Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 347 of 2020
Date of Decision: 07.06.2022
Shri. Salgira R. Marak
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. U.K. Nair, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.P. Sharma, Adv.
Mr. A. Chetia, Adv.
Ms. S.K. Nongrum, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA.
Mr. A. H. Kharwanlang, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The instant writ proceeding is a second round of litigation,
wherein the petitioner is before this Court. In the earlier round vide WP(C)
No. 382/2019, the petitioner had challenged two notifications bearing No.
SG.12/97/169 and SG.12/97/170 both dated 08.08.2019, whereby the State
respondents had created a post of Officer on Special Duty (OSD), personal
to the petitioner in the Administrative Department of the Printing and
Stationery Department. This Court by judgment and order dated 17.09.2020,
allowed the writ petition and quashed the impugned orders as being
unsustainable in law. The State respondents thereafter, preferred a Writ
Appeal being W.A No. 20/2020, which was however disposed of on
withdrawal on the ground that two fresh notifications both dated 09.11.2020,
had been issued, one, whereby a post of OSD was shown to have been
created in the Administrative Department and by the second, the petitioner
stood transferred from the post of Director, Printing and Stationery
Department to the post of OSD (Technical) in the Administrative
Department of Printing and Stationery. The said two notifications dated
09.11.2020, have now been impugned by way of this writ petition.
2.
It has been contended by the petitioner that the impugned
notifications both dated 09.11.2020, amount to an overreach/or sitting in
appeal over the earlier judgment dated 17.09.2020 passed in WP(C) No.
382/2019, inasmuch as, these notifications had been issued in partial
modification and in continuation of the earlier notifications dated
08.08.2019, which had been set aside and quashed by this Court. On this
count alone, it has been submitted that the notifications presently under
challenge are liable to be set aside and quashed.
3.
Apart from the above noted main ground of challenge, Mr. U.K.
Nair, learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
notifications creating a post of OSD (Technical) in the Senior Grade of the
Printing and Stationery (Technical Grade), is untenable as the Senior Grade
is a cadre in itself and as per Rule 4(2) of the Printing and Stationery
(Technical) Service Rules, each post forms an independent cadre and
movement from one cadre to another must be in accordance with rules. It is
also submitted that Rule 7 of the rules which provides for the method of
recruitment and the manner in which posts in different cadres are to be filled
up, does not permit or provide for such appointment, that is of OSD
(Technical) in the Senior Grade.
4.
It has also been argued by the learned senior counsel that the
manner of recruitment as given in the second paragraph of the notification
dated 09.11.2020, prescribing the manner of recruitment to the post of OSD
(Technical) is beyond the powers conferred under Rule 6(1) of the rules and
that the creation of the post of OSD (Technical) is not specifically mentioned
and incorporated in the cadre of Director of Printing and Stationery. He
submits the fact that the post of OSD (Technical) was created in the Senior
Grade and not in the cadre of Director, is clear from Paragraph-4 of the
impugned notification, whereby strength of the cadre after the alleged
creation of the post of OSD has been increased to 8 (eight). It has also been
urged that the post of OSD (Technical) was not created for the Directorate
Service, but created for the service in the Administrative Department which
he contends is governed by another set of rules and not by the service rules
applicable to the petitioner.
5.
The learned senior counsel has placed reliance on various
judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in support of the above noted
contentions, where it has been held that an inter-parte judgment of a
competent court of law cannot be said at naught or over-ruled by an
executive fiat. He concludes by submitting that the entire action of the
respondents is to oust the petitioner from the post of Director, which has
resulted in the complete violation of the rules and also amounts to sitting on
appeal over the earlier judgment of this Court, which is impermissible.
Accordingly, he prays that the impugned notifications be set aside and
quashed.
6.
Learned Advocate General, in reply to the submissions and
contentions of the counsel for the petitioner submits that both the impugned
notifications dated 09.11.2020, have been passed under Rule 6(1) of the
Service Rules amending the composition and strength of service of the
department and as such, has removed the basis of the judgment and order
rendered by this Court on 17.09.2020. The same he contends, are valid and
are not hit by the said judgment of this Court, and in fact, has removed the
defect in the earlier notification which had been pointed out by this Court. It
is contended that the creation of the post of OSD (Technical) is in accordance
with Rule 6(1) of the rules, thereby altering the strength and composition of
service in the Printing and Stationery Department which is to be filled up by
way of transfer from the post of Director, Printing and Stationery or an
equivalent post in the cadre. It is also submitted that the said post is no longer
made personal to the petitioner but also provides that the said post is a Senior
Grade post.
7.
