Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
FMA 1294 of 2025
National Insurance Company Limited
Vs.
Sarifan Khatun And Others
With
COT 153 of 2025
Sarifan Khatun And Others
Vs.
National Insurance Company Limited And Another
For the appellant
:
Mr. Saibalendu Bhowmik, Adv.
Mr. R.S. Basu, Adv.
For the Cross-objector
:
Mr. Subrata Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Ms. Srilekha Chattopadhyay, Adv.
Heard on
:
09.09.2026 and 15.09.2026
Judgment on
:
22.09.2026
Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.:1.
The appeal being FMA 1294 of 2025 and Cross-Objection
being COT 153 of 2025 are taken up together as they emanate from
the self-same judgment and award.
SK SOHEL
UDDIN
SOHEL UDDIN
Date: 2026.09.22
14:45:09 +05'30'
2.
FMA 1294 of 2025 is at the behest of the National Insurance
Company Limited i.e. the insurer challenging the impugned judgment
and award passed by learned MACC Tribunal-cum-Additional District
Judge, 1st Court, Arambagh, Hooghly on May 3, 2024 in MAC Case
No. 37 of 2021. COT 153 of 2025 is at the behest of the claimants
against the self-same judgment and award dated May 3, 2024.
3.
By the impugned judgment and award, the learned Tribunal
allowed the MAC Case No. 37 of 2021. Appellant in FMA 1294 of 2025
i.e. the Insurance Company was directed to pay a sum of Rs.
1,41,500/- with simple interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the
date of filing of the claim case till realization in full. The Insurance
Company was directed to deposit such amount by separate cheques in
the name of the claimants within three months of the date of the
award.
4.
It was contended by the appellant in FMA 1294 of 2025 that
the learned Tribunal erred in passing the impugned award. It was
contended by learned Advocate for the appellant i.e., Insurance
Company, that the learned Tribunal did not consider that the
offending vehicle was being driven in violation of the terms and
conditions of the contract of insurance. While passing the impugned
award, the learned Tribunal did not grant liberty to the insurance
company to recover the awarded amount from the owner of the
insured offending vehicle. He further submitted that the insured
offending vehicle was being driven by the owner without a valid driving
licence at the time of accident. Learned Advocate for the insurance
company also stated that driving a vehicle without a driving licence
was a clear violation of the terms and conditions of the contract of
insurance and, as such, the insurance company was not available to
pay compensation for such accident. In fact, the liability was with the
owner of the offending vehicle.
5.
The learned Advocate for the appellant-insurance company
also submitted that the learned Tribunal failed to appreciate that the
owner of the offending vehicle was under obligation to prove that there
was no violation of the terms of the insurance policy and the owner
having failed in discharging his onus, the learned Tribunal ought to
have directed the owner of the vehicle to pay compensation to the
claimants.
6.
In COT 153 of 2025, the learned Advocate for the cross-
objectors contended that the learned Tribunal erred in law and
erroneously determined the awarded sum. It was contended that the
accident occurred on September 1, 2021
which is after the
amendment of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, the ‘Act of
1988’) had come into effect.
7.
It was further submitted by the learned Advocate for the
cross-objectors that as per the amended Schedule II of the Act of
1988, the claimants were entitled to an award of Rs. 5,00,000/-. The
learned Tribunal erred in law in awarding the compensation of Rs.
1,41,500/-.
8.
Learned Advocate for the cross-objectors also stated that
since the insurance company had failed to pay the compensation
amount to the claimants with the time stipulated by the learned
Tribunal, the claimants are entitled for enhanced interest at the rate of
10% upon the minimum amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- prescribed under
Schedule II of the Act of 1988. In support of his contention, learned
Advocate for the cross-objector relied upon a Gazette notification
issued by Ministry of Road Transport and Highways dated May 22,
2018. Learned Advocate for the cross-objectors also relied upon 2025
SCC OnLine SC 2377 (Akula Narayana vs. Oriental Insurance
Company Limited and Another) and 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2297 (K.
Nagendra vs. New India Insurance Co. Ltd. and Others).
9.
On September 1, 2021 at about 9:00 p.m., an accident took
place at Khanakul Garer Ghat Road. The victim was standing in front
of his residential house at safe distance from the road. At that time, a
motor cycle bearing registration No. WB-18Z-6725 was coming out at
very high speed and in zigzag manner. The vehicle was being driven
rashly and negligently towards Khanakul. The offending vehicle
dashed the victim due to which the victim suffered grievous injuries.
