Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010561772007
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3396]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE 7th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1330/2007
Between:
1. SATYAMSETTI ANANTA LAKSHMI AND 3 OTHERS, W/O LATE
SATYAMSETTI
VENKATESHWARLU,
D/O
CHENNANGI
NAGESWARA R/O G.DONTAMURU VILLAGE, RANGAMPETA
MANDAL, E.G.DIST.
2. SATYAMSETTI DURGA NAGA SYAMALA, D/O LATE SATYAMSETTI
VENKATESHWARLU, MINOR R/O G.DONTAMURU VILLAGE,
RANGAMPETA MANDAL, E.G.DIST.
3. SATYAMSETTI DURGA GANESH,
VENKATESHWARLU, MINOR R/O
RANGAMPETA MANDAL, E.G.DIST.
S/O LATE SATYAMSETTI
G.DONTAMURU VILLAGE,
4. SATYAMSETTI DURGA JHANSI, D/O LATE SATYAMSETTI
VENKATESHWARLU, MINOR, PE.T 2 TO 4 ARE REP. BY THEIR
MOTHER -1ST PET. R/O G.DONTAMURU VILLAGE, RANGAMPETA
MANDAL, E.G.DIST.
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. UNION OF INDIA REP BY GM SC RLY SECUNDERABAD, REP. BY
ITS GENERAL MANAGER, S.C.RAILWAY, CCC, SECUNDERABAD.
...RESPONDENT
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. M V SURESH
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. N SASIKALA
2. JUPUDI V K YAGNADUTT(CENTRAL GOVERNMENT COUNSEL)
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1330/2007
JUDGMENT:1. The present appeal is preferred by the appellants/claimants, aggrieved
by the order dated 06.03.2007 passed in O.P. No.168 of 2004 on the file of
the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Principal District Judge), East Godavari
District, Rajahmundry (hereinafter referred to as "the Tribunal"), whereby the
Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs.1,09,500/- as compensation to the appellant
Nos.1 to 4/claimants, as against their claim of Rs.9,20,000/-, on account of the
death of Sri Satyamsetti Venkateswarlu in a road traffic accident, seeking
enhancement of the compensation.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as they were
arrayed before the Tribunal.
3. The petitioners are the wife and children of the deceased, Sri
Satyamsetti Venkateswarlu. The case of the petitioners, in brief, is that on
31.12.2002 at about 9:15 a.m., while the deceased was driving his tractor
bearing Registration No. AP 5X 2853 and was crossing the manned railway
level crossing bearing Gate No.415 at Km.605/22 towards Anaparthi, Train
No.2718 Ratnachal Express dashed against the tractor. It is their specific case
that the deceased was driving the tractor with due care and caution and
attempted to cross the railway gate as it was kept open. However, before he
could safely cross the railway track, the superfast train hit the tractor, resulting
in his instantaneous death at the spot. It is further pleaded that the tractor was
completely damaged in the accident. They filed the claim petition under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act claiming compensation of Rs.9,20,000/on account of the untimely death of the deceased, contending that the
accident occurred due to the negligence of the respondents.
4. Before the Tribunal, the respondent filed its written statement denying
the material averments made in the claim petition and contended that the
petitioners had not issued any claim notice prior to filing of the claim petition. It
was further contended that the railway gate could not be closed on the date of
the accident due to unavoidable circumstances and that the road users had
adequate visibility of the railway level crossing. The respondent further
contended that the deceased, without observing the safety precautions,
attempted to cross the railway track in a rash and negligent manner, despite
the continuous whistling of the approaching train, and thereby invited the
accident. It was further contended that the accident occurred solely due to the
negligence of the deceased, who was driving the tractor, and that there was
no negligence on the part of the respondent. It was also contended that the
respondent is not liable to pay any compensation and that the compensation
claimed by the petitioners is excessive. On the above grounds, the respondent
prayed for dismissal of the claim petition with costs.
5. Basing on the above pleadings, the following issues were framed by the
Tribunal:
1) Whether the deceased Satyamsetty Venkatacswarlu, died in
motor accident occurred on 31.12.2002 at 9-05 AM at KMS 605/2
Level Gate No.415 between Anaparthi and Biccavolu while the
deceased was driving tractor bearing No. AP 5X 2853 when the train
bearing No. 2718 Ratnachal Express hit the tractor due to the gross
negligence of the Station Master on duty and the gateman who are
working under the control of the respondent?
