Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010352372022
2026:CGHC:40789
NAFR
Digitally
RAGHVENDRA signed by
JAT
RAGHVENDRA
JAT
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 4666 of 2022
1 - Saraswati Mishra W/o Late Shri Rajkishore Mishra Aged About 71
Years R/o Plot No. 15, Kailash Nagar Bhilai, District- Durg, Chhattisgarh
2 - Vivek Mishra S/o Late Shri Rajkishore Mishra Aged About 38 Years
R/o Plot No. 15, Kailash Nagar Bhilai, District Durg Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Principal Secretary Department
Of (Industries), Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nava
Raipur,
District
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
2 - General Manager, District Industrial Central, Durg District Durg
Chhattisgarh.
3 - H.S. Mishra S/o D.N. Mishra Aged About 60 Years M/s Chhattisgarh
Alloy Casting, Industrial Area, Bhilai, District Durg Chhattisgarh. Present
Address-
Durg
Chhattisgarh.
4 - Anish Kumar S/o Late Shiv Kumar Aged About 30 Years Director
M/s. Shiv Engineering And Casting Pvt. Ltd. Industrial Area Bhilai,
District
Durg
Chhattisgarh.
5 - Sumesh Kumar S/o Late Shiv Kumar, Aged About 27 Years Director
M/s Shiv Engineering And Casting Pvt. Ltd. Industrial Area Bhilai,
District
Durg
Chhattisgarh.
6 - Rajat Kumar S/o Late Shiv Kumar Aged About 19 Years Director M/s
Shiv Engineering And Casting Pvt. Ltd. Industrial Area Bhilai, District
Durg
Chhattisgarh.
7 - Ajay Kumar Mishra, Notary, District Court Durg, District Durg
Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. T.K. Jha, Sr. Advocate along with
For Respondent(s)/State
For Respondent No. 3
Mr. Rohan Kumbhare, Advocate.
: Mr. Shobhit Mishra, Dy. G.A.
: Mr. MPS Bhati, Advocate.
For Respondents No. 4 to 6 : Mr. Imran Ahmed Khan, Advocate on
behalf of Mr. Ishan Verma, Advocate.
For Respondent No. 7
: Mr.
Harshwardhan
Singh
Thakur,
Advocate on behalf of Mr. B.P. Singh,
Advocate.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
18/09/2026
1. By way of this petition, the petitioners have prayed for following
reliefs:“10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
call for the entire records relating to this case.
10.2 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
allow the petition and set aside the letter for permission
(Annexure P/15 dated 25.03.2022) and amended lease
deed (Annexure P/16 dated 27.04.2022) in the interest of
justice.
10.3 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
allow the petition and substitute the name of petitioner in
place of deceased Raj Kishore Mishra in the lease deed
by way of amendment in the interest of justice.
10.4 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
allow the petition and order for enquiry as to why name of
petitioners were not substituted in place of deceased
husband Rajkishore Mishra and on the basis of false
documents/affidavits name of directors of M/s Shiv
Engineering and casting pvt. Ltd was substituted and take
action against the persons who are involved in the entire
transaction.
10.5 That, it is most humbly requested that necessary
action may be taken against the notary for falsely
preparing affidavits (Annexure P/13 dated 24.03.2022 and
Annexure P/9 dated 06.01.2022), in the interest of justice.
10.6 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
allow the petition and protect the possession of petitioners
by restraining the directors of M/s Shiv Engineering and
casting Pvt. Ltd.
10.7 That any other relief, which this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper together with cost of the petition.”
2. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the District
Industries Centre (DIC), Durg allotted a piece of land bearing Plot
No. 34, admeasuring 1 acre, in favour of respondent No. 3, H.S.
Mishra, and Rajkishore Mishra, husband of petitioner No. 1, on
27.10.1995. He submits that Rajkishore Mishra died on
27.04.2021 and, thereafter, petitioner No. 1 submitted applications
before the DIC, Durg for substitution of her name in place of her
deceased husband, but no action was taken on her applications. It
is further submitted that, on the basis of a forged relinquishment
deed and affidavit allegedly submitted by H.S. Mishra, the said
land was subsequently transferred in favour of M/s Shiv
Engineering and Casting Pvt. Ltd. The petitioners have never
executed any relinquishment deed in respect of their rights in the
said land, and despite making complaints to the concerned
authorities, no action has been taken. Learned counsel further
submits that the directors of M/s Shiv Engineering and Casting
Pvt. Ltd. are now attempting to take possession of the land.
