Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT: HYDERABAD
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
AND
HON’BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
APPEAL SUIT No.1273 OF 2017
(CNR No.HBHC010977622017)
Reserved on: 16.07.2026
Pronounced on: 07-09-2026
Uploaded on : 07-09-2026
Between:
Mr. Salla Veera Reddy
…Appellant
Vs.
Mr. M. Krishna Reddy
…Respondent
This Court delivered the following:
JUDGEMENT (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K. Lakshman)
Heard Mr. O. Manohar Reddy, learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant and Mr. V. Hari Haran, learned Senior Counsel representing
Mr. Srikanth Hariharan, learned counsel for the respondent.
2. The present appeal is preferred by the appellant-defendant
assailing the judgment and decree dated 06.09.2017 passed in
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
O.S.No.271 of 2008 by learned III Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Rangareddy District.
3. The appellant herein is the defendant in the aforesaid suit in
O.S. No.271 of 2008, while the respondent herein is the plaintiff. For
the sake of convenience, the parties are hereinafter referred to as they
were arrayed in the suit.
4. The plaintiff filed the aforesaid suit against the defendant for
specific performance of agreement of sale, dated 25.09.2000 and to put
him or his nominee in vacant and peaceful possession of the suit
schedule property i.e., the land admeasuring Acs.1.09 guntas in Survey
No.19 known as Bibisaheb Maktha, situated at Peerjadiguda Village,
Ghatkesar Mandal, Rangareddy District with the boundaries specified
therein.
5. The case of the plaintiff is that the defendant is the owner of
the suit schedule property. The defendant approached him and offered to
sell the suit schedule property for a total consideration of Rs.40,00,000/(Rupees Forty Lakhs Only). Accordingly, they entered into an
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
agreement of sale on 25.09.2000. The plaintiff had paid an advance sale
consideration of Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakh Only) to the
defendant in the presence of witnesses and the defendant issued receipt
to that effect. The balance sale consideration would be paid on
finalization of pending case before the Mandal Revenue Officer (MRO),
and registration would be effected within six (06) months thereof.
6. Thereafter, on enquiry by the plaintiff, the defendant informed
him that the proceedings pending before the MRO were being adjourned
from time to time on one count or the other. The plaintiff came to know
that the proceedings were pending with the Joint Collector, Rangareddy
District. Under the guise of pendency of the proceedings, the defendant
did not come forward to execute the sale deed. However, on the request
of the defendant, the plaintiff had further paid an amount of
Rs.1,00,000/- on 08.06.2001; Rs. 10,000/- on 28.09.2001, and Rs.
1,00,000/- on 26.03.2002 to the defendant and the defendant having
received the said amount issued receipts for the same. The plaintiff
waited for the outcome of the litigation, however under the guise of
pendency of the litigation, the defendant kept on prolonging execution
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
of sale deed. Even then, the plaintiff waited patiently for completion of
litigation before the Revenue Authorities.
7. The defendant by showing the progress in the case before this
Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court, collected further sum of
Rs.7,40,000/- (Rupees Seven Lakhs Forty Thousand Only) as part
consideration from the plaintiff from 2003 to 2007, for which no receipts
were issued keeping in view good relationship between them.
The
plaintiff had paid an amount of Rs.19,50,000/- (Rupees Nineteen Lakhs
and Fifty Thousand Only) in total as part sale consideration.
8. In fact, the defendant did not show any interest in executing
the sale deed and deliberately tried to avoid the plaintiff. Eventually, the
plaintiff learnt that litigation had ended in favour of the defendant and
that the defendant was trying to negotiate with third parties to sell the
suit schedule property taking advantage of the steep hike in the prices.
Thus, the plaintiff got issued a legal notice on 22.02.2008 calling upon
him to execute registered sale deed in his favour. The defendant issued
reply dated 12.03.2008 denying the agreement of sale itself and receipt
of earnest money or part payment towards sale consideration. He also
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
sought a copy of the said agreement. Thereafter, the plaintiff vide letter
dated 22.03.2008 addressed to the advocate of the defendant, furnished a
copy of the agreement of sale dated 25.09.2000. The plaintiff submits
that he has always been ready and willing to perform his part of contract,
and there was no default on his part. Therefore, he filed the aforesaid
suit.
9. Denying the case of the plaintiff, the defendant filed written
statement, contending that since the date of purchase of the property, it
was under litigation with one Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah. The plaintiff was
well aware of the said litigation. The plaintiff despite having knowledge
with regard to the litigation entered into an agreement dated 25.09.2000
with the defendant, whereunder the plaintiff had paid an advance sale
consideration of Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs Only). The plaintiff
did not sign the said agreement, as such he does not acquire any right
and title over the said property and the said agreement is not enforceable
in the eye of law. The essence of the contract as stipulated in the
agreement is for a limited period of six (06) months and after expiry of
the said period, the plaintiff demanded for return of advance amount
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
whereupon the defendant arranged Rs.5,00,000/- through his daughter C.
