Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP 41 of 2022
1. Sankar Sarkar, son of late Kalimohan Sarkar, Age-61
2. Dilip Sarkar, son of late Kalimohan Sarkar, Age-64
Both are resident of Bokafa, P.O. & P.S. Santir Bazar,
District- South Tripura,
3. Rina Das (Sarkar), wife of Sri Umesh Das, daughter of
late Kalimohan Sarkar, resident of West Jalefa,
P.O. & P.S. Sabroom, District- South Tripura, Age-47
4. Mina Sarkar, wife of Sri Asish Sarkar, daughter of late
Kalimohan Sarkar, resident of Damdama,
P.O. & P.S. Sabroom, District- South Tripura, Age-43
…………… Petitioner(s)
(2nd Party Claimants in NH (Ref) 01 of 2016)
Versus
1. Ranga Prava Sarkar, wife of late Rajmohan Sarkar
2. Hare Krishna Sarkar, son of late Rajmohan Sarkar
3. Mithun Sarkar, son of late Rajmohan Sarkar
4. Sajal Sarkar, son of late Rajmohan Sarkar
5. Satyajit Sarkar, son of late Rajmohan Sarkar
Sl No-2 to 5 are sons of late Raj Mohan Sarkar,
resident of East Bagafa, P.O. East Bagafa,
P.S. Santir Bazar, South Tripura
6. Manasa Sarkar (Patoyari), wife of Bimal Patoyari,
resident of Ashram Tilla, P.O. & P.S. Santir Bazar,
District- South Tripura
7. Swapna Sarkar (Mitra), wife of Dina Dayal Mitra,
Village & P.O. Nalua, P.S. Belonia, District- South Tripura
8. Swagata Sarkar (Dey), wife of Sri Sunil Dey, resident
of Dalubari, P.O. & P.S. Sabroom, District- South Tripura,
(1st Party Claimants in NH (Ref) 01 of 2016)
9. The Additional District Magistrate & Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia, Government of Tripura,
(Competent Authority under National Highway Act, 1956),
P.O. & P.S. Belonia, District- South Tripura.
10. The Sub Divisional Magistrate, Santir Bazar,
Government of Tripura, Office of the SDM, Santir Bazar,
P.O. & P.S. Santir Bazar, South Tripura.
.………….. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate
Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Debajit Biswas, Advocate
Date of hearing
:
05.02.2024.
Date of pronouncement
of Judgment and order :
08.02.2024
Whether fit for reporting:
No.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment and Order
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel, Mr. Kawsik Nath, learned
counsel and Mr. D. Sarkar learned counsel for the claimant-petitioners.
Also heard Mr. Debajit Biswas, learned counsel appearing for the
claimant-respondents.
[2]
The present petition has been filed for invoking the supervisory
jurisdiction
of
the
High
Court
to
quash/cancel
the
award
dated
07.05.2022 passed in NH(Ref)- 01 of 2016 by the learned District Judge,
South Tripura, Belonia and further to quash/cancel the Inquiry Report,
dated, 15.03.2022 issued by the Deputy Collector & Magistrate, Santir
Bazar, South Tripura District, which was forwarded by the ADM &
Collector
(competent
Authority)
South
Tripura,
vide
letter
dated,
19.03.2022.
[3]
It is the case of the claimant-petitioners that they are the sons
and daughters of late Kalimohan Sarkar, who was the original owner and
possessor of the total land measuring 0.330 acre under Khatian No.36,
Mouja- Santir Bazar, Tehsil-Santir Bazar, under old Dag No.3091 &
present Dag No.7431. Out of 0.330 acre, land measuring 0.260 acre was
acquired by the National Highway Authority and to that effect Declaration
No.F.NH-12037/86/2014/TR/SARDP-NE(Part),
dated,
01.01.2015
for
widening/double lining of NH-44, was issued by the competent authority.
Thereafter handing over & taking over of the acquired land was effected
from the legal heirs of late Kalimohan Sarkar, i.e., the present petitioners
herein. Thereafter, vide Notice of Award, dated, 30.05.2015, the
competent authority, i.e. the ADM & Collector, South Tripura, Belonia,
asked the predecessor of the petitioners, late Kalimohan Sarkar to appear
before him on 12.06.2015 for receiving the awarded amount regarding
acquisition of land.
[4]
It is contended in the
petition
that before
awarding the
compensation in favour of late Kalimohan Sarkar the competent authority
caused field inquiry, in respect to the interested persons in connection
with the acquired land and after inquiry being found the petitioners in
physical possession of the acquired land being the legal heirs of late
Kalimohan Sarkar, asked the petitioners for receiving the awarded
amount from the office of the competent authority, on 12.06.2015. The
said field inquiry was conducted as per Section 3 of the National Highway
Act and in terms of Section 3C of the NH Act, 1956, paper publication
was issued. As per the said notice dated, 30.05.2015, the petitioners
appeared before the office of the SDM, Santir Bazar on 12.06.2015 for
receiving the awarded money. At that time, the petitioners were came to
know that one Mithun Sarkar, i.e. respondent No.2 herein, filed an
objection on 09.06.2015 to the competent authority demanding release
the entire awarded amount in favour of the respondents No.1 to 8 herein.
