Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:898-DB
NAFR
Digitally
signed by
ANURADHA
ANURADHA TIWARI
TIWARI
Date:
2026.01.08
10:52:58
+0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WA No. 934 of 2025
Sachchidanand Dubey S/o Late Shri Suresh Chand Dubey Aged About
67 Years (Then Senior Assistant), R/o Koilari, P.O. Bhaiyathan, District
Surguja (Now Surajpur) Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
versus
1 - State Bank of India Through The Chief General Manager, Local
Head Office Hoshangabad Road, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh
2 - Dy. General Manager (O And C) Network 1, S.B.I. Administrative
Office, Byron Bazar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3 - Assistant General Manager Administration, S.B.I. Administrative
Office, Byron Bazar, Raipur, Chhattisgarh
4 - Enquiry Officer/ Chief Manager (Enquiry And Investigation) S.B.I.
Administrative Office, 3rd Floor, CCPC, Byron Bazar, Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
: Mr. Ashish Shrivastava, Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. Rahul Ambast, Advocate
For Respondent
: Mr. Pankaj Singh, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Arvind Kumar Verma, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
07.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Ashish Shrivastava, learned Senior Counsel assisted
by Mr. Rahul Ambast, learned counsel for the appellant as well as
Mr. Pankaj Singh, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.
By way of this writ appeal, appellant has prayed for following
relief(s):“It is, therefore, prayed that this Hon'ble Court
may kindly be pleased to allow the instant writ
appeal and quash and set-aside the order dated
07.10.2025 (Annexure WA/I) passed by Learned
Single Judge in W.P.S No. 3400 of 2011
(Sachchidanand Dubey versus State Bank of
India & Ors.) & allow the writ petition by quashing
& setting aside the dismissal order dated
14.08.2010 & consequential appellate order dated
05.05.2011 with all consequential benefits, in the
interest of justice.”
3.
The present intra Court appeal has been filed against the order
dated 07.10.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge in WPS
No.3400/2011 (Sachchidanand Dubey versus State Bank of India
& Ors.), whereby the writ petition filed by the appellant/writ
petitioner has been dismissed.
4.
Brief facts projected before the learned Single Judge are that the
appellant/writ petitioner was initially appointed as Cashier-cumClerk in respondent No.1/State Bank of India on 10.11.1983 and
was subsequently promoted/designated as Senior Assistant and
posted at Bhaiyathan Branch. During his posting, certain
allegations of serious irregularities and gross misconduct were
levelled against him in relation to sanction and disbursement of
agricultural loans, opening of accounts, unauthorized passing of
cash/transfer payments, and improper maintenance of loan
records and control cards. On the basis of the said allegations,
the appellant/writ petitioner was placed under suspension by
order dated 26.12.2006. A departmental enquiry was thereafter
initiated and a charge-sheet dated 27.05.2008 was issued,
alleging abuse of official position, procedural violations, financial
improprieties, opening of fictitious loan accounts, unauthorized
disbursement of loan amounts, manipulation of records, and
causing substantial financial loss to the Bank.
5.
The appellant/writ petitioner submitted his reply to the chargesheet on 12.07.2008. Upon completion of the enquiry, the Inquiry
Officer submitted his report on 07.07.2010. Based on the enquiry
report, a show-cause notice was issued to the appellant/writ
petitioner, to which he replied on 02.08.2010. After considering the
enquiry report and the reply, the disciplinary authority passed an
order of dismissal from service on 14.08.2010.
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the appellant/writ petitioner preferred a
departmental appeal, which was rejected on 05.05.2011.
Challenging the order of dismissal and the order passed in
appeal, the appellant/writ petitioner approached this Court by filing
the writ petition bearing WPS No.3400/2011, which was dismissed
by the learned Single Judge vide order dated 07.10.2025.
7.
Feeling aggrieved by the order dated 07.10.2025 passed in WPS
No.3400/2011, the present appeal has been filed by the
appellant/writ petitioners.
8.
Mr. Ashish Shrivastava, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr.
