Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.9689 of 2022 &
W.P.(C) Nos.35141 & 33699 of 2025
In the matter of an application under Article 226 & 227 of
the Constitution of India, 1950.
………………
….
Sabitri Patra
Petitioner
-versus-
State of Odisha & Others
For Petitioner
For Opp. Parties
….
Opp. Parties
: Mr. K.C. Sahu, Advocate
: Mr. S. P. Das, ASC
PRESENT:
THE HONBLE JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
Date of Hearing: 18.02.2026 and Date of Judgment: 18.02.2026
// 2 //
Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J.
1.
This matter is taken up through Hybrid Arrangement
(Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties.
3.
Since all these three Writ Petitions have been filed
challenging the order of punishment passed on 18.03.2019
in three different disciplinary proceedings initiated against
the deceased employee Jay Chandra Patra, all the matters
were heard analogously and disposed of by the present
common order.
4.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioner
contended that the deceased employee while in service
three different departmental proceedings were initiated
against
him
vide
Memorandums
dtd.13.01.1982,
03.01.1986 and 31.12.1991. In all those proceedings, the
deceased employee not only participated in the proceeding,
but also participated in the enquiry.
4.1. However, on the face of such participation of the
deceased employee, when no decision was taken in
concluding
the
proceedings,
the
deceased
employee
approached the Tribunal in O.A Nos.2126, 2127 & 2128 of
2002 with a prayer to direct the Opposite Parties to
conclude the proceedings within a stipulated time period.
4.2. All the three Original Applications were disposed of by
the Tribunal vide order dtd.08.11.2002 under Annexures-4
// 3 //
to 6 and with a direction on the disciplinary authorityOpposite Party No.4 to dispose of the proceedings within a
period of three (3) months from the date of receipt of the
order.
The Tribunal passed further order that pending
disposal of the disciplinary proceedings, the deceased
employee be allowed to draw minimum of the current
revised scale attached to the post he is holding.
4.3. It is contended that on the face of such order passed
by the Tribunal under Annexures-4 to 6, none of the
proceedings initiated against the deceased employee was
disposed of, nor the deceased employee was allowed the
benefit of increment as due and admissible after allowing
the minimum of the revised scale, till he attained the age of
superannuation on 30.09.2010.
4.4. It is contended that even after retirement of the
deceased employee on 30.09.2010, the deceased employee
was not sanctioned with pension and other pensionary
benefits, because of the pendency of the proceedings in
question.
However,
without
complying
the
provisions
contained
under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 (in
short ‘1962 Rules’) and without converting the proceedings
to a proceeding under Rule-7 of OCS (Pension) Rules, 1992
(in short ‘1992 Rules’), Opposite Party No.4 by a cryptic
orders of even date disposed of all the three proceedings,
vide the impugned office order dtd.18.03.2019, which are
impugned in the present three Writ Petitions.
// 4 //
4.5. It is also contended that such an order was passed by
the
disciplinary
–Opposite
authority
Party
No.4
on
18.03.2019, basing on the enquiry report submitted on
16.03.2019, so apparent on the face of the impugned order
itself.
4.6. Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioner
contended that since statutory provisions contained under
Rule-15 (10)(i)(a) & (b) of the 1962 Rules were never
followed, nor the proceeding was converted to a proceeding
under Rule-7 of 1992 Rules, prior to disposal of the
proceedings,
the
order
of
punishment
passed
on
18.03.2019 in all the three cases is not sustainable in the
eye of law and requires interference of this Court.
Rule-
15(10)(i)(a)&(b) of the 1962 Rules and Rule-7 of the 1992
Rules reads as follows:“Rule I5(10)(i) (a) & (b) of OCS (CC&A) Rules, 1962,
provides as follows;
"(a) If the inquiring officer is not the disciplinary
authority, the disciplinary authority shall furnish to
the delinquent Government servant a copy of the
report of the inquiring officer and give him notice by
registered post or otherwise calling upon him to
submit within a period of fifteen days such
representation as he may wish to make against
findings of the Inquiring Authority.
