Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010181202025
2026:GAU-AS:9356DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/4918/2025
SAMIRAN NESSA
D/O ABDUL SAMAD, W/O SHAHJAHAN, R/O VILL- BHATNAPAITYCHOR,
P.S.- BARPETA ROAD, DIST- BARPETA, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NEW DELHI-110001
2:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF ELECTION COMMISSIONER
NEW DELHI-110001
3:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
HOME AND POLITICAL (B) DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006
4:THE STATE COORDINATOR
NATIONAL REGISTER OF CITIZENS
ASSAM
BHANGAGARH
GUWAHATI-781004
5:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
BARPETA
ASSAM-781301
Page No.# 2/12
6:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
BARPETA
ASSAM-78130
Advocates for the petitioner
: Ms. D. Ghosh, Advocate
Advocates for the respondents
: Mr. J. Payeng, Adv for R- 3, 5 & 6
: Mr. A.I. Ali, Adv for R-2
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH MAZUMDAR
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 17.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 26.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
: NA.
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R (CAV)
(Rajesh Mazumdar, J)
Heard Ms. D. Ghosh, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. J.
Payeng, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 3, 5 & 6 and Mr. M. Islam,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. A.I. Ali, learned counsel for the
respondent No. 2.
2.
The petitioner has preferred this writ petition, being aggrieved by the
Opinion dated 5.12.2018 passed by the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal
Number-6, Barpeta, on 5.12.2018 in F.T Case Number 400/2015, corresponding
to reference case number 132/B/98 dated 02.07.1998. By the aforesaid opinion,
the writ petitioner, who was a proceedee therein, had been declared to be a
Page No.# 3/12
foreigner/illegal immigrant, who had entered Assam on or after 25.03.1971.
3.
The Electoral Registration Officer doubted the citizenship of the petitioner
and had the matter verified by on-the-spot local verification. The concerned
local verification officer had, on 22.9.1997, recorded that the petitioner, on
enquiry, could not produce any documentary evidence indicating her Indian
citizenship. The Superintendent of Police, Barpeta, had forwarded the case
records of IMDT Doubtful Case Number 132/B/98 dated 02.07.1998 to the
Chairman of the IMDT Court, Barpeta.
4.
The Foreigners Tribunal 6, Barpeta, received the reference and by order
dated 02.11.2015, required issuance of notice to the petitioner, fixing
15.12.2015 for service report and appearance. On her appearance, the
petitioner submitted her written statement and affidavit. On the next date, the
petitioner submitted the evidence-in-chief on affidavit, and the matter was fixed
for cross-examination. The petitioner was cross-examined on 27.09.2016.
Thereafter, the projected father of the petitioner adduced his evidence as DW-2,
and another person also adduced evidence on a different date. The final
arguments were heard on 12.09.2018, and the impugned Opinion was rendered
on 05.12.2018.
5.
During the proceedings before the learned Tribunal, the petitioner exhibited
the following documents.
a) Ext A: is the certified copy of the E/Roll 1966.
(b) Ext B: is the certified copy of the E/Roll 1970.
(c) Ext C: is the certified copy of the E/Roll 1997.
Page No.# 4/12
(d) Ext D: is the certified copy of the E/Roll 2010.
(e) Ext E: is the certificate of Gaonburha of village: Alopatichar Non
K.
(f) Ext F: is the certificate of Gaonburha of village: Bhatnapaitychar.
(g) Ext G: is the certificate of G.P. Secretary of Vil: Dharmapur
Bhatnapaity Gaon Panchayat.
(h)Ext: is an Affidavit.”
6.
The learned Tribunal has recorded that the proceedee had pleaded very few
material facts in her written statement and had not disclosed the date and year
of her birth. She had not mentioned her place of birth and her upbringing. The
proceedee had also abstained from disclosing the date of her marriage. The
proceedee did not disclose the details of her grandmother or her mother and
had referred to DW-2 and projected him as her father. The proceedee had given
evidence that her projected grandfather was included as a voter in the voter list
of 1970 and 1985, while the name of her projected father appeared in the voter
list of 1985 and 2010.
7.
