Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/16
GAHC010145462017
2026:GAU-AS:3274
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6512/2017
SANJIV TEA INDUSTRY PVT. LTD.
HAVING ITS REGD. OFFICE and PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS AND
OFFICE AT DHULIAGAON, P.O. MORONGI-785621, DIST. GOLAGHAT,
ASSAM, REP. BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, SRI SANJIV GOGOI, S/O. SRI
MUKUL GOGOI, R/O. DHULIAGAON, P.O. MORONGI, DIST. GOLAGHAT,
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION CO. LTD. and 2 ORS.
BIJULEE BHAWAN, PALTAN BAZAR, GHY.-781001 REP. BY ITS MANAGING
DIRECTOR.
2:THE APPELLATE AUTHORITY FOR A. P.D.C. LTD.
BIJULEE BHAWAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GHY.-781001.
3:THE AREA MANAGER/ASSESSING OFFICER
INDUSTRIAL REVENUE COLLECTION AREA
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION CO. LTD.
JORHAT
DIST. JORHAT
ASSAM
Page No.# 2/16
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Bhowmick, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K. P. Pathak, SC, APDCL
: Mr. B. Choudhury, SC, APDCL
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: N/A
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 27.02.2026
·
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
: No
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: Yes
·
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. Bhowmick, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Petitioner and Mr. K. P. Pathak, the learned Standing
counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3.
2.
The Petitioner herein which is a company engaged in the
business of plantation, manufacture and sale of black tea had
assailed the order dated 19.09.2017 passed in Review Petition
No.1/2017 as well as the Bill dated 03.10.2017. In addition to that
the Petitioner has also sought for refund of an amount of
Rs.32,78,365/- or to adjust the same against future dues.
3.
The Petitioner Company who is engaged in the business of
Page No.# 3/16
plantation, manufacture and sale of black tea had taken a
connection from the Respondent Authorities with a sanctioned load
of 620 KW and in that regard, a meter bearing No.ASB26400 was
installed. The Contract Demand as per the Agreement entered into
by and between the Petitioner and the APDCL Authorities was 403
KW. It was also mentioned in the said Agreement that the Seasonal
Contract Demand from April to November would be 474 KVA and
during the period from December to March which is the off season,
the contract demand would be 190 KVA.
4.
The materials on record show that on 09.01.2016, an
inspection was carried out by the Respondent No.3 and during the
inspection, it was found that the meter cover seals and meter
terminal cover seals were in tampered condition. The meter
cabinet glass was also found in broken condition. It is the finding
of fact arrived at by the Assessing Officer as well as also by the
Appellate Authority that the meter data was downloaded and
analyzed and found that the meter cover opened, tampered,
logged on 28.07.2014 at 11:50 hours which is more than one year
from the date of the inspection. The tampered meter was
withdrawn for further testing/analysis and a new laboratory tested
meter was installed in the Petitioner's premises. The withdrawn
meter was properly sealed in the presence of the Petitioner’s
Page No.# 4/16
representative and taken to the MTI Laboratory, Jorhat, for further
action.
5.
The materials on record further show that in terms with
Section 126 of the Electricity Act, 2003 (for short ‘the Act of 2003’),
a Provisional Assessment Bill amounting to Rs.1,50,09,966/- (One
crore fifty lakh nine thousand nine hundred sixty-six rupees) was
served upon the Petitioner on 11.01.2016. The Petitioner submitted
an objection and a hearing was conducted on 02.05.2016 and the
Provisional Assessment Bill was made final vide an order dated
03.05.2016. Being aggrieved, the Petitioner preferred an Appeal
under Section 127 of the Act of 2003 which was registered and
numbered as Appeal No.3/2017.
6.
The Petitioner paid 50% of the Final Assessment Bill on
06.04.2016 before finalization of the appeal proceedings. The
learned Appellate Authority vide an order dated 26.07.2017 came
to a finding that the Final Assessment Bill served upon the
Petitioner on 20.05.2016 was justified. However, the Appellate
Authority was further of the opinion that 20% of the penalty
amount is required to be waived subject to outstanding
assessment bill payment is paid within 30 days from the date of
the issuance of the said order and accordingly there was a
Page No.# 5/16
direction for issuance of a revised assessment bill and the
Petitioner was directed to deposit the same within 30 days or the
Petitioner would be liable to pay full assessment amount.
