The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. In Narmada Bachao Andolan v. State of Madhya W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025 2025:KER:9634 Pradesh [(2011) 7 SCC 639] a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court held that, it is a settled proposition of law that a party has to plead its case and produce/adduce sufficient evidence to substantiate the averments made in the petition and in case the pleadings are not complete the Court is under no obligation to entertain the pleas. Pleadings and particulars are required to enable the court to decide the rights of the parties in the trial. Thus, the pleadings are more to help the court in narrowing the controversy involved and to inform the parties concerned to the question(s) in issue, so that the parties may adduce appropriate evidence on the said issue. It is settled legal proposition that as a rule relief not founded on the pleadings should not be granted. Therefore, a decision of a case cannot be based on grounds outside the pleadings of the parties. The object and purpose of pleadings and issues is to ensure that the litigants come to trial with all issues clearly defined and to prevent cases being expanded or grounds being shifted during trial. If any factual or legal issue, despite having merit, has not been raised by the parties, the court should not decide the same as the opposite counsel does not have a fair opportunity to answer the line of reasoning adopted in that regard. Such a judg…
11. Viewed in the light of the law laid down in the decisions referred to supra, conclusion is irresistible that, in the absence of proper pleadings and materials, the petitioner is not entitled to seek a writ of mandamus commanding the 3rd respondent Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Malabar Devaswom Board Audit, to initiate action based on the audit report for the year 2019-22 in respect of Sree Manappully Bhagavathi Temple. In the above circumstances, this writ petition is disposed of, taking note of the submission made by the learned counsel for the 2nd respondent Executive Officer that no temporary employees are presently working in Sree Manappully Bhagavathi Temple, which has already been reported to the 1 st respondent Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, on 20.01.2025, and that the vacancies in the temple, other than those occupied by permanent employees, will be filled up only after obtaining sanction from the 1st respondent Commissioner, after complying with the procedure prescribed in Circular No.J8/7347/ 2010/MDB dated 15.10.2010. The 1st respondent Commissioner shall proceed with the request, if any, made for filling up the W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025 2025:KER:9634 vacancies in the sanctioned posts in Sree Manappully Bhagavathi Temple, other than those occupied by permanent employees, strictly in accordance with law. Sd/- ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE Sd/MURALEE KR…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K. NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
THURSDAY, THE 6TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 17TH MAGHA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 736 OF 2025
PETITIONER:
S.V. HARIHARAN, AGED 64 YEARS
S/O. K.R. VENKATESWARA IYER, SUBRAMANIA MADOM, PARALI
VILLAGE, PARALI. P.O., PIN - 678612
BY ADVS.BEJOY JOSEPH P.J.
M.RAMESH CHANDER (SR.)
GOVIND G. NAIR
BALU TOM
BONNY BENNY
RESPONDENTS:
THE COMMISSIONER
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD, HOUSE FED COMPLEX, MINI
BYPASS, ERANHIPALAM, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673006
EXECUTIVE OFFICER, SREE MANAPPULLY BHAGAVATHI TEMPLE,
KIZHAKKE YAKKARA, PALAKKAD TALUK, PIN - 678701
*3
DEPUTY DIRECTOR, KERALA STATE AUDIT DEPARTMENT,
MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD AUDIT, REGIONAL OFFICE,
PALAKKAD-678 001
[THE AUDIT OFFICER – CORRECTED*
KERALA STATE AUDIT DEPARTMENT, MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD
ZONAL OFFICE, THIRUVANGAD, THALASSERY, KANNUR
DISTRICT, PINCODE, PIN – 670103]
THE DESCRIPTION OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT IS SUO MOTU
CORRECTED AS ABOVE AS PER ORDER DATED 06.02.2025 IN
THE WRIT PETITION
*ADDL.R4 MALABAR DEVASWOM BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, HOUSEFED COMPLEX,
ERANHIPPALAM P.O., CALICUT, PINCODE 673 006 IS
IMPLEADED AS ADDITIONAL R4 AS PER ORDER DATED
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
13.01.2025 IN IA 01/2025 IN THE WP(C)
R BY BY ADV K.MOHANAKANNAN
SMT. RENJANIE R, SC, MDB
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
06.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
JUDGMENT
Anil K. Narendran, J.
