The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. A.A.No,l2a of 2025, along w,ith all ccnnccted applications, is accordingly allowed appointrng Ms. Srrt. .Jus _rce G. Rohini, Retired Chief Justrce, High Court of Dclhi, H.No..1.3.108/ 153 & 1,72, 'SURYA', New Friends Colony, phase 2, Attapur, Hyderguda, Rajendra Nagar, Ranga R<:ddy District 5OO 048, Mobile No.8527O27O27, as thc Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties. The parties shall appear before the Sole Arbitrator on 10.10.2026 at 11:00 A.lu{., alor-rg with a copy of this order. 'I'he Sok: erbitraLo'r shall th:rcaftc- proccecl with the arbitral proccedrngs in accordance with law. SD/- M. VIJAYA BHASKER //TRUE COPY// To Smt. Justice G. Rohrni, Retired Chief Justice, High Court of Delhi, H.No.3 3.108/153 & 172, 'SURYA", New Friends Colony, Phase-2, Attapur, hyderaguda, Rajendra Nagar, Ranga Reddy District -500 048, tt4obile No.8527 O27 O27 (By Speed Post) (Along wi'lh a Copy of affidavit and material papers) One CC to Sri. Burma Chakrapani, Advocate [OPIJC]
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 340s ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
ARBITRATION APPLICATION NO: 128 OF 2o2s
Between:
'l
. Safe Super Speciality Hospitals, O/o Plot No. 1, 2, 3 and 4, Survey No. 40,
Petbasheerabad, Iriledchal - I\/alka.igiri Drst, Telangana 500067.
Represented by its Managing Director
2. Yenugudati Veera Narendra Reddy, S/o Y K S It4 Ra1u, Aged about 46 years,
Occ. Business, R/o. D.No. 20-2, 2"o Floor, Above Bling and Bliss, Near St.
l\4arlins Engineering College, Dulapdlly, Kompally, Medchal-Malkajgiri Dist,
Telangana - 500014.
3. Aluwala Narendra Rani, Wo Yenugudati Veera Narender Reddy, Aged about 46
years, Occ: Business, R/o. D.No. 2O-2,2"d Floor, Above BIing and Bliss, Near St.
Ir,4artins Engineering College, Dulapally, Kompally, I\4edcha l-tVla lkajg iri Dist'
Telangana - 5000'14.
...APPLICANTS
AND
1. Unique lnida Constructions, O/o 306 and 307, 3'd Floor, T - '19 Towers, Ranigunj,
Hyderabad, Telangana - 500003 Rep by its Properties
2 lVr. Nikhil Champa Lal Jain, S/o Not Known, Aged about 45 years, Occ.
Business, R/o. D.No. 6-31237, 123711, Rai Bhavan Road, Sethi Towers,
Somajiguda, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500082.
3. l\,4rs. Apeksha Jain, Wo Nikhil Champa Lal Jain, Aged about 42 years, Occ:
Business, R/o- D.No. 6-31237, 123711, Rai Bhavan Road sethi Towers'
Somajiguda, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500082.
...RESPONDENTS
re-r
Arbitration Application under Section 1 1(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
read with Scheme for Appointment of Arbitrators 1996 praying that this Hon'ble Court
may be pleased to:
Appoint a sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes between the Applicants and
Respondents under Clause 3.0 of the Unregistered lnr'estment Agreement entered
on 27IO112022
Counsel for Applicants: Sri. Burma Chakrapani
Counsel for the Respondents: Sri. Boora Vijaya Kumar
The Court made the following: ORDER
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
ARBITRATION APPLICATION No.128 of 2025
(CNR No. HBH co 103692920251
DATE OF ORDER: 24.09.2026
Reserved oll.: L8.O9.2O26
Pronounced on : 24.09 2026
:24.O9.2026
Uploaded on
BETWEEN
Sar lc
Supt:r Spccralitv llospit.ris
Arrct 'lu,o ()thcrs
Applican ts
ANI)
Uniqut: India Cortstruclions, rcp. br. its
I)roprictor and l'wo Ot h('rs
Rcspondcnts
Mr.llurma Clrakrapanr, lcarned counscl ilppearlng tbr thc appllcrtnLs.
Mr.Boora VUava Kumar, learned counsel appcaring tbr Lhe respondents
ORDER: lt\ t llott l)lt"ltct (. .\/r:.r-')iirr' , )Ji(tt taclury(t)
t
L
'l'hc Arbit.ratior-r Appllcatron :rriscs ouI ol an Irlvt:stmct-tt
Agreement dated 27.01.2022 executed between the applicants
and thc rcspondcnl s.
2.
