Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 44
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No. 21/2026
CrlM No. 37/2026
Date of Pronouncement: 15.01.2026
Uploaded on:
19.01.2026
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Sakshi Khajuria
Through:-
Mr. Mayank Gupta, Advocate
V/s
…..Respondent(s)
Narinder Parsad Sharma & ors.
Through:-
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
15.01.2026
1.
After hearing learned counsel for the petitioner, it appears that the
petitioner is embroiled in a matrimonial dispute with her husband,
namely Sunil Sharma, whereas the respondents are close relatives of the
husband.
2.
The petitioner had earlier initiated proceedings under the Protection of
Women from Domestic Violence Act and, simultaneously, had also
lodged a complaint against the respondents and her husband before the
Police Station Women Cell, Jammu on 01.04.2024, which came to be
diarized as Complaint No. 21624. It is alleged that during the pendency
of the said complaint, the husband fled to New Zealand and never
appeared before the Women Cell, whereas the respondents continued to
participate in the proceedings. During the course of those proceedings,
the articles exchanged at the time of marriage were returned. However,
when the issue of alimony arose, the respondents allegedly backtracked
from their assurance, compelling the petitioner to insist upon the
physical appearance of her husband, Sunil Kumar. It is an admitted
position that divorce proceedings between the husband and wife are
pending before a competent court at Jammu. During the pendency of
the said divorce proceedings, the petitioner moved an application
before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jammu on 17.04.2025
seeking a status report in respect of the criminal complaint lodged
before the Women Cell. The said application came to be registered as
Application No. 181/2025 titled Sakshi Khajuria v. Women Cell,
bearing CNR No. JKJM030039042025.
3.
Aggrieved by the filing of the aforesaid application, the respondents
approached this Court by way of CRM(M) No. 847/2025, which was
disposed of with a direction to the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Jammu (hereinafter referred to as “CJM”), to call for a detailed status
report and record from the concerned Police Station and thereafter
dispose of the matter in accordance with law after affording reasonable
opportunity of hearing to both sides. It is submitted that during the
course of proceedings, the report submitted by the Police Station
Women Cell, Jammu revealed serious irregularities and a deliberate
attempt on the part of the police authorities to drag the matter. This
constrained the petitioner to move another application before the
learned CJM seeking monitoring of the enquiry being conducted by the
Women Cell in the earlier complaint. The said application came to be
transferred to the Court of the Excise Magistrate, Jammu, where
proceedings under the Domestic Violence Act were already pending
inter se the parties, and was numbered as Application No. 500/2025. It
is specifically stated in the said application that no express or written
prayer for transfer of the proceedings was ever made by the petitioner.
The respondents, misconstruing the directions passed by a Coordinate
Bench of this Court, filed an application before the learned Trial Court
raising a preliminary objection regarding the maintainability of the
petitioner’s application.
4.
The learned Trial Court, by way of the impugned order, not only
recalled the application pending before the Court of the learned Excise
Magistrate, Jammu, but also recorded reasoning which, according to the
petitioner, was unknown to law. It is contended that both the
applications filed by the petitioner were for distinct reliefs and based on
different causes of action, one being confined to calling for a
status/progress report and the other seeking monitoring and supervision
of the enquiry being conducted by the Women Cell, Jammu. It is
further contended that while allowing the application filed by the
respondents, the learned Trial Court assumed a power of judicial recall
not sanctioned by law. The learned Trial Court, after hearing both sides,
allowed the respondents’ application and observed as under:
“11. The application pending sub judice before the Court of
Ld. Excise Magistrate, Jammu has also been filed by
the non-applicant Sakshi Khajuria seeking monitoring
of the preliminary enquiry being conducted by Women
Police Station, Jammu. Thus, in both these
applications filed by non-applicant Sakshi Khajuria,
i.e., before this Court and before the Court of Ld.
Excise Magistrate, Jammu, both the Courts have to
pass orders after considering the grievances of the
applicant and the progress and legality of the
preliminary enquiry, which may result in contradictory
orders.
