Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:638
Serial No.16 & 17
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 494 of 2022
Date of Order :15.07.2024
Smti. Sankori Bala Shill,
Wife of Shri. Dulal Ch Shill,
Resident of Village Kalapani Part-III,
P.O.- Bholarbhita, P.S. Phulbari,
West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
State of Meghalaya represented by the
Chief Secretary.
2.
State Project Director SEMAN-SSA
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
3.
District Mission Coordinator, SSA,
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
4.
Joint District Mission Coordinator,
SSA, Dadenggre,
West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
5.
The School Managing Committee of the
Kaimbatapara J.B. Upgraded SSA,
Upper Primary School,
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya,
Represented by its Secretary.
6.
Shri. Hiralal Rabha,
Head Teacher of Kaimbatapara J.B. Upgraded SSA,
U.P. School, District West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:638
7.
Smti. Nabami Rabha (Hindi Teacher)
Wife of Shri. Hiralal Rabha,
Resident of Chibinang, Bazar, P.O-Chibinang,
P.S. Phulbari, District-West Garo Hills,
Meghalaya.
…Respondents
AND
WP(C). No. 526 of 2022
___________________________________________________________
Smti. Sankori Bala Shill,
Wife of Shri. Dulal Ch Shill,
Resident of Village Kalapani Part-III,
P.O.- Bholarbhita, P.S. Phulbari,
West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
State of Meghalaya represented by the
Chief Secretary.
2.
State Project Director SEMAN-SSA
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
3.
District Mission Coordinator, SSA,
West Garo Hills, Tura, Meghalaya.
4.
Joint District Mission Coordinator,
SSA, Dadenggre,
West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
5.
The School Managing Committee of the
Kaimbatapara J.B. Upgraded SSA,
Upper Primary School,
2024:MLHC:638
6.
Shri. Hiralal Rabha,
Head Teacher of Kaimbatapara J.B. Upgraded SSA,
U.P. School, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
…Respondents
___________________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. S.K.Hassan, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr. GA and
Mr. H.Abraham, GAfor R 1-4.
Mr. S.A.Shiekh, Adv. for R 5-7.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
These two writ petitions which have been preferred by the same writ
petitioner and on a continuing cause of action are being disposed of by this
common judgment and order.
2.
In WP(C). No. 494 of 2022, the prayer of the writ petition is for
consideration of the writ petitioner as one of the SSA supported sanctioned
teachers as per the resolution of the Managing Committee dated 30-033
2024:MLHC:638
2010, and for a further direction for release of monthly salaries of the
petitioner pending from June 2017 till date.
3.
In WP(C). No. 526 of 2022, the prayer of the writ petitioner is for
quashing of the impugned cancellation order dated 25-01-2019, whereby
the petitioner’s approval order dated 25-01-2017 was cancelled by the
respondent authorities without affording an opportunity of hearing.
4.
Before adverting further into the facts, it is noted that this matter
concerning the appointment and claim of the writ petitioner was already
before this Court in an earlier round of litigation in WP(C). No. 45 of
2019, wherein this Court had disposed of the same by order dated 03-082022, granting liberty to the petitioner to challenge the inquiry report
which had been directed to be gone into by order dated 10-05-2022. For
the sake of convenience, both the earlier orders passed by this Court in this
regard are reproduced herein below:
Serial No. 30
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 45 of 2019
Smti. Sankori Bala Shill
Ors.
Coram:
Date of Order: 10.05.2022
Vs. State of Meghalaya &
2024:MLHC:638
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. M.F. Qureshi, Adv.
For the Respondent(s) :Mr. H. Abraham, GA (For R 1-5)
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, Adv. (For R 6).
1.
After hearing the matter at some length,
the status of service of the petitioner cannot be
discerned by the Court from the documents that are
before it. Reference to the affidavit filed by the State
reflects that at Annexure-4 thereof, a letter under
Memo No. Jt. DMC-D/SSA/MISC/H-COURT/2019/27
dated 29th April, 2019, shows that the Joint District
Mission Coordinator SSA, Dadenggre, West Garo Hills
has confirmed that the petitioner is an SSA supported
Contractual Teacher working at Kaimbatapara JB SSA
U.P School.