Rahul Ambast, learned counsel for the appellant/writ petitioner
submits that—
•
the learned Single Judge has erred in law and failed to
appreciate that in the departmental enquiry the mandatory
procedure prescribed under the Award on the Industrial
Disputes between Certain Banking Companies and Their
Workmen (popularly known as the Sastry Award), which is pari
materia to the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control &
Appeal) Rules, 1965 and the Memorandum of Settlement on
Disciplinary Action and Procedure, 2002 applicable to bank
employees, was not followed by the disciplinary authority. As a
consequence thereof, full and proper opportunity of hearing
was denied to the appellant/writ petitioner to effectively defend
himself;
•
the learned Single Judge further failed to consider that the
documents relied upon by the disciplinary authority for arriving
at the finding of guilt were never supplied to the appellant/writ
petitioner despite repeated requests, in clear violation of the
principles of natural justice, as laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in P.V. Mahadevan v. M.D., T.N. Housing
Board (AIR 2006 SC 207), State of U.P. v. Saroj Kumar
Sinha (AIR 2010 SC 3131), Narinder Mohan Arya v. United
India Insurance Co. Ltd. (AIR 2006 SC 1748) and
Allahabad Bank v. Krishna Narayan Tewari ((2017) 2 SCC
308). It is contended that, despite these settled principles and
the law governing reinstatement with consequential benefits
as propounded in Deepali Gundu Surwase v. Kranti Junior
Adhyapak Mahavidyalaya ((2013) 10 SCC 324), State of
Chhattisgarh v. Iqbal Khan (2002 (4) MPHT 58) and H.K.
Lagar v. C.G. Gramin Bank (CGLJ 2022 (2) 12), the learned
Single Judge relied upon judgments which are clearly
misplaced in the facts of the present case, particularly in view
of T. Takano v. SEBI ((2022) 8 SCC 162) and Amit Kumar
Sharma v. Union of India ((2023) 20 SCC 486);
•
the learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that the
charges framed against the appellant/writ petitioner were
vague, omnibus and baseless, and that the same were never
proved by cogent evidence, contrary to the law laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Anil Gilurker v. Bilaspur
Raipur Kshetriya Gramin Bank ((2011) 14 SCC 379);
• the learned Single Judge did not consider that the
appellant/writ petitioner was sought to be held liable for acts
which were neither performed by him nor fell within the scope
of his duties or authority. It was urged that the appellant was
working under the direct control and supervision of the Branch
Manager and that preparation of control cards was not part of
his assigned duties as per the distribution of work;
• the finding of guilt recorded in the departmental enquiry is
based merely on conjectures and surmises, inasmuch as the
documents relied upon were neither proved in the enquiry nor
supplied to the appellant/writ petitioner, rendering the entire
enquiry vitiated in law;
• the imposition of the major penalty of dismissal is grossly
disproportionate to the alleged acts attributed to the
appellant/writ
petitioner
and
shocks
the
conscience,
warranting interference by this Court;
• the learned Single Judge also failed to appreciate that under
the bi-partite settlement dated 10.04.2002, particularly Clause
14 thereof, a departmental appeal is required to be decided
within a period of two months, whereas in the present case the
appeal was decided after an unexplained delay of more than
seven months;
• the material prosecution witnesses were never examined or
made available for cross-examination by the appellant/writ
petitioner during the enquiry; further, no written complaint by
any debtor was produced, nor was any allegation of forged or
fake signatures duly proved. It was also urged that during the
relevant period, most of the transactions were carried out by
other cashiers and the appellant has been wrongly implicated;
•
the learned Single Judge failed to consider Annexure P/10,
which evidences a police investigation conducted at the
instance of the Tehsildar, wherein the appellant/writ petitioner
was absolved of any criminal liability and was, in fact, cited
only as a witness; and
• finally, it is submitted that the charges were not proved in
accordance with law and the appellant/writ petitioner could not
have
been
dismissed
merely
on
assumptions
and
presumptions, without proper scrutiny of the evidence and
surrounding facts and circumstances.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. Pankaj Singh, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents opposes the submissions advanced by
learned Senior Counsel and submits that—
•
the departmental enquiry was conducted strictly in accordance
with the prescribed procedure and after affording full and
effective opportunity of hearing to the appellant/writ petitioner.
It is submitted that during the course of enquiry, the
Presenting Officer placed reliance upon various sets of
documents from time to time, all of which were duly supplied
to the Charged Employee.
• on 17.03.2009, the Presenting Officer placed before the
Enquiry Officer a set of documents which were supplied to the
Charged Employee. Thereafter, additional sets of documents
were produced on 08.05.2009, 18.05.2009, 19.05.2009,
17.12.2009 and 05.01.2010, and each time copies thereof
were furnished to the Charged Employee.
