Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010907932016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3604]
MONDAY, THE 5th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2307/2016
Between:
1. S. KRISHNAIAH, S/O S.NARASIMHULU @ NARASAIAH, AGED
ABOUT 34 YEARS, R/O CHINNABBANAIDU KANDRIGA VILLAGE,
PUTTUR MANDAL, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. S S LAKSHMI ANOTHER, W/O THURAMAN, OWNER OF CAR
BEARING NO.TN09AW0352, R/O NATHAMUNI STREET, T.NAGAR,
CHENNAI.
2. RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY, REP. BY ITS
BRANCH MANAGER, HOLDING ITS OFFICE AT CHENNAI.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtaggrieved by
the order and decree dated 24.5.2016 passed in M.V.O.P.No.255 of 2012 by
the learned Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunalcum-IV Additional
District Judge, Tirupathi
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. P JAGADISH CHANDRA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GUDI SRINIVASU
2.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
The Court made the following:
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2307 OF 2016
JUDGMENT:
This Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed against the
award and decree dated 24.05.2016 in M.V.O.P.No.255 of 2012 passed by
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Additional District Judge, Tirupati,
petitioner preferred the instant appeal seeking enhancement of compensation.
2.
The parties are being referred to as „petitioner‟ and „respondents‟ as
arrayed in the petition before the tribunal, for the sake of convenience and
clarity.
3. Case of the petitioner is thus:
On 29.05.2011, while the petitioner, his relative Reddaiah and his
brother‟s son Niranjan were returning from Puttur on his motorcycle bearing
No.AP 03 AR 4436 and when they reached near Middigunta village at 3.20
P.M, driver of Indigo car bearing No.TN 09 AW 0352 drove the same in a rash
and negligent manner and dashed against their two wheeler and as a result of
which, petitioner sustained severe multiple injuries.
Immediately after the
accident, he was shifted to C.M.C hospital, Vellore. Basing on the report of
the wife of the petitioner, a case in crime No.105 of 2011 is registered of the
offences under Sections 338, 337 and 279 of Indian Penal Code (hereinafter
referred to as „the Code‟) and Sections 134 (a) and (b) of the Motor Vehicle
Act, against the driver of Indigo car . The accident occurred due to the rash
and negligent driving of driver of Indigo car and as such, respondents are
liable to pay compensation.
4.
Respondent No.2 filed counter refuting the averments made in the
petition, wherein, inter alia contended that the petitioner claimed excessive
compensation, there was no negligence on the part of the driver of Indigo car,
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
rider of the two wheeler was at fault, petition is bad for non-joinder of the
owner and insurer of the said motor cycle and respondents are not liable to
pay compensation, and with other formal denials, prayed to dismiss the
petition.
5.
Taking into consideration of the aforementioned pleadings, the learned
tribunal settled the following issues:
1) Whether the accident took place due to rash and negligent
driving of Indigo car bearing No.TN 09AW 0352 of 1st respondent
by its driver?
2) Whether the petitioner is entitled to compensation and if so to
what amount and from whom?
3) To what relief?
6.
During trial, petitioner himself examined as PW1 and he has got
examined PWs 2 to 4, and filed Exs.A1 to A13 documents. As against the
said evidence, respondents have not adduced either oral or documentary
evidence.
At the culmination of trial, learned tribunal allowed the petition
granting compensation of Rs.3,94,490/- with interest at 7.5% per annum.
Feeling aggrieved by the said award and decree dated 24.05.2016, petitioner
preferred the instant appeal urging the following grounds:
i)
The Award and decree of the learned tribunal is illegal, arbitrary,
unjust and contrary to law.
ii)
The learned tribunal has not properly considered the oral and
documentary evidence to decide the issues.
iii)
The learned tribunal failed to consider the income of the
petitioner.
iv)
The learned tribunal erred in fixing the daily income at Rs.150/per day instead of Rs.400/-.
v)
The learned tribunal failed to appreciate the evidence of PW4
who deposed that mason worker daily wage is Rs.400/- to
Rs.500/-, and with other grounds, prayed to allow the appeal.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
7.
Heard both sides.
8.
On hearing both sides and upon perusing the material available on
record, the points that would arise for consideration are:
1.
Whether the accident dated 29.05.2011 occurred due to the rash
and negligent driving of Indigo car bearing No.TN 09 AW 0352?
2.
Whether the petitioner is entitled for compensation? If so, to what
amount?
3.
Whether the Award and decree dated 24.05.2016 passed by the
learned tribunal are sustainable in facts and law?
4.
9.
To what relief?
Admittedly, respondents have not preferred any appeal challenging the
findings of the learned tribunal, however, being the first appellate court and
final fact finding court, this court has to re-examine and re-appreciate the
entire oral as well as documentary evidence on record.
