The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. As would appear from the first issue in the show-cause, the same primarily relates to delayed filing of returns which having regard to the provisions of Section 16(4) of the said Act created an impediment on the registered tax payer to avail the benefit thereof. However, such situation has since changed with the insertion of Section 16(5) in the said Act. Since, going by the materials on record, it would transpire that the returns filed by the petitioner for the tax period of 2018-19 was before 30th November, 2021, I am of the view, the petitioner is entitled to the benefit of such provision and demand raised by the respondents on the petitioner for availing input tax credit to the extent of Rs. 33,49,590/-, cannot sustained and the same is accordingly quashed. Insofar as the short payment of ITC is concerned, I find that the petitioner wishes to rely on voluntary payment of input tax credit in form GSTR 03 dated 31st January, 2020. Although, the facts and figures match, however, considering the fact that aforesaid is a factual issue, I am of the view that in the fitness of things, it would only be prudent to remand the aforesaid issue to WPA 24640 of 2023 the adjudicating authority for reconsideration thereof. The only other issue which survives for consideration is with regard to mismatch of input tax credit. In the given facts, since it is argued that the matter relating to …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury
WPA 24640 of 2023
Santu Das
Versus
Assistant Commissioner of CGST & C. EX, Chandannagore Division
& Ors.
For the petitioner
:
Ms. Sutapa Roy Choudhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Abhijat Das, Adv.
Ms. Aratrika Roy, Adv.
Mr. Anirban Chatterjee, Adv.
For the State
:
Ms. Manju Agarwal, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Ram Chandra Agarwal, Adv.
For the CGST
:
Mr. Kaushik Dey, Adv.
Mr. Tapan Bhanja, Adv.
Heard on
:
01.07.2026.
Judgment on
:
01.07.2026.
Raja Basu Chowdhury, J (Oral):
1. Though the matter had come up under the heading “Extension of
Interim Order” since the writ petition has been pending since 2023,
this Court by consent of the parties, has taken up for hearing of the
writ petition itself.
2. The writ petitioner by the instant writ petition seeks to challenge
not only the adjudication order passed under Section 73(9) of the
WBGST/CGST Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as the said Act) for
WPA 24640 of 2023
the tax period of 2017-18 and 2018-19 but also two seperate
appellate order passed under Section 107 of the said Act both dated
23rd March, 2023 whereby not only the demand raised by the
respondents in form GST DRC 07 had been confirmed but at the
instance of the department, in a separate appeal the appellate
authority had enhanced the penalty from Rs. 1,00,000/- to Rs.
3,80,597/-.
3. To appreciate the contention of the parties, it is relevant to note
down the facts leading to filing of the writ petition.
4. It is not in dispute that a show cause had been issued on the
petitioner under Section 73(1) of the said Act, dated 6th July, 2021.
As would appear from the show cause, the same pertains to
irregular availment of input tax credit (ITC) for the tax period of
2018-19 and wrongful utilization thereof on the ground that the
returns filed by the petitioner under Section 39 of the said Act was
beyond the prescribed period. The second issue canvassed in the
show-cause was with regard to excess availemnt of ITC to the tune
of Rs. 4,04,174/- for the tax period of 2017-18 and utilization in
respect whereof having regard to mismatch in GSTR 9 submitted by
the petitioner as on verification of the annual return submitted by
the petitioner for the tax period of 2017-18, it was noticed that in
table No. 8 they have shown excess availment of input tax credit to
the tune of Rs. 40,414/-, and the input tax credit disclosed in form
GSTR 3B table 4A could not be reconciled with the details of tax,
WPA 24640 of 2023
auto populated at the instance of the petitioner’s service provider in
form GSTR 2A. The third issue involved in the show cause was with
regard to short payment of input tax credit to the extent of Rs.
52,208/-.
5. The
petitioner
had
duly
responded
to
the
show
cause.
Subsequently the proper officer had adjudicated upon the same and
had found that the petitioner had defaulted on all the 3 issues and
had accordingly raised a demand of Rs. 19,02,986/- by passing an
order under Section 73(9) of the said Act. The demand was raised
in form GST DRC 07 on 25th October, 2021. In addition thereto, the
proper officer had also imposed a penalty of Rs. 1,00,000/- in terms
of Section 73(1) read with Section 73(9) of the said Act. Not only the
petitioner being aggrieved with the aforesaid preferred appeal but
records would reveal that the department also chose to prefer
appeal under Section 107 of the said Act, insofar as the imposition
of penalty was concerned. The department insisted that higher
amount of penalty should be imposed.
6. By an order dated 22nd March, 2023, the petitioner’s appeal was
rejected. Insofar as the appeal filed by the department was
concerned, the appellate authority has been pleased to enhance the
quantum of the penalty by observing that the adjudicating authority
had completely ignored the provisions of Section 73(9) of the said
Act which stipulate that mandatory penalty should be 10% of the
WPA 24640 of 2023
tax or Rs.10,000/- whichever is higher. Following which the
demand in form GST ALP 04 was raised.
