Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed by
GOPAL SINGH
Date:
2026.05.12
17:37:09
+0530
2026:CGHC:21145
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 2403 of 2024
1 - Divisional Manager, The New India Insurance Company Limited
Divisional OfÏce Sada Complex, Transport Nagar, Korba, Chhattisgarh.
( Insurer Truck No. C.G. 13 / A.H./ 2982)
--- Appellant
versus
1 - Sabiya Parveen W/o Late Neyajuddin Aged About 32 Years
Resident House No. Number 118, Village - Telaaedhar, Post Battaikala, Thana - Sitapur, District Surguja, Chhattisgarh. (Claimant)
2 - Mohd. Moienuddin Khan S/o Late Neyajuddin Aged About 10 Years
Minor, Through Natural Guardian Mother Sabiya Parveen ( Respondent
No. 1) W/o Late Neyajuddin, Resident House No. Number 118, Village Telaaedhar, Post - Battaikala, Thana - Sitapur, District Surguja,
Chhattisgarh.
(Claimant)
3 - Mohseen Khan S/o Late Neyajuddin Aged About 8 Years Minor,
Through Natural Guardian Mother Sabiya Parveen ( Respondent No. 1)
W/o Late Neyajuddin, Resident House No. Number 118, Village Telaaedhar, Post - Battaikala, Thana - Sitapur, District Surguja,
Chhattisgarh.
(Claimant)
4 - Naajma Begum W/o Nejamuddin Aged About 57 Years Resident
House No. Number 118, Village - Telaaedhar, Post - Battaikala, Thana Sitapur,
District
Surguja,
Chhattisgarh.
(Claimant)
5 - Nejamuddin S/o Mohiuddin Aged About 62 Years Resident House
No. Number 118, Village - Telaaedhar, Post - Battaikala, Thana Sitapur,
District
Surguja,
Chhattisgarh.
(Claimant)
6 - Ulsan Ekka S/o Shilas Ekka Aged About 35 Years Resident
Saraskombo, Thana Bagicha, District Jashpur, Chhattisgarh. (Vehicle
Driver)
7 - Chetan Kumar Singhaniya S/o Pradeep Singhaniya Flat No. - 10
S.G. Height Gajaanandpuram Raigarh, District - Raigarh Chhattisgarh.
(Vehicle Owner)
--- Respondents
MAC No. 2407 of 2024
1 - Sabiya Parveen W/o Late Neyajuddin Aged About 32 Years R/o
Makan No. 118, Village Talaidhar, Post- Bataikela, Police StationSitapur, District- Surguja Chhattisgarh. (Claimant/ Applicant No. 1 )
2 - Mohd. Moin- Uddin Khan S/o Late Neyajuddin Aged About 10 Years
Minor They Are Being Represented By Appellant No. 1/ Mother- Sabiya
Parveen, W/o Late Neyajuddin Aged 32 Years R/o Makan No. 118,
Village Telaidhar, Post- Bataikela, Police Station- Sitapur, DistrictSurguja ( C.G.). Claimant/ Applicant No. 2 )
3 - Mohasin Khan S/o Late Neyajuddin Aged About 8 Years Minor They
Are Being Represented By Appellant No. 2/ Mother- Sabiya Parveen,
W/o Late Neyajuddin Aged 32 Years R/o Makan No. 118, Village
Telaidhar, Post- Bataikela, Police Station- Sitapur, District- Surguja
( C.G.). ( Claimant/ Applicant No. 3 )
--- Appellants
Versus
1 - Uslan Ekka S/o Shila Ekka Aged About 35 Years R/o Sarascombo,
Police Station- Baghicha, District- Jashpur ( C.G.). ( Driver/ NonApplicant No.1 )
2 - Chetan Kumar Singhaniya S/o Pradeep Kumar Singhaniya Flat No.
10, Sg Heights, Gajanandpuram, Raigarh, District- Raigarh ( C.G. )
( Vehicle Owner/ Non- Applicant No. 2 )
3 - Mandal Prabandhak The New India Insurance Company Limited
Mandal OfÏce Sada Complex Transport Nagar Korba District- Korba
( C.G.). ( Insurance Company/ Non- Applicant No. 3 )
4 - Najma Begam W/o Nejamuddin Aged About 57 Years R/o Bataikela,
Police Station - Sitapur, District- Surguja ( C.G.). ( Claimant/ Applicant
No. 4 )
5 - Nejamuddin S/o Mohi- Uddin Aged About 62 Years R/o Makan No.
