Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
&
& '
!"
%
%
$
()
)*
&
(
$
$
$
+
)
*
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
!
"
"#
!
$%&% '(
!
!
"
)
-2-
!
&"
!
"'"
!
&%
% (%" (%
#
("( %' %'
'#
!
!
!
(
(
%"&
*
"" ( "'"
!
!!
!
#&
!
(
!
)
*
$'&' &
!
$ % ' '+&
!
!
"
"#
,
!
$ %&% '(
!
!
!
"
&"
!
!
)
!
-3-
%"&
!
*
(%" (%
%' %'
#
'#
(
!
(
!
"" ( "
!
!!
!
"'"
!
&%
%
#& ("(
!
(
!
!
!
)
*
(&
"$ $&( "'
*
$ %&
"(
!
!
"
"#
!
$ %&% '(
!
!
"
!
&"
"'"
!
!
)
%"&
!
*
"" ( "'"
!
!!
-4-
&%
#&
(
% (%" (%
#
("( %'
%'
'#
(
!
!
(
!
!
!
!
!
+)
*
(&
"$ $&( "'
*
$%&
""
!
!
"
"#
!
$%&% '(
!
!
!
%"&
&"
!
!
(%" (%
%' %'
)
"
*
#
'#
"" ( "
!
!!
!
(
(
!
!
(
"'"
!
&%
%
#&
("(
!
-5-
!
!
!
!
,
,
.
/010 203434561 780 94:0; <6;08
/78734>7
7?784@
<87@1/7
0=3456 %"& 59
76/437 "'"( 35 A<71/ 3/0
285=00;46?1 7?74613 3/0 20343456081 7==<10;
76;
"'"
"" ( "'"
80?413080; C>
51 "
%
784146? 5<3 59
84B0
5:4=0
43>
5B06
958 3/0 59906=01 2<641/7C:0 <6;08
%'
%'
'# 807; D43/
76;
5D8> 85/4C43456
=3HI
206;46? 56 3/0 94:0
!
7:7C<87?4
"
/0
97=3<7:
0=3456
=3
0=34561
# 59
#
#&
76;
0=34561 (
3/0
4F4:
<;?0 76;
=710
801256;063
5 " 46 3/010 203434561 B78840; 560
7==<10;
( '( "'"(
3/0 2780631 59 801256;063
("(
E958 C80F43> G3/0
$ ;;434567:
B7384J
7:7C<87?4
3/73
@/4:01/
3 3/0 34B0 59 B78847?0
5 " ?7F0
' 35:71 59 ?5:; &'
-6-
35:71 59 14:F08 76; =71/ 59
1 % '' ''' $ 71 ;5D8>
3/0 B78847?0 801256;063
5 " 137830; 35 8014;0 =58;47::>
7:56? D43/ /08 /<1C76; 76; 46$:7D1 958 7 20845; 59 &
B563/1
/08079308
/<1C76; 7==<10;
3/010 20343456081 7:56? D43/ /08
137830; /7871146? 801256;063
5"
958 7;;434567: ;5D8> 56 3/0 28030J3 3/73 3/0> /7F0 ;0C3 59
1 " '' '' ''' $
5<3 C> 7==<10;
76; 56 '% '
<0 35 4635:087C:0 /78711B063 B030;
5 " 90:: 14=@
6 3/73 ;7> 7==<10;
:093 /08 73
/08079308 56 '# '
"'"
D/06 1/0
"'"
/08 2780637: /5B0
803<860;
76; 46$:7D1 801256;063
/08
7==<10; 20343456081
B7384B5647:
801387460;
/08
/5B0
7::
3/010
985B
0630846?
