Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra-Ordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, CJ.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
1.
Shri Samdup Tsh. Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF at Fambonglho
Wildlife Sanctury,
Headquarter at Deorali.
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Phurba Rinchen Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF at Block
Administrative Centre,
Ranka, East Sikkim.
3.
Shri Kul Bahadur Ghaley,
Presently posted as ACF at Survey and
Demarcation, Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
4.
Shri Nandu Lamichaney,
Presently posted as ACF (RVP)
South and West, Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
5.
Shri Kamal Subba,
Presently posted as ACF (FCA),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
6.
Shri Prem Prasad Silwal,
Presently posted as ACF at BAC,
Dentam, West Sikkim.
7.
Shri Sonam Zangpo Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (IWMP),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
8.
Shri Surya Kumar Subba,
Presently posted as ACF (Social Forestry)
Namchi, South Sikkim.
9.
Shri Chitra Prasad Sharma,
Presently posted as ACF at Social Forestry,
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
10.
Shri K.B. Basnet,
Presently posted as ACF at Working Plan,
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
11.
Shri D.K. Rai,
Presently posted as ACF,
BAC Nandu Gaon-Jorethang,
South Sikkim.
12.
Shri Rapden Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (Monitoring),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
13.
Shri Sonam Wangdi Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF at BAC,
Chungthang, North Sikkim.
14.
Shri Suk Bahadur Subba,
Presently posted as ACF (Environment & Soil
Conservation), Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
15.
Shri S.T. Lachungpa,
Presently posted as ACF (KNP), North,
Chungthang, North Sikkim.
16.
Shri Pempa Tsh. Lepcha,
Presently posted as ACF, BAC Yangang,
South Sikkim.
17.
Shri Tilak Kumar Mukhia,
Presently posted as ACF (Wildlife),
Namchi, South Sikkim.
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
18.
Shri James S. Lepcha,
Presently posted as ACF (Territorial),
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Petitioners.
versus
1.
State of Sikkim,
Through Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
2.
Principal Secretary,
Department of Personnel, AR & Training,
Public Grievance,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
3.
PCCF-cum-Principal Secretary,
Department of Forest,
Government of Sikkim.
4.
Shri Tenzing Norbu Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (Territorial),
Soreng, West Sikkim.
5.
Shri Palzor Ongda Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (Wildlife),
Ravangla, South Sikkim.
6.
Miss Tshering Denka Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (Territorial),
Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
7.
Miss Karma Choden Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (Wildlife),
Mangan, North Sikkim.
8.
Miss Dichen Namdul,
Presently posted as ACF (Wildlife),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
9.
Miss Arati Basnet,
Presently posted as ACF (SBB),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
10.
Miss Sewani Pradhan,
Presently posted as ACF (Silviculture),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
11.
Miss Nisha Subba,
Presently posted as ACF (Wildlife),
Soreng, West Sikkim.
12.
Miss Yangchen Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (Utilization),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
13.
Miss Peggy Tshering Venchungpa,
Presently posted as ACF (Territorial),
Namchi, South Sikkim.
14.
Miss Srijana Chettri,
Presently posted as ACF (Wildlife),
Ravangla, South Sikkim.
15.
Mr. Jigme Tsewang Sharngoe,
Presently posted as ACF (Territorial),
Attach with CCF (T/HQ), Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
16.
Miss Smita Shilai,
Presently posted as ACF (Territorial),
Rongli, East Sikkim.
17.
Miss Marmit Lepcha,
Presently posted as ACF (Social Forestry),
Namchi, South Sikkim.
18.
Miss Merab Basnet,
Presently posted as ACF at NTFP (East),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
19.
Shri Sonam Norden Bhutia,
Presently posted as ACF (Survey &
Demarcation),
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
20.
Miss Bhumka Rai,
Presently posted as ACF (Territorial),
Pakyong, East Sikkim.
21.
Miss Angela Ongmu Chettri,
Presently posted as ACF (SBFP),
North and East,
Headquarter at Deorali,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
22.
Shri Hem Bdr. Rai,
Presently posted as ACF at
Himalayan Zoological Part,
Bulbulay, East Sikkim.
…
Respondents.
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. B. Sharma, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Bhola N.