118, Village Telaidhar, Post Bataikela, Police Station- Sitapur, DistrictSurguja ( C.G. ). ( Claimant/ Applicant No. 5 )
--- Respondents
MAC No.2403 of 2024
For Appellant
:
Shri Sudhir Agrawal, Advocate
For Respondents No.1 to 5
:
Shri Sushil Dubey, Advocate
For Respondent No.7
:
Shri Amartya Bajpai, Advocate on
behalf
of
Shri
Ankit
Singhal,
Advocate
For Respondent No.6
:
None
MAC No.2407 of 2024
For Appellants
:
Shri Sushil Dubey, Advocate
For Respondent No.2
:
Shri Amartya Bajpai, Advocate on
behalf
of
Shri
Ankit
Singhal,
Advocate
For Respondent No.3
:
Shri Sudhir Agrawal, Advocate
For Respondents No.4 & 5
:
None Despite Service
Hon’ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput
Order on Board
06/05/2026
1.
As the present appeals have been filed against the award dated
11.9.2024 passed by the Principal Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal, Ambikapur (Surguja) (Chhattisgarh) (for short ‘Claims
Tribunal’) in Claim Case No.23 of 2023, they are being heard and
decided by this common order.
2.
Parties are referred to herein according to their status before the
Claims Tribunal.
3.
MAC No.2403 of 2024 has been filed by the insurance company
for reduction of the compensation awarded, whereas MAC
No.2407
of
has
been
filed
by
the
claimants
for
enhancement of the compensation awarded.
4.
By the award impugned, against a claim of Rs.71,82,000,
learned Claims Tribunal has assessed the dependency to
Rs.32,40,000, however, deducted 25% amount from the amount
of compensation on account of contributory negligence. Thus,
found the dependency to Rs.24,30,000 and thereafter adding
Rs.18,000 for loss of estate, Rs.18,000 for funeral expenses,
Rs.48,000 for loss of consortium and Rs.40,000 for filial and
parental consortium, awarded total Rs.25,54,000 in favour of
the claimants.
5.
As per the pleadings of the claim application filed under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short ‘the MV Act’),
deceased Neyajuddin was a driver and had gone to Banke Bihari
Company, Punjipathara for loading goods in truck bearing
registration No.CG 15 DE 3910 on 6.12.2022. On 7.12.2022, at
about 11:00 a.m., after loading and parking his truck, he was
talking on phone. At that time, the driver of the offending
vehicle truck bearing registration No.CG 13 AH 2982 drove the
offending vehicle rashly and negligently and dashed to the
deceased from behind resulting into injuries on his person. He
was taken to the hospital, where he was declared dead, upon
which an offence under Crime No.324/2022 under Section 304A
IPC was registered in Police Station Punjipathra against the
driver of the offending vehicle. As per further pleadings, the
deceased was a driver and earning Rs.22,000 per month. Thus,
the above stated compensation was claimed.
6.
The driver of the offending vehicle remained ex parte and did
not file any written statement. The owner of the offending
vehicle filed his written statement and denied the averments of
the claim application. It has been pleaded by the owner that
proper parties have not been arrayed. The driver of the
offending vehicle had valid and effective driving licence. Thus,
liability to pay compensation is upon the insurance company.
7.
The insurance company also filed written statement and in usual
course denied the averments of the claim application. It has
been pleaded by the insurance company that at the time of
incident, the truck of the deceased was not starting. In order to
tow his truck, he was afÏxing a jack rod between his truck and
the offending truck and he was in between the two trucks and
stuck in between. Thus, both the trucks were involved in the
accident and the driver, owner and the insurer of both the
trucks would be jointly liable. The owner and insurer of the truck
of the deceased are not arrayed as respondents. They are
necessary parties. No such accident had taken place as
projected. The offending truck was not holding valid permit and
fitness certificate. Thus, the insurance company cannot be held
liable to pay the compensation.
8.
Learned Claims Tribunal framed issues and decided them in
favour of the claimants. However, while deciding issue No.1 held
that the deceased contributed to the tune of 25% in causing the
accident. Thus, reduced the compensation as stated above.
9.
