Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
WP(C) No.36241 of 2025
….
Sarat Kumar Samal
Petitioner
Mr. Prabodha Chandra Nayak, Advocate
-versus….
State of Odisha and others
Opposite Parties
Mr. Sanjay Rath, AGA
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MURAHARI SRI RAMAN
ORDER
15.04.2026
Order No.
01.
1.
The petitioner being emerged successful in connection with
the tender call notice dated 25th November, 2021 invited by
the Chief Construction Engineer, Rural Works Circle,
Balasore-opposite party no.3, an agreement bearing
No.96/P-1 of 2021-22 has been executed on 29th December,
2021 indicating date of commencement of work as 29th
December, 2021 with stipulation as to completion on 28th
November, 2021. The petitioner completed the work in all
respect on 24th June, 2022, which was intimated to the
Superintending Engineer, Rural Works Division, Bhadrak
on 28th June, 2022. By letter dated 29th June, 2022, the
Superintending Engineer, Rural Works Division, Bhadrak
communicated the fact of completion of work in all respect
on 24th June, 2022, which is six month five days before the
stipulated date of completion as per agreement to the
Superintending Engineer, Rural Works Division, Bhadrak.
1.1. The Chief Construction Engineer, Rural Works Circle,
Balasore issued Letter No.3435, dated 16th August, 2023
addressed to the Chief Engineer (Roads), Rural Works,
Odisha, Bhubaneswar stating as follows:
“The work has been completed in all respect earlier before
30% of contract period (i.e. 6 month 5 days against 11
months) and thus eligible for incentive on early completion
of project @ of 5% of contract value.
As such it is requested to consider the incentive proposal as
per Clause 1.11 DTCN & Amendment 2016 Vol-I of
O.P.W.D. This is for favour of kind information and
necessary action.”
1.2. Despite such information given to the Chief Engineer
(Roads), Rural Works, Odisha, Bhubaneswar, the petitioner
being not accorded with the legitimate claim in terms of
Clause 1.11 of the Detailed Tender Call Notice (DTCN)
and Paragraph 3.5.5(V) of Note-III of OPWD Code
(Volume-I) as amended by virtue of Office Memorandum
File No.07556900032016-5288/W, dated 4th May, 2016
issued by the Government of Odisha in Works Department,
the petitioner has come up before this Court by way of
filing this writ petition invoking provisions under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India with the following
prayer(s):
“It is, therefore, most humbly prayed that this Hon'ble Court
may graciously be pleased to
2.
I.
Issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus in directing the
Opp. Party No.2-Chief Engineer (Roads), Rural Works,
Odisha to forthwith approve the petitioner's incentive
dues under Clause 1.11 of the DTCN, strictly in terms of
the recommendations of the Chief Construction
Engineer, Opp. Party No.3 dated 16.08.2023 (Annexure5) and the Superintending Engineer, Opp. Party No.4
dated 04.04.2023 (Annexure-4), and thereafter to ensure
release of the incentive amount @ 2% of the contract
value for the work Improvement Daxin Teghari High
School PWD road to Bindhapadmapur-Talsari road via
Ranibasan and Krushnanagar road under MMSY for the
year 2021-22 within a time to be stipulated by this
Hon’ble Court;
II.
Issue direction to the Opposite Parties to pay interest
12% per annum (or at such rate as this Hon'ble Court
deems just and proper) on the eligible incentive amount,
from 31.03.2023 (the actual date of completion of work)
till the date of actual payment;
III.
The unexplained and prolonged delay in processing and
approving the petitioner's incentive dues shall be
declared arbitrary, unreasonable, mala fide in law and
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India;
IV.
Any other writ, order or direction may be issued as this
Hon’ble Coat deems fit, just, equitable, proper and
necessary in the facts and circumstances of the case.
V.
And in this act of kindness, the petitioner shall as in duty
bound every pray.”
As the document forming part of writ petition evince the
aforesaid undisputed facts, it is felt necessary to dispose of
the writ petition as keeping the matter pending would not
subserve any fruitful purpose.