(b) On receipt of the representation referred to in sub
clause (a) if the disciplinary authority having regards
to the findings on the charges, is of the opinion that
any of the penalties specified in clauses (vi) to (ix) of
rule 13 should be imposed, he shall furnish to the
delinquent Government servant a statement of its
findings along with brief reasons for disagreement, if
any, with the findings of the inquiring officer and give
// 5 //
him a notice by Registered post or otherwise stating
the penalty proposed to be imposed on him and
calling upon him to submit within a specified time
such representation as he may wish to make against
the proposed penalty";
As the proposed tentative penalty of
“withholding of promotion till his retirement” on the
delinquent officer by the Disciplinary Authority does
not come under any of the penalties specified in
clauses (vi) to (ix) of rule-13 of OCS(CCA) rules, 1962,
hence the proposed penalty was not intimated to the
delinquent officer. Thus, there is no requirement
under law to issue a show cause notice to the
delinquent if a major penalty is not being imposed.
Hence, as per proviso to Rule-15(10)(i)(b) of
OCS(CC&A) Rules, 1962, advice of Odisha Public
Service Commission was sought for on the proposed
penalty along with all relevant documents Home
Department Letter No.567 dated 03.01.2023.”
“7. Right of Government
Withdraw Pension-
to
Withhold
or
(1) The Government reserve to themselves the right of
withholding a pension or gratuity, or both either in full
or in part, or withdrawing a pension in full or in part.
whether permanently or for specified period and of
ordering recovery from a pension or gratuity of the
whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the
Government, if in any departmental or judicial
proceedings, the pensioner is found guilty of grave
misconduct or negligence in duty during the period of
his service including service rendered on reemployment after retirement:
Provided that the Odisha Public Service Commission
shall be consulted before any final orders are passed:
Provided further that when a part of pension is
withheld / withdrawn, the amount of such pension
shall not be reduced below the amount of minimum
limit.
(2) (a) Such departmental proceedings referred to in
sub-rule (1), if instituted while the Government
// 6 //
servant was in service, whether before his retirement
or during his reemployment, shall, after the final
retirement of the Government servant, be deemed to
be a proceedings under this rule and shall be
continued and concluded by the authority by which
they were commenced in the same manner as if the
Government servant had continued in service:
Provided that when the departmental proceedings
are instituted by an authority, subordinate to
Government that authority shall submit a report
recording its findings to the Government.
(b) such departmental proceedings as referred to in
sub-rule (1) if not instituted while the Government
servant was in service, whether before his retirement
or during his reemployment(i) shall not be instituted save with the sanction of
Government;
(ii) shall not be in respect of any event which took
place more than four years before such institution ;
and
(iii) shall be conducted by such authority and in such
place as the Government
may, direct and in
accordance with the procedure applicable to
departmental proceedings in which an order of
dismissal from service could be made in relation to
the Government servant during his service;
(c)
[deleted]
Vide
Finance
Department
Notification No.33464/F., dtd.04.08.2006
(d) In the case of Government servant who has retired
on attaining the age of superannuation or otherwise
and against whom any departmental or judicial
proceedings are instituted or where departmental
proceeding are instituted or where departmental
proceedings are continued under clauses (a) and (b), a
provisional pension as provided in rule 66 shall be
sanctioned
(e) Where the Government decide not to withhold or
withdraw pension but order recovery of pecuniary
// 7 //
loss from pension, the recovery shall not ordinarily be
made at a rate exceeding one-third of the pension
admissible on the date of retirement of a Government
servant.
Explanation- For the purpose of this rule,(a) Departmental proceedings shall be deemed to be
instituted on the date on which the statement of
charges are issued to the Government servant or
pensioner, or if the Government servant has been
placed under suspension from the date of his
suspension; and
(b) judicial proceedings shall be deemed to be
instituted,(i) in the case of criminal proceedings, on the date on
which the complaint or report of a Police Officer, of
which the Magistrate takes cognizance, is made; and
(ii) in the case of civil proceedings, on the date of
presentation of the plaint in the Court”.
4.7. It is accordingly contended that with quashing of the
impugned order dtd.18.03.2019 in all the three cases,
Opposite Parties be directed to extend all service and
financial benefits as due and admissible to the deceased
employee in favour of the Petitioner, who happens to be the
wife of the deceased employee with interest as deem fit and
proper.
5.
Mr. S.P. Das, learned Addl. Standing Counsel for the
State on the other hand made his submission basing on the
stand taken in the counter affidavit so filed in W.P.(C)
No.9689 of 2022. It is contended that all the three orders
passed on 18.03.2019 were the subject matter of challenge
in W.P.(C) No.9689 of 2022.
