Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Criminal Appeal Jurisdiction)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai
W/o Shri Bir Kumar Rai
R/o Lingee, South Sikkim.
…. Appellant
versus
State of Sikkim
…. Respondent
----------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal under Section 374 (2) Cr.P.C. 1973.
Appearance:
Ms. Gita Bista, Legal Aid Counsel for the Appellant.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Additional Public Prosecutor
for the State-Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
(10.05.2018)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
In the quest for truth there is a delicate balance which is
required to be maintained by the Court to examine the
criminality of the offender. A criminal mind is a mind of its
own. What compels a criminal to commit the crime is a
question for which one still searches for answers. How a
criminal commits a criminal act is a matter of investigation
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
that is required to be cogently proved. Direct evidence may not
always be available and sometimes the Courts have to examine
circumstantial evidences. When a criminal commits a crime
against unsuspecting rustic villagers the evidence produced
may not be as perfect as we desire it to be. The task of the
Court in such circumstances becomes heavier. As the
Language of the Court is English and most of the rustic
villagers would communicate in vernacular sometimes the
correct statement may get lost in translation. The Court is
then required to sift minutely through the evidence in search
of the truth. Truth alone can render justice.
2.
This is an appeal preferred by the Appellant, Santa Maya
Rai, wife of Bir Kumar Rai, under Section 374 (2) Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.) against the judgment of
conviction dated 05.08.2016 and order of sentence dated
09.08.2016 passed by the Learned Sessions Judge, East
Sikkim at Gangtok (Learned Sessions Judge) in Sessions Trial
Case No. 26 of 2014. The Learned Sessions Judge has
acquitted Bir Kumar Rai who was Accused No.1 but found
cogent evidence against the wife, the Appellant herein, for
commission of offence under Section 489B and 489C of the
Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
3.
The Prosecution case is that on 23.04.2014 the Appellant
along with her husband travelled from Gangtok towards
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Dikchu in a vehicle bearing registration No. SK-01T/1171. On
the way, they stopped at various places and used the
counterfeit
currency-notes
of
₹500/-
denomination
to
purchase small items and receive substantial change of
genuine currency notes in return. It was alleged that the
modus operandi of the Appellant and her husband was to
make purchases and tender counterfeit currency-notes of
₹500/- denomination to the unsuspecting shopkeepers, who in
turn returned genuine currency notes as change besides
partying with property.
4.
Criminal investigation would be initiated on the lodging of
the First Information Report (FIR) (Exhibit-1) on 23.05.2014 on
the basis of a written complaint from Narad Nepal (P.W.1)
stating that a vehicle bearing No. SK 01T-1171 with two
persons, the Appellant and B. K. Rai, were trying to cheat the
local shopkeepers by giving counterfeit currency-note of
₹500/- denomination, buying small items, receiving original
currency-notes as change and trying to flee away. It was also
stated in the FIR that Narad Nepal (P.W.1) along with local
Panchayat, P. P. Adhikari (P.W.7), followed them to lower
Samdong at about 3 p.m., apprehended them and thereafter
informed the local Makha police outpost pursuant to which the
police nabbed them.
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
5.
On the completion of the investigation two charges would
be framed on 05.05.2015 which read as under:
“Firstly - That you on 23.05.2014, between 12.30 to 3.00 pm
hrs. at Singtam, East Sikkim, under the jurisdiction of Singtam
Police Station, East Sikkim, in common object with co-accused Bir
Kumar Rai used counterfeit Indian Currency Notes as genuine, of
the denomination of ₹500/-, knowing them to be counterfeit and
you have thereby committed an offence under Section 489 ‘B’ read
with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and within the
cognizance of this Court.
Secondly - That you on the same date, place and time herein
above mentioned, in common object with the Co-accused Bir Kumar
Rai, was found in possession of the 42 numbers of Counterfeit
Indian Currency Notes of the denomination of ₹500/- knowing them
to be counterfeit notes and intending the same to be used as
genuine and you have thereby committed an offence punishable
under Section 489 ‘C’ of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 read with
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and within the
cognizance of this Court.”
6.
Sixteen witnesses would be examined by the prosecution
during trial. The defence would not examine any witness. On
examination of the Appellant and her husband under Section
313 Cr.P.C the Learned Session Judge would hear the case
finally and pronounce the impugned judgement on 05.08.2016
and order on sentence on 09.08.2016 convicting the Appellant
and acquitting her husband.
7.
The judgment sought to be assailed convicted the
Appellant under Section 489B and 489C IPC and sentenced
her to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of two years
and to further pay a fine of ₹5000/- each for each of the said
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
offences and in default of payment of the said fine to undergo
imprisonment for a further period of six months. The
sentences were to run concurrently and the period of
imprisonment already undergone by the Appellant during
investigation and trial was required to be set off against the
sentences. The fine if recovered was directed to be made over
to seven prosecution witnesses @ ₹1000/- each for their loss
and harassment and the remaining amount of the fine was
required to be deposited in the State exchequer.
8.
