Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~7 & 29
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 12th August, 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010950022024
+
W.P.(C) 17482/2024
SARITA SAINI
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. R. K. Saini and Mr. Abhishek,
Advocates.
versus
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI AND OTHERS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gaurav Dhingra and Mr.
Shashank Singh, Advocates for R-1.
Mr. Pardeep Kumar and Ms.
Sanskriti, Advocates for R-4.
Mr. Arun Birbal and Ms. Nidhi
Sharma, Advocates for NDMC.
#
CNR No. DLHC010361802021
+
W.P.(C) 13268/2021, CM APPL. 41873/2021, CM APPL. 6876/2023,
CM APPL. 7767/2024, CM APPL. 74226/2024 & CM APPL.
49851/2025
MRS. YASH SALUJA AND ORS
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr. Rakesh Munjal, Senior Advocate
with Ms. Sana Ansari, Mr. Ayush
Gandhi and Ms. Hardeep Kaur,
Advocates.
versus
GOVT. OF NATIONAL CAPITAL TERRITORY OF DELHI &
ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ripin Sood, Advocate for R-1.
Mr. Pardeep Kumar and Ms.
Sanskriti, Advocates for R-4.
Mr. Arun Birbal and Ms. Nidhi
Sharma, Advocates for NDMC.
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J. (Oral):
1.
Can pension, lawfully earned by an employee of an aided school and
paid for years after retirement, be discontinued because the school later
closes down? That is the short question in these petitions.
2.
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 has been filed by retired teachers of R.M. Arya
Girls Primary School. Ms. Sarita Saini, who was originally arrayed as
Petitioner No. 9 therein, has subsequently filed W.P.(C) 17482/2024. In
view of the differences that arose between her and the remaining Petitioners,
she sought leave to pursue her claim independently. Since both petitions
have been heard together and arise from the same set of facts and raise a
common question for consideration, CM APPL. 74226/2024, filed in
W.P.(C) 13268/2021, is allowed. Ms. Saini shall accordingly stand deleted
from the array of Petitioners in W.P.(C) 13268/2021, and her claim shall be
considered separately in W.P.(C) 17482/2024. In view thereof, the objection
raised by the NDMC that Ms. Saini was pursuing parallel remedies no
longer survives.
3.
The material facts are largely undisputed. R.M. Arya Girls Primary
School was a recognised school receiving 95% grant-in-aid from the New
Delhi Municipal Council.1 The retired employees superannuated from the
Respondent School after completing the requisite service; their pensionary
entitlements were accepted; and pension was paid for substantial periods
thereafter. Family pension was likewise being paid in the cases where it had
“NDMC”
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
become due. Ms. Saini, for instance, retired as an Assistant Teacher on 30 th
April, 2009, and continued to receive pension until February, 2021. The
pension statement placed on record also reflects payment to her and to
several of the other pensioners immediately before the present dispute arose.
4.
The school was functioning from rented premises. An eviction order
came to be passed in respect of the said premises on 3 rd May, 2017. The
challenge to the eviction order eventually failed before this Court on 2 nd
December, 2020. SLP(C) No. 96/2021, preferred against the said order, was
thereafter dismissed by the Supreme Court on 18 th January, 2021. While
declining to interfere with the order, the Supreme Court granted the
management time until 30th June, 2021 to hand over peaceful and vacant
possession of the premises.
5.
With the date for vacating the premises approaching, the management
addressed a letter dated 27th February, 2021 to NDMC seeking permission to
close the school under Rule 46 of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973 2.
The letter also sought adjustment of the students, absorption or adjustment
of the serving staff, and appropriate action concerning the pensionary
benefits of the retired employees.
6.
The school vacated the premises and ceased to function on 30 th June,
2021. Its students were thereafter accommodated in NDMC schools. During
the pendency of W.P.(C) 13268/2021, pension and arrears were released to
the Petitioners up to 30th June, 2021. The surviving grievance is therefore
confined to the non-payment of pension from 1st July, 2021 onwards.
7.
