Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31426
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 7713 OF 2022
PETITIONER:
SALEELA A.
AGED 53 YEARS
W/O M.R.ABDUL SALAM, U.P SCHOOL ASSISTANT, THAZHUTHALA
MUSLIM U.P SCHOOL, KOTTIYAM P.O.KOLLAM-691 571,
RESIDING AT UPPUVEETTIL, KOTTIYAM P.O. KOLLAM-691 571
BY ADVS.
S.RAMESH
SIVANKUTTY S.
RESPONDENTS:
LAILA T.M.
MANAGER, THAZHUTHALA MUSLIM U.P SCHOOL, KOTTIYAM
P.O.KOLLAM-691 571.
SMT. GRACY CHACKO,
HEADMISTRESS, THAZHUTHALA MUSLIM U.P SCHOOL, KOTTIYAM
P.O.KOLLAM-691 571.
THE ASSISTANT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER,
OFFICE OF THE ASST. EDUCATIONAL OFFICER, CHATHANNOOR,
MINI CIVIL STATION, CHATHANNOOR, KOLLAM DISTRICT, PIN691 572
THE DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER, CIVIL
STATION, KOLLAM, PIN-691 001.
THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION
OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION, KOLLAM,
PIN-691 001
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-2-
2025:KER:31426
THE DIRECTOR OF GENERAL EDUCATION,
DIRECTORATE OF GENERAL EDUCATION, JAGATHY,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 014.
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, GENERAL
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695 001
*ADDL.R8 SMT. JAMEELA
PRESENT MANAGER, THAZHUTHALA MUSLIM U.P. SCHOOL,
KOTTIYAM P.O., KOLLAM- 691571
*(ADDL.R8 IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED 20/02/2023
IN IA 1/2023 )
BY ADVS.
Abdul Lathief T.M
B.MOHANLAL
ADVOCATE GENERAL OFFICE KERALA
KRISHOB K.NAIR
GP- NIMA JACOB
THIS
ADMISSION
WRIT
PETITION
ON
10.04.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
(CIVIL)
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-3-
2025:KER:31426
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 10th day of April, 2025
Above writ petition is filed challenging Exts.P5 and P5(a) and
also Ext.P13 order.
2.
The brief facts necessary for the disposal of the writ
petition is as follows:Petitioner was appointed as Upper Primary School Teacher in the 1 st
respondent school on 19.12.1990. As per Ext.P1 seniority list she is
ranked No.2, whereas the 2nd respondent is ranked No.3. As the
Headmaster was due to retire on 31.05.2021 petitioner made
Exts.P2 and P3 representation requesting to appoint her as
Headmistress based on Rule 44 of Chapter XIV of Kerala Education
Rules, 1959 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Rules, 1959’). While so, by
Ext.P4 proceedings the 1st respondent Manager individually took a
decision to appoint the 2nd respondent as Headmistress who is
admittedly junior to the petitioner. Later the 1st respondent issued
Exts.P5 and P5(a) proceedings appointing the 2 nd respondent as
Headmistress. In order to overlook the superior claim of the
petitioner for appointment as Headmistress the 2 nd respondent relied
in Ext.P5(a) that the institution is a minority institution and therefore
they could make appointments ignoring the seniority of the
petitioner.
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-4-
2025:KER:31426
3.
Ext.P6 appeal was preferred by the petitioner. While so,
the manager by a subsequent proceedings issued as Ext.P7,
promoted the 2nd respondent to the post of Headmistress. The
Assistant Education Officer declined to approve the appointment as
per Ext.P9 order in view of the delay in submitting the same for
approval. Against which appeal was preferred before the Deputy
Director of Education who as per Ext.P10 order condoned the delay
in submitting the proposal for approval, and by Ext.P11 order the
District Education Officer issued orders directing the 3 rd respondent
AEO to approve the appointment of the 2nd respondent. Petitioner
preferred Ext.P12 appeal before the 5 th respondent. Without
considering any of the contentions in Ext.P12 appeal the 3 rd
respondent AEO issued Ext.P13 order approving the appointment of
the 2nd respondent. Petitioner would contend that going by the
amendment to Rule 18 of the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education Rules, 2011, the teachers who are otherwise
eligible for being promoted as head teachers shall be exempted from
passing such departmental tests, and based on the said amendment
to the Rules which is produced as Ext.P14, it is contended that
petitioner is exempted from passing the test qualification as per the
provisions of the above said Rule.
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-5-
2025:KER:31426
4.