2) Whether the petitioners being the dependants of the deceased
S. Venkateswarlu, are entitled to the compensation of Rs.9,20,00000 with interest thereon from the respondent?
3) To what relief?
6. During the course of trial, the 1st petitioner examined herself as P.W.1
and examined P.Ws.2 and 3 and marked Exs.A1 to A10 on behalf of the
petitioners. R.W.1 was examined on behalf of the respondent.
7. After hearing the learned counsel appearing for both parties and upon
appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence available on record, the
Tribunal came to the conclusion that the accident occurred due to the
contributory negligence of both the deceased and the respondent's employee.
The Tribunal held that the respondent's employee was negligent in not closing
the manned railway level crossing while Train No.2718 Ratnachal Express
was passing through the level crossing and that the deceased was also
negligent in attempting to cross the railway track in a rash and negligent
manner. Accordingly, the Tribunal apportioned the negligence equally
between them and partly allowed the claim petition by awarding a sum of
Rs.1,09,500/- as compensation to the petitioners, together with proportionate
costs and interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of presentation
of the claim petition till the date of realization.
8. Aggrieved by the said Award, the appellants/claimants have preferred
the present appeal seeking enhancement of the compensation on the ground
that the Tribunal erred in attributing 50% contributory negligence to the
deceased and consequently deducting 50% of the compensation.
9. Heard Sri M.V.Suresh, learned counsel for the appellants and
Ms.T.Priyanka, learned counsel representing Sri Jupudi V.K.Yagnadutt,
learned Central Government Counsel for the respondent.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants would submit that
the appellants are the wife and children of the deceased, who died in the
accident while crossing the manned railway level crossing. It is contended that
there is no evidence on record to establish that all the other vehicles had
stopped at the railway crossing and that the deceased alone attempted to
cross the railway track in disregard of the approaching train. In the absence of
any such evidence, the Tribunal was not justified in attributing 50%
contributory negligence to the deceased. Learned counsel would further
submit that the Tribunal erred in assessing the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.1,500/-. According to the claimants, the deceased was an
agriculturist and was also using his tractor for agricultural operations on hire,
earning about Rs.6,000/- per month. Considering that the accident occurred
on 31.12.2002 and that the deceased was a skilled tractor driver, his monthly
income ought to have been taken at least at Rs.3,000/- for the purpose of
computing compensation. It is further submitted that the Tribunal failed to
award any amount under the conventional heads such as loss of consortium,
funeral expenses and loss of estate. Learned counsel finally prays that just
compensation may be awarded to the appellants/claimants, and submitted
that the appellants are ready and willing to pay the requisite court fee, if any,
on the enhanced compensation.
11.
Learned Central Government Counsel for the respondent would
submit that it is a clear case of contributory negligence. The evidence of
R.W.1 would clearly establish that, except the deceased, all the other road
users had stopped on noticing the approaching train, whereas the deceased,
despite observing the movement of the train, attempted to cross the manned
railway level crossing and, thereby, met with the accident. Learned counsel
would further submit that the Tribunal rightly fixed 50% contributory
negligence on the part of the deceased and awarded only 50% of the
compensation determined by it. Learned counsel finally submits that the Court
may pass appropriate orders regarding the quantum of the compensation.
12.
Having heard the submissions on both sides, now the points that
would emerge for determination in this mater are:
1) Whether the finding of the Tribunal attributing 50% contributory
negligence
to
the
deceased
and
consequently
reducing
the
compensation by 50% is sustainable in law and on the facts of the
case?
2) Whether the compensation determined by the Tribunal at
Rs.2,19,000/-
and
the
award
of
only
Rs.1,09,500/-
to
the
appellants/claimants, after deducting 50% on account of contributory
negligence, is just and reasonable, or whether the same warrants
interference by this Court while sitting in appeal?
Determination by this Court:
13.
Determination of compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 is not an exercise capable of mathematical precision. The endeavour of
the Court is to award "just compensation" having regard to the facts and
circumstances of each case. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in United India
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shila Datta,1 has observed that an award passed by
the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal is not in the nature of an adversarial
adjudication between litigating parties, but is a statutory determination of
compensation payable on the occurrence of a motor accident after due
enquiry. The object of the Act being a beneficial piece of legislation, the
approach of the Court must be to ensure that the compensation awarded is
not a windfall but is just, fair and reasonable. Further, in Geeta Dubey v.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Others, 2 the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reiterated that an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act is in the
nature of a first appeal, and the appellate Court is under a legal obligation to
independently examine the entire evidence on record and determine all
questions of fact and law.