There is some dispute as to whether the closure had the prior approval
contemplated by Rule 46. NDMC, in its original counter affidavit, stated
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
that permission to close the school had been granted under that provision. In
a later affidavit, however, it took the contrary position that no such approval
had ever been granted.
8.
That dispute need not be resolved in these petitions. The Petitioners
do not seek absorption, nor is any claim made for salary as members of
surplus staff. Whether the closure complied with Rule 46 may bear upon the
rights of the serving employees and upon the financial liability as between
the management and NDMC. It does not, by itself, answer the question:
whether closure of the school can bring to an end pension or family pension
that had already become payable under the applicable pension regime.
9.
Counsel for the Petitioners submits that it cannot. The retired
employees had completed the qualifying service, their pension had been
sanctioned and, in several cases, paid for years. The family pensioners had
likewise been receiving family pension before the school closed. Reliance is
placed on Section 10 of the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 3, Rule 126 of
the Rules, the procedure framed thereunder, and the decision of the Supreme
Court in Smt. Shakuntala Mehrishi v. New Delhi Municipal Committee4
and this Court in Manju Tomar v. NCT.5 The submission, in substance, is
that a pensionary entitlement which has already arisen cannot be undone by
a later dispute concerning closure or funding.
10.
The erstwhile management supports the Petitioners. Its position is that
the prescribed contribution towards pension had been made during the
service tenure of the employees and that pension, after retirement, was being
“the Rules”
“the Act”
(1990) 3 SCC 521.
LPA 441/2009, decided on 9th December, 2009.
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
disbursed through NDMC. The management maintains that closure of the
school at a later point of time cannot affect pension earned for service
already rendered. The Court records this as the stand of the management.
Whether every contribution payable by it was in fact deposited does not
require determination in these proceedings.
11.
NDMC contests the claim. Its principal submission is that once the
school ceased to exist and its recognition came to an end, the Petitioners
could no longer answer the description of an “employee” under Section 2(h)
of the Act. It further contends that neither the Act nor the Rules provide for
payment of pension to former employees of a school after its closure, and
that Rule 47 can operate only where the closure itself complies with Rule
46. Reliance is placed principally on New Delhi Municipal Council v.
Manju Tomar,6 and also on M.S. Tomar v. National Commission for
Scheduled Castes,7 S.P.S. Rana v. National Seeds Corporation8 and Indu
Shekhar Singh v. State of U.P.9
12.
The issue is best approached through the statutory scheme. Section 10
(1) of the Act places pension, gratuity and provident fund in the same
statutory setting as pay, allowances and medical facilities. In material part, it
provides as follows:
“(1) The scales of pay and allowances, medical facilities, pension,
gratuity, provident fund and other prescribed benefits of the employees of
a recognised private school shall not be less than those of the employees of
the corresponding status in schools run by the appropriate authority:
Provided that where the scales of pay and allowances, medical facilities,
pension, gratuity, provident fund and other prescribed benefits of the
employees of any recognised private school are less than those of the
2024 INSC 635.
2023 SCC OnLine Del 1627.
2007 (99) DRJ 227.
(2006) 8 SCC 129.
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
employees of the corresponding status in the schools run by the
appropriate authority, the appropriate authority shall direct, in writing,
the managing committee of such school to bring the same up to the level of
those of the employees of the corresponding status in schools run by the
appropriate authority:
Provided further that the failure to comply with such direction shall be
deemed to be non-compliance with the conditions for continuing
recognition of an existing school and the provisions of section 4 shall
apply accordingly.”
13.
NDMC’s reliance on Section 2(h) does not assist its case. The
provision defines an “employee” as a teacher and includes every other
employee working in a recognised school. A definition clause, however,
cannot be read in isolation from provisions which expressly confer a benefit
payable after employment has ended. If the expression “working in a
recognised school” were understood as a continuing condition for receipt of
pension, every employee would fall outside the statutory scheme upon
retirement. That plainly cannot be the meaning of a statute which expressly
provides for pension and gratuity. Section 2(h) identifies the employment
from which the pensionary right originates. It does not prescribe continued
employment, or the continued existence of the school, as a condition for
payment after retirement.