10. Point No.1:
(a)
To prove the contentions, petitioner examined himself as PW1, filed
examination in chief affidavit in lieu of his chief examination reiterating the
averments made in the petition. PW1 testified that on 29.05.2011, at about
03:20 P.M, while himself and two others were going by two wheeler and when
their two wheeler reached near Middigunta village, driver of Indigo car bearing
No.TN 09 AW 0352 drove the same in a rash and negligent manner and
dashed against their two wheeler and as a result, he sustained multiple
injuries and since the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving
of Indigo car, a case in crime No.105 of 2011 is registered of the offence
under Sections 338, 337 and 279 of the Code and Sections 134 (a) and (b) of
the Motor Vehicle Act, against the driver. Nothing useful material is elicited in
the cross examination of PW 1.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
(b)
Further, as seen from Ex.A1/first information report, a case in crime
No.105 of 2011 is registered of the offences stated supra against the driver of
Indigo car and after completion of investigation, police found fault with the
driver and laid charge sheet vide Ex.A2 alleging that the accident occurred
due to his rash and negligent driving.
So, Exs.A1 and A2 supports the
evidence of PW.1 and no rebuttal evidence is adduced by the respondents on
this aspect. Added to it, having received notice, respondent No.1 remained ex
parte and both the respondents failed to examine driver of the offending
vehicle who is the best person to speak about the accident and his non
examination is fatal to the case of the respondents. So, in the absence of any
rebuttal evidence, the evidence of PW No.1, which is buttressed by Exs.A1 &
A2, clinchingly proves that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving of Indigo car bearing No.TN 09 AW 0352 by its driver. Further, as
seen from Ex.A3/wound certificate, petitioner sustained injuries in the road
traffic accident. As per the material brought on to the record, this court came
to the conclusion that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving of Indigo car bearing No.TN 09 AW 0352 by its driver and the petitioner
sustained injuries in the said accident. Hence, this point is accordingly
answered in favour of the petitioner.
11. Point No.2:
(a)
As per the version of the petitioner, he was hale and healthy, was aged
about 30 years, was working as mason maistry and was earning Rs.400/- to
Rs.500/-, and immediately after commission of accident, he was shifted to
C.M.C. Vellore, took treatment as in patient for more than 75 days, underwent
surgeries, suffered loss of income and disability, and filed Exs.A3/wound
certificate, A4/discharge summaries, A5 to 8/consolidated bills, Ex.A9/O.P
slips, Ex.A10/Travel trip sheets, A11/Bunch of medical bills.
(b)
To prove his injuries and treatment, petitioner has got examined doctor
as PW2 and he testified that on 13.05.2011, the petitioner was admitted in
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
their hospital with the injuries of left shaft humerus, bilateral tibia fracture, left
fibula fracture, right shaft of femur fracture, left distal radius fracture and all the
injuries are grievous in nature, on 30.05.2011,
the petitioner underwent IM
Nailing right femur orif right tibia and external fixator application for left leg and
on 07.06.2011, petitioner underwent left distal radius orif and he was
discharged on 18.06.2011.
PW2 further testified that on 07.08.2011,
petitioner admitted in their hospital, underwent Ilizarov ring application for left
tibia and was discharged on 31.08.2011 and again, on 24.10.2011, he
admitted and underwent left leg skin release on 24.10.2011 and was
discharged on the same day and thereafter, he was again admitted on
02.08.2012, underwent surgery of left leg row area skin grafting for right thigh
and underwent surgeries on 21.08.2012 and 19.11.2012, for left tibia and for
right tibia debridement respectively. Finally, he testified that the petitioner
sustained 20 to 25% disability and to prove disability, petitioner filed
Ex.A13/Disability certificate issued by the hospital where he has taken
treatment. Having considered the injuries and treatment taken by the
petitioner coupled with medical record, the learned tribunal had considered the
functional disability at 20% and in view of the avocation of the petitioner, the
same can be accepted.
(c)
PW3/owner of the travels stated that on several occasions, the
petitioner hired car from their travels so as to go to Vellore CMC Hospital. As
per the evidence of PW3 coupled with Ex.A10, petitioner spent an amount of
Rs.74,255/- towards traveling expenses.
(d)
Insofar as age and income of the petitioner is concerned, he filed
Ex.A12/Construction worker registration card issued by the Assistant Labour
Officer, Puttur and examined PW4 who testified that the petitioner was
working as mason maistry and was earning Rs.400/- to Rs.500/- per day, as
on the date of the accident and the learned tribunal had considered earnings
of the petitioner at Rs.150/- per day as the PW4 failed to produce any
document showing actual payments.