• on 16.01.2010, the Charged Employee sought supply of
certain documents, which request was partly overruled by the
Enquiry Officer. Significantly, no objection was raised against
the said decision. A further request for additional documents
was, however, allowed by the Enquiry Officer. Pursuant
thereto, on 09.02.2010, the Presenting Officer produced the
documents as demanded.
•
on 10.02.2010, certain documents, which were either
unrelated to the charges or impractical to be produced, were
denied by the Enquiry Officer while allowing the demand for
other documents. The Charged Employee accepted the said
decision and accordingly restricted his demand. Subsequently,
on 16.04.2010 and 21.04.2010, the Presenting Officer
produced the documents sought by the Charged Employee,
and the Charged Employee expressly agreed to raise his
defence on the basis of the documents so supplied, without
any protest or demur.
• on 01.05.2010, prior to the closure of the enquiry proceedings,
the Charged Employee recorded his satisfaction with the
manner in which the enquiry was conducted and specifically
affirmed that he had been granted full and adequate
opportunity to defend himself.
•
therefore, the plea of violation of principles of natural justice or
non-supply of documents, as now sought to be urged, is
wholly misconceived and deserves to be rejected.
10.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and have
carefully considered the rival submissions advanced on their
behalf. We have also meticulously perused the impugned
order(s), the pleadings on record, the enquiry report, the orders
passed by the disciplinary as well as the appellate authorities, and
all other material documents placed before us.
11.
We have also perused the original record of the departmental
enquiry, which was produced before the Court by Mr. Pankaj
Singh, learned counsel appearing for the respondent, and the
same has been taken into consideration while examining the
merits of the case.
12.
After appreciating the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties as also the materials on record, the learned Single Judge
while applying the judicial precedents in The State of Punjab v.
Nachhattar Singh (dead) through Lr., 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 901,
Union of India and others v. K.G. Soni, (2006) 6 SCC 794 as
well as B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India and others, (1995) 6
SCC 749, has passed the impugned order in following terms:“7. After perusal of record it appears that the
petitioner was posted as a Senior Assistant at
Bhaiyathan Branch and during that period some
financial irregularities have been found against
him and pursuant to that on 26.12.2006 he was
suspended. The charges against the petitioner
are that he has committed irregularities and gross
misconduct
account
regarding
opening,
cash
sanctioning
of
loan,
payment
and
also
agriculture loan account were not properly drawn
and maintained as well as control cards were not
prepared and also requisite details were not
given. It is also alleged that the cash/transfer was
done by the petitioner is without authority of law.
A charge-sheet has been issued on 27.05.2008 in
which 11 charges have been leveled against the
petitioner and all are serious in nature. Record
also shows that a enquiry was conducted by the
Enquiry Officer on 12.07.2010 and except charge
No.7 all are found to be proved and on
20.07.2010 the petitioner has submitted his reply
on the said enquiry report. A show cause notice
for dismissal from service was issued to the
petitioner and he was directed to submit this
reply. The authority was not satisfied from the
reply submitted by the petitioner on 02.08.2010 a
dismissal from service of the petitioner has been
passed which is also affirmed by the appellate
authority on 05.05.2011 by the appeal filed by the
petitioner. The argument of the petitioner is that
he was under the direct control of Branch
Manager and work was assigned by him and at
that period he was working as cashier and
committed serious irregularities. The chargesheet issued to him also shows that during that
period he has done financial irregularities. The
next argument of the petitioner is that he has not
been given proper opportunity to defend himself
is baseless because all the documents relates to
enquiry has been supplied to him and show
cause has been given by the respondents.
Pursuant to that the petitioner has submitted his
reply and after passing an order he has also
preferred an appeal. It appears that the relevant
documents has been supplied to the petitioner
and also he was informed time to time regarding
proceedings therefore, he has submitted his reply.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of the
State of Punjab (Supra) held that mere nonsupply of the documents which may not have
resulted any prejudice caused to the employee,
the order passed by the disciplinary authority
cannot be set aside. The relevant para is quoted
herein-below:“ Having heard learned counsel appearing for
the respective parties and considering the
reasoning given by the High Court, we are of
the opinion that as such the impugned
judgment and order passed by the High Court
in exercise of powers under Section 100 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is unsustainable.
From the impugned judgment and order passed
by the High Court, it appears that the High
Court has set aside the order passed by the
disciplinary authority solely on the ground that
some documents were not supplied to the
delinquent. However, it is required to be noted
that as such there is no finding that non- supply
of some documents has resulted into any
prejudice caused to the delinquent-employee.
