Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CMA No. 56 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 2-04-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE R. KALAIMATHI
CMA No. 56 of 2026
1.S.Karpagam
W/o. Senthilkumar
2.Minor S.Elanchezhiyan
S/o. Senthilkumar
Represented by mother,
Natural Guardian
S.Karpagam, 1st appellant herein.
3.Minor S. Nedunchezhiyan
S/o. Senthilkumar
All are residing at No.18, Mariyammankoil Street,
Ambedkar Nagar,
Gundu Uppalavadi,
Cuddalore - 607 002.
Represented by mother, Natural Guardian
S.Karpagam, 1st appellant herein.
4.Rajavalli
W/o. Ammavasai,
No. 102, Ambedkar Nagar,
Gundu Uppalavadi,
Cuddalore- 607 002.
..Appellant(s)
Vs.
1.Acharya Arts and Science College
Acharyapuram, Villiyanur,
Puducherry - 605 010.
2.The Manager, Future General India Ins. Co. Ltd.,
9th Floor, VBC Solitair,
47 and 49, Buzullar Road,
T.Nagar,
Chennai- 600 017.
__________
Page1 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
..Respondent(s)
Prayer: Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under Section 173 of Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, to set aside the Order of the Tribunal exonerating the
liability of the Insurance Company and t enhance the award amount in MCOP
NO. 93 of 2020 dated 04.08.2025 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal/Special District Court II, Cuddalore.
For Appellant(s)
:
Ms.Subathra
for Ms.Ramya V.Rao
For Respondent(s):
No Appeararance for R1
Ms.C.Harini
for M/s.Gopalan Associates for R2
JUDGMENT
The claimants who are the legal heirs of Senthil Kumar have preferred
this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal against the Award dated 04.08.2025 passed in
M.C.O.P.No.73 of 2020 on the file of the Special District Court No.2 (to deal
with M.C.O.P. Cases), Cuddalore.
2. Parties are indicated herein as per their litigative status and ranking
before the Tribunal.
3. The claimants who are the wife, two minor sons and mother of the
deceased Senthil Kumar have sought for compensation for the death of Sentil
Kumar in a road accident that took place on 09.12.2019. The compensation
was quantified at Rs.18,91,000/- on the ground that the deceased was earning
Rs.25,000/- per month by working as mason. As to the manner in which the
__________
Page2 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
accident occurred, it has been stated that on 09.12.2019 at about 8.45 hours
while the deceased was riding his motor cycle bearing registration No.TN 31BA-7338 from north to south direction with pillion (Dhandapani) proceeding
from Pondicherry to Cuddalore along ECR road, when the vehicle was
reaching Periyakanganankuppam, south of Penaiyaru bridge, a bus belongs
to the 1st respondent-Educational Institution bearing Registration No.PY 01 K
6685 came from the opposite direction at high speed and in rash and
negligent manner, dashed upon the deceased's Senthil Kumar motor cycle. In
the result, the deceased was thrown off and sustained serious injuries. On the
way to Government Hospital, Cuddalore, he was declared dead.
4. The owner of the 1st respondent bus, despite the receipt of notice,
remained ex-partie.
5. The 2nd respondent / Insurance Company resisted the claim by
contending that the driver of the bus bearing Registration No.PY 01 K 6685
had no valid license with necessary endorsement to drive the vehicle and the
vehicle was plied without proper permit and fitness certificate, thereby the
owner has violated the insurance policy conditions. The accident occurred on
09.12.2019 at 8.45 a.m., outside the Union Territory of Pondicherry. Permit
was produced during the motor vehicle inspection. As there was no permit at
the time of alleged accident, the 1 st respondent had taken temporary permit at
15.14 hours on the said date of accident. As the policy conditions are wilfully
__________
Page3 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
breached, the 2nd respondent/ Insurance Company is not liable to pay any
compensation to the petitioner and the 1st respondent alone is liable to pay
compensation. The Tribunal rejected the claim of the Insurance Company on
the issue of negligence by holding that the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving of the bus based on the evidence of P.W.4 Hariputhiram
coupled with other evidence of claimant.
6. As regards the liability of the 2 nd respondent / Insurance Company,
the Tribunal held that since the vehicle plied without permit and the temporary
permit was obtained on the same day after the occurrence, the Insurance
Company was held to be not liable to pay compensation and the 1 st
respondent is saddled with responsibility to pay compensation in entirety. The
Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs.18,91,000/- taking notional income of the
deceased at Rs.15,000/- adding future prospectus at 25% deducting 1/4 th
towards personal expenses, awarded a sum of Rs.48,000/- towards spousal
consortium, Rs.96,000/- toward parental consortium, Rs.36,000/- towards
funeral expenses & loss of estate, and towards transport expenses,
Rs.10,000/-. In all, total compensation was quantified at Rs.18,91,000/-.
7. Aggrieved, the claimants are on appeal on quantum as well as on
liability issue.