The
Learned
Sessions
Judge
after
a
thorough
examination of the evidence produced by the prosecution and
after a detailed hearing held:
“30. There is therefore, no reason to doubt that ₹500 currency
notes (marked M.O.-IA and M.O.-IB) found in the possession of
accused No.2 were counterfeit currency notes. The fact that accused
persons
stopped
at
numerous
shops
between
Singtam
and
Samdong, and tendered counterfeit ₹500/- currency notes to collect
the genuine currency notes from the unsuspecting shopkeepers goes
to show the mens rea which she had. It is certain that accused No.2
had the required knowledge and reason to believe that ₹500/currency notes used by her are counterfeit notes.”
9.
Heard Ms. Gita Bista, Learned Counsel for the Appellant
and Mr. Thinlay Dorjee, Learned Counsel for the StateRespondent. While Ms. Gita Bista would contend that the
prosecution has failed to establish the required mens rea for
the alleged offences, Mr. Thinlay Dorjee would contend that the
modus operandi of the Appellant in using the currency-notes of
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
₹500/- denomination at every shop and buying articles of
small value and getting substantial genuine currency-notes
from the shopkeepers as change would itself establish the
mens rea of the Appellant for the commission of the offences.
10. Ms. Gita Bista would further submit that the prosecution
has failed to prove the seizure of the currency-notes of ₹500/denomination and establish that the said currency-notes were
used by the Appellant. Ms. Gita Bista would submit that
although the prosecution witnesses deposes about purchase of
various items by the Appellant using the counterfeit currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination the said items allegedly
purchased by the Appellant have not been seized and
produced before the Trial Court and as such the benefit of
doubt must be given to the Appellant. Ms. Gita Bista would
further submit that the prosecution has failed to establish how
the Appellant came in possession of the counterfeit currencynotes even if it is assumed, without admitting so, that the
Appellant was in possession. It is submitted that since no
charge was framed under section 489A IPC against the
Appellant it is quite evident that there is no evidence on record
as to how the said counterfeit currency-notes came into
possession of the Appellant.
11. Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, on the other hand would
submit that the seizures of the 42 numbers of counterfeit
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
currency-notes have been cogently proved by the prosecution.
The seizure memo (exhibit-3) vide which 42 number of
counterfeit currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination each has
been proved by seizure witnesses-Narad Nepal (P.W.1) and
Manoj Pradhan (P.W.8) and Dhruva Chettri (P.W.14) the
Analyst-cum-Assistant Chemical Examiner to the Government
of Sikkim at the Regional Forensic Science Laboratory (RFSL),
Saramsa, Ranipool, East Sikkim who examined the 51 Indian
currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination has clearly proved that
the said currency-notes which were seized were counterfeit.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia would thus submit that the
ingredients of Section 489C of IPC for possession of forged or
counterfeit currency-notes or bank notes have been proved by
the prosecution. Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia would further
submit, in so far as Section 489B IPC is concerned, the
evidence produced by the prosecution has unquestionably
proved that the Appellant had used the forged or counterfeit
currency-notes as genuine knowing or having reason to believe
the same to be forged or counterfeit and thus liable for
punishment prescribed. He would submit that the evidence of
Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10), Ran Maya Rai (P.W.12) and
Kailash Chettri (P.W.13) clearly establishes that the Appellant
had
used
the
counterfeit
currency-notes
of
₹500/-
denomination at different shops at Ralap, purchased small
items and duped the shop owners to accept the counterfeit
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination and get change of
genuine currency-notes in return. Similarly, he would submit
that the evidence of Anu Rana (P.W.3) and Phul Maya
Neopaney (P.W.6) would establish and prove a repetition of the
same criminal act at Singbel as done at Ralap. Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia would rely upon the evidence of Tek Nath
Sharma (P.W.11) and the evidence of Sujata Pradhan (P.W.4)
and Chandrakala Adhikari (P.W.5) to prove similar modus
operandi at Kokoley and Tumin respectively. He would submit
that the evidence of Narad Nepal (P.W.1) and Manoj Pradhan
(P.W.8) would establish the seizure of 9 counterfeit currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination used as genuine by the
Appellant at the aforesaid adjacent villages of Ralap, Singbel,
Kokolay and Tumin. Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia would further
submit that the blunt denial of the Appellant to various
questions put by the Trial Court without furnishing any
explanation to the incriminating material would entitle the
Court to draw an inference, including such adverse inference
against the Appellant as may be permissible in accordance
with law.
12. Narad Nepal (P.W.1) resident of Tumin is the first
informant. He is also the witness to the seizure of 42 currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination from the Appellant vide seizure
memo (exhibit-3) on 23.05.2014 and the seizure of 9 currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination at the Singtam police station
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
from Kailash Chettri (P.W.13) on the same date. Narad Nepal
(P.W.1) identified the Appellant as the person who had been
apprehended from Samdong on 23.05.2014 and from whom 42
counterfeit currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination had been
seized at the Singtam police station in his presence and in the
presence of Manoj Pradhan (P.W.8) the second seizure witness.
13. The deposition of Narad Nepal (P.W.1) from Tumin, Prem
Prasad Adhikari (P.W.7), the Panchayat of 44 Tumin Gram
Panchayat Unit and Churamani Bhattarai (P.W.2) a resident of
Tumin and who works at the Tumin petrol pump corroborate
each other in material particulars and proves the facts leading
to the arrest of the Appellant and her husband on 23.05.2014
from Samdong the day on which the alleged criminal acts were
committed by the Appellant and her husband. They identified
the Appellant. The said three prosecution witnesses cogently
establishes that on 23.05.2014 on being informed that the
Appellant and her husband were using counterfeit currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination on unsuspecting shopkeepers
were apprehended at Samdong and handed over to the police.
