The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Recently a Bench of this Court in Ismail Kunju vs. State of Kerala [2025 (1) KHC 547] has categorically held that the authorities are obliged to give reasons in the orders passed under the Act. It is W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025 2025:KER:26846 apposite to refer to the legal principles in the decision, which reads as follows: “11. Thus, the scheme of the Act of 1994 and the Rules of 2014 obligates the Authorisation Committee to provide the applicants an opportunity to be heard, and if the application is to be rejected, it has to give the reasons in writing. The discretion has to be used pragmatically and all interviews are to be videographed. Therefore, the statutory scheme contemplates and ensures transparency and objectivity in the decision making process of the Committee. The reasons are to be given in reference to the parameters under R.7(3) of the Rules of 2014 as to why the application filed for organ transplantation between the proposed living donor and the recipient, who are not near relatives, is being rejected.
12. Apart from the statutory mandate, as a matter of fairness and transparency in the decision - making, if the Authorisation Committee comes to the conclusion that the application for organ transplantation is not to be approved, then the applicant is entitled to know the reasons, especially since the decision has serious consequences on the applicant. When a person's request for kidney transplant is rejected, it directly affects his / her right to life and health. In the case of Kranti Associates (P) Ltd. and Another v. Masood Ahmed Khan and Others, 2010 (9) SCC 496, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, after taking a review of the law on the subject of duty to give reasons, summarised certain principles. The Hon'ble Supreme Court held that recording of reasons operates as a restraint on any possible arbitrary exercise of judicial and quasi - judicial or even administrative power. Reasons re - assure that discretion has been exercised by the decision - maker on relevant grounds and by disregarding extraneous considerations. The Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that reasons have become now indispensable component of a decision making process even by administrative bodies, affecting the right of the citizens. Reasons in the orders facilitate the process of judicial review by superior courts. Insistence on reasons in the order is a requirement for both accountability and transparency. If reasons…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.S.DIAS
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 9466 OF 2025
PETITIONERS:
SALEENA CHEMBRAKUNNATH
AGED 50 YEARS
W/O NASAR, CHEMBRAKUNNATH, RAROTH P.O,
PARAPPANPOYI, KOZHIKODE, KERALA, PIN – 673573.
SIKHAMANI
AGED 49 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VETTANATTAYIL HOUSE, CHAMMANOOR,
PUNNAYURKULAM, CHAVAKKAD, THRISSUR, KERALA, PIN 679561
NASAR P.K
AGED 53 YEARS
S/O USSAYIN, CHEMBRAKUNNATH, PARAPPANPOYIL,
KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673573
BY ADVS.
A.PARVATHI MENON
M.A.SHEEBA
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, HEALTH &
FAMILY WELFARE, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
TRIVANDRUM., PIN – 695001.
AUTHORIZATION COMMITTEE FOR TRANSPLANTATION OF
HUMAN ORGANS
NORTHERN ZONE, REPRESENTED BY IT’S CHAIRMAN,
KOZHIKODE MEDICAL COLLEGE HOSPITAL, KOZHIKODE,
PIN – 673008.
AUTHORIZATION COMMITTEE
REPRESENTED BY IT’S CHAIRMAN, ASTER MIMS
HOSPITAL, GOVINDAPURAM, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673016
DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF
OFFICE OF DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF, THRISSUR,
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
RAMAVARMAPURAM ROAD, MANNUMKAD, RAMAVARMAPURAM,
KERALA, PIN - 680631
STATION HOUSE OFFICER
VADAKKEKAD POLICE STATION, ANDATHODE PO ,THRISSUR
CITY, KERALA, PIN – 679564.
GOVT.PLEADER SRI.B.S.SYAMANTHAK
THIS
ADMISSION
WRIT
ON
PETITION
28.03.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
(CIVIL)
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
C.S.DIAS, J.