3/0
B7384B5647: /5B0 76; 46138<=30; /08 3/73 49 1/0 41 7C:0 35
C846? 7;;434567: ;5D8> 56:> 3/06 3/0> D4:: :03 /08 35 06308
3/0 B7384B5647: /5B0
1 1<=/ :093 D43/ 65 53/08 523456
1/0 803<860; 35 /08 2780637: /5B0
(
7308 56 '" '" "'"
1/0 56=0 7?746 F41430; /08
B7384B5647: /5B0 7:56? D43/ /08 2780631
3 3/73 34B0
7:: 3/0 7==<10; 2081561 C> 46134?7346? 7==<10;
-7-
24=@0; <2 A<7880: D43/ 801256;063
7==<10;
5 " 76; 3/080C>
7117<:30; /08 76; 53/08 7==<10; 5<387?0;
/08 B5;013> 76; 954130; :490 3/8073 35 /08
06=0 :093 D43/
65 53/08 523456 1/0 56=0 7?746 803<860; 35 /08 2780637:
/5<10 76; 137830; 8014;46? 7:56? D43/ /08 2780631
<C10A<063:> 1/0 :5;?0; 7 =5B2:7463 C09580 801256;063
$ 5:4=0 56 '% '
84B0
"'"
"'"
/0 17B0 D71 80?413080; 46
801256;063
K 5:4=0
46F0134?730; 3/0 =710 76; :74; =/78?0 1/003 7?74613 7:: 3/0
7==<10; 46=:<;46? 3/010 20343456081 C> 7887>46? 3/0B 71
7==<10;
51 "
% 76;
==58;46?:>
3/0 :07860;
7?4138730 355@ =5?64L76=0 59 3/0 59906=01
20343456081 7==<10;
51 "
06=0
3/0
780 C09580 3/41
5<83
5 "'"'## "'"%$7==<10;
5"
% 76;
84B467:
0343456
84B467:
0343456
5 "'" '( "'"%$7==<10;
0343456
5 "'" '" "'"%$7==<10;
0343456
5 "'" '
"'"%$7==<10;
285=00;46?1 7?74613 3/0B
84B467:
5%
76;
84B467:
35 A<71/ 3/0
-8-
078; :07860; =5<610: 958 3/0 20343456081 15
7:15
:07860;
801256;063
801256;063
%
;;434567:
K
<C:4=
76;
:07860;
8510=<358
=5<610:
5 " 46 7:: 3/0 203434561
07860; =5<610: 958 3/0 20343456081 46 7:: 3/010
203434561 C> 8043087346? 3/0 ?85<6;1 <8?0; 46 3/0 203434561
=56306;0; 3/73 7==<10;
7==<10;
41 8014;46? 73
76; % 780 8014;46? 73
06?7:<8< 76;
46?71<?<8 71 1<=/
3/0> 780 653 1/7846? 3/0 =5BB56 8559 D43/ 7==<10;
35 (
6 1<=/ =48=<B1376=01 3/0 7::0?734561 7?74613 3/0B
780 5B64C<1 7::0?734561 46 3/0 =5B2:7463 76; 53/08 =/78?0
1/003 B730847:1
==58;46?:>
/0 287>1 35 7::5D 3/0
203434561
:07860; =5<610: 958 801256;063
76;
:07860;
;;:
522510;
=56306;0; 3/73 3/5<?/ 7==<10;
46?71<?<8 7==<10;
3/0
203434561
5"
76;
76; % 780 8014;46?
