Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 28th October, 2025
Pronounced on: 30th January, 2026
%
CRL.M.C.4721/2017
+
1. SANDHYA GUPTA
W/o Shri Satish Gupta
….Petitioner No.1
2. ABHISHEK GUPTA
S/o Shri Satish Gupta
...Petitioner No.2
Both residents of
1003, Jasminium-II,
Vatika City, Gurgaon
Haryana.
Both Petitioners through their Attorney
Kamal Madnani,
S/o Late Sh. M.G. Madnani,
R/o C-3/179, Janak Puri,
New Delhi
Through: Mr. Bhushan Kapur, Advocate.
versus
SHRI GANESH TRADERS
RZH-791-B, Gali No. 13,
Raj Nagar-II, Palam Colony
Near Jat Dharamshala
New Delhi-110045
….Respondent
Through: Mr. Lokesh Kumar, Advocate.
CRL.M.C.5207/2017 & CRL.M.A. 20487/2017 (stay)
1.
SANDHYA GUPTA
W/o Shri Satish Gupta
….Petitioner No.1
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
2.
ABHISHEK GUPTA
S/o Shri Satish Gupta
...Petitioner No.2
Both residents of
1003, Jasminium-II,
Vatika City, Gurgaon
Haryana.
Petitioner No.2, through their Attorney
Kamal Madnani,
S/o Late Sh. M.G. Madnani,
R/o C-3/179, Janak Puri,
New Delhi
Through: Mr. Bhushan Kapur, Advocate.
versus
SHRI GANESH TRADERS
RZH-791-B, Gali No. 13,
Raj Nagar-II, Palam Colony
Near Jat Dharamshala
New Delhi-110045
….Respondent
Through: Mr. Lokesh Kumar, Advocate.
CRL.M.C.5208/2017 & CRL.M.A. 20489/2017 (stay)
1.
SANDHYA GUPTA
W/o Shri Satish Gupta
….Petitioner No.1
2.
ABHISHEK GUPTA
S/o Shri Satish Gupta
...Petitioner No.2
Both residents of
1003, Jasminium-II,
Vatika City, Gurgaon
Haryana.
through their Attorney
Kamal Madnani,
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
S/o Late Sh. M.G. Madnani,
R/o C-3/179, Janak Puri,
New Delhi
Through:
...Petitioner No.2
Mr. Bhushan Kapur, Advocate.
versus
SHRI GANESH TRADERS
RZH-791-B, Gali No. 13,
Raj Nagar-II, Palam Colony
Near Jat Dharamshala
New Delhi-110045
Through:
….Respondent
Mr. Lokesh Kumar, Advocate.
CRL.M.C.5209/2017 & CRL.M.A. 20491/2017 (stay)
1. SANDHYA GUPTA
W/o Shri Satish Gupta
….Petitioner No.1
2. ABHISHEK GUPTA
S/o Shri Satish Gupta
...Petitioner No.2
Both residents of
1003, Jasminium-II,
Vatika City, Gurgaon
Haryana.
Petitioner No. 2, through their Attorney
Kamal Madnani,
S/o Late Sh. M.G. Madnani,
R/o C-3/179, Janak Puri,
New Delhi
Through: Mr. Bhushan Kapur, Advocate.
versus
SHRI GANESH TRADERS
RZH-791-B, Gali No. 13,
Raj Nagar-II, Palam Colony
Near Jat Dharamshala
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
….Respondent
New Delhi-110045
Through:
Mr. Lokesh Kumar, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J
U D G M E N
T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
CRL.M.A. 18823/2017 (Exemption) in CRL.M.C.4721/2017
1.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The Application stands disposed of.
CRL.M.C.4721/2017, CRL.M.C.5207/2017, CRL.M.C.5208/2017 &
CRL.M.C.5209/2017
3.
The aforesaid Petitions under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as „Cr.PC‟) have been filed on
behalf of the Petitioners to challenge the Criminal Complaint Nos.
