The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
04. 11.2022 has disposed of the appeals by suspending the Employees’ Pension (Amendment) Scheme, 2014 for a period of six months as indicated in para 23 which is reproduced hereinabove. Further the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also stipulated certain guidelines to be followed under Para-44 which has also been reproduced hereinabove.
9. In view of the same, the present writ appeals are accordingly disposed of. However, liberty is given to the effected parties in the event if they are aggrieved by any further proceedings, they are at liberty to avail remedies under law. Accordingly, writ appeals are allowed and disposed of. Sabyasachi B CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA. No.102 of 2020
Connected with
WA. No.103 of 2020 WA. No.104 of 2020 WA. No.105 of 2020 WA.
No.106 of 2020 WA. No.107 of 2020 WA. No.108 of 2020 WA. No.109
of 2020 WA. No.110 of 2020 WA. No.111 of 2020 WA. No.112 of 2020
WA. No.113 of 2020 WA. No.114 of 2020 WA. No.115 of 2020 WA.
No.116 of 2020 WA. No.117 of 2020 WA. No.118 of 2020 WA. No.119
of 2020 WA. No.120 of 2020 WA. No.121 of 2020 WA. No.122 of 2020
& WA. No.123 of 2020
In W.A.No.102 of 2020
Sanjoy Kumar Paul
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.103 of 2020
Smt. Sudipta Nath
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.104 of 2020
Shipra Malakar
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.105 of 2020
Sri Madan Deb
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.106 of 2020
Sri Rahim Debbarma
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.107 of 2020
Maman Singha Roy
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.108 of 2020
Arjun Shil
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.109 of 2020
Pradip Lodh
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.110 of 2020
Sri Subrata Sarkar
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.111 of 2020
Sri Debajit Chakraborty
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.112 of 2020
Gopal Debnath
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.113 of 2020
Alok Saha
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.114 of 2020
Pranab Majumder
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.115 of 2020
Sri Sudhansu Pal
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.116 of 2020
Nirmal Chandra Saha
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.117 of 2020
Dasarath Reang
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.118 of 2020
Benu Kumar Debbarma
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.119 of 2020
Pramod Lal Das
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.120 of 2020
Tapan Debnath
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.121 of 2020
Sri Debasish Sengupta
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.122 of 2020
Sri Achalmani Biswas
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
In W.A.No.123 of 2020
Sri Sashi Mohan Debbarma
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
The Union of India and Others
……….Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Sankar Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. P.K. Pal, Adv.
Mr. S. Baidhya, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, CGC.
Mr. P.K. Debnath, Adv.
Date of Hearing of
Judgment & Order
:
12.01.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES/NO
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order
[Chief Justice(Acting)]
Heard Mr. Sankar Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant as well as Mr. Biswanath Majumder, learned CGC appearing for the
respondents No.1 and 2 and Mr. P.K. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent No.3.
2.
All these writ petitions being W.A. No.103 of 2020, W.A. No.104
of 2020, W.A. No.105 of 2020, W.A. No.106 of 2020, W.A. No.107 of 2020,
W.A. No.108 of 2020, W.A. No.109 of 2020, W.A. No.110 of 2020, W.A. No.111
of 2020, W.A. No.112 of 2020, W.A. No.113 of 2020, W.A. No.114 of 2020,
W.A. No.115 of 2020, W.A. No.116 of 2020, W.A. No.117 of 2020, W.A. No.118
of 2020, W.A. No.119 of 2020, W.A. No.120 of 2020, W.A. No.121 of 2020,
W.A. No.122 of 2020 & W.A. No.123 of 2020 are combined for disposal by a
common judgment and order inasmuch as the basic facts in the present writ
appeals are identical in nature.
3.
The fact of the case is that the appellant entered into service as
clerical status on 02.09.1991 under the Managing Director Tripura Scheduled
Castes and Tripura Scheduled Tribes Co-operative Development Corporation
Limited covered by the Employees’ Provident Fund and Misc. Provisions Act,
1952 (hereinafter referred to as the EPF Act). The EPF enrolment number of
the appellant is NE/AGT/2202/19 under the EPF & Misc. Provision Act, 1952.
The appellant was also inducted to the EPF Pension Scheme, 1995 under the
same enrolment EPF number.
4.
The EPF was to be constituted by depositing an Employees’ Share
@ 12% of the Basic wages including Dearness Allowances. The Employer also
to contribute an identical amount which together would constitute Provident
Fund. The corpus of the pension fund was to be constituted by transferring
8.33% out of Employer’s Contribution under Section 6 of the Act on the basis
of maximum pensionable amount of Rs.6,500/- per month which had enhanced
upto Rs.15,000/- per month vide Amendment of Notification No.GSR 609(E)
dated 22.08.2014 came into effect on 01.09.2014.
5.