Sharma and Mr. Sajal Sharma, Advocates for the
Petitioners.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General with
Ms. Pollin Rai, Asstt. Govt. Advocate and Ms. Rita
Sharma, Advocate for State-Respondents No. 1 to 3.
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Ms. Panila Theengh and Ms. Tashi
Doma Sherpa, Advocates for Respondents No. 4 to 22.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
JUDGMENT
(13.09.2017)
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
Assailing the correctness of the seniority list published
vide, Notification No. 114/G/DOP dated 01 st September 2016
(Annexure P-12) (hereinafter referred to as “the impugned
notification”), whereunder the petitioners were placed below the
4th respondent to 22nd respondent, the petitioners have come up
with this petition.
2.
The petitioners seek quashing of the said impugned
notification, a direction to place the petitioners above the private
respondents, considering their officiation on the post of Assistant
Conservator of Forest (hereinafter referred to as “ACF”) and also
to consider their promotion to the post of Divisional Forest Officer
(hereinafter referred to as “DFO”) in officiating capacity on
permanent basis.
3.
The chronological events leading to filing of the instant
petition are that the petitioners, initially appointed as Block
Officers, were promoted to the post of Range Officers on 19th
August 2000 (Annexure P-2).
Thereafter, the petitioners were
promoted as ACF in an officiating capacity vide, Office Orders No.
2633/G/DOP dated 12th February 2010 and No. 466/G/DOP dated
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
05th
August
respectively).
(Annexure
R-16
and
Annexure
R-17
Subsequently, the petitioners were promoted on
permanent basis on the post of ACF vide Office Order No.
3691/G/DOP dated 19th March 2013 (Annexure R-21). It appears
that the official respondents have issued a provisional seniority
list vide Memo No. 9021/G/DOP dated 10th July 2014 (Annexure
P-14), placing the petitioners down below the direct appointee/
private respondents, which prompted the petitioners to make a
representation on 04th August 2014 (Annexure P-10) and also to
send a legal notice on 04th April 2016 (Annexure P-11) seeking
grant of seniority with effect from the date of officiation and their
placement above the direct recruits, who completed
their
probation on 21st May 2013. The instant petition is filed on 12 th
September 2016, resubmitted on 13th September 2016, after a
period of two years from the date of issuance of provisional
seniority list on 10th July 2014.
4.
Mr. B. Sharma, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr.
Bhola N. Sharma and Mr. Sajal Sharma, learned Advocates,
would contend that the petitioners were promoted as ACF on
officiating capacity against the existing vacancies and their
services continued without interruption till they were confirmed
on 19th March 2013, before completion of probation period of
private respondents on 21st May 2013. The appointment of the
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
petitioners was in accordance with the Rules against the clear
vacancies and, as such, the petitioners are entitled to seniority
with effect from the date of their promotion on the post of ACF,
on officiation.
5.
Mr.
Sharma
further
contended
that
the
private
respondents were appointed on probation, which came to end on
21st May 2013. Thus, they become members of service only on
completion of probation.
In that event, the petitioners were
senior, as they were confirmed on the post on 19th March 2013.
It is also urged that the Principal Secretary-cum-Principal Chief
Conservator of Forest has recommended for protection of
seniority of the petitioners vide notings dated 19 th December
2013 (Annexure P-7). The Chairman, Law Commission of Sikkim
has strongly observed that it is well-settled law that in absence
of
any
rule
to
the
contrary,
the
continuous
service
on
confirmation cannot be ignored for determining the place in
seniority list. Mr. Sharma would lastly submit that in the facts of
the case wherein the petitioners were promoted on officiating
basis, in accordance with rule, and thereafter confirmed on the
post, the petition deserves to be allowed with a direction to place
the petitioners above the private respondents in the seniority list,
who were recruited subsequently and to grant subsequent
promotion and other consequential benefits.
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
Mr. Sharma, in support of his case relied on S.B.
Patwardhan and another v. State of Maharashtra and others 1 ,
Pran Krishan Goswami and others v. State of West Bengal and
others 2 , G.K. Dudani and others v. S.D. Sharma and others 3 ,
G.C. Gupta and others v. N.K. Pandey and others4, State of W.B.
and others v. Aghore Nath Dey and others 5 and B. Amrutha
Lakshmi v. State of Andhra Pradesh and others6.
