Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
L
[ 34481
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST,DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2853 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 ot lhe Constitution of lndia, aggrieved by the
Order dated: 11.01 .2023 in l.A.No. 295 ol 2022 in OS No. 4083 of 2021 on the file
of the Court of the XX Junior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad.
Between:
1. S. Lalitha. W/o. Late. S. Bikshapathi Goud, Aged 50 years, Occ: General
Secretary'and Correspondent of St. Maria Education Sodiety, Sole Proprietor
and Owner of M/s. St. Maria High School, 18-84'12/A St. Maria High, School,
Uppuguda, Hyderabad
PETITIONERYDEFENDANT No.3
2. St. Maria Educational Society, Uppuguda, Hyderabad, Rep. by its President
and Correspondent S. Soujanya, D/o. Late, S. Bikshapathi Goud, Occ:
Practicing Advocate, R/o. 1B-B-4'13/tu1 Uppuguda, Hyderabad
3. S. Soujanya, D/o. Late S, Bikshapathi Goud, President and Correspondent in
St. Maria Educational Society, Uppuguda, Hyderabad, Occ: Practicing
Advocate, R/o. 1B-8-413/fu1 Uppuguda, Hyderabad.
4. V.Ganesh Goud, S/o V- Ramulu Goud, representing as Member of St. Maria
Educational Society, Occ: Business, R/o. 23-5-904 Bela X Road, Sudha
Theater, Hari Bowli, Hyderabad.
5. Barla Srinivasa Rao, S/o. B. Narasimha, representing as Member of St Maria
Educational Society, Occ: Business, R/o. 18-8-4121A10 Uppuguda,
Hyderabad
6. Jhansi Rani, D/o. Venkatesham Goud, representing as Member of St. Maria
E{ucational Society, Occ: Business, R/o. 18-3-463, Rajanna Bowli,
Hyderabad.
7. V. Renuka Goud, Wo. V.Ganesh Goud, representing as Member of St. Maria
Educational Society, Occ: Business, R/o. 23-5-904 Bela X Road, Sudha
Theater, Hari Bowli, Hyderabad.
8. K. Naraimha, S/o. Pullaiah, representing as Member of St Maria Educational
Society, Occ: Business, R/o. 53, Road No. 5, Lecturers Colony, Hayathnagar,
Ranga Reddy Dist.
(Petitioner No.1 GPA Holder on behalf of Petitioner No.4 to B)
...PETITIONERS/DEFENDANTS No.1,2 & 4 to I
AND
'l S. Sai Ramana Goud, S/o. Late S. Bikshapathi Goud, R/o. 10- 1- 10211117
Bhagnaga Colony, Karmanghat, Hyderabad.
RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF
2. The District Educational Officer, Occ: Govt. Employee, Hyderabad Dist.,
Nampally, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT/
|.A.NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under order Vl Rule 14-A of CPC., praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
may be pleased to direct the respondenVplaintiff to forthwith furnish his correct
address and also impose exemplary costs for not furnishing the correct address
while filing the suit before the trial court.
lA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section'151 CPC., praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay all further proceedings in OS No. 4083 of 2021 pending before the Hon'ble
Court of the XX Junior Civil Judge, City Civil Court. pending disposal of the CRP.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri. P V Krishnaiah
Counsel for the Respondents: Sri. Yogeshwar Raj Saxena
The Court made the following: ORDER
;
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OT TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CTVIL REVISION PETITION.NO.28s3 OF 2023
DATED: 21* JANUARY, 2026
l
BETWEEN:
S.Lalitha, W/o.Late S.Bikshapathi Goud and Others
... Petitioners/Defendants
AND
S.Sai Ramana Goud, S/o.Late S.Bikshapathi Goud,
R/o.1O- 1- 102 III17,Bhagnaga Colony,
Karmanghat, Hyderabad.
