Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010256132022
2026:GAU-AS:8643
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/8094/2022
SARALA DAS
W/O- LATE DULAL DAS,
R/O- JONAKI NAGAR, BORBARI,
P.O.- HENGRABARI, GUWAHATI,
P.S- DISPUR, DISTRICT- KAMRUP(M),
ASSAM, PIN- 781036.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 8 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SPECIAL COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO
THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM,
PUBLIC WORKS BUILDING AND NH DEPARTMENT,
DISPUR, ASSAM.
2:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PWD NH DIVISION
NAGAON.
3:THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
PWD NH DIVISION
NAGAON.
4:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PWD
KALIABOR ROAD DIVISION
JAKHALABANDHA.
5:THE ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PWD
NH SUB-DIVISION
Page No.# 2/11
JAKHALABANDHA.
6:THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL ASSAM
BELTOLA
GUWAHATI-27.
7:THE DIRECTOR OF PENSION
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
NAHARONI PATH
HOUSEFED
DISPUR
BASISTHAPUR
GUWAHATI-06.
8:THE TREASURY OFFICER
NAGAON.
9:SMT. RULI DAS
R/O- RAHA HARIA MUKH
P.S.- RAHA
DISTRICT- NAGAON
PIN- 782103
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR S BHARALI, MR. M DAS,MR. K PATHAK,BAIJOYONTA
BAROOAH,N K NEOG,MR. M DAS
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, MR. R HAZARIKA(R9),MR. I K
BURAGOHAIN(R9),MR. S SARMA(R9),SC, TREASURY,SC, AG,SC, PWD
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 15.06.2026
Heard Mr. M. Das, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. R. Dhar, learned Standing Counsel, PWD, Assam, appearing for
the respondent nos.1, 2, 3, 4 and 5; Mr. C. Baruah, learned Standing
Page No.# 3/11
Counsel, AG (A&E), Assam, appearing for the respondent no.6; Ms. D. Das
Barman, learned Additional Senior Government Advocate, representing the
Director of Pensions; and Mr. R. Hazarika, learned counsel, appearing for the
respondent no.9.
2.
The petitioner by way of instituting the present writ petition,
projecting that, she is the 1 st wife of Late Dulal Das, has prayed for a
direction upon the respondent authorities to authorize to her the Family
Pension in respect of the services rendered by her husband Late Dulal
Chandra Das.
3.
The petitioner in the present writ petition has projected that she
has married Dulal Das in the month of February 1982. At the relevant point
of time, the husband of the petitioner was employed as a Sub Engineer
Grade-II, under the Office of the Executive Engineer, PWD, Nagaon, N. H.
Division, Nagaon. It is further projected that on account of the mental and
physical torture meted out to her, the petitioner had instituted F.C.(Civil)
Case No.195/1999, before the Court of the Principal Judge, Family Court,
Guwahati, Kamrup, seeking a judicial separation from her husband. The
Family Court, thereafter, vide Judgment & Order dated 19.02.2001,
proceeded to pass a order granting judicial separation to the petitioner
along with payment of maintenance allowance of Rs.2000/- (Rupees Two
Thousand) per month. It is further projected that on a reconciliation
Page No.# 4/11
occasioning between the petitioner and her husband, a joint application was
filed, wherein, a prayer was made for withdrawal of the order of judicial
separation. The Family Court thereafter, vide order 07.12.2005, proceeded
to allow the prayer for withdrawal of the order of judicial separation passed
vide the Judgment & Order dated 19.02.2001. Accordingly, the petitioner
projects that there being no divorce occasioning in the matter and the order
of judicial separation also having been withdrawn, the status of the
petitioner as the wife of Late Dulal Chandra Das continued to be
maintained.
In the writ petition, it is further projected that the respondent no.9,
by projecting herself to be the wife of Late Dulal Chandra Das, had
approached the respondent authorities claiming for being authorized the
family pension. The respondent authorities on processing of the matter is
contended to have authorized the respondent no.9, the family pension in
respect of the services rendered by Late Dulal Chandra Das. It is to be
noted that Late Dulal Chandra Das had passed on, on 12.12.2021, after
having superannuated from his services in the year 2016. In the above
background, the petitioner has instituted the present writ petition.
4.