It is further submitted that in exercise of the rule making power
conferred under Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the defects pointed
out by this Court vide judgment dated 17.09.2020, have been removed by
creating the post of OSD (Technical) after altering the strength and
composition of service, and this creation is also in the nature of a policy
decision based on administrative consideration. The transfer of the petitioner
to the newly created post it is argued, does not amount to deputation of the
petitioner to an external department as the petitioner would continue to be
governed by the department of Printing and Stationery. It is lastly submitted
that, transfer is an incidence of service and that the petitioner has no vested
right to remain in the post of Director, Printing and Stationery Department.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties. In the earlier round of
litigation that is WP(C) No. 382/2019, this Court by judgment and order
dated 17.09.2020, had quashed and set aside notifications No. SG.12/97/169
and SG.12/97/170 both dated 08.08.2019, on the ground that the same were
unsustainable in law, as the same was issued in violation of statutory rules.
The notification No. SG.12/97/169 dated 08.08.2019, sanctioned the
creation of one post of OSD personal to the petitioner in the administrative
department and by notification No. SG.12/97/170, the petitioner was
appointed as OSD in the said administrative department.
9.
The impugned notifications herein, being No. SG.12/97/238
and SG.12/97/239 both dated 09.11.2020, were issued with the same
objective that is the creation of one post of OSD (Technical) in the
administrative department and the transfer of the petitioner to the said post.
However, the creation of the OSD (Technical) post is stated to be in exercise
of powers conferred by Rule 6(1) of the Printing and Stationery (Technical)
Service Rules, 1995, in the Senior Grade of the Printing and Stationery
(Technical) cadre. The said notification for the sake of convenience is
reproduced herein below:
GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
PRINTING AND STATIONERY DEPARTMENT
****
No.SG.12/97/238
Dated Shillong, the 9th November, 2020.
From:
Smti. O.D. Mairom.
Under Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya.
To
The Director Printing and Stationery.
Meghalaya, Shillong.
Subject:
Creation of 1(one) post of Officer on Special Duty (Technical).
Ref:-
NO.SG.12/97/169 dated Shillong, the 8th August, 2019.
Sir,
In exercise of powers conferred by sub-rule (1) of Rule 6 of the Printing
and Stationery (Technical) Service Rules, 1995 and upon review of the administrative
requirements of the Department of Printing and Stationery, the Governor of Meghalaya
is pleased to sanction the creation of 1(one) post of Officer on Special Duty (Technical)
in the Administrative Department in the scale of Pay Level 21, in the Senior Grade of the
Printing and Stationery (Technical) Cadre of the Department of Printing and Stationery,
Government of Meghalaya.
The post of Officer on Special Duty (Technical) in the Administrative
Department shall be filled by transfer, from the post of Director, Printing and Stationery
or person holding equivalent post within the same cadre.
The expenditure for the said post is debitable at par with all other posts
in the cadre, under the head of Account “2058 STATIONERY AND PRINTING - 103GOVT PRESSES (01) Press Administrative 01 Salaries – General 2020-2021.
The sanctioned strength of the cadre after creation of the post of Officer
on Special Duty (Technical) in the Administrative Department stands at 08.
This partially modifies this Department’s sanction letter issued vide NO.
SG.12/97/169, dated 8th August, 2019.
Yours faithfully
Under Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya
Printing and Stationery Department
Dated Shillong, the 9th November, 2020.
Memo. No.SG.12/97/238-A
Copy forwarded to :1. Finance (E.C.I) Department with reference to their I/D No. FC(1) 108/201920 dated 19.7.2019.
2. Personnel & A.R. (A) Department with reference to their I/D No. 27/19 dated
15.5.19
3. Treasury Officer, Shillong South
By Order etc.,
Under Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya
Printing and Stationery Department
Dated Shillong, the 9th November, 2020.
Memo. No.SG.12/97/238-B
Copy forwarded to :1. The Principal Accountant General (Audit) Meghalaya (Attention : CASS. Section)
Shillong- 793001
2. The Accountant General (A & E), Meghalaya, Shillong
By Order etc.,
Financial Adviser to the Govt. of Meghalaya
Printing and Stationery Department
10.
By
notification
No.
SG.12/97/239
dated
09.11.2020,
consequent to the creation of the said post OSD, the petitioner was
transferred to this post. Notification No. SG.12/97/239 is reproduced herein
below:
GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
PRINTING AND STATIONERY DEPARTMENT
****
ORDERS BY THE GOVERNOR
NOTIFICATION
Dated Shillong, the 9th November, 2020.
No.SG.12/97/239 - In continuation to Notification No. SG.12/97/170 dated 8th
August, 2019 and consequent upon the creation of one post of Officer on Special Duty
in the Administrative Department of the Printing and Stationery vide letter No.