2.
This letter appears to be in contradiction
to
letter
under
Memo
No.
Jt.
DMCD/SSA/Cancel/2019/225 dated Dadenggre, the 25th Jan
2019 (at Annexure-A of the additional affidavit of the
respondent No.6), which shows the cancellation of
approval of the petitioner as Assistant Teacher of the
said school.
3.
Submissions has been forwarded both by
the petitioner and the respondent No. 6 which cannot
be reconciled with the documents that have been
produced.
4.
Accordingly, the State Project Director,
SSA (respondent No. 2) is directed to initiate an
enquiry and to apprise this Court, as to the exact
status of the service of the petitioner as on April, 2019,
inasmuch as, the letters of the Joint District Mission
Coordinator SSA, Dadenggre, West Garo Hills
appears to be confusing. The said enquiry is to be
conducted independently by the respondent No. 2 and
2024:MLHC:638
report to be furnished to this Court within 4(four)
weeks hereafter.
5.
Copy of the order to be given to the
learned GA to inform to the respondent No. 2 for
compliance.
List this matter on 13th June, 2022.
6.
Sd/Judge
Meghalaya
10.05.2022
“D.Thabah-PS”
Serial No. 22
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 45 of 2019
Date of Order: 03.08.2022
Smti Sankori Bala Shill Vs. State of Meghalaya &Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. M.F. Qureshi, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:Mr. H. Abraham, GA (For
R 1-5)
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, Adv. (For R
6)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Yes/No
Law journals etc:
2024:MLHC:638
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
(ORAL)
1.
Mr. M.F. Qureshi, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits on instructions that he may be
allowed to withdraw this writ petition with liberty to
challenge the enquiry report, which is a new cause of
action in the matter.
2.
Prayer is allowed, accordingly the matter
stands closed on withdrawal, with liberty as prayed.
Sd/JUDGE
Meghalaya
03.08.2022
“V. Lyndem-PS”
5.
Mr. S.K.Hassan, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
the petitioner is a founder teacher who had been duly appointed by the
Managing Committee in 2010, and by the illegal actions of the
respondents, particularly the Managing Committee, has been divested of
her post. He further submits that though this Court had directed for an
enquiry to be gone into, the inquiry report and findings arrived at, are
contradictory to the actual facts, and further the materials placed and the
case of the writ petitioner was not considered in the correct perspective. It
is further submitted that the petitioner was never informed about the
2024:MLHC:638
cancellation of the approval and as such, even on the ground of violation of
the principles of natural justice, the matter deserves a fresh inquiry to be
gone into by the respondents. He therefore, prays that the inquiry report be
set aside and directions be issued to institute a fresh inquiry by affording
full opportunity to the petitioner to present her case.
6.
Mr. H.Abraham, learned GA together with Mr. A.H.Kharwanlang,
learned Addl. Sr. GA appearing for the State respondents No. 1-4 in both
the writ petitions have submitted that nothing is left for consideration,
inasmuch as, pursuant to the orders of this Court, a detailed inquiry had
been gone into by the respondent No. 2, wherein findings have been
arrived at, establishing the fact that the writ petitioner is not a teacher
appointed in a sanctioned post, but is purely a teacher appointed by the
Managing Committee.
7.
Mr. S.A.Sheikh, learned counsel appearing for the private
respondents No. 5, 6 & 7 in both the matters, apart from endorsing the
submission of the learned GA, has submitted that it is not a fact that the
cancellation of the approval was
not to the knowledge of the writ
petitioner, inasmuch as, in WP(C). No. 45 of 2019, the same was made
known and the same was also considered thereafter in the inquiry, wherein
the petitioner was given adequate opportunity of hearing. He further
2024:MLHC:638
submits that the writ petition having no merit in view of the inquiry, the
same is liable to be dismissed.
8.
Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties, it is noted that as
observed earlier, the matter had appeared before this Court and the relevant
orders that have been reproduced in para 4 above, show that on the
contentions of the writ petitioner, the direction had been issued for
conducting the inquiry. The inquiry report which is appended to the writ
petition, reflects that the writ petitioner apart from other concerned
officials, had been duly examined. The aspect of the cancellation of the
approval has also been dealt with by the respondent No. 2, and
observations and findings in the inquiry have been generated, which show
that the status of the writ petitioner, is of an additional teacher in a nonsanctioned post on being appointed by the Managing Committee
Kaimbatapara SSA UPS. The inquiry report showing the fact that the
petitioner had been duly heard, apart from the statement of the District
Mission Coordinator and the observations and findings are reproduced
herein below:
“OFFICE OF THE STATE EDUCATION Phone No.0364-2502315/
2226062
MISSION AUTHORITY
Tele Fax: 0364-2225356/
2226062
MEGHALAYA ::: SHILLONG
E.mail:
meghalayassaplanning&gmail.co
m
Kennelworth Road,
Laitumkhrah,
Shillong – 793003.
2024:MLHC:638
Meghalaya
Inquiry Report conducted on the 6th June, 2022 in the O/O
The Addl. Director of School Education & Literacy, Tura,
West Garo Hills District in connection with the order of the
Hon’ble High Court of Meghalaya in WP(C). No. 45 of 2019
filed by Smti. Sankora Bala Shill, Asst. Teacher,
Kaimbatapara JB SSA Upper Primary School Vrs State of
Meghalaya & Others.
………….
1. Introduction In pursuance to the Order of the
Hon’ble High Court of Meghalaya Dated 10.5.2022 in
Writ Petition No. WP(C) No. 45 of 2019, I have
conducted an inquiry into the appointment of teachers
at Kaimbatapara JB SSA Upper Primary School.
For the purpose of my inquiry a notice Dated
11.5.2022 was issued to all Respondents including the
Petitioner to appear before me and to attend a hearing
on the 6th June, 2022 at the O/O Addl. Director of
School Education & Literacy, Tura from 11.00 am
onwards including submission of documents if any in
support of the claims and counter claims. The list of
officials and parties concerned present during the
Inquiry is enclosed at Annexure –I.
2. Proceedings of the Inquiry – At the outset of the
Inquiry, I have explained the Order of the Hon’ble
High Court of Meghalaya Dated 10.05.2022 to all the
officials and parties present during the Inquiry
pertaining to 2(two) documents filed by the Petitioner
and the Respondent before the Hon’ble High Court of
Meghalaya which was issued by the Jt. DMC (SSA),
Dadenggre. 1. Order Dated 29/4/2022 and 2. Order
Dated 25/1/2019 respectively which are contradictory
to each other. Further, in order to get a clear
perspective on the matter related with the two
documents referred above, all the officials/respondents
were asked to give their views, comments and
statements to be recorded to find out the clear picture
and position of the case arising out of the two
documents mentioned above. I have also recorded the
2024:MLHC:638
statements of officers and other respondents including
the Petitioner.
(1) Statement of Shri. Rod Tenang A Sangma, District
Mission Coordinator (SSA), West Garo Hills District,
Tura – Respondent No. 3 –
The District Mission Coordinator (DMC) SSA, West
Garo Hills District in his submission in the Inquiry
state thatKaimbatapara JB SSA Upper Primary School was
brought under SSA support Vide Letter No.
SSA/WGH/UpgradationLPS-UPS/2009-10/3277 Dated
11.2.2010 with (1) Shri. Hiralal Rabha, (2) Shri. Fozial
Hoque and (3) Smti. Nabami Rabha. The above
teachers were deputed to undergo 15(fifteen) days
Induction training before resuming their service in
their school. Their salary also was paid and
transferred to the Bank account of the school.
He stated that the dispute in Kaimbatapara JB SSA
School started with the approval of one teacher Smti.
Sankori Bala Shill (Petitioner) as Social Study teacher
by the then Jt. District Mission Coordinator (SSA) ,
Dadanggre (Shri. Thomas S. Sangma) Vide Order Dt.