14.
The law relating to determination of just compensation in cases of
death arising out of motor vehicle accidents has evolved through a consistent
line of decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, beginning with Sarla Verma &
Ors. v. Delhi Transport Corporation &Anr., 3 developed further by the
(2011) 10 SCC 509
2024 INSC 998
(2009) 6 SCC 121
Constitution Bench in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi & Ors.4,
and thereafter consolidated into a structured and step-wise framework by a
series of other precedents. Importantly, a three Judge Bench of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur @
Satwinder Kaur, 5 culled outthat the criteria to be taken into consideration for
assessing compensation in a case of death are: (i) the age of the deceased at
the time of death; (ii) the number of dependants left behind by the deceased;
and (iii) the income of the deceased at the time of death.In furtherance of the
law laid down in Sarla Verma, (referred supra) it was further held that to arrive
at the loss of dependency, the Tribunal must take into consideration three
factors i.e., the additions or deductions to be made for arriving at the income,
the deduction to be made towards the personal and living expenses of the
deceased and the multiplier to be applied with reference to the age of the
deceased.
15.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sarla Verma(referred supra)
undertook a very comprehensive examination of the principles governing
assessment of compensation in fatal motor accident cases and evolved a
standardized method for determining loss of dependency. It was held that the
multiplier method is the most appropriate and scientific method for computing
compensation, as it promotes uniformity, certainty and consistency in awards
passed by the Courts and Tribunals. The Hon'ble Supreme Court further held
that the selection of the appropriate multiplier must ordinarily be with reference
(2017) 16 SCC 680
(2020) 11 SCC 1
to the age of the deceased and not the age of the dependants. Further, on the
point of the multiplier, it is held that a standardized, age-linked table shall
govern the computation, such that the multipliers to be applied are 18 for the
age group 15 to 25 years, 17 for 26 to 30 years, 16 for 31 to 35 years, 15 for
36 to 40 years, 14 for 41 to 45 years, 13 for 46 to 50 years, 11 for 51 to 55
years, 9 for 56 to 60 years, 7 for 61 to 65 years, and 5 for 66 to 70 years. On
the deduction towards personal and living expenses, it is held that one-third of
the income is to be deducted where the deceased was married, and one-half
where the deceased was unmarried.
16.
The Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pranay
Sethi (referred supra) while dealing with the conventional heads of
compensation in death cases, held that compensation is payable under the
heads of loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses. It was also
held that these conventional heads cannot be determined on a percentage
basis, but have to be quantified on a reasonable basis, keeping in view the
relevant factors. The Constitution Bench at para 52 inter alia, fixed the
amounts under the said heads as Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate,
Rs.40,000/- towards loss of consortium and Rs.15,000/- towards funeral
expenses, subject to appropriate enhancement in terms of the principles laid
down therein.
On the question of additions to income towards future
prospects, the Constitution Bench extended the benefit beyond permanent
employees, holding that the calculation of future prospects is to be extended
to persons who are self-employed or on a fixed salary, and not confined to
those in permanent employment. The percentages of addition were fixed i.e.,
for permanent employment, 50% where the deceased was below 40 years,
30% between 40 and 50 years, and 15% between 50 and 60 years; and for
self-employed persons or persons on a fixed salary, 40% below 40 years,
25% between 40 and 50 years, and 10% between 50 and 60 years. It was
held that such addition towards future prospects forms an integral component
of the determination of loss of dependency.Subsequently, in Magma General
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram,6 and in Satinder Kaur,
(referred supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court explained that the term
"consortium" is a comprehensive concept encompassing spousal consortium,
parental consortium and filial consortium.
17.
Here, there is no dispute with regard to the factum of the accident
or the death of the deceased. It is also not in dispute that the petitioners are
the wife and three children of the deceased and are his dependants. As rightly
contended by the learned counsel for the appellants/claimants, it is the
specific case of the petitioners that the deceased was an agriculturist and was
also using his tractor for agricultural operations on hire, earning about
Rs.6,000/- per month. The Tribunal, however, assessed his income at Rs.60/per day, i.e., Rs.1,500/- per month, which, in the opinion of this Court, is on
the lower side.
18.