They were the ones who followed the Appellant and her
husband to Samdong from where they apprehended the
Appellant’s husband and the Appellant was apprehended by
the villagers.
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
14.
Manoj Pradhan (P.W.8) also identified the Appellant as
the person who had been apprehended by the villagers at
Samdong where he had gone chasing the Appellant and her
husband after Sujata Pradhan (P.W.4) his wife informed him
that the Appellant had also duped her by tendering a
counterfeit
currency-note
of
₹500/-
denomination
and
purchasing 3 packets of Mimi noodles from their shop and
taking away ₹470/- as change from her. Manoj Pradhan
(P.W.8) also witnessed the Appellant and her husband being
taken to the Singtam police station and the search and seizure
conducted on the Appellant where the police recovered 42
counterfeit currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination from the
Appellant for which he along with Narad Nepal (P.W.1) stood as
witness. Manoj Pradhan (P.W.8) and Narad Nepal (P.W.1) were
also witness to the seizure of 9 currency-notes of ₹500/denomination on 23.05.2014 from Kailash Chettri (P.W.13)
when the shopkeepers who had been duped by the Appellant
had come to the Singtam police station and deposited the said
currency-notes.
15. The seizure memos (exhibit-3 and exhibit-4) both dated
23.05.2014 recorded the serial numbers of the currency-notes
which were seized. Narad Nepal (P.W.1) could identify all the
51 currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination seized vide seizure
memo (exhibit-3 and exhibit-4) by going through its serial
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
numbers and comparing it with the serial numbers noted in
the said seizure memos.
16. Dhurba
Chettri
(P.W.14)
the
Analyst-cum-Assistant
Chemical Examiner proved that he had examined all the said
51 currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination and found them to
be counterfeit vide his opinion (exhibit-6). He has opined that
poor quality of paper ink, defective watermarks, defective
window
security
thread,
absence
of
intaglio
printing
technology, defective micro printing, absence of optically
variable ink, absence of scattered fluorescence fibres and
absence of criss-cross markings on the said currency-notes of
₹500/- denomination as the reasons to come to the conclusion
that the said notes were counterfeit.
17. Section 489B of the IPC provides:
“489-B. Using as genuine, forged or counterfeit currency-notes
or bank-notes:- Whoever sells to, or buys or receives from, any
other person, or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine, any forged
or counterfeit currency-note or bank-note, knowing or having reason
to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit, shall be punished
with [imprisonment for life], or with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also
be liable to fine.].”
18. Section 489B IPC makes the trafficking of forged or
counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes or the use as
genuine, any forged or counterfeit currency-notes or banknotes with the required mens rea i.e. criminal intent (knowing
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit)
punishable.
19. In the present case the Learned Sessions Judge has
found the Appellant guilty of use of the forged or counterfeit
currency-notes as genuine knowing or having reason to believe
the same to be forged or counterfeit. Thus the necessary
ingredients of Section
489B IPC for the use of forged or
counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes are:i.
Proof of the currency-note or bank-note being
forged or counterfeit.
ii.
The use of the said currency-note or bank-note
as genuine knowing or having reason to believe
the same to be forged or counterfeit.
20. Section 489C of the IPC provides:
“489-C. Possession of forged or counterfeit currency-notes or
bank-notes.—Whoever has in his possession any forged or counterfeit currency-note or bank-note, knowing or having reason to believe
the same to be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the same
as genuine or that it may be used as genuine, shall be punished
with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend
to seven years, or with fine, or with both.”
21. Section 489C IPC makes possession of any forged or
counterfeit currency-note or bank-note with the mens rea i.e.
criminal intent (knowing or having reason to believe the same to
be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the same as
genuine or that it may be used as genuine) punishable. The
necessary ingredients of Section 489C IPC for possession of
forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes are:-
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
i. Possession of forged or counterfeit currency-note
or bank-note.
ii. knowing or having reason to believe the same to
be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the
same as genuine or that it may be used as
genuine.
22. Sachita
Nanda
Darjee
(P.W.10)
has
identified
the
Appellant in Court which identification is not contested. She is
a resident of Ralap, East Sikkim and runs a provision shop. As
per her deposition the Appellant came to the shop and
purchased ten packets of Mimi noodles and offered a currencynote of ₹500/- denomination. Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10)
deducted the price of the Mimi noodles and returned ₹450/- to
the Appellant as change. On realising that the currency-note of
₹500/-
denomination
was
counterfeit
from
information
received from other shopkeepers she went to the Makha police
outpost first and thereafter to Singtam police station where she
handed over the said currency-note of ₹500/- denomination.
She identified the same currency-note in Court which was
tendered by the Appellant to her as she has signed her name
on it at the time of handing over the same to the Singtam
police station. The evidence of Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10)
clearly proves that the Appellant had used the currency-note of
₹500/- denomination and duped her at Ralap. The said
currency-note of ₹500/- denomination identified by her was
seized by the police and sent for forensic examination to RFSL
which proved that the said currency-note was counterfeit.
