Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND
LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on:
06.06.2026
Pronounced on: 03.07.2026
Uploaded on:
06.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:
Full
LPA No.323/2025
SANJAY SARAF
... APPELLANT(S)
Through: -
Mr. Danish Majid, Advocate, with
Ms. Ahra Syed, Advocate.
Vs.
JAMMU AND KASHMIR CRICKET ASSOCIATION & ORS.
…RESPONDENT(S)
Through: -
CORAM:
Mr. Rahul Pant, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Rajat Gupta, Advocate.
Mr. Arif Sikandar, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjay Dhar ‘J’:
1)
The appellant has called in question judgment dated
17.12.2025 passed by the learned Writ Court, whereby the
writ petition (WP(C) No.3158/2025) filed by him challenging
order dated 19.03.2025 passed by the Ombudsman Jammu
and
Kashmir
Cricket
Association
(JKCA),
has
been
dismissed on the ground that the same is not maintainable
as the impugned action does not have a public element.
LPA No.323/2025
2)
It
appears
that
the
appellants/writ
petitioner
(hereinafter for short “the writ petitioner”) filed a writ petition
before the learned Writ Court challenging the decision of
Ombudsman appointed by JKCA, Hon’ble Justice L.
Narsimha Reddy, whereby faction of Whites Cricket Club
headed by respondent No.4, Shri Rajeev Pandita, has been
recognized for limited purpose of taking part in voting for
elections of JKCA. The writ petitioner also sought a
declaration that in the light of findings returned by
Ombudsman Hon’ble Shri Justice Syed Bashir-ud-Din, he
be declared as the lawful representative of Whites Cricket
Club with the direction to the respondents including Election
Officer to treat Whites Cricket Club, Kashmir, as the Court
recognized affiliated unit and to refrain from extending
recognition, voting rights to any faction or individual in
derogation of the Court-appointed Ombudsman’s finding. A
further direction upon the Election Officer to treat the writ
petitioner as the only eligible representative of Whites
Cricket Club, Kashmir, and that respondent No.4 has no
lawful locus to represent the said Club, has also been
sought.
3)
Briefly stated, the grievance of the writ petitioner, as
stated in the writ petition, is that order dated 19.03.2025
passed by the Ombudsman of JKCA, whereby the faction
headed by respondent No.4 has been recognized for the
LPA No.323/2025
limited purpose of taking part in the voting for the elections
of JKCA, has seriously prejudiced his rights. According to
the writ petitioner, the said order is contrary to the findings
recorded by the Court appointed Ombudsman Hon’ble
Justice Syed Bashir-ud-Din in his order dated 29.10.2019.
It was contended by the writ petitioner that he has been
unanimously elected as president of the Whites Cricket
Club, Srinagar and the impugned order has been passed by
the Ombudsman of JKCA behind his back and without his
participation in the proceedings. It was alleged that
respondent No.4 is neither a duly elected office bearer of
Whites Cricket Club, Kashmir nor there was any credible
material
demonstrating
his
participation
as
nominee
representative of the said club in the JKCA working
committee meetings over the years. It was contended that
the impugned order has the effect of disenfranchising the
writ petitioner and the genuine members of the club.
4)
Before the learned Writ Court, the respondents raised
a preliminary objection to the maintainability of the writ
petition on the ground that the writ petition raises a purely
private dispute between the two factions of a cricket club and
that there is no element of public law involved in the case,
therefore, the writ petition is not maintainable.
LPA No.323/2025
5)
The learned Writ Court, after hearing the parties and
after analyzing the legal position on the subject, came to the
conclusion that there is no element of public law involved in
the writ petition as it is a case involving a dispute between
two factions of Whites Cricket Club, hence the writ petition
is not maintainable. The learned Writ Court also observed
that in view of Clause (C) of Section 40 of the Memorandum
of Association of JKCA, the Electoral Officer is empowered to
decide a dispute as to the eligibility to vote and the decision
of the Electoral Officer is final and conclusive. Therefore, the
writ petitioner has a remedy available for redressal of his
grievances projected in the writ petition.
6)
The appellant/writ petitioner has challenged the
impugned judgment passed by the Writ Court on the ground
that the impugned decision of the Ombudsman determines
the composition of electoral college of JKCA in an election
mandated by the orders of the Supreme Court and, as such,
any adjudication, which confers, divests or re-allocates
voting rights in such an election, cannot be reduced to a
private civil dispute. It has been further contended that the
learned Writ Court has failed to examine the true nature and
effect of the impugned action of the Ombudsman of JKCA.
