Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:920
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 248 of 2021
Date of Decision: 17.10.2024
Shri. Senora Johny Arengh
S/o Shri. David Shira
R/o Sunny Hills Council Complex,
New Tura, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
……Petitioner
-Versus1. The Garo Hills Autonomous District
Council, represented by its Secretary,
Executive Committee, West Garo Hills,
Tura.
2. The Chief Executive Member of Garo Hills
Autonomous District Council, Tura.
3. The Principle Secretary to the Executive
Committee Garo Hills Autonomous
District Council, Tura.
……Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. P.T. Sangma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Dey, SC, GHADC
Ms. N. Rajee, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:920
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard Mr. P.T. Sangma, learned counsel for the petitioner who
has submitted that the fundamental rights of the petitioner guaranteed
under Article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India having been
violated by the action of the respondents herein has prompted the filing
of this instant application for issuance of a writ in the nature of
mandamus, and/or certiorari and any other appropriate writ.
2.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the petitioner was
appointed as an employee of the Garo Hills Autonomous District
Council (GHADC), Tura and at the relevant period, was functioning as a
Lower Divisional Assistant on the strength of an order dated 16.01.2013
passed by the Secretary to the Executive Committee, GHADC.
3.
In course of his service, the petitioner was served with a show
cause notice dated 30.07.2021 issued by the Principal Secretary,
GHADC with a direction to file a reply within 72 hours. In the said
show cause notice addressed to the petitioner as President of the NonGazetted Employee Association (NGEA), it was alleged, inter alia, that
he had instigated other non-gazetted staff members of the Council to
gather in the office premises of the GHADC, Tura on 22.07.2021 in
protest of the said authority, and that he had also made several
statements with the intention to denigrate and defame the Administration
and Officers of the GHADC.
4.
The petitioner has then replied to the said show cause notice
which was received by the respondent authorities on 01.08.2021,
2024:MLHC:920
refuting the charges made against him. However, the respondent
authority in the Executive Committee meeting held on 05.08.2021 in the
office chamber of the Chief Executive Member, GHADC/respondent
No. 2 had inter alia, decided to terminate the services of the petitioner,
the said decision being followed by the order dated 06.08.2021 whereby
his services has been terminated.
5.
The learned counsel has submitted that the action of the
respondent authority is in gross violation of the accepted norms of
service jurisprudence wherein an employee can be terminated only after
proper disciplinary or departmental procedure has been followed.
However, in the case of the petitioner no departmental proceeding has
been initiated and as such, without the appointment of an Enquiry
Officer who would conduct such enquiry in a proper manner, the
termination of the services of the petitioner has been carried out
arbitrarily and illegally.
6.
The learned counsel has also submitted that apart from the
show cause notice and suspension of the petitioner, seven other
employees of the Council were also issued similar show cause for which
a joint written reply dated 01.08.2021 was filed by them including the
petitioner herein. It is to be noted that the seven other employees have
been placed under suspension vide relevant order dated 06.08.2021
issued by the Principal Secretary to the Executive Committee, GHADC,
Tura whereas, the petitioner vide a separate order dated 06.08.2021
(supra) has been terminated from service. Furthermore, as on date, all
the seven employees referred to hereinabove have since been reinstated
in service vide respective order of the Secretary to the Executive
Committee, GHADC, Tura. One such order dated 22.03.2022 has been
2024:MLHC:920
brought on record by way of an additional affidavit by the petitioner
wherein vide the said order one of the suspended employees named
Henyvirth Ch. Marak, Forest Guard, Forest Department, GHADC was
reinstated in service and directed to join office duty. This smacks of
differential treatment to the petitioner, thereby violating his right of
being treated equally with other similarly situated employees who were
charged with the same offence.
7.
The principle of natural justice having been violated, the
petitioner is therefore before this Court with a prayer to set aside and
quash the impugned termination order dated 06.08.2021, submits the
learned counsel.
8.
Per contra, Mr. S. Dey, learned Standing Counsel, GHADC
appearing for all the respondents herein has submitted that the petitioner
as President of NGEA was in the forefront of several protests, strikes
and agitations against the authorities of the GHADC. The said show
cause notice dated 30.07.2021 was issued upon the petitioner who was
found to have indulged in activities unbecoming of an employee of the
District Council when on 22.07.2021 in the midst of the COVID-19
pandemic lockdown he had instigated other employees to protest against
the authorities, such activities being violative of the conduct expected
from an employee of the Council.
9.
The learned Standing Counsel has also further submitted that
the Executive Committee has carefully considered the reply filed by the
petitioner and has found out that the same was more of a challenge and
counter allegation in nature, the same being directed at the authorities
concerned. It is on this ground, the reply not being found satisfactory,
2024:MLHC:920
that the Executive Committee had decided to terminate the services of
the petitioner.
10.