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Dhurba Chettri (P.W.14) the Analyst-cum-Assistant Chemical
Examiner has proved that the said currency-note of ₹500/denomination was counterfeit. Thus the prosecution has been
able to prove the possession and use of counterfeit currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination by the Appellant. Possession of
counterfeit currency-note is an ingredient of Section 489C IPC.
Use of counterfeit currency-note is an ingredient of Section
489B IPC. However, it is yet to be seen whether the Appellant
had the required mens rea and whether the Appellant was
aware that the said currency-notes were counterfeit and
intended to use them knowing that they were counterfeit. The
knowledge
that
the
said
currency-notes
of
₹500/-
denomination were counterfeit and the intention to use it as
genuine would satisfy the second ingredient of the alleged
offences.
23. The evidence of Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10) as
discussed above does establish the use of currency-note of
₹500/- denomination identified by her as she had signed on it
at the time of the seizure. Sachita Nanda Darjee’s (P.W.10)
deposition cogently proves the use of the said currency-notes
of ₹500/- denomination by the Appellant which was obviously
part of the counterfeit currency-notes in her possession on
23.05.2014. Although Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10) did not
state the date of the incident in her deposition, the seizure
memo
(exhibit-4)
dated
23.05.2014
through
which
the
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
particular currency-note of ₹500/- denomination which was
tendered by the Appellant to Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10) on
the date of the incident was seized clearly establishes that the
Appellant had in fact used the said currency-note of ₹500/denomination on 23.05.2014 itself on the same day she was
also found in possession of 42 counterfeit currency-notes.
24. In re: Mohd. Farooque Yusuf Chaiwala vs. State of
Maharashtra1 the Bombay High Court would hold:
“28. Thus, to bring home the charge of offences punishable
under Sections 489B and 489C of the IPC the prosecution is
required to establish, inter alia, that the accused knew (or had
reason to believe) the notes in question to be counterfeit or
forged. The prosecution is also required to establish that the
accused intended to use the same as genuine. It is true that
such knowledge or existence of reason to believe, can be
proved by, or can be inferred, only from circumstantial
evidence. In this case, the prosecution has not been able to
point out the evidence or circumstances showing that each of
the Appellants had knowledge that the notes were counterfeit
or that each of them wanted to use the same as genuine. If
there were any such circumstances appearing in the evidence
of the prosecution, such circumstances should have been put
to the Appellants during their examination under Section 313
of the Code. No such circumstances were put to any of the
Appellants by the trial Court, presumably because the trial
Court did not consider this aspect of the matter. In fact, the
trial Court also did not put the report received from the India
Security Press, Nasik to any of the Appellants in their
examination
under
Section
of
the
Code.
Such
circumstances, namely viz. evidence showing that the notes in
question were counterfeit and the evidence and circumstances
suggesting that the accused knew the same should have been
put to the Appellants. The Appellants were therefore not given
2011 SCC OnLine Bom. 521
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
an opportunity to offer any explanation about these aspects,
which were held as ‘proved’ against them, by the trial Court.”
25. In re: Pannal Lal Gupta vs. State of Sikkim2 a Division
Bench of this Court would hold:
“21. In view of the above circumstances, the possibility
of the fake currency-notes' having been given, to him by the
customers in the course of his business and he being alayman could not suspect the said currency-notes to be fake
cannot be ruled out. It is hardly necessary to observe that
mere possession of, forged note is not an offence. The offence
is directed against trafficking in fake notes and what is
essential is that apart from possessing the fake notes the
appellant must know of its, falsity and having known uses
them. The appellant must have known or at least must have
had reason to believe that the notes were counterfeited. It is
also the requirement of law that, the possession must be
accompanied by intention to use that as genuine. Nothing has
been
brought
on
record
by
way
of
even
collateral
circumstances to show that the appellant had intention to use
the fake notes as genuine. On the other hand, as already
noted above, it cannot be said on the basis of the materials; on
record that the appellant knew or had rea,-son to believe that
the currency-notes he was dealing with Were” counterfeited
and issued such notes as genuine.”
26. Ms. Geeta Bista would rely upon the pronouncement of
the Supreme Court in re: Umashanker v. State of Chhattisgarh3
in which it was held:
“7. Sections 489-A to 489-E deal with various economic offences in
respect of forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes. The
object of the legislature in enacting these provisions is not only to
protect the economy of the country but also to provide adequate
protection to currency notes and banknotes. The currency notes are,
2009 SCC OnLine Sikk 19
(2001) 9 SCC 642
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
in spite of growing accustomedness to the credit card system, still
the backbone of the commercial transactions by the multitudes in our
country. But these provisions are not meant to punish unwary
possessors or users.
8. A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, shows that mens rea
of offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C is “knowing or having
reason to believe the currency notes or banknotes are forged or
counterfeit”. Without the aforementioned mens rea selling, buying or
receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as
genuine forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes, is not
enough to constitute offence under Section 489-B IPC. So also
possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit
currency notes or banknotes is not sufficient to make out a case
under Section 489-C in the absence of the mens rea, noted above. No
material is brought on record by the prosecution to show that the
appellant had the requisite mens rea. The High Court, however,
completely missed this aspect. The learned trial Judge on the basis
of the evidence of PW 2, PW 4 and PW 7 that they were able to make
out that the currency note alleged to have been given to PW 4 was
fake, “presumed” such a mens rea. On the date of the incident the
appellant was said to be an eighteen-year-old student. On the facts
of this case the presumption drawn by the trial court is not
warranted under Section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not
shown that any specific question with regard to the currency notes
being fake or counterfeit was put to the appellant in his examination
under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code. On these facts,
we have no option but to hold that the charges framed under
Sections 489-B and 489-C are not proved. We, therefore, set aside
the conviction and sentence passed on the appellant under Sections
489-B and 489-C IPC and acquit him of the said charges (see: M.
