Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 30-09-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI
CRP Nos. 4715, 4716, 587 & 589 of 2026
CNR:{HCMA011532912026}
AND CMP NO. 27019 of 2026 and
CMP. Nos.10728, 10731, 20694, 20690,
3250 & 3245 of 206
CRP. No.4715 of 2026
1. S.Udhayakumar
S/o J.Shakthivel,
No.21,F2, Praneel Anoop Apartments,
5th street, East Banu Nagar,
Ambattur, Chennai- 600053.
2. L.Gunaseelan,
S/o R.Logananthan,
No.500, Anjaneyar Kovil St,
Arakkonam Tk, Ranipet Dt.
3. P.Vedanayagi
D/o Pushparaj,
No.143, Mosur Road,
Arakonam- 631 001.
4. P.Anna Mary
D/o Pushparaj,
No.143, Mosur Road,
Arakonam- 631 001,
Ranipet District.
5. K.Ravikumar
S/o K.Kuppa Naidu,
15/21, Nehruji Nagar 5th St,
Arakkonam- 631 003, Ranipet Dt.
6. M.Prashanthi
D/o Munusamy,
No.339(1) Raja St,
Thanigaipolur, Arakkonam - 631 003
__________
Page1 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
Ranipet District.
7. P.Olivannan,
S/o P.M.Panjatcharam,
M210A, TNHB Jothi Nagar,
Arakkonam- 631 003.
8. N.Saravanan,
S/o Narayanan,
MIG 2/11, TNHB,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
9. T.R.Sowmiya
W/o C.S.Sathish Prasad,
No.4, Balasubramani Kovil St,
Suvalpettai, Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
10.C.S.Sathish Prasad,
S/o Chandrasekaran,
No.4, Balasubramani Kovil St,
Suvalpettai, Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
11.P.Latha
W/o Purushothamman,
No.41/24, Town hall 3rd St,
Suvalpettai, Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
12.Deepa.L
No.316, 8th B Cross,
Flower Garden,
Bangaole North 560 023,
Magadi Road, Bangalore,
Karnataka State.
13.Premnaath Susila Munirathinam
S/o Munirathinam,
No.1, Neruji Nagar 5th St,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
14.K.Senthilkumar,
S/o Kirubanandam,
__________
Page2 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
No.5, Senthil Nagar,
Mangammapettai Gate,
Vadamambakkam,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
15.Lavanya
w/o Logesh,
No.22-696/5, Rajaji nagar,
Estate CK Palli Po,
Chittoor 517 001,
Andhra Pradesh
16.G.Kavitha
w/o Gopi
M-176, TNHB
Jothi Nagar Po,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
17.V.Devi
W/o Vedvyasan,
No.316, Bajanai Kovil St,
Kattupakkam 632 502,
Nimili Tk, Ranipet Dt.
18.B.S,Padma,
W/o Lingamoorthy,
No.133, sholinghar Road,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
19.Vadivel
S/o M.K.Vasantharayan
No.12-139, N.T.R.Nagar,
Pudupettai Nagari,
Chitoor- 517 590,
Andhra Pradesh.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. Maryrajam Irudayaraj,
W/o. Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
__________
Page3 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram,
Chennai - 600 023.
2. I.Immagulate Mary
D/o. Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram, Chennai - 600 023.
3. I.Victoria,
D/o. Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram, Chennai - 600 023.
4. T.R.Subramanian,
S/o. T.S.Ramalinga Mudaliar,
112, Gandhi Road,
Tiruttani,
Tiruvallur District.
J.D.Philamen Raj (died)
J.D.Xavier (died)
J.D.Vincent (died)
J.D.Josephine (died)
5. J.D.Margret Mary,
D/o Late J.Dyrianathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar, Arakkonam-7.
6. J.D.Alphonsa Mary,
D/o Late J.Dyriranathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar, Arakkonam-7.
..Respondent(s)
CRP No. 587 of 2026
CNR:{HCMA012950672025}
S. Nalina
W/o.T.Sundaramoorthy,
5/3, Milk Society Subramani Street,
Suvalpet -631 001,
__________
Page4 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
Arakkonam Taluk,
Ranipet District.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. J. D. Margret Mary,
D/o.late J.Dyrianathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar,
Arakkonam -631 003.