Having regard to the fact that the deceased was an agriculturist, a
skilled tractor driver, and owner of a tractor, this Court deems it appropriate to
(2018) 18 SCC 130
(2020) 11 SCC 1
assess his notional income at Rs.3,000/- per month. As the deceased was
aged about 22 years at the time of the accident, an addition of 40% towards
future prospects is required to be made in terms of the law laid down by the
Constitution Bench in Pranay Sethi (referred supra) thereby taking his
monthly income to Rs.4,200/- (Rs.3,000/- + Rs.1,200/-). The annual income
thus comes to Rs.50,400/- (Rs.4,200/- × 12). Since there are four dependants,
one-fourth of the income is liable to be deducted towards personal and living
expenses in terms of Sarla Verma (referred supra)leaving an annual
contribution of Rs.37,800/- to the family. Applying the multiplier of 18,
appropriate to the age of the deceased as laid down under Sarla
Verma(referred supra), the loss of dependency works out to Rs.6,80,400/(Rs.37,800/- × 18).
19.
The
Tribunal
has
not
awarded
any
amount
under
the
conventional heads. In terms of Pranay Sethi,(referred supra) as explained
in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd.(referred supra) and Satinder Kaur
(referred supra),the 1st petitioner, being the wife of the deceased, and
petitioner Nos.2 to 4, being his children, are each entitled to consortium i.e.,
spousal consortium to the 1st petitioner and parental consortium to petitioner
Nos.2 to 4. Accordingly, a sum of Rs.40,000/- each is awarded, aggregating to
Rs.1,60,000/- (Rs.40,000/- × 4). Further, this Court awards Rs.15,000/towards loss of estate and Rs.15,000/- towards loss of expectation of life,
neither of which was awarded by the Tribunal. The claimants are also entitled
to Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses.
20.
Coming to the aspect of contributory negligence, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the finding of the Tribunal attributing 50%
contributory negligence to the deceased is not sustainable either on facts or in
law. The Tribunal recorded the said finding solely on the basis of the evidence
of R.W.1, who was admittedly not the driver of the train. Except for the
interested testimony of R.W.1, there is no independent evidence on record to
establish that all other road users had stopped at the railway level crossing
and that the deceased alone attempted to cross the track despite noticing the
approaching train.
21.
It is not the case of the respondent that the deceased deliberately
attempted to cross the railway track with an intention to commit suicide. At the
same time, being a road user, the deceased was also expected to exercise
reasonable care while crossing the railway level crossing. Taking an overall
view of the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the opinion
that it would be just and proper to attribute only 10% contributory negligence
to the deceased, instead of 50% as fixed by the Tribunal. Points Nos.1 and 2
are accordingly answered.Accordingly, the compensation is re-assessed and
modified under the various heads as follows:
Sl. No.
Head of
Compensation
Awarded by
Modified by
the Tribunal (Rs.)
this Court (Rs.)
1.
Loss of dependency
2,04,000
6,80,400
2.
Consortium
15,000
1,60,000
(Rs.40,000 × 4)
Sl. No.
Head of
Awarded by
Modified by
Compensation
the Tribunal (Rs.)
this Court (Rs.)
3.
Loss of estate
—
15,000
4.
Loss of expectation of
—
15,000
—
15,000
2,19,000
8,85,400
1,09,500 (50%)
88,540 (10%)
1,09,500
7,96,860
life
5.
Funeral expenses
Total Compensation
Deductions:
Contributory negligence
Net Compensation
Payable
22.
In the result, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is
allowed in part, modifying the Award dated 06.03.2007 passed in O.P. No.168
of 2004 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Principal District
Judge), East Godavari District, Rajahmundry to the extent above. The
compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from Rs.1,09,500/- to
Rs.7,96,860/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the
claim petition till the date of realization. The finding of the Tribunal fixing 50%
contributory negligence on the part of the deceased is modified, and the
contributory negligence is fixed at 10%. The respondent is directed to deposit
the enhanced compensation amount, after giving credit to the amount, if any,
already deposited, within a period of eight (8) weeks from the date of receipt
of a copy of this judgment. On such deposit, the appellants/claimants are
permitted to withdraw the same, along with accrued interest and costs, in
accordance
with
the
apportionment
made
by
the
Tribunal.
The
appellants/claimants shall pay the requisite court fee, if any, on the enhanced
compensation.There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand
closed.
_________________________________________
Dr. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
Date: 07.07.2026.
UPS
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1330/2007
Dt.07.07.2026.
UPS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review