3.
Learned Additional Government Advocate having appeared
for opposite parties, waives issue of notice as advance copy
of the writ petition had already been served upon him on 9th
December, 2025.
4.
Perusal of the documents enclosed with the writ petition, it
is revealed that Clause 1.11 of the DTCN entitles the
petitioner to avail the incentive as follows:
“1.11.
For availing Incentive Clause in any project which
is completed before the stipulated date of
completion subject to other stipulations it is
mandatory on the part of the concerned
Superintending Engineers/Executive Engineers to
report the actual date of completion of the project
as soon as possible through fax or e-mail so that
the report is received within 7 (seven) days of such
completion by the concerned Superintending
Engineer, Engineer-in-Chief & the Administrative
Department.”
4.1. Paragraph 3.5.5(V) of Note-III of OPWD Code (Volume-I)
as amended by Office Memorandum dated 4th May, 2016
reads as follows:
“For availing Incentive Clause in any project which is
completed before the stipulated date of completion, subject to
other stipulations it is mandatory on the part of the concerned
Executive Engineer to report the actual date of completion of the
project as soon as possible through Fax or e-mail so that the
report is received within 7 (seven) days of such completion by the
concerned Superintending Engineer, Chief Engineer & the
Administrative Department. ***”
4.2. Letters of Superintending Engineer dated 29th June, 2022
(Annexure-4) and the Chief Engineer (Roads), Rural
Works
Circle,
Balasore
dated
16th
August,
(Anneuxre-5) addressed to the Chief Engineer (Roads)
Rural Works, Odisha, Bhubaneswar unequivocally reflects
that the work entrusted to the petitioner was completed in
all respect before 24th June, 2022, i.e., around six months
five days before the stipulated date of completion. Since
the work was completed much ahead of date so stipulated,
i.e., 28th November, 2022 as per agreement dated 29th
December, 2021, the petitioner is entitled to claim
incentive as envisaged in Clause 1.11 of the DTCN and in
terms of Paragraph 3.5.5 (V) of Note-III of the OPWD
Code (Volume-I).
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has referred to
and cited order dated 18th March, 2021 passed in the case of
Jayram Pujahari vs. State of Odisha and others, WP(C)
No.30637 of 2020, wherein the following has been
observed:
“6.
*** Thus, timely intimation of completion of the
project by the concerned Executive Engineer is a
mandatory requirement under the aforesaid provision
in order to avail incentive by the Contractor for early
completion of the Project. The report that regard has
to be intimated within a period of seven days from the
date of completion of the project. Admittedly, the
intimation was not sent by the Executive Engineer
within the stipulated period of seven days. There is
also no allegation that the Petitioner has contributed
to such delay in intimation. In view of the ratio in
Prafulla Kumar Pradhan vs. State of Odisha, 2017
(I) ILR-CUT-381, the Petitioner cannot be faulted
with for the delay in communication of the
completion report by the Executive Engineer. The
Petitioner cannot be made to suffer for no fault on his
part, particularly when the authorities have accepted
the fact that the Project was completed prior to the
stipulated date.
7.
In that view of the matter, we have no hesitation to
set aside the order dated 20th August, 2020
(Annexure-1) passed by the Commissioner-cumSecretary, Works Department, Government of
Odisha, Bhubaneswar (OP No.1) in refusing the
claim of the petitioner for grant of incentive.”
5.1. It is submitted that the said order was carried before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India by the State of Odisha in
SLP (C) No.12359 of 2021, which came to be disposed of
vide order dated 5th April, 2023 with the following
observation(s):
“Learned counsel for the petitioner-State made a statement
before us in compliance of our order dated 19.08.2021 &
17.09.2021, the Government of Orissa has conducted the
enquiry as directed and the report has been placed on the
record of the case and a SOP has also been notified on
03.03.2022. Additional affidavit is taken on record. The SOP
having been finalised, the same would govern the timely
completion of project and the grant of incentive for the same.
