Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP NO.83 OF 2022
1. Sahajada Choudhury,
W/o- late Abdul Kayam Choudhury,
R/o- Baldakhal, P.O.- Paschim Champamura,
P.S.- Bodhjungnagar, Sub-Division-Jirania,
District- West Tripura, 799008.
2. Abu Kalam Choudhury,
S/o- Late Abdul Kayam Choudhury,
R/o- Baldakhal, P.O.- Paschim Champamura,
P.S.- Bodhjungnagar, Sub-Division- Jirania,
District- West Tripura-799008.
3. Abul Hussan Choudhury,
S/o- late Abdul Kayam Choudhury
R/o- Baldakhal, P.O.- Pashim Champamura,
P.S.- Bodhjungnagar, Sub-Division- Jirania,
District- West Tripura-799008.
4. Abu Khayer Choudhury,
S/o- Late Abdul Kayam Choudhury,
R/o- Baldakhal, P.O.- Pashim Champamura,
P.S.- Bodhjungnagar, Sub-Division-Jirania,
District- West Tripura-799008.
5. Sahim Choudhury,
S/o- Late Abdul Kayam Choudhury,
R/o- Baldakhal, P.O.- Pashim Champamura,
P.S.- Bodhjungnagar, Sub-Division-Jirania,
District- West Tripura-799008.
6. Ayasha Choudhury,
D/o- Late Abdul Kayam Choudhury,
R/o- Baldakhal, P.O.- Pashim Champamura,
P.S.- Bodhjungnagar, Sub-Division- Jirania,
District- West Tripura, 799008.
(The petitioners were substituted on the death of Original
Decree Holder Abdul Kayam Choudhury, S/o-late Afsar
uddin@ Afsar Uddin Choudhury @ Afsar Uddin Sardar).
……… Petitioner(s)
Vs.
1. Mamataj Begam,
W/o- Late Ahidur Rahaman.
2. Md. Azaher Uddin,
S/o- Late Ahidur Rahaman.
3. Md. Alauddin,
S/o- Late Ahidur Rahaman.
4. Ms. Tania Begam,
D/o- Late Ahidur Rahaman.
All are resident of Baldakhal, P.O.- Pashim Champamura, P.S.Bodhjungnagar, Sub- Division- Jirania District- West Tripura799008.
……..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: None.
Date of hearing
: 11.10.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 16.10.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
The present CRP was disposed of vide order dated
27.07.2023 and by application, review of the same is sought for in
I.A. No.01 of 2023. By order dated 11.10.2023, this Court allowed
the review and recalled the order. Now the CRP is reopened and is
heard.
2.
The petitioners before this Court are plaintiffs. The
sole defendant expired pendente lite. The plaintiffs filed a suit
bearing registration No.T.S.90 of 2014 against the sole defendant
(Ahidur Rahaman) for restoring the property which has been
damaged by the defendant by digging sand(excavation) from the
open land and by changing the nature of the property. The
plaintiffs also sought claim for such damages.
3.
The suit schedule property belonging to the plaintiffs
which is said to have been damaged by the defendant is as under:“
SCHEDULE OF THE SUIT LAND
Within the District-East Tripura, Pargana-Agartala earlier
within P.S.- East Agartala at present within P.S. Bodhjungnagar, SubDivision-Jirania, earlier Sub-Division-Sadar, Revenue Circle-Jirania,
recorded under Mouja & Tehasil Cachery-Uttar Champamura, recorded in
khatian No.281/1, R.S. Plot No.108 for an area measuring 0.08 acres
nature of land Bastu, Part of Rs. Plot No.106 recorded in khatian No.281/2
for and area measuring 0.03 acre out of 0.06 acres of pukur par and part
of R.S. Plot No.114 for an area measuring 0.03 acres out of 0.10 acres of
bastu recorded in khatian No.281/2, totaling 0.14 acres of land which is
butted and bounded by
North by:- Plaintiff and his brother
South by:- Baldakhal-Matabari Road.
East by:- Nur Mahammad and others(heirs of Rahim-chand bibi.
West by:- R.S. Plot No.107 & 106 recorded in khatian No.281/2
of the same mouja
Within the schedule total 0.14 acres of land.”
4.
The Court below has decreed the suit by Judgment
and decree dated 27.09.2014. The decree is as under:“
ORDER
In the result, it is hereby ordered that the suit of
the plaintiff is decreed on contest without cost. It is hereby directed to the
defendant that he shall raise and re-fill the suit land in it is original
position and also to construct the bank(par) of the tank(pukur).