Suchitha on 05.02.2003. The plaintiff received the said amount as hand
loan, and in turn issued a receipt. The said amount was refundable on
demand, but the plaintiff did not repay, as such the amount was repaid
on behalf of the plaintiff by the defendant to C. Suchitha. On acceptance
of Rs. 5 lakhs, the said agreement stands as withdrawn, and thereby
unenforceable. He asked the plaintiff to hand over the original
agreement, but the plaintiff promised him that he would return the same
only after the receipt of balance amount. The defendant by raising hand
loans from his relatives paid an amount of Rs.7,10,000/- by the end of
April 2003 and discharged his liability. Except Rs.12,10,000/-, he has
not received any amount including an amount of Rs.7,40,000/- as
alleged by the plaintiff.
10. The plaintiff has developed a false story of advancing said
amount of Rs.7,40,000/- and having paid total amount of Rs.19,50,000/(Rupees Nineteen Lakhs Fifty Thousand Only) to the defendant. The
plaintiff after receipt of balance amount failed to return the original
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
agreement. As such, the suit is time barred and the agreement is not
enforceable.
11. The defendant further contended that he contested the matter
initiated by Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah, in respect of suit scheduled property
before the Revenue Authorities. The plaintiff received the total sale
consideration from the defendant. As such, the question of execution of
sale deed on the ground of part performance does not arise. He did not
receive any amount of Rs.7,40,000/- (Rupees Seven Lakhs Forty
Thousand Only) from the plaintiff during the period from 2003 to 2007
as part payment. After return of the entire amount, he has no obligation
to inform the plaintiff about the progress and stage of the case before
revenue authorities as well as the Courts. Now, the defendant has no
intention to sell the suit property to anybody and he decided to construct
a building to fetch regular income through rent. There is no cause of
action. The subject agreement is unregistered, as such, the same is not
admissible in law. The plaintiff with a mala fide intention, by
suppressing the facts filed the suit to have wrongful gain. With the said
contentions, the defendant sought to dismiss the suit.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
12. Basing on the aforesaid pleadings, learned trial Court framed
the following issues for consideration:
i)
Whether the suit claim is barred by limitation?
ii)
Whether the sum of Rs.12,10,000/- was returned by the
defendant to the plaintiff?
iii)
Whether the agreement of sale dated 25.09.2000 executed
in favour of the plaintiff is true and valid and enforceable?
iv)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of specific
performance of the agreement of sale, as prayed for?
v)
To what relief?
13. To prove the case of the plaintiff, he examined himself as
P.W.1 and examined P.Ws.2 to 4 on his behalf and got marked Exs.A.1
to A.11. Further, Exs. A.12 to A.20 were marked during crossexamination of D.W.1. To disprove the case of the plaintiff, the
defendant examined himself as D.W.1 and examined D.Ws. 2 to 4 and
got marked Ex.B.1.
14. On consideration of the aforesaid evidence, both oral and
documentary, learned trial Court decreed the suit directing the plaintiff
to pay Rs.27,90,000/- (Rupees Twenty Seven Lakhs, Ninety Thousand
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
Only) with interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing of
the suit till the date of the judgment to the defendant within two months
and obtain regular registered sale deed in respect of the suit schedule
property. If the defendant fails to comply with the same, he should
deposit the said amount before Court and obtain regular registered sale
deed.
15.
Challenging the said judgment and decree, defendant
preferred the present appeal.
16. Contentions of the appellant - defendant:
i)
The plaintiff failed to pay balance sale consideration within
six (06) months from the date of resolution of the case
before the MRO/Tahsildar.
ii)
No steps were taken by the plaintiff during the period
prescribed in the agreement. The first step taken was
issuing Ex.A6 - legal notice dated 22.02.2008.
iii)
The suit is barred by limitation.
iv)
The plaintiff never expressed his readiness and willingness
to perform his part of contract.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
v)
The plaintiff failed to prove the payment of Rs.7,40,000/as part sale consideration from 2003 to 2007.
vi)
Burden lies upon the plaintiff to plead and prove with
regard to his willingness and readiness to perform his part
of contract. The plaintiff failed to discharge the said burden.
vii)
Time is the essence of contract. Even then, the plaintiff
failed to perform his part of contract as per Ex.A1 agreement of sale.
viii) The conduct of the plaintiff is not bona fide. He has taken a
false plea of payment of amount from the years 2003-07
without obtaining any receipt from the defendant.