=============================
W.P (C)No.9466 of 2025
=============================
Dated this the 28th March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The writ petition is filed to quash Ext.P11 order
passed by the 2nd respondent.
2.
The
1st petitioner
is
suffering
from
chronic liver disease. She has been advised to undergo
transplantation. The 3rd petitioner is the husband of the
1st petitioner. As there is no suitable relative in the 1 st
petitioner's family to donate a part of the liver, the 2 nd
petitioner has volunteered to donate a part of his liver.
Consequently,
the
petitioners
submitted
a
joint
application along with the requisite documents before
the 2nd respondent seeking permission for the donation.
By Ext.P8 order, the 2nd respondent has withheld the
joint application of the petitioners 1 and 2 for the
certificate of altruism from the District Police Chief.
The action of the 2nd respondent is arbitrary. Hence,
the writ petition.
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
3.
2025:KER:26846
When the writ petition came up for
consideration on
14.3.2025, the learned Government
Pleader submitted that the 2nd respondent had kept the
petitioners' application
on the hold awaiting the
certificate of altruism from the Assistant Commissioner
of Police, Guruvayoor.
The 2 nd respondent would take
a decision on the joint application immediately on
receipt of the certificate of altruism. Accordingly, the
writ petition was adjourned to today.
4.
Heard;
the learned counsel for the
petitioners' and the learned Government Pleader.
5.
Today when the writ petition was taken
up for consideration, the learned Government Pleader
handed over the order dated 26.3.2025 passed by the
2nd respondent rejecting the petitioners' application for
permission.
The said order is suo motu accepted on
record and marked as Ext.P11 in the writ petition.
6.
On a reading
of the said order, I find
that the 2nd respondent has rejected the
application
solely for the reason that the police report does not
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
categorically rule out financial transaction. Therefore,
the 2nd respondent found it is inappropriate to approve
the transplantation as per the provisions of the
Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Rules,
2014 ('the Rules').
7.
The Transplantation of Human Organs
and Tissues Act, 1994 (Act No.42 of 1994) ('Act', in
short), is enacted to regulate the removal, storage and
transplantation
therapeutic
of human organs and tissues for
purposes
and
for
the
prevention
of
commercial dealings in human organs and tissues and
for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.
8.
The Act permits and regulates organ and
tissue transplantations among near-relatives and nonnear-relatives as per the provisions of the Act, 1994,
and the Rules made thereunder.
9. S.2(i) defines "near relatives" as spouse, son,
daughter, father, mother, brother, sister, grandfather,
grandmother, grandson or granddaughter.
10. The above provision permits the donation of
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
human organs and tissues in favour of a person who is
not a near relative but with the prior approval of the
Authorisation Committee.
11.
To achieve the object of the Act, sub-rule
(3) of Rule 7 and Rule 19 of the Transplantation of
Human Organs and Tissues Rules, 2014 ('the Rules')
have been incorporated in the Rules, which reads as
under:
"R.7 Authorisation Committee. –
***
***
***
(3) When the proposed donor and the recipient are not
near relatives, the Authorisation Committee shall, ―
(i) evaluate that there is no commercial transaction
between the recipient and the donor and that no
payment has been made to the donor or promised to be
made to the donor or any other person;
(ii) prepare an explanation of the link between
them and the circumstances which led to the offer being
made;
(iii) examine the reasons why the donor wishes to
donate;
(iv) examine the documentary evidence of the link,
e.g. proof that they have lived together, etc.;
(v) examine old photographs showing the donor
and the recipient together;
(vi) evaluate that there is no middleman or tout
involved;
(vii) evaluate that financial status of the donor and
the recipient by asking them to give appropriate
evidence of their vocation and income for the previous
three financial years and any gross disparity between
the status of the two must be evaluated in the backdrop
of the objective of preventing commercial dealing;
(viii) ensure that the donor is not a drug addict;
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
(ix) ensure that the near relative or if near relative
is not available, any adult person related to donor by
blood or marriage of the proposed unrelated donor is
interviewed regarding awareness about his or her
intention to donate an organ or tissue, the authenticity
of the link between the donor and the recipient, and the
reasons for donation, and any strong views or
disagreement or objection of such kin shall also be
recorded and taken note of."