7.
Resisting, Mr. J.B. Pradhan, learned Addl. Advocate
General assisted by Ms. Pollin Rai, learned Assistant Government
Advocate and Ms. Rita Sharma, learned Advocate, would contend
that under sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 of the Sikkim State Forest
Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1976 (hereinafter referred to as
“the Recruitment Rules”), 50% post of ACF is to be filled up by
direct recruitment through open competitive examination and
50% by promotion. The total sanctioned strength of ACF on the
relevant date was 87. On 06th February 2007, it was proposed to
fill up 21 posts of ACF by direct recruitment and as more than
50% of quota was utilized by promotion from the post of Range
Officers. As on relevant date, altogether 71 persons were
AIR 1977 SC 2051
AIR 1985 SC 1605
AIR 1986 SC 1455
(1988) 1 SCC 316
(1993) 3 SCC 371
AIR 2014 SC 751
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
working as ACF from promotion quota. In pursuance thereof, an
advertisement for filling up of 21 posts of ACF was published on
07th June 2010.
In response thereto, the private respondents
participated successfully in competitive examination and were
accordingly appointed.
The result was declared on 28th March
2011 and a list of selected candidates was sent to the
Department of Personnel, Government of Sikkim on 15 th April
2011 (Annexure R-1). Out of 21 posts, two posts, namely, MBC
and MBC (W) could not be filled up and the same was carried
forward due to non-availability of eligible candidates.
The
appointment orders were issued in the months of May and June
2011.
The promotion of the petitioners to the post of ACF on
officiation was subject to two conditions, namely,
(i)
(ii)
the officiating capacity shall not confer any right
for regular promotion and shall not be counted
towards senior; and
regular promotion shall be made on the
recommendation of the Sikkim Public Service
Commission,
which was made subsequently leading to regularization of the
petitioners. The said conditions were accepted by the petitioners
without a demur or protest.
8.
The petitioners were appointed as ACF in officiating
capacity against the direct recruitment quota, as the appointment
against direct recruitment had taken some time.
14 persons
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
were already serving as ACF on substantive capacity and 12
persons were serving as DFO on officiating capacity, continuing
to hold their lien in the cadre of ACF. As such, 91 ACFs, including
the petitioners, against the cadre strength of 87, were working as
ACF.
9.
Mr. Pradhan would further contend that in order to
accommodate the petitioners, Department of Personnel, issued
two notifications dated 31st October 2011 (Annexure R-22) and
12th February 2013 (Annexure R-23), relaxing the method of
recruitment after creation of substantive vacancies of ACFs,
under promotion quota, the petitioners were confirmed and
granted regular promotion.
10.
In support, Mr. Pradhan, relies on Direct Recruit Class
II Engineering Officers’ Association v. State of Maharashtra and
others 7 , State of W.B. and others v. Aghore Nath Dey and
others 8 , and M.P. Palanisamy and others v. A. Krishnan and
others9.
11.
Adopting
the
arguments
advanced
by
learned
Additional Advocate General, Mr. Jorgay Namka, learned counsel
appearing for the private respondents/direct recruits, would
(1990) 2 SCC 715
(1993) 3 SCC 371
(2009) 6 SCC 428
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
submit that the appointment of the petitioners on the post of ACF
was purely temporary on officiating basis, in excess of the quota
reserved for promotees against direct appointee vacancy.
The
petitioners were appointed to perform the duties and functions of
ACFs, as no officers appointed in accordance with rules were
available. The appointment was purely a stop-gap arrangement.
It is further contended that the appointment order of the
petitioners, appointing them on officiating basis as ACF, clearly
indicate that the appointment
was not against a regular
substantive vacancy. Thus, the petition deserves to be dismissed
maintaining the seniority of the private respondents above the
petitioners,
as
private
respondents
have
completed
their
probation within the prescribed time and as per rules seniority
relates back to the date of initial appointment on completion of
probation period in time.
12.
Having
given
my
anxious
consideration
to
the
submissions put forth by the learned counsel appearing for the
parties,
on
examination
of
the
pleadings
and
documents
appended thereto, it is manifest that the petitioners‟ appointment
vide orders dated 12th February 2010 (Annexure R-16) and 05th
August 2010 (Annexure R-17) was conditional, as clearly stated
in the order itself.