Therefore, the same disentitles the plaintiff from seeking
discretionary relief of specific performance in terms of the
Specific Relief Act.
ix)
The plaintiff agreed to purchase the suit schedule property
despite being well aware that there is litigation between the
defendant and Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah with regard to said
property.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
x)
Ex.A1 is unenforceable as the stipulated period of six (06)
months had already lapsed.
xi)
The findings of learned trial Court are contrary to the
evidence, more particularly the admissions made by PWs.1
to 4 during cross-examination.
xii)
Learned trial Court failed to consider Ex.B1 - receipt.
xiii) Ex.A1 agreement of sale is dated 25.09.2000, according to
which, the plaintiff has to pay balance sale consideration
within six (06) months from resolution of dispute before the
MRO. Whereas, the plaintiff got issued Ex.A6 legal notice
only on 22.02.2008.
Therefore, the suit is barred by
limitation.
xiv) The relief of specific performance is discretionary in nature.
While granting such relief, the Trial Court has to consider
the conduct of the plaintiff.
xv)
The plaintiff approached the Court with unclean hands.
xvi) The evidence of PWs.1 to 4 is contrary to the pleadings in
the plaint and Ex.A6 - legal notice.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
xvii) Without considering the said aspects, learned trial Court
decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff erroneously and
the same is liable to be set aside.
17. Contentions of the respondent - plaintiff:
i)
Under Ex. A1 - agreement of sale, the defendant agreed to
receive balance sale consideration within six (06) months
from the date of resolution of dispute before the MRO.
ii)
The defendant received an amount of Rs.10 lakhs on
25.09.2000 under Ex.A1 agreement and also issued Ex.A2
receipt in the presence of PWs.2 and 3.
iii)
Once the dispute is resolved, it is the duty of the defendant
to inform the said fact to the plaintiff. In the present case,
the defendant failed to inform about resolution of the
dispute between him and Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah.
iv)
The dispute between the defendant and Mr. P. Bala
Narsaiah with regard to the suit schedule property was
pending before the Revenue Authorities and Civil Courts.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
In both the fora, the defendant succeeded. Even then, he
has not informed the said fact to the plaintiff.
v)
In Ex.A9 - Reply dated 12.03.2008, he has denied the
execution of Ex.A1 - agreement of sale, demanded to
furnish copy of the same. Therefore, under Ex. A10 - reply
notice dated 22.03.2008, the plaintiff furnished a copy of
the same to learned counsel, who had issued Ex. A9 - reply
notice on behalf of the defendant. The plaintiff and the
defendant have known each other.
vi)
Under Ex.A9 - reply notice, the defendant denied the
execution of Ex.A1, whereas in his written statement he
admitted about the same.
vii)
The plaintiff expressed his readiness and willingness to
perform his part of contract under Ex.A1 and he has
specifically stated in Ex.A6 - legal notice and the plaint.
viii) On consideration of the said aspects only, more
particularly, the evidence both oral and documentary,
learned trial Court decreed the suit. It is a reasoned
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
judgment. There is no error in it. Even then, the defendant
preferred the present appeal and the same is liable to be
dismissed.
18. In the light of the aforesaid rival submissions, the following
points arise for consideration:
(i)
Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
(ii)
Whether time is the essence of contract under Ex.A1 agreement of sale dated 25.09.2000?
(iii)
Whether the plaintiff failed to adhere to the time schedule
and the obligation cast upon him under Ex.A1 agreement of sale?
(iv)
Whether the plaintiff has expressed readiness and
willingness to perform his part of contract as required
under Section - 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 and
established the same before the Trial Court?
(v)
Whether the litigation between the defendant and Mr. P.
Bala Narsaiah is nothing to do with the present litigation
between the plaintiff and the defendant herein?
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
(vi)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to equitable and
discretionary relief of specific performance of agreement
of sale dated 25.09.2000?
(vii) To what relief?
19. Point No.(i) to (iii):
i) In Ex. A1 - agreement of sale, the defendant agreed for sale of
suit schedule property for a total sale consideration of Rs.40,00,000/(Rupees Forty Lakhs Only). The plaintiff had paid an amount of
Rs.10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs Only) on 25.09.2000 i.e., on the date
of execution of agreement of sale, towards advance sale consideration.