One cannot expect detailed
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
documentary proof from the person who had given evidence supporting the
avocation of the injured. In the given facts and circumstances coupled with the
fact that the accident occurred in the year 2011 and on a reasonable
hypothesis, monthly earnings of the petitioner have to be considered at
(200x30) Rs.6,000/-. As seen from Ex.A3/wound certificate, age of the
petitioner is 30 years. There is no contra evidence to that effect. So, it can
safely be concluded that the petitioner was aged about 30 years, as on the
date of the accident.
(e)
So, as per the evidence of PWs 1 to 4 coupled with Exs.A1 to A13,
petitioner sustained grievous injuries, underwent seven surgeries, took
treatment for more than 75 days, admitted in hospital on several occasions
from 13.05.2011 to 29.11.2012, incurred Rs.2,05,633/- towards treatment,
74,255/- towards transpiration, lost income during the period of treatment and
also suffered functional disability at 20% and the details of compensation
under each head are as follows:
I. Pecuniary Damages:
i) Loss of earnings due to disability and future prospects:
(a)
Having considered the nature of job, age, education and other allied
aspects, this court assessed the functional disability of the petitioner at 20. In
Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation 1 , Hon‟ble Apex Court held
thus:
“It is necessary to reiterate that the multiplier method is logically sound and legally
well established. There are some cases which have proceeded to determine the
compensation on the basis of aggregating the entire future earnings for over the
period the life expectancy was lost, deducted a percentage therefrom towards
uncertainties of future life and award the resulting sum as compensation. This is
clearly unscientific. For instance, if the deceased was, say 25 years of age at the time
of death and the life expectancy is 70 years, this method would multiply the loss of
dependency for 45 years virtually adopting a multiplier of 45 and even if ─ ─ one-third
or one-fourth is deducted therefrom towards the uncertainties of future life and for
immediate lump sum payment, the effective multiplier would be between 30 and 34.
This is wholly impermissible.”
(2009) 6 SCC 121
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
(b)
This principle applies to the permanent disability cases also. So, the
loss of future earnings have to be calculated by applying the multiplier
method. It is evident from the record that the petitioner was aged about 30
years, as on the date of accident and the relevant multiplier is „17‟. Further, in
National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi 2, the Hon‟ble Apex
Court considered the claim for future prospects of a victim, a carpenter, who
had suffered permanent disability. Since, the petitioner was aged about 30
years, 40% of the future prospects have to be taken into consideration.
ii) Loss of earnings (Past):
As per the evidence of PW.s 1 and 2, the petitioner was away from work
for the period from 13.05.2011 to 29.11.2012 and it is already stated above
that Rs.6,000/- per month has to be considered towards monthly earnings of
the petitioner, as on the date of accident. So, he is entitled to an amount of
Rs.1,08,000/- (Rs.6,000x18).
iii) Medical Expenses: As per the evidence of PWs.1 and 2 coupled with
Exs.A5 to A9 and A11, petitioner incurred an amount of Rs.2,05,633/-,
towards treatment. So, the same is to be considered.
iv) Attendant Charges: In view of the judgment of Hon‟ble Apex Court in
R.D.Hattangadi Vs M/s. Pest Control (India) Private Limited and Others3,
the Court need not be mathematical in calculating expenses towards home
attendant, but ought to look upon the circumstances prevailing in the society
to decide the amount and in the present case at hand, the petitioner took
treatment and underwent surgeries, was advised bed rest and also follow up
treatment, and as such, he is entitled to attendant charges for 18 months,
which is assessed at Rs.18,000/-.
2017 (16) SCC 680
1995 1 SCC 551
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
v) Loss of Conveyance: In Sidram Vs. The Divisional Manager, United
India Insurance Company Limited and another4 (Supra), the Hon‟ble Apex
Court held at para No.89 as follows:
“89. Hence, we may grant the appellant loss of conveyance and special diet
up to Rs.50,000/- considering that after the accident at Kulgod-Gokak Road,
the appellant was shifted to Lake view Hospital Belgaum wherein he was
admitted as an indoor patient from 18.07.2012 to 06.08.2012 for 19 days, and
took treatment for the injuries suffered by him, and continued to take the
treatment after getting discharged from the Hospital as well.”
As per the evidence of PW3 coupled with Ex.A10, an amount of
Rs.74,255/- is awarded towards conveyance.
II) Non-Pecuniary Damages:
(i) Pain and Suffering:
The Divisional Controller, KSRTC v. Mahadeva Shetty and
Another5, the Hon‟ble Apex Court held thus:
“A person not only suffers injuries on account of accident but also
suffers in mind and body on account of the accident throughout his life
and a feeling is developed that he is no more a normal man and cannot
enjoy the amenities of life as another normal person can. While fixing
compensation for pain and suffering as also for loss of amenities of life
the features like his age, marital status and unusual deprivation he has
undertaken in his life has to be reckoned”.