14.
The Petitioners also invoke Rule 72. In material part, it provides that
where aid to a school has been stopped, reduced or suspended and the
managing committee consequently fails to deposit its share of the salaries
and allowances of the employees, the Administrator shall pay, or cause to be
paid, that share and utilise the amount towards payment of the salaries and
allowances of the employees.
15.
The Court does not consider Rule 72 determinative of the present
controversy. Its language concerns the management’s share of “salaries and
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
allowances” where aid has been stopped, reduced or suspended. It does not
expressly deal with payment of pension after a school has permanently
ceased to function. The Petitioners do not need to enlarge its reach. Their
pensionary entitlement arises independently under Section 10, Rule 126 and
the procedure framed pursuant to Rule 126.
16.
Smt. Shakuntala Mehrishi bears directly on the issue. The Petitioner
there had served as a teacher in R.M. Arya Girls Pathshala. Examining the
pension scheme framed under Rule 126, the Supreme Court held that the
CCS (Pension) Rules applied and that pension became payable from the date
on which the employee ceased to be borne on the establishment upon
superannuation. The Court then dealt with the contention that the modalities
concerning contribution to the pension fund had not been finalised. It
rejected that objection in terms which are particularly relevant here:
“Rule 35 of these Rules provides that a superannuation pension shall
be granted to a Government servant who is retired on his attaining the
age of compulsory retirement. Rule 83 of these Rules, on the other
hand, inter alia, lays down that the pension shall become payable
from the date on which a government servant ceases to be borne on
the establishment. Since these Rules will apply to the petitioner as
contemplated by notification dated 17th October 1975, she is obviously
entitled to get pension with effect from the date on which she ceased to
be borne on the establishment of the school in which she was working
consequent upon reaching the age of superannuation. Rule 126 of the
Rules under which the notification dated 17th October, 1975 had been
issued gives the power to specify procedure for payment of pay and
allowances, pension and gratuity etc. to the Administrator in
consultation with the Accountant General, Central Revenues. The very
opening words of the said notification make it abundantly clear that
the said notification had been issued in exercise of the powers
conferred by Rule 126 of the Rules by the Administrator in
consultation with the Accountant General, Central Revenues. The
notification having thus been issued by the competent authority and
the petitioner who was an existing employee of an aided school on the
date of the issue of the said notification having opted for the pension
and gratuity within the stipulated period in the prescribed proforma
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
which was duly counter-signed by the Education Officer, she
obviously became entitled to the benefits conferred by the said
notification. This is so all the more in view of the fact that the
notification dated 17th October, 1975 did not contemplate finalisation
of the modalities about contribution towards pension fund as a
condition precedent to the entitlement of the benefits under the said
notification. The finalisation of the said modalities was a matter of
details among the authorities concerned and could have no bearing on
the entitlement to the benefits of the notification dated 17th October,
1975. Such finalisation could not even defer the date of the
entitlement.”
17.
NDMC has placed reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in
NDMC v. Manju Tomar, whereby it was held that the protection of Rule 47
could not be invoked by the management of a school which had closed
without the prior approval required under Rule 46. The closure contemplated
by Rule 47, the Court held, must be a valid closure, and the management
could not shift to NDMC the burden of re-employment and payment of
salaries of teaching and non-teaching staff rendered surplus by an unlawful
closure. That holding concerns employees who became surplus upon closure
and the obligation to absorb them. It does not decide whether pensionary
rights which had already accrued to retired employees stand extinguished
merely because the school was subsequently closed without complying with
Rule 46.
18.
