Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010850652016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3548]
MONDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1048/2016
Between:
1. SADHU LAKSHAMMA & 3 OTHERS, W/O. LATE KONDIAH, R/O.
POLINENIPALEM VILLAGE, V.V.PALEM MANDAL, PRAKASAM
DISTRICT.
2. SADHU MAHENDRA,, S/O. LATE KONDAIAH, R/O. POLINENIPALEM
VILLAGE, V.V.PALEMMANDAL, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
3. SADHU HARIKRISHNA,, S/O.LATE KONDIAH, AGED ABOUT 22
YEARS, R/O. POLINENIPALEM VILLAGE, V.V.PALEM MANDAL,
PETITIONER NO.3 DECLARED AS MAJOR AND 1ST PETITIONER
MOTHER DISCHARGED OF THEIR GUARDIAN VIDE COURT
ORDER DATE.13.02.2024 IN IA.NO.1/2024
4. SADHU KONDAMMA,, W/O. LATE RAMAIAH, R/O. POLINENIPALEM
VILLAGE, V.V.PALEM MANDAL, PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. JAGADABI RAMESH 2 OTHERS, S/O. MALAKONDAIAH, DRIVER OF
THE TRACTOR AND TRAILOR NO. AP 26 R 2868 & 2869 R/O.
METLAVARIPALEM VILLAGE, KODANDA RAMA PURAM, P.C.PALLI
MANDAL, DLF AP 022760622007.
2. PATCHA TIRUPATHAIAH, S/O. PERAIAH, R/O. VELIGANDLA
VILLAGE, KONDAPURAM MANDAL, NELLORE DISTRICT.
3. UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP. BY ITS BRANCH
MANAGER, BIRUDDURAJU TOWERS, TRUNK ROAD, ONGOLE,
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
PRAKASAM DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court, aggrieved by
the award in M.V.O.P No.410 of 2009, dated 28-10-2010 on the file of the
Court of Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ongole-Cum-I Additional District
Judge, Ongole to the extent of not awarding compensation against the 3rd
Respondent
IA NO: 1 OF 2011(MACMAMP 1867 OF 2011
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 51 days in preferring the appeal
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
prayed that this Hon‟ble Court may be to declare the Petitioner.No.3 as major
and discharge his mother as guardian in MACMA.No.1048/2016 in the interest
justice, and pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. K KOUTILYA
2.
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. SRINIVASA RAO VUTLA
2. .
The Court made the following:
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
JUDGMENT:
Heard,
Sri K.Koutilya, learned counsel for the claimants and Sri Srinivasa Rao
Vutla, learned counsel for respondent No.3. None appeared for respondent
Nos.1 and 2.
1.
Embittered with the Award, dated 28.10.2010, in M.V.O.P.No.410
of 2009 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-I Additional
District Judge, Ongole (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”), the present
appeal is preferred by the claimants on the settled principles that the Award is
totally in contravention to the principles laid down by the Constitution Bench in
National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi1.
2.
The parties are arrayed as arrayed in the M.V.O.P. before the
Tribunal.
3.
The petition was filed by the claimants/appellants/petitioners
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, for compensation of
Rs.4,00,000/- for the death of Sadhu Kondaiah, who died in the motor vehicle
accident. The 1st petitioner is the wife, petitioners 2 and 3 are the sons and the
4th petitioner is the mother of the deceased. The facts are not denied
regarding the age of the deceased as 45 at the time of accident and was
working as a coolie in a tractor and trailer and earning Rs.5,000/- per month.
On 06.07.2009 in the evening, the deceased, his wife and other coolies, went
to Botlaguduru village to load paddy husk in the tractor and trailer and while
coming to the village after loading the husk, the driver of the vehicle drove the
tractor and trailer in a rash and negligent manner which resulted in the falling
of the deceased from the tractor and died instantaneously. The tire of the
trailer ran over his head, which caused the accident. A crime was registered,
Crime No.91 of 2009 of Pamuru Police Station under Section 304-A of IPC
2017 (16) SCC 680
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
against the 1st respondent, who is the driver and the compensation was
claimed against the respondents 1 to 3.