“R.19. Procedure in case of transplant other
than near relatives.― Where the proposed transplant
is between other than near relatives and all cases where
the donor or recipient is foreign national (irrespective of
them being near relative or otherwise), the approval will
be granted by the Authorisation Committee of the
hospital or if hospital - based Authorisation Committee
is not constituted, then by the District or State level
Authorisation Committee."
12. If the Authorisation Committee is satisfied that
the applicants fulfill the conditions under sub-rule (3) of
Rules 7, it will issue a Certificate under Form -18 of the
Rules granting permission for the transplant.
13. In Kuldeep Singh v. State of T.N., [(2005) 11
SCC 122], the Honourable Supreme Court, while
interpreting sub-section (3) of Section 9 of the Act, has
held that the object of the statute is to prevent
commercial dealings in human organs. If the donor is
not
a
near
relative
of
the
recipient,
then
the
Authorisation Committee has to be satisfied that the
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
real purpose of the donation is due to the affection or
attachment or for any other special reason. The
Authorisation Committee would be better positioned to
ascertain the authorisation's true intent and purpose by
lifting the veil of projected affection or attachment and
the so-called special reasons and by focusing on the
true intent. The burden is on the applicants to establish
the real intent by placing relevant materials for
consideration before the Authorisation Committee.
Whether there is affection, attachment, or special
reason
is
within
the
special
knowledge
of
the
applicants, and a heavy burden is cast on them.
14. Going by the scheme of the Act, the
statutory authorities have to be satisfied whether the
organ or tissue donation is altruistic as per the
parameters laid down under Rule 7 (3) and the
materials placed before them. There is no definitive
formula to categorically determine whether a donation
is altruistic or if there is a commercial transaction.
However, in marginal cases, like the present one, the
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
distinction between granting or denying approval for
transplantation is separated by a narrow line. The
commendable
intent
of
the
Act
is
to
prohibit
commercial transactions in transplantations and to
safeguard vulnerable individuals from exploitation. It’s
not
to
be
forgotten
that
some
compassionate
individuals are willing to selflessly donate their organs
to give a new lease of life to a family member or friend.
So, it would be unpragmatic to assess every donation
between non-relatives on arithmetical scales or view
them with scepticism in such summary proceedings. A
rigid and inflexible interpretation of Section 9 (3) of the
Act would undermine the laudable object of the
provision and render it otiose and nugatory. Even
otherwise, nowadays, it is common knowledge that the
number of recipients outnumber the donors.
15.
Recently a Bench of this Court in Ismail
Kunju vs. State of Kerala [2025 (1) KHC 547] has
categorically held that the authorities are obliged to
give reasons in the orders passed under the Act. It is
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
apposite to refer to the legal principles in the decision,
which reads as follows:
“11. Thus, the scheme of the Act of 1994 and the Rules of
2014 obligates the Authorisation Committee to provide
the applicants an opportunity to be heard, and if the
application is to be rejected, it has to give the reasons in
writing. The discretion has to be used pragmatically and
all interviews are to be videographed. Therefore, the
statutory scheme contemplates and ensures transparency
and objectivity in the decision making process of the
Committee. The reasons are to be given in reference to
the parameters under R.7(3) of the Rules of 2014 as to
why the application filed for organ transplantation
between the proposed living donor and the recipient, who
are not near relatives, is being rejected.
12.