Defendant is also directed to pay an amount of
Rs.10,38,300/- as damages in favour of the plaintiff for loss of
construction on the suit land. The defendant is to abide by the direction of
this order and to comply the order within two months from the date of
passing this order/judgment and if the defendant falls the plaintiff will
have the liberty to knock the door of the appropriate court for seeking
redressal.
With the aforesaid observation, the present suit is
decreed on contest without cost.
Draw the decree.
Make necessary entry in the concerned TR.”
5.
The decree-holder filed an execution proceeding
under Order XXI Rule-11 of the CPC bearing registration No. Ex(T)07 of 2018 seeking attachment of the property of the defendants.
The schedule of the property seeking attachment of the execution
proceeding is as under:“ SCHEDULE OF THE PROPERTY
With the District West Tripura, Sub-Division,
Jirania Revenue Circle-Jirania, P.S. Bodhjungnagar, Mouja & Tehasil KachariUttar Champamura, recorded in Touji No.24(P), Khatian No.1239, Sabek Plot
No.PB-10,174, Hal Plot No.331, for land area measuring 0.32 acres of nul
land, butted and bounded byNorth-Road(Baldakhal-Matarbari Road)
South Sahinchowdhury and another
East- Sahajada Begam Chowdhury
West- Rafique Miah
Within this boundary for land area measuring 0.32 acres
of classified as nul.”
6.
Initially, after complying with the formalities of
serving summons and hearing, the Court below passed an interim
order of attachment on 06.10.2018. The same is extracted hereunder:“
Case No.T(EX)07 of 2018
06.10.2018.
Today was fixed for order.
Ld. Counsel L.R. Khadim is present on behalf of
Decree Holder.
I have heard him at length.
No step is filed by the Judgment Debtor side.
This is a petition for execution of the Decree dated
23.09.2016 passed by this Court in TS 90 of 2014 where by this
Court was placed to direct the present Judgment Debtor to pay an
amount of Rs.10,38,3000/- to the present Decree Holder as
damages.
Ld. Counsel for the Decree Holder seeks realization of
the said amount through attachment and sale of the property of the
Judgment Debtor described in the execution petition in schedule.
Ld. Counsel for the Decree Holder also fairly submits
that the property described in the schedule to the petition is wholly
owned by the Judgment Debtor.
Notice was duly served to the Judgment Debtor but
he did not enter appearance, hence, I am inclined to order as follows:
1. Issue Warrant of Attachment of the property of the
Judgment Debtor namely Ahidur Rahaman described in the schedule
to the execution petition if requisites are submitted.
Fix 23.11.2018 for execution report regarding
attachment.”
7.
The third parties to the suit filed an application under
Order XXI Rule 58 of CPC before the Execution Court and apart
from the other points contended that notices were not served and
they are affected parties and have rights, title and interest upon
the property under attachment. To this effect, submissions were
also made before the Court indicating that the original owners of
the property under attachment is Rahij Uddin and four other his
legal heirs namely,(1) Sahidur Rahaman, (2) Rafik Uddin, both son
of lt. Rahij Uddin (3) Smti. Surjahan Begam, W/o late Ulfath Ali,
(4) Smti. Manora Begam and (5) Smti. Nurjahan Begam (expired
without leaving any legal heirs behind her).
8.
It is seen that according to the third parties before
the Court below, the Judgment-debtor-Ahidur Rahaman deceased
pendente lite is not the owner. But it is seen from the cause title
that he is son of original owner i.e., late Rahij Uddin.
9.
The Court below after hearing both sides has passed
an order dated 24.06.2022 lifting the attachment which was
passed earlier and further directed the matter to be listed on 30th
August 2022 to proceed with the matter. The same is extracted
here-under:“Case No. Civil Misc(J) 40 of 2022
24-06-2022
Ld. Advocate Mr. L.R. Khadim is present on behalf
of the PlaintiffDH who has submitted list of documents in Firisti
after serving copies to the DefendantJD i.e. the Petitioner of Civil
Misc (J) 40 of 2022.
Ld. Advocate Mr. B.S. Bhowmik files memo of
appearance for the DefendantJD(Petitioner).
Heard both sides.