4.
After receipt of the notice, respondents 1 and 2 remained
ex parte, while 3rd respondent represented through counsel, filed written
statement denying the allegations including age, income, avocation etc., and
the claimants were put to strict proof regarding the driving license of the driver
and the insurance policy. The 3rd respondent, in the counter, categorically
admits that the tractor was insured for agricultural purpose and at the time of
accident, the vehicle was being used for public purpose and further contends
that the very policy conditions are violated. The aspect of the tractor being
insured for agricultural purpose is widely amplified. It is further contended that
the deceased is categorized as authorized passenger and the deceased is
covered under the policy.
5.
Basing on the pleadings contained in the M.V.O.P. and the
counter, the Tribunal framed the following issues:
i.
Whether the death of the deceased Sadhu Kondaiah,
S/o. Late Ramaiah is occurred on 06.07.2009 at about
08:00 p.m. due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the tractor and trailer bearing No.AP26R2868 &
2869 by its driver?
ii.
Whether the petitioners are entitled to claim any
compensation? and if so, to what amount and against
whom?
iii.
To what relief?
6.
To prove their case, the 1st claimant examined herself as PW1
and one Mannem Nageswara Rao, eye-witness as PW2 and got marked
Exs.A1
to
A5.
On
behalf
of
3rd
respondent,
Smt.A.Sussela
Devi,
Administrative Officer, was examined as RW1 and Exs.B1 and B2 were
marked.
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
7.
While answering issue No.1, the Tribunal extensively considered
the pleadings and the evidence adduced on both the sides, including Exs.A1
to A5 marked by the claimants, to support the stance that the accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving and the same was fortified in the
cross-examination of RW1, who categorically stated that she has no
knowledge as to how the accident took place. It is a settled principle that,
when the FIR and the charge sheet are left unchallenged, the same cannot be
disputed and the same has to be accepted. The said principle is followed in
The United India Insurance Company Limited vs. Deepak Goel and
others2, wherein, at paragraph 21, it was observed as follows:
“21. Nonetheless, in a case, where FIR is lodged,
chargesheet is filed and specially in a case where driver after causing
the accident had fled away from the spot, then the documents
mentioned above are sufficient to establish the fact that the driver of
the offending vehicle was negligent in causing the accident
particularly when there was no defence available from his side before
the learned Tribunal. Thus, the claimants have prove negligence of
the driver of the offending vehicle.”
8.
The charge sheet will be filed after a complete investigation by
the competent authority and the same engrafts that the accident has occurred
due to rash and negligent driving and taking this into consideration, the issue
No.1 was answered in favour of the petitioners and against the respondents. It
is pertinent to note that respondents 1 and 2 remained ex parte.
9.
While dealing with issue No.2, the Tribunal, while considering the
liability of respondents 1 and 2, has drawn the conclusion that they are liable
to pay the compensation. In respect of 3rd respondent, the Tribunal examined
Ex.B1, Insurance Policy and its applicability. The policy was in force as on the
date of the accident, which is not denied and the 3rd respondent claimed
exemption in paying the compensation for the violation of terms and
conditions of the Insurance Policy, which are as follows:
“Ex.B1 insurance policy is a farmers package policy i.e.
agricultural policy and R3 is liable to pay compensation only when the
2014 SCC OnLine Del 362
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
tractor and trailer was used for agricultural purpose. The counsel of
R3 contended that at the time of the accident, the tractor and trailer
was being used for transporting paddy husk i.e. public purpose and
thus there is violation of policy conditions.”
10.
As seen from the above argument or stance of the 3rd respondent
that at the time of accident, the tractor and trailer are used for transporting
paddy i.e., public purpose and that there is violation of conditions. It is not
disputed that the tractor and trailer was carrying husk at the time of
transportation and simply because, the deceased and his wife travelling in the
tractor and trailer does not mean or construe that the vehicle is used for public
purpose and not for agricultural purpose.
11.