Mammutti v. State of Karnataka.”
27. M. Hidayatullah, J. in re: Ranjit D. Udeshi vs. State of
Maharashtra4
while dealing with the criminal prosecution
under Section 292 IPC against one of the four partners of a
firm which owned a book-stall in Bombay and was accused of
AIR 1965 SC 881
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
having been found in possession, for the purpose of sale,
copies of an alleged obscene book called ‘Lady Chatterley’s
Lover’, would hold:
“11. ..... In criminal prosecution mens rea must necessarily be
proved by circumstantial evidence alone unless the accused
confesses. .........”
28. In re: Kailash Kumar Sanwatia vs. State of Bihar and Anr.5
the Supreme Court would hold:
“9.....As the question of intention is not a matter of direct
proof, certain broad tests are envisaged which would
generally afford useful guidance in deciding whether in a
particular case the accused had mens rea for the crime. ......”
29. In re: Devender Kumar Singla vs. Baldev Krishan Singla6 the
Supreme Court while examining a case of cheating and
dishonestly inducing delivery of property would hold:
“8. As was observed by this Court in Shivanarayan Kabra v.
State of Madras [AIR 1967 SC 986: 1967 Cri LJ 946] it is not
necessary that a false pretence should be made in express words by
the accused. It may be inferred from all the circumstances including
the conduct of the accused in obtaining the property. In the true
nature of things, it is not always possible to prove dishonest
intention by any direct evidence. It can be proved by a number of
circumstances from which a reasonable inference can be drawn.”
30. In re: Sooguru Subrahmanyam v. State of A.P.7 referred to by
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, the Supreme Court would hold:
“21. Now, we may deal with the submission that the
prosecution has not been able to prove any motive for the
(2003) 7 SCC 399
(2005) 9 SCC 15
(2013) 4 SCC 244
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
commission of the crime because the suspicion on the part of the
husband has not been established. We have already recorded an
affirmative finding on that score. However, we may, in this context,
profitably refer to the pronouncement in Nathuni Yadav v. State of
Bihar [(1998) 9 SCC 238: 1998 SCC (Cri) 992] wherein a two-Judge
Bench has laid down thus: (SCC p. 244, para 17)
“17. Motive for doing a criminal act is generally a
difficult area for prosecution. One cannot normally see into the
mind of another. Motive is the emotion which impels a man to
do a particular act. Such impelling cause need not necessarily
be proportionally grave to do grave crimes. Many a murders
have been committed without any known or prominent motive.
It is quite possible that the aforesaid impelling factor would
remain undiscoverable. Lord Chief Justice Champbell struck a
note of caution in R. v. Palmer [ Shorthand Report at p. 308
CCC May 1856] thus:
‘But if there be any motive which can be assigned, I am bound
to tell you that the adequacy of that motive is of little importance. We
know, from experience of criminal courts that atrocious crimes of this
sort have been committed from very slight motives; not merely from
malice and revenge, but to gain a small pecuniary advantage, and to
drive off for a time pressing difficulties.’
Though, it is a sound proposition that every criminal act is
done with a motive, it is unsound to suggest that no such criminal
act can be presumed unless motive is proved. After all, motive is a
psychological phenomenon. Mere fact that prosecution failed to
translate that mental disposition of the accused into evidence does
not mean that no such mental condition existed in the mind of the
assailant.”
31. In the light of the various pronouncement of the Supreme
Court, the Bombay High Court, this Court as well as the
compelling thoughts of Lord Chief Justice Champbell in R.v.
Palmer on the requirement of establishing mens rea before
saddling the Appellant with criminal liability under Section
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
489B and 489C IPC and “motive” it is vital to examine if, as
submitted by Mr. Thinlay Dorjee, the Appellant’s repeated use
of the counterfeit currency-notes itself establishes the criminal
intent.
32.
Ran Maya Rai (P.W.12) who runs a vegetable shop at
Ralap did not identify the Appellant in Court. She does not
remember the date and the month but she recollects that in
the year 2014 one lady alighted from a blue coloured car
driven by a male driver, purchased vegetables from her shop
worth ₹100/-, tendered ₹500/- and was given ₹400/- as
change by her. On the same day after the said lady left, some
vehicles had stopped at Ralap and she heard that some
persons
were
circulating
counterfeit-currency
notes
at
Samdong and were told to be careful. Since she had also
received currency-note of ₹500/- denomination from the lady,
she accompanied the other persons similarly duped to Singtam
police station where she also deposited the same. There were 4
to 5 other persons who had reached Singtam police station
who were all complaining about one lady and one male person
coming to their shops in a car and tendering currency-note of
₹500/- denomination to purchase some articles from their
shop. The deposition of Ran Maya Rai (P.W.12) that sometime
in 2014 a lady tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination
to her which she deposited with the Singtam police station
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
along with other shop-keepers is relevant and corroborates the
evidence of Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10) about the same.
