Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NIRMALA
RAO
2026:CGHC:9272
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 1988 of 2025
1 - Savita Chandrakar W/o Late Dileshwar Chandrakar Aged About 36 Years R/o
Village- Jhopadi Potar Kholi, Ward No.- 65, Thana And Tahsil- Sirgitti, Distt.Bilaspur (C.G.) Hall- Mukam- Uddhavnagar Bakipara Kormi, Near- Madan Kirana
Store,
Thana-
Sirgitti
Bilaspur,
Tahsil
And
Distt.-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
2 - Dilshan Chandrakar S/o Late Dileshwar Chandrakar Aged About 13 Years Minor
Through Legal Guardian Mother Appellant No. 1 Savita Chandrakar, R/o VillageJhopadi Potar Kholi, Ward No.- 65, Thana And Tahsil- Sirgitti, Distt.- Bilaspur (C.G.)
Hall- Mukam- Uddhavnagar Bakipara Kormi, Near- Madan Kirana Store, ThanaSirgitti
Bilaspur,
Tahsil
And
Distt.-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
3 - Paras Chandrakar S/o Late Dileshwar Chandrakar Aged About 7 Years Minor
Through Legal Guardian Mother Appellant No. 1 Savita Chandrakar, R/o VillageJhopadi Potar Kholi, Ward No.- 65, Thana And Tahsil- Sirgitti, Distt.- Bilaspur (C.G.)
Hall- Mukam- Uddhavnagar Bakipara Kormi, Near- Madan Kirana Store, ThanaSirgitti
Bilaspur,
Tahsil
And
Distt.-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
4 - Shiv Prasad Chandrakar S/o Jageshwar Chandrakar Aged About 64 Years R/o
Village- Jhopadi Potar Kholi, Ward No.- 65, Thana And Tahsil- Sirgitti, Distt.Bilaspur (C.G.) Hall- Mukam- Uddhavnagar Bakipara Kormi, Near- Madan Kirana
Store,
Thana-
Sirgitti
Bilaspur,
Tahsil
And
Distt.-
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
5 - Son Bai W/o Shiv Prasad Chandrakar Aged About 58 Years R/o Village- Jhopadi
Potar Kholi, Ward No.- 65, Thana And Tahsil- Sirgitti, Distt.- Bilaspur (C.G.) HallMukam- Uddhavnagar Bakipara Kormi, Near- Madan Kirana Store, Thana- Sirgitti
Bilaspur, Tahsil And Distt.- Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Nand Kumar Yadav S/o Vedram Yadav Aged About 40 Years R/o VillageKohrauda Ward No.- 05, Thana- Masturi, Tahsil- Navagarh, District- Bemetara
(C.G.) (Driver Of The Offending Vehicle Truck No. C.G. 10/ A.P./9614)
2 - Ajit Tiwari S/o Krishna Chand Tiwari R/o Phooleshwari Sharma House, Kashim
Para Shankar Nagar, Thana- Torwa, Bilaspur, Tahsil And District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
(Owner
Of
The
Offending
Vehicle
Truck
No.
C.G.
10/a.P./9614)
3 - Through Branch Manager The Oriental Insurance Company Limited, Ram Trade
Centre, 1st Floor, Near- Old Bus Stand, In Front Of Rajiv Plaza- Bilaspur, Tahsil And
District- Bilaspur (C.G.) (Insurer Of The Offending Vehicle Truck No. C.G. 10/
A.P./9614)
... Respondent(s)
For Appellants
For Respondents No.1 & 2
For Respondent No.3
:
:
:
Shri A.L. Singraul, Advocate.
None.
Shri Raj Awasthi, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
Order on Board
23.02.2026
1.
The appellants/ claimants have filed this appeal for enhancement of
compensation assailing the judgment and award passed by the learned
Sixth Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur in
Claim Case No.31 of 2022 dated 20.1.2025 whereby the learned
Tribunal passed an award to the tune of Rs.29,76,210/- alongwith
interest @ 9% per annum on account of death of Dileshwar
Chandrakar.
2.
The facts, in brief, are that on 21.5.2021 when deceased Dileshwar
Chandrakar alongwith his brother were returning from Dharsiva, District
Baloda Bazar, near Masturi Darrighat Highway, the driver of the
offending Truck bearing registration No.C.G.10 A.P. 9614, by driving it
rashly and negligently dashed the motorcycle resultantly, Dileshwar
Chandrakar sustained grievous injuries and succumbed to death on
14.6.2021.