... Respondent/ Plaintiff
The District Educational Officer,
Occ: Govt. Employee, Hyderabad Dist.,
Nampally, Hyderabad.
...
Respondent/ Defendant No.9
ORDER
1.
This Memorandum of Civil Revision Petition is filed under
Arttcle 227 of the Constitution of India assailing the order passed
by the learned XX Junior Civil Judge, City Civil Court at
zlro
BRMR,J
cRP_2a53 2023
\
Hyderabad in IA.No.295 of 2022 in OS.No.4083 of 202 1, dated
lt.or_2023
2.
Petitioners are the defendant Nos. 1 to 8. Respondent No.l is
the respondent No.1-plaintiff and respondent No.2 is defendant
No.9 in IA No.295 of 2022 in OS.No.4083 of 2O2L.
3.1. Petitione;- No.1 has sworn the afhdavit in IA.No.295 of 2022
on her behalf and also on behalf of other petitioners-defendant
Nos.1, 2, 4 to 8
3.2. It is stated in the aflidavit that respondent No. l-plaintiff is
her son, he frled the suit on behalf of her deceased husbandS.Bikshapathi Goud. Bikshapathi Goud has filed suit in OS No.5O
of 2079 on the file of VII Senior Civil Judge against petitioner No. I
for eviction admitting that she is the General Secretary and
Correspondent of suit schedule school.. When respondent No.1-
plaintiff was never in possession of the property at any point of
time, he cannot seek any relief. Plaint establishes that she is in
actual possession of the suit schedule schooi and that respondent
No. l-plaintiff has no title, right, interest and she has purchased
the school in the year 1996, she is in exclusive possession of the
same, one person should not be bothered twice for the same relief.
But unfortunately, petitioner No. l-defendant No.3 has been vexed
-/
I
J-
BRMR,J
cRP_2853_2023
thrice. Respondent No. l-plaintiff and S.Bikshapathi have hled suit
in OS No.661 of 2Ol7 for perpetual injunction against petitioner
No.1 before XX Junior Civil Judge, City Civil Court at Hyderabad.
In the said suit, petitioner No. l-defendant No.3 was shown as
housewife and now in the present suit i.e., OS No.4083 of 2021 she
is shown as a Teacher and the suit is hit by Order 2 Rule 2 of CPC
and there is no cause of action to file the suit and the same is
barred by law.
3.3. Petitioner No.l-defendant No.3 husband by
name
S.Bikshapathi died on 14.05.2021 leaving behind herself, two
daughters by names S.Saujanya, S.Thejasvi and one son by name
S.Sai Ramana (respondent No. 1-plaintiff). Respondent No.1plaintiff is showing the petitioner No.1-defendant No.3 on behalf of
her deceased husband-S.Bikshapathi which is barred by law and
he has no locus standi to file the suit and prayed to reject the
plaint.
.
Respondent No. l-piaintiff has frled his counter and
contended that the suit is filed seeking relief to declare him as
absolute owner and possessor of suit schedule school as owner
and possessor ald the reliefs prayed in the suit with that of suit in
OS.No.50 of 2019 and suit in OS No.661 of 2017 are quite different
4lto
BRMR,J
cRP,2853-2023
\
and it has no similarity, it is not hit by Order 2 Rule 2 of CPC and
prayed to dismiss the same.
5.
The learnecl trial Court after going through the material on
record observed that "three suits are frled for different reliefs and
under different cause of action, whether the doctrine of estoppel is
applicable to the present suit can be adjudicated after full-fledged
trial", ultimately dismissed IA.No.295 of 2022.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the order of
the learned trial Court is perverse and has committed error in
rejecting IA No.295 of 2022 and the learned trial Court has not
properly appreciated the contentions of the petitioners in proper
prospective and passed an erroneous order and failed to note that
the suit frled by respondent No. l-plaintiff is hit by Order 2 Rule 2
of CPC and the plaint does not disclose a cause of action and is
barred by law. Counsel to substantiate her contention has relied
on the decisions in the cases of (1) T.Arivandandam Vs.
