Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 26.08.2019
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
:
Petitioner
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
versus
:
Respondents
The State of Sikkim and Another
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
--------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Tashi Norbu Basi and Mr. William Tamang, Advocates, for
the Petitioner.
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate General with Mr.
Thupden Youngda, Government Advocate and Mr. S.K. Chettri
and Ms. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocates, for the
Respondents No.1 and 2.
---------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The
only
question
for
determination
herein
is
whether the Respondent No.2 ought to be directed to accept the
Tender Bid Documents including the Term Deposit Receipt
(hereinafter “TDR”), of Rs.90,62,000/- (Rupees ninety lakhs and
sixty two thousand) only, submitted by the Petitioner on
07.03.2019 at 12.20 p.m., beyond the stipulated time of
submission, fixed at 12 noon, by the Respondent No.2.
2.
The
Petitioner
is
a
registered
Government
Contractor, Grade IAA. An advertisement was published in a
local daily newspaper “Sikkim Express,” dated 02.03.2019, on
behalf
of
the
Gangtok
Smart
City
Development
Limited
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
(hereinafter “GSCDL”), inviting sealed Tenders from eligible
Contractors enlisted with the State Government, for construction
of Social Housing for Economically Weaker Sections, under
Affordable Housing for Urban Poor at Sokaythang, Gangtok, East
Sikkim. The advertisement, in the paragraph “Instructions to
Bidders,” specified inter alia that a complete set of Bid
Documents may be purchased by interested eligible bidders from
the Chief Executive Officer, GSCDL, on payment of nonrefundable cost of Bid Documents. Forms would be available
from 05.03.2019 to 06.03.2019 between 13:00 Hrs to 15:00
Hrs. The Petitioner, in response thereto, purchased the said Bid
Documents for Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs) only, vide a
Demand Draft of the Central Bank of India, Gangtok Branch,
dated 04.03.2019 payable to “CEO, GSCDL.” Admittedly, the last
date for submission of the Bid Documents was fixed on or before
12:00 Hrs on 07.03.2019. The Petitioner avers that although he
attempted to collect the entire
Bid Documents from the
Respondent No.2 on 05.03.2019 at 13:00 Hrs, he was told that
the said documents were not ready and was instructed to collect
it on 06.03.2019. The documents were issued to him on
06.03.2019
at
14:00
Hrs.
On
07.03.2019,
the
Petitioner
telephonically sought extension of one hour for submission of the
documents, from the Additional Chief Engineer and the Assistant
Engineer of the GSCDL in view of the time taken to complete the
documents and the aforestated circumstances, apart from being
obstructed by traffic on the same day. An assurance was given
by the Additional Chief Engineer that his request shall be taken
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
into consideration. However, when the Petitioner reached the
Office of the GSCDL at 12.20 Hrs, he found the Office closed
despite the fact that the Office Hours are till 4 p.m. and thereby
could not submit his Bid Documents. The Petitioner however
learnt that the Respondent No.2 had relaxed the scheduled time
for other Contractors and had permitted them to file their Bid
Documents at around 12.10 p.m. while denying him of such
opportunity. Laying the blame at the door of the Respondent
No.2 for availability of the Bid Documents only on 06.03.2019
instead of 05.03.2019, the Petitioner sought the following reliefs
i.e., a direction to the Respondent authorities to accept his Bid
Documents for the Contract Work as published vide “Notice
Inviting Re-Tender (NIT) No.GSCDL/TENDER/NIT/SHEWS/2019
vide its Ref. No.15/ SPV/GSCDL/SHEWS/2019, Dated 28-022019,” in Sikkim Express on 02.03.2019, and in the alternative,
to quash the said Notice. A further direction was sought to the
Respondents to re-tender the Contract Work.
3.
The Respondent No.1 had no Counter-Affidavit to
file.
4.