One of the main contention raised by the petitioner is that
the 1st respondent Manager has personally made a choice to appoint
the 2nd respondent without relying upon any of the decision of the
management, and it is contended that it is for the management
committee
to
take
a
decision
for
appointment
of
the
Headmaster/Principal of minority institution which is admittedly not
done in the present case. Petitioner relies on Ext.P18 bye law
especially clause 8 which mandates that in all the matters
connected with the running of the school including appointments it
is the majority decision of the management committee that is to be
implemented by the Manager as per Rules. Therefore, on the basis of
the same, it is contended that the decision to appoint the 2 nd
respondent as Headmistress was a unilateral decision of the 1 st
respondent Manager, and therefore the said appointment is bad.
Going by the averment in the writ petition the essential contention
raised by the petitioner is that she is the senior most teacher and
therefore
she
is
entitled
for
appointment
to
the
post
of
Headmistress, and further that going by Ext.P14 amendment to the
Rule 18 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education
Rules, 2011, she is exempted from test qualification. Yet another
contention raised by the petitioner is that even though the school
could claim minority status the appointment of the 2 nd respondent is
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-6-
2025:KER:31426
the sole decision of the 1st respondent Manager and not by the
management committee, and therefore the said decision is illegal
and void. To drive home the point petitioner relies on the judgment
in Manager Corporate Educational Agency v. James Mathew
and Others [(2017) 15 SCC 595]. Relying on the said judgment it
is contended that it is for the management of the minority
educational institution to take a decision to appoint a person of their
choice as Headmaster.
5.
The 1st respondent manager at the time of appointment of
the 2nd respondent has filed a counter affidavit. Based on the said
counter affidavit it is contended that the 2nd respondent was fully
qualified for being appointed as Headmistress as on the date of
occurrence of vacancy on 01.06.2021. The 2 nd respondent is
appointed taking into account her suitability for the post, her
qualification, seniority and acceptance. As regards the contention of
the petitioner that the appointment is made by the Manager and
decision is not taken by the management committee is absolutely
without any basis. It is contended that, going by the provisions of
the Rules, 1959 the decision taken by the management is
implemented through the Manager, and in such situation it cannot
be said that appointment is not made by the management especially
in view of the fact that petitioner who is also a management
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-7-
2025:KER:31426
committee member has no case to the effect that decision to
promote the 2nd respondent is not a decision by the management. It
is further submitted that as the said selection was made during the
covid pandemic period, notice through whats app was given to all
the management committee members, and as per Ext.R1(a) the
views of all the management committee members were obtained,
which is submitted as Ext.R1(a) to R1(f). It is submitted that
Ext.R1(f) is the opinion given by the petitioner herself who is also a
member of the management committee. Thereafter it is contended
that the 1st respondent Manager acted in terms of the majority
decision as per clause 8 of the approved bye law and appointed the
2nd respondent as the Headmistress. It is further contended that the
post of Manager is a pivotal position connecting the educational
agency and the Education Department, and the person appointed as
Headmistress should work in tandem with the management and
should work for the progress, upliftment and development of the
school, and that the petitioner was always trying to create problem
and was instrumental in taking action by the Education Department
for
bogus
admission.
The
2nd
respondent’s
appointment
as
Headmistress was fully approved and her probation was declared as
per Ext.R1(l) by the present Manager who is impleaded as additional
8th respondent . It is further submitted on the basis of the decision in
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-8-
2025:KER:31426
Unnikrishnan v. DEO Palakkad [1996 (1) KLT 501] that the
petitioner being a member of the managing body who was working
as teacher in the school cannot claim the post of Headmaster in the
school. It is further submitted that as per the judgment of this Court
in WP(C) No.34092/2019 and connected cases, petitioner will not get
the benefit of the amendment to Rule 18(1) of the Kerala Right of
Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules, 2011, as the
amendment was declared to have operation only prospectively.
6.
The 2nd respondent has filed a detailed counter affidavit
and submits that she is fully qualified for being appointed and
therefore she was considered for being appointed as Headmistress
and her appointment has been duly approved as per Ext.P13 order.
The petitioner has never challenged Ext.P13 order till date in any
appellate proceedings and the same has become final. The learned
Counsel for the 2nd respondent would further submit that after the
appointment of the 8th respondent as Manager an attempt is being
made to remove the 2nd respondent from the post of Headmistress
and to appoint the petitioner in her place. The learned Counsel
appearing for the 2nd respondent would further submit that though
such an attempt was made the same is in violation of the provisions
of Rule 9 of Chapter XIV A of Rules, 1959 which specifically
mandates that an order of appointment shall not be affected by any
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
-9-
2025:KER:31426
change in the educational agency or the Manager, since the 2 nd
respondent has been appointed as Headmistress and the same is
duly approved by the educational authorities as evident from
Ext.P13. The 8th respondent who subsequently became the Manager
cannot challenge the appointment of the 2 nd respondent as
Headmistress.