The petitioners have not protested at any
point of time to the conditions, which were duly accepted by
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
them at the time of their appointment on the post of ACF on
officiating basis.
The orders seeking appointment of officiating
basis clearly prescribed that their officiating capacity shall not
confer any right for regular promotion and shall not be counted
towards seniority.
The appointment to the regular promotion
was subject to recommendation of the Sikkim Public Service
Commission.
13.
On examination of the documents produced by the
parties, it is proven that as on the relevant date, the sanctioned
strength of the cadre of ACF was 87, as enhanced vide
Notification dated 18th December 2006 (Annexure R-13). Out of
87 posts, 10 posts were filled up by direct recruits. For filling up
of 21 posts of ACF, necessary steps were initiated on 06 th
February 2007.
The advertisement for filling up of 21 posts of
ACF was published on 07th June 2010, which culminated into
appointment of the 4th to 22nd respondents vide orders dated 21st
May 2011 (Annexure R-2), 25th May 2011 (Annexure R-3), 26th
May 2011 (Annexures R-4 and R-5) 27th May 2011 (Annexure R6),
31st
May
(Annexures
R-8
and
and
01st
June
Indisputably,
all
the
private
(Annexure
R-9).
R-7)
respondents (4th to 22nd respondents) have completed their
probation in time, on expiry of a period of two years and as such
they are entitled to their seniority from the date of their initial
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
appointment, as per Rule 7(A) of the Sikkim Government
Establishment Rules, 1974.
14.
As contemplated under the provisions of the Sikkim
State Services (Regulation of Seniority) Rules, 1980 (hereinafter
referred to as “the Seniority Rules, 1980”), which is applicable to
the forest service as prescribed under Rule 18 (A) of the
Recruitment Rules, it is well established that a direct recruit is
entitled to seniority from the date of initial appointment on
completion of probation within the prescribed time i.e. two years.
In the case on hand, all the direct recruits, 4th to 22nd
respondents, have completed their probation in two years time
and as such they became members of the Service from the initial
date of appointment.
15.
Rule 4 of the Recruitment Rules contemplates “Method
of Recruitment to the Service”, which reads as under: “4.
METHOD OF RECRUITMENT TO THE SERVICE:- (1)
Recruitment to the Service after the commencement of
these rules shall be by the following methods, namely: (a)
By the Competitive Examination to be held by the
Commission;
(b)
By selection from among persons holding the post
of Range Officer or any other post or posts
declared equivalent thereto by the Government.
(2)
The proportion of vacancies to be filled in any year
in accordance with clauses (a) and (b) above, shall be 50
: 50 respectively:
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Provided that the number of persons, recruited
under clause (b) above, shall not at any time exceed 50%
of the total strength of the Service.
(3)
Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1),
if in the opinion of the Government, the exigencies of the
service so require, the Government may, after
consultation with the Commission, adopt such method of
recruitment to the Service, other than those specified in
the said sub-rule, as it may, by Notification in this behalf,
prescribe.”
Sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 of the Recruitment Rules provides that the
vacancies of a cadre to be filled up by the competitive
examination in accordance with clause (a) and by selection from
among persons holding the post of Range Officers as per clause
(b) in 50 : 50 ratio. Proviso to sub-rule (2) further provides that
the number of persons, recruited under clause (b) shall not at
any time exceed 50% of the total strength of the Service. It is
established in this case that out of total 87 cadre strength, 43 or
44 posts were to be filled up by promotion. When the petitioners
were promoted on officiating basis on the post of ACF vide order
dated 12th February 2010 and 05th August 2010, there were
already 56 promotee ACFs working in the cadre.
Thus, the
appointment of the petitioners was in excess of the requisite
limit, as prescribed under the Rules.
In such a situation,
whether it can be held that the appointment of the petitioners
was in accordance with the rules?
16.
The subsequent regularization or absorption of the
petitioners on permanent cadre was done by the Government
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
after relaxation in the rules, as evident from the notifications
dated 31st October 2011 and 12th February 2013 (Annexures R22 and R-23 respectively), exercising power under sub-rule (3)
of Rule 4 of the Recruitment Rules. In such factual matrix, the
ineluctable conclusion is that the appointment of the petitioners
as ACF on officiating basis was not in accordance with the law i.e.
the Recruitment Rules, as it was clearly indicated in the
appointment order itself and such their claim to seniority from
initial date of officiating appointment merits rejection.