12. Thus, to prevent any such situation, in my considered
opinion, the application of the applicants deserves to
be allowed to the extent of recalling the application
pending before the Court of Ld. Excise Magistrate,
Jammu, so that both the applications may be heard by
one Court and the possibility of contradictory orders is
avoided.
13. For the foregoing reasons and keeping in view the
mandate of Section 450 BNSS, the application is
allowed and the application seeking monitoring of the
preliminary enquiry is recalled from the Court of Ld.
Excise Magistrate, Jammu. A copy of this order be
furnished to the learned Excise Magistrate, Jammu for
information and compliance. List on 29.01.2026 along
with the main application pending in this Court.”
5.
Given the context of the order reproduced above, once the respondents
had obtained an order from the Coordinate Bench in CRM(M) No.
847/2024 granting them a right of hearing before the learned CJM,
Jammu, the learned CJM was required to obtain a detailed status report
and record from the concerned Police Station and thereafter dispose of
the matter in accordance with law after affording an opportunity of
hearing to both parties. The complaint being before the Women Cell,
the first application filed by the petitioner was confined only to seeking
a status/progress report, whereas the second application dated
14.11.2025 sought monitoring of the enquiry in respect of the same
complaint. In essence, the second application ought not to have been
transferred to the learned Excise Magistrate once the learned CJM was
seized of the matter pursuant to the directions issued by this Court on
02.09.2025. It appears that due to administrative exigencies, the matter
escaped the attention of the learned CJM. Nonetheless, the petitioner
was essentially seeking the status of the enquiry being conducted by the
Women Cell, Jammu.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner vehemently argued that although the
learned CJM had the power to recall the application pending before the
learned Excise Magistrate and assign it to himself, one of the
applications ought to have been consigned to records, as the
respondents had no authority or locus standi to seek recall of the
petitioner’s application for monitoring the preliminary enquiry.
7.
Be that as it may, the impugned order does not cause any prejudice to
the petitioner. It is true that the respondents have only a limited right at
the pre-cognizance stage, and the enquiry being conducted by the
Women Cell does not suffer from any apparent legal infirmity. The
learned CJM, perhaps owing to the rush of court work, should have
retained both applications instead of sending one to the Court of the
learned Excise Magistrate. The respondents rightly brought this aspect
to the notice of the learned Trial Court, resulting in the recall of the
application so that both applications could be decided together.
8.
The argument that the power of recall is unknown to law is untenable.
The learned CJM was not recalling any judicial order but merely
exercising powers vested under Section 450 of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), which empowers the Chief Judicial
Magistrate to withdraw or recall any case made over to a subordinate
Magistrate. Thus, the use of the word “recall” is in conformity with the
statutory mandate.
9.
This Court agrees with the contention of learned counsel for the
petitioner that the respondents lacked locus standi to seek recall of the
monitoring application from the Court of the learned Excise Magistrate.
However, the learned CJM, in his judicial wisdom, rightly deemed it
appropriate to hear and decide both applications by a single order.
Although the reliefs sought in the two applications were distinct, one
relating to calling of a status report and the other to monitoring of the
enquiry, no prejudice has been caused to the petitioner. Ultimately, it is
for the learned CJM to obtain the status of the enquiry, direct
expeditious completion thereof, and examine whether the complaint
discloses cognizable offences warranting further proceedings in
accordance with law.
10.
It needs no reiteration that the right of hearing granted to the
respondents at this stage is limited and cannot be expanded to derail or
obstruct the police enquiry initiated on the basis of the petitioner’s
complaint.
11. For the foregoing reasons, no interference is warranted with the
impugned order. The learned CJM, Jammu is directed to proceed
further in the matter and decide both applications strictly in accordance
with law.
12. The petition is, accordingly, disposed of.
(SANJAY PARIHAR)
Judge
JAMMU
RAM MURTI
15.01.2026
Whether the order is speaking? : Yes
Whether the order is reportable? : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review