Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010691912025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3311]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Tuesday, the twenty seventh day of January two thousand and twenty six
Present
The Honourable Ms. Justice B. S. Bhanumathi
Civil Revision Petition No.3692 of 2025
Between:
S. Lakshmi Narasamma and others
...
...Petitioners
and
R. Anitha
etitioners:
Counsel for the petitioner
1. P. Madhukar Reddy
Counsel for the respondent:
espondent:
1. Y. N. Anjaneyacharyulu
The Court made the following:
...
...Respondent
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3692 of 2025
ORDER:
This revision is filed by the respondents / defendants under Article
227 of the Constitution of India against the decree and the order, dated
11.11.2025, allowing the appeal in C.M.A.No.06 of 2024 on the file of
the Court of the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Penukonda, which was
filed against the decree and the order, dated 01.12.2023, dismissing
I.A.No.286 of 2023 in O.S.No.195 of 2023 on the file of the Court of the
Principal Junior Civil Judge, Penukonda, filed under Order XXXIX,
Rules 1 and 2 C.P.C., along with the suit, seeking interim injunction
restraining
the
respondents
from
interfering
with the
peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule items Nos.1 and 2
properties described below:
Item No.1:
Property situated in Sri Sathyasai district, R.D. of
Puttaparthy and S.R.D. of Chilamattur within the limits of
Gownivaripalli revenue village.
S.No.
Babu
1.
G.D.
S.No.
103-1B1 pyki
Bounded by:East
:
Land of Ramappa
West
:
Land of Ramana Reddy
North
:
Land of Narasimhulu
South
:
Jagananna Layout
Extent
Ac.0.56 cents
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3692 of 2025
Item No.2:
2. G.D.
Bounded by:-
2.
108-A1 pyki
Ac.0.50 cents
Total
Ac.1.06 cents
East
:
Vanka
West
:
Land of P.Rangappa
North
:
Land of Narasimhulu
South
:
Land of Pedda Nagappa
The respondent herein filed the suit against the revision
petitioners stating the case briefly as follows:
a.
The petition schedule properties of Ac.0.56 cents in Sy.No.103-1
and Ac.0.56 cents in Sy.No.108, in total, Ac.1.12 cents belong to
Rangamma W/o. late Chinna Narasimhappa. She was in possession
of the same till she sold and delivered the same to the petitioner under a
registered sale deed, dated 07.11.2014. Since then, the petitioner has
been in possession and enjoyment of the same by raising crops without
objection from anybody. The name of the petitioner was entered in the
revenue records. After division of the survey numbers, the petitioner got
only Ac.0.50 cents in Sy.No.108-A1 and Ac.0.56 cents in Sy.No.
103-1B1. After an elaborate enquiry, the Tahsildar, Gorantla mandal
issued pattadar passbook to the petitioner under patta No.3022 as per
the Andhra Pradesh Rights in Land and Pattadar Passbooks Act, 1971.
The petitioner obtained a crop loan from the State Bank of India,
Gorantla, by deposit of title deed. The Village Revenue Officer issued a
confirmation certificate with boundaries of the land to prove possession
and enjoyment of the petitioner. The respondents do not have any right
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3692 of 2025
over the plaint schedule properties. They developed an evil eye to grab
it and are trying to interfere with the possession of the petitioner.
b.
The respondents filed a counter denying the case of the petitioner
and further stating as follows:
Nagappa S/o. Yerrappa and Gangappa S/o. Babanna purchased
half share, i.e., Ac.5.00 cents in Sy.No.103 and Ac.4.00 cents in
Sy.No.108 on 20.02.1951 from K.V.Subba Rao S/o. K.Vasantha Rao.
Chowdepalli Pedda Narasimhappa and Chinna Narasimhappa are sons
of Gangappa. Nagamma and Lakshminarasamma are the daughters of
Pedda Narasimhappa. Rangamma is the wife of Chinna Narasimhappa.
Thus, Ac.1.25 cents in Sy.No.103 belongs to Pedda Narasimhappa and
Chinna Narasimhappa. They enjoyed it during their life time. On the
death of Pedda Narasimhappa, his wife, Narasamma and daughters,
Nagamma and Lakshminarasamma succeeded to his half share of the
property.
The remaining half share was enjoyed by Rangamma.
Chinna Narasimhappa died issueless. The entire property is owned and
enjoyed by Nagamma, Lakshminarasamma and Rangamma and they
are in joint possession of it. Rangamma does not have exclusive title to
the properties, but sold her share without specific boundaries and extent
and sub division of land. Hence, the petitioner has to file a suit for
partition and separate possession, if she purchased it from Rangamma.
By suppressing the facts, the petitioner obtained the revenue record,
though not in possession. Therefore, the respondent No.1 filed a
petition before the Revenue Divisional Officer, Puttaparthy, to rectify the
records by deleting the name of the petitioner as only the respondents
are in possession.