__________
Page4 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
8. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants / claimants,
Ms.Subathra and Ms.C.Harini for Mr.Gopalan Associates for the second
respondent.
9. The learned counsel for the appellants / claimants Ms.Subathra would
vehemently argue that the deceased while driving the two wheeler was hit by
the bus and he being the third party, the Tribunal saddled responsibility upon
the 1st respondent to pay compensation is fallacious.
She would further
contend that the deceased was working as a Mason at the time of accident
and he was 41 year of age at the relevant point of time and was earning a
sum of Rs.25,000/- per month. But the Tribunal assumed notional income at
Rs.12,000/- is not adequate and sought for enhancement of compensation.
10. Per contra, the learned second respondent / Insurance Company
Ms.C.Harini, would strenuously contend that on account of the fact that the
bus was plied without permit, the Tribunal exonerated the Insurance Company
to pay compensation. She would further contend that, taking into the account
of age, avocation of the deceased and other attending circumstances,
amounts awarded by the Tribunal as mentioned supra are in order and
according to her, the same may be confirmed.
11. The learned counsel would draw the attention of this Court to the
__________
Page5 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
following judgments:
(i). National Insurance Company Limited vs. Challa Upendra Rao,
reported in (2004) 8 SCC 517, wherein, in the said case, three persons were
travelling in an auto rickshaw which met with an accident on 09.05.1992. Two
persons lost their lives, while one was seriously injured. The injured person as
well as the legal representatives of the two deceased persons filed claim
petitions under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short, “the
Act”). The auto rickshaw in question belonged to the insured. The insured
resisted the claim on the ground that he had not obtained a permit to ply the
vehicle and therefore, in terms of the policy of insurance, the insurer had no
liability. The Motor Vehicle Accidents Claims Tribunal (the Tribunal) accepted
the plea. However, it held that the insured was liable to pay compensation,
which was quantified at Rs.1,24,000/- in the case of death and in the case of
the injured claimant, it was quantified at Rs. 2,000/-. The said judgment was
challenged in appeal before the Division Bench of the High Court, questioning
the correctness of the view regarding the non-liability of the insurer. Whereas,
the High Court held that the insurer was liable to indemnify the award.
Allowing the appeal, the Supreme Court held that the statutory defences
available to the insurer to contest the claim are confined to those provided in
Section 149(2) of the Act. A person without a permit to ply a vehicle cannot be
placed on a better pedestal vizi-a-viz one who has a permit but has violated
any condition thereof. Plying a vehicle without a permit is an infraction.”
Therefore, in terms of Section 149(2) of the Act, defence is available to
__________
Page6 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
the insurer in this regard. Therefore, it was concluded that the High Court was
not justified in holding the insurer liable and ordered to pay the compensation
at the first instance and to recover the same from the insured at a later point
of time.
(ii). It is relevant to refer to the observations made by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Amrit Paul Singh vs Tata Aig General
Insurance Co. Ltd., reported in 2018 (7) SCC 558, wherein,
“23. In the case at hand, it is clearly demonstrable from the
materials brought on record that the vehicle at the time of the
accident did not have a permit. The appellants had taken the stand
that the vehicle was not involved in the accident. That apart, they
had not stated whether the vehicle had temporary permit or any
other kind of permit. The exceptions that have been carved out
under Section 66 of the Act, needless to emphasise, are to be
pleaded and proved. The exceptions cannot be taken aid of in the
course of an argument to seek absolution from liability. Use of a
vehicle in a public place without a permit is a fundamental statutory
infraction. We are disposed to think so in view of the series of
exceptions carved out in Section 66. The said situations cannot be
equated with absence of licence or a fake licence or a licence for
different kind of vehicle, or, for that matter, violation of a condition
of carrying more number of passengers. Therefore, the principles
laid down in Swaran Singh (supra) and Lakhmi Chand (supra) in
that regard would not be applicable to the case at hand. That
apart, the insurer had taken the plea that the vehicle in question
had no permit. It does not require the wisdom of the "Tripitaka",
that the existence of a permit of any nature is a matter of
documentary evidence. Nothing has been brought on record by the
__________
Page7 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
insured to prove that he had a permit of the vehicle. In such a
situation, the onus cannot be cast on the insurer. Therefore, the
tribunal as well as the High Court had directed the insurer was
required to pay the compensation amount to the claimants with
interest with the stipulation that the insurer shall be entitled to
recover the same from the owner and the driver. The said
directions are in consonance with the principles stated in Swaran
Singh (supra) and other cases pertaining to pay and recover
principle.”
In the said case, the vehicle which caused the accident did not have
permit. Nothing was brought on record by the Insured / 1 st respondent to
prove that he had permit for the vehicle and recovery order was passed by the
Tribunal was confirmed by the High Court and the same was confirmed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court.