7.
The 4th respondent has also filed a detailed counter
affidavit, stating that the petitioner is not test qualified for being
appointed as Headmistress and that the Manager of the minority
institution is
vested with legal right to appoint a qualified
Headmistress from the staff of the school without insisting on the
seniority.
It
is
further
submitted
that
the
Manager
of
the
management institution has absolute right to appoint a qualified
teacher from the staff as Headmaster/Headmistress other than the
senior claimant. The 2nd respondent is appointed as Headmistress
invoking the minority rights of the educational institution which is
perfectly legal and valid.
8.
I have heard the rival contentions of both sides.
9.
As stated earlier one of the contention raised by the
petitioner is that she is senior to the 2 nd respondent going by Ext.P1
and ought to have been appointed as the Headmistress of the
school. Another contention raised by the petitioner is that the
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
- 10 -
2025:KER:31426
appointment of the 2nd respondent was by the Manager and not by
the management committee, and therefore per se illegal and liable
to be interfered with. An important aspect to be noted is that by
Ext.P13 the appointment of the 2nd respondent is approved as early
as on 20.09.2021. The petitioner has not preferred any statutory
appeal or challenged the same in any other proceedings except
challenging the same in this writ petition which was filed only on
08.08.2022 i.e. after a lapse of almost six months. Petitioner does
not dispute the fact that the school is a minority run institution, and
that admittedly the management has every right to appoint a
qualified teacher of their choice as the Headmistress and appointed
the 2nd respondent herein. The contention of the petitioner is that
the appointment of the 2nd respondent is the sole decision of the 1 st
respondent Manager. In the counter affidavit filed by the 1 st
respondent it is specifically contended that notice regarding the
appointment of the Headmistress was brought to the notice of all the
committee members as per Ext.R1(a) and due to covid pandemic
the notice was issued through whats app and as per Ext.R1(a) to
R1(f) opinions of the committee members was also obtained and on
the basis of the majority decision the 2 nd respondent is appointed. It
is pertinent to note that even the petitioner who was a management
committee member has given her opinion as Ext.R1(l). In the light of
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
- 11 -
2025:KER:31426
the above, the contention of the petitioner that the appointment of
the 2nd respondent as Headmistress was sole decision of the 1 st
respondent Manager cannot be accepted, and it is to be held that it
was a decision taken out on the basis of the majority opinion of the
management committee members. The Division Bench of this Court
in Unnikrishnan’s case cited supra has also categorically held that
a member of the managing body who was working as teacher in the
school cannot stake a claim the post of Headmaster of that school,
and therefore the petitioner being a management committee
member
cannot
claim
for
appointment
to
the
post
of
Headmaster/Headmistress. Though the petitioner has relied on the
decision of the Apex Court in James Mathew’s case cited supra
which held that it is the management of the minority institution who
is to make appointment of Headmaster, the said decision has
categorically held that there is absolutely no obligation for the
minority institution to appoint the available senior qualified member
of the same community, and since the appointment of the
Headmaster depends upon the assessment of candidate’s outlook,
philosophy and ability to implement objects of the minority
institution, even the members of the same community have to yield
to right of management under Article 30(1) to establish and
administer educational institutions, and further held that once the
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
- 12 -
2025:KER:31426
management of the minority educational institution makes a
conscious choice of a qualified person to lead the institution either
as a Headmaster/Principal, the Court cannot go into the merits of the
choice or the rationality or propriety of the process of choice, and
that in this regard the right under Article 30(1) is absolute.
In the light of the discussion as above no interference is called
for on the appointment of the 2 nd respondent as Headmistress and
the consequential approval of the said appointment by the
educational authorities. Accordingly the writ petition is dismissed.