3.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3692 of 2025
The documents filed by the parties are shown hereunder:Documents marked on behalf of the petitioner
Ex.P1 Sale deed dt.07.11.2014 executed by Rangamma in
favour of petitioner
Ex.P2 1-B dt.15.06.2023 stands in the name of petitioner
Ex.P3 Adangal for Sy.No.103-1B1, dt.15.06.2023 for Fasli year
Ex.P4 Adangal for Sy.No.108-A1, dt.15.06.2023 for Fasli year
Ex.P5 Confirmed certificate issued by V.R.O (Dhruveekarana
patram). (This document is marked subject to objection
by counsel for respondents that Village Revenue Officer
is not competent authority to issue it)
Documents marked on behalf of the respondents
--Nil--
4.
After hearing both the parties, the trial Court dismissed the
petition stating that there is dispute as to identity of the plaint schedule
property and the title of the petitioner over the plaint schedule property
and that these aspects can be decided only after full-fledged trial as it is
not a stage to make roving enquiry. With such view, the trial Court held
that there is no prima facie case. It was further observed that though
the respondents had not filed any documents as to their ownership in
the petition schedule properties, the counter and arguments advanced
go to show that they are joint holders of the property and therefore,
balance of convenience tilts in favour of the respondents and the
respondents would suffer irreparable loss if injunction is granted and
reverse is not the position if interim injunction is not granted.
5.
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3692 of 2025
Aggrieved by the order and the decree passed by the trial Court,
the petitioner / plaintiff preferred appeal in C.M.A.No.06 of 2024.
6.
After hearing both the parties, the appellate Court allowed the
appeal mainly observing that interim injunction can be granted basing
on the possession of the property as on the date of institution of the suit
and that the registered sale deed under Ex.P1 coupled with Exs.P2 to
P4 established the title and possession of the petitioner over the plaint
schedule properties as on the date of filing of the petition / suit and the
identity of the property is prima facie established by virtue of Ex.P5 and
its merit can be decided later on during the course of trial.
The
appellate Court is of the view that whatever share is held by Rangamma
was sold to the petitioner / appellant and the absence of boundaries of
the property under the sale deed / Ex.P1 is only the deficiency which is
supplemented in the light of the documents under Exs.P2 to P5,
particularly, Ex.P5.
7.
The appellate Court rejected the contention of the respondents
that the petitioner / purchaser of undivided share ought to have filed a
suit for partition and is not entitled to seek relief of temporary injunction,
keeping in view that such relief can be granted on establishing prima
facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable loss.
8.
Aggrieved by the order under decree of the appellate Court, this
revision petition was filed.
9.
While reiterating the grounds taken before the trial Court, it was
argued that interim injunction cannot be granted in respect of the
properties for which there were no boundaries mentioned in the sale
deed as the vendor had sold undivided share and therefore, without
filing suit for partition and separate possession, the relief cannot be
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3692 of 2025
granted. It was further argued that Ex.P5 is not valid in law as the
V.R.O. has no authority to grant such certificate.
10.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent /
plaintiff submitted that the respondent had not filed any document in
support of the case pleaded by the defendants and that the appellate
Court had rightly appreciated the facts and the legal position and
reiterated the same as was held by the appellate Court.
11.
In reply, the learned counsel for the revision petitioners submitted
that though the revision petitioners have not filed any documents, from
the case pleaded by the plaintiff and the documents filed by the plaintiff
clearly indicate that the property sold is undivided and has no
boundaries and therefore, non-filing of any documents by the
defendants is not fatal to resist the relief claimed by the plaintiff either in
the suit or in the interlocutory application.
12.
The enquiry in an interlocutory application is to protect the
possession of the property pending adjudication of the main suit.
Therefore, what is to be examined is the prima facie case, balance of
convenience and irreparable loss which are cardinal principles and well
settled. The main grounds on which the defendants resist the relief are
jointness of the property and non-identity of the property for want of
boundaries in the sale deed.
When the suit and the interlocutory
application were filed, specific boundaries were given, the defendants /
respondents have not contended that the boundaries are incorrect or
the property with such boundaries does not exist. It is not even the
case that half share of property of Rangamma which is shown in the suit
with specific boundaries is gainful to the plaintiff to the detriment of the
property of the defendants. That apart, they mainly failed to file any
BSB, J
C.R.P.No.3692 of 2025
documents showing joint possession of the properties as on the date of
filing of the suit or at any time after Ex.P1. Even if the property when
purchased is joint, later if the parties enjoy and possess specific item of
property in their respective parts, for the purpose of suit or interlocutory
application for injunction, prima facie title as well as possession would
support grant of such relief.
As per the plaintiff, since the date of
purchase of the property, it was put to use by raising crops within these
boundaries and necessary mutations were also made in the revenue
records with regard to her title and possession. If there is any contrary
evidence, that can be placed before the Court by defendants during the
course of trial. Basing on such evidence, the trial Court may take an
independent view after the trial. For the present, with the pleadings and
evidence available on record, there is no error committed by the trial
Court. Without any evidence, the trial Court took its view based on
counter and arguments only, completely rejecting the evidence placed
by the plaintiff.
Thus, this Court does not see any reason to interfere
with the order and decree of the appellate Court.
13.
In the result, the Civil Revision Petition is dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
Dt. 27.01.2026
RAR
__________________
B.S. BHANUMATHI, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review