The manner in which the Supreme Court dealt with NDMC’s own
appeals in the aforesaid case is equally significant. The Court recorded that
the Division Bench had required NDMC to bear, in the first instance, the pay
and other service benefits, including pension, while permitting it to seek
reimbursement from the management. It further noted that, during the
pendency of the appeals, NDMC had already paid the principal amount
towards salary, pension and other retiral benefits. The Supreme Court
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
declined to interfere with the direction for payment of interest, directed
NDMC to pay the remaining dues, and preserved its right to seek
reimbursement from the management. The final disposition therefore
furnishes no support for the proposition that pension already earned is lost
because the school closed without complying with Rule 46. It instead
preserves a distinction which is material here: payment of the employee’s
dues on the one hand, and adjustment of financial liability between NDMC
and the management on the other.
19.
NDMC also relies upon an interim order dated 30th August, 2010 in
the same proceedings, under which the management was directed to pay
pension during the pendency of the appeals. That was an interim
arrangement as to which party would make the payment while the dispute
remained sub judice. It did not determine the pensionary rights. More
importantly, an interim arrangement cannot be read independently of the
final judgment, which ultimately directed NDMC to discharge the remaining
dues while leaving its right of reimbursement intact.
20.
M.S. Tomar arises in an altogether different setting. The Petitioner
there had been dismissed from service, was a provident fund optee and had
never opted for the pension scheme during service. He later sought
compassionate allowance under the Bank of India Pension Regulations. The
Court held that eligibility for pension was a condition precedent to
consideration of compassionate allowance and declined to extend that
benefit to a person who had no underlying pensionary entitlement. The
distinction is evident; the Petitioners before this Court are not seeking entry
into a pension scheme to which they never belonged. Their pensionary
entitlements had already been recognised, sanctioned and acted upon. The
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
question is whether those existing entitlements could thereafter be
discontinued for a reason which finds no place in the governing pension
scheme.
21.
S.P.S. Rana also does not assist NDMC’s case. The principle invoked
from that decision is that a Court cannot supply an omission in statutory
rules by introducing a condition which the rule-making authority did not
provide. There is no occasion to do so here. The right to pension is already
found in Section 10 and Rule 126. The omission, if any, lies elsewhere:
NDMC has been unable to point to any provision under which that right
ceases upon closure of the school. The Petitioners do not ask the Court to
create a pensionary entitlement where none exists; they assert an entitlement
which had already accrued under the governing scheme and had been
recognised and acted upon by the authorities. Indu Shekhar Singh, which
dealt with the transfer and permanent absorption of employees drawn from
different statutory organisations, also stands on a different footing
altogether. No question of absorption arises in the pension claims before this
Court.
22.
The record contains one further circumstance which is consistent with
this statutory position. On 9th June, 2021, barely three weeks before the
school ceased to function, NDMC issued an office order extending the 7th
Central Pay Commission10 regime to its three aided and recognised schools,
expressly including both shifts of R.M. Arya Girls Primary School. The
instruments adopted by that order included the revision of pension of pre
2016 pensioners and family pensioners in accordance with the 7th CPC
scales. This order is not the source of the Petitioners’ right to pension, nor
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
does the Court treat it as such. It, nonetheless, shows that immediately
before the closure, NDMC itself continued to administer the statutory
pension regime in respect of the pensioners of these aided schools. That
contemporaneous position sits uneasily with the present contention that
pension depended upon the continued functioning of the school.
23.
This, ultimately, is where NDMC’s argument falters. It treats pension
as though it were a recurring incident of the school continuing to function. It
is not. The aided status of the school and the qualifying service rendered by
its employees furnished the legal basis on which pensionary rights arose.
Those rights had matured under the applicable scheme before the school
closed, whether as pension payable to the retired employee or as family
pension derived from that service. A later event affecting the institution
cannot, without statutory authority, reach back and undo them.
24.
The consequence of NDMC’s construction would be grave and
anomalous. A teacher may serve for decades in a recognised aided school,
retire, have pension sanctioned and receive it for years, yet, if the school
closes thereafter, the pension ceases the following month. Neither the Act
nor the Rules nor the procedure governing pension produces such a result.
More importantly, NDMC has identified no provision under which a pension
validly earned and sanctioned ceases merely because the institution in which
the qualifying service was rendered subsequently closes.