4989424/2016,
4989842/2016,
4988950/2016
and
4989101/2016
respectively initiated under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act
(hereinafter referred to as „N.I. Act‟) and also the Order dated 03.05.2017
vide which the Application seeking the dropping of the proceedings under
Section 251 CrPC against the Accused Nos. 3 & 5, was dismissed.
4.
Briefly stated, the aforesaid Complaint Cases under S.138 N.I. Act,
were filed by the Respondents against the Petitioners in respect of the
dishonour of the cheques pertaining to the year 2014. The Respondents had
asserted that they were dealing in the business of supplying materials with
Sh. Rambir Singh, partner in Ganesh Traders were having their Office at
RZH-791-B, Gali No. 13, Raj Nagar-II, Palam Colony, Near Jat
Dharamshala, New Delhi-110045. Sh. Rambir Singh had authorized his wife
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
to look after, manage and control the affairs of the Company. The building
material was supplied to the Petitioners at Spaze Business Park, Sector-66,
Gurgaon, Bhartiya Vidhya Bhawan, K.G. Marg, Connaught Place and Spaze
Corporate Park, Gurgaon. Mr. Satish Gupta, one of the Director of the
Company, had issued three cheques in the sum of Rs.5,00,000/- each, drawn
on HDFC Bank, A/12, Shopping Mall, DLF Phase-I, Qutub Enclave,
Gurgaon-122002, in discharge of their liabilities, towards the material
supplied to them with an assurance that the cheques on presentation would
be encashed but the cheques on presentation were dishonoured for the
reason ‘Debit not allowed’.
5.
After serving legal Notice, the Complaints under Section 138 of N.I.
Act, were filed. The Petitioners were summoned vide Order dated
03.05.2017.
6.
The Petitioners filed an Application for dropping of the Complaints
against them under Section 251 Cr.P.C., but the Application was dismissed
vide Order dated 03.05.2017 by observing that the judgment of a larger
bench is to be followed, and placed reliance on Subramanium Sethuraman
vs. State of Maharashtra, Crl. Appeal No. 1253 of 2002, wherein it was held
that accused cannot be discharged during the framing of notice under
Section 251 Cr.P.C. It held that the Accused No.3, who had sought
discharge on the ground of being a sleeping Director, and Accused No.5,
seeking discharge on the ground that he was not a director at the time of
offence would have to both prove their case during the course of trial.
7.
The Petitioners have sought the quashing of the Complaints on the
grounds that the Complaint filed under Section 138 of N.I. Act, was bad in
law. The Petitioners (Accused) had no legal liability of any nature qua the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
Respondents. The bare perusal of the Complaint demonstrates that there is
no allegation or evidence against the Petitioners, to implicate them in the
Complaint Case.
8.
It has not been appreciated by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate
that the Petitioner No. 2, Mr. Abhishek Gupta was not the signatory or the
Director of the Accused Company at the time of issuance of cheque, which
is evident from Form-32, obtained from the website of Registrar of
Companies. It has also not been appreciated that the Petitioner No. 2, Mr.
Abhishek Gupta had already resigned from the Company on 01.10.2013,
while the cheques pertained to the year 2014; he has been erroneously
dragged into the present Case.
9.
Furthermore, Accused, Ms. Sandhya Gupta is only a house wife and
at no point of time, was managing day-to-day affairs of the Accused
Company. She was a sleeping Director and was not responsible for the dayto-day affairs of the Accused Company. It has been falsely alleged that the
Petitioners being the Directors, were in charge and responsible for the dayto-day affairs of the Accused Company. The Petitioners in fact never dealt
with the Complainant in any manner.
10.
The Complaint also is altogether silent about the allegations in regard
to the liability of the Petitioners. Not a single document has been filed to
substantiate the allegations made in the Complaint. In a catena of
Judgments, the Apex Court has held that if the Complaint is silent in regard
to the role of the Directors of the Company, then no liability can be imputed
on them and they are liable to be discharged.
11.