33. Kailash Chettri’s (P.W.13) sister Heema Chettri runs a
grocery shop at Ralap. He is the person whose name is
recorded as the person from whom the 9 currency-notes of
₹500/- denomination were seized in the seizure memo (exhibit4). Kailash Chettri’s (P.W.13) does not recollect the exact date
but sometime in May, 2014 some shopkeepers of Ralap were
reported to have received forged Indian currency-notes from
some lady who had come to Ralap. Heema Chettri and other
shopkeepers of Ralap had told him that the said lady had
purchased small items such as Mimi noodles worth ₹50/- from
the shops including that of his sister. He was informed that
the said lady had tendered forged Indian currency-notes of
₹500/- denomination to purchase small items from the shops.
The police from Makha police outpost visited Ralap and told
them
to
bring
the
forged
currency-note
of
₹500/-
denomination received from the said lady to Singtam police
station. Accordingly he along with other shopkeepers went to
Singtam police station and handed over the said currencynotes received by the shopkeepers to a police officer who seized
the same duly preparing a seizure memo. The currency-note
bearing serial number 7NV979471 was handed over by Kailash
Chettri (P.W.13) to the police at the time of the seizure. The
name ‘Kailash Chettri’ found written on the said note was
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
written by him in his own handwriting while handing over the
said currency-note to the police on the relevant day. As he did
not compare the numbers of the other currency-notes marked
MO I B (collectively) he could not say whether those were the
same notes that was seized at Singtam police station. However,
he could definitely identify the currency-note of ₹500/denomination that was submitted by him at Singtam police
station since he had written his name on it. Although, Heema
Chettri was not examined the deposition of Kailash Chettri
(P.W.13) about
what he heard about one lady using forged
Indian currency-notes of ₹500 denomination/- from her and
other shopkeepers of Ralap; the police from Makha police
outpost visiting Ralap and telling them to bring the forged
currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination received from the said
lady
to
Singtam
police
station;
he
along
with
other
shopkeepers going to Singtam police station and handing over
the said currency-notes received by the shopkeepers to a police
officer who seized the same duly preparing the seizure memo
has corroborative value to the other evidence produced by the
prosecution.
MO I B (2) identified and marked by Kailash
Chettri’s (P.W.13) as the said currency-note of ₹500/denomination is also part of the seizure vide seizure memo
(exhibit-4) which is dated 23.05.2014. Therefore, it is certain
that the date of the incident narrated by Kailash Chettri’s
(P.W.13) is also 23.05.2014. The said seizure memo (exhibit-4)
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
records the serial numbers of the 9 counterfeit currency-notes
of ₹500/- denomination seized from Kailash Chettri (P.W.13).
Although there is some discrepancy as pointed out by Ms. Gita
Bista on how the seizure of these 9 currency-notes was
effected due to the fact that the said seizure memo (exhibit-4)
records the name of Kailash Chettri (P.W.13) as the person
from whom the 9 currency-notes of
₹500/-
denomination
were seized it is however clarified by Kailash Chettri (P.W.13)
that the police from Makha police outpost who visited Ralap
told him and other shopkeepers to bring the forged currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination tendered by the Appellant to
Singtam police station and accordingly he along with other
shopkeepers went to Singtam police station and handed over
the counterfeit currency-notes received by the shopkeepers to
a police officer who duly prepared a seizure memo. The fact
that Kailash Chettri (P.W.13) also identified the currency-note
of ₹500/- denomination bearing serial number 7NV979471
which had been seized by the Singtam police on 23.05.2014 at
the Singtam police station in connection with the same case
and which currency-note was examined by Dhurba Chettri
(P.W.14) Analyst-cum-Assistant Chemical Examiner and found
to be counterfeit convincingly proves that the Appellant had
used counterfeit currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination in her
possession to dupe other shopkeepers as well.
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
34. The deposition of Anu Rana (P.W.3) clearly establishes
the identity of the Appellant as the person who came to her
ration shop at Singbel on 23.05.2014 at around 12:30 p.m.,
tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination, purchased
ten packets of Mimi noodles worth ₹50/- and took ₹450/- from
her as change and drove towards Makha. However, she did not
identify the said currency-note of ₹500/- denomination which
according to her she along with other shopkeepers deposited at
the Singtam police station.
35. Phul Maya Neopaney (P.W.6) is also a resident of Singbel
and owns a vegetable shop. She also identified the Appellant.
As per her deposition in May, 2014 at around 12.10 p.m. the
Appellant had come to her shop and purchased tomatoes
worth ₹10/- and cucumber worth ₹20/-. The Appellant
tendered currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination and Phul
Maya Neopaney (P.W.6) returned ₹470/- to the Appellant. After
the Appellant left her shop Phul Maya Neopaney (P.W.6) came
to know that the Appellant had used fake currency-notes in
other shops as well. When she checked the currency-note of
₹500/- denomination tendered to her by the Appellant she
found that it was counterfeit too. She also went with other
villagers to Singtam police station and handed over the same
to the police there and returned home. However, she also did
not identify the said currency-note of ₹500/- denomination but
was absolutely certain that she along with other shopkeepers
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
had deposited the said currency-note at the Singtam police
station.