I have examined the application filed by the
Petitioner side (DefendantJD) under Order XXI Rule 58(2) of CPC
for taking into consideration the name of all the legal heirs of Rahij
Uddin, the original owner of the suit land as described in the plaint
and scrutinized the WO filed by the Plaintiff-DH.
The main thrust of the arguments led by the Sr.
Advocate Mr. S. Chakraborty to bring the name of all the legal
heirs on record of Lt. Rahij Uddin whose names are intentionally
omitted and (1) Sahidur Rahaman(2) Rafik Uddin (3) Surjahan
Begam (4) Manora Begam and Nurjahan Begam(dead) has to
brought on record along with the other legal heirs of Lt. Ahidur
Rahaman S/O Lt. Rahij Uddin since the above named legal heirs
are also the owners of the schedule of the suit land.
Ld. Advocate for the Plaintiff-DH did not raise any
counter facts denying the status of the legal heirs. Rather, the Ld.
Advocate for the Plaintiff-DH asserts the fact that the deceased
Ahidur Rahaman was not suffering from any illness and attended
the office regularly and disputed the illness of the deceased Ahidur
Rahaman in response to the plea of illness taken by the
Defendant-JD(Petitioners) in Para3 of the petition. The pivotal
question remains that whether the property which is attached on
04-01-2019 in terms of the Judgment and Order of decree dated,
23-09-2016 can be further executed when the other legal heirs
raising their objection regarding the ownership/claim of the
schedule of the suit land. A perusal of order XXI Rule 58(2) of CPC
discloses as that all questions including those right, title and
interest in the attached property are required to be decided by the
same Court and not by a separate suit. Since the
objectors/claimants who are actually brought on record in terms of
order dated, 1112 2020 on a petition moved by the Ld. Advocate
for the Plaintiff-DH are stating themselves there are other legal
heirs, it is thus lawful to hear the other persons namely,(1)
Sahidur Rahaman(2) Rafik Uddin (3) Surjahan Begam (4) Manora
Begam since the said persons may also have right, title and
interest of the suit land which has been attached in view of the
done in respect of the claim made by the Claimant / Objector and
the persons namely,(1) Sahidur Rahaman(2) Rafik Uddin (3)
Surjahan Begam (4) Manura Begam to be brought on record. The
Defendant-JD and other legal heirs as named may file appropriate
petition, if any, regarding their claim and it would be a
continuation of the proceedings under Order XXI Rule 58(2) of
CPC. The petition under Order XXI Rule 58(2) of CPC is allowed.
The Defendant-JD(Petitioners) to take necessary step in the spirit
of this order. Fix 30082022 for Hearing/ Step by the DefendantJD(Petitioners) / Step by the Plaintiff-DH.order dated, 06-10-2018.
The claim or objection for determination of the right title and
interest, if any has to be properly adjudicated by fair investigation.
Considering the fact and adjudication has to be done in
respect of the claim made by the Claimant / bjector and the
persons namely,(1) Sahidur Rahaman(2) Rafik Uddin (3) Surjahan
Begam (4) Manura Begam to be brought on record.
The Defendant-JD and other legal heirs as named may file
appropriate petition, if any, regarding their claim and it would be a
continuation of the proceedings under Order XXI Rule 58(2) of
CPC. The petition under Order XXI Rule 58(2) of CPC is allowed.
The Defendant-JD(Petitioners) to take necessary step in
the spirit of this order.
Fix 30-08-2022 for Hearing/ Step
Defendant-JD(Petitioners) / Step by the Plaintiff-DH.”
10.
by
the
Aggrieved by the said order of lifting the
attachment, the present CRP is filed by the Decree holder seeking
the following reliefs:“ i) Admit the instant petition.
ii) Call for records.
iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents & thereafter.
iv) Hear the instant petition and after hearing allow the
instant petition preferred by the petitioner by quashing & cancelling the
impugned Orders, dated, 24.06.2022 passed in Civil. Misc.(J)-40 of 2022
& Civil Misc.(J)-39 of 2022 & Order, dated 24.06.2022, passed in Ex(T)07 of 2018.
v) Be pleased to Pass an interim stay order, staying the
operation of the impugned Orders, dated 24.06.2022 passed in Civil
Misc(J)-40 of 2022 & Civil Misc(J)39 of 2022 & Order dated 24.06.2022,
passed in Ex(T) of 2018, till disposal of the instant petition.
vi) Pas any other or further order or orders as the
Hon’ble High Court may deem fit and proper in this regard for fair ends of
justice.”