He agreed to pay the balance sale consideration after resolution of
dispute between him and Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah before the MRO and
execute a registered sale deed in favour of the plaintiff. On receipt of the
said amount of Rs.10 lakhs, the defendant had issued Ex.A2 - cash
receipt dated 25.09.2000. PW.2 and PW.3 are witnesses to the said
receipt.
ii) It is apt to note that there is dispute between the defendant and
Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah with regard to the suit schedule property.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
According to the defendant, he purchased the suit schedule property
from one Mr. M. Satyanarayana under a private sale deed. Thereupon,
his name was mutated in revenue records. He has also obtained pattadar
passbook and title deed. After purchase of the suit schedule property,
litigation cropped up with Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah. The claim of the said
P. Bala Narsaiah is that he purchased the suit schedule property from
Mrs. Indira D/o Mr. M. Satyanarayana, under a registered sale deed.
Later, P. Bala Narsaiah also filed a suit for recovery of possession. The
defendant as DW.1 admitted the aforesaid facts during crossexamination.
iii)
The defendant made an application before the MRO for
mutation of the suit schedule property in his name. After the issuance of
mutation proceedings, the MRO had issued pattadar passbook and title
deed in his favour. Aggrieved by the mutation proceedings being issued
in favour of the defendant, Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah filed an application
before the RDO challenging the said mutation proceedings.
iv) Pursuant to the application filed by Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah
under Sections 4, 5 and 6-A of the Andhra Pradesh Rights in Land and
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
Pattadar Pass Books Act, 1971 (hereinafter, “the Act, 1971”), seeking
mutation/amendment of ROR, vide Ex. A12 proceedings dated
23.01.2002; the MRO, Ghatkesar Mandal, ordered to incorporate his
name in respect of the suit schedule property in revenue records as
pattadar. Aggrieved by the said proceedings, the defendant preferred an
appeal before the Special Grade Deputy Collector-cum-RDO, East
Division, Rangareddy District. Vide Ex.A13 order dated 13.12.2005, the
Special Grade Deputy Collector-cum-RDO, East Division, Rangareddy
District, dismissed the appeal filed by the defendant. Challenging the
said order, dated 13.12.2005, the defendant filed revision before Joint
Collector-II, Rangareddy District. Vide Ex.A14 order dated 23.09.2006,
the Joint Collector-II, Rangareddy District, set aside the order dated
13.12.2005 passed by the RDO and the order dated 23.01.2002 passed
by the MRO and remanded the matter to the MRO for necessary action
under the Act, 1971.
v)
Challenging the said order dated 23.09.2006 of the Joint
Collector-II, Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah filed a writ petition vide
W.P.No.16119 of 2007. Vide Ex.A15 order dated 09.08.2007, this Court
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
dismissed the said writ petition. Challenging the order passed by learned
Single Judge, Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah preferred an Intra- Court Appeal vide
W.A. No.979 of 2007. Vide Ex.A16 Order dated 09.11.2010, a Division
Bench of this Court dismissed the appeal confirming the order of learned
Single Judge.
vi) Perusal of record would also reveal that Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah
had filed a suit in O.S. No.184 of 1998 against the defendant seeking
recovery of possession. The same was dismissed on 31.12.2003 vide
Ex.A17 - judgment. Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah preferred an appeal vide A.S.
No.30 of 2004, which was dismissed on 13.04.2006 vide Ex.A18. He
also preferred a second appeal vide Second Appeal No. 1184 of 2006,
which was dismissed on 13.11.2006 vide Ex.A19 judgment. He also
approached the Supreme Court by filing Special Leave to Appeal (Civil)
No.5076 of 2007, which was dismissed on 26.03.2007 vide Ex.A20.
vii) Thereafter, the plaintiff got issued Ex.A6- legal notice dated
22.02.2008 to the defendant demanding the execution a registered sale
deed in his favour. The defendant replied vide Ex.A9 on 12.03.2008,
denying the execution of Ex.A1 - agreement of sale, however, sought a
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
copy of the said agreement of sale. Vide Ex.A10 – letter/reply notice
dated 22.03.2008, the plaintiff furnished copy of the agreement of sale to
learned counsel for the defendant. Thereafter, he has filed the suit on
26.03.2008. PWs.1 to 4 specifically deposed the said facts. Therefore,
the defendant cannot contend that the suit is barred by limitation.
viii) It is apt to note that Article 54 of the Limitation Act has two
limbs, i.e., “the date fixed for the performance, or, if no such date is
fixed, when the plaintiff has notice that performance is refused”. If there
is a specific date fixed for performance, the limitation period would be
three years from the date, otherwise, three years from the refusal to
perform the said contract. The said principle was also held by the
Supreme Court in Usha Devi v. Ramkumar Singh1. In the present
case, Ex.A1 - agreement of sale is dated 25.09.2000 and an amount of
Rs.10 Lakhs was paid by the plaintiff. As per recitals of the said
agreement, the balance amount is payable within six months after the
dispute between the defendant and said Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah before the
MRO stands resolved. The said dispute went up to the Division Bench
. (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1915
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
of this Court in W.A. No.979 of 2007 and the same was dismissed on
09.11.2010. Simultaneously, Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah also pursued
proceedings before the Civil Court vide O.S. No.184 of 1998 and the
matter went up to the Supreme Court, where by virtue of dismissal of the
SLP, the litigation came to an end on 26.03.2007.