36. Tek
Nath
Sharma
(P.W.11) a
resident of
Kokolay
identified the Appellant in Court. His deposition has proved
that on 23.05.2014 the Appellant had come to his shop after
alighting from a taxi, purchased three dozen bananas worth
₹30/- per dozen and other eatables worth ₹10/-, tendered
currency-note of ₹500/- denomination and was given a sum of
₹400/- by him as change. Tek Nath Sharma (P.W.11) also
deposed that he had surrendered the said currency-note of
₹500/- denomination at the Singtam police station. However,
he also did not identify the currency-notes of ₹500/denomination which he had deposited.
37. Chandra Kala Adhikari (P.W.5) is the wife of Prem Prasad
Adhikari (P.W.7) the Panchayat who runs a Provision shop at
Tumin busty which is also near Singbel. She identified the
Appellant in Court as the person she had seen on the date of
the incident. She does not remember the exact date but in
May, 2014 at around 1 to 2 p.m. the Appellant alighted from
the car and came to her shop asked for Mimi noodles,
purchased ten packets of Mimi noodles, tendered currencynote of ₹500/- denomination and took away ₹450/- as change
given by her. On being asked by Prem Prasad Adhikari (P.W.7),
her husband, whether two persons had visited their shop and
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination, Chandra Kala
Adhikari (P.W.5) confirmed the same after which Prem Prasad
Adhikari (P.W.7) took away the said currency-note and went
after the Accused persons. However, Prem Prasad Adhikari
(P.W.7) did not elucidate further as to what he did with the
said currency-note of ₹500/- denomination.
38. Sub Inspector (SI) Tshering Doma Bhutia (P.W.16) the
Investigating Officer has deposed that the Appellant along with
her husband were brought to Singtam police station by the
local people and the police of Makha police outpost. This fact
has been clearly proved by the prosecution with the evidence of
the prosecution witnesses-Narad Nepal (P.W.1) Churamani
Bhattarai (P.W.2) Prem Prasad Adhikari (P.W.7) and Manoj
Pradhan (P.W.8). The Investigating Officer (P.W. 16) deposed
that after the Appellant and her husband were brought to
Singtam police station they were arrested by her and later she
had seized 9 numbers of suspected fake currency-notes of
₹500/- denomination which the Appellant and her husband
had tendered to different shopkeepers after purchasing some
items from them through seizure memo (exhibit-4).
39. The rough sketch map (exhibit-8) prepared by the
Investigating Officer reflects that Ralap, Singbel and Tumin are
adjacent villages.
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
40.
Anu Rana (P.W.3) of Singbel, Tek Nath Sharma (P.W.11)
of Kokolay and Chandra Kala Adhikari (P.W.5) of Tumin
although identified the Appellant as the person who had
tendered the currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination at their
respective shops could not identify the specific currency-notes
in Court. Ms. Gita Bista would submit that this was a major
discrepancy and therefore, the prosecution had failed to
establish the mens rea. In every criminal case it is the
prosecution who alleges the criminality and thus it is
incumbent upon the prosecution to establish every ingredient
of the offence alleged. While examining the evidence produced
in the Court must necessarily seek assurance that the facts
emanating from the evidence produced cogently proves the
offence. Scientific precision cannot be expected of the evidence
given by rustic villagers. There are bound to be minor
discrepancies.
Although some of the prosecution witnesses
have not identified the specific currency-notes which were
tendered by the Appellant at their respective shops at Singbel,
Kokolay and Tumin it is unequivocally certain that the said
currency-notes were definitely amongst the 9 currency-notes of
₹500/- denomination seized by the Singtam police on the date
of the incident i.e. 23.05.2014 after the arrest of the Appellant
and her husband when the villagers who had been duped by
the Appellant i.e. Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10) of Ralap, Ran
Maya Rai (P.W.12) of Ralap, Kailash Chettri (P.W.13) of Ralap,
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Anu Rana (P.W.3) of Singbel, Phul Maya Neopaney (P.W.6) of
Singbel, Tek Nath Sharma (P.W.11) of Kokolay had gone and
deposited the currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination tendered
by the Appellant to the aforesaid prosecution witnesses of
different adjacent villages on the same day i.e. 23.05.2014. The
fact that each of the said 9 currency-notes of ₹500/denomination were proved to be counterfeit is reassuring since
if any one or more of the said 9 currency-notes were found
genuine It may have been difficult to trace the particular
currency-note to the particular shopkeeper to whom it was
tendered. The names of 9 persons with the serial numbers of
the currency-notes are recorded in seizure memo (exhibit-4)
dated 23.05.2014. The prosecution witnesses named above are
also amongst them. The evidence of the Investigating Officer
(P.W.16), Kailash Chettri (P.W.13) and the said prosecution
witnesses cogently assures this Court with absolute certainty
that each of the said currency-notes tendered by the Appellant
at various shops were amongst the said 9 currency-notes of
₹500/- denomination deposited by the prosecution witnesses
named above at the Singtam police station on 23.05.2014. The
9 currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination were also sent for
forensic examination and found to be counterfeit. The evidence
of Dhurba Chettri (P.W.14) Analyst-cum-Assistant Chemical
Examiner, along with his opinion (exhibit-6) clearly establishes
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
that the said 9-currency notes of Rs.500/- denomination were
counterfeit.