The learned Tribunal had observed that the petitioner did not disclose from
where her forefathers had come from, where her parents were born and
brought up, whether her projected father had any brothers and sisters, the date
or year in which the projected parents got married, or whether the petitioner
had any brothers and sisters. The learned Tribunal noticed that the proceedee
did not disclose the details about herself. Thus, the learned Tribunal found fault
with the projected stand of the proceedee. The learned Tribunal had also
observed that the affidavit filed by the proceedee did not disclose that she
Page No.# 5/12
understood the contents thereof.
8.
Referring to the evidence of the DW-2, i.e., the projected father of the
proceedee, the learned Tribunal found that it contained manuscript sentences,
in relation to facts which were not pleaded in the written statement. The
learned Tribunal observed that due to non-disclosure and also suppression of
material facts, the written statement and the evidence under consideration
could not be regarded as admissible or reliable evidence. The learned Tribunal
found that the document sought to be projected to establish a link between the
proceedee and the projected father was a certificate issued by the Secretary of
72 No. Dharmapur, Bhatnapaity Gaon Panchayat. However, this document was
not proved in accordance with the law. With regard to Exhibit-F, the learned
Tribunal held that the authority issuing the same had not been examined to
prove either the document or the contents thereof and further, due to the usage
of the State Emblem, the certificate would be inadmissible in evidence. With
regard to the evidence led by the projected father of the proceedee, the learned
Tribunal held that the aforesaid witness did not establish his linkage to the
projected grandfather of the petitioner.
9.
The DW2, according to the Tribunal, had failed to disclose the period when
they had shifted from their villages. The learned Tribunal found various
shortcomings in the the evidence of DW2, which, according to the learned
Tribunal, had resulted in the failure of the DW-2 to either connect him to his
projected ancestors, or to connect him to the proceedee. The learned Tribunal
found that the voter lists of 1966 and 1970 were not referable to the biological
parents of the proceedee and hence, the documents relied upon by the
proceedee had lost their probative value. The learned Tribunal observed that the
Page No.# 6/12
O.P had failed to establish that she was an Indian by birth.
10. Ms. D. Ghosh, the learned counsel for the petitioner had submitted that the
appreciation of the evidence, in the manner it was done, is not acceptable in
law and therefore, the impugned opinion, deserves interference of this Court.
She has submitted that the father of the petitioner had adduced evidence as
DW-2 and the petitioner had exhibited the certificates issued by the Gaon
Panchayat and the Gaonbura and had also adduced the evidence of the
Gaonbura of village Alopatichar Non K as DW-3, in her support. The learned
counsel for the petitioner had submitted that, although some vital material facts
had not been brought to the knowledge of the learned Tribunal in the written
statement filed by the petitioner, the petitioner has given all relevant material
facts in this writ petition. Therefore, the interest of justice would demand that
the petitioner is given an opportunity to bring the facts before the learned
Tribunal and to lead further evidence in support of her projection and the
impugned Opinion deserves interference of this Court to that extent. The
learned counsel has submitted that, given an opportunity, the petitioner would
be able to establish not only several facts to demonstrate her claim as an Indian
citizen, but, she would also be able to bring on evidence records to prove her
projection as an Indian Citizen.
11. The learned counsel has submitted that the petitioner would be able to
produce certified copies of voters list to establish her linkage before the Tribunal
in the event the matter is remanded back to the Tribunal, to afford an
opportunity of defence to the petitioner.
12. Mr. J. Payeng, learned Standing Counsel, Foreigners Tribunal has submitted
that the writ petition suffers from unexplained delay and laches, inasmuch as,
Page No.# 7/12
the petitioner herein was declared to be a foreigner by the order dated
05.12.2018 and the present writ petition has been filed on 12 th August, 2025.
The learned counsel has submitted that pursuant to the Opinion dated
05.12.2018, the petitioner was taken into custody by the concerned authorities
on 20.12.2024. He submits that although the petitioner had filed a writ petition
bearing W.P(C) No. 4402/2005, the same was withdrawn on 06.08.2025, with a
liberty to file afresh. The learned Standing Counsel has submitted that such a
liberty would not ipso-facto amount to condonation of delay on the part of the
petitioner in filing the present writ petition. The learned Standing Counsel has
submitted that this Court in WP(C) No. 7037/2025 by order dated 12.03.2026
had rejected the writ petition on the ground of inordinate delay and laches of
about six (6) years in assailing the impugned Opinion. He has submitted that in
the aforesaid case also, the petitioner claimed to be a rustic and poor person.