The petitioner, who is a devotee of Sree Manappully
Bhagavathi Temple, which is a controlled institution under the
additional 4th respondent Malabar Devaswom Board, has filed
this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
seeking a writ of mandamus commanding the 1st respondent
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, to take up Ext.P1
representation dated 14.11.2024 and initiate action forthwith
and to cancel the appointments of those temporary employees,
who have been appointed through the back door in Sree
Manappully Bhagavathi Temple. The petitioner has also sought
for a writ of mandamus commanding the 3rd respondent Deputy
Director, Kerala State Audit Department, Malabar Devaswom
Board Audit to initiate action based on the audit report for the
year 2019-22 with respect to the aforesaid temple.
2.
Going by the averments in the writ petition, the
grievance of the petitioner is that in violation of the statutory
orders
issued
by
the
Malabar
Devaswom
Board,
many
appointments are illegally made in Sree Manappully Bhagavathi
Temple, by the 2nd respondent Executive Officer, to the posts
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
which are not sanctioned by the Board. It is alleged that such
appointments are done totally in violation of the relevant
circulars issued by the Board and also the directions contained in
the judgments of this Court. After making those appointments
through the back door, without even calling for applications from
the public, thereby denying eligible persons the right to seek
employment, the appointees are allowed to continue for years
and now the attempt is to get orders from the Board to
regularise their appointment. Huge expenses are incurred by the
temple for paying salary to such employees. In the audit report
for the year 2019-22, it is specifically found that many persons
have got appointments in the temple illegally, and they are
continuing in the said posts. In the audit report, an objection is
also
raised
regarding
an
expenditure
to
the
tune
of
Rs.30,00,000/- towards salary of such illegal appointees and the
said expenditure has not been sanctioned by the State Audit.
3.
On 13.01.2025, when this writ petition came up for
admission, the learned Standing Counsel for Malabar Devaswom
Board took notice for the 1st respondent Commissioner and also
for the additional 4th respondent Board. The learned Senior
Government Pleader took notice for the 3rd respondent. This
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
Court issued urgent notice on admission by speed post to the 2nd
respondent Executive Officer, returnable within three weeks. The
learned Standing Counsel for the Board and the learned Senior
Government Pleader were directed to get instructions.
4.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
learned Standing Counsel for Malabar Devaswom Board for the
1st respondent and also for the additional 4th respondent, the
learned counsel for the 2nd respondent Executive Officer and also
the learned Senior Government Pleader for the 3rd respondent
Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit Department.
5.
During the course of arguments, the learned counsel
for the 2nd respondent Executive Officer would submit that no
temporary employees are presently working in Sree Manappully
Bhagavathi Temple, which has already been reported to the 1st
respondent
Commissioner,
Malabar
Devaswom
Board,
on
20.01.2025. The vacancies in the temple, other than those
occupied by permanent employees, will be filled up only after
obtaining sanction from the 1st respondent Commissioner, after
complying with the procedure prescribed in Circular No.J8/7347/
2010/MDB dated 15.10.2010.
6.
Another relief sought for in this writ petition is a writ
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
of mandamus commanding the 3
rd
respondent Deputy Director,
Kerala State Audit Department to initiate action based on the
audit report for the year 2019-22 with respect to Sree
Manappully Bhagavathi Temple.
7.
Other than Ext.P1 representation dated 14.11.2024
made by the petitioner before the 1st respondent Commissioner,
Malabar Devaswom Board, no documents are placed on record in
support of the aforesaid relief sought for against the 3rd
respondent Deputy Director. Not even a copy of the said audit
report for the year 2019-22, forms part of the pleadings in this
writ petition. Specific pleadings in support of that relief find no
place in the statement of facts.
8.
In Bharat Singh v. State of Haryana [(1988) 4
SCC 534] the Apex Court held that, when a point which is
ostensibly a point of law is required to be substantiated by facts,
the party raising the point, if he is the writ petitioner, must plead
and prove such facts by evidence which must appear from the
writ petition and if he is the respondent, from the counter
affidavit. If the facts are not pleaded or the evidence in support
of such facts is not annexed to the writ petition or to the counter
affidavit, as the case may be, the Court will not entertain the
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
point. The Apex Court held further that there is a distinction
between a pleading under the Code of Civil Procedure Code,
1908 and a writ petition or a counter affidavit. While in a
pleading, i.e., a plaint or a written statement, the facts and not
evidence are required to be pleaded, in a writ petition or in the
counter affidavit not only the facts but also the evidence in proof
of such facts have to be pleaded and annexed to it.