The claimants, who are widow, two minor children and
parents filed a claim case under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles act
wherein they pleaded that the deceased was a Contractor earning
Rs.5,00,000/- per annum and was aged about 40 years at the time of
accident.
They claimed a sum of Rs.29,76,210/-.
The Insurance
Company filed its reply denying the averments made in the claim
petition. Learned Tribunal framed issues, the parties led their evidence
and thereafter, an award was passed.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellants would submit that a xerox copy of
the Income-tax return for the financial year 2017-18 was placed on
record. He would submit that according to ITR, the gross income of the
deceased was Rs.3,04,800/- and the learned Tribunal should have
taken that figure while assessing the income of the deceased.
He
would further contend that the deceased remained hospitalized for
23 days.
It is submitted that the learned Tribunal has honoured
medical bills placed by the claimants before the learned Tribunal but
failed to grant compensation towards pain and suffering. He would
fairly submit that under other heads, the learned Tribunal has awarded
just and proper compensation.
He would pray to enhance the
compensation. He has placed reliance on the judgments passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Sayar and Ors. vs.
Ramkaran and Ors., passed in SLP(C) No.24501 of 2025 and in the
matter of Nidhi Bhargava and Ors. vs. National Insurance Company
Ltd. And Ors., passed in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.10664 of
2019.
4.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No.3/ Insurance
Company would oppose the submissions made by counsel for the
appellants. He would submit that the claimants placed on record the
xerox copy of ITR for the financial year 2017-18 and therefore, the
same was not exhibited. He would submit that the learned Tribunal has
rightly ignored the said document. He would further submit that the
Tribunal failed to examine any officials from the Income-tax department
to prove the ITR for the financial year 2017-18, therefore, the learned
Tribunal treated the deceased a semiskilled labourer and assessed his
income at Rs.10,890/- per month. He would submit that the learned
Tribunal has granted just and proper compensation and the appeal
deserves to be dismissed. He has placed reliance on the judgment
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of New India
Assurance Company Limited vs. Sonigra Juhi Uttamchand,
reported in (2025) 3 SCC 23, wherein it is held that the xerox copies of
the income-tax returns are not admissible in evidence.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents present on record.
6.
Admittedly, the deceased met with an accident on 21.5.2021 and died
on 14.6.2021. The claimants pleaded that the income of the deceased
was Rs.3,04,800/- and placed on record a xerox copy of income-tax
return for the financial year 2017-18. The claimants failed to examine
any officials from the Income-tax department, therefore, learned
Tribunal treated the deceased as a semiskilled labourer and assessed
his income at Rs.10,890/- per month.
7.
In the matter of Sayar (supra), it has been held that the returns for the
preceding year or years must be taken as a foundational benchmark,
subject to careful judicial examination, recognizing that business profits
are seldom static and often exhibit a progressive growth trajectory.
Para 12 is reproduced herein below:
“12. What flows from Nidhi Bhargava (supra) is that the
Income Tax Returns filed after the accident/death can also be
taken into consideration for calculation of income to award
compensation. However, having due regard for the Tribunal’s
well-placed doubts, in so far as returns filed for the relevant
year, we take a different approach. In the instant case, it
cannot be simply assumed that there is no profit accruing from
the business of the deceased at the time of the accident. To
adopt such a presumption would be contrary to the settled
principles guiding the assessment of compensation. Rather,
the returns for the preceding year or years must be taken as a
foundational
benchmark,
subject
to
careful
judicial
examination, recognizing that business profits are seldom
static and often exhibit a progressive growth trajectory. The
exercise thus calls for a fair and reasonable assessment,
grounded in available evidence, of the financial benefits that
the deceased would have justifiably earned but for the
untimely accident. In our considered view, in order to award
just and fair compensation, the annual income of the deceased
is re-assessed at Rs.1,00,000/- per annum. The claimantappellant(s) are also entitled to compensation under other
heads in accordance with the settled principles of law.
8.
In the matter of Nidhi Bhargava (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has held that an income tax return is a legally admissible document on
the basis of which the income of the deceased can be assessed. Para
13 is reproduced herein below:
“13. The Income Tax Return is a legally admissible document on
which the income assessment of the deceased could be made.