However, in so far as the present case is concerned, we see no
good ground to interfere with the impugned order passed by the
High Court and as such, the special leave petition, in so far as
the challenge to the impugned order is concerned, stands
dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed
of.”
5.2. Against the denial of incentive under the above Paragraph
of the OPWD Code, where the work entrusted to the
petitioner in Sairaj Dalai Vs. State of Odisha and others,
WP(C) No.15195 of 2025 got completed before the
stipulated date as per agreement, vide order dated 8th April,
2026 held as follows:
“5.
On a meaningful reading of the language, words and the
expressions used in the above quoted Clause, we fail to
appreciate the stand taken by the authorities that it is
obligatory on the part of a contractor to make an
application within the specified time. The said provision
does not ordain any application to be made by the
contractor but mandated the Executive Engineer to
report the actual date of completion of the project as
soon as possible through e-mail or facsimile mail within
seven days from the date of the completion thereof. The
said Clause is misread, misconstrued and wrongly
applied as a deterrent on the part of the contractor who
appears to have been penalized for the lapses which
cannot be attributable to his conduct. The bare reading of
said Clause indicates that in order to avail the incentive
Clause in any project completed before the actual date of
completion, it is mandatory on the part of the concerned
Executive Engineer to report the actual date of
completion of the project through such modes within
seven days therefrom.
6.
It is improbable and inconceivable that a person or the
authority would reap the benefit of his own wrong and
deny the just and equitable claim on such score. We fail
to find any words or the expressions from the said Clause
as quoted above that makes it imperative on the part of
the contractor to approach the authority by making an
application but it conveys a clear and laudable message
that it is obligatory on the part of the authority concerned
to report through such modes within the time stipulated
therein. If the authority has committed a mistake or his
conduct indicates some lapses and negligence on his part
in not reporting the date of completion of the entire
project, the contractor who should be incentivized by
virtue of said Clause-34 should not be penalized.
6.
7.
Simply on the equitable principle that a person cannot
reap the benefit from his own wrong, the authority on
account of his lapses cannot deny the legitimate claim
shifting the lapses to the shoulder of the contractor. The
contractor who completed the work before handed cannot
be denied such beneficial piece of the Clause which gives
incentives to him who has diligently executed the work to
the satisfaction of the authority.
8.
We, thus, do not find that the authority can take
advantage of his own lapses and/or wrong committed by
him as a weapon to deny the just and equitable claim
accrued to the petitioner in terms of such Clause-34 and,
therefore, the order of rejection dated 8th November,
2024 is hereby quashed and set aside.”
The letters dated 29th June, 2022 and 16th August, 2023 vide
Annexure-4 and 5 respectively as referred to above clinch
that the work entrusted to the petitioner has been completed
one month and three days ahead of stipulated date of
completion, i.e., 24th June, 2022 as per agreement dated 29th
December, 2021 (Annexure-1). The learned Additional
Standing Counsel having not impeached such letters of the
Superintending Engineer and the Chief Construction
Engineer having admitted commencement of works on 29th
December, 2021 and completion thereof on 28th November,
2022, the legitimate claim of the petitioner cannot, thus, be
denied or delayed in view of the clarified position as set
forth in the aforesaid decisions.
6.1. It is, therefore, felt expedient to direct the Chief Engineer
(Roads), Rural Works, Odisha, Bhubaneswar to take a
decision on the recommendation made to him by the Chief
Construction Engineer, Rural Works Circle, Balasore vide
Letter No.3435, dated 16th August, 2023 within a period of
two weeks from receipt of copy of this order in the light of
discussions made supra and communicate the result thereof
to the petitioner forthwith.
7.
With the aforesaid observation and direction, the writ
petition stands disposed of; and pending Interlocutory
Application (s), if any, shall also be disposed of.
(Harish Tandon)
Chief Justice
(M.S. Raman)
Judge
MRS/Laxmikant
Digitally Signed
Signed by: LAXMIKANT MOHAPATRA
Designation: SENIOR STENOGRAPHER
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 17-Apr-2026 14:36:55
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review