that
The Respondent No.2, in its Counter-Affidavit, stated
initially
a
Notice
Inviting
Tender
bearing
Reference
No.08/SPV/GSCDL/SHEWS/2019,
dated
01.02.2019,
was
uploaded in its official website on the same day and published in
a local daily newspaper on 03.02.2019. The Notice Inviting
Tender gave specific instructions to the Bidders. The instructions
also stated that the Bid Documents would be available from
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
11.02.2019 to 13.02.2019 between 11:00 Hrs to 14:00 Hrs on
22.02.2019. The Petitioner was one of the seven Bidders who
purchased the tender documents. Later, due to reduction in the
bid security value for various reasons, a Corrigendum dated
12.02.2019, was issued by the Respondent No.2. As per
instructions issued therein, the sealed Bids duly signed by the
authorized signatory were to be delivered to the CEO, GSCDL,
Gangtok, on or before 12:00 Hrs on 22.02.2019 but the
Respondent No.2 did not receive any Bids despite purchase of
seven Tender Documents from their Office. In view of this
circumstance, a proposal for re-tendering the Contract Work was
made and Notice Inviting Re-Tender dated 28.02.2019 for the
Project, as reflected in the petition, was again uploaded in the
official website and published in the daily newspaper “Sikkim
Express.” That, it was specified therein that 'Sealed bid in
duplicate duly signed by authorised signatory must be delivered
to CEO, GSCDL, Gangtok on or before 12:00 Hrs of 07.03.2019'
and that “Late bid will not be accepted by tendering authority.” A
total
of
eleven
Bidders
thereafter
purchased
the
Tender
Documents which included the Petitioner. On 07.03.2019, seven
Bidders out of the eleven intending Bidders, submitted their
sealed documents on or before 12:00 Hrs at the Office of the
Chief Executive Officer of the Respondent No.2, however, the Bid
of the Petitioner was not accepted as he arrived beyond the
scheduled time of 12:00 Hrs, which disqualified him outright, in
view of instruction No.5 of the “Instruction to Bidders.” Besides
the Petitioner, one Nirmal Bajaj, also an intending Bidder, was
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
not permitted to submit his Bid after the closing time. The
Petitioner having purchased the Bid Documents twice, was fully
aware of the requirements, consequently the petition is not
maintainable as the Petitioner was not diligent and slept over his
rights. Hence, the petition deserves a dismissal.
5.
In Rejoinder, the Petitioner while reiterating the facts
made in the Writ Petition supported his pleadings with an
Affidavit filed by one Bhola Nath Sharma, representative of
Tejasurya Construction Pvt. Ltd., Siliguri, who swore that his
tender bid documents was accepted by the Respondent No.2 at
“12.10 Hrs,” on 07.03.2019.
6.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner canvassed the
arguments that although the Petitioner was denied his rights for
the reason that he reached the Office of the Respondent No.2 at
12.20 Hrs, but as evident from the Affidavit of Bhola Nath
Sharma, representing Tejasurya Construction Pvt. Ltd., Siliguri,
despite him having reached the Office of the Respondent No.2 at
12:10 Hrs, beyond the time prescribed, he was permitted to
submit his Bid Documents. That, although Annexure R-6, dated
28.02.2019 relied on by the Respondent No.2, details the 'List of
Bidders who submitted their Bids on 07.03.2019 at 12:00 Hrs,'
and lists Tejasurya Construction Pvt. Ltd., Siliguri, as having
submitted the Bid at 12 noon, but the reverse side of the
document would demolish this contention in the absence of
Bhola Nath Sharma’s signature in the list of signatories. Only six
signatures are affixed when the Bid Documents were accepted at
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
12:00 Hrs and the seventh signature is non-existent, indicating
falsity in the assertion of the Respondent No.2. That, the same
opportunity
extended to
Tejasurya
Construction Pvt. Ltd.,
Siliguri, ought to be given to the Petitioner, as he was delayed
by only another ten minutes. To augment his submissions,
learned Counsel placed reliance on G.J. Fernandes v. State of
Karnataka1. Reiterating the time schedule for collecting the Bid
Documents, it was urged that the Respondent No.2, in his
Counter Affidavit, has accepted the fact that the Petitioner had
indeed come to their Office on 05.03.2019 to collect the Bid
Documents. However, he reached at 1 p.m. and not earlier as
sought to be posited by the Respondent No.2. That, the
ineptitude of the Respondent No.2 resulted in the delayed
delivery of the Bid Documents to the Petitioner and hence the
petition be allowed.
7.
Vehemently
resisting
the
arguments
of
the
Petitioner, learned Additional Advocate General would submit
that in the first instance, the petition is not maintainable for the
reason that the alternative prayer of the Petitioner includes
quashing of the “Notice Inviting Re-Tender (NIT) No.GSCDL/
TENDER/NIT/SHEWS/2019
vide
its
Ref.
No.15/SPV/GSCDL/
SHEWS/2019, Dated 28-02-2019.” Should this Court be inclined
to grant the prayer, then the other Bidders who are not
impleaded as parties would suffer the consequences. Thus, their
impleadment is imperative, failing which, the petition deserves
1990 SCC (2) 748
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
to be dismissed. That apart, the “Instructions to Bidders”
specifically states that Bids were to be submitted on or before
12:00 Hrs of 07.03.2019 and there would be no extension of
time. That, no proof of a third person having been afforded extra
time by the Office of the Respondent No.2, was presented before
this Court and the Petitioner rather belatedly by an Affidavit of a
third person seeks to bring this stance on record. The Deponent
of the said Affidavit has no locus standi and therefore the
Affidavit deserves to be ignored by this Court. In support of her
contentions, learned Additional Advocate General placed reliance
on Vijay Kumar Kaul and Others v. Union of India and Others 2.
8.
Parties have been heard at length, their submissions
considered and all documents on record duly perused as also the
citations made at the Bar.
9.