25.1.2017 basing on the resolution of the School
Managing Committee of the school Dt. 21.4.2017.
However, as per RTI information Dt. 4.1.2019
furnished by the SMC of Kaimbatapara JB SSA UPS
revealed that there was no such resolution passed by
the above SMC considering the Petitioner as Social
study teacher. Thus the Jt. DMC (SSA), Dadenggre
(Shri. Thomas S. Sangma) cancelled the said approval
above (Dt. 25.1.2017) Vide Order Dt. 25.1.2019 citing
forgery in obtaining approval by the Petitioner. The
District Mission Coordinator (SSA) further revealed
that as per record, the Petitioner was appointed as
MIL teacher.
He also stated that the inclusion of the Petitioner as
sanctioned teacher in TIMS (Teacher Information
Management System) Vide Order Dt. 30.08.2018 was
2024:MLHC:638
based on the approval Dt. 25.1.2017 issued by the then
Jt. DMC (SSA) Dadenggre (Shri. Thomas S. Sangma)
which was later cancelled by the same Officer. He also
further stated that compilation of data under TIMS is
yet to be finalized and approved by the Dept/Govt. for
official reference.
Further, he also stated that the approval Orders issued
provisionally by the different Jt. District Mission
Coordinator (SSA) Dadenggre located at the SubDivision are not valid as per SSA norms as all official
sanctions are issued from the O/O The District Mission
Coordinator (SSA) who is the District Head and
authorized officer in matter of sanctioning of various
Grants/Appointment and other administrative orders.
Then he also confirmed that the data of all schools in
the state are being compiled every year known as
UDISE (Unified District Information of School
Education) and the name of Smti. Sankori Bala Shill
(Petitioner) does not appear as sanctioned teacher or
SSA supported teacher but rather as SMC appointed
teacher.
The Statement of the District Mission Coordinator
(SSA), West Garo Hills District, Tura is enclosed as
ANNEXURE II.
(2) Statement of Shri. Rajen K.Hajong I/C Jt. District
Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadanggre Sub-Division,
West Garo Hills District – Respondent No. 4.
I have also recorded the statement of Jt. District
Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadanggre who recently
took charge in the said Sub-Division.
(1) He said that as per records available, the approval of
appointment of Smti. Sankori Bala Shill was issued
Vide Order Dt. 25.1.2017 based on the resolution of the
SMC of Kaimbatapara JB SSA School Dt. 21.4.2016.
However, as per RTI information sought by Smti.
Nabami Rabha related with the resolution Dt.
21.4.2016, it revealed that no such record of copy of
2024:MLHC:638
meeting resolution No. 2 has been taken by the SMC of
Kaimbatapara JB SSA School. Hence, the then Jt.
District Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadanggre (Shri.
Thomas S Sangma) cancelled the approval Vide Order
Dt. 25.1.2019.
(2) Further he also stated that the then Jt. District Mission
Coordinator (SSA), Dadanggre (Smti. Ella Begum
Lasker) has also approved the appointment of teachers
vide Memo. No. Jt. DMC-D/SSA/Appt/Tr/2017/290-93
dated 26/07/2017 based on the resolution No. 2 dated
01/02/2010 which was recorded in the issue register.
The above order is enclosed as Annexure-III. The said
Jt. DMC above has also reinstated the service of Smti.
Sankori Bala Shill Vide Memo No. J.TDMCD/SSA/Reinstate/Order/2019 dated 07/03/2019. After
the above teacher was terminated by the SMC vide
order dated 26/02/2019. However, he stated that the
reinstatement order dated 07/03/2019 was not recorded
in the issue register of the office.
(3) In view of the above facts, he stated that the claim of
the Petitioner as sanctioned teacher under SSA is
baseless.
The Statement of the Jt. District Mission Coordinator
(SSA), Dadenggre Sub-Division, West Garo Hills
District, is enclosed as ANNEXURE IV.