Shri Sudhir Agrawal, learned counsel for the appellant/insurance
company submits that the monthly income of the deceased to
the tune of Rs.15,000 has wrongly been assessed by the learned
Claims Tribunal. The salary certificate issued by the employer of
the deceased cannot be looked into as an evidence in absence
of any other documentary evidence. At the most, the deceased
could be considered as a skilled labour. Thus, his income ought
to have been considered on the basis of minimum wages
prevailing at that time for skilled labour. Apart from this, he
submits that the Claims Tribunal erred in holding the age of the
deceased to 35 years relying upon the post mortem report. He
submits that the driving licence of the deceased was placed on
record and also exhibited as Ex.P16C showing his date of birth
as 3.2.1985. Thus, on the date of incident, he was more than 37
years of age. Thus, the application of multiplier of 16 is also
wrong. Apart from this, he submits that the 50% addition of
future prospects is not appropriate. It ought to have been 40%.
Thus, in light of above, he submits that the compensation
awarded may be suitably reduced.
10.
Shri
Amartya
Bajpai,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent/vehicle owner supports the impugned award.
11.
Shri Sushil Dubey, learned counsel for the claimants submits
that apart from the monthly salary of Rs.15,000, the deceased
was also being paid Rs.500 per day as diet money. Learned
Claims Tribunal erred in not assessing compensation adding the
diet money to the emoluments of the deceased. Thus, he
submits that compensation may be suitably enhanced. He
further submits that the deceased was not driving any vehicle.
In fact, he was dashed by the offending vehicle resulting into his
death. No pleadings was ever raised by either the owner or the
insurance company of the offending vehicle with regard to
contributory negligence of the deceased. Thus, the finding of
contributory negligence as found by the learned Claims Tribunal
deserves to be set aside.
12.
I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and
perused the record of the Claims Tribunal with due care.
13.
First point for determination before this Court is as to whether
the learned Claims Tribunal committed an error in deducting
25% compensation on account of contributory negligence on the
part of the deceased. From perusal of the record, it appears that
the deceased was not driving any of the vehicles. Learned
Claims Tribunal found that the deceased was fixing a rod with
the offending vehicle in order to start his vehicle and was near
the offending vehicle and stuck in between the two vehicles.
Thus, on the basis of above availability of evidence, the Claims
Tribunal found that the deceased also contributed to the
accident. In the opinion of this Court, this finding cannot sustain
as no specific pleading was ever raised by the owner or the
insurance company of the offending vehicle with regard to
contributory negligence. The claim application under the M.V.
Act is summary in nature. No evidence was also led by the
driver of the offending vehicle to suggest that the deceased also
contributed to the accident. The criminal case was registered
against the driver of the offending vehicle and charge sheet was
also filed. In absence of any other evidence contrary to the
available on record, in the opinion of this Court, the finding with
regard to contributory negligence recorded by the Claims
Tribunal appears to be misplaced. Thus, the same is hereby set
aside.
14.
This leads this Court to second point for determination as to
what would be the just compensation to be awarded to the
claimants.
15.
Learned counsel for the claimants tried to persuade this Court
that the Claims Tribunal erred in not adding Rs.500 per day diet
money to the emoluments of the deceased. Whereas, learned
counsel for the insurance company submits that the reliance on
the salary certificate issued is misplaced and the compensation
is to be assessed on the basis of minimum wages of a skilled
labour. From the evidence on record, it appears that the
deceased was a driver as he had gone to Punjipathra to load
certain material on his vehicle. After loading material and
parking his vehicle on the side he was talking on phone. As his
vehicle was not being started, he was putting jack between his
vehicle and the offending vehicle and in the meanwhile the
accident occurred. Apart from this, the deceased had a licence
to drive a transport vehicle is also exhibited. This is informative
piece of evidence to show that the deceased could be the driver
of the truck bearing registration No.CG 15 DE 3910.
16.
Apart from this, the manager of the company in which the
deceased was said to be working as a driver has also been
examined and he has stated that the deceased was a driver in
his company. It appears that the company had a large number
of trucks engaging drivers. In light of the above, this Court can
safely gather that the deceased was a driver in truck bearing
registration No.CG 15 DE 3910 and had gone to load the
material. The salary certificate has been issued by the employer
of the deceased which has been duly proved by the manager.
Apart from this, some ledger account has also been exhibited
which goes to show that some diet money was also being paid.