He has therefore submitted that the present writ petition be dismissed on the
grounds of delay and laches itself.
13. On the merits of the claim made by the petitioner in this writ petition, the
learned Standing Counsel has submitted that a perusal of the records available
before the learned Tribunal would reveal that the learned Tribunal did not
commit any error when it appreciated the written statement and the evidence
led by the petitioner herein. The learned Standing Counsel has further
submitted that even with regard to the evidence led by D.W Nos. 2 & 3, the
order of the Tribunal also did not suffer from any discrepancy. With regard to
the evidence led by D.W-3, the learned Standing Counsel has submitted that the
evidence led would show that he was not the Government Gaonburah of the
village and was rather the son of the Gaonburah, who was bedridden due to his
illness. With regard to the voter list of 1966 as exhibited by the petitioner, the
Page No.# 8/12
learned Standing Counsel has submitted that, when the same is contrasted with
the voter list of 1970, the sudden appearance of Biyakul Miya in the list of 1970
raises doubts. The absence of the name Biyakul Miya in the voter list of 1966
has not been explained by the petitioner in the proceedings before the learned
Tribunal. The learned Standing Counsel has pointed out other discrepancies in
the evidence led by the petitioner before the learned Tribunal and has submitted
that the learned Tribunal did not commit any error when it rejected the
projection of the petitioner herein.
14. The learned Standing Counsel has also submitted that the documents now
sought to be relied upon by the petitioner for establishing her linkage to her
projected ancestors cannot be allowed to question the validity of the Opinion of
the learned Tribunal.
15. We have perused the Opinion of the learned Tribunal and we have also
gone through the Trial Court Records, which has been received on requisition.
16. The records reveal that the petitioner had appeared and filed her written
statement on 15.12.2015 and thereafter, had submitted her evidence-in-chief on
affidavit on 20.01.2016. The matters were fixed on 02.03.2016 and 05.04.2016,
when the cross-examination could not take place, although the petitioner was
present.
17. The records of the Trial Court reveal that the writ petitioner had been
afforded opportunity to contest the allegation of being a foreigner, who had
entered India after 25.03.1971 and to facilitate her defence, she had adduced
her own evidence and the evidence of two other witnesses. The document
exhibited by the petitioner have also been considered and it is seen that the
documents available on record did not establish a clear linkage of the petitioner
Page No.# 9/12
either to her projected father or to the projected other relatives.
18. This Court in Ayna Khatun Alias Anowara Khatun Vs. Union of India
& Ors. passed in WP(C) No. 7037/2025, held as follows:
“30. The Supreme Court of India, in paragraph 46 of the case of
Urban Improvement Trust v. Vidhya Devi, 2024 INSC 980: 2024) 0 Supreme(SC)
1189, has reiterated the law that undue delay in approaching the Court can be a
ground for refusing relief and it has been expressed that that only in exceptional
cases, delay can be condoned. The said paragraph 46 [extracted from (2024) 0
Supreme(SC) 1189 ] is quoted below:"46. As regards the appellant's challenge to the inordinate delay of 21 years
in filing of the writ petitions by the respondents, we are of the view that the
same needs to be considered in the facts and circumstances of the case.
While it is true that the courts have consistently held that undue delay in
approaching the court can be a ground for refusing relief, the courts have
also recognized that in exceptional cases, where the impugned action is
patently illegal or affects fundamental rights, the delay must be condoned."