Vellore District.
2. J.D.Alphonsa Mary
D/o.late J.Dyrianathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar,
Arakkonam -631 003.
Vellore District.
3. T.R.Subramanian
S/o.T.S.Ramalinga Mudaliar,
1123, Gandhi Road,
Tiruttani,
Tiruvallur District -631 209.
..Respondent(s)
CRP No. 589 of 2026
CNR:{HCMA012950682025}
S. Nalina
W/o.T.Sundaramoorthy,
5/3, Milk Society Subramani Street,
Suvalpet -631 001,
Arakkonam Taluk,
Ranipet District.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
__________
Page5 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
1. Maryrajam Irudayaraj,
W/o.Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
Residing at
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram,
Chennai -600 023.
2. I.Immagulate Mary,
D/o.Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
Residing at
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram, Chennai -600 023.
3. I.Victoria,
D/o.late J.D.Irudayaraj,
Residing at
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram, Chennai -600 023.
4. T.R.Subramanian,
S/o.T.S.Ramalinga Mudaliar,
1123, Gandhi Road,
Tiruttani, Tiruvallur District -631 209.
J.D.Philamen Raj(Died)
J.D.Xavier (Died)
J.D.Vincent(Died)
J.D.Josephine(Died)
5. J.D.Margret Mary,
D/o.late J.Dyrianathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar,
Arakkonam -631 003.
Vellore District.
6. J.D.Alphonsa Mary,
D/o.late J.Dyrianathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar, Arakkonam -631 003.
Vellore District.
... Respondents
__________
Page6 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
CRP No. 4716 of 2026
CNR:{HCMA011532922026}
1. S. Udhayakumar
S/o J.Sakthivel,
No.21,F2,
Praneel Anoop Apartments,
5th street,
East Banu Nagar,
Ambattur,
Chennai- 600053.
2. L.Gunaseelan,
S/o R.Logananthan,
No.500, Anjaneyar Kovil St,
Arakkonam Tk, Ranipet Dt.
3. P.Vedanayagi
D/o Pushparaj,
No.143, Mosur Road,
Arakonam- 631 001.
4. P.Anna Mary
D/o Pushparaj,
No.143, Mosur Road,
Arakonam- 631 001,
Ranipet District.
5. K.Ravikumar
S/o K.Kuppa Naidu,
15/21, Nehruji Nagar 5th St,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt,
6. M.Prashanthi
D/o Munusamy,
No.339(1) Raja St,
Thanigaipolur,
Arakkonam - 631 003
Ranipet District.
7. P.Olivannan,
S/o P.M.Panjatcharam,
__________
Page7 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
M210A, TNHB Jothi Nagar,
Arakkonam- 631 003.
8. N.Saravanan,
S/o Narayanan,
MIG 2/11, TNHB,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
9. T.R.Sowmiya
W/o C.S.Sathish Prasad,
No.4, Balasubramani Kovil St,
Suvalpettai, Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
10.C.S.Sathish Prasad,
S/o Chandrasekaran,
No.4, Balasubramani Kovil St,
Suvalpettai, Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
11.P.Latha
W/o Purushothamman,
No.41/24, Town hass 3rd St,
Suvalpettai,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
12.Deepa.L
No.316, 8th B Cross,
Flower Garden,
Bangalore North 560 023,
Magadi Road,
Bangalore, Karnataka State.
13.Premnaath Susila Munirathinam
S/o Munirathinam,
No.1, Neruji Nagar 5th St,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
14.K.Senthilkumar,
S/o Kirubanandam,
No.5, Senthil Nagar,
__________
Page8 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
Mangammapettai Gate,
Vadamambakkam,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
15.Lavanya
w/o Logesh,
No.22-696/5, Rajaji nagar,
Estate CK Palli Po,
Chittoor 517 001,
Andhra Pradesh
16.G.Kavitha
w/o Gopi
M-176, TNHB
Jothi Nagar Po,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
17.V.Devi
W/o Vedvyasan,
No.316, Bajanai Kovil St,
Kattupakkam 632 502,
Nimili Tk, Ranipet Dt.