(3) Statement of Shri. Emelious D. Sangma, SEO &
Block
Mission Coordinator (SSA), Selsella C &
RD Block, West Garo Hills District Respondent No. 5(1) As per records available in his office, Smti. Sankori
Bala Shill (Petitioner) was approved as Social study
teacher without the knowledge and resolution of the
SMC of Kaimbatapara JB SSA School.
(2)Smti. Sankori Bala Shill was not appointed in the
sanctioned post by the Managing Committee of the
School.
The Statement of the Block Mission Coordinator (SSA),
Selsella is enclosed as ANNEXURE V.
2024:MLHC:638
(4) Statement of Shri. Hiralal Rabha, Headmaster
Cum Ex-Officio Convener, Managing Committee,
Kaimbatapara JB SSA Upper Primary School.
Respondent No. 6.
The Headmaster Cum Ex-Officio member, Managing
Committee, Kaimbatapara JB SSA Upper Primary
School in his statement submits the following facts
related with matters on the appointment of teachers in
the said school as given below:(1) In his statement, he stated that when the school was
brought under SSA in the year 2010, four teachers
were appointed Viz : 1. Shri. Abu Hussain as
Headmaster (sanctioned post) who later left the
school, (2) Smti. Nabami Rabha as Asst. Teacher
(sanctioned post) (3) Shri. Fozial Hoque as Science
Teacher (sanctioned post) and (4) Smti. Sankori
Bala Shill as Addl. Teacher (Non-sanctioned post).
The proceedings dated 30.3.2010 is enclosed as
ANNEXURE VI.
(2) That he (Shri. Hiralal Rabha) was appointed as
Headmaster in place of Shri. Abu Hussain who left
the school. He also stated that Smti. Sankori Bala
Shill was not appointed in a sanctioned post but as
Addl. Teacher and her salary was paid by the
Managing Committee of the school. In support of
his claim he furnished the contract appointment
issued by the District Mission Coordinator (DMC)
SSA, West Garo Hills District consisting of the
teachers mentioned in Para (1) above and the
Acquittance Roll Register for the month of April &
May, 2010. The copies of appointment orders are
enclosed as ANNEXURE VII, VIII, & IX, and the
Pay Register is enclosed at Annexure X & XI
respectively.
(3) He also stated that the teachers who were appointed
in a sanctioned post have also attended the
Induction Training conducted by the Block Mission
Coordinator (SSA) during the year 2010. Smti.
2024:MLHC:638
Sankori Bala Shill did not undergone the training as
she was not appointed in a sanctioned post.
(4) He further submitted that the then Jt. District
Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadenggre (Smti. Ella
Begum Lasker) Vide Order Dt. 26.7.2017 had
approved the following teachers:(1) Shri. Hiralal Rabha, (2) Smti. Nabami Rabha, (3)
Shri. Fozial Hoque. He also stated that Smti.
Sankori Bala Shill was not appointed in a
sanctioned post whereas (Smti. Ella Begum Lasker)
has also issued one letter Dt. 29.4.2019 stating that
Smti. Sankori Bala Shill is a SSA supported
contractual teacher working at Kaimbatapara JB
SSA Upper Primary School which is contradictory.
The Order Dt. 26.7.2017 and Dt. 29.4.2019 are
enclosed as ANNEXURE XII & XIII respectively.
(5)He then went on to state that the then I/C Jt. DMC
(SSA), Dadenggre (Shri. Thomas S Sangma) has issued
provisional order stating that Smti. Sankori Bala Shill
is a Social study teacher Vide Order Dt. 25.1.2017
which was later cancelled by the same Officer above
due to forgery and fake resolution of the SMC of
Kaimbatapara JB SSA Upper Primary School which
Smti. Sankori Bala Shill produced and was detected by
filing RTI application by Smti. Nabami Rabha and later
cancelled by the same Officer Shri. Thomas S. Sangma.
(6)Lastly, he also submitted that the UDISE data also
indicates that Smti. Sankori Bala Shill is not a
sanctioned teacher.