Thereafter, the
plaintiff got issued a legal notice on 22.02.2008 and thereafter filed the
suit on 26.03.2008 i.e., within three years from the date of conclusion of
proceedings before the Supreme Court. As such, the said suit is filed
well within the limitation. On consideration of the said aspects, learned
trial Court held that the suit is filed within limitation. Thus, the
defendant cannot contend that the suit is barred by limitation.
ix) With regard to the contention that time is the essence of the
contract, reference is being made to the judgment in Saradamani
Kandappan v. S. Rajalakshmi2, wherein the Supreme Court held in
agreements for sale of immovable property, time is ordinarily not the
essence of contract unless such intention is evident from the express
. (2011) 12 SCC 18
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
terms of the agreement, or can be gathered by implication from the
terms and circumstances of the transaction.
x) In K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima3 , the Apex court held that
“whether time is of the essence in a contract”, has to be culled out from
the reading of the entire contract as well as the surrounding
circumstances. Merely having an explicit clause may not be sufficient to
make time the essence of the contract.
xi) In Indira Kaur v. Sheo Lal Kapoor4, the Apex Court held
that in transactions of sale of immovable properties, time is not the
essence of the contract. In the case of immovable property, there is no
presumption as to time being the essence of the contract.
xii) In the light of aforementioned judgments, the defendant
cannot contend that the plaintiff failed to adhere to timelines mentioned
in Ex.A1 - Agreement of Sale. Point Nos.(i) to (iii) are accordingly
answered.
. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1014
. (1988) 2 SCC 488
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
20. Point No.(iv):
i) In Ex.A1, it is agreed by both the parties that the plaintiff failed
to pay the balance sale consideration within six months after resolution
of the dispute before the MRO. The Revenue litigation between the
defendant and Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah went up to a Division Bench of this
Court, which dismissed the Writ Appeal filed by Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah
on 09.11.2010.
ii)
As discussed above, the revenue litigation between the
defendant and Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah ended on 09.11.2010 vide dismissal
of Writ Appeal No. 979 of 2007 by a Division Bench of this Court.
Simultaneously, the civil litigation between them ended on 26.03.2007
vide dismissal of SLP (C) No.5076 of 2007 by the Supreme Court.
Thereafter, the plaintiff got issued Ex. A6 legal notice dated 22.02.2008.
In the said notice, the plaintiff specifically pleaded that he has enough
resources to pay the entire balance sale consideration to the defendant at
any short notice. The defendant is well aware of the same. It is also
further stated in Ex.A6 legal notice that the plaintiff has always been
ready and willing to perform his part of contract. Even as on the date of
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
issuance of the said notice, he had the necessary resources to pay and
obtain a sale deed in his favour.
iii) It is also apposite to note that, even in the plaint, the Plaintiff
specifically pleaded that he has always been ready and willing to
perform his part of the contract. Further, being a businessman, payment
of the balance sale consideration under the Agreement was never an
issue for him, nor was it financially burdensome. He at all times made
arrangements to draw the funds through his regular source of finance
and paid to the defendant as and when required. Both the plaintiff and
the defendant are well known to each other. The said fact is admitted by
PWs.1 to 4 and DWs.1 to 4 in their depositions.
iv) It is also apt to note that DW.1 during cross-examination
admitted that he does not know whether the plaintiff owns and possesses
land, rice mills, buildings and complexes in Uppal, Ramanthapur. He
knows that plaintiff owns one building and it was leased out to a school
and the said building is situated adjacent to the suit schedule property.