He was taken to hospital and was admitted to Khanakul BPHC from
where he was referred to Arambagh SD Hospital. The victim died on
his way to hospital. It was contended that the victim died due to rash
and negligent driving of the offending vehicle.
10.
The claim case under Section 163A of the Act of 1988 was
filed by the legal heirs of the victim. In such application, it was
contended that the family of the victim sustained financial loss and
mental pain. The victim was said to be earning member of his family
and, therefore, a sum of Rs.5,00,000/- was claimed by the claimants.
Summons was served upon the opposite party in such claim
application. Opposite party No. 1 therein, i.e., owner of the vehicle
appeared in the case by filing a vakalatnama on April 21, 2022.
Subsequently, the owner did not contest the case and the case
proceeded ex parte against the owner. The opposite party No. 2, i.e.
National Insurance Company also entered appearance and decided the
case by filing a written statement.
11.
On the basis of the pleading put by the parties, the learned
Tribunal issued as many as seven issues for adjudication of the claim
application which are as follows:
“1) Is the case maintainable in its present form and prayer?
2) Whether the victim injured on 01.09.2021 in a road traffic
accident due to involvement of the offending motorcycle
bearing registration No. WB-18Z-6725”
3) Whether the accident happened on the Khanakul-Garer
ghat road at Dainan-Anantanagar on 01.09.2021 at about
9:00 pm caused by the motorcycle bearing registration No.
WB-18Z-6725?
4) Whether the offending motorcycle bearing registration No.
WB-18Z-6725 had valid insurance coverage and other
documents valid on the date of accident?
5) Whether the accident took place due to rash and negligent
driving by the driver of the offending motorcycle bearing
registration No. WB-18Z-6725?
6) Are the petitioners entitled to get compensation against the
death of the victim in road traffic accident as prayed for? If so
what would be the quantum of compensation for such death?
7) To what other relief or reliefs, if any, the petitioners are
entitled to get?
12.
In the course of trial, the claimants adduced to oral witnesses.
Besides that, the claimants also relied upon several documents like
First Information Report, seizure list, charge-sheet, insurance policy,
post mortem report and other several documents which were admitted
in evidence.
13.
All the issues were taken up by the learned Tribunal for
consideration together. Upon consideration of the oral as well as
documentary evidence adduced on behalf of the claimants, the learned
Tribunal decided that the case was maintainable in its present form
and prayer and the victim was injured in a road traffic accident on
September 1, 2021 involving offending vehicle bearing registration No.
WB-18Z-6725. The learned Tribunal also came to a conclusion that
the offending vehicle had a valid insurance coverage and that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent act on the part of the
driver of the offending vehicle. Since, the claim application was under
Section 163A of the Act of 1988, the learned Tribunal held that the
claimants were entitled for a compensation for the death of the victim
occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the driver of the
offending vehicle, proceeded to calculate the quantum of the
compensation required to be awarded on structured formula basis
provided in such section. The learned Tribunal, in calculating the
compensation to be awarded, took in consideration the notional
income, annual income, net monthly income, the multiplier to be used
and the loss of future income etc. On the basis of a structured formula
basis, the learned Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs. 1,41,500/- to the
claimants.
14.
As it transpires from the materials on record, the accident
took place on September 1, 2021 and the victim expired on that very
day on his way to the hospital. The claim case was decided on May 3,
2024.
15.
The provisions of the Act of 1988 underwent an amendment
by a notification issued by Ministry of Road Transport and Highways.
Such amendment came into force from the date of its notification in
the official Gazette i.e. May 22, 2018 which reads as follows:“MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS
NOTIFICATION
New Delhi, the 22nd May, 2018
S.O. 2022(E).- In exercise of the powers conferred by
sub-section (3) of section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
(59 of 1988), the Central Government, keeping in view the cost
of living, hereby makes the following amendment to the
Second Schedule to the said Act, namely:In the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, for the Second
Schedule, the following Schedule shall be substituted namely:“THE SECOND SCHEDULE
(See Section 163A)
SCHEDULE FOR COMPENSATION FOR THIRD PARTY
FATAL ACCIDENTS/INJURY CASES CLAIMS
1. (a) Fatal Accidents:
Compensation payable in case of Death shall be five lakh
rupees.
(b) Accidents resulting in permanent disability:
Compensation payable shall be = [Rs. 5,00,000/- x
percentage disability as per Schedule I of the Employee’s
compensation Act, 1923 (8 of 1923)] :
Provided that the minimum compensation in case of
permanent disability of any kind shall not be less than fifty
thousand rupees.
