to deal with the property as her exclusive
property and eventually executed the Gift Deed in favour of Defendant No.
1. There is nothing on record to suggest that this Agreement was ever acted
upon by the parties. Therefore, the Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009,
which required compulsory registration, is not admissible even for collateral
purposes. The contention raised on behalf of the Appellant, therefore, does
not serve him in any manner.
88.
Therefore, learned District Judge rightly, held that this document was
not admissible, since it was not a registered document and therefore, could
not be given any effect or held to have made the Suit Property, i.e. Alipur
Farm, as joint family property. The Suit Property was in the exclusive name
of Defendant No.2 and it did not change its status to that of a joint property,
by virtue of Family Arrangement dated 10.10.2009.
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
89.
From the averments made in the Plaint itself, it was established that
the Suit Property did not acquire a status of joint family property and
Defendant No. 2 continued to be the exclusive owner of the SuitProperty
and was thus, competent to execute the Gift Deed dated 21.05.2018,in
favour of Defendant No.1.
90.
Therefore, learned District Judge has rightly appreciated the facts and
law and rejected the Suit filed by the Plaintiff under Order VII Rule 11 the
CPC.
91.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, there is no merit in the present
Appeal, which is hereby,dismissed, along with pending Applications.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 10, 2026
R/N
RFA 1050/2025
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
13:16:50
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review