Apart from the statutory mandate, as a matter of
fairness and transparency in the decision - making, if the
Authorisation Committee comes to the conclusion that the
application for organ transplantation is not to be
approved, then the applicant is entitled to know the
reasons, especially since the decision has serious
consequences on the applicant. When a person's request
for kidney transplant is rejected, it directly affects his /
her right to life and health. In the case of Kranti
Associates (P) Ltd. and Another v. Masood Ahmed Khan
and Others, 2010 (9) SCC 496, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, after taking a review of the law on the subject of
duty to give reasons, summarised certain principles. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that recording of reasons
operates as a restraint on any possible arbitrary exercise
of judicial and quasi - judicial or even administrative
power. Reasons re - assure that discretion has been
exercised by the decision - maker on relevant grounds
and by disregarding extraneous considerations. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that reasons have
become now indispensable component of a decision making process even by administrative bodies, affecting
the right of the citizens. Reasons in the orders facilitate
the process of judicial review by superior courts.
Insistence on reasons in the order is a requirement for
both accountability and transparency. If reasons are not
given in the decision making process, then it may not be
possible to determine whether the authority has applied
its mind to the issue. The Hon'ble Supreme Court also
held that reasons in support of decisions must be cogent
and clear and pretense of reasons or "rubber - stamp
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
reasons" is not to be equated with a mere valid decision making process. This law, expounded by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, applies more stringently when an
application for an organ transplantation made by a
patient at a critical stage is rejected by the Committee on
the ground that the donation is not altruistic”.
16.
Going by the scheme of the Act, Rules
framed thereunder and the law referred to in the
aforecited decisions, I am of the firm view that it is for
the 2nd respondent to form an independent opinion as to
whether the permission can be granted or not.
The 2 nd
respondent is not expected to only follow the police
report, instead an independent decision has to be taken
with cogent reasons.
17.
Indisputably, since there is no specific
reason stated in Ext.P11 order passed by the
2 nd
respondent, I am of the definite view that the said
decision is untenable. Therefore, I am convinced and
satisfied that the 2nd respondent is to reconsider the
joint application submitted by the petitioners 1 and 2
and take a decision on the same as per the provisions
of the Act, Rules framed thereunder and the law laid
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
down by this Court in the aforecited decision. Hence, I
am convinced and satisfied that this is an appropriate
case for this Court to exercise its extra-ordinary
jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
In the above conspectus, I quash Ext.P11 order
passed by the 2nd respondent. The 2 nd respondent is
directed to reconsider the joint application and pass a
reasoned order, after affording the petitioners an
opportunity of being heard.
The above exercise shall
be carried out in accordance with law, and as
expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within a period of
three weeks from the date of production of a copy of
this judgment. It is made clear that this Court has not
expressed anything on the merits of the application.
The writ petition is ordered accordingly.
Sd/-C.S.DIAS, JUDGE
ma/28.03.2025
W.P (C) No.9466 of 2025
2025:KER:26846
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 9466/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY
THE HOSPITAL, DATED 10.12.2024,
REJECTING THE FIRST PETITIONER’S
DAUGHTER AS A DONOR
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTARIZED CONSENT FORM
GIVEN BY THE SECOND PETITIONER, DATED
27.12.2024
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTARIZED AFFIDAVIT BY
THE 1ST PETITIONER DATED 27.12.2024
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE FORM 11 APPLICATION
ALONG WITH FORM 3 APPLICATION WHICH IS A
JOINT APPLICATION BY THE DONOR AND
RECIPIENT ALONG WITH NECESSARY DOCUMENTS
DATED 31.12.2024
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 02.01.2025
FROM THE HOSPITAL TO THE 1ST PETITIONER
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE SCREENSHOT OF THE
CROWDFUNDING EFFORTS DATED 30.10.2024
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMORANDUM OF APPEAL
BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT DATED
10.01.2025
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF RECOMMENDATION DATED
27.02.2025 BY 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER FROM THE 3RD
RESPONDENT DATED 06.03.2025
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL FILED BEFORE THE
1ST RESPONDENT ON 11.03.2025
Exhibit P10(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE POSTAL RECEIPT DATED
NILL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review