9.
In M/s.Larsen and Toubro Ltd. v. State of
Gujarat [(1998) 4 SCC 387] the Apex Court was dealing with
a case arising out of the proceedings initiated for the acquisition
of land for M/s.Larsen and Toubro Ltd. under the provisions of
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The Apex Court noticed that, in
the absence of any allegation that Rule 3 the Land Acquisition
(Companies) Rules, 1963 had not been complied and there being
no particulars in respect of non compliance of Rule 4 also, it is
difficult to see as to how the High Court could have reached the
finding that statutory requirements contained in these Rules
were not fulfilled before issuance of notification under Section 4
and declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act. High
Court did not give any reason as to how it reached the
conclusion that Rules 3 and 4 had not been complied in the face
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
of the record of the case. Rather, it returned a finding which is
unsustainable that it was "not possible on the basis of the
material on record to hold that there was compliance with Rules
3 and 4". The Apex Court held that, it is not enough to allege
that a particular Rule or any provision has not been complied. It
is a requirement of good pleading to give details, i.e., particulars
as to why it is alleged that there is non compliance with a
statutory requirement. Ordinarily, no notice can be taken on such
an allegation which is devoid of any particulars. No issue can be
raised on a plea, the foundation of which is lacking. Even where
rule nisi is issued, it is not always for the department to justify
its action when the court finds that a plea has been advanced
without any substance, though ordinarily department may have
to place its full cards before the court. On the facts of the case,
the Apex Court found that the State has more than justified its
stand that there has been compliance not only with Rule 4 but
with Rule 3 as well, though there was no challenge to Rule 3 and
the averments regarding non compliance with Rule 4 were
sketchy and without any particulars whatsoever. High Court was,
therefore, not right in quashing the acquisition proceedings.
10.
In Narmada Bachao Andolan v. State of Madhya
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
Pradesh [(2011) 7 SCC 639] a Three-Judge Bench of the Apex
Court held that, it is a settled proposition of law that a party has
to plead its case and produce/adduce sufficient evidence to
substantiate the averments made in the petition and in case the
pleadings are not complete the Court is under no obligation to
entertain the pleas. Pleadings and particulars are required to
enable the court to decide the rights of the parties in the trial.
Thus, the pleadings are more to help the court in narrowing the
controversy involved and to inform the parties concerned to the
question(s) in issue, so that the parties may adduce appropriate
evidence on the said issue. It is settled legal proposition that as
a rule relief not founded on the pleadings should not be granted.
Therefore, a decision of a case cannot be based on grounds
outside the pleadings of the parties. The object and purpose of
pleadings and issues is to ensure that the litigants come to trial
with all issues clearly defined and to prevent cases being
expanded or grounds being shifted during trial. If any factual or
legal issue, despite having merit, has not been raised by the
parties, the court should not decide the same as the opposite
counsel does not have a fair opportunity to answer the line of
reasoning adopted in that regard. Such a judgment may be
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
violative of the principles of natural justice.
11.
Viewed in the light of the law laid down in the
decisions referred to supra, conclusion is irresistible that, in the
absence of proper pleadings and materials, the petitioner is not
entitled to seek a writ of mandamus commanding the 3rd
respondent Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit Department,
Malabar Devaswom Board Audit, to initiate action based on the
audit report for the year 2019-22 in respect of Sree Manappully
Bhagavathi Temple.
In the above circumstances, this writ petition is disposed
of, taking note of the submission made by the learned counsel
for the 2nd respondent Executive Officer that no temporary
employees are presently working in Sree Manappully Bhagavathi
Temple, which has already been reported to the 1 st respondent
Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, on 20.01.2025, and
that the vacancies in the temple, other than those occupied by
permanent employees, will be filled up only after obtaining
sanction from the 1st respondent Commissioner, after complying
with the procedure prescribed in Circular No.J8/7347/ 2010/MDB
dated 15.10.2010. The 1st respondent Commissioner
shall
proceed with the request, if any, made for filling up the
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
vacancies in the sanctioned posts in Sree Manappully Bhagavathi
Temple, other than those occupied by permanent employees,
strictly in accordance with law.
Sd/-
ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
AV
W.P.(C)No.736 of 2025
2025:KER:9634
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 736/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED
14.11.2024 TO THE FIRST RESPONDENT WITHOUT
THE ENCLOSURES.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review