Mere non-supply of the documents which may
not have resulted any prejudice caused to the
employee, the order passed by the disciplinary
authority cannot be set aside.”
8. It also appears that he has misused his
position and work contrary to Rules, Regulations
and guidelines of the Bank and also failed to
check and maintain the requisite documents. The
prosecution proved its case against the petitioner
by leading oral as well as documentary evidence.
It also appears from the record that the finding
recorded by the Enquiry Officer and confirmed by
the disciplinary authority as well as the appellate
Authority is correct and not liable to be interfered
by this Court. The Supreme Court in the case of
Union of India and others (Supra) held in Para 22
as under:22. In another Judgment reported as B.C
Chaturvedi v. Union of India & Ors., it was held
that the power of judicial review is meant to
ensure
that
the
individual
receives
fair
treatment and not to ensure that the conclusion
which the authority reaches is necessarily
correct in the eye of the court. The Judicial
review is not an appeal from a decision but a
review of the manner in which the decision is
made. The Court is to examine as to whether
the inquiry was held by a competent officer or
whether rules of natural justice are complied
with. This Court held as under:“12. Judicial review is not an appeal from a
decision but a review of the manner in which
the decision is made. Power of judicial
review is meant to ensure that the individual
receives fair treatment and not to ensure that
the conclusion which the authority reaches is
necessarily correct in the eye of the court.
When an inquiry is conducted on charges of
misconduct
by
a
public
servant,
the
Court/Tribunal is concerned to determine
whether the inquiry was held by a competent
officer or whether rules of natural justice are
complied with. Whether the findings or
conclusions are based on some evidence,
the authority entrusted with the power to hold
inquiry has jurisdiction, power and authority
to reach a finding of fact or conclusion. But
that finding must be based on some
evidence. Neither the technical rules of
Evidence Act nor of proof of fact or evidence
as defined therein, apply to disciplinary
proceeding. When the authority accepts that
evidence and conclusion receives support
therefrom, the disciplinary authority is entitled
to hold that the delinquent officer is guilty of
the charge. The Court/Tribunal in its power of
judicial review does not act as appellate
authority to reappreciate the evidence and to
arrive at its own independent findings on the
evidence. The Court/Tribunal may interfere
where the authority held the proceedings
against the delinquent officer in a manner
inconsistent with the rules of natural justice
or in violation of statutory rules prescribing
the mode of inquiry or where the conclusion
or
finding
reached
by
the
disciplinary
authority is based on no evidence. If the
conclusion
or
finding
be
such
as
no
reasonable person would have ever reached,
the Court/Tribunal may interfere with the
conclusion or the finding, and mould the
relief so as to make it appropriate to the facts
of each case.
13. The disciplinary authority is the sole
judge of facts. Where appeal is presented,
the appellate authority has coextensive
power to reappreciate the evidence or the
nature of punishment. In a disciplinary
inquiry, the strict proof of legal evidence and
findings on that evidence are not relevant.
Adequacy
of
evidence
evidence
cannot
be
or
reliability
permitted
to
of
be
canvassed before the Court/Tribunal. In
Union of India v. H.C. Goel [(1964) 4 SCR
718 : AIR 1964 SC 364 : (1964) 1 LLJ 38]
this Court held at p. 728 that if the
conclusion,
upon
evidence
reached
consideration
by
the
of
the
disciplinary
authority, is perverse or suffers from patent
error on the face of the record or based on
no evidence at all, a writ of certiorari could be
issued.”
9. The submission of the petitioner is that some
documents relates to enquiry has not been
supplied to him but he has not mentioned that
what document has not been supplied and what
prejudice has been caused, therefore, on this
ground he cannot claim any relief. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of State Bank of India
(Supra) held as under:“33. The Appellate Authority in its order dated
6th June, 1984 noticed that the respondent had
"failed to submit his list of documents and
witnesses which he wanted to produce for the
purpose of his defence within the date
stipulated the Inquiring Authority and he also
did not raise any objection during the course of
enquiry." The Review Committee in its order
dated 12th November, 1987 upon consideration
of the entire matter observed as follows:"The Petitioner has contended that certain
documents required by him were not made
available to him by the prosecution at the
inquiry. The records reveal, in this respect,
that he was asked to submit his lists of
documents and witnesses by the 31st March,
1982 and that he had failed to do so. The
lists were in fact received by the Presenting
Officer on the 28th May 1982, far beyond the
stipulated time, and as such no action was
taken thereon. However, the Committee is at
a loss to understand as to why the Petitioner
did not press at the Inquiry for the production
of the requisite documents if they were so
vital as to cause serious prejudice to his
defence
as
alleged.