From the entire record placed before this Court, there is no iota of
evidence to substantiate the claim of the 3rd respondent – Insurance Company
that the tractor and trailer was used for public purpose and mere submission
in the counter cannot impeach the contention of the petitioners for
compensation. The Insurance Company did not examine or elicit any contra
evidence regarding the said aspect of tractor and trailer being used for public
purpose by examining the owner or the driver of the tractor and trailer and
unless there is impeachable evidence, this Court is not convinced to the
accept the said argument.
12.
While considering the issue as to whether the vehicle was used
for public purpose or for transporting husk as agricultural purpose, the
Tribunal has went against the claimants reasoning that neither the claimants
nor the owner of the tractor could not prove that the transportation of paddy
husk in the vehicle was for any agricultural purpose and thus concluded that
the tractor and trailer was not being used for agricultural purpose and is for
commercial purpose and therefore concluded that there is violation of terms
and conditions of Ex.B1, insurance policy.
13.
Regarding this aspect, this Court finds that the statement of the
claimants in the very petition is that the deceased and his wife, along with
other coolies, went to Botlaguduru village to load paddy husk in the tractor and
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
trailer, and after loading the same, while coming to the village, the said
accident occurred, which necessarily be construed that the tractor and trailer
was used for agricultural purpose. When there is a statement made by the
claimants in the petition, it is at the first instance, the burden lies on part of the
respondents to substantiate the argument that the vehicle was in fact used for
agricultural purpose. As earlier stated supra, there is no evidence adduced
either by 3rd respondent in oppugnation to the said claim and in such
circumstances, it is not justified on part of the Tribunal to hold that the tractor
and trailer was not used for agricultural purpose, when admittedly the tractor
and trailer was carrying husk, which is an agricultural produce. This aspect
was silent in the Award of the Tribunal and hence, the finding to that effect is
set aside.
14.
Now, coming to the coverage of the policy to an authorized
person, the main contention forwarded on behalf of 3rd respondent is that the
deceased being a coolie in the vehicle was classified as an authorized
passenger and not an unauthorized passenger and in view of the ratio laid
down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court only for unauthorized/gratuitous
passengers, „pay and recover‟ principle can be adopted. In the present case,
the Insurance Company itself admitted that the deceased is an authorized
passenger, and in unequivocal terms, the 3rd respondent clearly admitted that
the policy is covered to the said authorized passenger, and in view of the said
admission, the question of „pay and recover‟ principle does not arise. With
regard to the 2nd limb, this Court has answered at paragraph No.9 of this
judgment. Therefore, the Tribunal‟s observation regarding non-liability of the
Insurance Company is erroneous and contrary to the law.
15.
Regarding the quantum of compensation, the Tribunal has taken
the earning of the deceased as Rs.3,000/- per month i.e., Rs.36,000/- per
annum and the deceased being aged about 45 years, the multiplier „15‟ is
taken and the compensation payable is Rs.5,40,000/- (Rs.36,000/- x 15). But
the Tribunal has mistakenly taken the same as Rs.5,04,000/-. Out of which,
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
1/3rd has to be deducted towards personal expenses, which comes to
Rs.1,80,000/- (Rs.5,40,000 x 1/3), and the contribution towards family is
Rs.3,60,000/- (Rs.5,40,000 – Rs.1,80,000). The Tribunal awarded Rs.5,000/to the 1st petitioner, being the wife of the deceased towards loss of
consortium, Rs.2,000/- towards funeral expenses, and Rs.2,500/- towards loss
of estate. Therefore, the total compensation will be Rs.3,69,500/- (Rs.3,60,000
+ 5,000 + 2,000 + 2,500).
16.
Sri K.Koutilya, learned counsel for the claimants, would contend
that the award of compensation under the following heads is clearly against
the pronouncement in National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay
Sethi3, a Constitutional Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court. In respect of
loss of consortium, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has awarded Rs.40,000/- to
the wife and all the dependents and in the present case, there are three
dependents along with wife i.e., Rs.40,000/- x 4 = Rs.1,60,000/-. Coming to
funeral expenses, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court awarded Rs.15,000/- and
Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate. Thus, under these conventional heads, the
total comes to Rs.1,90,000/-.