18.B.S,Padma,
W/o Lingamoorthy,
No.133, sholinghar Road,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
19.Vadivel
S/o M.K.Vasantharayan
No.12-139, N.T.R.Nagar,
Pudupettai Nagari,
Chitoor- 517 590,
Andhra Pradesh.
... Petitioners
Vs
1. J. D. Margret Mary
D/o Late J.Dyrianathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
__________
Page9 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
Jothi Nagar,
Arakkonam-7.
2. J.D.Alphonsa Mary,
D/o Late J.Dyriranathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar,Arakkonam-7.
3. T.R.Subramanian
S/o T.S.Ramalinga Mudaliar,
112, Gandhi Road,
Tiruttani, Tiruvallur Dt.
.. Respondents
CMP No. 27019 of 2026
I. Victoria,
D/o. Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram,
Chennai - 600 023.
... Petitioner
Vs
1. S. Udhayakumar
S/o J.Shakthivel,
No.21,F2,
Praneel Anoop Apartments,
5th street, East Banu Nagar,
Ambattur, Chennai- 600053.
2. L.Gunaseelan
S/o R.Logananthan,
No.500, Anjaneyar Kovil St,
Arakkonam Tk,Ranipet Dt.
3. P.Vedanayagi
D/o Pushparaj,
No.143, Mosur Road,
Arakonam- 631 001.
4. P.Anna Mary
D/o Pushparaj,
No.143, Mosur Road,
__________
Page10 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
Arakonam- 631 001,
Ranipet District.
5. K.Ravikumar
S/o K.Kuppa Naidu,
15/21, Nehruji Nagar 5th St,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt,
6. M.Pranshanthi
D/o Munusamy,
No.339(1) Raja St,
Thanigaipolur,
Arakkonam - 631 003
Ranipet District.
7. P.Olivannan
S/o P.M.Panjatcharam,
M210A, TNHB Jothi Nagar,
Arakkonam- 631 003.
8. N.Saravanan,
S/o Narayanan,
MIG 2/11, TNHB,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
9. T.R.Sowmiya
W/o C.S.Sathish Prasad,
No.4, Balasubramani Kovil St,
Suvalpettai, Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
10.C.S.Sathish Prasad,
S/o Chandrasekaran,
No.4, Balasubramani Kovil St,
Suvalpettai, Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
11.P.Latha
W/o Purushothamman,
No.41/24, Town hass 3rd St,
Suvalpettai,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
__________
Page11 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
12.Deepa.L
No.316, 8th B Cross,
Flower Garden,
Bangalore North 560 023,
Magadi Road,
Bangalore, Karnataka State.
13.Premnaath Susila Munirathinam
S/o Munirathinam,
No.1, Neruji Nagar 5th St,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
14.K.Senthilkumar,
S/o Kirubanandam,
No.5, Senthil Nagar,
Mangammapettai Gate,
Vadamambakkam,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
15.Lavanya
w/o Logesh,
No.22-696/5, Rajaji nagar,
Estate CK Palli Po,
Chittoor 517 001,
Andhra Pradesh
16.G.Kavitha
w/o Gopi
M-176, TNHB
Jothi Nagar Po,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
17.V.Devi
W/o Vedvyasan,
No.316, Bajanai Kovil St,
Kattupakkam 632 502,
Nimili Tk, Ranipet Dt.
18.B.S,Padma,
W/o Lingamoorthy,
__________
Page12 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
No.133, sholinghar Road,
Arakkonam- 631 003,
Ranipet Dt.
19.Vadivel
S/o M.K.Vasantharayan
No.12-139, N.T.R.Nagar,
Pudupettai Nagari,
Chitoor- 517 590,
Andhra Pradesh.
20. Maryrajam Irudayaraj,
W/o. Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram, Chennai - 600 023.
21. I.Immagulate Mary
D/o. Late J.D.Irudayaraj,
24/2, Somasundaram 6th Street,
Ayanavaram, Chennai - 600 023.