11.
Here it is pertinent to mention earlier vide order
dated 27.07.2023, the present CRP was disposed of in the
following terms:“In view of above, the entire execution proceedings before
the Court below are set aside. The petitioners, the decree holders are at
liberty to initiate fresh execution proceeding. This Court finds that neither
in the pleadings of the execution proceeding nor in the order passed in the
execution proceeding, which is impugned with regard to the suit schedule
property and the subject matter, the property which is under attachment in
the execution proceeding are separate and no proper reasoning is given in
this regard, either in E.P. papers nor in the order. In view of the same, the
proceedings under execution proceeding are set aside, both the parties are
at liberty to avail remedies in accordance with law. The matter is remand
back to the learned Court below for fresh adjudication.”
12.
However in terms of the order passed in Rev. Pet
No.50 of 2023, this present CRP is again re-opened for hearing and
proper adjudication.
13.
Mr.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Sr. counsel assisted by
S.
Bhattacharjee,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner(s)/decree holder submits that the Court below having
satisfied has ordered the execution petition in the form of
attaching the property and without any proper reasons, the order
of attachment has been lifted and thus prayed to continue the
order of attachment.
14.
Heard and perused the evidence on record.
15.
Admittedly, the suit is decreed and the decree holder
has filed the execution petition, in respect of the third party
property and sought an attachment of the said property. The
learned Sr. counsel has not drawn the attention of this Court to
any such record to show that the Judgment debtor is the absolute
owner of the property under execution and there are no other
claimants.
16.
Initially, the Court below by order dated 06.10.2018
has passed an order of attachment. However, after hearing the
third parties the said order of attachment has been lifted in all
fairness to appreciate their rights, title, and interest and to follow
the doctrine of principles of natural justice.
17.
In this regard, it becomes necessary to examine the
Order XXI Rule 58 of CPC and other relevant rules that protect the
interest of the third parties.
Accordingly Order XXI Rule 58 and Rule 97 to 103 of
CPC hereby are extracted herein-under:-.
“Order XXI Rule 58:- Adjudication of claims to, or objections to
attachment of, property.
(1) Where any claim is preferred to, or any objection is made to the
attachment of, any property attached in execution of a decree on the ground
that such property is not liable to such attachment, the Court shall proceed
to adjudicate upon the claim or objection in accordance with the provisions
herein contained:
Provided that no such claim or objection shall be entertained(a) where, before the claim is preferred or objection is made, the property
attached has already been sold; or (b) where the Court considers that the
claim or objection was designedly or unnecessarily delayed.
(2) All questions (including questions relating to right, title or interest in the
property attached) arising between the parties to a proceeding or their
representatives under this rule and relevant to the adjudication of the claim
or objection, shall be determined by the Court dealing with the claim or
objection and not by a separate suit.
(3) Upon the determination of the questions referred to in sub-rule (2), the
Court shall, in accordance with such determination:(a) allow the claim or objection and release the property from attachment
either wholly or to such extent as it thinks fit; or
(b) disallow the claim or objection; or
(c) continue the attachment subject to any mortgage, charge or other
interest in favour of any person; or
(d) pass such order as in the circumstances of the case it deems fit.
(4) Where any claim or objection has been adjudicated upon under this rule,
the order made thereon shall have the same force and be subject to the
same conditions as to appeal or otherwise as if it were a decree.
(5) Where a claim or an objection is preferred and the Court, under the
proviso to sub-rule (1), refuses to entertain it, the party against whom such
order is made may institute a suit to establish the right which he claims to
the property in dispute; but, subject to the result of such suit, if any, an
order so refusing to entertain the claims or objection shall be conclusive.
Order XXI Rule 97:- Resistance
possession of immovable property.
or
obstruction
to
(1) Where the holder of a decree for the possession of immovable property
or the purchaser of any such property sold in execution of a decree is
resisted or obstructed by any person in obtaining possession of the property,
he may make an application to the Court complaining of such resistance or
obstruction.
(2) Where any application is made under sub-rule (1), the Court shall
proceed to adjudicate upon the application in accordance with the provisions
herein contained.
Order XXI Rule 98:- Orders after adjudication.
(1) Upon the determination of the questions referred to in rule 101, the
Court shall, in accordance with such determination and subject to the
provisions of sub-rule (2),(a) make an order allowing the application and directing that the applicant
be put into the possession of the property or dismissing the application; or
(b) pass such other order as, in the circumstances of the case, it may deem
fit.