17.
Recommendation
of
the
Principal
Secretary-cum-
Principal Chief Conservator of Forest, Government of Sikkim for
grant of seniority to the petitioners vide his notings dated 19th
December 2013 and also the observation made by the Chairman,
Law Commission, are not relevant and binding in the facts of the
case.
18.
The „officiating appointment‟ is defined under the
Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974 (hereinafter referred to
as “Service Rules of 1974”) in clause (13) of Rule 5, as under: “(13) „Officiating
appointment‟ – A Government
Servant is said to be holding an officiating
appointment, when he performs the duties of a vacant
or newly created temporary post on which no
Government Servant holds a lien without completing
the minimum number of qualifying years of service as
may have been or as may be prescribed by the
Government from time to time.”
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Bare
perusal
of
the
definition
clearly
provides
that
the
appointment is to perform the duties of a vacant post without
holding a lien in the service.
19.
In S.B. Patwardhan1, cited by the learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the petitioners, interpretation of the
provisions of the Bombay Service of Engineers (Class I and Class
II) Recruitment Rules, 1960, was involved, wherein the Supreme
Court held Rule 8 (iii) as unconstitutional, holding that the
valuable right of seniority may not depend upon the mere
confirmation.
20.
Senior
In Pran Krishan Goswami2, referred by learned
Counsel
(Determination
for
of
the
petitioners,
Seniority)
Rules,
the
W.B.
1981,
was
Services
under
examination, wherein some Sub-Inspectors of Police have been
officiating for almost three decades, without examining the fact
as to whether there officiation was against the substantive
vacancy, the Supreme Court held that the Sub-Inspectors are
entitled to benefit of their continuous officiating service as SubInspectors of Police.
21.
In G.K. Dudani and others3, again referred by the
learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, wherein the
Mamlatdars were promoted and appointed to hold ex-cadre
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
posts, it was held that it could not be said not to have been
regularly appointed. In such factual background, they were held
to be entitled to seniority of their continuous officiation.
22.
In G.C. Gupta and others4, it was held that the
temporary Assistant Engineers on absorption were entitled to
seniority from the date on which their service were regularized
i.e. the date from which they became members of the service.
23.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, learned Addl. Advocate General,
referring to an observation made by the Supreme Court in M.P.
Palanisamy and others9 submit that the petitioners have
accepted the conditions of appointment on officiation. Thus, they
cannot be permitted to retrace back and take a contrary stand.
The Supreme Court held as under: “31. The panel is absolutely correct in the light of
GOMs No. 1813. The appellants merely raised a lame
plea that they did not challenge GOMs No. 1813, as
they were expecting themselves to be placed over and
above the T.N. PSC-selected candidates. Such could
never be the position in the wake of plain language of
GOMs No. 1813. This is one of the main reasons why
the claim of the appellants has to be rejected. The
aspect of conditional regularization, therefore, had to
be kept in mind.”
24.
In O.P. Garg and others v. State of U.P. and
others 10 , the Supreme Court examined the seniority and
1991 Supp (2) SCC 51
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
promotion of Judicial Officers under the U.P. Higher Judicial
Service Rules, 1975 and held as under: “26. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the
arguments of the parties. This Court has time and
again held that when an incumbent is appointed to a
post in accordance with the Service Rules his seniority
has to be counted on the basis of continuous length of
service and not in reference to the date of
confirmation. Even in the present case the promotees
have been confirmed long after the availability of
permanent vacancies. This Court in S.B. Patwardhan
v. State of Maharashtra. : (1977) 3 SCC 399 observed
that "confirmation is one of the inglorious uncertainties
of Government service depending neither on efficiency
of the incumbent nor on the availability of substantive
vacancies". A Constitution Bench of this Court in Direct
Recruit Class II Engineering Officers' Association v.
State of Maharashtra : (1990) 2 SCC 715 approved
Patwardhan case and laid down the following
propositions in this respect:
“(A) Once an incumbent is appointed to a post
according to rule, his seniority has to be counted
from the date of his appointment and not
according to the date of his confirmation.
