Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
WP(C) No. 780/2026
CM No. 1978/2026
Reserved on: 22.09.2026
Pronounced on: 25.09.2026
Uploaded on: ______________
Operative part or full judgment: Full
Dr. Saima Kabir
D/O Abdul Kabir Lone
R/O Sogam,
District Kupwara.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Adv. Ishfaq Bashir.
Vs.
1. Union Territory of J&K
through Commissioner Secretary,
Health Department,
Kashmir, Srinagar.
2. Director, Health Services,
Kashmir, Srinagar.
3. Director, Sher-i-Kashmir
Institute of Medical Sciences (SKIMS),
Soura, Srinagar.
4. Medical Superintendent, Sher-i-Kashmir
Institute of Medical Sciences (SKIMS),
Soura, Srinagar.
5. Head of the Department (HOD), Anesthesia,
Sher-i-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences
(SKIMS), Soura, Srinagar.
6. Financial Advisor/ Chief Accounts Officer,
Sher-i-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences
(SKIMS), Soura, Srinagar.
…Respondent(s)
Page |2
Through: GA Faheem Nisar Shah.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner has invoked the writ jurisdiction of this
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
seeking the following reliefs:
(i)
a
writ
of mandamus
directing
the
respondents to release the pending
salary of petitioner forthwith along-with
interest;
(ii) a writ of mandamus directing the
respondents
to
issue
experience
certificate to the petitioner for the work
performed by her; and
(iii) a writ of mandamus directing the
respondents to release the security
deposit amount of Rs.55,000/- which
were deposited by the petitioner at the
time of joining her duties with the
respondent department.
2.
The case of the petitioner, as projected in the petition,
is
that
she
was
provisionally
engaged
by
the
respondents as Stipendiary Senior Resident in the
Page |3
department of Anesthesia at Sher-i-Kashmir Institute
of Medical Sciences (SKIMS) Soura Srinagar, vide
Government Order No. SIMS/ACAD/538 of 2023
dated 31.09.2023 for a period of one year and,
pursuant thereto she discharged her duties; that the
contractual term of the petitioner was not extended
by the respondents beyond one year as has been done
in the case of other similarly situated doctors; that
the petitioner was paid salary/wages only for one
month on 04.04.2024 amounting to Rs. 1,27,772/which was deposited into her Bank account; that the
balance amount for eleven months has been illegally
withheld by the respondents without any reason and
justification; that an amount of Rs.55,000/-, as
security, deposited by the petitioner at the time of
joining her duties, is still lying with the respondents,
despite completing her tenure.
3.
Respondents’ stand is that the engagement order of
the petitioner was a conditional appointment; that the
petitioner was provisionally engaged for a period of
one year subject to the terms and conditions
incorporated in the order of engagement; that one of
the important condition stipulated is that in the event
an
adverse
report
regarding
her
character/antecedents was received from the CID
department, she would not claim any right to
Page |4
engagement and the engagement would be deemed to
have been cancelled ab initio; that the petitioner while
accepting
the
terms
of
furnished
an
Affidavit,
the
engagement
whereby
she
order,
expressly
undertook that in case an adverse report regarding
her character/antecedents was received, she would
not claim any right to engagement; that an adverse
report was received and on the basis thereof, the
respondents passed Order No.SIMS/ACAD/35 of
2025 dated 17.07.2025, whereby the petitioner's
engagement was cancelled ab initio; that the said
order has not been challenged by the petitioner in the
present petition.
4.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the
material available on file and considered the matter.
5.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner
vehemently argued that irrespective of the adverse
report
regarding
character/antecedents
of
the
petitioner, she had actually discharged her duties for
a whole year and, therefore, the respondents cannot
withhold the salary/wages for the services actually
rendered by her; that the petitioner had submitted a
written application before the respondents requesting
for release of salary/wages but the same has not been
considered by them; that the petitioner had worked
and performed her duties with honesty and the
Page |5
respondents are legally bound to pay the pending
salary/wages of the petitioner; that the petitioner is
also entitled to an experience certificate and refund of
the security deposit of Rs.55,000/-.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents, exadverso, contends that the petitioner's engagement
was purely provisional and conditional; that the
petitioner had consciously accepted the condition
that
an
adverse
CID
report
would
result
in
cancellation of her engagement ab initio and had filed
an affidavit undertaking not to claim engagement in
such eventuality; that the claim of the petitioner
having deposited an amount of Rs.55,000/- as
security deposit with the respondents, there is no
documentary evidence, whatsoever, evidencing such
alleged deposit; that the order dated 17.07.2025
cancelling the engagement of the petitioner has not
been
assailed,
therefore,
the
petitioner
cannot,
indirectly, seek to nullify its consequences through
the present petition.
7.
The first question which arises for consideration is as
to the nature of the petitioner's engagement. The
material placed before the Court makes it clear that
the petitioner was not engaged unconditionally for a
fixed
period.
Her
engagement
was
expressly
provisional and was subject to the condition that in
Page |6
case
an
adverse
report
regarding
her
character/antecedents was received from the CID
department, she would have no claim to such
engagement
and
the
engagement
would
stand
cancelled ab initio. The petitioner was fully conscious
of the said condition. She did not merely accept the
engagement order but also furnished an affidavit
undertaking that in case an adverse character report
was received, she would not claim engagement.