(2) Where, upon such determination, the Court is satisfied that the
resistance or obstruction was occasioned without any just cause by the
judgment-debtor or by some other person at his instigation or on his behalf,
or by any transferee, where such transfer was made during the pendency of
the suit or execution proceeding, it shall direct that the applicant be put into
possession of the property, and where the applicant is still resisted or
obstructed in obtaining possession, the Court may also, at the instance of
the applicant, order the judgment-debtor, or any person acting at his
instigation or on his behalf, to be detained in the civil prison for a term
which may extend to thirty days.
Order XXI Rule 99 Dispossession by decree-holder or
purchaser.
(1) Where any person other than the judgment-debtor is dispossessed of
immovable property by the holder of a decree for possession of such
property or, where such property has been sold in execution of a decree, by
the purchaser thereof, he may make an application to the Court complaining
of such dispossession.
(2) Where any such application is made, the Court shall proceed to
adjudicate upon the application in accordance with the provisions herein
contained.
Order XXI Rule 100. Order to be passed upon application
complaining of dispossession.
Upon the determination of the questions referred to in rule 101, the Court
shall, in accordance with such determination,-
(a) make an order allowing the application and directing that the applicant
be put into the possession of the property or dismissing the application; or
(b) pass such other order as, in the circumstances of the case, it may deem
fit.
Order XXI Rule 101 Question to be determined.
All questions (including questions relating to right, title or interest in the
property) arising between the parties to a proceeding on an application
under rule 97 or rule 99 or their representatives, and relevant to the
adjudication of the application, shall be determined by the Court dealing with
the application and not by a separate suit and for this purpose, the Court
shall, notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any other law
for the time being in force, be deemed to have jurisdiction to decide such
questions.
Order XXI Rule 102
transferee pendent lite.
Rules
not
applicable
to
Nothing in rules 98 and 100 shall apply to resistance or obstruction in
execution of a decree for the possession of immovable property by a person
to whom the judgment-debtor has transferred the property after the
institution of the suit in which the decree was passed or to the dispossession
of any such person.
Order XXI Rule 103:- Orders to be treated as decrees.
Where any application has been adjudicated upon under rule 98 or rule
100 the other made thereon shall have the same force and be subject to the
same conditions as to an appeal or otherwise as if it were a decree.
18.
In the light of the submission made on behalf of the
third party claimants that they are the legal heirs of the original
owners Rahij uddin, there cannot be any order against their
property as the original owner late Rahij uddin and also they are
not party to the suit and further the defendant/Judgment debtor is
not the sole owner of the said property.
19.
With regard to deciding the third party claim who is
not party to the suit, their rights, title, and interest need to be
examined by giving them a fair opportunity, otherwise, it will
amount to a violation of principles of natural justice and also would
effect their Rights to Property as construed under Article 300A of
the Constitution of India.
20.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Para No.5 of its
Judgment reported in
AIR 1997 SC 856 titled as Bhramdeo
Chaudhary v. Rishikesh Prasad Jaiswal and another read as
under:“5.
In short the aforesaid statutory provisions of
Order XXI lay down a complete code for resolving all disputes pertaining
to execution of decree for possession obtained by a decree-holder and
whose attempts at executing the said decree meet with rough weather.