This Court in Malarvizhi v United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,
(2020) 4 SCC 228 affirmed that the determination of income
must proceed on the basis of Income Tax Return(s), when
available, being a statutory document. In S Vishnu Ganga v
Oriental Insurance Company Limited, 2025 SCC OnLine SC
182, we opined:
‘11. …It is no longer res integra that Income Tax
Returns are reliable evidence to assess the income of
a deceased, reference whereof can be made to Amrit
Bhanu Shali v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., (2012) 11
SCC 738 [Para 17]; Kalpanaraj v. Tamil Nadu State
Transport Corporation, (2015) 2 SCC 764 [Para 7],
and K Ramya (supra) [Para 14 of 2022 SCC OnLine
SC 1338].’
(emphasis supplied)”
9.
In the matter of Sonigra Juhi (supra), xerox copies of the Income Tax
Returns of the financial years 2003 to 2007 were placed on record.
Learned Tribunal as well as the High Court did not treat them as
admissible evidence and assessed the income without placing reliance
on the said xerox copies. The Hon’ble Supreme Court affirmed the
view taken by the Tribunal and the High Court. The relevant paras 9 &
10 are reproduced herein below:
“9. A perusal of the impugned judgment would reveal the
monthly income of the appellant's father as also the mother
were fixed by the Tribunal and the same was not
challenged by the respondent in appeal. The fact is that,
the appellant had produced only the xerox copies of the
Income Tax Returns of her parents, pertaining to the
financial years 2003 to 2007. Indisputably, the Tribunal as
also the High Court did not take them as admissible
evidence and make assessment on their basis. At the same
time without placing reliance on the xerox copies of the
Income Tax Returns, the Tribunal fixed the monthly income
of her father as Rs.12,000/- and that of her mother as
Rs.8,000/-. The impugned judgment would reveal that the
monthly income thus fixed in the case of the parents were
slightly enhanced by the High Court and it in the case her
of father was re-fixed as Rs. 18,000/- and in case of her
mother as Rs. 9,000/-.
10. As held by this Court in Sarla Verma's case (supra), in
the matter of assessment of compensation, hypothetical
considerations would be involved, but nevertheless such
assessments should be objective. As noticed hereinbefore,
the accident had occurred in the year 2007, and the father
of the appellant, who claimed to had been running a
jewellery shop, was aged only 48 years at the time of the
accident. In the case of the mother of the appellant, she
was aged only 38 years at the time of the accident and she
was also not a mere housewife and claimed to had been
running a jewellery shop. The Tribunal could not be said to
have committed any mistake in not accepting the xerox
copies of the tax returns and virtually adopted guess work
relying on the attending circumstances to fix the monthly
income of the parents of the appellant for calculation
purpose.”
10.
It is a well-settled principle of law that an income-tax return is a legally
admissible document. The income of the deceased can be assessed
based on ITR but at the same time, the claimants are required to
submit a certified copy of the return or a copy issued by the Competent
Authority before the learned Tribunal.
The claimants may also
examine any official of the income-tax department to prove the
contents of the ITR.
11.
In the present case, the claimants failed to submit a certified copy or a
copy issued by the Competent Authority of ITR before the learned
Tribunal. Therefore, the learned Tribunal ignored the said document
and assessed the income of the deceased by applying the minimum
wages matrix. The approach adopted by the learned Tribunal appears
to be proper.
12.
It is not in dispute that the deceased remained hospitalized for 23 days.
The learned Tribunal has granted a sum of Rs.6,65,000/- towards
medical expenses incurred during treatment. As held by by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the matter of Devendra Kumar Tripathi & Ors. vs.
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. and Anr. passed in Special
Leave Petition (C) No.2195 of 2024, the claimants would be entitled
to a sum of Rs.25,000/- towards pain and suffering. Under the other
heads, the learned Tribunal has granted just and proper compensation.
Accordingly, the submission made by counsel for the appellant with
regard to income of the deceased based on ITR is hereby rejected.
The claimants shall be entitled for a sum of Rs.25,000/- for pain and
suffering, as the deceased remained hospitalized for 23 days.
The
Insurance Company is directed to deposit the enhanced amount of
compensation as awarded by this Court within a period of 60 days from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order. The additional amount of
compensation shall carry interest @ 9% per annum from the date of
filing of claim application before the Tribunal till its realization. Rest of
the conditions of the impugned award shall remain intact.
13.
Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed and the impugned award is
modified to the extent as indicated herein-above.
Sd/(Rakesh Mohan Pandey)
Judge
Nimmi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review