The corollary of the above rule is that where the
initial appointment is only ad hoc and not
according to rules and made as a stop-gap
arrangement, the officiation in such post cannot
be taken into account for considering the
seniority.
(B) If the initial appointment is not made by
following the procedure laid down by the rules
but the appointee continues in the post
uninterruptedly till the regularisation of his
service in accordance with the rules, the period of
officiating service will be counted.
(C) When appointments are made from more
than one source, it is permissible to fix the ratio
for recruitment from the different sources, and if
rules are framed in this regard they must
ordinarily be followed strictly.”
27. Keeping in view the scheme of the 1975 rules, we
are of the view that first proviso to Rule 26(1)(a) of
the 1975 Rules which links the seniority with the date
of confirmation is on the face of it arbitrary and as
such violative of Article 16 of the Constitution of India.
Since the recruitment to the service is from three
sources the existence of a vacancy either permanent
or temporary is the sine qua non for claiming benefit
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
of continuous length of service towards seniority. The
period of officiation/service which is not against a
substantive vacancy (permanent or temporary) cannot
be counted towards seniority. While striking down first
proviso to Rule 26(1)(a) of the 1975 Rules we hold
that the continuous officiation/service by a promotee
shall be counted for determining his seniority only
from the date when a substantive vacancy against a
permanent or temporary post is made available in his
quota under the 1975 rules.”
25.
In Keshav Chandra Joshi and others v. Union of
India and others 11 , wherein fixation of seniority of the
petitioners, who were promoted during the period from 13 th
March 1974 to 21st November 1981, as Assistant Conservator of
Forest, on ad hoc basis was involved.
recruits
were
vacancies.
appointed
on
probation
In 1976, some direct
against
substantive
When the petitioners became due for promotion as
Deputy Conservator of Forest, the promotees claimed seniority
over the direct recruits. The promotion of the petitioners as ad
hoc was in excess of quota and had to be resorted to because of
non appointment of direct recruits due to litigation, the Supreme
Court observed as under: “19. The heart of the controversy lies in the question
as to when a person is appointed to a post in the
service in a substantive capacity within the meaning of
Rule 3(h) read with Rules 5 and 24 of the Rules. Under
Rule 5 read with Rule 3(h) a member of the service
means a person, be it direct recruit under Rule 5(a) or
promotee under Rule 5(b), appointed in a substantive
capacity to the service as per the provisions of the
rules. In order to become a member of the service
he/they must satisfy two conditions, namely, the
appointment must be in substantive capacity and the
appointment has to be to the post in the service
1992 Supp (1) SCC 272
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
according to rules and within the quota to a
substantive vacancy. There exists marked distinction
between appointment in a substantive capacity and
appointment to the substantive post. Therefore, the
membership to the service must be preceded by an
order of appointment to the post validly made by the
Governor. Then only he/they become member/
members of the service. Any other construction would
be violation of the Rules.
x
x
x
24. It is notorious that confirmation of an employee in
a substantive post would take place long years after
the retirement. An employee is entitled to be
considered for promotion on regular basis to a higher
post if he/she is an approved probationer in the
substantive lower post. An officer appointed by
promotion in accordance with Rules and within quota
and on declaration of probation is entitled to reckon
his seniority from the date of promotion and the entire
length of service, though initially temporary, shall be
counted
for
seniority.
Ad-hoc
or
fortuitous
appointments on a temporary or stop gap basis cannot
be taken into account for the purpose of seniority,
even if the appointee was subsequently qualified to
hold the post on a regular basis. To give benefit of
such service would be contrary to equality enshrined
in Article 14 read with Article 16(1) of the Constitution
as unequals would be treated as equals. When
promotion is outside the quota, the seniority would be
reckoned from the date of the vacancy within the
quota, rendering the previous service fortuitous. The
previous promotion would be regular only from the
date of the vacancy within the quota and seniority
shall be counted from that date and not from the date
of his earlier promotion or subsequent confirmation. In
order to do justice to the promotees it would not be
proper to do injustice to the direct recruits. The rule of
quota being a statutory one it must be strictly
implemented and it is impermissible for the authorities
concerned to deviate from the rule due to
administrative exigencies or expediency. The result of
pushing down the promotees appointed in excess of
the quota may work out hardship but it is unavoidable
and any construction otherwise would be illegal,
nullifying the force of statutory rules and would offend
Articles 14 and 16(1). Therefore, the rules must be
carefully applied in such a manner as not to violate the
rules or equality assured under Article 14 of the
Constitution. This Court interpreted that equity is an
integral part of Article 14. So every attempt would be
made to minimise, as far as possible, inequity.