(c) Accidents resulting in minor injury:
A fix compensation of twenty five thousand rupees shall be
payable:
2. On and from the date of 1st day of January, 2019 the
amount of compensation specified in the clauses (a) to (c) of
paragraph (1) shall stand increased by 5 per cent
annually.
3. This notification shall come into force on the date of its
publication in the Official Gazette”.
[F. No.RT-11021/65/2017-MVL]
ABHAY DAMLE, Jt. Secy.”
16.
The amended Second Schedule of the Act of 1988 provides for
compensation of death to be Rs.5,00,000/-. In view of the amended
Second Schedule appended to the Act of 1988, I find force in the
contention of the learned Advocate for the cross-objector that the
learned Tribunal erred in not granting the minimum amount of
compensation as per the amended Second Schedule of the Act of
1988.
17.
As to the contention of learned Advocate for the appellant-
insurance company regarding the liability of the owner to pay
compensation, the impugned judgment and award has directed the
appellant-insurance company to pay compensation along with interest
at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim to the
claimants. The insurance company is aggrieved with such direction
sans a liberty to the insurance company to recover the sum from the
owner of the vehicle which was at fault by driving the offending vehicle
without a valid driving licence. Driving a vehicle without a valid driving
licence is violative of the terms and conditions of an insurance
company. Such fact was apparently not taken into consideration by
the learned Tribunal while passing the impugned judgment and
award. In the impugned judgment and award, the learned Tribunal,
upon consideration of Exhibit-4, came to a conclusion that the
offending vehicle was covered under a valid insurance policy.
18.
In K. Nagendra (supra), it was held by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court that,
“9. The purpose of an insurance policy in the present context is to
shield the owner/operator from direct liability when such an
unforeseen/unfortunate
incident
takes
place.
To
deny
the
victim/dependents of the victim compensation simply because the
accident took place outside the bounds of the permit and, therefore,
is outside the purview of the insurance policy, would be offensive to
the sense of justice, for the accident itself is for no fault of his. Then,
the Insurance Company most certainly ought to pay.
10. At the same time though, when an Insurance Company takes on
a policy and accepts payments of premium in pursuance thereto, it
agrees to do so within certain bounds. The contract lays down the
four corners within which such an insurance policy would operate. If
that is the case, to expect the insurer to pay compensation to a third
party, which is clearly outside the bounds of the said agreement
would be unfair. Balancing the need for payment of compensation to
the victim vis-à-vis the interests of the insurer, the order of the High
Court applying the pay and recover principle, in our considered
view, is entirely justified and requires no interference.”
19.
Similarly, in Akula Narayana (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court observed as follows:“12. Where the contract of insurance is not disputed, even on breach
of insurance conditions, this Court had allowed recovery of
compensation from the insurer by giving right to the insurer to
recover the same from the vehicle owner. The pay and recover
principle has been consistently followed even though it was doubted
in a reference which remained unanswered. Taking a conspectus of
various pronouncements, this Court recently in Rama Bai v. Amit
Minerals7 again applied the said principle and while allowing the
appeal of the claimant directed that the insurance company shall
satisfy the award and may recover from the insured. Following the
aforesaid decisions, we deem it appropriate to allow the appeal by
directing that the first respondent (i.e., the insurer) shall satisfy the
award, though, however, it can recover the amount so paid from the
insured (i.e., owner of the vehicle).”
20.
In view of the aforegone discussions and applying the
principles laid down in K. Nagendra (supra) and Akula Narayana
(supra), I am of the opinion that the claimants are entitled to the
minimum compensation provided in Schedule II of the Act of 1988 to
the tune of Rs. 5,00,000/-. The aforesaid claim amount shall also
carry interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the
claim application till realization, as directed by the learned Tribunal.
21.
The appellant-insurance company shall deposit the aforesaid
amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- with interest by five separate cheques of
equal amount in the name of five claimants which shall be disbursed
to the claimants upon proper identification and verification. The
appellant-insurance company shall comply such order within six
weeks from date.
22.
At the same time, in view of the ratio laid down in Akula
Narayana (supra), the appellant-insurance company shall be at
liberty to recover the amount of compensation paid by it to the
claimants from the owner of the offending vehicle in due process of
law.
23.
With such observations, FMA 1294 of 2025 along with COT
153 of 2025 are disposed of, however, without any order as to costs.
Connected applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
24.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties on priority basis upon compliance of all
formalities.
[MD. SHABBAR RASHIDI, J.]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review