Mr. M. Das, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner, after
reiterating the facts noticed, hereinabove, has submitted that the
respondent no.9, in her pleading has contended that she had married Dulal
Page No.# 5/11
Chandra Das in the month of January, 1985. Mr. Das by referring to the
Judgment & Order dated 19.02.2001, passed by the Principal Judge, Family
Court, Guwahati, Kamrup, in F.C.(C).No.195/1999, has submitted that,
therein, the date of solemnization of marriage of the petitioner with Dulal
Chandra Das has been recorded as February 1982. Accordingly, he submits
that the petitioner is the 1 st wife of Late Dulal Chandra Das and accordingly,
in terms of the provision of Rule 143 of the Assam Services (Pension) Rules,
1969, it is she who is entitled to be authorized the family pension in respect
of the services rendered by Dulal Chandra Das after his demise.
5.
Mr. M. Das by referring to the contentions raised by the respondent
no.9, in the affidavit filed by her in the present proceeding that, on the date
of marriage of the petitioner she was aged around 14 (fourteen) years, as
submitted in the writ petition, the said fact is not disputed. However, the
marriage between the petitioner and Dulal Chandra Das, in view of the
above position, would be a voidable marriage and the petitioner not having
prayed for annulment of the marriage after she had attained majority, the
said marriage is held to have been maintained and accepted by the
petitioner and accordingly, the status of being wife of Dulal Chandra Das,
continued to be maintained, in respect of the petitioner, herein.
6.
In the above premises Mr. M. Das, submits that a direction is called
upon to be issued to the respondent authorities for authorizing to the
Page No.# 6/11
petitioner her family pension in respect of the services rendered by her
husband, Late Dulal Chandra Das.
7.
Mr. R. Dhar, learned Standing Counsel, PWD, Assam, has submitted
that basing on the materials available on record, including the declarations
made by Late Dulal Chandra Das, projecting the respondent no.9, to be his
nominee, the pension papers of Late Dulal Chandra Das, was so processed
by construing the respondent no.9 as his nominee. He submits that the fact,
that the petitioner was the 1st wife of Late Dulal Chandra Das was not
known to the Departmental Authorities, till after the demise of Late Dulal
Chandra Das.
8.
Mr. C. Baruah, learned Standing Counsel, AG (A&E), Assam, has
submitted that in the pension proposal as forwarded to it from the
Departmental Authorities, the respondent no.9, was disclosed, therein, as
the spouse of Late Dulal Chandra Das. It is further projected that Late Dulal
Chandra Das, had put his signature in the forms, including Form No.1A,
wherein, the name of his spouse was declared by him as Ruli Das i.e. the
respondent no.9. He submits that there is no material available on record
while processing the pension proposal received in respect of Late Dulal
Chandra Das that the petitioner, herein, was his 1st wife.
9.
Mr. R. Hazarika, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent
no.9, has submitted that the marriage of the petitioner with Dulal Chandra
Page No.# 7/11
Das is disputed. It is submitted that the marriage having occasioned when
the petitioner was a minor, the said marriage is a void marriage and would
not confer a status of wife upon the petitioner. It is submitted that Dulal
Chandra Das before his demise was living with the respondent no.9 and her
children, and accordingly, had declared respondent no.9, in his pension
papers as his spouse. It is also projected that late Dulal Chandra Das had
retired from his services on reaching the age of superannuation w.e.f.
31.07.2016, and prior to his such retirement, he had submitted his pension
papers and therein, nominated the respondent no.9 and their daughter as
beneficiaries of his pension and pensionary benefit. It is submitted that late
Dulal Chandra Das had passed on, on 12.12.2021 only, and even during the
period after his superannuation till the date of his death, no steps was taken
by late Dulal Chandra Das for correcting the nomination made by him in
his pension papers. Accordingly, it is submitted that the very factum of the
petitioner being the wife of late Dulal Chandra Das being in dispute, the
claim made by the petitioner without there being a further declaration to the
effect from a Civil Court of competent jurisdiction to be the wife of Late
Dulal Chandra Das, would not mandate an acceptance from this Court and
accordingly, the claim made in the present writ petition would mandate to
be rejected.
10.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused
Page No.# 8/11
the materials available on record.
11.