T.V.Satyapal and Anotherr, (2) Pandurang Vithal Kevne Vs. Bharat
Sanchar Nigam Limited and Another2.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has not pressed the relief
in respect of CMASR No.72497 of 2023 on 18.09.2025.
J (dp77) 4 scc 467
I 2024 SCC Online SC 4108
slt0
BRMR,J
cRP_2E53,2023
I
8.
Learned counsel for respondent No. l-plaintiff submits that
the learned trial Court has properly appreciated the facts of the
case and rightly dismissed the petition filed by the petitioners for
rejection of the plaint. Counsel to substantiate his contention has
relied on the decision in the case of Srihari Hanumandas Totala
Vs. Hemant Vithal Kamat and Others3.
9.
1. Respondent No.l-plaintiffs counsel has hled Memo in USR
No.i02518 and enclosed copy of the judgment and decree in
OS No.661 ot2017, dated 11.O9.2023.
9.2. It is apt to note here that in rejection of plaint, the averments
of the plaint plays an important role while deciding the matter.
Hence, the Memo filed by respondent No. l-plaintiff cannot be
looked into at this stage.
10. Heard learned counsel on record, perused the material.
1I
.
Now the point for consideration is : Whether the order
passed by the learned trial Court suffers from any perversity or
illegality? If so, does it require interference of this Court?
I Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/62758350/
6/ro
BRMR,J
cRP 2853_2023
I
.J
12- The main contention of the petitioners is that the suit is hit
by Order 2 Rule 2 of CPC and there is no cause of action and the
same is barred by law.
13. Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 deals
with suit to include the whole claim which the plaintiff is entitled
to make in respect of the cause of action and the plaintiff may
relinquish any portion of his claim in order to bring the suit within
the jurisdiction of any Court.
14. Order 7 deals ivith plaint and Rule 11 deals with rejection of
plaint. The plaint shall be rejected (a) when it does not disclose
cause of action (d) where the suit appears from the statement in
the plaint to be barred by any law.
15. Respondent No. l-plaintiff has filed suit in OS No.4O83 of
2021 against the petitioners-defendants. and against respondent
No.2-defendant No.9 under Section 26, Order 7 Rule I and 2 of
CPC. The relief claimed in the suit is to declare the plaintiff
(respondent No. t herein) is the absolute owner and possessor of
suit schedule school and for grant of perpetual injunction
restrlining the defendants (petitioners herein), ttreir agents,
workman, henchman from interfering into his peaceful possession
and enjoyment and for relief of mandatory injunction directing the
-"/
a
7lr0
BRMR,J
cRP_2853_2023
petitioners-defendant Nos. 1 to 8 to remit and render ali the school
fees, funds and arrears with the plaintiff.
I
i6.1. The plaint averments goes to show that on 10.O9.2018 while
they were receiving documents from the defendants therein in a
suit for perpetual injunction in OS No.661 of 2077 on the file of
XXVIII Junior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, during that
time the plaintiffs father was bedridden arrd it was informed that
there is a change of Members and Executive Committee Members
of St.Maria Educational Society by defendant Nos.2 and 3 in the
suit uide document dated May, 2018 and the defendant Nos. 1 to 8
(petitioners herein) were shown as Members/Executive Committee
from 3 1.O3.2018 onwards. The plaint further states that defendant
No.3 (petitioner No.l herein) was a Teacher in the school which
was owned and possessed by the plaintiffs father and she used to
draw a salary of Rs. 15O/- per month under Mariamma's
Management. Father of the plaintiff has purchased the rights of the
subject school in the year 1996 from one St.Mariamma by paying
an amount of Rs.5O,O00/-. Since then, the plaintif{'s father was
managing the same. Plaintifls father was removed in the Executive
Committee of the subject institution and the defendant Nos.1 to 9
(petitioners and respondent No.2 herein) has not issued any notice
to the plaintiff with regard to the deletion or removal of plaintiffs
8/ 10
BRMR,J
cRP_2853_2023
\
father name as Correspondent/ President of the Institution. Father
of the plaintiff has issued notice on 17.03.2021 calling all the
defendant Nos. I to 9 (petitioners and respondent No.2 herein) to
re-instate and restore lor the post of President and Correspondent
of the Institution and the plaintiff has the ownership and title of
the suit schedule school after the death of his father on
14.O5.2021.