DW.2, daughter of the defendant, also admitted during crossexamination that the plaintiff is having rice mill complex at Ramantapur.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
Huge buildings are at Uppal and the land is situated in the vicinity of
Uppal. In the light of the same, the defendant cannot contend that the
plaintiff failed to perform his part of contract despite expressing
readiness and willingness at all times.
v)
In Syed Dastagiri v. T. R. Gopalakrishna Shetty5, the
Supreme Court held that plaintiff can always tender the amount to the
defendant or deposit in the court, towards performance of his obligation
under the contract. Such tender rather exhibits the willingness of the
plaintiff to perform his part of obligation. What is not essential is only
means need not do but does not mean he cannot do so. When the
plaintiff has tendered the balance amount in Court even without the
court order, it cannot be constitute adversely against the plaintiff under
explanation -1 of Section 16 (c) of the Act, 1963.
vi) It is apt to note that in Zarina Siddique v. A. Ramalingam6,
the Apex Court held that relief of specific performance is equitable and
discretionary and therefore, courts have to consider the conduct of the
parties and that parties must come before the court with clean hands.
. (1999) 6 SCC 337
. (2015) 1 SCC 705
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
vii) In R.C. Chandiok v. Chunilal Subarwal7, the Apex court
held that readiness and willingness cannot be treated as a straightjacket
formula. This has to be determined from the entirety of the facts and
circumstances relevant to the intention and conduct of the party
concerned.
viii) In Sugharsingh v. Harisingh (dead through L.Rs.)8 and
others, the Apex Court held that the Court while dealing with a suit for
specific performance, more particularly readiness and willingness to
perform the contract, has to consider overall circumstances, conduct on
the part of the parties and prayer of the plaintiff in whose favour
execution of agreement shall be made has been held to be proved. They
are the relevant factors to be considered for the purpose of deciding
readiness and willingness.
ix) In Motilal Jain v. Ramdasi Devi9, the Apex Court held that
the readiness and willingness need not be in specific phraseology and
language.
. (1970) 3 SCC 140
. (2021) 17 SCC 705
. AIR 2000 SC 2408
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
x) In Chand Rani v. Kamal Rani10, the Apex Court held that
although time is ordinarily not the essence in contracts relating to
immovable property, the Court must examine the following conditions,
to determine whether performance within the stipulated time was
intended.
(i)
Express terms of the contract;
(ii)
Nature of property, and
(iii)
Surrounding circumstances.
The Apex Court further held that where the conduct of the purchaser
demonstrates lack of readiness and willingness to perform contractual
obligations, the decree for specific performance cannot be granted. The
relevant paragraphs are extracted hereunder:
“25. From an analysis of the above case-law it is
clear that in the case of sale of immovable property
there is no presumption as to time being the essence
of the contract. Even if it is not of the essence of the
contract the Court may infer that it is to be performed
in a reasonable time if the conditions are:
1. From the express terms of the contract;
2. from the nature of the property; and
. (1993) 1 SCC 519
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
3. from the surrounding circumstances, for
example: the object of making the contract.
29. The analysis of evidence would also point out
that the plaintiff was not willing to pay this amount
unless vacant delivery of possession of one room on
the ground floor was given. In cross-examination it
was deposed that since income tax clearance
certificate had not been obtained the sum of Rs
98,000 was not paid. Unless the property was
redeemed the payment would not be made. If this
was the attitude it is clear that the plaintiff was
insisting upon delivery of possession as a condition
precedent for making this payment. The income tax
certificate was necessary only for completion of sale.
We are unable to see how these obligations on the
part of the defendant could be insisted upon for
payment of Rs 98,000. Therefore, we conclude that
though as a general proposition of law time is not the
essence of the contract in the case of a sale of
immovable property yet the parties intended to make
time as the essence under clause (1) of the suit
agreement. From this point of view, we are unable to
see how the case in Nathulal [(1969) 3 SCC 120 :
(1970) 2 SCR 854] could have any application to the
facts of this case.”
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
xi) In Katta Sujatha Reddy v. Siddamsetty Infra Projects (P)
Ltd.11, considering the fact that as agreement of sale for an immovable
property, there was an obligation on the part of the Vendor therein that
he has to produce income tax exemption certificate and agriculture
certificate, placing reliance on the principle laid down in Chand Rani10,
the Apex Court held that in sale of immovable property, there is no
presumption that time is essence of the contract, however, the Court may
infer performance in a reasonable time if the conditions are evident from
the express terms of the contract, from the nature of the property, and
from the surrounding circumstances.
xii)
Gaddipati Divija v. Pathuri Samrajyam12, the Vendor
therein agreed to measure and demarcate the subject land therein in three
months. The Apex Court held that unless the vendor got the subject land
measured and demarcated within the agreed three months, it would be
impossible for the Purchaser to get a sale deed executed, as such, the
question of paying the balance sale consideration does not arise. It was
. (2023) 1 SCC 355
. 2023 SCC OnLine SC 442
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
further held that when specific performance of the terms of the contract
has not been done, the question of time being the essence does not arise.
xiii) The sum and substance of the aforesaid judgments is that the
plaintiff has to always plead and prove readiness and willingness to
perform his part of contract and also establish the same. The relief of
specific performance is an equitable and discretionary relief. The parties
seeking the said relief have to approach the court with clean hands. The
court while dealing with suit for specific performance has to consider
the conduct of the parties and overall circumstances of the case.
xiv) As discussed above, the plaintiff has been pleading readiness
and willingness to perform his part of contract right from the beginning.