7.
On the basis of the above directions so passed by the learned
Appellate Authority on 26.07.2017, a revised assessment bill was
served
upon
the
Petitioner
on
01.08.2017
amounting
to
Rs.60,03,986/-. The Petitioner thereupon sought a review of the
order dated 26.07.2017 passed by the learned Appellate Authority
on the ground that while preparing the revised assessment bill, the
APDCL Authorities cannot take resort to the Assam Electricity
Regulatory Commission Supply Code for calculation of the
assessment amount and they have to do so in terms with Section
126(5) of the Act of 2003. It was also mentioned that if the
assessment was carried out in terms with Section 126(5) of the Act
of 2003, the total amount to which the Petitioner would have been
liable was Rs.84,53,236/- being the double the bill amount for the
12 months immediately preceding the date of inspection, i.e.
09.01.2016 and out of which, an amount of Rs.42,26,618/- being
the bill amount from January, 2015 to December, 2015 having
already been paid, the only amount payable by the Petitioner was
Rs.42,26,618/- as per Section 126(5) of the Act of 2003.
Page No.# 6/16
8.
It is also very pertinent to take note of that in addition to the
review application so filed, the Petitioner also filed an additional
affidavit in the said proceeding drawing the attention of the
learned Appellate Authority that tea is a seasonal industry and the
consumption is low during the off season period ought to have
been considered and more particularly, when the off season
contract demand was 190 KVA instead of the connected load of
620 KW.
9.
The latter of the grounds i.e. about the off season demand
which was taken by the Petitioner in the additional affidavit found
favour with the learned Appellate Authority in the said review
proceedings inasmuch as the learned Appellate Authority taking
into account that the tea industry is seasonal in nature and the
consumption pattern is very low during off season, directed that
their monthly assessed consumption during the off season period
may be considered as 40% of the season period. However, the
learned Appellate Authority observed that as the payment was not
made within a period of 30 days as directed in the order dated
26.07.2017, the waiver of 20% of the penalty amount for payment
within 30 days was withdrawn.
10. Subsequent to the order dated 19.09.2017, another revised
Page No.# 7/16
assessment bill was served upon the Petitioner on 03.10.2017
wherein it was held that the Petitioner was liable to pay an amount
of Rs.34,14,729/- after taking into consideration the amount
already
paid
by
the
Petitioner.
The
Petitioner
thereupon
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition on
27.10.2017.
11. The record reveals that the learned Coordinate Bench of this
Court vide an order dated 02.11.2017 issued notice but stayed the
realization of the amount of Rs.34,14,729/- subject to deposit of
Rs.9,48,253/-. It is the case of the Petitioner that the said amount
of Rs.9,48,253/- have already been deposited.
12. The record reveals that the Respondents herein have filed
their affidavit-in-opposition whereby the order passed in the review
application by the learned Appellate Authority was supported. It
was further mentioned that the case of the Petitioner would strictly
come within the ambit of meter tampering and as such, the
Petitioner was not entitled to any relief in the instant proceedings
more particularly taking into consideration that Act of 2003 was
enacted with a clear revenue focus.
13. It was further mentioned in the said affidavit-in-opposition
Page No.# 8/16
that the findings of facts arrived at by the learned Appellate
Authority to the effect that there was tampering of the meter is
based upon materials inasmuch as, a foreign circuit was found
inside the meter and the meter seals were broken. There was no
explanation by the Petitioner to explain as to how such
unauthorized use had taken place within its premises. The
Respondents have also referred to Clause 4.2.125 of the Electricity
Supply Code and Related Matters Regulations, 2004 which imposes
the sole responsibility upon the consumer for unauthorized use. It
is also mentioned that the Petitioner herein had only assailed the
review order but there is no challenge to the findings of the
learned Appellate Authority in the order dated 26.07.2017.
14.