As per thc Invcstmcnt Agrecmcnt datcd 27.01 .2022, th<'
respondents agreed to jnvest Rs. 16,00,0O,000/ -
in thc
applicarrts'hospitr,rl ernd, in cxchangc, acquirc 4Ook of shares of
thc ',rrppliirirnt No. I ,/llostrrir-al. 'l'hc invcstmer)t was to tie
arrangcd bv Lhc rcspondcnts u'ithrn 30 62v5 of signing th(l
Investment Agrcemcnt. The Inveslment Agreemellt contains an
Arbitratio:-r Clause under Clause No.3.0 thereof.
3.
Dispurcs arosc bctrveen thc parties in respcct of tht:
allegcd violation of thc lerms of thc lnvesitmcn[ Agreement on
the part of the respondents.
4.
According to lcarncd counscl appearing lor the applican[s,
the respondents had agreed 'to arrange an investment of
Rs. 16,00,00,OOO/ in the applicanL No.1,/Hospi.al, The total
invcstmcnt ol' Rs. 16:,00,00,t10Q/ was to be divided rnto
Rs,12,00,OO,OOO/ towards 409/o cquitl- eLnd Rs.4,00,O0,00O/-
structure as per company 1aw guidelines as mentioned in
Clause No. 16. Counsel further submits that as per Clause
No.16, the rcspondents wcre obligated to arrange a sum ol
Rs.50,O0,OOO/- on or beforc 01 .O1.2022, Rs 1,25,00,000/- on or
before 10,02.2022, Rs.5O,0O,00O/- on or before 28.02.2022 and
lls.9,75,OO,OOO/ uithin 4 5 months thereaf cr.
Couns<:l
submits that thc respondcnts hou'c:vcr .trranged onll''
Rs.3,85,00,OOO/- (as opposed to Rs.16,00,00,000/-) that too in
instalments upLt: 1 2.09.2022.
-
5.
Counsel submits that due to the shortfall of the required
investment and, on account of breach on the part of the
respondents, the applicants were lorced to alienate their
personal assets and avail high-interest loans. The applicants
were ultimately compcllcd lo sell tht: cntire hospital business in
December, 2023 undcr firtanr:ral distress. Counsel further
submits that the rcsportdcnts abandoned the applicants after
payment of Rs.3,85,00,000/ on 12.O9.2022 and thereafter
failed to respond to the applicants' ca1ls and Notices thereafter.
6.
Learncd counscl appcaring for thc rcspondents disputes
the existence of an Arbilrat.ion Agrdement and consequently any
basis for seeking appoin tmcnt of an Arbitrator. Counsel further
submits that the applicanl s have sold thc hospital business to
third parties in December, 2023 and are hence disentitled from
raising any dispute wil h thc respondents. It is also submitted
that the parties to the Arbitratron Application were not parties to
the Investment Agrecment.
7.
I have heard thc rospcct.ive contentions made on behalf of
the parties
8.
Clause No.3.0 of the lnvestm<:r t Agrcemcnt dated
27 .O1.2022 contains the Arbitration n greernent. 'l'he Arbitratron
Agreement consists of sub-clauses 3.0 - 3.8, whir:h provide that
disputes arising betwce n the parties in conne,:tion with the
validity. interpretation, implcmentation or anv alicged breach of
the Agreement including any qucsti()n wi h regard to
termination of the Agrccmcllt must first underg, r a mandatory
sixty days amicable settleme nl period folkrwed b',. a thirty days
Notice to the other party in writipg. In the event of such farlure,
the dispute shall be referred to a mut'-rally zLppointed Sole
Arbitrator in Hyderabad. 'lhe arbitration proceedings shall be
governed b1' The Arbitration and Conciliation A rt, 1996 (A&C
Act). The Arbitration Au,ard must be substantiated in writing,
with costs borne by the unsuccessful party as dctr'rmined by the
Arbitrator, and is enforceable in an) competent Court.
AdditionaUy, the Clause further states that the pa.ties retain the
liberty to approach competent Courts rn I yderat,ad for interim
measures of protection and this entire Arbitrarion provision
explicrt11. survives the termination ol thc Agrc()mcr.t.
9.
It is evrdcnt fiom thc documcnt placr:d on rccord that the
applicants issued a l,egal Notice for the first tirne to the
-
-
respondents on 27.O3.2O2O calling upon thc respondents to pay
an amount of Rs. 1 0,O0,00,000/ - as compensation for breach of
the Investment Agreement along with interest @ 24%o per
annum. Thc applicant.s rssucd a sccorrci l-cgal Notice to the
respondents on 24 .O3.2025 statrng t.hat the applicants suffered
severe financial distress on account of breach on the part of the
respondents. The apphcants sought compensation of
Rs.20,0O,00,000/ for busincss collapse, loss of assets and
burden of debt. Iloth lhe Noticcs were received by the
respondents. Proof of receipts is part of thc record.