In order to make the Directors liable for an offence committed by the
Company, under Section 141 of the Act, there must be specific averments
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
against the Directors showing how and in what manner they were
responsible for the conduct of the affairs of the Company. The only
averments against them is that they are responsible for day-to-day affairs of
the Company. The entire Complaint is silent about the manner in which they
were managing the affairs of the Company.
12.
Hence, the prayer is made that the Order dated 03.05.2017 dismissing
the dropping of proceedings Application against the Petitioners, be set-aside
and the Complaint be quashed.
13.
The Respondents filed a Reply wherein a preliminary objection was
taken that the Complaints were transferred to Gurgaon Court due to the
Orders of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and thereafter, all the four
Complaints were transferred back to Dwarka Court. All the four Accused
were summoned before the Gurgaon Court and they had made a total
payment of Rs.9,00,000/-, in order to settle the Settlement. All the four
Directors, therefore, admitted their liability by making such payment, which
amounts to admission that they are looking after and taking care of day-today affairs of the Company. The instant Petitions are, therefore, liable to be
dismissed on the ground of concealment of the facts.
14.
It is further asserted that there is no illegality or infirmity in the
impugned Order dated 03.05.2017 whereby the Application for dropping the
proceedings against the Petitioners, was dismissed. It is stated that the
Application was filed under wrong provisions of law and was consequently
dismissed with a reasoned Order. There is no ground to challenge the
impugned Order.
15.
It is further asserted that the Petitioner No. 1 Sandhya Gupta is not a
sleeping Director, but is actively involved in day-to-day affairs and the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
business activities of SP Contracts Private Limited. In case No.
CC/6194/2017 filed under Section 138 of N.I. Act, titled M/s Rathi Super
Steel Ltd. vs. SP Contract, before the Court of learned Metropolitan
Magistrate, the cheque dated 10.06.2014, which was in question, had been
signed by Accused /Petitioner No. 1, Ms. Sandhya Gupta, in favour of the
Complainant. It sufficiently establishes that she was the authorised signatory
of the Account of the Accused Company and therefore, was an active
Director taking part in the day-to-day business. She not only had the right to
sign the cheques, but also the Balance Sheets and the other documents of the
Company. The CTC of the relevant documents i.e. Form No. 23 AC for the
year 2010-2011, 2011-2012 are annexed in support thereof.
16.
It is further submitted that the Petitioner No. 2 Mr. Abhishek Gupta
was a director, on the date of issuance of the cheques and was involved in
the affairs of the Company.
17.
Mr. Satish Gupta, the Director/Accused No. 1 in Complaint Case
bearing CC No. 4989424/2016 titled as “Shree Ganesh Traders vs. SP
Contract (P) Ltd. & Ors”, was sick and was unable to take care of the daily
business of the Company. Therefore, he had delegated his functions and
powers to the Petitioners herein, who were looking after the affairs of the
Company and were actively taking part in the affairs of the Company, on
daily basis. Mr. Satish Gupta, husband of the Petitioner No. 1 and father of
the Petitioner No. 2, expired last year, due to prolonged sickness.
18.
The alleged resignation dated 01.10.2013 of the Petitioner No. 2, is a
forged and fabricated document as the resigning Director i.e. Mr. Abhishek
Gupta was not even in India, on the said date. Further, even on the date of
entering into negotiations with the Respondent/Complainant; on the date of
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
issuance of cheques; on the date of dishonour of the cheques; on the date of
service of Notice of demand, Petitioner No. 2 was a Director, as per the
record of the Registrar of Companies. The resignation is an afterthought,
after the Complaints under N.I. Act, were filed against them and Petitioner
No. 2 was summoned. The alleged resignation was uploaded on 11.07.2018
and the Stamp Paper was also purchased on 11.07.2018.
19.