// 8 //
5.1. Learned ASC contended that since all the proceedings
were initiated against the deceased employee with serious
charges, because of the pendency of the proceedings, the
deceased employee was not sanctioned with the increment
as due and admissible on the revised scale of pay, and after
his retirement on 30.09.2010, Petitioner was sanctioned
with provisional pension only in terms of the provisions
contained under Rule-66 of the 1992 Rules. The wife of the
deceased employee / substituted Petitioner is getting the
provisional family pension after the death of the deceased
employee on 11.10.2023.
5.2. It is contended that since all the three proceedings
were initiated against the deceased employee with serious
charges, basing on the enquiry report so submitted by the
Enquiry Officer on 16.03.2019 under Annexure-C/4-Series,
the proceedings were disposed of with imposition of the
punishment
in
each
of
the
proceedings
vide
order
dtd.18.03.2019.
5.3. It is accordingly contended that taking into account
the seriousness of the charges and the enquiry report
submitted by the Enquiry Officer on dtd.16.03.2019, no
illegality or irregularity can be found with the impugned
orders so passed on dtd.18.03.2019 in all the three
proceedings.
6.
Having heard learned counsel appearing for the
Parties and considering the submissions made, this Court
finds that the deceased employee while in service, three
// 9 //
nos. of departmental proceeding were drawn up against
him under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 vide
Memorandums
dtd.13.01.1982,
03.01.1986
and
31.01.1991.
6.1. On the face of such initiation of the proceeding, as the
proceedings were not disposed of and the deceased
employee was not extended with the benefit of revised scale
of pay under different ORSP Rules, the deceased employee
approached the Tribunal by filing O.A Nos.2126, 2127 and
2128 of 2002.
The Tribunal vide order dtd.08.11.2002
under Annexures- 4 to 6, while disposing all the three
Original Applications directed Opposite Party No.4 to
dispose of the proceeding within a period of three (3)
months from the date of receipt of the order.
Pending
disposal of the proceedings, it was also directed to allow the
deceased employee to draw the minimum of the revised
scale of pay.
6.2. However, on the face of such order passed by the
Tribunal on 08.11.2002 under Annexures-4 to 6, all the
three proceedings were never disposed of till the deceased
employee retired on 30.09.2010.
However, after such
retirement of the deceased employee and without converting
the proceeding to a proceeding under Rule-7 of the 1992
Rules
basing
on
the
enquiry
report
submitted
on
16.03.2019, all the three proceedings were disposed of vide
the impugned order dtd.18.03.2019 in all the three Writ
Petitions.
// 10 //
6.3. This Court after going through the impugned order
dtd.18.03.2019 in all the three cases finds that, prior to
imposing such punishment, the deceased employee was
never issued with the 1st and 2nd show cause as provided
under Rule-15(10)(i)(a) & (b) of the 1962 Rules, nor the
proceeding was converted to a proceeding under Rule-7 of
the 1992 Rules.
6.4. In view of the aforesaid analysis and since statutory
provision contained under the 1962 Rules as well as 1992
Rules were never followed by Opposite Party No.4 prior to
disposal of all the three proceeding vide the impugned order
dtd.18.03.2019, this Court is inclined to quash order
dtd.18.03.2019 so passed by Opposite Party No.4 and
impugned in all the three cases.
While quashing the
impugned order dtd.18.03.2019 in all the three cases, this
Court directs Opposite Party No.4 to sanction and release
all the service benefits as due to the deceased employee
prior to his retirement and all the retiral dues as due and
admissible to the deceased employee in favour of the
present Petitioner, who happens to be the wife. This Court
directs Opposite Party No.4 to complete the entire exercise
within a period of four (4) months from the date of receipt of
this order.
6.5. However, it is observed that, if the order will not be
complied with, within the aforesaid time period, the
deceased employee will be held eligible and entitled to get
// 11 //
interest @ 6% per annum all through, on all the sums to be
held payable to the deceased employee.
7.
Accordingly, all the Writ Petitions stand disposed of.
8.
Photocopy of the order be placed in other connected
Writ Petitions.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Dated the 18th February, 2026/Subrat
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUBRAT KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 24-Feb-2026 11:52:59
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review