With regard to conduct of the parties, as discussed above, under Ex.A9 reply notice dated 12.03.2008, the defendant denied execution of Ex.A1
- agreement of sale and demanded copy of the said agreement of sale.
Under Ex.A10 - letter/reply, the plaintiff has furnished copy of the same
to the counsel of the defendant, who issued Ex.A9 - reply notice. In the
written statement, the defendant has admitted the execution of Ex.A1 agreement of sale.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
xv) The defendant completed his B.Sc., but discontinued his
education in law. He admitted the same during cross-examination. He
also admitted that Ex.A1 - agreement of sale dated 25.09.2000 was
executed by him in favour of the plaintiff. Ex.A1 was prepared in his
own handwriting as per the instructions of PW.1. He has not mentioned
the said fact in his written statement. When a question was posed to the
defendant during cross-examination as to whether it is mentioned in
Ex.A1 agreement of sale that irrespective of the result of the MRO
proceedings, the plaintiff has to pay the balance sale consideration and
get the registered sale deed from him, to which the defendant answered
that there is no mention in Ex.A1 with regard to registration aspect
irrespective of result of MRO proceedings.
xvi) The defendant further admitted that he has not received
amount from the plaintiff after dismissal of orders from MRO. He has
received the amount from the plaintiff in the year 2002. On 28.03.2003,
he paid an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- to DW.2, his daughter on the request
of the plaintiff. He also further admitted with regard to receipt of Ex.A6
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
notice, issuance of Ex.A9 reply and Ex.A10 rejoinder along with copy of
agreement of sale dated 25.09.2000.
xvii) During cross-examination, the defendant further admitted
that he has received amounts from the plaintiff under Exs.A2 to A5
receipts and that altogether he has received Rs.12,10,000/- from the
plaintiff. In his chief-examination, he has stated that he did not receive
any further amounts from the plaintiff and all the cash receipts are
forged and fabricated, as such, he denied correctness of the same.
However, he has clarified that the same is with regard to the amount of
Rs.7,40,000/-, and not regarding Exs.A2 to A5 receipts. He has also not
issued any notice to the plaintiff for return of Ex.A1 - agreement of sale.
He was having good relations with the plaintiff up to the year 2003.
Though during cross-examination he has admitted that he demanded the
plaintiff to return Ex.A1 for which the plaintiff replied that Ex.A1 is
with the brother of the plaintiff, he has not mentioned the said aspect
either in his written statement or in his chief-examination affidavit.
xviii)
Thus, the aforesaid admissions and evidence of the
defendant would reveal that he has taken contradictory stands. In Ex.A9
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
- reply to Ex.A6 - legal notice, he denied the execution of agreement of
sale itself, however, during cross-examination he admitted about the
same, receipt of an amount of Rs.12,10,000/- and also execution of
Exs.A2 to 5 - receipts. Whereas, it is the consistent stand of the plaintiff
with regard to execution of Ex.A1 - agreement of sale, payment of
advance sale consideration and issuance of Exs.A2 to A4 - cash receipts
by the defendant. Therefore, the conduct of the defendant is not bona
fide. On consideration of the said aspects only, learned trial Court
decreed the suit and there is no error in it.
21. Point No.(v):
i) It is the specific contention of the defendant that the litigation
between the said Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah and the defendant is nothing to do
with Ex.A1 - agreement of sale. The said contention of the defendant is
untenable. In Ex.A1, it is specifically mentioned that the plaintiff shall
pay balance sale consideration six months after resolution of revenue
litigation before the MRO.
As discussed above, the said revenue
litigation had ended on 09.11.2010 on dismissal of W.A. No.979 of 2007
by a Division Bench of this Court.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
ii) As discussed above, the civil litigation between the defendant
and Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah went up to the Supreme Court and the same
ended only on 26.03.2007 after the dismissal of SLP. Therefore, the
defendant cannot contend that the litigation between him and Mr. P. Bala
Narsaiah is nothing to do with the Ex. A1 agreement of sale. The
conduct of the defendant would show that he is trying to avoid the
obligation cast upon him i.e., receipt of balance sale consideration on
resolution of disputes between him and Mr. P. Bala Narsaiah, and the
execution of a registered sale deed in favour of the plaintiff. On
consideration of the said aspects only, learned trial Court decreed the
suit in favour of the plaintiff.