16.2. In the cause of action para it is stated that his father has
conferred him all the powers and authority attached to the post of
President and Correspondent of the Institution. OS No.661 of 2017
is Iiled for perpetual injunction by respondent No. 1-plaintiff and
his father S.Bikshapathi as stated in plaint para No.2.
17. 1. In T.Arivandandamr, the Supreme Court observed that "if
clever drafting has created the illusion of a cause of action, the
Court must nip it in the bud at the first hearing by examining the
party searchingly under Order X CPC".
17.2. In Pandurang Vithal Kevne2, the Supreme Court observed
that "cost to be imposed in unscrupulous litigation for not daring
to play with the judicial system".
18. Power of the High Court under Article 22T of the
€onstitution of India is to be sparingly exercised in casgs where
\/
!
BRMR,J
cRP-2453_2023
errors are apparent on the face of the record or exercising its
jurisdiction in a perverse mallner : See K.Valarmathi and Others
Vs. Kumaresan (2025 SCC Online SC 985).
19. Srihari Hanumandas Totala3 deals with Section 11 of CPC
(resjudicata) and further held that in order to consider Order 7
Rule 11, the Court has to look into the averments in the plaint and
L
the same can be exercised by the trial Court at any stage of the
suit.
I
I
20. Babasaheb Ramdas Shirole & Others Vs. Rohit Enterprises
& Others, Special leave to Appeal Civil No.16809 of 2025, dated
17 .11.2025, the Supreme Court observed that
'it is weil settled
that limitation is a mixed question of law and fact and unless the
same is patently and unequivocally clear, it cannot form a ground
under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC for non-suiting a plainlifl".
2l .
On reading of the entire piaint, it is evidently clear that the
cause of action for the suit arose in the year 1996 when the father
of the plaintiff by name S.Bikshapathi Goud has purchased the
\
rights of the school from St.Mariamma who was managing the
school then and also when there is a change of Members and
Executive Committee Members of the school by defendant Nos.2
and 3 on 31.03.2018 and also when the father of the respondent
Y
BRMR,J
cRP_2853 2023
10/10
No.1-plaintiff died and conferring a-ll the powers on the respondent
No. 1-plaintiff.
22. The decisions cited by the petitioner's counsel are
distinguishable from the facts of the present case and thus the
ratio of those cases would not apply.
23. Scope of Article 227 of the Constitution of India is iimited
and the learned trial Court has rightly exercised its jurisdiction
and passed a reasoned order by rejecting the petition filed by the
petitioners for rejection of plaint and there is no perversity in the
order passed bv the learned trial Court.
24. Petitioners have not made out any case, hence CRP is liab1e
to be dismissed and is accordingly dismissed
25. CRP is dismissed with costs.
Interim Orders if any shall stands vacated. Miscellaneous
application/ s stands closed.
SD/. C. DEEPIKA
SSI TANT REGISTRAR
t\
//TRUE COPYII
\
CTION OFFICER
To
1. The XX Junior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hvderabad.
2. One CC to SRl. p V Krishnaiah, Advocate tOpUCI
3. One CC to SRl. yooeshwar Raj Saxena, RdvocatelOeUCl
4. Two CD Copies
PR,/PSL
ry-
/
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2110112026
THE S Te
ORDER
CRP.No.2853 of 2023
()
I JAit
f
'J.r'.
DISMISSING THE CRP WITH COSTS
b
?x
),1"
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review