The
Petitioner's
accusation that the Inquiry Authority refused
to summon all the defence witnesses is also
not acceptable for the same reason that the
list was not received within the stipulated
period. The committee, however, observes
that the Inquiring Authority had, in fact,
permitted the Petitioner to produce his
witnesses for deposition."
34. These observations indicate even though
the grievance was made belatedly, the same
was duly considered by the highest authority of
the Bank. Even at that stage, the respondent
had failed to point out as to what prejudice had
been caused to him during the course of the
enquiry. In such circumstances, the Division
Bench was wholly unjustified in setting aside
the entire disciplinary proceedings and the
findings recorded by the learned Single Judge.
10. Apart from Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
of B. C. Chaturvedi Vs. Union of India and Others
reported in (1995) 6 SCC 749 in Paras 12 & 13
held as under:“12. Judicial review is not an appeal from a
decision but a review of the manner in which
the decision is made. Power of judicial review is
meant to ensure that the individual receives fair
treatment and not to ensure that the conclusion
which the authority reaches is necessarily
correct in the eye of the court. When an inquiry
is conducted on charges of misconduct by a
public servant, the Court/Tribunal is concerned
to determine whether the inquiry was held by a
competent officer or whether the inquiry was
held by a competent officer or whether rules of
natural justice are complied with. Whether the
findings or conclusions are based on some
evidence, the authority entrusted with the
power to hold inquiry has jurisdiction, power
and authority to reach a finding of fact or
conclusion. But that finding must be based on
some evidence. Neither the technical rules of
Evidence Act nor of proof of fact or evidence as
defined
therein,
apply
to
disciplinary
proceeding. When the authority accepts that
evidence and conclusion receives support
therefrom, the disciplinary authority is entitled
to hold that the delinquent officer is guilty of the
charge. The Court/Tribunal in its power of
judicial review does not act as appellate
authority to re- appreciate the evidence and to
arrive at its own independent findings on the
evidence. The Court/Tribunal may interfere
where the authority held the proceedings
against the delinquent officer in a manner
inconsistent with the rules of natural justice or
in violation of statutory rules prescribing the
mode of inquiry or where the conclusion or
finding reached by the disciplinary authority is
based on no evidence. If the conclusion or
finding be such as no reasonable person would
have ever reached, the Court/Tribunal may
interfere with the conclusion or the finding, and
mould the relief so as to make it appropriate to
the facts of each case.
13. The disciplinary authority is the sole judge
of facts. Where appeal is presented. The
appellate authority has co- extensive power to
reappreciate the evidence or the nature of
punishment. In a disciplinary inquiry the strict
proof of legal evidence and findings on that
evidence
are
not
relevant.
Adequacy
of
evidence or reliability of evidence cannot be
permitted
to
be
canvassed
before
the
Court/Tribunal. In Union of India v. H.C. Goel
[(1964) 4 SCR 781], this Court held at page
728 that if the conclusion, upon consideration
of the evidence, reached by the disciplinary
authority, is perverse or suffers from patent
error on the face of the record or based on no
evidence at all, a writ of certiorari could be
issued.”
11. The petitioner being a Bank employee was
required to exercise higher standards of honesty
and integrity. He was required to take all possible
steps to protect the interests of the Bank, to
discharge
his
duties
with
utmost
integrity,
honesty, devotion and diligence and to do nothing
which is unbecoming of a Bank employee. Good
conduct and discipline are inseparable from the
functioning of every officer/employee of the Bank.
The punishment inflicted upon the petitioner
cannot be said to be shocking to the conscience
of the Court and most of the allegations made
against the petitioner have been found proved.
12. With regard to circular dated 18.08.2005 by
which duties of the petitioner has been submitted
is no relevant in this case because he has
conducted financial irregularities and regarding
memorandum of settlement dated 29.07.2002
after examination of misconduct and financial
irregularities
committed
by
the
petitioner
appropriate order has been passed, therefore, it
cannot be said that the circular has come to in his
rescue.
