Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 485 of 2022
Shri. Saket S. Gokhale
Date of Decision: 03.02.2023
Vs.
Election Commission of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv.
Mr. F. Askari, Adv.
Mr. S.K. Hassan, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. B. Shangrit, Adv.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv. (For R 1 & 2)
Mr. S. Sahay, Adv. with
Ms. S. Laloo, Adv. (For R 3).
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Oral:
1.
The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner, who
is a Spokesperson of the All India Trinamool Congress, praying for
action to be initiated against the respondent No. 3, by the respondents
No. 1 and 2 (Election Commission of India) for violation of electoral
rules given in Rule 16A of the Election Symbols (Reservation and
Allotment) Order, 1968.
2.
When the matter was initially taken up on earlier dates, the
respondent No. 3, had raised questions on the maintainability of the writ
petition, and on a preliminary hearing, while allowing the parties to
complete the pleadings, the matter has been fixed today for admission
hearing, on the point of maintainability.
3.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
4.
Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel for the respondent No. 3, has
raised the following grounds to question the maintainability of the
petition, which are under the following heads;
i)
Writ petition not maintainable in view of the bar under
Article 329(b) of the Constitution of India.
ii)
Writ petition barred by inordinate delay and laches.
iii)
Petition under Article 226, not maintainable for failure to
make out mandatory pre-conditions for invoking writ
jurisdiction.
iv)
Writ petition liable to be dismissed for concealment of
material facts.
v)
Writ petition is a ‘political’ interest litigation and
petitioner lacks locus.
vi)
5.
Writ petition unsustainable on merits.
Mr. S. Sahay, learned counsel has advanced arguments on the
respective heads as noted above, and on the first objection, submits that
a constitutional bar exists against interference by Courts in electoral
matters and has referred to Article 329(b) of the Constitution, to support
this point. He further submits that, the bar to interference includes all
matters directly or incidentally connected with the electoral process,
which is already under way in the State of Meghalaya, whereby elections
to the Legislative Assembly, has been notified on 18.01.2023. Learned
counsel in support of his submission, has placed reliance on the case of
Election Commission of India through Secretary Vs. Ashok Kumar,
(2000) 8 SCC 216.
6.
On the point of inordinate delay, learned counsel submits that,
the writ petition is hit by inordinate delay and laches, inasmuch as, the
filing of election expenditure report relates to 2018, whereas, the writ
petitioner has instituted the present writ petition only in 2022, without
providing any explanation for the delay in preferring the same. He
submits that, the fact that, the writ petition was filed only in December,
2022, clearly shows that the same is actuated by political motive, as it
has been filed immediately prior to the 2023 elections, at the behest of
the political party, to which the petitioner belongs. Learned counsel has
placed the following decisions, in support of his contentions, namely City
and Industrial Development Corp. Vs. Dosu Aardeshir Bhiwandiwala,
(2009) 1 SCC 168 and Karnataka Power Corp. Ltd. Vs. K. Thangappan,
(2006) 4 SCC 322.
7.
On the point of failure to meet the pre-conditions for invoking
writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, the learned
counsel submits that, it is settled law that, there must be a judicially
enforceable right, as well as, a legally protected right to seek a
mandamus. The petitioner he submits, is seeking a direction from this
Court, for the respondent No. 1 to act against respondent No. 3, which is
neither based on an enforceable legal right or a fundamental right. The
exercise of powers of Rule 16A of the Election Symbols (Reservation
and Allotment) Order, 1968, he contends, is a discretion vested with the
respondent No. 1, and there can be no mandamus for enforcing
discretionary power, especially against respondent No. 1, which is a
constitutional body under Article 324 of the Constitution.
8.
On the point of locus and concealment of materials facts, the
learned counsel submits that, the writ petitioner is neither an elector nor
a candidate in any constituency within Meghalaya, and that, the writ
petition has been instituted with a personal and political motive, to
convert the Court proceedings into a political arena. This he submits, is
apparent from the mass press and media coverage of the pendency of this
writ petition, which includes the contents of the filings made by the
petitioner, which has appeared in many articles. Learned counsel also
contends that the statements on affidavit made by the petitioner, that he
does not have any personal interest, personal gain, or private motive is
palpably false as by his own admission, he is a spokesperson of a political
party having private motives against the respondent No. 3. As such, he
submits, the instant writ petition is nothing but a political interest
litigation, couched in the form of a writ petition. In this context, the
learned counsel has placed reliance in the cases of Janata Dal Vs. H.S.