The Proprietor of the Complainant/Respondent, Mr. Rambir Singh
was approached by the Petitioners i.e. Ms. Sandhya Gupta and Mr. Abhishek
Gupta along with late Sh. Satish Gupta, who had expressed their intention to
purchase the building material from the Respondent Firm. Both the
Petitioners had also shown that they were the Directors in the Accused
Company and both assured the security of payment against the goods
supplied to them. They confirmed that though, there are two more Directors,
namely, Sh. Satish Gupta (Managing Director) and Mr. Dinkar Dogra
(Director), but all are equally responsible for day-to-day affairs of the
Company.
20.
It is further asserted that all these pleas as agitated in the present
Petitions, were taken by the Petitioners in the Notice under Section 251
Cr.P.C. There is no ground for quashing the Petitions under Section 482
Cr.P.C. and must resort to the remedies available under Law to air their
grievances.
21.
Furthermore, the Petitioners had made a payment of Rs.9,00,000/-,
before the Gurgaon Court, in order to settle the matter. Therefore, all the
four Directors have a liability for the payment of the cheque amount. On
merits, all the allegations made in the Petitions, were denied.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
22.
A Rejoinder had been filed on behalf of the Petitioners wherein
submissions are made that the Form 32, which is a public document, reflects
that the Petitioner No. 2 was not a Director at the relevant point of time.
Aside from making bald, general and vague allegations against the
Petitioners, there are no specific averments to show the manner in which the
Petitioners were responsible for the business of the Company and no
criminal liability can be fastened on the Petitioners.
23.
Reliance is placed on N.K. Wahi vs. Shekhar Singh & Others, AIR
2007 SC 1454. The other averments made in the Petitions, are reiterated.
24.
Written Submissions have been filed on behalf of the Respondents,
who have asserted that the impugned Cheques were dishonoured on
14.07.2014, because of the reason ‘Debit not allowed’. This Court vide its
Order dated 18.09.2014, had issued Notice in the Winding-up Petition and
since the dishonour was prior in time, the Winding-Up Petition, has no
bearing on the facts of this Case. The reference is made to Kusum Ingots &
Alloys Ltd. vs. Pannar Peterson Securities, 2000 AIR 954.
25.
It is further submitted that the Petitioners had filed signatory details
taken on 09.11.2017 from the web portal of Ministry of Corporate Affairs,
which is incomplete and does not show the resignation of the Petitioner No.
2. The date of resignation is alleged to be 01.10.2013, which was approved
by the Board of Directors on 07.10.2013. It is submitted that the copy of
Form No.32, has not been filed to show its acceptance with Registrar of
Companies and the date of payment of fees for the said change. The
resignation is effective only when the fee is paid and the change is made in
the record. The same can be decided only after adducing the evidence.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
Reference is placed on Malwa Cotton and Spinning Mills Ltd. vs. Singh
Sidhu, 2008 AIR Supreme Court 3273.
26.
Furthermore, the Petitioners have admitted that the Petitioner No. 1,
namely, Ms. Sandhu Gupta was an authorised signatory in the SP Contracts
Private Limited, which is a position of responsibility and impliedly admitted
the participation in the day-to-day affairs in her capacity as a Director in the
Accused Company. The claim that she was only a sleeping partner, is
falsified.
27.
The blatant admissions of the Petitioners in their Petitions, do not
justify quashing of the Complaint or the Summoning Order. It is, therefore,
submitted that the Petitions are liable to be rejected.
28.
Learned counsel for the Petitioners in support of their Case, have
relied upon K.S. Mehta vs. M/s Morgan Securities & Credits Pvt. Ltd.,
MANU AIR 2025 SC 1607.
29.
Learned counsel for the Respondents, has placed reliance on the Case
of Bijoy Kumar Moni vs. Paresh Manna & Anr., Crl. Appeal No. 5556/2024,
decided on 20.12.2024.
Submissions heard and the record perused.
30.
The Complaints under Section 138/142 of the Negotiable Instruments
Act were filed by the Complainant, Ganesh Traders against the Company
i.e. S.P. Contract Private Limited, as well as its four Directors, namely, Sh.