22. Point No.(vi):
i) As discussed above, the relief of specific performance is an
equitable relief. Parties have to approach the Court with clean hands. It
is the specific contention of the plaintiff right from the beginning of
issuance of Ex.A6 - legal notice that he is ready and willing to perform
his part of obligation. Thus, the conduct of the plaintiff is bona fide
whereas the conduct of the defendant is not bona fide. He has taken
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
contradictory stands. At the initial stage, he has denied the execution of
Ex.A1 and issuance of Exs.A2 to 5 - receipts in Ex.A9 - reply dated
12.03.2008, whereas, in the written statement and his deposition, he has
admitted the same. Therefore, on consideration of the said aspects only,
learned trial Court decreed the suit. There is no error in it.
ii) It is apt to note that the defendant contended that he arranged
hand loan of Rs. 5 lakhs through his daughter (DW.2), which was
received by the plaintiff vide Ex. B1 receipt. The said fact was also
admitted by DW.2. The learned trial Court analyzed the entire evidence,
both oral and documentary and gave a specific finding in paragraph
Nos.20, 21 and 22 that the defence taken by the defendant under Ex.B1
is weak and there is no mention of the same in written statement and
affidavit of DW.1 filed in lieu of his examination-in-chief. There is no
error in it.
23. Point No.(vii):
i)
As discussed above, learned trial Court decreed the suit
considering the entire evidence, both oral and documentary. It is a
reasoned judgment and well-founded. The appellant herein - defendant
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
failed to make out any case to interfere with the said judgment.
Therefore, this appeal is liable to be dismissed.
ii) In K. Prakash v. B.R. Sampath Kumar13, the Apex court
held that when the trial court exercises its discretion in one way of the
other after appreciation of entire evidence and materials on record, the
appellate court should not interfere unless it is established that the
discretion has been exercised perversely, arbitrarily or against judicial
principles, the appellate Court should also not exercise its discretion
against the grant of specific performance on extraneous considerations
or sympathetic considerations.
iii) In Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari14, a Three-Judge
Bench of the Apex Court observed that while reversing a reasoned
judgment of the Trial Court, the Appellate Court must remain conscious
that the findings of fact recorded by the trial Court, particularly those
based on conflicting oral evidence and assessment of the credibility of
witnesses, should ordinarily not interfere with such finding. Though the
Appellate Court is competent to re-appreciate the evidence and reverse
. (2015) 1 SCC 587
. (2001) 3 SCC 179
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
such findings, interference is warranted where the decision of the Trial
Court suffers from material irregularity, is based on inadmissible
evidence, or is otherwise unsustainable. The Supreme Court further held
that while reversing a finding of fact, the Appellate Court must come
into close quarters with the reasoning assigned by the Trial Court and
assign its own cogent reasons for arriving at a different conclusion.
iv) In Lakshmi v. Gopi15, the Apex Court reiterated that the First
Appellate Court, being the final Court of fact, is required to
independently reappraise the evidence. While reversing the findings of
the Trial Court, the Appellate Court is bound to record clear, cogent and
succinct reasons for its disagreement rather than passing a cryptic order.
Mere extraction of the Trial Court’s reasoning followed by a general
observation that the Court below failed to understand the dispute would
not suffice. Even where the Trial Court’s reasoning is found erroneous,
the Appellate Court must give its own reasons for arriving at a different
conclusion. Reasons being the lifeblood of every judicial conclusion, a
. 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 681
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
judgment of reversal without due application of mind would be contrary
to the settled principles governing appellate jurisdiction.
v) It is apt to note that vide order dated 21.12.2017 in ASMP
No.3201 of 2017 in A.S. No.1273 of 2017, this Court permitted the
plaintiff to withdraw the balance sale consideration deposited by him
before the trial Court pursuant to the impugned judgment and decree. It
is the specific contention of Mr. V. Hari Haran, learned Senior Counsel
appearing on behalf of the plaintiff that the said amount is lying to the
credit of the aforesaid suit. Though this Court permitted the plaintiff to
withdraw the said amount, he did not withdraw the same.
24.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, this appeal is
dismissed confirming the judgment and decree dated 06.09.2017 passed
in O.S.No.271 of 2008 by the learned III Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District. In the circumstances of the case,
there shall be no order as to costs.
A.S. No.1273 of 2017
KL,J & BRMR,J
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in
this appeal shall stand closed.
____________________________
K. LAKSHMAN, J
7th September, 2026
VVR/Mgr
____________________________
B.R. MADHUSUDHAN RAO, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review