An affidavit-in-reply thereagainst have been filed by the
Petitioner wherein it was mentioned that the best judgment
assessment which is made under Section 126(1) of the Act of 2003
has to be a fair assessment and more particularly taking into
account the relative considerations. It was further mentioned that
while making the assessment, the lean period of 4 (four) months
should have been taken into consideration. It was also mentioned
that during the seasonal period, the contract demand was 474
KVA, which, when converted to kilowatts, is 403 KW and the offseasonal load would be 190 KVA, which, when converted to
Page No.# 9/16
kilowatts, is 162 KW and these aspects should have been
considered by the learned Appellate Authority as well as the
Assessing Officer while making the Assessment.
15. An additional affidavit was also filed by the Petitioner bringing
on record the Notification dated 16.10.2020 whereby the Assam
Electricity Regulatory Commission (Electricity Supply Code) (Third
Amendment) Regulations, 2020 was notified. The said notification
was brought on record to show that as per Clause 5.3.1(a)(ii), a
consumer shall have to pay an initial Security Deposit based on
estimated consumption as specified in Appendix-I of the Principal
Regulations and calculated as per Clause (i) above on the contract
demand.
It is therefore the contention of the Petitioner in the
said additional affidavit that the assessment has to be made on the
basis of the contract demand and not on the sanctioned load.
16. I have heard the learned counsels appearing on behalf of the
parties and have perused the materials on record.
17. The submissions so made by the learned counsels are in line
with the respective pleadings and as such, for the sake of brevity,
this Court is not repeating the same.
18. From the materials on record, it is apparent that an inspection
Page No.# 10/16
was carried out on 09.01.2016 and the meter which was in the
premises of the Petitioner was found in a tampered condition. It is
also apparent from the findings which is based upon analysis that
the meter cover was open, tampered and was logged on
28.07.2014 at 11:50 hours which is more than one year prior to
the date of the inspection. The findings of facts so arrived at by
both the Assessing Officer as well as the learned Appellate
Authority in respect to the tampering of the meter do not call for
any interference in a proceedings under Article 226 of the
Constitution taking into account that there is no perversity found.
The question therefore arises as to whether the assessment which
was carried out was done as per the prevailing norms.
19. It is relevant to take note of that at that relevant time, when
the inspection was carried out, i.e. on 09.01.2016, the Electricity
Supply Code and Related Matters Regulations, 2004 which was
amended by the Electricity Supply Code and Related Matters
Regulations, 2004 (First Amendment 2007) (for short ‘the
Regulations of 2004’) and notified on 13.06.2007 was holding the
field. Chapter V.A.0 of the Regulations of 2004 is with the heading
“Interference with Supply Mains and Apparatus”. Clause 5.A.4 of
the Regulations of 2004 stipulated the method of assessment of
electricity charge payable in case of theft pending adjudication by
Page No.# 11/16
the appropriate Court.
20. A further perusal of Clause 5.A.4 of the Regulations of 2004
shows that the said provision is under various sub-headings
inasmuch as, Clause 5.A.4.1 is in respect to use of unauthorized
electricity/load exceeding authorized/ connected load; 5.A.4.2 is in
respect to resale of electricity; 5.A.4.3 is in respect to interference
with metering system; 5.A.4.4 is in relation with unmetered use of
electricity (theft of electricity) and 5.A.4.5 is in respect to use of
electricity for any purpose other than that for which supply is
connected.
21. A perusal of the assessment order would show that the
Respondent Authorities have assessed the case of the Petitioner in
terms with Clause 5.A.4.4 of the Regulations of 2004 i.e.
unmetered use of electricity (theft of electricity). It is relevant to
take note of that in terms with the various Sub-Clauses of Clause
5.A.4 of the Regulations of 2004, the period for which the
assessment had to be carried out have been mentioned in the
various Sub-Clauses and the rate at which the billing is to be
carried out in the assessments is also mentioned.
22. Be that as it may, it is also very pertinent to take note of
Page No.# 12/16
Section 126(5) of the Act of 2003 which stipulates that if the
Assessing Officer reaches to the conclusion that the unauthorized
use of electricity have taken place, the assessment shall be made
for the entire period during which such unauthorized use of
electricity have taken place and if, however, the period during
which such unauthorized use of electricity have taken place cannot
be ascertained, such period shall be limited to a period of 12
months immediately preceding the date of inspection. Taking into
account Section 126(5) of the Act of 2003, it appears that a further
amendment was carried out to Clause 5.A.4 wherein the 3 months
and 6 months which were being mentioned in the various SubClauses of Clause 5.A.4 was substituted by 12 months and the rate
of billing at 1.5 times of the existing tariff was substituted by 2
times of the existing tariff.