8.
A person who accepts an engagement/appointment
subject to specified conditions cannot ordinarily seek
enforcement
of
the
engagement/appointment
contrary to those very conditions. The Supreme Court
has
repeatedly
held
that
engagements/appointments
contractual/temporary
are
governed
by
the
terms on which the engagement/appointment is
made and that a person engaged/appointed for a
limited or specified tenure does not acquire a right to
continuation contrary to the governing conditions.
The Supreme Court has also recognized the relevance
of the terms of engagement/appointment in matters
concerning character verification and cancellation of
appointment on account of adverse antecedents. In
Kerala State Electricity Board v. Kurien E.
Kalathil reported as
(2000) 6 SCC
293, the
Supreme Court emphasised that where a dispute
Page |7
arises out of contractual terms, the rights of the
parties have to be determined with reference to the
contract and the Court cannot rewrite its terms.
Likewise, in State of U.P. v. Neeraj Awasthi
reported as (2006) 1 SCC 667, the Supreme Court
reiterated that a temporary/adhoc appointee has no
indefeasible right to continue in service contrary to
the terms and conditions governing the appointment.
9.
In the present case, the petitioner's own affidavit
assumes considerable significance. Having expressly
undertaken that she would not claim engagement in
the event of receipt of an adverse character report, as
such,
in
the
absence
of
a
challenge
to
the
foundational condition itself, she cannot seek a
direction which would have the effect of continuing or
recognising her engagement. It is also significant that
the respondents subsequently passed order dated
17.07.2025 cancelling the petitioner's engagement ab
initio. The said order has not been challenged by the
petitioner in the present petition. Therefore, the
validity of the said order is not directly in issue before
this Court. The Court, as such, cannot grant a relief
which would, in substance, nullify the effect of the
order dated 17.07.2025, without the said order itself
having been questioned. The Supreme Court has
consistently maintained that where the relationship is
Page |8
governed by contractual terms, the Court ordinarily
cannot rewrite the contract or substitute terms
different from those accepted by the parties.
10. The claim for unpaid salary, however, requires
consideration. The fact that the engagement was
subsequently cancelled does not, by itself, answer the
question whether salary had accrued in respect of
services actually rendered before the cancellation.
The contention, on behalf of the respondents that the
engagement order, after receipt of adverse CID report,
having been cancelled ab initio, and without being
challenged by the petitioner, she is not entitled to any
of the reliefs prayed for, is not tenable, to the extent
of payment of wages/salary. Withholding and denial
of payment of the remuneration for the period the
petitioner had worked, would be violative of Article 23
of the Constitution of India. The condition in the
engagement order which disentitles an appointee to
wages/salary for the period for which she has
worked, is in teeth of Article 23 of the Constitution
and even on filing of an undertaking, cannot be
enforced. In this backdrop
respondents
cannot
deny
of the matter, the
wages/salary
to
the
petitioner, for the period, for which she has actually
worked with them. This Court finds support to take
this view, in view of the judgment passed by a co-
Page |9
ordinate Bench in WP(C) No.2769/2025, having
identical factual background.
Accordingly, without
disturbing the cancellation order dated 17.07.2025,
the respondents are required to be directed to
consider/verify the petitioner's claim for unpaid
salary for the period during which she actually
discharged duties and for release the amount, in
accordance with the terms of engagement.
11. The next relief sought is for issuance of an experience
certificate. An experience certificate is essentially a
certification of the factum and period of service
rendered by a person. However, in the present case,
the petitioner's engagement was expressly conditional
and has subsequently been cancelled ab initio in
terms of the conditions accepted by
petitioner
cannot
seek
through
a
her. The
direction
for
issuance of an experience certificate, which in
essence will declare that she was validly engaged,
notwithstanding
17.07.2025.
the
cancellation
Nevertheless,
if
the
order
dated
official
record
establishes that the petitioner actually discharged
duties for a particular period, there appears to be no
justification for the respondents from issuing a
factual certificate recording the period for which she
actually rendered services.
P a g e | 10
12. The petitioner has also sought release of the security
deposit of Rs.55,000/- through the medium of this
petition. Learned counsel for the petitioner, under
instructions, however, would urge that in absence of
any documentary proof and not being admitted by the
otherside, petitioner does not wish to press this relief
of refund of security deposit, if any.
13. For the foregoing reasons and the discussions made
hereinabove, this petition is, thus, partially allowed
and the respondents are directed to release the
legitimately unpaid earned wages/salary in favour of
the petitioner for the period she had actually worked
with the respondents, preferably within a period of
eight weeks from the date a copy of this order is
served upon them, however in default the petitioner
shall be entitled to receive the amount along-with
simple interest @ 6% per annum on the outstanding
wages/salary from the date of filing of this petition
i.e.
15.04.2026
till
the
amount
is
realized.
Furthermore, the respondents shall also consider
issuance of a factual certificate recording the period
for which the petitioner actually rendered her services
in the respondent department, without certifying any
period subsequent to the cancellation order dated
17.07.2025.
P a g e | 11
14. Disposed of, in terms of the above, along-with the
pending application(s).
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Srinagar
25.09.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review