Chowdhary (1992) 4 SCC 305, Tehseen Poonawalla Vs. Union of India
(2018) 6 SCC 72, and Dr. M. Ismail Faruqui Vs. Adityanath (2022)
SCC OnLine All 768.
9.
On the writ petition being unsustainable on merits, the learned
counsel submits that, no statutory provision has been set out in the
petition, which has been purportedly not complied with. The answering
respondent he submits, has already submitted its election and
expenditure report in compliance with the notices of the respondent No.
1, and as such, the basis of the writ petition itself, is no longer in
existence, as there is no violation to speak of. He lastly submits that, the
conduct of the petitioner, is a case of attempting to gain political mileage
from the pendency of these proceedings and an abuse of the process of
law, and on this count alone, the petition is liable to be dismissed.
10.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner in reply
has at the outset, given a brief outline as to the circumstances that, has
caused the writ petitioner to come before this Court. He submits that,
after the petitioner came to learn that the respondent No. 3, had not filed
the election expenditure statements for several elections, including the
Meghalaya Assembly Elections of 2018, a petition was filed before the
respondent No. 2 on 07.09.2022, to take immediate action against the
respondent No. 3, political party. Thereafter, he submits with
information received by RTI on 03.10.2022, wherein, letters dated
15.06.2018, 20.08.2018 and 14.09.2022 of the respondent No. 1 were
enclosed, it became clear that, the respondent No. 3 had breached the
stipulation given in Rule 16A of the Election Symbols (Reservation and
Allotment) Order, 1968, which mandated that, the election expenditure
was to be filed within a period of 75 days, after the completion of
Assembly Elections. The learned Senior counsel then submits that, as the
respondent No. 3, had violated this provision, necessary punitive action
was to be inflicted by the respondent No. 1, which however, had failed
to take any action, warranting the filing of the instant writ petition, for
issuance of appropriate directions.
11.
On the grounds of maintainability, the learned Senior counsel
submits that, Article 329 will not be attracted, as no election has been
called into question. Reliance has been placed upon Para – 32 of Election
Commission of India through Secretary Vs. Ashok Kumar (supra), to
support his contention that, the filing of the instant writ petition will not
have the effect of interrupting or obstructing the election proceedings,
and that, the decision sought will not amount to calling in question an
election, but in fact, will subserve and is in furtherance of the election
proceedings. He further submits that, the notification for elections was
issued only on 18.01.2023, after the writ petition had been filed.
12.
On the question of locus, the learned Senior counsel submits
that, Article 144, makes it the bounden duty and obligation of all to aid
in the implementation of the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court,
and for this purpose, it is merely sufficient that the directions of the
Supreme Court be brought to the notice of constitutional authorities and
Courts. He further submits that, it was only on 16.12.2022, that the
election expenditure statements were filed by the respondent No. 3
before the respondent No. 1, after the instant writ petition had been
instituted, which indicates the efficacy of the instant proceedings.
13.
The learned Senior counsel submits that, delay is not a factor
and there is no question of delay, but a question of compliance. The writ
petition, he submits is not politically motivated, but the petitioner is a
person who has an interest in politics, and that, it was only after he came
to learn that election expenditure of the respondent No. 3, had not been
filed, and the subsequent events that transpired thereafter, which then
prompted him to prefer the instant writ petition as there was a clear
violation of Rule 16A of the Election Symbols (Reservation and
Allotment) Order, 1968.
14.
The learned Senior counsel then submits, that Rule 16A of the
Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968, vest power
on respondent No. 1 to take action and it is not clear, as to whether any
action as contemplated under the Rules is sought to be taken. He submits
that, though the wording of Rule 16A uses the word ‘may’ the same
however, is to be read as ‘shall’, inasmuch as, it is a mandatory
requirement for a political party to file election expenditure returns,
which in turn will attract a penal action on the same not being complied
with.