SG.12/97/169 dated Shillong the 8th August, 2019 with partial modification vide letter
No. SG.12/97/238 dated Shillong the 9th November, 2020; the Governor of
Meghalaya is pleased to transfer Shri. Salgira R. Marak, Director, Printing and
Stationery, Meghalaya, Shillong to the post of Officer on Special Duty (Technical) in
the Administrative Department of the Printing and Stationery Department in the scale
of pay level 21 with effect from the date of taking over charge until further orders.
(Smti. M. War Nongbri, IAS)
Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya.
Printing and Stationery Department.
Dated Shillong, the 9th November, 2020
Memo No.SG.12/97/239-A
Copy to:1. P.S. to Chief Minister, for kind information of the Chief Minister
2. P.S. to Minister Incharge Printing and Stationery Department for kind
information of the Minister
3. P.S. to Chief Secretary for kind information of the Chief Secretary
4. P.A. to Commissioner & Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya P& S Department
5. P.A. to Secretary Printing and Stationery Department
6. Joint Secretary, Printing and Stationery Department
7. Director Printing & Stationery, Meghalaya, Shillong
8. The Accountant General (A & E) Meghalaya, Shillong
9. Personnel & A.R. (A) Department
10. Finance (E.C.I) Department.
11. Director Printing and Stationery, Meghalaya Shillong. He is requested to publish
the above Notification in the next issue of the Meghalaya Gazette.
12. Treasury Officer, Shillong South
13. Nazir, Meghalaya (Civil) Secretariat for information and necessary action.
14. Joint Director Directorate Printing and Stationery, Meghalaya, Shillong.
15. Guard File.
By order etc.,
Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya
Printing and Stationery Department
****
11.
On a bare perusal of these two notifications, firstly with regard
to No. SG.12/97/238, the last para states that this notification partially
modifies the departments sanctioned letter issued vide No. SG.12/97/169
dated 08.08.2019. The second notification No. SG.12/97/239 states that the
transfer order has been issued in continuation of notification No.
SG.12/97/170 dated 08.08.2019. The issuance of these two impugned
notifications dated 09.11.2020, on the basis and in continuation of the earlier
notifications dated 08.08.2019 is strange and though it has been submitted,
that these notifications have removed the basis of the judgment of this Court
dated 17.09.2020, it cannot be said to have achieved the same, for the basic
reason that they have been issued in partial modification and in continuation
of notifications that no longer exist as they have been quashed and set aside
by this Court.
12.
On the other aspect that is, whether the rules permit the creation
of a post of OSD (Technical) in a Senior Grade of the Printing and Stationery
(Technical Grade), it is noted that Rule 4(2) has provided that, each post
form an independent cadre and movement from one cadre to another must
be in accordance with the rules. Rule 7 of the rules provides the method of
recruitment in which post in different cadres are to be filled up. Rule 4(1)
and (2) and Rule 7(1) for the sake of convenience are reproduced herein
below:
“ 4. Composition of the Service :- (1) The service shall consist
of the following grades and posts:(I) Senior Grade
(1) Director
Printing and Stationery.
(2) Jt. Director
(II) Grade I
(III) Grade II
Deputy Director (Printing),
-
Asstt. Director (Printing).
(2) The categories of posts in clause (i), (ii) and (iii) of Subrule (1) shall form an independent cadre. Members of the
lower cadre shall not claim for appointment to any of the
higher cadre except in accordance with the provisions made
in these Rules.
7. Method of Recruitment:- (1) Appointment to the post of
Director shall be made by promotion from amongst the
confirmed Joint Director (Printing & Stationery) having the
experience as specified in Schedule-II and included in the
select list approved under Sub-rule (5) of Rule 10.
Provided that if the appointing Authority is satisfied
that suitable and technically qualified persons are not
available for appointment by promotion, the post may be filled
up by direct recruitment on the result of the examination
conducted by the Commission or adopt such other method for
appointment to the post.”
13.
A perusal of Rule 4(1) shows that, the service consists of 3
grades with the post of Director and Joint Director being placed in the Senior
Grade over Grade-I and Grade-II, and as per Rule 4(2) these posts formed
an independent cadre. Rule 7 providing the method of recruitment does not
speak of appointment to the post of a cadre of OSD (Technical) and
moreover, the second paragraph of the impugned notification dated
09.11.2020, prescribing the manner of recruitment to the post of OSD does
not find place in Rule 6(1) of the rules. The creation of the post of OSD
(Technical) in the Senior Grade and not in the cadre of Director therefore, is
highly questionable especially the fact that it is specifically given that the
said post has been created in the Administrative Department. This exercise
by the respondents is a thinly disguised attempt to implement the earlier
notifications dated 08.08.2019, in placing the petitioner in the
Administrative Department at all costs and to keep him away from raising a
legitimate claim to continue in the post of Director which he was occupying,
by incorporating the manner of recruitment in the impugned notification
dated 09.11.2020, which allows the filling up of the post of OSD (Technical)
by way of transfer from the post of Director, Printing and Stationery.