23. In the backdrop of the above, this Court now finds it pertinent
to take note of the Final Assessment Bill dated 27.01.2016 issued
by the Assessing Officer wherein an amount of Rs.1,50,09,966/was the amount to which the Petitioner was held to be liable. It is
seen that the Final Assessment Bill has been made in terms with
the then existing Clause 5.A.4 by assessing the period for a period
of 12 months immediately preceding the date of the inspection and
then applying the rate of 2 times of the existing tariff. It is also
Page No.# 13/16
seen that for the 12 months for which the Petitioner had already
paid, the same was set off. The appeal filed thereagainst was not
interfered with by the learned Appellate Authority. However 20%
penalty was waived subject to deposit of the same within 30 days.
24. This Court further finds it relevant to take note of that the
agreement which was entered into by and between the Petitioner
as well as the Respondent Authorities wherein the Petitioner
though had a sanctioned load of 620 KW but the seasonal contract
demand for the period from April to November was 474 KVA which
is 403 KW and from the month of December to March, the
seasonal contract demand was 190 KVA which comes to 162 KW.
25. This Court has also taken note that in the review application
so filed, the learned Appellate Authority had observed that during
the lean period, i.e., from the month of December to March, the
use of electricity in the tea industry is too less as compared to the
peak seasonal period, i.e. from April to November and accordingly
was of the opinion that there should have been a 40% discount
during the off season period in the bill instead of 100% of the
connected load.
26. At this stage, this Court also takes note of the submission of
Page No.# 14/16
Mr. P. Bhowmick, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Petitioner that the assessment should not have been done on the
basis of the sanctioned load but should have been on the basis of
the contract demand taking into account that the Petitioner under
no circumstances could have surpassed the contract demand. In
the opinion of this Court, the said submission appears to be
misconceived in the facts of the instant case inasmuch as the
present case relates to tampering of the meter and under such
circumstances, the question of making the assessment on the basis
of contract demand does not arise.
27. It is the further opinion of this Court that as the meter in
question as is apparent from the findings of facts was tampered
with, the assessment has to be made in terms with the connected
load which the learned Appellate Authority in the review order
dated 19.09.2017 had held.
28. Accordingly, this Court does not find any merit in the challenge
to the order dated 19.07.2017. This Court however also finds it
very pertinent to take note of another aspect of the matter in the
impugned order dated 19.09.2017 whereby the waiver of the 20%
penalty amount was withdrawn. It is the opinion of this Court that
the learned Appellate Authority having reviewed its earlier order
Page No.# 15/16
dated 26.07.2017 vide the order dated 19.09.2017 ought not to
have withdrawn the waiver of the 20% penalty but ought to have
granted an extension. Be that as it may, in the impugned
assessment bill dated 03.10.2017, the penalty is not imposed.
29. Accordingly, this Court does not find any ground to interfere
with the impugned order dated 19.09.2017 save and except the
withdrawal of the waiver of 20% of the penalty. This Court is also
of the opinion that the assessment bill dated 03.10.2017 in
accordance with law and therefore do not call for any interference.
30. Accordingly, the writ petition stands disposed off with the
following observations and directions:
(i)
The impugned order dated 19.09.2017 do not call for
interference except the part of the said order whereby the waiver
of the penalty was withdrawn.
(ii)
The impugned assessment bill dated 03.10.2017 is not
interfered with.
(iii) The Respondent Authorities would be at liberty to initiate
recovery proceedings against the remaining amount payable by the
Petitioner in terms with the Assessment Bill dated 03.10.2017 after
Page No.# 16/16
deducting the amount, the Petitioner had already paid.
(iv) The interim order passed earlier stands vacated.
Bijoy
Saha
Digitally signed
by Bijoy Saha
Date: 2026.03.06
17:44:55 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review