Under the said amendment, there is a provision that the
employees contribution towards the Pension Scheme beyond Rs.15,000/- shall
be on the basis of actual pay drawn by filing joint option (Employees and
Employers) within the cutoff date. Subsequently, the Hon’ble Kerala High Court
set aside the notification No.GSR 609(E) dated 22.08.2014 vide judgment and
order dated 12.10.2018 observing that there should not be a cut off date and
at any time joint option can be exercised and the employee under EPS will be
entitled to got their pension on the basis of their actual last pay drawn and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court also upheld the said judgment and order of Kerala High
Court vide judgment and order dated in SLP (Civil)Diary No.9610 of 2019.
Being similarly situated, the appellant preferred the writ petition before this
Hon’ble High Court and after hearing, the learned Single Judge vide judgment
and order dated 28.02.2020 dismissed the writ petition. Being aggrieved and
dissatisfied with the judgment and order dated 28.02.2020, the appellant has
preferred this writ appeal.
6.
Mr. Sankar Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted that the employer to contribute an identical amount
which together would constitute Provident Fund. The corpus of the pension
fund was to be constituted by transferring 8.33% out of Employer’s
Contribution under Section 6 of the Act on the basis of maximum pensionable
amount of Rs.6,500/- per month which had enhanced upto Rs.15,000/- per
month vide Amendment of Notification No.GSR 609(E) dated 22.08.2014 came
into effect on 01.09.2014. Under the said amendment, there is a provision that
the employees contribution towards the Pension Scheme beyond Rs.15,000/shall be on the basis of actual pay drawn by filing joint option (Employees and
Employers) within the cutoff date. Subsequently, the Hon’ble Kerala High Court
set aside the notification No.GSR 609(E) dated 22.08.2014 vide judgment and
order dated 12.10.2018 observing that there should not be a cut off date and
at any time joint option can be exercised and the employee under EPS will be
entitled to got their pension on the basis of their actual last pay drawn and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court also upheld the said judgment and order of Kerala High
Court vide judgment and order dated in SLP (Civil)Diary No.9610 of 2019.
7.
During the course of his submission, Mr. Deb, learned senior
counsel has referred the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated
04.11.2022 arising out of Special Leave Petition(C)Nos.8658-8659 of 2019. He
has referred to paras-23, 35 and 44 which reads as under :
“23. The first point on which argument has been made on
behalf of the appellants before us is that the aforesaid
amendment had been made in exercise of power
under Section 7 of the 1952 Act read with entry 10 of the III
Schedule of the Act. Thus, the legislative authorization is there
for modification of a scheme whether prospectively or
retrospectively. Moreover, our attention has been drawn to
paragraph 32 of the 1995 scheme, which stipulates :
“32. Valuation of the Employees' Pension Fund and review of
the rates of contributions and quantum of the pension and
other benefits.-
The Central Government shall have an annual valuation of the
Employees' Pension Fund made by a Valuer appointed by it:
Provided that it shall be open to the Central Government to
direct a valuation to be made at such other times s it may
consider necessary.
At any time, when the Employees' Pension Fund so permits,
the Central Government may alter the rate of contributions
payable under this Scheme or the scale of any benefit
admissible under this Scheme or the period for which such
benefit may be given.”
Entry 10 of the III Schedule to the Act, which refers to
matters for which provision may be made in the pension
scheme, provides:
“10. The scale of pension and pensionary
benefits and the conditions relating to grant of
such benefits to the employees.”
35. The requirement in the scheme for employee’s
contribution to the extent of 1.16 per cent for option
members, in our opinion, is illegal. There is nothing in the
1952 Act which requires payment to the pension fund by an
employee. Section 6A of the Act also does not have any such
stipulation. Since the Act does not contemplate any
contribution to be made by an employee to remain in the
scheme, the Central Government under the scheme itself
cannot mandate such a stipulation. What is to be considered
here is that for the mandatory members, the Central
Government continues to contribute the requisite 1.16 per
cent of their salary. For option members, additional
contribution by them is contemplated in order to remain in the
scheme. In such a situation, in our opinion, a legislative
amendment of the Act would have been necessary, providing
for contribution to be made by an employee. To that extent,
the provision of the scheme requiring contribution by an
individual employee is ultra vires the parent act. At the same
time, we cannot ignore the fact that the pension amount to be
paid has been calculated on projections that the corpus would
include the option employees’ additional contribution of 1.16
per cent. We also cannot mandate the Central Government to
contribute to a pension scheme, in absence of a legislative
provision to that effect. It would be for the administrators to
readjust the contribution pattern within the scope of the
statute and one possible solution could be to raise the level of
the employer’s contribution in the scheme. We shall, however,
suspend the operation of this part of our judgment for a
period of six months so that the legislature may consider the
necessity of bringing appropriate legislative amendment on
this count. For the aforesaid period, the scheme as it stands
shall continue. Till such time, if no such legislative exercise is
undertaken, the duty to contribute 1.16 per cent of the salary
shall apply on option members as well. This contribution shall
be adjusted depending on any amendment that may be
brought. For the period of six months, however, the opting
employees shall make payment of 1.16 per cent contribution
as stop gap measure. In the event no amendment to the
statute or the scheme is made within such extended time,
then the administrators of the fund will have to operate the
pension fund for the option members from out of the existing
corpus.