Disparity is inherent in the system of working out
integration of the employees drawn from different
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
sources, who have legitimate aspiration to reach
higher echelons of service. A feeling of hardship to
one, or heart burning to either would be avoided. At
the same time equality is accorded to all the
employees.
x
x
x
34. Accordingly we have no hesitation to hold that the
promotees have admittedly been appointed on ad-hoc
basis as a stop-gap arrangement, though in
substantive posts, and till the regular recruits are
appointed in accordance with the rules. Their
appointments are de hors the rules and until they are
appointed by the Governor according to rules, they do
not become the members of the service in a
substantive capacity. Continuous length of ad hoc
service from the date of initial appointment cannot be
counted towards seniority. The Governor shall have to
make recruitment by promotion to substantive
vacancies in the posts of Asstt. Conservator of Forest,
if not already made, in accordance with Rule 5(b) read
with Appendix 'B' and Rule 6. Their seniority shall be
counted only from the respective dates of appointment
to the substantive posts in their quota under Rule 6 as
per the rules. The direct recruits having been
appointed in accordance with Rule 5(a) read with
Appendix 'A', their seniority shall be counted from the
date of their discharging the duties of the post of
Asstt. Conservator of Forest and the seniority of the
direct recruits also shall accordingly be fixed. The inter
se seniority of the direct recruits and promotees shall
be determined in accordance with Rules 5, 6 and Rule
24 in the light of the law declared in the judgment. All
the employee are entitled to all consequential benefits.
On account of the pendency of judicial proceedings, if
any of the employees became barred be age for
consideration for promotion to cadre posts, the
appropriate Governments would do well to suitability
relax the rules and do justice to the eligible
conditions.”
26.
In State of W.B. and others vs. Aghore Nath Dey
and others8, the Supreme Court clarified the ratio laid down
earlier in Direct Recruit Class II Engineering Officers’ Assn.7
case:“22. There can be no doubt that these
conclusions have to be read harmoniously,
two
and
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
conclusion (B) can not cover cases which are expressly
excluded by conclusion (A). We may, therefore, first
refer to conclusion (A). It is clear from conclusion (A)
that to enable seniority to be counted from the date of
initial appointment and not according to the date of
confirmation, the incumbent of the post has to be
initially appointed 'according to rules'. The corollary
set out in conclusion (A), then is, that 'where the
initial appointment is only ad hoc and not according to
rules and made as a stop-gap arrangement, the
officiation in such posts cannot be taken into account
for considering the seniority‟. Thus, the corollary in
conclusion (A) expressly excludes the category of
cases where the initial appointment is only ad hoc and
not according to rules, being made only as a stop-gap
arrangement. The case of the writ petitioners squarely
falls within this corollary in conclusion (A), which says
that the officiation in such posts cannot be taken into
account for counting the seniority.
23. This being the obvious inference from conclusion
(A), the question is whether the present case can also
fall within conclusion (B) which deals with cases in
which period of officiating service will be counted for
seniority. We have no doubt that conclusion (B) can
not include, within its ambit, those cases which are
expressly covered by the corollary in conclusion (A),
since the two conclusions cannot be read in conflict
with each other.
24. The question, therefore, is of the category which
would be covered by conclusion (B) excluding
therefrom the cases covered by the corollary in
conclusion (A).