According to the writ petitioner, an order passed by a person
lacking lawful authority is void ab initio and non-est in the
eyes of law and, as such, the writ petition is maintainable. It
LPA No.323/2025
has been contended that merely because there was an
alternative remedy available to the writ petitioner, the Writ
Court could not have refused to entertain the writ petition
once it was shown that the impugned action of the
Ombudsman was contrary to the principles of natural
justice. It has been contended that Section 40(c) of the
Memorandum of Association of JKCA does not bar judicial
review of a decision which is tainted with illegality. It has
been
contended that
the impugned
decision of the
Ombudsman being contrary to the observations rendered by
the court-appointed Ombudsman, the writ petition raises a
substantial question as to the illegality of the impugned
order passed by the Ombudsman of JKCA.
7)
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and we
have also gone through the grounds projected in the appeal
as also the record of the Writ Court.
8)
Before the Writ Court, the writ petitioner, as already
stated, has challenged the decision of the Ombudsman
appointed by the JKCA. The dispute relates to determination
of voting rights of two rival factions of White's Cricket Club
headed by the writ petitioner and respondent No.4. By now,
it is a settled position of law that the ambit of Article 226 of
the Constitution being larger than the ambit of Article 32 of
the Constitution, a High Court, while exercising its powers
LPA No.323/2025
under Article 226 of the Constitution, is vested with
jurisdiction to issue writs even against a person or an
authority which is neither a State nor an instrumentality of
the state. The Supreme Court in the case of Board of
Control for Cricket in India vs. Cricket Association of
Bihar and Ors, (2015) 3 SCC 251, has held that the Board
of Control for Cricket in India is amenable to writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution. By that logic, the
Jammu and Kashmir Cricket Association, which is a
constituent of Board of Control for Cricket in India, is also
amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution, even though it may not be a State under Article
12 of the Constitution.
9)
The Supreme Court in the case of Anandi Mukta
Sadguru Shree Muktajee Vandas Swami Suvarna Jayanti
Mahotsav Smarak Trust and Ors. Vs. V. R. Rudani and
Ors. (1989) 2, SCC 691, has analyzed the issue as to in
which cases a writ petition would lie against a person or an
authority which is neither a State nor an instrumentality of
the State. The Supreme Court carved out two exceptions to
the issuance of writ of mandamus against a person or a body
which is not a State or its instrumentality; (1) if the rights
are purely of private character, no mandamus can be issued,
and (2) if the management of the college is purely a private
body with no public duty, mandamus will not lie.
LPA No.323/2025
10)
In Binny Ltd. & Anr. vs. V. Sadasivan & Ors, (2005)
6 SCC 657, the Supreme Court has observed that a writ can
be issued against any private body or person only for
enforcement of public duty. The Court clarified that there
has to be public law element in the action of that body before
a writ can be issued against such body.
11)
In St. Marys Education Society & Anr. vs Rajendra
Prasad Bhargava & Ors., 2022 SCC Online SC 109, the
judgment which has been relied upon by the learned Writ
Court, it has been held that even if body performing public
duty is amenable to writ jurisdiction, all its decisions are not
subject to judicial review. The Court further held that only
those decisions which have public element therein can be
judicially reviewed under the writ jurisdiction. The Supreme
Court further held that the body or the person against whom
writ is sought to be issued must be shown to owe that duty
or obligation to the public involving the public law element.
12)
Recently, the Supreme Court in the case of S. Shoba
vs. Muthoot Finance Ltd. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 177,
summed up the legal position in the following manner:
(1) For issuing writ against a legal entity, it would
have to be an instrumentality or agency of a State or
should have been entrusted with such functions as
are Governmental or closely associated therewith by
being of public importance or being fundamental to
the life of the people and hence Governmental.
LPA No.323/2025
(2) A writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India may be maintainable against (i)
the State Government; (ii) Authority; (iii) a statutory
body; (iv) an instrumentality or agency of the State; (v)
a company which is financed and owned by the State;
(vi) a private body run substantially on State funding;
(vii) a private body discharging public duty or positive
obligation of public nature; and (viii) a person or a
body under liability to discharge any function under
any Statute, to compel it to perform such a statutory
function.
(3) Although a non-banking finance company like the
Muthoot Finance Ltd. with which we are concerned is
duty bound to follow and abide by the guidelines
provided by the Reserve Bank of India for smooth
conduct of its affairs in carrying on its business, yet
those are of regulatory measures to keep a check and
provide guideline and not a participatory dominance
or control over the affairs of the company.