22. T.R.Subramanian,
S/o. T.S.Ramalinga Mudaliar,
112, Gandhi Road,
Tiruttani, Tiruvallur District.
23. J.D.Margret Mary,
D/o Late J.Dyrianathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar, Arakkonam-7.
24. J.D.Alphonsa Mary,
D/o Late J.Dyriranathan,
M11/15, TNHB,
Jothi Nagar, Arakkonam-7. .. Respondents
__________
Page13 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
RAYER in CRP No. 4715 of 2026: This Civil Revision Petition is filed under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, to set aside the order dated 25.08.2025
made in I.A.No.12 of 2025 in O.S.No.158 of 2024 on the file of the learned
Second Additional District and Sessions Court, Arakonam.
PRAYER in CRP No. 4716 of 2026: This Civil Revision Petition is filed under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, to set aside the petition and order dated
19.03.2025 made in I.A.No.4 of 2025 in O.S.No.158 of 2024 on the file of the
learned Second Additional District and Sessions Court, Arakonam by allowing
this Civil Revision Petition.
CRP No. 587 of 2026:This Civil Revision Petition is filed under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India, to set aside the petition and order dated 19.03.2025
made in IA No.4 of 2025 in OS No.158 of 2024 on the file of the learned
Second Additional District and Sessions Court, Arakkonam by allowing this
Civil Revision Petition.
CRP No. 589 of 2026: This Civil Revision Petition is filed under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India, to set aside the fair order dated 25.08.2025 made in IA
No.12 of 2025 in OS No.158 of 2024 on the file of the
learned Second
Additional District and Sessions Court, Arakkonam.
CMP No. 27019 of 2026: This Civil Miscellaneous Petition is filed under
Section 340 CR.P.C. read with 195 Cr.P.C., to expedite criminal proceedings by
directing a preliminary inquiry into the offences committed by Respondent
No.22/4, T.R.Subramanian, the Petitioner, and their associates in OS No.158 of
2024 (formerly OS No.47 of 2015) pending before the II Additional District
and Sessions Court, Arakkonam, file a written complaint before the competent
Magistrate.
__________
Page14 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
For Petitioner(s):
For Respondent(s):
Mr.N.Manoharan
in all CRPs
Rajeni Ramadass for
M/s.Rajeni Associates for R1 and R2
Mr.P.Raja for R5 and R6
in CRP. Nos.4715 & 589 of 2026
for R1 & R2 in CRP. Nos.4716 & 587 of 2026
I.Victoria (Party in person ) (R3)
in CRP. No.4715 & 587 of 2026
COMMON ORDER
These revision petitions are at the instance of the third party seeking the
following reliefs:-
(i) CRP. No.587 of 2026: Challenging the order passed in I.A. No.4 of
2025, in O.S. No.158 of 2024, dated 19.03.2025 on the file of the II Additional
District and Sessions Judge, Arakonam, in and by which the Trial Court had
allowed the prayers sought for by the defendants 6 and 7, to cancel the sale deed
dated 07.01.2011, in Doc. No.2120 of 2011, executed by the Court in E.P.
No.66 of 2016.
(ii) CRP. No.589 of 2026- to set aside the order passed in I.A. No.12 of
2025, in O.S. No.158 of 2024 on the file of the II Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Arakonam, in and by which, the Trial Court has entertained and
__________
Page15 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
allowed the Application filed by the defendants 8 to 10, seeking to cancel all
registered instruments executed pursuant to sale deed dated 23.08.2017.
(iii) Similarly, other third parties have filed CRP. No.4715 and 4716 of
2026 for the very same reliefs, on the same grounds on which CRP. Nos.587
and 589 of 2026 have been filed.
(iv) As far as CMP. No.27019 of 2026, it has been filed to expedite
criminal proceedings by directing a preliminary inquiry into the offences
committed by Respondent No.22/4, T.R.Subramanian, the Petitioner, and their
associates in OS No.158 of 2024 (formerly OS No.47 of 2015) pending before
the II Additional District and Sessions Court, Arakkonam, file a written
complaint before the competent Magistrate.