Sd/VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sbk/-
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
- 13 -
2025:KER:31426
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 7713/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE SENIORITY LIST AS ON
1.1.2021 PUBLISHED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT
ON 3.5.2021
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
31.5.2021 FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE
THE 1ST RESPONDENT
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
31.5.2021 FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE
THE HEADMASTER OF THE SCHOOL
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE 1ST
RESPONDENT NO 01/HM/2021 DATED 31.6.2021
WITH REGARD TO THE APPOINTMENT OF THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE APPOINTMENT ORDER NO
02/HM/2021 DATED 1.6.2021 OF THE 2ND
RESPONDENT ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT
MANAGER
Exhibit P5(A)
TRUE COPY OF THE APPOINTMENT ORDER NO
02/HM/2021 DATED 1.6.2021 OF THE 2ND
RESPONDENT ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT
MANAGER
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL DATED 1.6.2001
FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE 3RD
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS NO 03/HM/2021
DATED 12.6.2021 OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL DATED 12.6.2021
FILED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT BEFORE THE 3RD
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO D1/12383/2021
DATED 29.6.2021 ISSUED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
- 14 -
2025:KER:31426
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO
DDEKLM/10548/2021-B2/K.DIS DATED 20.8.2021
ISSUED BY THE 5TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO B1/194200/2021
DATED 31.8.2021 ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL DATED 5.7.2021
PREFERRED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE 5TH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P13
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO D/114150/2021
DATED 20.9.2021 ISSUED BY THE 3RD
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P14
TRUE COPY OF THE AMENDMENT OF THE RULES
PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE DATED 5.1.2021 AS
PER NOTIFICATION GO (P) NO 1/2021/G.EDN
DATED 5.1.2021
Exhibit P15
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN OP(KAT) NO
184 OF 2019 DATED 27.1.2020 OF THIS
HON'BLE COURT
Exhibit P16
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE HON'BLE
SUPREME COURT DATED 17.6.2020 IN SLP
(CIVIL) NO 12310/2020
Exhibit P17
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY
THE GOVERNMENT BEFORE THE HON'BLE KERALA
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL IN OA NO 441/2021
Exhibit P18
TRUE COPY OF THE BY-LAW OF THE CORPORATE
BODY
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1A
True copy of the letter dated 17/5/2021 by
the 1st respondent
Exhibit R1B
True copy of the consent letter of Smt.
Jameela dated 19/5/2021
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
- 15 -
2025:KER:31426
Exhibit R1C
True copy of the consent letter of Sabeela
dated 25/5/2021
Exhibit R1D
True copy of the consent letter of Shyla
dated 20/5/2021
Exhibit R1E
True copy of the consent letter of Sheela
dated 19/5/2021
Exhibit R1F
True copy of the letter of petitioner
dated 20/5/2021
Exhibit R1G
True copy of the byelaw dated 12/3/2018
Exhibit R1H
True copy of the proceedings of the under
Secretary to government dated 5/3/2019
Exhibit R1I
True copy of the judgment in W.P.(C)
No.38056/2018 dated 25/3/2019
Exhibit R1J
True copy of the judgment in W.P.(C) No.
19033/2019 dated 27/8/2019
Exhibit R1K
True copy of the judgment in W.P.(C) No
31275/2019 dated 7/10/2020
Exhibit R1L
True copy of the proceedings of the
manager dated 1/6/2022
Exhibit R1M
True copy of the test qualification
certificates of 2nd respondent
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Ext.P19
True copy of the Minutes dated 30-3-2021
and 28-7-2021 of the Managing Committee,
obtained under the RTI Act.
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R8
True copy of the settlement deed bearing
no 3368/1994 of Kottayam Sub Registry
Exhibit R2(a)
The true copy of the order dated
01.06.2022 of the 8th Respondent
WP(C) No. 7713 of 2022
- 16 -
2025:KER:31426
Exhibit R2(b)
The true copy of the details of the
admissions made in the School issued by
the Headmaster to the Public Information
Officer attached to the office of the 3rd
Respondent as per reference No.74/2012
dated 20.12.2012 under Right to
Information Act
Exhibit R2(c)
The true copy of the Reply No.A/1618/13
dated 27.05.2013 issued under Right to
Information Act by the Public Information
Officer attached to the office of the 3rd
Respondent to Sri.M.A.Gafoor
Exhibit R2(d)
The true copy of the order
No.VA1/293849/2021/DGE dated 29.12.2022
issued by the 6th Respondent
Exhibit R2(e)
The true copy of the Reply No.A1971/15
dated 27.07.2015 issued by the 3rd
Respondent to Sri. Abdul Salam
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P20
True copy of the Order No.
D1/1131/2020K.Dis. dated 18-5-2020 issued
by the Asst. Educational Officer,
Chathannoor.
Exhibit P21
True copy of the Order No.
SC(1)/3061/2019/DGE dated 26-3-2021 issued
by the Director of Public Instructions.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review