44. We accordingly hold and direct:
(i) The provisions contained in the notification no. G.S.R.
609(E) dated 22nd August 2014 are legal and valid. So far as
present members of the fund are concerned, we have read
down certain provisions of the scheme as applicable in their
cases and we shall give our findings and directions on these
provisions in the subsequent subparagraphs.
(ii) Amendment to the pension scheme brought about by the
notification no. G.S.R. 609(E) dated 22nd August 2014 shall
apply to the employees of the exempted establishments in the
same manner as the employees of the regular establishments.
Transfer of funds from the exempted establishments shall be
in the manner as we have already directed.
(iii) The employees who had exercised option under the
proviso to paragraph 11(3) of the 1995 scheme and continued
to be in service as on 1st September 2014, will be guided by
the amended provisions of paragraph 11(4) of the pension
scheme.
(iv) The members of the scheme, who did not exercise option,
as contemplated in the proviso to paragraph 11(3) of the
pension scheme (as it was before the 2014 Amendment)
would be entitled to exercise option under paragraph 11(4) of
the post amendment scheme. Their right to exercise option
before 1st September 2014 stands crystalised in the judgment
of this Court in the case of R.C. Gupta (supra). The scheme as
it stood before 1st September 2014 did not provide for any cut
off date and thus those members shall be entitled to exercise
option in terms of paragraph11(4) of the scheme, as it stands
at present. Their exercise of option shall be in the nature of
joint options covering 47 | P a g e preamended paragraph
11(3) as also the amended paragraph 11(4) of the pension
scheme.
There was uncertainty as regards validity of the post
amendment scheme, which was quashed by the aforesaid
judgments of the three High Courts. Thus, all the employees
who did not exercise option but were entitled to do so but
could not due to the interpretation on cutoff date by the
authorities, ought to be given a further chance to exercise
their option. Time to exercise option under paragraph 11(4) of
the scheme, under these circumstances, shall stand extended
by a further period of four months. We are giving this
direction in exercise of our jurisdiction under Article 142 of
the Constitution of India.
Rest of the requirements as per the amended provision shall
be complied with.
(v) The employees who had retired prior to 1st September
2014 without exercising any option under paragraph 11(3) of
the pre-amendment scheme have already exited from the
membership thereof. They would not be entitled to the benefit
of this judgment.
(vi) The employees who have retired before 1st September
2014 upon exercising option under paragraph 11(3) of the
1995 scheme shall be covered by the provisions of the
paragraph 11(3) of the pension scheme as it stood prior to the
amendment of 2014.
(vii) The requirement of the members to contribute at the rate
of 1.16 per cent of their salary to the extent such salary
exceeds Rs.15000/ per month as an additional contribution
under the amended scheme is held to be ultra vires the
provisions of the 1952 Act. But for the reasons already
explained above, we suspend operation of this part of our
order for a period of six months. We do so to enable the
authorities to make adjustments in the scheme so that the
additional contribution can be generated from some other
legitimate source within the scope of the Act, which could
include enhancing the rate of contribution of the employers.
We are not speculating on what steps the authorities will take
as it would be for the legislature or the framers of the scheme
to make necessary amendment. For the aforesaid period of six
months or till such time any amendment is made, whichever is
earlier, the employees’ contribution shall be as stop gap
measure.
The said sum shall be adjustable on the basis of alteration to
the scheme that may be made.
(viii) We do not find any flaw in altering the basis for
computation of pensionable salary.
(ix) We agree with the view taken by the Division Bench in the
case of R.C. Gupta (supra) so far as interpretation of the
proviso to paragraph 11(3) (preamendment) pension scheme
is concerned. The fund authorities shall implement the
directives contained in the said judgment within a period of
eight weeks, subject to our directions contained earlier in this
paragraph.
(x) The Contempt Petition (C) Nos.19171918 of 2018 and
Contempt Petition (C) Nos. 619620 of 2019 in Civil Appeal
Nos. 1001310014 of 2016 are disposed of in the above terms.”
8.
Having heard the counsel this court has come to a conclusion that
both sides have placed on record the judgment passed by the apex Court dated
04.11.2022 arising out of Special Leave Petition(C)Nos.8658-8659 of 2019 with
regard to subject matter which is subjudice before the apex Court where the
present writ appeals are connected. The Hon’ble Supreme Court by order dated
04.11.2022 has disposed of the appeals by suspending the Employees’ Pension
(Amendment) Scheme, 2014 for a period of six months as indicated in para 23
which is reproduced hereinabove. Further the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also
stipulated certain guidelines to be followed under Para-44 which has also been
reproduced hereinabove.
9.
In view of the same, the present writ appeals are accordingly
disposed of. However, liberty is given to the effected parties in the event if
they are aggrieved by any further proceedings, they are at liberty to avail
remedies under law.
Accordingly, writ appeals are allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review