2. I have heard Mr.N.Manoharan, learned counsel revision petitioners in
all the revision petitions, Mrs.Rajeni Ramadoss, learned counsel for M/s.Rajeni
Associates for the respondents 1 and 2, Mrs.I.Victoria, Party in Person/third
respondent and Mr.P.Raja, learned counsel for the respondents 5 and 6.
__________
Page16 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
3. Mr.N.Manoharan, learned counsel for the petitioners in all the revision
petitions, would firstly contend that the Trial Court has committed a grave error,
resulting in miscarriage of justice, by setting aside the registered sale deed,
without even given an opportunity of hearing to the aggrieved party, viz., the
revision petitioners who are admittedly purchasers of portions of the suit
property, for valuable sale consideration. The learned counsel for the petitioners
would further contend that pursuant to their respective purchasers, the
petitioners also put up construction and emphasises the fact that such
construction cannot come up overnight and the respondents were fully aware of
the factum of physical possession being with third party purchasers and despite
the same, no effective steps were taken to challenge the sale deeds in favour of
the revision petitioners, before the Competent Civil Court.
4.Mr.N.Manoharan, learned counsel for the petitioners would also state
that even the encumbrance certificate clearly discloses the alienations made in
favour of the revision petitioners and behind their back, the respondents have
mischievously and fraudulently obtained orders, annulling their sale deeds,
which is clearly violative of the principles of natural justice and fair hearing. In
support of his submission, the learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the
__________
Page17 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
following decisions:(i) Kranti Associates Private Limited and Another Vs.
Masood Ahmed Khan and Others, reported in (2010) 9 SCC
496;
(ii) Binayak Swain Vs. Ramesh Chandra Panigrahi and
Another, reported in 1965 SCC Online SC 350;
(iii) Chinnammal and others Vs. P.Arumugham and
Another, reported in (1990) 1 SCC 513;
(iv) Narendra Kumar Srivastava Vs. State of Bihar and
Others, reported in (2019) 3 SCC 318; and
(v) Amarsang Nathaji as Himself and as Karta and
Manger Vs. Hardik Harshadbhai Patel and others, reported
in (2017) 1 SCC 113.
5. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents and also
the third respondent in person, would state that the petitioners are not bonafide
purchasers and they have purchased plots pursuant to an exparte decree
obtained in a suit for specific performance. According to the third respondent as
well as the learned counsel for the other respondents, the suit itself was filed
against the dead persons, without bringing to the notice of the Court that the
defendants were not alive on the date of the institution of the suit and therefore,
the decree for specific performance is clearly vitiated and null and void and not
__________
Page18 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
binding on the lawful owners, viz., the respondents. The third respondent, as
well as the other counsel appearing for the respondents would also bring to my
notice that the third defendant also died soon after the decree came to be passed
and therefore, according to the respondents, the predecessor in interest of the
petitioners has played fraud and snatched away the valuable properties
belonging to the respondents and therefore,
there is absolutely no error
committed by the Trial Court in passing orders in I.A. Nos.4 and 12 of 2025. It
is also contended by the learned counsel for the respondents that the petitioners
cannot claim to be bonafide purchasers, since they should have verified whether
the decree had been passed against living persons and therefore, today they
cannot claim any right in equity. Therefore, they pray for dismissal of all the
four revision petitions.
6. I have carefully considered the submissions advanced by the learned
counsel on either side and also perused the available material records.
7. Insofar as CMP. No.27019 of 2026, the third respondent in person,
states that permission has to be sanctioned to her to prosecute the respondents
under Section 340 of the Cr.P.C., read with Section 195 of Cr.P.C., since the
__________
Page19 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
respondents have all committed perjury and the matter has to be therefore
necessarily tried before the Judicial Magistrate. Meeting the relief sought for in
this CMP, Mr.N.Manoharan, learned counsel for the revision petitioners would
bring to my notice that for the very same prayer, an Application in I.A. No.28 of
2026, is pending before the Trial Court and therefore, contends that the relief
sought for in this application cannot be entertained. As the respondents have
already moved the Trial Court, for initiating Criminal Proceedings, by way of
perjury against the respondents and the said application is pending enquiry, it is
not proper on the part of the third respondent to seek the very same prayer by
filing the application in the pending revision petitions. It is always open to the
third respondent, or the petitioners who have filed the said application in I.A.
