The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. 1 The authorities themselves have, in one such case, Baiju T B v. Union of India2, restored the pay which was being drawn by similarly placed persons on the date of his retirement by giving him the benefit of Fundamental Rule-22(B)(1). This Court disposed of the case of the said person by the following directions: “3. The Competent Authority has passed the order dated 25.01.2025 Judgment dated 11.02.2025 in W.P.(C) No.41234/2024 WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023 2025:KER:27476 revising the pension of the petitioner as claimed in the Writ Petition. The said order has been communicated to the 5th respondent.
4. Considering the aforesaid facts and the decision taken to revise the pension of the petitioner as prayed in this writ petition, the present writ petition is disposed of with direction to the 5th respondent to pay the arrears of pension to the petitioner, within a period of one month and the regular pension thereafter at the revised date.”
6. 2 In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present writ petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to revise the petitioner’s basic pay to Rs.42,800/-, entitling him to a basic pension of Rs.21,400/-, and pay the arrears of pension within one month from today. The amount of Rs.1,78,011/- recovered from the DCRG of the petitioner shall also be refunded to the petitioner within one month. With the aforementioned observation and directions, the present writ petition stands allowed. However, without costs. Sd/- jjj WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023 2025:KER:27476 Exhibit -P1 TRUE COPY OF OFFICE ORDER NO.P.III.03/2022-PEN-2 SIG DATED
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE D. K. SINGH
THURSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 6TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
PETITIONER/S:
SAJITH C, AGED 40 YEARS
S/O SHRI.CHANDRAN G, EX. HEAD CONSTABLE RADIO OPERATOR/CRPF, PREVIOUSLY
OF 2 SIGNAL BATTALION, HYDERABAD, RESIDING AT MANAKKAMPAT HOUSE,
PATHIRIPPALA, GANDHI SEVA SADAN POST, OTTAPPALAM, PALAKKAD DISTRICT,
KERALA STATE, PIN - 679302
BY ADVS.
T.SANJAY
SHABNA T.K.
SANIL KUMAR G.
RESPONDENT/S:
UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NORTH BLOCK, NEW
DELHI, PIN - 110001
THE DIRECTOR GENERAL/CRPF
CGO COMPLEX, LODHI ROAD NEW DELHI, PIN - 110003
THE INSPECTOR GENERAL/CRPF
COMMUNICATIONS) EAST BLOCK, NO.7, RK PURAM, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110066
DEPUTY INSPECTOR GENERAL/CRPF
RANGE HEAD QUARTERS, SALT LAKE, KOLKATA, WEST BENGAL, PIN - 700091
THE COMMANDANT
CRPF 2 SIGNAL BATTALION, HYDERABAD, TELANGANA, PIN - 500005
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
CENTRAL PENSION ACCOUNTING OFFICER
CENTRAL PENSION ACCOUNTING OFFICE, (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA), TRIKOOT-II,
BHIKAJI CAMA PLACE, NEW DELHI, PIN - 110066
THE SECRETARY (PENSION),
DEPARTMENT OF PENSION AND PENSIONER’S WELFARE, JANPATH BHAWAN, B WING,
8TH FLOOR NEW DELHI, PIN - 110001
BY ADV N.S.DAYA SINDHU SHREE HARI
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING FINALLY HEARD ON 27.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME
DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
JUDGMENT
The petitioner, who took voluntary retirement from the post of
Head Constable/Radio Operator in CRPF on 30.04.2023, filed the present
writ petition aggrieved by the decision to reduce his basic pay from
Rs.42,800/- to Rs.41,600/- with effect from 01.01.2023 and accordingly
reduce his pension from Rs.21,400/- to Rs.20,800/- as well as against the
recovery of Rs.1,78,011/- from his gratuity.
2.
The petitioner was enlisted as a Constable (General Duty) in
the Central Reserve Police Force on 03.03.2003 in the pre-revised pay
scale of Rs.3,050-75-3,950-80-4,590 which was revised to Rs.5,200 – 20,200
+ GP 2000 with effect from 01.01.2006. Subsequently, the petitioner was
re-mustered as Head Constable/Radio Operator with effect from
24.08.2009 in the revised pay scale of Rs.5,200-20,200 + GP 2,400/-. Due
to him having higher academic qualifications with Physics, Chemistry
and Maths as core subjects, his pay was fixed at Rs.7,830/- + 2,400/- with
effect from 24.08.2009 by giving pay fixation benefit in the post of Head
Constable/Radio Operator on re-musteration.
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
2.1
As the petitioner was due for voluntary retirement with effect
from 30.04.2023, the respondents have re-fixed his pay at Rs.41,600/with effect from 01.01.2023 by treating his re-musteration as Head
Constable/Radio Operator as a fresh appointment to the said post with
effect from 24.08.2009.
3.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that it
was not a fresh appointment but a promotion, and the petitioner's past
services could not be wiped out. Therefore, the re-fixation of pay,
treating him as a fresh appointee with effect from 24.08.2009 as Head
Constable/Radio Operator, is wholly illegal and unjustified.