41. The deposition of Narad Nepal (P.W.1), Prem Prasad
Adhikari (P.W.7) and Churamani Bhattarai (P.W.2) have proved
that the Appellant and her husband were apprehended at
Samdong on 23.05.2015 after they had received information
that two persons were using counterfeit currency-notes. The
said prosecution witnesses also proved that after apprehending
the Appellant and her husband they informed the Makha
police outpost pursuant to which police personnel arrived and
took them to Singtam police station where Narad Nepal (P.W.1)
lodged the FIR and the investigation commenced. Thereafter,
on 23.05.2014 itself at the Singtam police station the
Appellant was searched and 42 currency-notes of ₹500/denomination were recovered and seized from her. The police
also seized 9 currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination from one
Kailash Chettri (P.W.13).
These 9 currency-notes of ₹500/-
denomination were deposited by the shopkeepers who were
duped by the Appellant on 23.05.2014. All the 51 currencynotes of ₹500/- denomination seized on 23.05.2014 were
found to be counterfeit by Dhruba Chettri, (P.W.14) Analystcum-Assistant Chemical Examiner. Manoj Pradhan (P.W.8)
identified the Appellant in Court as the person who was
apprehended by the villagers on 23.05.2014 at around 1.00
p.m. from Samdong and taken to Singtam police station where
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
he along with Narad Nepal (P.W.1) stood as witness to the
seizure of all the 51 currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination.
Sujata Pradhan (P.W.4) of Tumin, wife of Manoj Pradhan
(P.W.8) and who was also duped by the Appellant by tendering
currency-note of ₹500/- denomination and purchasing ten
Mimi noodles and taking ₹450/- as change also identified the
Appellant in Court. Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10) has not
only identified the Appellant as the one who came to her
provision shop at Ralap, purchased ten packets of Mimi
noodles, tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination and
took back ₹450/- as change but also identified the same
currency-note
of
₹500/-
denomination
tendered
by
the
Appellant. Anu Rana (P.W.3) from Singbel also identified the
Appellant as the person who came to her ration shop on
23.05.2014, tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination
purchased ten packets of Mimi noodles and took ₹450/- as
change from her. Similarly, Phul Maya Neopaney (P.W.6) from
Singbel also identified the Appellant as the person who came
to her shop sometime in May, 2014, purchased vegetables
worth ₹30/-, tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination
and took back ₹470/- as change. Tek Nath Sharma (P.W.11) of
Kokolay identified the Appellant
as the person who on
23.05.2014 had come to his shop, purchased three dozen
bananas worth ₹30/- and other eatables worth ₹10/-,
tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination and took back
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
₹400/- as change. Chandra Kala Adhikari (P.W.5) of Tumin
busty also identified the Appellant as the one who in May,
2014 had come to her shop, purchased ten packets of Mimi
noodles, tendered currency-note of ₹500/- denomination and
took back ₹450/- as change.
42. The seizure witnesses Narad Nepal (P.W.1) has identified
the Appellant in Court as the same person from whom the
police seized 42 currency-notes of ₹500/- denomination on
23.05.2014. Narad Nepal (P.W.1), Churamani Bhattarai (P.W.2)
and Prem Prasad Adhikari (P.W.7) who followed the Appellant
and her husband on 23.05.2014 on being informed about
them using counterfeit currency-notes and apprehending them
at Samdong have also identified the Appellant as the same
person. The shop owners and villagers viz. Anu Rana (P.W.3)
and Phul Maya Neopaney (P.W.6) both from Singbel, Sujata
Pradhan (P.W.4), Chandra Kala Adhikari (P.W.5) both from
Tumin, Sachita Nanda Darjee (P.W.10) from Ralap and Tek
Nath Sharma (P.W.11) from Kokolay also identified the
Appellant as the one who had duped them by tendering
counterfeit currency-note of ₹500/- denomination on the date
of the incident.
43. The modus operandi of the Appellant is absolutely clear
from
the
Appellant
deposition
had
of
the
counterfeit
prosecution
witnesses. The
currency-notes
of
₹500/-
Crl. A. No. 25 of 2016
Santa Maya Rai vs. State of Sikkim
denomination in her possession, she had knowledge that the
said currency-notes were counterfeit. The Appellant intended
to use the said counterfeit currency-notes as genuine. The
Appellant used the said counterfeit currency-notes as genuine
at
different
shops
knowing
that
the
said
notes
were
counterfeit. The prosecution has established mens rea a vital
ingredient of both the offences under Section 489B and 489C
IPC. All the ingredients of the said offences have been cogently
established by the prosecution.
44. This Court is thus of the view that that impugned
judgment dated 05.08.2016 and order of sentence dated
09.08.2016 call for no interference. The order on sentence
dated 09.08.2016 passed by the Learned Sessions Judge
stands confirmed. The Appeal is dismissed. The Appellant is on
bail. The bail bonds are forfeited. The Appellant shall be
arrested and produced before the Sessions Court, East Sikkim
at Gangtok to serve out her sentence.
45. Urgent certified photocopy of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the Learned Counsels for the parties upon
compliance of all formalities.
Sd/-
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
10.05.2018
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
to/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review