Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 84
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP 331/2025
Date of pronouncement 12-02-2026
Uploaded on 23-02-2026
SGT BALKIRSHAN SONI (RETD)
…Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. Arvind Kumar, Advocate.
Vs.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
...Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. T M Shamsi, DSGI with
Mr. Faizan, CGC.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
ORDER
12.02.2026
1. The petitioner in the instant petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution has sought the following reliefs;
i.
Issue a writ in the nature of Habeas Corpus, direction or
order whereby the official respondents may be directed to
release the petitioner, produce the petitioner before the
Hon’ble Court from the illegal custody and quash the
impugned order bearing No. 1w/c141/248/pl dated 01-092025 and set the petitioner free forth with.
ii.
Issue a writ of Mandamus, direction or order in the nature
of mandamus whereby the official respondents may be
directed to pay all terminal benefits vis-à-vis pension,
gratuity, leave encashment, AFGIS, Provident Fund etc,
arising out of the retirement from the service.
2. Facts under the shade and cover to which the aforesaid reliefs have been
prayed and as are stated in the petition filed by the petitioner are that the
1|Page
HCP 331/2025
petitioner was enrolled in Indian Air Force (IAF) on 01-04-1997 as
Catering Assistant and while working as such at unit 01 Wing Air Force
(WAF), a Court of Inquiry (COI) was ordered by the Air Officer
Commanding (AOC) 01 Wing to investigate financial irregularities
related to sales of casual meals, supply of kerosene oil and fresh ration at
Air Force Station, Srinagar. It is further stated that pursuant to the orders
passed by the (AOC) 1 dated 01-09-2025, the COI was approved by the
competent authority vide HQ WACPS 388 dated 28-08-2025 and vide
signal dated 22-08-2025, the petitioner was asked to report to Srinagar
Station where the petitioner was handed over a copy of order passed by
AOC 01 No. 1W/C 141/248/PI dated 01-09-2025 issued under Section
122 of the Air Force Act 1950 invoked against him on the directions of
ADC-N-C WAC LAF without assigning any reasons, whereupon the
petitioner was kept under custody on 01-09-2025 in terms of the said
order dated 01-09-2025 to holding proceedings against him.
3. The petitioner herein has challenged the order dated 01-09-2025, inter
alia, on the premise that the provisions of Section 122 of the Act of 1950
is not applicable to the petitioner as the same are applicable to the
subjects of the Act and that the petitioner had ceased to be subject to the
Act upon having superannuated on 31-08-2025 and that though an
application in this regard came to submitted by the petitioner on 02-092025 before the respondents also seeking copies of the Court of Inquiry
proceedings followed by another applications dated 23-09-2025 and 2509-2025, yet the respondents failed to advert to the said applications and
that since the petitioner was discharged from service at 1400 hours on 3108-2025 upon superannuation yet he was not physically released from the
2|Page
HCP 331/2025
service on account of the proceedings initiated against him under Section
122 of the Act of 1950 on 01-09-2025, and that the respondents not only
detained the petitioner illegally for holding of said proceedings but also
withheld his terminal benefits due to him upon his retirement and though
an application for release of said benefits was submitted before the
respondents on 21-11-2025, the same did not yield any results as the
respondents implicated the petitioner maliciously in the case for ulterior
motives and that non-release of terminal benefits in his favour violates
his fundamental rights depriving him to engage a counsel for defending
his case, more so when the petitioner has been subjected to disciplinary
proceedings after having been detained after his retirement on 31-082025.
4. Two set of objections have been filed by the respondents to the petition,
wherein the petition is being opposed while stating that the petitioner has
suppressed material facts and that the petition has been filed as an
attempt to delay lawful proceedings already initiated against the
petitioner and that the petitioner has before maintaining the instant
petition filed similar petition before the High Court of Delhi as well as
the Armed Forces Tribunal, after having withdrawn the same though with
liberty yet without any justified reason and that the Air Force Station,
Srinagar on 30-01-2025 and on subsequent dates convened COI against
the petitioner to inquire into financial irregularities relating to Mess
Management, wherein the petitioner was found blameworthy and upon
the conclusion of the said Court of Inquiry, appropriate proceedings were
initiated against the petitioner pursuant to the invoking of Section 122 of
the Act of 1950 and that the petitioner though superannuated on 31-083|Page
HCP 331/2025
2025 (PM) and was struck off from the strength of the force on 01-092025 and a formal order in this regard came to be issued bearing No.
01W/C 141/248/PI dated 01-09-2025, whereafter the disciplinary
proceedings commenced on 15-10-2025 and Summary of Evidence
(SOE) was ordered on 22-10-2025 and same has since been completed
and the General Court Martial (GCM) to try the petitioner assembled on
08-12-2025 at Air Force Station, Srinagar and that upon completion of
Summary of Evidence, the petitioner was released from the close arrest
and the petitioner presently is accommodated at SNCO’s Mess Air Force
Station, Srinagar, as the Court Martial Proceedings are yet to be
completed.
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the record produced by the
counsel for the respondents.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner while making his submissions in tune
with the case set up in the petition would insist that the respondents could
not have invoked the provisions of Section 122 of the Act of 1950 on 0109-2025, after superannuation of the petitioner on 31-08-2025, as the
petitioner ceased to be subject to the provisions of the Act of 1950 and
therefore not only the Court Martial Proceedings initiated against the
petitioner by the respondents are legally unsustainable and without
jurisdiction, but also the withholding of the terminal benefits of the
petitioner on account thereof is violation of his fundamental rights.