C046? 3/0 141308 59 7==<10;
41 8014;46? 46 /08 2780631 /5<10 7:56? D43/ 7==<10;
35 ( 46 3/0 1/780; 8559 7:56? D43/ /08 156 D/5 41
-9-
7;B4330; 46 7
=/55: 73
3/73 801256;063
/5B0
7:7C<87?4
/0> 7:15 =56306;0;
5 " 41 807;> 35 M546 3/0 B7384B5647:
C<3 56:> C0=7<10 59 7==<10;
51 " 35
1/0 41
<67C:0 35 =56346<0 /08 B78437: 80:734561/42 D43/ 7==<10;
==58;46?:> 3/0> 287> 35 ;41B411 3/0 203434561
+
/7F0 ?4F06 B> 76J45<1 =5614;0873456 C53/ 56
3/0 1<CB4114561 B7;0 C> 3/0 :07860; =5<610: 958 3/0
80120=34F0 2783401 76; 3/0 063480 =/78?0 1/003 B730847:1
&
80:734561/42
=5<:;
C0
C03D006
?73/080;
985B
801256;063
5"
20343456081 41 653 46 ;412<30
80=58;1
3/0
76;
3/010
3 41 7:15 653 46 ;412<30 3/73
79308 3/0 B78847?0 59 7==<10;
D43/ 801256;063
5"
3/0> C53/ 137830; 8014;46? 46 3/0 B7384B5647: /5B0
6 3/0
174; B7384B5647: /5B0
84B467:
8014;46?
0343456
7==<10;
5" 40
2034345608 46
5 "'"'## "'"% 76; 7==<10;
5 ( D080
/5<?/ 43 41 =56306;0; C> :07860; =5<610: 958 3/0
20343456081 3/73 7==<10;
7==<10;
5 % 73
41 8014;46? 7:56? D43/
46?71<?<8 3/0 =/78?0 1/003 B730847:1
80F07: 3/73 1/0 /71 7:15 0A<7::> 27834=42730; 46 3/0
- 10 -
/78711B063 35 801256;063
5 " 7:56? D43/ 7==<10;
35 (
#
5805F08 43 41 =56306;0; C> :07860; =5<610: 958
3/0 801256;0631 3/73 7==<10;
41 8014;46? 7:56? D43/
/08 2780631 46 /08 2780637: /5B0 76; /08 156 41 7:15
137>46?
7:7C<87?4
/0
13730B063
B730847:
D43601101 46 3/0 =/78?0 1/003 =:078:> 80F07:1 3/73 7==<10;
/787110; 801256;063
79308
14J
B563/1
B7384B5647:
1/0
/5B0
D71
/5<?/
B7384B5647: /5B0 7==<10;
5 " 76; 4BB0;4730:>
3/85D6
1/0
3840;
51 " 35
5<3
985B
3/0
M546
3/0
780 653 7::5D46?
/08 35 =56346<0 3/0 B78437: 80:734561/42 D43/ 7==<10;
$
/<1C76;
6 1<=/ =48=<B1376=0 46 B> =5614;080; 5246456
3/080 780
B730847:1 2:7=0; 46 3/0 =/78?0 1/003
7?74613 7==<10;
'
5D0F08 4615978 71 7==<10;
=56=0860; 4 0
8014;46? 73
7==<10;
5 % /<1C76; 59 7==<10;
46?7<1?<8 76; 7==<10;
C853/08 59 7==<10;
51 % 76;
41 8014;46? 73
D/5 41 3/0
06?7:<8< 76; 3/0>
- 11 -
780 653 1/7846? 3/0 =5BB56 8559
/0 7::0?734561 7?74613
3/0B 46 3/0 =/78?0 1/003 780 5B64C<1 7::0?734561 76;
D43/5<3 76> 1<=/ 1<C1376347: B730847:
6 1<=/ =48=<B1376=01 3/0 285=00;46?1 =76653
C0 =56346<0; 7?74613 7==<10;
3/0
56.C:0
20J
-.
71 :74; ;5D6 C>
5<83 46 3/0 =710 59
!