The issue arising
in the present writ petition is to the effect that
amongst the petitioner and the respondent no.9, both of whom claimed to
be the wives of Late Dulal Chandra Das, who is to be held to be the 1 st wife
of the deceased Government servant. The said determination is mandated
in view of the provisions of Rule 143 of the Assam Services (Pension) Rules,
1969. Note 1 to the said Rules mandate that in case there are 2 (two) or
more widows, pension will be payable to the eldest surviving widow. On her
death, it will be payable to the next surviving widow, if any. The term
‘eldest’ has been prescribed to be determined with reference to the date of
marriage. Although neither a marriage certificate is brought on record by
the petitioner in the present writ petition nor such certificate has been
brought on record by the respondent no.9, the claim of the respondent
no.9, is that Late Dulal Chandra Das, having nominated her in his pension
papers to be his spouse, the same is proof enough of the status of the
respondent no.9, to be the wife of late Dulal Chandra Das. It is further
projected that marriage between the respondent no.9 and Dulal Chandra
Das, was solemnized in the month of January 1985. On the other hand, the
petitioner has contended that the marriage between the petitioner and Dulal
Chandra Das was so solemnized in the month of February 1982. No
marriage certificate to the said effect was brought on record, however, on a
Page No.# 9/11
perusal of the Judgment & Order dated 19.02.2001, passed by the Principal
Judge, Family Court, Guwahati, Kamrup, in a proceeding instituted by the
petitioner seeking judicial separation from said Dulal Chandra Das, this
Court finds that it was recorded, therein, that the marriage between the
petitioner and late Dulal Chandra Das was solemnized in the month of
February, 1982.
12.
The respondent no.9, has not disputed the date of solemnization of
marriage of the petitioner with Late Dulal Chandra Das, as recorded in the
Judgment & Order dated 19.02.2001, passed by the Principal Judge, Family
Court,
Guwahati,
Kamrup,
in
F.C.(C).No.195/1999.
Accordingly,
solemnization of the marriage of the petitioner with Dulal Chandra Das
having been found by this Court, to have been so solemnized in the month
of February, 1982, from orders passed in a judicial proceeding, this Court
would proceed to hold that the marriage of the petitioner was so solemnized
in the month of February, 1982, with Dulal Chandra Das. Basing on the
dates of marriage now coming on record of the petitioner as well as the
respondent no.9, with Dulal Chandra Das, this Court finds that the petitioner
was married to Dulal Chandra Das, earlier in point of time before the
solemnization of marriage of the respondent no.9, with Dulal Chandra Das.
Accordingly, applying the provisions of Note 1 to Rule 143 of the Rules of
1969, this Court finds that it is the petitioner, herein, who is to be held to be
Page No.# 10/11
the 1st wife of Late Dulal Chandra Das, and accordingly, during her lifetime,
the Family pension could not have been authorized in favour of the
respondent no.9, who is held by this Court to be the 2 nd wife.
13.
In view of the above conclusion, drawn by this Court, this Court
directs the Respondent Nos.1, 2, 3 and 4, to submit a revised family pension
proposal, in respect of the services rendered by late Dulal Chandra Das, in
favour of the petitioner, herein. Such proposal be furnished to the Office of
the Accountant General (A&E), Assam, within a period of 01 (one) month
from the date of a receipt of a certified copy of this order. The Office of the
Accountant General (A&E), Assam, on receipt of such proposal from the
Departmental Authorities, shall further process the same and issue a fresh
Family Pension Payment Order (FPPO), in favour of the petitioner, herein, by
reckoning her status as being the 1 st wife of Late Dulal Chandra Das. Such
Family Pension Payment Order (FPPO), be issued to the petitioner within a
period of 02 (two) months, from the date of receipt of a certified copy of
this order.
14.
As this Court had already concluded that it is the petitioner, herein,
who is to receive Family Pension in respect of the services rendered by Late
Dulal Chandra Das, being his 1st wife, the Office of the Accountant General
(A&E), Assam, as well as the Treasury Officer, Nagaon, Assam, i.e. the
Page No.# 11/11
Respondent No.8, is directed to stop payment of Family Pension in respect
of the Respondent no.9, forthwith. However, it is provided that the Family
Pension drawn by the Respondent no.9 till date be not recovered.
15.
The petitioner, herein, would be entitled only to receive of pension
and pensionary benefits prospectively. It is further provided that, in the
event, the respondent no.9 is solely dependent upon the pension and
pensionary benefits of the Family Pension received by her on account of the
service rendered by Dulal Chandra Das, the directions passed in the present
order would not stand in the way of the Respondent no.9 approaching the
competent Court of law, claiming maintenance from the petitioner, herein.
16.
In the event, such application is filed, the competent Court of law
shall consider the same strictly on its merit, without being swayed by the
observations and directions passed, hereinabove.
17.
With the above observations and directions, the present writ
petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review