14.
In the realm of legislative action in rendering the decision of
Court ineffective by removing defects, the same is usually resorted to by
validating legislations, wherein the defects are removed with retrospective
effect and the portions that had been declared as invalid by the concerned
Court are then made valid and effective. In such exercises, the same has been
held that it does not amount to encroachment into judicial powers as there is
no prohibition against retrospective legislation but the same is subject to
legislative competence. This position has been enunciated in the case of M/s
Utkal Contractors and Joinery (P) Ltd. & Others. Vs. State of Orissa
reported in 1987 (Supp) SCC 751, wherein in para-15 it has been held as
follows:
“15. The next question to be considered is whether the
State while purporting to amend the Act has
encroached upon the judicial power and set aside the
binding judgment of this Court. We do not think that
Mr Nariman was justified in contending so. The
principles have been well established in a string of
decisions of this Court, and we may briefly summarise
as follows:
“The legislature may, at any time, in exercise of the
plenary power conferred on it by Articles 245 and 246
of the Constitution render a judicial decision ineffective
by enacting a valid law. There is no prohibition against
retrospective legislation. The power of the legislature to
pass a law postulates the power to pass it prospectively
as well as retrospectively. That of course, is subject to
the legislative competence and subject to other
constitutional limitations. The rendering ineffective of
judgments or orders of competent courts by changing
their basis by legislative enactment is a well known
pattern of all validating acts. Such validating
legislation which removes the causes of ineffectiveness
or invalidity of action or proceedings cannot be
considered as encroachment on judicial power. The
legislature, however, cannot by a bare declaration,
without more, directly overrule, reverse or set aside any
judicial decision. Hari Singh v. Military Estate
Officer [(1973) 1 SCR 515 : (1972) 2 SCC 239 : AIR
1972 SC 2205] , Government of A.P. v. Hindustan
Machine Tools Ltd. [1975 Supp SCR 394 : (1975) 2
SCC 274 : AIR 1975 SC 2037] , I.N. Saksena v. State of
M.P. [(1976) 3 SCR 237 : (1976) 4 SCC 750 : AIR 1976
SC 2250] and Misrilal Jain v. State of Orissa [(1977) 3
SCR 714 : (1977) 3 SCC 212 : AIR 1977 SC 1686] .”
15.
However, it is also true as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
that a binding judgment cannot be made ineffective with the aid of legislative
power if the same is not a legislative enactment which displaces or removes
the basis or foundation of the judgment and will have uniform application to
a class or persons concerned with the subject. This has been laid down in the
judgment of S.R. Bhagwat and Others vs. State of Mysore reported in
(1995) 6 SCC 16, wherein in para-12 it has been held as follows:
“12. It is now well settled by a catena of decisions of
this Court that a binding judicial pronouncement
between the parties cannot be made ineffective with the
aid of any legislative power by enacting a provision
which in substance overrules such judgment and is not
in the realm of a legislative enactment which displaces
the basis or foundation of the judgment and uniformly
applies to a class of persons concerned with the entire
subject sought to be covered by such an enactment
having retrospective effect.………………. judgments.”
16.
Taking into account the above propositions of law, the action
of the respondents, though seeking to maintain that the proviso to Article
309 of the Constitution allows the Governor to make rules regulating the
recruitment and conditions of service in the absence of an Act, this ground
is however, not available to the respondents as the impugned notifications
can clearly be said to be an encroachment into a judicial pronouncement.
The chain of events and facts as has been narrated and discussed above, does
not warrant any further deliberation to arrive at a conclusion as to the legality
of the impugned notifications. Attempts have been made by the State
respondents to somehow present a case that the impugned notifications have
been issued with due consideration and made with the objective to remove
the defects of the earlier notifications which had been pointed out by this
Court in the judgment dated 17.09.2020, and that the fresh notifications are
no longer personal to the petitioner. However, the very fact that the
impugned notifications categorically state that they have been passed in
partial modification and in continuation of the notifications dated
08.08.2019, which have been quashed by this Court, leave little room for the
State respondents to justify the impugned orders.
17.
Accordingly, for the reasons aforementioned, the impugned
notifications No. SG.12/97/238 and No. SG.12/97/239, both dated
09.11.2020 are set aside and quashed and the writ petition stands allowed.
18.
Parties to bear their own costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
07.06.2022
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review