15.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior counsel appearing for the
respondents No. 1 and 2 submits that, the instant case, is no longer a case
of non-filing of statement of election expenditure, but one of delay and
the penalty for non-filing is not the same as for delay. He further submits
that, as elections have been notified, it is for the respondent No. 1, to take
a call on the matter being the competent authority. At this stage, he
submits no directions may be issued as the returns have since been filed.
16.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties. To the mind of this
Court, the maintainability of the instant writ petition has first to be
examined from the stand point of Article 329 of the Constitution of India.
For the sake of convenience, Article 329 is reproduced herein below;
“329. Bar to interference by courts in electoral matters.[Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution]
(a) the validity of any law relating to the delimitation of
constituencies or the allotment of seats to such
constituencies, made or purporting to be made under
article 327 or article 328, shall not be called in
question in any court;
(b) no election to either House of Parliament or to the
House or either House of the Legislature of a State
shall be called in question except by an election
petition presented to such authority and in such
manner as may be provided for by or under any law
made by the appropriate Legislature.”
17.
Article 329 bars the interference by Courts in electoral matters,
and as such, will normally oust the jurisdiction of this Court in any matter
relating to election, by way of a writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution, except where the assistance of the Court is sought merely
to correct or smoothen the progress of election proceedings, or to remove
the obstacles that may stall an election process. The instant petition has
been filed seeking action to be taken by the respondent No. 1, under Rule
16A of the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968,
against the respondent No. 3. As such, the purport of this rule is to be
considered as to its implications and whether the writ petition can be
entertained, on the prayer contained therein. The Election Symbols
(Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968, it is noted was formulated in
exercise of the powers conferred by Article 324 of the Constitution [read
with section 29A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (43 of
1951)] and rules 5 and 10 of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 and
all other powers enabling it by the Election Commission of India
(respondent No. 1).
18.
The source of power of The Election Symbols (Reservation and
Allotment) Order, 1968, as given, and Rule 16A of the Election Symbols
(Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968 reads as follows;
NOW THEREFORE, in exercise of the powers conferred by
Article 324 of the Constitution 1 [read with section 29A of the
Representation of the People Act, 1951 (43 of 1951)] and rules 5 and 10 of
the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 and all other powers enabling it in
this behalf, the Election Commission of India hereby makes the following
Order :………
“16A. Power of Commission to suspend or
withdraw recognition of a recognised political
party for its failure to observe Model Code of
Conduct or follow lawful directions and
instructions of the CommissionNotwithstanding anything in this Order, if the
Commission is satisfied on information in its
possession that a political party, recognised
either as a National party or as a State party
under the provisions of this Order, has failed or
has refused or is refusing or has shown or is
showing defiance by its conduct or otherwise (a)
to observe the provisions of the ‘Model Code of
Conduct for Guidance of Political Parties and
Candidates’ as issued by the Commission in
January, 1991 or as amended by it from time to
time, or (b) to follow or carry out the lawful
directions and instructions of the Commission
given from time to time with a view to furthering
the conduct of free, fair and peaceful elections or
safeguarding the interests of the general public
and the electorate in particular, the Commission
may, after taking into account all the available
facts and circumstances of the case and after
giving the party reasonable opportunity of
showing cause in relation to the action proposed
to be taken against it, either suspend, subject to
such terms as the Commission may deem
appropriate, or withdraw the recognition of such
party as the National Party or, as the case be, the
State Party.”
19.
The non-compliance of Rule 16A, therefore, will come within
a wider ambit, which will necessarily include the purport of Article 324
of the Constitution, as also the provisions of the Representation of the
People Act, 1951, inasmuch as, the Election Symbols (Reservation and
Allotment) Order, 1968 was made by powers conferred by the
Constitution and by the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The
issue of non-compliance of Rule 16A, an Order made under the powers
vested under Article 324, will in turn, be covered by Section 100 (1) (d)
(iv) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, which is widely
worded to include all kinds of infractions which are residual in nature,
within the scope of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. Section
100(1)(d)(iv) reads as follows;
“100. Grounds for declaring election to be
void.- [(1) Subject to the provisions of sub-
section (2) if [the High Court] is of
opinion(a) …………………..
(b) ………………..
(c) ………………..
(d) ……………….