25.
The Petitioners also rely on D.S. Nakara v. Union of India,11
Chairman, Railway Board v. C.R. Rangadhamaiah,12 and U.P.
“CPC”
(1983) 1 SCC 305.
(1997) 6 SCC 623.
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
Raghavendra Acharya v. State of Karnataka.13 The decisions approach
pension in different factual settings, but the principle relevant here is settled:
pension is not a bounty dependent upon grace; it is a benefit earned by past
service, and a pensionary right which has accrued under the governing rules
cannot be taken away to the prejudice of the retiree without authority of law.
26.
The age and circumstances of the Petitioners explain the hardship
caused by the stoppage of pension, but hardship is not the basis of the
decision. The answer lies in the statutory scheme. These are not claims to a
discretionary payment. The Petitioners seek continuation of pensionary
benefits which had arisen from service rendered while the school was
recognised and aided, had been sanctioned under the applicable regime and
had, in fact, been paid before the present dispute arose.
27.
That leaves the question of payment. The school received 95% grant
in aid from NDMC, and the pensionary benefits were administered within
that statutory arrangement. Section 10 and the procedure framed under Rule
126 contemplate a contribution from the management towards pension and
other service benefits. There may remain questions between NDMC and the
erstwhile management as to the extent of their respective financial liabilities
after closure, particularly in view of the controversy surrounding Rule 46.
Those questions need not, and should not, be resolved at the cost of the
pensioners.
28.
The course adopted in Manju Tomar provides the appropriate answer.
Payment of an accrued pensionary entitlement cannot be made to await
resolution of an accounting dispute between the authority administering the
grant and the erstwhile management. NDMC shall therefore discharge the
(2006) 9 SCC 630.
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
pensionary dues in the first instance. It will remain open to NDMC to
recover from the management such amount as may be recoverable in
accordance with the Act, the Rules, the applicable pension scheme and the
law declared in Manju Tomar. Nothing in this judgment determines the
inter se liability between them.
29.
The Petitioners have remained without their monthly pensionary
payments for a considerable period despite a subsisting entitlement. Release
of the principal arrears alone would not fully compensate for the delay in
receiving sums which ought to have been paid periodically. In these
circumstances, simple interest at 6% per annum from the respective due
dates until payment would be just.
30.
The petitions are accordingly allowed with the following directions:
(i)
The refusal to continue pension and family pension after the school
ceased to function, on the ground of its closure, is held to be unsustainable.
(ii)
NDMC and its Director (Education) shall calculate and release to each
Petitioner the arrears of pension or family pension, as the case may be, from
1st July, 2021, until the date of actual payment. The computation shall
include all revisions otherwise admissible under the applicable pension
regime, including the revision flowing from the office order dated 9 th June,
2021, wherever applicable.
(iii)
The exercise shall be completed, and payment made, within eight
weeks from today. If, upon reconciliation, any pensionary amount or
revision pertaining to the period prior to 1st July, 2021 is found to remain
unpaid to any Petitioner, after giving credit for amounts already released
during the pendency of these proceedings, that amount shall also be paid
within the same period.
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
(iv)
The arrears of pension and family pension shall carry simple interest
at 6% per annum from the date on which each monthly payment fell due
until the date of actual payment.
(v)
Upon clearance of the arrears, pension or family pension shall
continue to be remitted regularly to the respective bank accounts of the
Petitioners in accordance with the applicable pension rules.
(vi)
These directions are without prejudice to the right of NDMC to seek
contribution, reimbursement or recovery from the erstwhile management to
the extent permissible in law. The payment of pension or family pension to
the Petitioners shall not await, or be made contingent upon, such recovery.
31.
The writ petitions are allowed in the aforesaid terms. CM APPL.
74226/2024 is allowed in terms of Paragraph No. 2 above. All other pending
applications stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
AUGUST 12, 2026/hc
Digitally Signed
By:HIMANSHI CHAWLA
19:41:05
W.P.(C) 13268/2021 & W.P.(C) 17482/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review