7. Ms. Roy Chowdhury, learned senior advocate representing the
petitioner has drawn the attention of this Court to the provisions of
Section 16(5) of the said Act and would submit that subsequent to
the insertion of the aforesaid Section by way of Finance Act (No.2)
Act, 2024, (15) of 2024 dated 16th August, 2024 with effect from
27th September, 2024 vide SO 4253 (E) with effect from 1st July,
2017, the very basis of the demand raised by the respondents in
terms of the first issue forming part of the show-cause dated 6th
July, 2021 no longer survives. Insofar as the second issue is
concerned, she would submit that though the petitioner had
purchased services from Aircel and due payments were made in
respect thereof, unfortunately, Aircel having being involved in
insolvency proceedings before the National Company Law Board,
Aircel may not have uploaded the returns. The failure on the part
of the Aircel to upload the returns cannot be attributable to the
petitioner, especially when the petitioner had made the entire
payment of tax liability. Insofar as the third issue with regard to
short payment of ITC is concerned, she would submit, by relying on
annexure P1 to the writ petition which is a voluntary payment
receipt of ITC made in form GST DRC 03 dated 31st January, 2020
that entire amount of tax which is claimed to be short paid has
already been paid by the petitioner. She would submit that since
WPA 24640 of 2023
the very demand raised by the respondents no longer survives
especially, having regard to Section 16(5) of the said Act, the
penalty imposed by the respondents needs to be revisited and
reconsidered. Accordingly, the matter may be remanded back on
the aforesaid score.
8. Mr. Dey, learned advocate appears for the CGST authorities. He
would submit that having regard to the insertion of Section 16(5),
the petitioner may be entitled to the benefit thereof. Insofar as the
payment made by the petitioner to the Aircel is concerned, he would
submit that unless the petitioner’s service provider files the returns
and makes payment of the input tax credit, the petitioners liability
cannot vanish. He would submit that in the event, the petitioner’s
service provider had made payment of the input tax credit, the
same would have been auto populated in GSTR 2A and as such
there is no irregularity in such decision. On the issue of payment of
short deposit, he would submit that these are factual issues and
this Court ought not to enter into the same.
9. Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective
parties and having considered the materials on record, I find that in
the instant case, a show cause was issued. To morefully appreciate
the same, the relevant portion of the show-cause which deals with
the issues raised therein are extracted hereinbelow:
“The said taxpayer had irregularly availed imput tas credit (ITC) to the
extent of Rs. 33.49.590/- Rs. 16,74,795/- (CGST) Rs 16,74,795/- (SGST)
[for the tax period between November, 2018 to March, 2019beyond the
due date of availing ITC for the financial year 2018-19 and utilized the
WPA 24640 of 2023
said irregularly availed credit for payment of taxes on outward supply
[as detailed in 'Annexure- A' to this notice]
ii) the said taxpayer has availed excess credit to the tune of Rs 4,04,1/4
[Rs.2,02,087/-(CGST) + Rs.2,02,087/-(SGST)]as is reflected in tablet of
then Annual return (GSTR 9)submitted for the period 2017-18 and
utilized the sand irregularly availed credit for payment of taxes on
outward supply as detailed in 'Annexure B' to this notice;
iii) The said taxpayer have short paid GST to the extent of Rs. 52 208/(CGST Rs.26,104/+ SGST Rs.26,104/-) as they have shown excess
clearance to the tune of Rs 2,90,042/- in their GSTR 1 for the month of
August 2017 in comparison to GSTR 3B for the same period as detailed
in 'Annexure - C' to this notice.”
10.
As would appear from the first issue in the show-cause,
the same primarily relates to delayed filing of returns which
having regard to the provisions of Section 16(4) of the said Act
created an impediment on the registered tax payer to avail the
benefit thereof. However, such situation has since changed with
the insertion of Section 16(5) in the said Act. Since, going by the
materials on record, it would transpire that the returns filed by
the petitioner for the tax period of 2018-19 was before 30th
November, 2021, I am of the view, the petitioner is entitled to the
benefit of such provision and demand raised by the respondents
on the petitioner for availing input tax credit to the extent of Rs.
33,49,590/-, cannot sustained and the same is accordingly
quashed. Insofar as the short payment of ITC is concerned, I find
that the petitioner wishes to rely on voluntary payment of input
tax credit in form GSTR 03 dated 31st January, 2020. Although,
the facts and figures match, however, considering the fact that
aforesaid is a factual issue, I am of the view that in the fitness of
things, it would only be prudent to remand the aforesaid issue to
WPA 24640 of 2023
the adjudicating authority for reconsideration thereof.
The only
other issue which survives for consideration is with regard to
mismatch of input tax credit.
In the given facts, since it is
argued that the matter relating to insolvency of Aircel is now
pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court as submitted by the
parties, and since, there does not appear to be much discussion
on the above subject, I am of the view, the aforesaid issue should
also be reconsidered by the proper officer. Since, the demand
raised by the respondents insofar as the first issue is concerned,
has been set aside and since the question of quantum of penalty
is dependent upon the demand raised, I am of the view that the
imposition of penalty which has since been enhanced by the
appellate authority, in the given facts cannot be sustained. The
same is set aside and the issue of imposition of penalty is
accordingly
remanded
back
to
the proper
officer
for
re-
adjudication. As a sequel thereto, the orders passed both by the
adjudicating authority as also the appellate authority are set
aside. Since no other issue survives for adjudication, the writ
petition is disposed of.
11.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for,
be made available to the parties upon compliance of all requisite
formalities.
(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J.)
Sayandeep
A.R. (Court)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review