On the basis of the objection raised by the respondent No.2, the SDM,
Santir Bazar did not release the awarded amount in favour of the
petitioners.
[5]
Thereafter, the respondents No.1 to 8 filed the writ petition, vide
WPC No.485 of 2015, praying for causing reference of the LA Case
No.25/STB/2015 to the learned Principal Civil Court (the District &
Sessions Judge, Belonia, South Tripura) in terms of Section 3H(4) of the
NH Act, 1956. This High Court after hearing both the parties, vide order
dated, 04.02.2016 disposed of the writ petition by directing the Addl.
District Magistrate & Collector, South Tripura to release the 50% of the
amount as awarded as the compensation to the present petitioners
herein, on proper identification and following all requirements of law and
it was further ordered that the remaining amount shall be deposited in
the Court of the learned Principal Civil Court (the District Judge, Belonia,
South Tripura) by the Competent Authority (the Addl. DM & Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia). It was further observed by this Court that the
release of the said amount would further be subject to outcome of the
reference.
[6]
In terms of the Order dated 04.02.2016 passed by the
Hon’ble High Court in WP(C) 485 of 2015, the ADM & Collector, South
Tripura, Belonia released the 50% of the awarded amount in favour of
the petitioners herein and rest 50% of the awarded amount was kept
withheld subject to outcome of the reference in terms of the Order, dated
04.02.2016 passed by this Court.
[7]
Thereafter, learned District & Sessions Judge, Belonia,
South Tripura, in terms of the reference, registered case vide No.
NH(Ref)-01 of 2016 and issued notice upon the parties to the LA Case
No.25/STB/2015 and the petitioners appeared before the learned court
and filed their claim statement as 2nd party claimants. The respondents
No.1 to 8 also filed their claim statement. Issues were framed by the
learned Court for deciding the lis involved in the case. Both the parties
adduced their evidence and subsequently, they were examined and
cross-examined by the respective parties. Witnesses were also examined
and cross-examined and documents were exhibited by both the parties.
[8]
Learned Court after
perusing all
the
documents and
evidence adduced by the parties, vide Order dated, 07.12.2019 asked for
a field inquiry by the ADM & Collector, South Tripura, i.e., the competent
authority for proper determination of the lis involved in the case and as a
result, the competent authority on 07.02.2020 through the SDM, Santir
Bazar, make a field inquiry and submitted report before the learned Trial
Court. Thereafter, the petitioners herein, submitted objection against the
said report before the learned Trial Court on the ground that at the time
of field inquiry, the petitioners were not noticed or called for to remain
present at the time of field inquiry. Upon hearing the parties to the
objection filed by the petitioners, the learned Trial Court, vide order
dated 18.07.2020, set aside the field inquiry report dated 07.02.2020
and asked for fresh inquiry report from the competent authority.
[9]
On the basis of the order dated 18.07.2020 passed by the
learned Trial Court, the competent authority caused fresh inquiry and
submitted report on 27.07.2021 which was forwarded by the competent
authority
to
the
learned
Court
on
16.08.2021.
Thereafter,
the
respondents No.1 to 8 filed their objection against the inquiry report
dated 16.08.2021, on the ground of inconsistency with the earlier report,
dated 07.02.2020 and, learned Trial Court vide order dated 08.02.2022
rejected the objection submitted by the private respondents No.1 to 8.
[10]
The private respondents No.1 to 8, challenging the order
dated 08.02.2022 of the learned Trial Court approached this Court by
filing CRP 10 of 2022. This Court, vide order dated, 08.03.2022, disposed
of the said CRP 10 of 2022 with the following observations:
“In view of the contradiction pointed out in the reports
dated 20.01.2020 and 18.07.2020, this Court feels that ends of
justice would be met if an opportunity of cross-examination of
the competent authority is given to the petitioners by the
learned Court below within a stipulated dated i.e. 14.03.2022
and the learned Court below shall also communicate the same
to the concerned authority to be present in the Court for crossexamination on the reports as stated above.
Further, it is made clear that since the suit pertains to
2016, prolonging the matter by way of any tactic, cannot be
appreciated. In view of the same, this Court feels that no
further adjournment would be granted on 14th March, 2022
itself, with regard to the examination of the concerned
authority i.e. the DCM, Santirbazar. It has been further clarified
that after hearing both sides, appropriate order be passed as
expeditiously as possible preferably within the stipulated dated
of 14th March, 2022. Registry is directed to furnish a copy of
this order to the learned counsel for the petitioners and also
dispatch copies to the DCM, Santirbazar, South Tripura and the
learned District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia, during the
course of the day.
Accordingly, the present petition stands disposed of.”