25. In our opinion, the conclusion (B) was added to
cover a different kind of situation, wherein the
appointments are otherwise regular, except for the
deficiency of certain procedural requirements laid
down by the rules. This is clear from the opening
words of the conclusion (B), namely, 'if the initial
appointment is not made by following the procedure
laid down by the rules' and the later expression 'till the
regularisation of his service in accordance with the
rules'. We read conclusion (B), and it must be so read
to reconcile with conclusion (A), to cover the cases
where the initial appointment is made against an
existing vacancy, not limited to a fixed period of time
or purpose by the appointment order itself, and is
made subject to the deficiency in the procedural
requirements prescribed by the rules for adjudging
suitability of the appointee for the post being cured at
the time of regularisation, the appointee being eligible
and qualified in every manner for a regular
appointment on the date of initial appointment in such
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
cases. Decision about the nature of the appointment,
for determining whether it falls in this category, has to
be made on the basis of the terms of the initial
appointment itself and the provisions in the rules. In
such cases, the deficiency in the procedural
requirements laid down by the rules has to be cured at
the first available opportunity, without any default of
the employee, and the appointee must continue in the
post uninterruptedly till the regularisation of his
service, in accordance with the rules. In such cases,
the appointee is not to blame for the deficiency in the
procedural requirements under the rules at the time of
his initial appointment, and the appointment not being
limited to a fixed period of time is intended to be a
regular appointment, subject to the remaining
procedural requirements of the rules being fulfilled at
the earliest. In such cases also, if there be any delay
in curing the defects on account of any fault of the
appointee, the appointee would not get the full benefit
of the earlier period on account of his default, the
benefit being confined only to the period for which he
is not to blame. This category of cases is different
from those covered by the corollary in conclusion (A)
which relates to appointment only on ad hoc basis as a
stop-gap arrangement and not according to rules. It
is, therefore, not correct to say, that the present cases
can fall within the ambit of conclusion (B), even
though they are squarely covered by the corollary in
conclusion (A).”
27.
In P.K. Singh vs. Bool Chand Chablani and
others12, the Supreme Court has clearly held that when ad hoc
appointment is made dehors the rules, such appointment does
not enure to the benefit of the appointee for the purpose of
determining seniority in the cadre.
28.
In Radha Mohan Malakar and others v. Usha
Ranjan Bhattacharjee and others 13 , the Supreme Court
observed as under:
(1998) 5 SCC 726
(2009) 14 SCC 619
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“23. In our opinion the principle of the decision in N.
K. Chauhan v. State of Gujarat : (1977) 1 SCC 308
can be illustrated by taking a hypothetical example.
Suppose in a particular service 50% of the vacancies
are to be filled in by promotion and 50% by direct
recruitment, and suppose there is a rule that the inter
se seniority of direct recruits and promotees is to be
fixed according to the rotation of vacancies between
direct recruits and promotees in the manner that the
first post will go to a promotee, the second to a direct
recruit, the third to a promotee, the fourth to a direct
recruit, and so on. Even here the ordinary rule that
seniority will depend on the length of the continuous
officiating service has to be followed unless the quota
of direct recruits or of the promotees has been
exceeded. It is only if the said quota is exceeded that
the appointees have to be pushed down in the
seniority, otherwise seniority has to be taken from the
date of continuous officiating service.
24. In the present case it is admitted that the quota of
direct recruits has not been exceeded. Hence, in our
opinion, the seniority of direct recruits (the appellant)
has to be taken from the date of their initial
appointment and they cannot be pushed down in
seniority. The promotees (the respondents herein)
were appointed to Grade II of TCS after the
appointments of the direct recruits (the appellants).
Hence the former have to be treated as junior to the
latter. The earlier Division Bench decision of the High
Court dated 29.7.1992 has to be understood in the
light of the decision of this Court in N.K. Chauhan case
(supra).”
29.
From the judicial pronouncements made by the
Supreme Court in various cases, as aforestated, it is well
established that the length of service of appointment on
promotion made on ad hoc or temporary basis or on officiation in
accordance with law against the substantive vacancies, may be
counted for the purpose of seniority from the date of initial
appointment.
In the case on hand, all the appointments were
made in excess of their quota, not in accordance with rules,
W.P. (C) No. 39 of 2016
Samdup Tsh. Bhutia & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
subject to conditions enshrined in the order, stating that the
appointees shall not claim seniority or regular promotion on the
said basis.
The petitioners are not entitled to the benefit of
period of officiation on the post of ACF before their appointment
on permanent basis, on recommendation of the Sikkim Public
Service Commission, as required under the Rules as well as
under the conditions of the appointment of officiating basis. The
petition is bereft of merits.
30.
Resultantly, the writ petition is dismissed.
No order
as to costs.
Chief Justice
13.09.2017
jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review