According to the learned counsel, after the death of Rajkishore
Mishra, the name of petitioner No. 1, being his widow and legal
heir, ought to have been substituted on the basis of her
applications dated 28.05.2021 and 21.06.2021, but the same was
deliberately not done. It is further submitted that the request made
by petitioner No. 1 to the General Manager, DIC, Durg was
ignored and, on the basis of the alleged forged relinquishment
deed and affidavit dated 25.03.2022 submitted by H.S. Mishra, the
transfer in favour of Anish Kumar was permitted on the very same
day, which, according to the learned counsel, was done with mala
fide and dishonest intention and in collusion with the persons
concerned. Learned counsel further submits that, after the
amendment of the lease deed on 27.04.2022, the subsequent
issuance of a letter to H.S. Mishra and Anish Kumar seeking their
response regarding the consent of petitioner No. 1 was merely an
eyewash. It is also submitted that the affidavits dated 06.01.2022
and 24.03.2022 are forged and fabricated and, therefore, the
subsequent amendment in the lease deed dated 27.04.2022 is
illegal and has no legal effect. Learned counsel lastly submits that
the persons involved in the alleged forgery, including the
concerned notary, are liable to be proceeded against in
accordance with law.
3. Learned counsel for the State submits that after the death of
Rajkishore Mishra, petitioner No. 1 applied for substitution of her
name in place of her deceased husband. Thereafter, the land was
transferred in favour of M/s Shiv Engineering and Casting Private
Limited after examination and verification of the relevant
documents and affidavits. It is further submitted that, when the
petitioners raised an objection to the transfer, notices were issued
to the concerned parties, but petitioner No. 1 failed to submit an
affidavit in support of her complaint. Learned counsel submits that
the petitioners have not disclosed the complete and correct facts
before this Court and, therefore, the writ petition deserves to be
dismissed.
4. Learned counsel for respondents No. 4 to 6 submits that the
petitioners have failed to make out any case for interference by
this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is
submitted that the writ petition involves disputed questions of fact
and unsupported allegations, which cannot be properly decided in
writ jurisdiction and may be adjudicated before the competent civil
court. Learned counsel further submits that respondents No. 4 to
6 have acted bona fide and in accordance with the permissions
granted by the competent authorities and have complied with the
applicable conditions. It is also submitted that the petitioners have
neither shown any illegality on the part of the answering
respondents nor established any violation of their legal or
constitutional rights. Learned counsel further submits that the
petitioners have suppressed material facts and have also violated
the status quo order passed by this Court. On these grounds,
dismissal of the writ petition is prayed for.
5. Learned counsel for respondent No. 7 supported the submissions
made by learned counsel for the State as well as respondents No.
4 to 6.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused
the material available on record.
7. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of A.P. Electrical
Equipment Corporation vs. Tahsildar and others, 2025 SCC
Online SC 447 has observed as under:“48. Normally, the disputed questions of fact are not
investigated or adjudicated by a writ court while
exercising powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. But the mere existence of the disputed question of
fact, by itself, does not take away the jurisdiction of this
writ court in granting appropriate relief to the petitioner. In
a case where the Court is satisfied, like the one on hand,
that the facts are disputed by the State merely to create a
ground for the rejection of the writ petition on the ground
of disputed questions of fact, it is the duty of the writ
court to reject such contention and to investigate the
disputed facts and record its finding if the particular facts
of the case, like the one at hand, was required in the
interest of justice.
49. There is nothing in Article 226 of the Constitution to
indicate that the High Court in the proceedings, like the
one on hand, is debarred from holding such an inquiry.
The proposition that a petition under Article 226 must be
rejected simply on the ground that it cannot be decided
without determining the disputed question of fact is not
warranted by any provisions of law nor by any decision of
this Court. A rigid application of such proposition or to
treat such proposition as an inflexible rule of law or of
discretion will necessarily make the provisions of Article
226 wholly illusory and ineffective more particularly
Section 10(5) and 10(6) of the Act, 1976 respectively.
Obviously,
the
consequences.
High
Court
must
avoid
such
50. In the aforesaid context, we may look into the
decision of this Court in the case of State of Orissa v. Dr.
(Miss) Binapani Dei, AIR 1967 SC 1269. In paragraph 6
at p. 1270 of the said judgment, this Court has been
pleased to hold as follows:—
“Under Art. 226 of the Constitution the High Court is
not precluded from entering upon a decision on
questions of fact raised by the petition. Where an
enquiry into complicated questions of fact arises in
a petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution before
the right of an aggrieved party to obtain relief
claimed may be determined. The High Court may in
appropriate cases decline to enter upon that enquiry
and may refer the party claiming relief to a suit. But
the question is one of discretion and not of
jurisdiction of the Court.”