31. In respect of the legal proposition that delay and laches is fatal
to a belated challenge to the opinion of the Foreigners Tribunals, it may be
relevant to refer to the decision of this Court in the case of Jonali Das v. Union of
India, 2018(5) GLT 492: (2018) 0 Supreme (Gau) 1186. Paragraph 9 thereof is as
follows:"9. In Azmat Ali @ Amzad Ali Vs. Union of India [W.P.(C) No. 4971/2018, disposed
of
on
01.08.2018],
this
Court
had
observed
as
follows:-
"It is more than three decades that the issue of influx of foreign nationals has been
in public domain in the State of Assam and has engaged the attention of the
Page No.# 10/12
people. Interest of the State is of paramount importance in that unabated influx
has the potential to affect the integrity and sovereignty of the country. Citizenship
of a person, no doubt, is a very valuable right and should be zealously guarded.
There is no gainsaying the fact that a person who is alleged to be a foreigner must
be given due and reasonable opportunity to establish that he is a citizen of India.
However, if a person does not take steps for safeguarding his interest, he does so
at his own risk and peril as grant of opportunity cannot be an endless exercise.
Right to a fair hearing or principles of natural justice cannot be permitted to lead to
a farcical situation and to be an engine for defeating the very object of
identification and deportation of foreigners."
32. The Supreme Court of India, in the case of Shivamma (Dead) by
LRs v. Karnataka Housing Board & Ors., 2025 INSC 1104: 2025 Supreme(SC)
1679, while dealing with the provision of Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963
has laid down certain guidelines. Though Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963
does not apply to a writ petition, but in the considered opinion of the Court, when
a writ petition is filed to assail the opinion of the Foreigners Tribunals, under
certiorari jurisdiction, the same principles should apply, requiring the petitioner to
provide at least some cogent and acceptable explanation for the inordinate delay in
assailing the opinion.
34. It must be taken note of the fact that the Supreme Court of
India, in the case of Sarbananda Sonowal v. Union of India, 2005) 5 SCC 665, in
paragraph 73, had held to the effect that the procedure under the Foreigners Act,
1946 and the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964 is just, fair and reasonable and
does not offend any constitutional provision. In paragraph 63, the Supreme Court
of India had observed that there can be no manner of doubt that the State of
Assam is facing external aggression and internal disturbance on account of large-
Page No.# 11/12
scale illegal migration of Bangladeshi nationals and that it, therefore, becomes the
duty of the Union of India to take all measures for protection of the State of Assam
from such external aggression and internal disturbance as enjoined in Article 355
of the Constitution of India. In paragraph 70, it was observed that the influx of
Bangladeshi nationals who have illegally migrated into Assam pose a threat to the
integrity and security of the North Eastern region and that their presence has
changed the demographic character of that region and the local people of Assam
have been reduced to a status of minority in certain districts.”
19. We are of the opinion that the aforesaid judgment would apply to the facts
of the present case also. The learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon
the Judgment & Order dated 15.05.2026 passed by this Court in the case of
Niva Suklabaidya @ Niva Baidya Vs. Union of India & Ors. , to impress
that this Court has also condoned the delay of more than 9 years and 4 months.
She has referred to the Judgment of this Court in Hamida Begam Vs. Union
of India & Ors. in WP(C) No. 250/2024 delivered on 06.03.2024 where this
Court had condoned the delay of 15 years by remanding the Opinion rendered
against the petitioner therein back to the learned Tribunal to allow the petitioner
therein an opportunity to contest the allegation against her.
20. We noticed that the aforesaid two judgments were delivered in the facts of
those cases and the judgments may not be applicable to the facts of the present
case. In Niva Suklabaidya @ Niva Baidya (supra), no fault was found with
ex-parte Opinion passed against the petitioner therein. However, since the
petitioner had projected that her grand-father was registered as Indian citizen
and her projected uncle had also been declared to be not a foreigner by the F.T,
it was deemed fit to remand the matter back to the learned Tribunal to prove
her case.
Page No.# 12/12
21. In the case of Hamida Begam (supra), notice was not served to the
petitioner in the manner known and recognized in law and therefore, this Court
set aside the ex-parte order and granted the petitioner an opportunity to prove
her case before the learned Tribunal.
22. In the present case, we have also examined the materials available in the
writ petition and we find that the Opinion expressed by the learned Tribunal
does not require interference. Resultantly, the writ petition fails both on the
account of inordinate delay and laches, as well as on merits.
23. Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. No order as to cost.
24. Registry to return the Trial Court Records expeditiously along with a copy
of this Order.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review