6. In response to the aforesaid submissions of the counsel for the petitioner,
the counsel for the respondents would contend that the plea of the
counsel for the petitioner is factually incorrect, in that, the provisions of
Section 122 of the Act came to be invoked prior to the superannuation of
4|Page
HCP 331/2025
the petitioner when a formal sanction for invoking the said provisions of
Section 122 came to be ordered by Air Officer Commanding in Chief
(AOC) (Western Air Command) on 28-08-2025 and a reference in this
regard is made to a signal produced in the open Court and same is taken
on record.
It is further contended by the counsel for the respondents that since
the provisions of Section 122 came to be rightly invoked prior to the
superannuation of the petitioner, when the petitioner was subject to
provisions of Act of the 1950, the proceedings initiated against the
petitioner and his detention in furtherance thereof is legally valid and
under these circumstances, a writ of Habeas Corpus can be neither sought
nor granted to the petitioner.
7. Before proceeding to advert to the aforesaid rival submissions of the
appearing counsel for the parties, it is deemed appropriate to refer to the
provisions of Section 122 of the Act of 1950 hereunder being relevant to
the issues involved;
122. Liability of offender who ceases to be subject to Act.-(1) Where an
offence under this Act had been committed by any person while subject
to this Act, and he has ceased to be so subject, he may be taken into and
kept in air force custody, and tried and punished for such offence as if
he continued to be so subject.
(2) Except as provided by sub-sections (3) and (4), any such person
shall not be tried for an offence, unless his trial commences within six
months after he had ceased to be subject to this Act.
(3) The provisions of sub-section (2) shall not apply to the trial of any
such person for an offence of desertion or fraudulent enrolment or for
any of the offences mentioned in Section 37.
(4) Nothing contained in sub-section (2) shall affect the jurisdiction of
a civil court to try any offence triable by such court as well as by a
court-martial.
(5) When a person subject to this Act is sentenced by a court-martial to
transportation or imprisonment, this Act shall apply to him during the
term of his sentence, though he is cashiered or dismissed from the Air
Force, or has otherwise ceased to be subject to this Act, and he may be
5|Page
HCP 331/2025
kept, removed, imprisoned and punished as if he continued to be
subject to this Act.
(6) When a person subject to this Act is sentenced by a court-martial to
death, this Act shall apply to him till the sentence is carried out.
8. Keeping in mind the aforesaid provisions of the Act, inasmuch as the
respective pleadings of the parties including the aforesaid rival
submissions of the appearing counsel for the parties, the moot question to
be addressed in the instant petition would be as to whether a writ in the
nature of Habeas Corpus as also the consequential writ of mandamus can
be issued in favour of the petitioner.
9. It is significant to mention here that, in law, a writ of Habeas Corpus is in
the nature of an order calling upon the person who has detained another
to produce the later before the court in order to let the court know on
what grounds he has been confined and set him free, if there is no legal
jurisdiction for his detention and if the detention appears to the court to
be in violation of the procedure established by law, the court has no
option to allow him to be detained on the ground, such as, security of
state or expediency.
The Apex Court in case titled as Union of India vs Chaya
Ghoshal and Anr., reported in 2005 (10) SCC 97 as held that the writ of
Habeas Corpus is a writ of right which is grantable ex-debito-justitiae and
though a writ of right, it is not a writ of course making it incumbent upon
the applicant to show a prima facie case of his unlawful detention.
However, it is also settled position of law in regard to the writ of Habeas
Corpus that if it appears on the face of the returns filed by a party
opposing the issuance of writ of Habeas Corpus that a person is in
detention in execution of the sentence or indictment on a criminal charge,
6|Page
HCP 331/2025
that would be a sufficient answer to an application for Habeas Corpus.
This view has been expressed by the Apex Court in case titled as
Janardan Reddy and Ors vs The State of Hyderabad reported in AIR
1951 SC 217.
10. Having regard to the aforesaid position of law enunciated by the Apex
Court and reverting back to the case in hand and it is not in dispute that
the petitioner herein has superannuated on 31-08-2025 (PM) and action
under the provisions of Section 122 of the Act against the petitioner was
ordered on 28-08-2025 by the CNC stated to be the competent authority
in the matter, manifestly suggesting that on the said date the petitioner
was subject to the provisions of the Act of 1950.
11. Insofar as the plea of the counsel for the petitioner that the provisions of
Section 122 have been invoked by the incompetent authority which has
ordered holding of court martial in the aforesaid petition, said plea
however, is not the subject matter of the instant petition and as such, this
Court refrains from making any observations thereof or rendering any
decision thereto.
12. Therefore, in view of above, it cannot by any stretch of imagination be
said that the petitioner is detained illegally by the respondents’
warranting issuance of writ of Habeas Corpus.
13. Insofar as the writ of Mandamus sought by the petitioner is concerned, the
respondents are required to be called upon to consider the case of the
petitioner in regard to the release of terminal benefits in accordance with
law. Ordered accordingly.
7|Page
HCP 331/2025
14.Viewed thus, for what has been observed, considered and analyzed
hereinabove, the petition shall be stand disposed of accordingly.
(JAVED IQBAL WANI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
12.02.2026
Sarvar
Whether the order is Speaking
Yes
Whether the order is reportable Yes/No
8|Page
HCP 331/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review