(Emphasis supplied)
51. This Court in the case of Gunwant Kaur v. Bhatinda
Municipality, (1969) 3 SCC 769 : AIR 1970 SC 802 observed as
follows:—
“The High Court observed that they will not determine
disputed question of fact in a writ petition. But what
facts were in dispute and what were admitted could
only be determined after an affidavit in reply was filed
by the State. The High Court, however, proceeded to
dismiss the petition in limine. The High Court is not
deprived of its jurisdiction to entertain a petition under
Art. 226 merely because in considering the petitioner's
right to relief questions of fact may fall to be
determined. In a petition under Art. 226 the High Court
has jurisdiction to try issues both of fact and law.
Exercise of jurisdiction is, it is true, discretionary, but
the discretion must be exercised on sound judicial
principles. When the petition raises questions of fact
of a complex nature, which may for their determination
require oral evidence to be taken, and on that account
the High Court is of the view that the dispute may not
appropriately be tried in a writ petition, the High Court
may decline to try a petition. Rejection of a petition in
limine will normally be justified, where the High Court
is of the view that the petition is frivolous or because
of the nature of the claim made, dispute sought to be
agitated., or that the petition against the party against
whom relief is claimed is not maintainable or that the
dispute raised thereby is such that it would be
inappropriate to try it in the writ jurisdiction, or for
analogous reasons.”
(Emphasis supplied)
52. In one of the recent pronouncements of this Court in State of
U.P. v. Ehsan, 2023 INSC 906, this Court observed that:—
“28. We are conscious of the law that existence of an
alternative remedy is not an absolute bar on exercise
of writ jurisdiction. More so, when a writ petition has
been entertained, parties have exchanged their
pleadings/affidavits and the matter has remained
pending for long. In such a situation there must be a
sincere effort to decide the matter on merits and not
relegate the writ petitioner to the alternative remedy,
unless there are compelling reasons for doing so. One
such compelling reason may arise where there is a
serious dispute between the parties on a question of
fact and materials/evidence(s) available on record are
insufficient/inconclusive to enable the Court to come to
a definite conclusion.
29. Bearing the aforesaid legal principles in mind, we
would have to consider whether, in the facts of the
case, the High Court ought to have dismissed the third
writ petition of the first respondent and relegate him to
a suit as there existed a serious dispute between the
parties regarding taking of possession. More so, when
the High Court, in the earlier round of litigation,
refrained from taking up the said issue even though it
had arisen between the parties.
30. No doubt, in a writ proceeding between the State
and a landholder, the Court can, on the basis of
materials/evidence(s) placed on record, determine
whether possession has been taken or not and while
doing so, it may draw adverse inference against the
State where the statutory mode of taking possession
has not been followed [See State of UP v. Hari Ram
(supra)]. However, where possession is stated to have
been taken long ago and there is undue delay on the
part of landholder in approaching the writ court,
infraction of the prescribed procedure for taking
possession would not be a determining factor,
inasmuch as, it could be taken that the person for
whose benefit the procedure existed had waived his
right thereunder [See State of Assam v. Bhaskar Jyoti
Sarma, (supra)]. In such an event, the factum of actual
possession would have to be determined on the basis
of materials/evidence(s) available on record and not
merely by finding fault in the procedure adopted for
taking possession from the land holder. And if the writ
court finds it difficult to determine such question, either
for insufficient/inconclusive materials/evidence(s) on
record or because oral evidence would also be
required to form a definite opinion, it may relegate the
writ petitioner to a suit, if the suit is otherwise
maintainable.”
(Emphasis supplied)
8. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and,
particularly, the reliefs sought by the petitioner, it appears that the
dispute is essentially between private parties and involves serious
disputed questions of fact. Such disputed questions of fact cannot
appropriately be adjudicated upon in exercise of the extraordinary
writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Therefore, this Court is of the considered view that the petitioner
should avail the appropriate remedy before the competent
authority or the appropriate forum, as may be available to him in
accordance with law.
9. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. However, the
petitioners shall be at liberty to approach before the concerned
authority or the appropriate forum by filing an appropriate
application/petition for seeking the reliefs prayed for in the present
writ petition. If such an application/petition is filed, the same shall
be considered and decided by the competent authority/forum in
accordance with law.
SD/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Raghu Jat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review