10. The applicants ultimatcl)' issricd thc Nol.ice on 14.O5.2025
for invoking thc arbitration Clausc i.c., Clausc No.3.0 of the
Investment Agreement. In the said Notice, which was duly
received by the respondents, the apphcants relterated the
contentions raised rn their carlier Lcgal Notrces and nominated a
Re tired Chief Justicc of the Patna I ligh Court as thcir Arbitrator
The respondents replied to this Noticc on 1 6 .O5 .2025, denying
all lhe contentions raiscd by thr: applicants and raised a
Countcr Claim of rcfund oI Rs.4,1r,t)O,O0O/ paid to the
apphcants as initial investmont along nrth interest threreon at
the rate bf 24o/o Per annum
,. -;
-
11. 1t is evidcnt from thc arguments and the rnaterial placed
on record that there ts a live and subsisting dispr-Lte between the
parties. The respondr:nts' contention of the absence of a valid
Arbitration Agreement, u'hich is capabl: of enfol-cement, is
contrarv to the admitted facts. In any event, asj stated above,
the Arbitratron Agrecment also enc()mpasses questions
concerning the validity, lnte rpretation, impk:mentation or
alleged breach of any condition of the Agre.ement. including any
question as to the ternination oI the arbitrrttion aEreement.
12. Moreover, the respondents' contention that the parties to
the present Arbrtration Applica'tion were not parties to the
Arbitration Agrcement is incorrect and wil.hout basis since the
Investment Agrccmcnt <:lcarlr mcnttons thc nami:s of both the
parties representing the applicants'hospitrrl. Th,: fact that the
respondent No.1 is not a party to the Inve stmenl Agreement is
immaterial since thc Investment Agreement also mentions the
name of the respondent No.1 described as a proprietary firm
being represented by the respondent Nos.2 and 3 as its
Proprietors.
-
13. Furthermore, the respondents' additional ground that the
applicants have sold thc hosprtal busincss to third parties does
not obliteratc thc dispute. 'lhe drspute remains valid as on
date, namely, the applicants clarm for damages against the
respondents and the respondents Counter claim of refund of
Rs.4,I5,00,000/- along with interest at the rate of 24oh per
annum. It is also cvidcnt fiom the pleadings and
correspondence on record that the applicants tried to amicably
settle the matter but such attempts were rebutted by the
respondents. The Counter claim raised by the respondents rn
the reply Notice further bolsters" the existence of a dispute
between the partics, which falls within the scope of Clause
No.3.0 of the Investment Agreement.
14. Hencr:, this CourL is o[ Lhe- considered view that the
present case satishes the statutory conditions for appointment
of a Sole Arbitrator under section 1 1(5) of the A&C Act. The
respondents have dispuled the contentions in the applicants'
Notice invoking arbitration and havc wrongly reiuted the
existence of the Arbitration Agreemen 1.. In essence, the
respondents have failed to act as rcquircd under Clause No.3.0
of thc Investment. Agr-ccmcnt in tcrms ol the appointment
,l
procedure agreed upon by the Parties uLnder rhe Arbitration
Agreement
15. A.A.No,l2a of 2025, along w,ith all ccnnccted applications,
is accordingly allowed appointrng Ms. Srrt. .Jus _rce G. Rohini,
Retired Chief Justrce, High Court of Dclhi, H.No..1.3.108/ 153 &
1,72, 'SURYA', New Friends Colony, phase 2, Attapur,
Hyderguda, Rajendra Nagar, Ranga R<:ddy District 5OO 048,
Mobile No.8527O27O27, as thc Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the
dispute between the parties. The parties shall appear before the
Sole Arbitrator on 10.10.2026 at 11:00 A.lu{., alor-rg with a copy
of this order. 'I'he Sok: erbitraLo'r shall th:rcaftc- proccecl with
the arbitral proccedrngs in accordance with law.
SD/- M. VIJAYA BHASKER
JOINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
Smt. Justice G. Rohrni, Retired Chief Justice, High Court of Delhi,
H.No.3 3.108/153 & 172, 'SURYA", New Friends Colony, Phase-2, Attapur,
hyderaguda, Rajendra Nagar, Ranga Reddy District -500 048, tt4obile
No.8527 O27 O27 (By Speed Post) (Along wi'lh a Copy of affidavit and
material papers)
One CC to Sri. Burma Chakrapani, Advocate [OPIJC]
2. One CC to Sri. Boora Vijaya Kumar, Advocate [OF'UC]
3. Two CD Copies
Pr/GNK
\w
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2410912026
ORDER
ARBAPPL.No.128 of 2025
HE SI4 14:
+
-)
o
ii!
z:l
01 ocl 2026
i
ALLOWING THE ARBITRATION
APPLICATION
c, &R'i
VA- \ 9-{ '{c
{roo
:,'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review