(4) A private company carrying on banking business
as a Scheduled bank cannot be termed as a company
carrying on any public function or public duty.
(5) Normally, mandamus is issued to a public body
or authority to compel it to perform some public duty
cast upon it by some statute or statutory rule. In
exceptional cases a writ of mandamus or a writ in the
nature of mandamus may issue to a private body, but
only where a public duty is cast upon such private
body by a statute or statutory rule and only to compel
such body to perform its public duty.
(6) Merely because a statue or a rule having the force
of a statute requires a company or some other body to
do a particular thing, it does not possess the attribute
of a statutory body.
(7) If a private body is discharging a public function
and the denial of any rights is in connection with the
public duty imposed on such body, the public law
remedy can be enforced. The duty cast on the public
body may be either statutory or otherwise and the
source of such power is immaterial but, nevertheless,
there must be the public law element in such action.
(8) According to Halsbury's Laws of England, 3rd Ed.
Vol.30, p.682, “a public authority is a body not
necessarily a county council, municipal corporation
or other local authority which has public statutory
LPA No.323/2025
duties to perform, and which perform the duties and
carries out its transactions for the benefit of the public
and not for private profit”. There cannot be any
general definition of public authority or public action.
The facts of each case decide the point.
13)
From the foregoing analysis of the legal position, we are
of the view that even though a writ petition is maintainable
against a private body like Board of Control for Cricket in
India or JKCA, yet the determinative factor as to whether a
writ petition would lie against BCCI or JKCA is the nature of
duty that is sought to be enforced by the writ petitioner
against these bodies. While the whole issue relating to
amenability of writ jurisdiction is not relevant as even a
body, public or private, is amenable to writ jurisdiction, yet
the test of maintainability is the function that is subject
matter of the writ petition. If a public duty or public function
is involved, any body, public or private in relation to that
duty or function, would be subject to judicial scrutiny of the
High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution.
14)
Adverting to the facts of the present case, the writ
petitioner
is
seeking
to
assail
the
decision
of
the
Ombudsman appointed by JKCA. The dispute on which the
Ombudsman has rendered his opinion is regarding the
voting rights of two rival factions of a private cricket club,
namely, Whites Cricket Club. The dispute involved does not
at all relate to any public functioning of the JKCA. It does
not relate to selection of a team or performance of JKCA or
LPA No.323/2025
Board of Control for Cricket in India so far as their actions
affect the public at large. Who represents a particular cricket
club or a particular private association is none of the
concerns of the public at large and it does not affect the
public. A purely private dispute between two fractions of a
cricket club can, by no stretch of reasoning, be elevated to
status of a dispute involving public law element. Therefore,
a writ cannot be issued by this Court in respect of such a
dispute.
15)
Apart from the above, the Ombudsman, whose decision
is being assailed by the writ petitioner, has not been
appointed under any statute or any Court order. The
Ombudsman has been appointed by the JKCA, a private
body. A decision taken by an authority, which is neither
statutory in nature nor is judicially appointed, cannot be
tested by a Writ Court for the purpose of issuing a Writ of
Certiorari. On this ground alone, the writ petition is not
maintainable.
16)
It has been argued by learned counsel for the writ
petitioner that the writ petitioner would be rendered
remediless if the writ petition is not entertained. The
argument is absolutely without any substance as it is always
open to the writ petitioner to file a suit before the Civil Court
for redressal of his grievances and for assailing the decision
LPA No.323/2025
of the Ombudsman or for that matter the decision of the
Electoral Officer rendered in terms of Section 40(c) of the
Memorandum of Association of JKCA.
17)
It is a settled law that in an intra-court appeal, a
judgment or an order of a learned Single Judge can be set
aside only when there is a patent error apparent on the face
of the record or the judgment is against the established or
settled principles of law. An intra-court appeal is really not
a statutory appeal preferred against the judgment and order
of an inferior to the superior court. Therefore, unless it is
shown that there is a patent illegality committed by the
learned Single Judge, it is not open to this Court to interfere
in the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge. In
the present case, as already stated, we do not find any
illegality, much less a patent illegality, in the view taken by
the learned Single Judge vide the impugned judgment that
would warrant interference by this Court.
18)
For what has been discussed hereinabove, we do not
find any merit in this appeal. The same is dismissed
accordingly.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Srinagar,
03.07.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the JUDGMENT is reportable:
LPA No.323/2025
YES/NO
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review