17.
Similarly, learned counsel for the claimants relied upon a
judgment of a learned Single Judge of this Court in M.A.C.M.A.No.3601 of
2012, dated 08.01.2026, to substantiate his stance regarding the loss of
consortium and other heads considered by this Court.
18.
Another judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the
petitioner is M.A.C.M.A.No.286 of 2024 [2025 Supreme (AP) 629], dated
06.08.2025, to fortify his stance regarding the authorized passenger and the
liability of the Insurance Company under Section 147 of the Motor Vehicles
Act. He would draw the attention of this Court to paragraph No.12, which
reads as follows:
“12. The aforesaid finding of Tribunal in the opinion of this
Court is on mere conjecture as there is no specific evidence
(2017) 16 SCC 680
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
forthcoming on the said aspect. P.W.2 never spoke of any negligence
on the part of deceased. The Tribunal presumed that the deceased
was negligent as he was sitting on the paddy bags in the trailer. As
rightly contended by learned counsel for claimants and as considered
by this Court in Tummalapalli Srinu‟s case (supra 2), as the trailer is
meant for carrying goods and in that process, the coolies who are
supposed to load and unload also incidentally travel on the trailer,
they cannot be considered as unauthorized passengers under
Section 147 of Motor Vehicles Act. It is apt to refer to Paragraph
No.16 of the said judgment, which reads as under:
“16. It is settled law that a coolie or laborer who is
loading or unloading goods from the tractor-trailer can be
considered as an authorized passenger under Section 147 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. In National Insurance Company
Limited v. Prema Devi4, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed
that “the term „authorized passenger‟ is not limited to only those
who are travelling in the vehicle for their own purposes, but also
includes those who are travelling in connection with the purpose
of the vehicle, such as loading or unloading goods. Thereby, it
is crystal clear that the claimant was travelling in the crime
vehicle as coolie by the date of accident can be called as
authorized passenger. As such, the contention raised by the
learned counsel that the claimant was a gratuitous passenger is
absolutely no legs to stand.””
19.
Sri K.Koutilya, learned counsel would further submit that the
Tribunal has grossly erred in awarding compensation towards loss of care and
guidance for minor children, i.e., petitioners 2 and 3, and in not awarding
Rs.1,00,000/- as laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Rajesh and
others vs. Rajbir Singh and others4. It is contended that, as per the said
ratio, petitioners 2 and 3 are entitled to the said amount.
20.
This Court finds force in the argument of the learned counsel for
the appellants/claimants, and without hesitation, is awarding Rs.1,00,000/towards loss of care and guidance for minor children i.e., petitioners 2 and 3
as per Rajesh and others vs. Rajbir Singh and others (supra 4).
21.
Now, this Court, while modifying the Award of the Tribunal, which
is under challenge to the extent indicated above and the compensation so
awarded to the claimants i.e., Rs.6,59,500/- (Rs.3,69,500 + 1,90,000 +
(2013) 9 SCC 54
GTK, J
M.A.C.M.A.No.1048 of 2016
1,00,000) is to be paid by the 3rd respondent – Insurance Company along with
the 1st respondent – driver and the 2nd respondent – owner.
22.
Liberty is given to the 3rd respondent – Insurance Company to
recover the enhanced compensation amount from the 1st respondent – driver
and the 2nd respondent – owner. This observation is made since the
appellants/claimants stated that till date the driver and the owner have not
responded to the Award, dated 28.10.2010, in M.V.O.P.No.410 of 2009
passed by the Tribunal. The claimants shall pay the deficit court fee on the
enhanced compensation amount, if any. The enhanced compensation shall be
apportioned as directed by the Tribunal. It is made clear that the claimants are
not entitled for any interest on the enhanced compensation.
23.
In fine, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed,
modifying the Award to the extent indicated above. There shall be no order as
to costs.
24.
As a sequitur, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
___________________________
TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA, J
Date : 20-04-2026
BMS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review