In view of the injuries and permanent disability sustained by the
petitioner and the period of treatment taken by him, an amount of
Rs.2,00,000/- is awarded towards pain and suffering.
(ii) Loss of Amenities:
In Pappu Deo Yadav Vs. Naresh Kumar and others6, the Hon‟ble
Apex Court held thus:
(2022) 8 SCR 403
2003 (7) SCC 197
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
“The principle consistently followed by this court in assessing motor
vehicle compensation claims, is to place the victim in as near a position as
she or he was in before the accident, with other compensatory directions
for loss of amenities and other payments. These general principles have
been stated and reiterated in several decisions (Govind Yadav Vs. New
India Insurance Co Limited, (2011) 10 SCC 683.”
Having regard to the injuries and treatment, an amount of Rs.20,000/- is
awarded towards loss of amenities.
Further, in Govind Yadav Vs. New India Insurance Co Limited 7 ,
Hon‟ble Apex Court held thus:
“18. In our view, the principles laid down in Aravind Kumar Mishra Vs. New
India Assurance Company Limited (2010) 10 SCC 264 and Raj Kumar Vs.
Ajay Kumar must be followed by all the Tribunals and the High Courts in
determining the quantum of compensation payable to the victims of
accident, who are disabled either permanently or temporarily . If the victim
of the accident suffers permanent disability, then efforts should always be
made to award adequate compensation not only for the physical injury and
treatment, but also for the loss earning and his inability to lead a normal life
and enjoy amenities, which he would have enjoyed but for the disability
caused due to the accused”.
The learned tribunal erred in deducting 1/3rd of the total income towards
f)
personal expenses as this is the case of injuries. So, in all, the petitioner is
entitled to the compensation as follows:
S.No.
I
HEADS
CALCULATION
Pecuniary damages:
i)
Loss of earnings due to disability (6,000 X
Rs.
12 X 17 X20/100)
ii)
Future Prospects (2,44,800X 40/100)
Rs.
97,920/-
iii)
Loss of earnings (past) for 18 months
Rs.
(6,000x18)
1,08,000/-
iv)
Medical expenses
Rs.
2,05,633/-
v)
Attendant charges
Rs.
18,000/-
vi)
conveyance
Rs.
74,255/-
Total
II
Non Pecuniary expenses:
AIR 2020 SCC 4421
(2011) 10 SCC 683
2,44,800/-
7,48,608/-
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
vii)
Pain and suffering
Rs.
2,00,000/-
viii)
Loss of amenities
Rs.
20,000/-
Total
TOTAL (pecuniary+non-pecuniary damages)
(7,48,608+2,20,000)
Rs.
g)
2,20,000/9,68,608/(rounded to
9,68,700/-)
In this court‟s well considered view that in accordance with the
propositions of law laid down by the Hon‟ble Apex Court, the compensation of
Rs. 9,68,700/- is just and reasonable. It is needless to say that though the
petitioner claimed compensation of Rs.5,00,000/-, in view of the settled
principles of law, just and fair compensation is to be awarded to the petitioner.
h)
So far as the liability of the respondents is concerned, it is to be noted
that a finding is already recorded in issue No.1, holding that driver of Indigo
car bearing No.TN 09 AW 0352 was solely responsible for the accident and
respondent No.2/insurance company is vicariously liable to indemnify the
liability of respondent No.1/owner. It is not in dispute that the policy of the
offending vehicle was in force as on the date of accident. Hence, this issue is
answered, holding that the respondent Nos.1 and 2 are jointly and severally
liable to pay compensation.
12. Point No.3:
Upon reappraisal of the evidence on record, and for the foregoing
reasons, this court came to the conclusion that the learned tribunal erred in
assessing the quantum of compensation and as such, the same is liable to be
modified. Hence, this point is answered accordingly.
13. Point No.4:
(i) In the result, this Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is
allowed, and the compensation awarded by the tribunal is enhanced from
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2307 of 2016
Rs.3,94,490/- (Three lakhs ninety four thousand four hundred ninety
rupees only) to Rs. 9,68,700/- (Rupees Nine lakhs sixty-eight thousand
seven hundred only) together with interest at the same rate as awarded by
the tribunal, from the date of the claim petition till the date of realization.
(ii) Time for deposit, as aforesaid, with interest, excluding the amount, if
any, already deposited, is one (1) month from the date of receipt of a copy of
this judgment.
(iii) On such deposit, the petitioner is permitted to withdraw the
compensation as awarded supra along with accrued interest thereon,
excluding the amount, already paid.
(iv) There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
SUNITHA GANDHAM, J
Dt:05.10.2026
Vns
Whether the order is :
✓
Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No
✓
Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review