The Statement of Shri. Hiralal Rabha, Headmaster
Cum Ex-Officio Convener, Managing Committee,
Kaimbatapara JB SSA UPS is enclosed as ANNEXURE
XIV.
(5) Statement of Smti. Sankori Bala Shill, Petitioner.
The Petitioner Smti. Sankori Bala Shill was also
present during the inquiry and she was given the
opportunity to submit her claim who made the
following statement:15
2024:MLHC:638
(1)In her statement, she stated that she has filed her
Petition in the Hon’ble High Court because she was
illegally removed from the sanctioned post and her
salary was not paid by the School Managing
Committee.
(2)She also stated that she was appointed in the
sanctioned post as a social study teacher in the year
2010 and have been continuously serving in the school
without any break till date. She alleged that the present
Headmaster, Shri. Hiralal Rabha has targeted her and
removed her in order to appoint his wife in her place.
Her salary was also stopped from April, 2019.
(3)Her appointment was provisionally approved by the
Jt. District Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadenggre but
was cancelled without following any official procedure
which is illegal. The whole matter was enquired by the
BRC and CRC and she was found to be a genuine
teacher but she was terminated by the Headmaster
without any show cause notice.
(4) After her appointment, she has undergone inservice training (not induction training) for a period of
10 days for which she has obtained a certificate which
shows that she was appointed in a sanctioned post.
(5) She also stated that her name was also included in
TIMS which indicates that she is an original
teacher and also submitted other documents for
scrutiny and verification.
(6)She then stated and made submission that after her
termination, she was re-instated in her post by the then
Jt. District Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadenggre
(Smti. Ella Begum Lasker) and since then she has been
attending school everyday but she was not allowed to
sign in the Attendance Register of Teachers by the
Headmaster. Therefore, she has maintained her own
Attendance Register duly certified by the then Jt. DMC,
Dadenggre (Smti. Ella Begum Lasker).
2024:MLHC:638
3.
Observations:
During the course of my
inquiry, I have observed that during the last few years,
maximum number of court cases under the Education
Dept. are from Dadenggre Sub-Division. The reason
for the disputes, claims and in counter claims is that
the school authorities of SSA schools under Dadenggre
Sub-Division has been appointing excess number of
teachers than the prescribed norms which are making
things complicated by producing/manufacturing
documents and official Orders which ultimately leads
to so many litigations.
In this connection, it may be worth mentioning
that particularly with this instant case, one
letter/direction was issued from the O/O The State
Project Director (SSA), Shillong Vide No.
MEGH/SEMAM-SSA/AO/CC/11/2019/55
Dated
18.3.2018 where many relevant issues were highlighted
for information and necessary action and compliance
by the concerned officials and SMCs. The said letter
above is enclosed as ANNEXURE XVI.
4.
Findings of the inquiry – I have examined the
following documents presented before me by the
officers of the District Mission Coordinator (SSA), Tura
and Jt. District Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadenggre
Sub-Division as well as the school authority
represented by the Headmaster including the Petitioner
:(i)
Order Dated 29/4/2019 and Dated
26.7.2017 approval order issued by the Jt.
District Mission Coordinator, Dadenggre
Sub-Division (Smti. Ella Begum Lasker)
(ii) Order Dated 25.1.2017 and Dated
25/1/2019 for approval and cancellation
issued by the Jt. District Mission
Coordinator, Dadenggre Sub-Division
(Shri. Thomas S. Sangma)
(iii) Proceeding of the Managing
Committee of Kaimbatapara JB SSA UPS
Dt. 30.1.2010,
2024:MLHC:638
(iv) Appointment orders of Shri. Abu
Hussain, Smti. Nabami Rabha and Shri.
Fozial Hoque issued by the District
Mission
Coordinator,
Tura
Dated
29.6.2010.
(v) Acquittance Register of the salary of
Teachers of Kaimbatapara JB SSA UPS
for the month of April & May, 2010.
I have also examined the statement
of Officers of the O/O The District Mission
Coordinator (SSA), Tura, Jt. District
Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadenggre
Sub-Division, Headmaster Cum Secretary
of the school including the Petitioner.