3.1
The petitioner was drawing the salary of Rs.42,800/- and it
was his last drawn pay. Hence, the gratuity and pension should have
been fixed accordingly. Instead of fixing his salary and gratuity on his
basic pay of Rs.42,800/-, the petitioner’s pay has been re-fixed to
Rs.41,600/- treating him to be a fresh appointee to the post of Head
Constable/Radio Operator with effect from 24.08.2009. The petitioner’s
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
re-musteration to the post of Head Constable/Radio Operator was all
along treated as his promotion from the post of Constable (General
Duty), and he was paid accordingly. Now, on the eve of his retirement,
treating the petitioner to have been appointed afresh on re-musteration
to the post of Head Constable/Radio Operator is arbitrary, illegal, unjust,
improper and in violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India.
3.2
The petitioner has further submitted that the issue is also
otherwise covered by the judgment in the case of State of Punjab v. Rafiq
Masih1.
4.
On the other hand, Mr Daya Sindhu Sreehari learned Central
Government Counsel has submitted that as per the provisions laid down
in paragraph 6.4(b) Chapter VI of CRPF Recruitment Manual-1975, the
re-musteration to the rank of Naik/Radio Operator from Constables
(General Duty/Bug/Mali and painter) and the communication of DIG
(2014) 8 SCC 883
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
(Communication), Directorate General, CRPF dated 25.08.2021 would
suggest that on re-musteration, it should be treated as fresh
appointment to the post of Head Constable/Naik/Radio Operator and the
pay should be fixed accordingly.
4.1
The submission is that the petitioner would not be entitled to
one increment while fixing pay on re-musteration as there was no such
provision available either in the Fundamental Rules or any other
Manuals. On re-musteration, the pay of the Head Constable/Radio
Operator is to be fixed as per Fundamental Rules FR-22(B)(1) by
protecting his presumptive pay being drawn in the rank of CT(GD).
Annual Increment would also be granted on the normal date of
increment in the lower pay scale till completion of his probation in the
higher rank, so as to fix his pay after completion of the probation period
in the higher rank. The pay fixation benefit would be admissible at the
time of re-mustering as Head Constable/Naik/Radio Operator as per
Chapter VI of the Recruitment Manual of CRPF and the re-musteration
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
to the rank of Naik/Radio Operator from Constable (General
Duty/Bug/Mali/Painter) is to be treated as fresh appointment.
4.2
Mr Daya Sindhu Sreehari learned Central Government
Counsel has further submitted that the CRPF has sought clarification
from the Ministry of Home Affairs vide letter dated 23rd/24th January
2023. However, no clarification has been received on this issue. He has
also submitted that the Accounts Officer (Audit), Headquarters, New
Delhi, has forwarded the case of the petitioner to the Senior Accounts
Officer, IAW-19, Ajmer, vide letter dated 13.06.2023 for re-examination
and to submit a speaking order for taking further course of action. In
the meantime, IG (Comn&IT) vide communication dated 07.11.2023 had
issued directions to DIC, Signal Range and all Signal Units not to allow
pay fixation benefits under Fundamental Rule-22 to all Head
Constable/Naiks/Radio Operators till an appropriate decision is taken in
the matter so as to avoid overpayment and unnecessary recovery from
the individual concerned.
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
4.3
Furthermore, in the light of the above facts, the pay of the
petitioner was fixed treating his re-musteration as a fresh appointment
to the post of Head Constable/Naik/Radio Operator. Therefore, the
overpayment of Rs.1,78,011/- had to be recovered from his DCRG.
5.
I have considered the submissions on behalf of the parties and
perused the records.
5.1
On the eve of retirement, the petitioner’s promotion to the
post of Head Constable/Naik/Radio Operator was treated as a fresh
appointment to the said post and his pay has been fixed on that basis
with effect from 24.08.2009 without giving him the benefit of
Fundamental Rule-22(B)(1) by protecting his pay of the rank of Constable
(General Duty). All along, till he took the voluntary retirement, he was
given the benefit of Fundamental Rules-22(B)(1), and his pay on the post
of Constable (General Duty) was protected, and his appointment to the
post of Head Constable/Naik/Radio Operator was treated as promotion.
5.2
This Court fails to understand that after fourteen years from
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
the date of his appointment to the post of Head Constable/Naik/Radio
Operator, the authorities have taken the U-turn that his appointment on
re-musteration as Head Constable/Naik/Radio Operator shall not be
treated as promotion but fresh appointment and he would not be
entitled to the benefit of Fundamental Rule-22(B)(1).
6.
This Court is of the considered view that the authorities
cannot take such a view after fourteen years and re-fix the pay of the
petitioner to his detriment. Even otherwise, the recovery of a sum of
Rs.1,78,011/- from the DCRG of the petitioner is wholly unjustified in
view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih (supra).