On pain of repetition, it is but apposite to notice that
the Instructions to Bidders of the Notice Inviting Tender specify
as follows;
“A complete set of bidding documents in the
English language, may be purchased by the interested
eligible bidders on submission of bidder application to
Chief Executive Officer, GSDCL, Gangtok 737102, Sikkim
(India) and on payment of the non-refundable cost of
bidding document as specified in Column no. 6 of above
during normal office hours and all working days from
Date-05.03.2019 to 06.03.2019, 13:00 hrs to 15:00 hrs.”
(emphasis supplied)
It issues with clarity that the Bid Documents were to be made
available to the interested Bidders on both dates i.e. 05.03.2019
(2012) 7 SCC 610
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
and 06.03.2019 at the hours stipulated therein. The averments
of the Respondent No.2 admitted at paragraph 13 as follows;
“13. It is submitted that as per the instructions
more particularly serial No.3, the intending bidders were
required to purchase the tender documents from
5.03.2019 to 6.03.2019 within 13.00 hrs to 15.00hrs on
the said days. ...”
(emphasis supplied)
This averment is an unequivocal admission that the
Bid
Documents were to be made available to the Contractors on both
days mentioned, at the scheduled time of 13:00 Hrs to 15:00
Hrs. In contradiction to the assertion of the Petitioner that he
reached the Office of the Respondent No.2 on 05.03.2019 at
13:00 Hrs, it is stated by the Respondent No.2 as follows;
“... It is submitted that the petitioner came to the
office of the respondent no. 2 during morning hours on
5/3/2019 instead of the facts (sic) that the documents
was to be collected after 1300 hours. The petitioner failed
to come during the time prescribed in NIT. In other
words, the petitioner failed to comply with the terms and
condition for collection of the bid documents as prescribed
under instruction to the bidders.”
From the above, it is evident that the Petitioner had indeed
reached the Office of the Respondent No.2 on 05.03.2019. This
fact has not been controverted by the Respondent No.2, save to
the effect that the Petitioner reached in the “morning hours,”
without
delineating
the
exact
hour.
In
other
words,
the
Respondent No.2 has failed to disclose the facts purported to be
within their knowledge. It is indeed incongruous to imagine that
the Petitioner having reached the Office of the Respondent No.2,
be it in the morning hours of 05.03.2019, would not have waited
till 13:00 Hrs to collect the documents. This is an inconceivable
argument and deserves to be and is discarded by this Court.
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
Despite the time detailed in the advertisement pertaining to the
purchasing of Bids, lamentably, the Respondent No.2 failed to
comply with its part of the bargain as described and enumerated
in the advertisement and did not release the documents timely
to the Petitioner. This delay led to a consequential delay of
twenty minutes by the Petitioner in his submission of the
documents for reasons enumerated by him. The argument of the
Respondent No.2 that the Petitioner was aware of the contents
of the Bid Documents having purchased it earlier thereby
insinuating that he ought not to have been enmeshed in filling
the details, is an incongruous and unsustainable argument,
besides being timorous. If an act is expected from the Petitioner
then it has to be reciprocated by the Respondent No.2, in other
words, had the Respondent No.2 been diligent and handed over
the document to the Petitioner on 05.03.2019, as detailed in the
advertisement, it would have enabled the Petitioner to act
diligently in response. The delay of twenty minutes of the
Petitioner is a consequence of the delay of more than twenty
four hours meted out to him by the Respondent No.2. The action
of the Respondent No.2 cannot be exonerated. Besides, if the
Respondent
No.2
had
no
intention
of
releasing
the
Bid
Documents on 05.03.2019, they ought to have confined the date
to 06.03.2019 for such purposes.
10.
So far as the Affidavit of the third party Bhola Nath
Sharma is concerned, it is irrelevant for the present purposes,
having been filed by a third person who is not a party to the
proceedings, neither does he claim to be prejudicially affected by
WP(C) No.07 of 2019
Sajan Kumar Agarwal
vs. The State of Sikkim and Another
the act of the Respondent No.2 which is being assailed before
this Court and is, therefore, not even being considered.
11.
In view of the aforestated circumstances and the
discussions that have ensued, I am of the considered opinion
that the Petitioner ought to be allowed to submit his documents
before the Respondent No.2, which he shall do so on or before
12 noon tomorrow i.e. 27.08.2019. Be it noted that the relief
granted to the Petitioner shall not apply to any other party who
may consider himself aggrieved by the act of the Respondent
No. 2 but is not a party to the instant proceedings.
12.
In consideration of the undertaking given by learned
Counsel for the Respondents that the Respondent No.2 shall stay
its hands from taking any further steps in connection with the
Notice
Inviting
Re-Tender
(NIT)
No.GSCDL/TENDER/NIT/
SHEWS/2019 vide its Ref. No.15/SPV/ GSCDL/SHEWS/2019,
dated 28-02-2019, till 12.30 p.m. tomorrow i.e. 27.08.2019, the
Order dated 29.04.2019 stands vacated.
13.
Writ Petition disposed of accordingly as also I.A. No.
01 of 2019.
14.
No order as to costs.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
26.08.2019
ml
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review