Once resistance is offered by a purported stranger to the decree and
which comes to be noted by the Executing Court as well as by the
decree-holder the remedy available to the decree-holder against such
an obstructionist in only under Order XXI Rule 97 sub-rule (1) and he
cannot bypass such obstruction and insist on re-issuance of warrant for
possession under Order XXI Rule 35 with the help of police force, as
that course would amount to by-passing and circumventing the
procedure laid down under Order XXI Rule 97 in connection with
removal of obstruction of purported strangers to the decree. Once such
an obstruction is on the record of the Executing Court it is difficult to
appreciate how the Executing Court can tell such obstructionist that he
must first lose possession and then only his remedy is to move an
application under Order XXI Rule 99, CPC and pray for restoration of
possession. The High Court by the impugned order and judgment has
taken the view that the only remedy available to a stranger to the
decree who claims any independent right, title or interest in the decretal
property is to go by Order XXI Rule 99. This view of the High Court on
the aforesaid statutory scheme is clearly unsustainable. It is easy to
visualise that a stranger to the decree who claims an independent right,
title and interest in the decretal property can offer his resistance before
getting actually dispossessed. He can equally agitate his grievance and
claim for adjudication of his independent right, title and interest in the
decretal property even after losing possession as per Order XXI, Rule
99. Order XXI, Rule 97 deals with a stage which is prior to the actual
execution of the decree for possession wherein the grievance of the
obstructionist can be adjudicated upon before actual delivery of
possession to the decree-holder. While Order XXI, Rule 99 on the other
hand deals with the subsequent stage in the execution proceedings
where a stranger claiming any right, title and interest in the decretal
property might have got actually dispossessed and claims restoration of
possession on adjudication of his independent right, title and interest
dehors the interest of the judgment-debtor. Both these types of
enquiries in connection with the right, title and interest of a stranger to
the decree are clearly contemplated by the aforesaid scheme of Order
XXI and it is not as if that such a stranger to the decree can come in the
picture only at the final stage after losing the possession and not before
it if he is vigilant enough to raise his objection and obstruction before
the warrant for possession gets actually executed against him. With
respect the High Court has totally ignored the scheme of Order XXI,
Rule 97 in this connection by taking the view that only remedy of such
stranger to the decree lies under Order XXI, Rule 99 and he has no
locus standi to get adjudication of his claim prior to the actual delivery
of possession to the decree-holder in the execution proceedings. The
view taken by the High Court in this connection also results in patent
breach of principles of natural justice as the obstructionist, who alleges
to have any independent right, title and interest in the decretal property
and who is admittedly not a party to the decree even though making a
grievance right in time before the warrant for execution is actually
executed, would be told off the gates and his grievance would not be
considered or heard or merits and he would be thrown off lock, stock
and barrel by use of police force by the decree-holder. That would
obviously result in irreparable injury to such obstructionist whose
grievance would go overboard without being considered on merits and
such obstructionist would be condemned totally unheard. Such an order
of the Executing Court, therefore, would fail also on the ground of noncompliance with basic principles of natural justice. On the contrary the
statutory scheme envisaged by Order XXI ,Rule 97, CPC as discussed
earlier clearly guards against such a pitfall and provides a statutory
remedy both to the decree- holder as well as to the obstructionist to
have their respective say in the matter and to get proper adjudication
before the Executing Court and it is that adjudication which subject to
the hierarchy of appeals would remain binding between the parties to
such proceedings and separate suit would be barred with a view to
seeing that multiplicity of proceedings and parallel proceedings are
avoided and the gamut laid down by Order XXI Rules 97 and 103 would
remain a complete code and the sole remedy for the concerned parties
to have their grievances once and for all finally resolved in execution
proceedings themselves.”
21.
In view of the above, since the matter requires
adjudication under Order XXI Rule 58, 97 to 100 of CPC, if an
application is made by the stranger, without filing a fresh suit for
declaration of right, title and interest, and if the Court decide the
same, it will amount to passing of a decree. Since the third parties
are not before this Court and since the matter is pending before
the Trial Court, it is not for this Court to go and decide upon the
other aspects and thus confines the case only to the extent of
issues involved in the CRP i.e., with regard to the lifting of the
attachment.
22.
During the course of the argument, Mr. Roy Barman,
learned Sr. counsel upon instruction submitted that after lifting the
attachment, the case was scheduled to be listed before the Court
below on 30th of August 2022, but, for the pendency of the present
CRP in the High Court, the same is pending on the file of the Trial
Court. Since the major issue of deciding the right, title, and
interest is pending before the Court below, passing an order of
attachment or lifting the attachment in no way would prejudice the
rights of the decree-holder. At times, deciding a matter purely on
technicalities to say that the pleading do not disclose any reasons
cannot be a ground to deprive the legitimate right of a citizen
when the citizen is before the Court of law for his rights. His rights
are to be protected under Constitution of India and the same
needs to be given high pedestal in order to meet the ends of
justice.
23.
For the reasons stated above, this Court feels that it
would be just and proper if the interests of the third parties are
also decided in respect of the property under execution is
concerned. Accordingly, there shall be a direction to the Court
below to give an opportunity to the third parties to the suit and if
any application are filed, the same be decided as per procedure by
giving an opportunity to all concerned.
24.
Accordingly, the order passed in the present CRP is
taken on record, and with the above observation, the instant CRP
stands dismissed.
25.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands.
JUDGE
suhanjit
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2023.10.17
SINGHA 15:30:27 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review