(i)
……………
(ii)
……………
(iii)
…………….
(iv)
by any non-compliance with the
provisions of the Constitution or
of this Act or of any rules or
orders made under this Act,
[the High Court] shall declare
the election of the returned
candidate to be void.”
20.
The abovenoted observation is being made, in view of the fact
that, the election process has already been set in motion and therefore,
apart from a proceeding under the Representation of the People Act,
1951, no other forum can adjudicate in such matters. No special
circumstances that, the writ petition has been filed in aid of and in
furtherance of the election process, are visible or apparent in any manner,
as the petitioner seeks that action be taken against the respondent No. 3,
which cannot be said to subserve the election process. Therefore, the
decision relied upon by the Senior Counsel for the petitioner that is
Election Commission of India through Secretary Vs. Ashok Kumar
(supra) is of no assistance to his case.
21.
On the question of ouster of jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution, and the scheme of Section 100 of the Representation of
the People Act, 1951, especially clause (1)(d)(iv), it would be apposite
to refer to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Manda
Jaganath Vs. K.S. Rathnam & Ors. (2004) 7 SCC 492, wherein to settle
the dilemma, with regard to this issue, has held in Paras – 13-16 as
follows;
“13. It is to be seen that under Article 329(b) of
the Constitution of India there is a specific
prohibition against any challenge to an election
either to the Houses of Parliament or to the
Houses of Legislature of the State except by an
election petition presented to such authority and
in such manner as may be provided for in a law
made by the appropriate legislature. Parliament
has by enacting the Representation of the People
Act, 1951 provided for such a forum for
questioning such elections hence, under Article
329(b) no forum other than such forum
constituted under the RP Act can entertain a
complaint against any election.
14. The word “election” has been judicially
defined by various authorities of this Court to
mean any and every act taken by the competent
authority after the publication of the election
notification.
15. In Ponnuswami this Court held: (AIR p. 68,
para 9)
The law of elections in India does not
contemplate that there should be two attacks on
matters connected with election proceedings, one
while they are going on by invoking the
extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution (the
ordinary jurisdiction of the courts having been
expressly excluded), and another after they have
been completed by means of an election petition.
16. The above view of this Court in Ponnuswami
case has been quoted with approval by the
subsequent judgment in M.S. Gill wherein this
Court after quoting the passages from the said
judgment in Ponnuswami case held that there is a
non obstante clause in Article 329 and,
therefore, Article 226 stands pushed out where the
dispute takes the form of calling in question an
election, except in special situations pointed out
but left unexplored in Ponnuswami case. It is
while considering the above unexplored situations
in Ponnuswami that in M.S. Gill case this Court
held thus: (SCC p. 429, para 34)
"34. This dilemma does not arise in the
wider view we take of Section
100(1)(d)(iv) of the Act. Sri Rao's attack on
the order impugned is in substance based
on alleged non-compliance with a provision
of the Constitution viz. Article 324 but is
neatly covered by the widely-worded,
residual catch-all clause of Section 100.
Knowing the supreme significance of
speedy elections in our system the framers
of the Constitution have, by implication
postponed all election disputes to election
petitions and tribunals. In harmony with
this scheme Section 100 of the Act has been
designedly drafted to embrace all
conceivable infirmities which may be
urged.
To
make
the
project
foolproof Section 100(1)(d)(iv) has been
added to absolve everything left over. The
Court has in earlier rulings pointed out
that Section 100 is exhaustive of all
grievances regarding an election."
(Emphasis supplied)
22.
The above quoted judgment, having covered any lacunae that,
may have existed, in the considered view of this Court, the dispute sought
to be raised by the writ petitioner will not be entertainable under Article
226 of the Constitution, more specifically with the electoral process
already underway. Further, as submitted by the learned Senior counsel
for the respondents No. 1 and 2, the basic issue also no longer survives
for adjudication, as it is no longer a case of non-compliance of Rule 16A,
but rather a case of delay in complying with the same.
23.
This Court having come to a finding on the maintainability of
the writ petition to be barred by Article 329(b) of the Constitution, the
other questions and the authorities placed are not gone into or discussed,
and this writ petition accordingly stands dismissed, as not maintainable.
Judge
Meghalaya
03.02.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review