# " )
51 % 76;
" #"
)
73 2787?872/
$
$
* "
%
&
8025830; 46
/0:; 3/73 3/0
'"
"%(
+ ,
5<83 1/5<:; C0
=7809<: 46 285=00;46? 7?74613 3/0 ;413763 80:734F01 46 =84B01
208374646? 35 B7384B5647: ;412<301 76; ;5D8> ;073/1
/0
80:734F01 59 3/0 /<1C76; 1/5<:; 653 C0 8520;$46 56 3/0
C7141 59 5B64C<1 7::0?734561 <6:011 120=494= 461376=0 59
3/048 46F5:F0B063 46 3/0 =84B0 780 B7;0 5<3
3 41 7:15
1033:0; 25143456 59 :7D 3/73 49 7 208156 41 B7;0 35 97=0 7
=84B467: 3847: 56 15B0 ?06087: 76; 1D00246? 7::0?734561
D43/5<3 C846?46? 56 80=58; 76> 120=494= 461376=01 59
=84B467: =56;<=3 43 41 653/46? C<3 7C<10 59 285=011 59 3/0
5<83
/0
5<831 2510 7 ;<3> 35 1<CM0=3 3/0 7::0?73456
- 12 -
:0F0::0; 46 3/0 =5B2:7463 35 7 3/585<?/ 1=8<346> 35 946; 5<3
D/03/08 3/080 41 76> ?746 59 38<3/ 46 3/0 7::0?734561 58
D/03/08 3/0> 780 B7;0 56:> D43/ 3/0 15:0 5CM0=3 59
46F5:F46? =083746 46;4F4;<7:1 46 7 =84B467: =/78?0
B580
27834=<:78:> D/06 7 28510=<3456 78410 985B 7 B7384B5647:
;412<30
"
"
!<83/08 3/0
/ *)&
56HC:0
" %
20J
5<83 46 3/0 =710 59
!
/0:; 46 2787
8025830; 46
51 "% 76; "& 71 <6;08,
!
"
#
$
%
&
$ '
- 13 -
$ '
$ %
(
2 )
!
*+,
#
!
(
.
!
*+,
#
/ .
"
. !
.
#
-
!
*+,
#
.
#
(
3 41 1033:0; 25143456 59 :7D 3/73
5<831 /7F0 35
C0 =7809<: 76; =7<345<1 46 ;07:46? D43/ =5B2:7463 76; B<13
37@0 287?B734= 807:43401 4635 =5614;0873456 D/4:0 ;07:46?
D43/ B7384B5647: ;412<301 D/080 3/0 7::0?734561 /7F0 35
- 14 -
C0 1=8<3464L0; D43/ ?8073 =780 76; =48=<B120=3456 46 58;08
35 280F063 B41=78847?0 59 M<134=0 76; 7C<10 59 285=011 59
5<83
5D0F08 71 ;41=<110;
3/080 780
B730847:1 9583/=5B46? 4615978 71 7==<10;
/06=0 3/0 285=00;46?1 7?74613 3/0B =76653 C0 A<71/0;
/0 =56346<73456 59 285=00;46?1 7?74613 7==<10;
51 %
76;
5<83
653/46?
==58;46?:>
C<3
7C<10
285=011
285=00; 35 2711 3/0 95::5D46?,
84B467:
0343456
C> 7==<10;
5 "'"'## "'"% 94:0;
5 " 76;
84B467: 20343456
5 "'" '( "'"% 94:0; C> 7==<10;
780 $& )&
$
84B467:
0343456
C> 7==<10;
5 "'" '
/0
5 "'" '" "'"% 94:0;
5 % 76;
84B467:
0343456
"'"% 94:0; C> 7==<10;
3 $
285=00;46?1
20343456081 7==<10;
7?74613
51 %
76;
3/0
- 15 -
"" ( "'"
"'"
80?413080; C>
7:7C<87?4
43>
2<641/7C:0 <6;08
%'
784146? 5<3 59
0=34561
'# 807; D43/
76;
0=34561 ( 76;
85/4C43456
=3
;;434567:
5B06 5:4=0
3/0
%'
84B0
59906=01
#&
("(
0=3456
# 59
5D8>
#
206;46? 56 3/0 94:0
4F4:
<;?0
76;
!
7:7C<87?4 41 /080C> A<71/0;
,)
&
%
(
%
$
5,
:
5 , (%
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review