Paragraph 18 of the said judgment, which is relevant, is extracted
hereunder:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which would
govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be
that as it may, based on the decisions referred to herein above, we may,
as a ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein
recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV service
(or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due to retire
within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment has been made
for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required
to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to work against an
inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion, that
recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance
of the employer’s right to recover.”
6.1
The authorities themselves have, in one such case, Baiju T B
v. Union of India2, restored the pay which was being drawn by similarly
placed persons on the date of his retirement by giving him the benefit of
Fundamental Rule-22(B)(1). This Court disposed of the case of the said
person by the following directions:
“3. The Competent Authority has passed the order dated 25.01.2025
Judgment dated 11.02.2025 in W.P.(C) No.41234/2024
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
revising the pension of the petitioner as claimed in the Writ Petition. The
said order has been communicated to the 5th respondent.
4. Considering the aforesaid facts and the decision taken to revise the
pension of the petitioner as prayed in this writ petition, the present writ
petition is disposed of with direction to the 5th respondent to pay the
arrears of pension to the petitioner, within a period of one month and
the regular pension thereafter at the revised date.”
6.2
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present writ petition
is allowed. The respondents are directed to revise the petitioner’s basic
pay to Rs.42,800/-, entitling him to a basic pension of Rs.21,400/-, and
pay the arrears of pension within one month from today. The amount
of Rs.1,78,011/- recovered from the DCRG of the petitioner shall also be
refunded to the petitioner within one month.
With the aforementioned observation and directions, the present
writ petition stands allowed. However, without costs.
Sd/-
D. K. SINGH
JUDGE
jjj
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 43373/2023
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit -P1
TRUE COPY OF OFFICE ORDER NO.P.III.03/2022-PEN-2 SIG DATED
11.03.2023 ISSUED BY THE 5TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE PAY SLIP SHOWING HIS BASIC PAY IN THE
MONTH OF APRIL 2023 @ RS.42,800/-
Exhibit -P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.468/2023-ACCTS-BR-DA1-ACT-2SIG
DATED 04.05.2023 ISSUED BY THE 5TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P4
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 28.05.2023 SENT BY
THE PETITIONER ADDRESSED TO THE 4TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION NO. V.II-4/2023-SRC-IV-@
SIG DATED 08.07.2023 RECEIVED FROM THE 5TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION NO. P-III_1/2023-EST-I(MISC)
DATED 12.07.2023 ISSUED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P7
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 27.09.2023 PREFERRED
BY THE PETITIONER ADDRESSED TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P8
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 27.09.2023 PREFERRED
BY THE PETITIONER ADDRESSED TO THE 3RD RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P9
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION NO. V.II-4/2023-SRC-IV-2 SIG
DATED 16.10.2023 RECEIVED BY THE PETITIONER FROM THE 5TH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P10
. A TRUE COPY OF THE SPECIAL SEAL AUTHORITY APPROVED THE
PENSIONARY BENEFITS TO THE PETITIONER DATED 03.08.2023 ISSUED
BY THE 6TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit -P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE PENSION PAYMENT ORDER BEARING
NO.239032324927 DATED 25-07-2023 IN RESPECT OF THE PETITIONER
Exhibit -P12
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 18.07.2023 ISSUED BY THE
DEPUTY DIRECTOR ACCOUNTS CRPF NEW DELHI SHOWING THE
ADMISSIBLE GRATUITY OF THE PETITIONER AT RS.5,90,720/-
WP(C) NO. 43373 OF 2023
2025:KER:27476
Exhibit - P13
A TRUE COPY OF THE BANK STATEMENT FROM 01.07.2023 TO
18.12.2023 ISSUED BY SBI MANKARA BRANCH
Exhibit -P14
A TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE OFFICE MEMORANDUM NO.F.NO. 1
8/03/20 1 5-ESTT. (PAY-I), DATED 02.03.2016 ISSUED BY THE
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND TRAINING
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R5(a)
A true copy of the Chapter-VI of Recruitment Manual dated NIL
Exhibit R5(b)
A true copy of the 2nd signal Bn order No. P.I-04-2023-SRC-IV dated
17-04-2023
Exhibit R5(c)
A true Copy of the signal No. P.I-1-2020-21-C 10 dated 25-08-2021
Exhibit R5(e)
A true copy of the No. P.I-1-2022-23-C-10-217470- dated 06-07-2023
Exhibit R5( f)
A true copy of the No. IAW- HQ-MHA-CRPF-PF2023-24 dated 13-062023
Exhibit R5(h)
A true copy of the Dept. of Pen- P.W. O.M. No. 28-91-2022-P and PW-B-2- dated 20-10-2023
Exhibit R5(i)
A true copy the undertaking by the Petitioner dated Nil
Exhibit R5(d)
A true copy of the signal No. P.VII-52-2020-DA-1-P- dated 06-09-2021
Exhibit R5(g)
A true copy of the signal no. P.I-1-2023-24-C-10-217470 dated 07-112023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review