The learned Standing Counsel has also submitted that the
GHADC is not governed by the service rules of the State Government
and/or the Central Government to make it applicable to its employees,
and as such, there is no requirement of a formal disciplinary enquiry to
be initiated. However, due opportunity was given to the petitioner to
explain himself. As such, there is no violation of the principle of natural
justice.
11.
The learned Standing Counsel has also submitted that the
petitioner is well aware that his employment is temporary in nature, for
which the respondent authority has the right to terminate such temporary
services at any point of time which was done so under the
circumstances. Therefore, having lost faith in the conduct of the
petitioner, his termination from service is found justified and there is no
question of his reinstatement.
12.
The learned Standing Counsel has cited the case of Sirsi
Municipality v. Cecelia Kom Frances Tellis, reported in 1973(3) SCR
348 to say that in such case the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that
termination or dismissal of what is described as a pure contract of
master and servant is not declared to be a nullity however wrongful and
illegal it may be. The reason is that dismissal in breach of contract is
remedied by damages. The same principle was also followed in the case
of Executive Committee of U.P. State Warehousing Corporation Limited
v. Chandra Kiran Tyagi, (1970) 2 SCR 250 and also in the case of Indian
Airlines Corporation v. Sukhdeo Rai, 1971 (2) SCC 192, further submits
2024:MLHC:920
the learned Standing Counsel.
13.
In order to lay stress on the nature of employment of the
petitioner and the consequences thereof, the learned Standing Counsel
has also referred to the case of Abdul Motaleb v. Garo Hills District
Council, Tura & Anr., AIR 1961 Assam 69 wherein at para 5 the Court
has observed as follows:
“5. In this matter the petitioner does not contend that the State
Government had anything to do either with the appointment or
dismissal or had any control over the duties and activities of the
person concerned. Therefore in our opinion Article 311 of the
Constitution has no application and he could not invoke the aid
thereof. Apart from what is stated above, we find nothing in the
facts stated in the petition that there has been any violation of
the principles of natural justice. The petitioner was an employee
of the District Council and was asked to serve on a temporary
basis. It is not contended either on his behalf that the post
became either permanent or quasi-permanent and therefore the
notice terminating his appointment could not be said to be
invalid in the eye of law. The petition accordingly fails and is
dismissed but without costs.”
14.
Finding nothing wrong with the passing of the impugned order
of termination of the services of the petitioner the learned Standing
Counsel has submitted that this petition being devoid of merits is liable
to be dismissed.
15.
What is apparent from the materials on record and on
consideration of the submission and contention made by the learned
counsels for the rival parties is that the mode and manner in which the
employment of the petitioner as an employee of the GHADC, Tura was
terminated is under scrutiny herein.
16.
The services of the petitioner have not been terminated
2024:MLHC:920
simpliciter, that is, because such employment is temporary in nature.
Even if this is the case, adequate reasons for such termination have to be
furnished to justify the action taken. However, the termination of the
petitioner was based solely on the fact that on an apparent misconduct
on his part, after show cause was called for to which he has accordingly
replied, the reply found not satisfactory, he was thereafter terminated
from his employment.
17.
The learned Standing Counsel for the respondent/GHADC has
not been able to show from the records that before the said termination
order was passed the petitioner was subjected to a proper enquiry to
allow the concerned authorities to come to a finding necessitating his
termination. Though reliance was placed in the authority of the case of
Abdul Motaleb(supra) to say that as far as the issue of termination from
service of an employee of the GHADC vis-à-vis the case of an employee
under the State or Union Government, is concerned, there cannot be any
comparison as the provision of Article 311 of the Constitution of India
will not be applicable to an employee of the GHADC, the ruling never
suggested that the principle of natural justice as far as the applicability
of the principles of service jurisprudence is concerned will not be
applicable in matters of employment.
18.
Be that as it may, the learned Standing Counsel has
contradicted himself in this respect as it is very evident from the
contents of the minutes of the meeting of the Executive Committee, the
Apex body of the GHADC, held on 05.08.2021, which has been
annexed as Annexure-4 in this petition, certain resolutions have been
passed, one, being that the seven employees mentioned by the petitioner
be placed under suspension, secondly, that the petitioner be terminated
2024:MLHC:920
from service, thirdly, that an Inquiry Committee for disciplinary action
has been constituted with the Chairman and members named therein. Yet
another resolution is the decision to adopt the Meghalaya Services
(Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 2011.
19.
What the above entails is that the Executive Committee is
conscious of the fact that for the purpose of fair administration, a
delinquent employee has to be subjected to a process of an enquiry
before any action is contemplated to be taken against him or her. If such
a process is made available to the seven employees who were served
with similar show cause notices and who have jointly filed their reply
along with the petitioner, then indeed the principle of natural justice as
far as the petitioner is concerned has not been followed or applied.
20.