After examining all the different
aspects the case my findings from the
statements made before me and the
documents made available for verification
clearly indicates that :(1) The teachers who were appointed
and approved by the District Mission
Coordinator (SSA), West Garo Hills
District in the sanctioned post are:
(i)
(Shri. Abu Hussain) replaced
by Shri. Hiralal Rabha
(ii) Smti. Nabami Rabha
(iii) Shri. Fozial Hoque.
(2) The status of Smti. Sankori Bala
Shill (Petitioner) is an Addl. Teacher
(Non-sanctioned post) appointed by the
Managing Committee of Kaimbatapara JB
SSA UPS. The salary of the above teacher
is borne by the concerned Managing
Committee, Kaimbatapara JB SSA UPS.
(3) The approval and cancellation
order in respect of Smti. Sankori Bala Shill
(Petitioner) issued by the then Jt. District
Mission Coordinator (SSA), Dadenggre
Vide Letter Dt. 29.4.2019 issued by Smti.
Ella Begum Lasker and Dt. 25.1.2019
issued by Shri. Thomas S. Sangma
2024:MLHC:638
respectively which had led to the dispute
do not have any merit and not
maintainable as both of them are
subordinate officers who do not have any
authority to issue any such approval
orders.
(4) As for the claim made by Smti.
Sankori Bala Shill that her name has been
recorded in the TIMS (Teachers
Information and Management System)
cannot be construed that she is appointed
in the SSA sanctioned post as TIMS is only
at the stage of data collection on pilot
basis which is yet to be finalized by the
State Government.
(5)
As for her claim that her salary was
withheld from April 2019, it is the
responsibility of the SMC to pay the salary
of teachers (Non-sanctioned post) by the
concerned SMC. Therefore, finally my
finding is that the claim of Smti. Sankori
Bala Shill is not justified as she is not
appointed in the SSA sanctioned post. She
is purely appointed as Additional Teachers
(Non-sanctioned post) by the SMC.
Submitted for information of the
Hon’ble High Court of Meghalaya.
Sd/(Shri. A. Ch. Marak,
IAS)
Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Education Dept & State Project Director,
SEMAM-SSA, Shillong.”
9.
A perusal of the proceedings and report of the inquiry reflects that
there is no irregularity or any denial of opportunity of hearing to the writ
petitioner to vitiate the findings in any manner. There is also no allegation
2024:MLHC:638
that there were any procedural irregularities in the inquiry or any violation
of the Principles of natural justice.
10.
It is further observed by this Court that the appointment of the writ
petitioner on 04-03-2010, was on a consolidated pay by the Managing
Committee itself, and was to the post of an MIL teacher and not Social
Studies teacher as alleged by the writ petitioner. An examination of the
affidavit of the respondents No. 5, 6, & 7, wherein the records furnished by
the State respondents have been annexed also confirm the fact that the
petitioner is a teacher appointed by the Managing Committee.
11.
Though vehement submissions have been advanced by Mr.
S.K.Hassan, learned counsel for the petitioner for demanding a re-inquiry,
on the basis of the findings of the inquiry and discussions made herein
above, it is seen that adequate opportunity was afforded to the writ
petitioner and the factum of the alleged illegal approval and cancellation
have also been addressed. As such, the prayer for a re-inquiry does not
seem to have any merit.
12.
However, it is noted that as the teacher had been appointed by the
Managing Committee, the salary is to be borne by the said Managing
Committee and as such therefore, it is their responsibility to pay the writ
petitioner for whatever services she has rendered. Though it has been
submitted that the petitioner is still in service which has been disputed by
2024:MLHC:638
the respondents, the same being a matter of disputed facts, the Court is not
making any observation in this regard.
13.
The petitioner is at liberty to make her claim for whatever salary she
feels entitled before the Managing Committee, within a period of two
months hereafter, and the same be addressed by the Managing Committee
within a period of four weeks thereafter.
14.
Matter accordingly stands closed and disposed of.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2024.07.16 18:08:11 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review