[11]
In terms of the order dated 08.03.2022 passed by this
Court in CRP 10 of 2022, the DCM, Santir Bazar, appeared before the
learned Trial Court to face cross examination and in the cross
examination, the DCM, Santir Bazar stated that the report submitted by
him on 27.07.2021 was erroneous and he wanted to clarify the mistake
committed by him. Thereafter, the learned Court, vide Order dated,
14.03.2022 gave another opportunity to the DCM, Santir Bazar to file a
fresh inquiry report before the learned Court and accordingly, the DCM,
Santir Bazar, submitted report on 15.03.2022, which was forwarded to
the learned Court by the ADM & Collector, South Tripura on 19.03.2022.
[12]
Thereafter, petitioners filed objection(s) regarding the field
report, and finally on perusal of evidence on record and upon hearing the
parties, learned Trial Court vide Award, dated 07.05.2022 passed in
NH(Ref)-01/2016,
declared
that
the
1st
party
claimants,
i.e.
the
respondents No.1 to 8 herein are entitled to get the remaining 50% of
the compensation out of total compensation amount since the 1 st party
claimants have been able to prove their right, title and possession over
the northern portion of the acquired land. In view of this, the learned
Court allowed the 1st party to withdraw the remaining part of the
awarded amount. The observation made by the learned Court on
07.05.2022 is as under:
“…….12. So, this court finds that, the first party-petitioners is
the owner and possessor of the acquired land of the northern
side as per exhibit-1 to 5 and exhibit-7 and also by the
corroborative evidence of CW-1 and exhibit-C-2/CW-1. Hence,
this court finds that the first party had right, title and
possession over the acquired land. Accordingly, first partypetitioners are entitled to remaining amount.
Accordingly, issue Nos.(I) and (II) are decided in favour
of the first party-petitioners.
AWARD
13. In the result, the The first party-petitioners are entitled
to remaining 50% amount of compensation out of the total
compensation amount since the first party-petitioners able to
prove their right, title and possession over the north portion of
the acquired land. Thus, the remaining part of the awarded
amount shall be released in favour of the first party-petitioners
being legal heirs of Late Raj Mohan Sarkar.
14. The case is decided accordingly and stands disposed
of…….”
[13]
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners herein preferred the
present CRP seeking following reliefs:
(i) Admit the instant petition;
(ii) Call for records;
(iii) Issue Rule upon the respondents;
(iv) After hearing, allow the instant petition preferred by the
petitioners herein by quashing and cancelling the Award,
dated, 07.05.2022 passed in NH (Ref)-01 of 2016 by the
learned District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia;
(v) Quash & cancel the Inquiry Report dated, 15.03.2022,
issued by the Deputy Collector & Magistrate, Santir Bazar,
South Tripura District, which was forwarded by the ADM &
Collector (Competent Authority) South Tripura, vide letter
dated, 19.03.2022 and to declare the said report is illegal, null
and void.
(vi) To pass an ad interim stay order, staying the operation of
the Award, dated, 07.05.2022, passed in NH (Ref)-01 of 2016
and release of the awarded amount in favour of the
respondents No.1 to 8, till disposal of instant petition……
[14]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners submits that the impugned award dated, 07.05.2022, passed
in
NH(Ref)-01/2016,
suffers
from
illegality,
impropriety
and
incorrectness. According to him, the impugned award is based on the
report which is ex-facie not sustainable. It is further submitted by Mr.
Roy Barman, learned senior counsel that the impugned award has been
passed absolutely relying on the basis of erroneous report, submitted by
the DCM, Santir Bazar on 15.03.2022, which suffers from serious laches
and inadmissible in evidence.
[15]
On the other hand, Mr. Debajit Biswas, learned counsel
appearing for the claimant-respondents contends that learned Court
below in case No. N.H. (Ref.) 01 of 2016 passed judgment in favour of
the respondents herein, based on the evidences brought on record and
the reports of field enquiry. He further contends that the finding of the
learned Trial Court was just, fair and proper and the same should not be
interfered with.
[16]
Having heard the learned counsel for the respective parties
and on perusal of record, it is evident that in compliance with the order
dated 08.03.2022 passed by this Court in CRP 10 of 2022, the DCM,
Santir Bazar, appeared before the learned Trial Court and faced cross
examination and in the cross examination he admitted that the report
submitted by him on 27.07.2021 was erroneous and he wanted to clarify
the mistake committed by him. Thereafter, the learned Court below, vide
Order dated, 14.03.2022 gave another opportunity to the DCM, Santir
Bazar to file a fresh inquiry report before the learned Court and
accordingly, on 15.03.2022, the DCM, Santir Bazar, submitted fresh
report, which was forwarded to the learned Court below by the ADM &
Collector, South Tripura on 19.03.2022 and the map/plan was also
system generated and was duly attested by the authority.
[17]
Since, the fresh field report has been obtained by cross-
examining the concerned DCM and on examination of all the relevant
records, the learned Court below passed the order in favour of the
claimant respondents i.e. respondents No.1 to 8, this Court feels that
there is no infirmity in the order and award passed by the learned Court
below on 07.05.2022. Thus, the present CRP filed by the petitioners is
liable to be dismissed. Accordingly, the present CRP is hereby dismissed
affirming the order of the Court below.
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall
also stand closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
signed by
SABYASACHI Digitally
SABYASACHI GHOSH
Date: 2024.02.09 17:23:57
GHOSH
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review