Furthermore, to say that the GHADC is not required to follow
the accepted norm of institution of an enquiry to examine a case of
misdemeanor of an employee, the adopting of the Meghalaya Services
(Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 2011 should not have been resorted to. It
may be pointed out that as per Rule 9 of the said Rules of 2011, the
procedure of how an inquiry is to be conducted has been laid down. This
Rule is extracted herein as:
“9. Procedure for imposing penalties. - (9,1) Without
prejudice to the provisions of the Public Servants (Inquiry) Act,
1850, no order imposing on a Government servant any of the
penalties specified in rule 7 shall be passed except after an
inquiry, held as far as may be, in the manner hereinafter
provided.
(9.2) The Disciplinary Authority shall frame definite charges on
the basis of the allegations on which the inquiry is proposed to
be hold. Such charges, together with a statement of the
allegations on which they are based, shall be communicated in
writing to the Government servant, and he shall be required to
2024:MLHC:920
submit within such time as may be specified by the
Disciplinary Authority, a written statement of his defence and
also to state whether he desires to be heard in person. At the
time of delivering the charges, the Disciplinary Authority shall
invariably furnish to the Government servant a list of
documents and witnesses by which each article of charges is
proposed to be sustained.
Explanation - In this sub-rule and in sub-rule (3), the expression
"the Disciplinary Authority" shall include the authority
competent under these rules to impose upon the Government
servant any of the penalties specified in rule 7.
(9.3) The Government servant shall, for the purpose of
preparing his defence, be permitted to inspect and take extracts
from such official records as he may specify, provided that such
permission may be refused if, for reasons to be recorded in
writing in the opinion of the Disciplinary Authority such
records are not relevant for the purpose or it is against the
public interest to allow him access thereto:
Provided that when a Government servant is permitted to
inspect and take extracts from official records due care shall be
taken against tampering, removal or destruction of records.
(9.4) On receipt of the written statement of defence, or if no
such statement is received within the time specified the
Disciplinary Authority may itself inquire into such of the
charges as are not admitted or, if it considers it necessary so to
do, appoint for the purpose a Board of inquiry or an Inquiring
Officer.
(9.5) The Disciplinary Authority may nominate any person to
present the case in support of the charges before the Authority
inquiring into the charges (hereinafter referred to as the
Inquiring Authority). The Government servant may present his
case with the assistance of any other Government servant
approved by the Disciplinary Authority, but may not engage a
legal practitioner for the purpose unless the person nominated
by the Disciplinary Authority as aforesaid is a legal practitioner
or unless the Disciplinary Authority, having regard to the
circumstances of the case, so permits.
(9.6) The Inquiring Authority shall, in the course of the inquiry
consider such documentary evidence and take such oral
2024:MLHC:920
evidence as may be relevant or material in regard to the
charges. The Government servant shall be entitled to crossexamine witnesses examined in support of the charges and to
give evidence in person, and to adduce documentary and oral
evidence in his defence. The person presenting the case in
support of the charges shall be entitled to cross-examine the
Government servant and the witnesses examined in his defence.
If the Inquiring Authority declines to examine any witness or to
admit any document in evidence on the ground that his
evidence or such document is not relevant or material, it shall
record its reasons in writing.
Explanation - If in the opinion of the Inquiring Authority the
proceedings of the enquiry establish any article of charge
different from the original article of the charge, it may record
its findings on such article of charge;
Provided that the findings on such article of charge shall not be
recorded unless the Government servant has either admitted
that facts on which such article of charge is based or has been
afforded a reasonable opportunity of defending himself against
such article of charge.
(9.7) At the conclusion of the inquiry, the Inquiring Authority
shall prepare a report of the inquiry, recording its findings on
each of the charges together with reasons therefore.
(9.8) The record of the inquiry shall include
(i) the charges framed against the Government servant
and the statement of allegations furnished to him under
sub-rule (2)
(ii) his written statement of defence, if any;
(iii) the oral evidence taken in the course of the enquiry;
(iv) the documentary evidence considered in the course of
the inquiry;
(v) the orders, if any, made by the Disciplinary Authority
and the Inquiring Authority in regard to the inquiry;
and
(vi) a report netting out the findings on each charge and
the reasons therefore.
(9.9) The Disciplinary Authority shall, if it is not the Inquiring
Authority, consider the record of the inquiry and record its
2024:MLHC:920
findings on each charge….”
21.
It is obvious that the said procedure as prescribed in Rule 9
(supra) has not been carried out in the case of the petitioner. Therefore,
his termination from service has not only violated the related Rule 9 but
has also demonstrated that the principle of natural justice has not been
followed in his case.
22.
On an overall analysis of the case of the parties, this Court is
convinced that the impugned order of termination has been passed
arbitrarily and is therefore illegal. The same is, therefore, liable to be
quashed which is done so herewith.
23.
The prayer of the petitioner in this regard is allowed, the said
order of termination dated 06.08.2021 is hereby set aside and quashed
and the respondent authorities are directed to reinstate the petitioner in
service forthwith with all consequential financial benefits.
24.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
Date: 2024.10.17 18:21:25
PDT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review