No.28 of 2026, to prosecute the same and bring it to a logical conclusion. In the
light of the above, I do not see any merit or even any purpose in entertaining
CMP. No.27019 of 2026, and the same is dismissed.
8. As far as the revision petitions are concerned, the vendor of the
revision petitioners obtained an exparte decree on 17.11.2015 and thereafter, he
has sold portions of the suit property to various third party purchasers for
consideration. 20 amongst the said purchasers are the revision petitioners
__________
Page20 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
herein. The case of the revision petitioners is that they are bonafide purchasers
for value and their vendor had been the beneficiary of registered sale deed
executed by the competent Civil Court in his favour and therefore, there is
absolutely no occasion for the petitioners who doubt the decree in favour of the
vendor, necessitating any conduct of any roving investigation or enquiry.
Mr.N.Manoharan, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the in all
fairness, the purchasers should have been proceeded against and that the reliefs
granted in I.A. Nos. 4 and 12 of 2025 ought to have been granted only after
issuing notice to the petitioners and in their presence
9. I find considerable force in the arguments of Mr.Manoharan, learned
counsel for the revision petitioners. All the petitioners are subsequent
transferees, post a decree for specific performance, pursuant to which, a sale
deed has been executed in favour of the vendor of the revision petitioners. It
may be the case of the respondents that the agreement of sale in favour of the
vendor of the petitioners itself was fraudulent in nature and not capable of
specifically being enforced. However, they do not dispute the fact that the
specific performance suit filed by the vendor of the petitioner by name,
T.R.Subramaniam, was decreed on 17.11.2025 and an Application was taken
__________
Page21 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
out by the 5th defendant to set aside the exparte decree in an application to
condone a delay of 1416 days in filing the application to set aside the exparte
decree. The said application came to be allowed, despite the objection of the
first respondent/plaintiff therein viz., the vendor of the petitioner and the delay
was condoned by an order dated 07.09.2023. Much later, on 15.07.2025, it also
appears that subsequently, suit has been restored to file and thereby the exparte
decree for specific performance itself has been set aside. However, the Court
ought to have taken note of the fact that between the time the exparte decree
was passed and was in force and till such time, it was set aside, since several
alienations had taken place, such alienation cannot be annulled or set aside for
the mere asking.
10. The Trial Court should have put on notice and called upon, all the
purchasers who have purchased portions of the suit property, between the date
of decree and the date of setting aside the exparte decree. Without doing so,
unfortunately, the Trial Court has allowed applications I.A. No.4 of 2025, and
I.A. No.12 of 2025, accepting the arguments of the learned counsel for the
respondents, without noticing that serious prejudice would be caused to
bonafide purchasers, including the revision petitioners, who have invested their
__________
Page22 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
hard earned savings especially when they have purchased their respective
portions after the decree for specific performance. This cannot strightaway
annul the sale deeds, without giving them a fair and reasonable opportunity.
11. In view of the above, the Trial Court has clearly committed an error in
allowing I.A. Nos.4 and 12 of 2025, and thereby cancelling the various sale
deeds, behind the back of the interested, proper and necessary parties. Even
though, as rightly contended by the respondents, the plaintiff in the suit for
specific performance has not come forward to contest the application filed to
cancel the sale deed, having already alienated the entire suit property to various
third party purchasers, it is quite natural and understandable that the plaintiff in
the specific performance suit may have lost interest to pursue the litigation,
since he has already disposed of the property. The decree has been set aside
only after a huge delay of about 1404 days, in even filing the application to set
aside the exparte decree. In such circumstances, the orders in I.A. Nos.4 and 12
of 2025 are necessarily to be set aide and the petitioners shall be impleaded as
respondents in the said Application and they shall be given an opportunity of
hearing including filing of counter and after conducting due enquiry, the learned
II Additional District and Sessions Judge, Arakkonam, Ranipet District shall
__________
Page23 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
dispose of the Applications in I.A. Nos.4 and 12 of 2025 afresh, considering the
oral and documentary evidence, that may be adduced on behalf of both the
parties. The learned II Additional District and Sessions Judge, shall endeaver to
pass final orders in both Applications on or before 30.04.2027, on merits and in
accordance with law.