However, it does not disclose that the said diet money was
being paid to the deceased. The evidence also suggests that it
has been stated that whenever the deceased was on leave, no
diet money was being paid to him. The Courts and the Claims
Tribunals have to see that just compensation is awarded. It
should not be a meager amount or a bonanza. The learned
Claims Tribunal on assessment of the entire evidence available
on record gave a finding that the deceased was earning
Rs.15,000 per month. Thus, the finding so recorded by the
Claims Tribunal is based upon proper assessment of the
evidence available on record. Thus, the contention of Shri Sudhir
Agrawal, learned counsel for the insurance company is repelled
that the compensation should have been calculated on the basis
of minimum wages prevailing at the relevant time and the
contention of Shri Sushil Dubey, learned counsel for the
claimants is also rejected that the deceased driver was getting
Rs.500 per day as diet money has not been assessed. The
finding with regard to income of the deceased to Rs.15,000 per
month is hereby afÏrmed.
17.
Now, next contention of Shri Sudhir Agrawal, learned counsel for
the insurance company is that 40% future prospects ought to
have been added instead of 50%. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and
others, 2017 ACJ 2700
has laid down parameters for
calculation of compensation under the MV Act. Paragraph 61 of
the judgment reads thus:
“61. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we proceed to
record our conclusions:
xxx
(iii)
xxx
xxx
While determining the income, an addition of 50
per cent of actual salary to the income of the deceased
towards future prospects, where the deceased had a
permanent job and was below the age of 40 years,
should be made. The addition should be 30 per cent, if
the age of the deceased was between 40 and 50 years.
In case the deceased was between the age of 50 and 60
years, the addition should be 15 per cent. Actual salary
should be read as actual salary less tax.
(iv)
In case the deceased was self-employed or on a
fixed salary, an addition of 40 per cent of the
established income should be the warrant where the
deceased was below the age of 40 years. An addition of
25 per cent where the deceased was between the age
of 40 and 50 years and 10 per cent where the deceased
was between the age of 50 and 60 years should be
regarded as the necessary method of computation. The
established income means the income minus the tax
component.”
18.
Sub para (iii) of para 61 of the aforesaid judgment indicates that
when the deceased had a permanent job and was below the age
of 40 years, 50% enhancement ought to have been made.
Whereas sub para (iv) of para 61 of the judgment indicates that
in case the deceased was self-employed or on a fixed salary, an
addition of 40% ought to have been applied. From perusal of the
record of the instant case, it appears that the deceased was on
a fixed salary of Rs.15,000 per month. Thus, this Court is
inclined to add 40% future prospects and hence recalculate the
compensation in the following manner:
Sl.No.
Particulars
Amount
(Rs.)
Annual Income
1,80,000
(Rs.15,000 x 12)
Income with Future Prospects
2,52,000
(Rs.1,80,000 x 40% Future Prospects =
Rs.72,000; Rs.1,80,000 + Rs.72,000)
Income after Deduction of Personal and
1,89,000
Living Expenses of the Deceased
(Rs.2,52,000 / 4 = Rs.63,000; Rs.2,52,000
– Rs.63,000)
Loss of Dependency after Application of
28,35,000
Multiplier
(Rs.1,89,000 x 15)
Funeral Expenses
16,500
Loss of Estate
16,500
Spousal
Consortium
to
Wife
of
the
44,000
Parental Consortium to 2 Children and
1,60,000
Deceased
Filial Consortium to 2 Parents of the
Deceased
(Rs.40,000 x 4)
19.
Total Compensation =
30,72,000
(-) Compensation Awarded by the Claims Tribunal =
25,54,000
Enhancement in Compensation =
5,18,000
In view of the aforesaid analysis, the claimants are held to be
entitled
to
an
additional
amount
of
compensation
of
Rs.5,18,000. The enhanced amount of compensation shall carry
simple interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of the
instant appeals, i.e., 16.12.2024 till final payment of the
enhanced compensation. The insurer of the offending vehicle,
i.e., The New India Insurance Company Limited is directed to
deposit the amount of compensation as enhanced by this Court
along with the interest within a period of 60 days from the date
of receipt of a copy of this order. Out of the enhanced amount of
compensation, Rs.1,50,000 each, total Rs.3,00,000 shall be
invested in fixed deposit in a nationalised bank in the names of
claimants/appellants No.2 and 3 till their attaining majority.
Rs.1,00,000 shall be invested in fixed deposit in the same
nationalised bank in the name of claimant/appellant No.1 for a
period of 2 years. Rs.50,000 each, total Rs.1,00,000 shall be
disbursed to claimants/respondents No.4 and 5. Remaining
amount shall be disbursed to claimant/appellant No.1. Rest of
the impugned award shall remain intact.
20.
Thus, the appeal filed by the insurance company is dismissed
and the appeal filed by the claimants is partly allowed as
indicated above. The impugned award is modified to the extent
shown above.
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
JUDGE
Gopal
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review