Satish Gupta (Managing Director, since deceased) Ms. Sandhya Gupta, Mr.
Dinkar Dogra and Mr. Abhishek Gupta.
Liability Of The Director/Ms. Sandhya Gupta:
31.
The Petitioner, Ms. Sandhya Gupta had sought a discharge on the
ground that she was a sleeping Director and was not involved in the day-to-
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
day affairs of the Company. The most significant document is Form-32 of
the Company, which shows that she was a Director in the Company. Not
only this, she was a signatory to the cheques and also was a co-signatory to
the Balance Sheets, which were being submitted on behalf of the Company.
For her to claim that she was not involved in the affairs of the Company, is
not supported by the documents on record. Pertinently, she has claimed
herself to be the Sleeping Director, which is not borne from the record. The
Summoning Order against Ms. Sandhya Gupta, is justified as the documents
clearly reflect that she was involved in the day-to-day affairs of the
Company. It is her defence that she was not actively involved, which she
may prove during the trial. At this stage, the Summoning Order cannot be
faulted and she has been rightly summoned as an Accused.
Liability Of The Director/Abhishek Gupta:
32.
The Petitioner, Mr. Abhishek, who is the son of Mr. Satish Gupta, has
asserted that he had resigned from the Company on 01.10.2013 and
therefore, cannot be held liable for the affairs of the Company after post his
resignation. Pertinently, the cheques are claimed to have been issued in
May, 2014 and were dishonoured in July, 2014. Therefore, it becomes
significant to consider whether Abhishek Gupta indeed had resigned on
01.10.2013 and thus, cannot be made liable for the affairs of the Company
post his resignation.
33.
The first document of relevance is the Form-32, which clearly reflects
that he was admitted as a Director on 15.11.2013 and resigned on
01.10.2013. His resignation is also supported by Minutes of the Meeting of
the Board of Directors held on 07.10.2013 wherein the resignation tendered
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
by Mr. Abhishek Gupta, was accepted w.e.f. 07.10.2023. T resignation of
Mr. Abhishek Gupta on 01.10.2013 is supported by Form-32.
34.
It is claimed on behalf of the Respondent that the bare perusal of this
Form-32, shows that it has been manipulated and submitted only in the year
2018. It is claimed that his resignation is being created only to escape the
liability under these Complaint Cases.
35.
In this context, it would be pertinent to refer to Section 168
Companies Act, 2013, Resignation of Director. It provides that a Director
may resign from his Office by giving a Notice in writing to the Company
and the Board shall on receipt of such Notice, take the note of the same and
shall intimate the Registrar in such manner, within such time and in such
Form as may be prescribed and shall also place the fact of such resignation
in the report of Directors be laid in the immediately following General
Meeting of the Company. An Amendment was made in the Proviso w.e.f.
07.05.2018 wherein it was provided that the Director may also forward the
copy of his Resignation along with the detailed reasons for the resignation,
to the Registrar, within 30 days of his resignation.
36.
In the present Case, the Form-32 clearly records that Mr. Abhishek
Gupta had resigned from the Company on 01.10.2013, which is fully
corroborated by the Minutes of the Meeting of the Board of Directors. There
is cogent independent evidence on record, reflecting the resignation of Mr.
Abhishek Gupta before the cause of action arose in the aforesaid Complaints
under Section 138 NI Act. In no way, can he be said to be involved in the
affairs of the Company, after his resignation.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
37.
Mr. Abhishek Gupta, therefore, is entitled to be discharged and the
Summoning Order dated 03.05.2017 vis-à-vis Mr. Abhishek Gupta, is
hereby quashed.
Conclusion:
38.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the Summoning Order dated
03.05.2017 vis-à-vis Ms. Sandhya Gupta is upheld, while it is set-aside in
respect of Abhishek Gupta, who is discharged in the Complaints under
Section 138 of N.I. Act.
39.
The Petitions, along with pending Applications, are accordingly,
disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 30, 2026/RS
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:26:20
CRL.M.C.4721/2017 & connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review