12. Though several judgments have been cited by Mr.N.Manoharan, I
have no quarrel with regard to the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in all the said cases where it has been repeatedly reiterated that the
principles of natural justice have to be followed and reasons have to be recorded
before passing orders. In any event, I am in entire agreement with the arguments
of Mr.N.Manoharan, learned counsel for the petitioners that the Trial Court
clearly committed a grave error in proceedings to set aside the sale deeds
without even putting the purchasers from notice.
13. Though the plaintiff in the suit for specific performance challenging
the order condoning the delay filed in CRP. No.4840 of 2023, the revision came
to be dismissed and the Trial Court was directed to dispose of the suit within a
period of four months. Admittedly, subsequently, though the exparte decree was
__________
Page24 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
set aside, till date, the suit is still pending and pending the suit, these
interlocutory applications came to be filed and disposed of. In the light of the
above, in order to do substantial justice to the parties and also give a quietus to
the entire lis, while allowing the revision, I direct the petitioners to be permitted
to be impleaded as the plaintiffs, since the Plaintiff T.R.Subramaniam, who no
longer has any subsisting interest in the suit property, is not any way going to
contest the suit, which would only result in dismissal of the suit for non
prosecution. However, as purchasers not only bonafide, but also their purchases
being lawful on the date of the respective purchases made by the petitioners,
since on the date of their respective sale deeds, the decree for specific
performance was intact, I permit the plaintiffs/all the revision petitioners to
come on record and step into the shoes of the original plaintiff,
T.R.Subramanian and prosecute the suit on his behalf. It is however made clear
that the petitioners shall not be permitted to seek for any amendment of the
plaint and they shall have to stand or fall by the case of their vendor, the
plaintiffs, since they are bound by the actions, inactions or omissions of their
vendor.
__________
Page25 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
14. In the light of the above, the Civil Revision Petitions are allowed and
the orders dated 25.08.2025 & 19.03.2025 in I.A. Nos.4 and 12 of 2025 are set
aside and the learned counsel for the revision petitioners before the Trial Court
shall be permitted to amend the plaint, by impleading the revision petitioners as
plaintiffs 2 to 20. It is also seen from the records that there is no written
statement filed by the defendants, excepting for their applications for
condonation of delay and to set aside the exparte decree. Therefore, the
defendants shall be entitled to file written statement within a period of three (3)
weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of the amended plaint and the newly
impleaded purchasers from the original plaintiff, T.R.Subramanian, shall be
entitled to file a reply statement within a period of two weeks thereafter. The
Trial Court shall frame issues within a period of one (1) week and shall
commence trial without any delay. The parties shall cooperate for expeditious
trial of the suit and the suit shall be disposed of on merits, and in accordance
with law on or before 30.04.2027. The Trial Court shall not insist on any formal
application for impleadment or amendment of the plaint and in view of the
order, the revision petitioners can straight away be permitted to carry out the
amendments to the plaint and filed an amended copy of the plaint, within a
period of two (2) weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
__________
Page26 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
15. In the light of the above, these Civil Revision Petitions are allowed.
CMP is dismissed. No costs.
30-09-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
RKP
To
The II Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Arakonam.
__________
Page27 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
P.B.BALAJI J.
RKP
CRP No. 4715 of 2026
AND
CMP NO. 10728 OF 2026,CMP NO. 10731 OF 2026,CRP NO. 4716 OF
2026,CMP NO. 20694 OF 2026,CMP NO. 20690 OF 2026,CMP NO. 27019
OF 2026,CRP NO. 587 OF 2026,CRP NO. 589 OF 2026,CMP NO. 3250 OF
2026,CMP NO. 3245 OF 2026
30-09-2026
__________
Page28 of 28
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review