13. The next submission of the petitioner is that
an FIR has been lodged by the then Tahsildar
Surajpur in which the petitioner was absolved
from criminal liabilities and he was made a
witness
in
the
said
case,
therefore,
the
departmental enquiry on the basis of same
charges is not sustainable. The FIR was not
lodged by the Bank it is lodged by the Then
Tahsildar, therefore, it cannot be said that the
respondents are binding upon the said FIR and
the employer/Bank has conducted independent
departmental enquiry. The departmental enquiry
would be decided on the preponderance of
probability, whereas in the criminal case the
prosecution has to prove the guilt of an accused
beyond reasonable doubt. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of Noida Entrepreneurs Associates
Vs. Noida and Others reported in AIR 2007 SC
1161 in Para 17 held as under:“17.The
standard
of
proof
required
in
departmental proceedings is not the same as
required to prove a criminal charge and even if
there is an acquittal in the criminal proceedings
the
same
does
not
bar
departmental
proceedings. That being so, the order of the
State Government deciding not to continue the
departmental proceedings is clearly untenable
and is quashed. The departmental proceedings
shall continue.”
14. In present case a detailed enquiry was
conducted by the respondent and after giving
proper opportunity of hearing to the petitioner and
supplying the papers of departmental enquiry he
has submitted his reply and thereafter he was
found guilty and looking to the nature of
misconduct and financial irregularities an order of
dismissal
from
service
has
been
passed.
Therefore, he cannot get any relief from this
argument. Taking into consideration the abovediscussed facts and the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the opinion of this
Court, no case is made out for interference.
Consequently, the instant petition fails and is
hereby dismissed.”
13.
Upon a comprehensive reappraisal of the entire factual matrix, the
pleadings on record, the original records of the departmental
enquiry, and the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel
for the parties, we are of the considered opinion that the learned
Single Judge has rightly dismissed the writ petition and that the
impugned order dated 07.10.2025 does not suffer from any legal
infirmity, perversity, or jurisdictional error warranting interference
in intra-court appellate jurisdiction.
14.
The record unmistakably demonstrates that the departmental
enquiry was conducted in accordance with the applicable
statutory provisions, settlement norms, and the principles of
natural justice. The appellant/writ petitioner was afforded repeated
and adequate opportunities to defend himself, including supply of
documents relied upon by the disciplinary authority, consideration
of his objections, and grant of opportunity to present his defence.
Significantly, the appellant himself recorded his satisfaction with
the manner of conduct of the enquiry prior to its closure, which
clearly belies the plea of denial of reasonable opportunity.
15.
It is equally well settled that the scope of judicial review in
disciplinary matters is limited. Neither this Court nor the learned
Single Judge can sit in appeal over the findings of fact recorded
by the Enquiry Officer or re-appreciate the evidence as if
exercising appellate jurisdiction. So long as the findings are
supported by some evidence and the enquiry is conducted fairly
and by a competent authority, interference is not warranted. In the
present case, the findings of guilt recorded against the appellant
are based on oral as well as documentary evidence and cannot
be said to be perverse or based on no evidence.
16.
The contention regarding non-supply of documents or violation of
principles of natural justice has rightly been negatived, as the
appellant has failed to demonstrate any specific prejudice caused
to him. Mere allegations of non-supply, without pointing out how
such alleged omission has affected the defence, are insufficient to
vitiate a disciplinary enquiry, particularly in view of the
authoritative pronouncements of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
governing the field.
17.
The argument that the appellant was acting under the directions
or supervision of superior officers, including the Branch Manager,
does not absolve him of responsibility, especially when the
charges pertain to misuse of position, unauthorized financial
transactions, and gross procedural violations. A bank employee is
expected to adhere to the highest standards of integrity, honesty,
and diligence, and the nature of misconduct proved in the present
case justifies the penalty imposed.
18.
We also find no substance in the plea regarding proportionality of
punishment. Considering the gravity of the charges, the scale of
financial irregularities, and the resultant loss and erosion of public
confidence in banking operations, the punishment of dismissal
from service cannot be said to be shockingly disproportionate or
arbitrary so as to call for interference by this Court.
19.
The reliance placed on the outcome of a criminal investigation or
the appellant being absolved of criminal liability is also misplaced.
It is settled law that departmental proceedings operate in a distinct
sphere and are governed by the principle of preponderance of
probabilities, unlike criminal trials which require proof beyond
reasonable doubt.
20.
In view of the foregoing discussion, we are satisfied that the
learned Single Judge has correctly appreciated the facts and
applied the settled principles of law. No ground is made out to
interfere with the impugned order in exercise of our intra-court
appellate jurisdiction.
21.
Consequently, the writ appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.
22.
After due perusal of the original record of the departmental
enquiry produced before this Court, the same has been returned
in Court to Mr. Pankaj Singh, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
Anu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review