12. It is profitable to refer to Section 149 (2) of the Act, it relates to a
vehicle not covered by a permit to ply for hire or regard. Section 149 (2) of
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is extracted hereunder:
“149(2) No sum shall be payable by an insurer under sub-section
(1) in respect of any judgment or award unless, before the
commencement of the proceedings in which the judgment or
award is given the insurer had notice through the Court or, as the
case may be, the Claims Tribunal of the bringing of the
proceedings, or in respect of such judgment or award so long as
execution is stayed thereon pending an appeal; and an insurer to
whom notice of the bringing of any such proceedings is so given
shall be entitled to be made a party thereto and to defend the
action on any of the following grounds, namely:—
__________
Page8 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
(a) that there has been a breach of a specified condition of
the policy, being one of the following conditions, namely:—
(i) a condition excluding the use of the vehicle—
(a) for hire or reward, where the vehicle is on the
date of the contract of insurance a vehicle not covered by a permit
to ply for hire or reward, or
(b) for organised racing and speed testing, or
(c) for a purpose not allowed by the permit under
which the vehicle is used, where the vehicle is a transport vehicle,
or
(d) without side-car being attached where the vehicle
is a motor cycle; or
(ii) a condition excluding driving by a named person or
persons or by any person who is not duly licensed, or by any
person who has been disqualified for holding or obtaining a
driving licence during the period of disqualification; or
(iii) a condition excluding liability for injury caused or
contributed to by conditions of war, civil war, riot or civil
commotion; or
(b) that the policy is void on the ground that it was obtained by the
non-disclosure of a material fact or by a representation of fact
which was false in some material particular.”
13. Section 66 of the Act deals with permit and the same reads as
follows:
“66. Necessity for permits. - (1) No owner of a motor
vehicle shall use or permit the use of the vehicle as a transport
vehicle in any public place whether or not such vehicle is actually
__________
Page9 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
carrying any passengers or goods save in accordance with the
conditions of a permit granted or countersigned by a Regional or
State Transport Authority or any prescribed authority authorising
him the use of the vehicle in that place in the manner in which the
vehicle is being used:
Provided that a stage carriage permit shall, subject to any
conditions that may be specified in the permit, authorise the use
of the vehicle as a contract carriage:
Provided further that a stage carriage permit may, subject
to any conditions that may be specified in the permit, authorise
the use of the vehicle as a goods carriage either when carrying
passengers or not:
Provided also that a goods carriage permit shall, subject to
any conditions that may be specified in the permit, authorise the
holder to use the vehicle for the carriage of goods for or in
connection with a trade or business carried on by him.
[Provided also that where a transport vehicle has been
issued any permit or permits, as well as a licence under this Act,
such vehicle may be used either under the permit, or permits, so
issued to it, or under such licence, at the discretion of the vehicle
owner.]
(2)The holder of a goods carriage permit may use the
vehicle, for drawing of any trailer or semi-trailer not owned by him,
subject to such conditions as may be prescribed:[Provided that the
holder of a permit of any articulated vehicle may use the primemover of that articulated vehicle for any other semi-trailer.]
(3)The provisions of sub-section (1) shall not apply(a)to any transport vehicle owned by the Central
Government or a State Government and used for Government
purposes unconnected with any commercial enterprise;
__________
Page10 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
(b)to any transport vehicle owned by a local authority or by
a person acting under contract with a local authority and used
solely for road cleansing, road watering or conservancy purposes;
(c)to any transport vehicle used solely for police, fire
brigade or ambulance purposes;
(d)to any transport vehicle used solely for the conveyance
of corpses and the mourners accompanying the corpses;
(e)to any transport vehicle used for towing a disabled
vehicle or for removing goods from a disabled vehicle to a place of
safety;
(f)to any transport vehicle used for any other public purpose
as may be prescribed by the State Government in this behalf;
(g)to any transport vehicle used by a person who
manufactures or deals in motor vehicles or builds bodies for
attachment to chassis, solely for such purposes and in accordance
with such conditions as the Central Government may, by
notification in the Official Gazette, specify in this behalf;
[* * *]
(i)to any goods vehicle, the gross vehicle weight of which
does not exceed 3,000 kilograms;
(j)subject to such conditions as the Central Government
may, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify, to any transport
vehicle purchased in one State and proceeding to a place, situated
in that State or in any other State, without carrying any passenger or
goods;
(k)to any transport vehicle which has been temporarily
registered under section 43 while proceeding empty to any place for
the purpose of registration of the vehicle;
[* * *]
__________
Page11 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
(m)to any transport vehicle which, owing to flood, earthquake
or any other natural calamity, obstruction on road, or unforeseen
circumstances, is required to be diverted through any other route,
whether within or outside the State, with a view to enabling it to reach
its destination;
(n)to any transport vehicle used for such purposes as the
Central or State Government may, by order, specify;
(o)to any transport vehicle which is subject to a hire-purchase,
lease or hypothecation agreement and which owing to the default of
the owner has been taken possession of by or on behalf of, the
person with whom the owner has entered into such agreement, to
enable such motor vehicle to reach its destination; or
(p)to any transport vehicle while proceeding empty to any
place for purpose of repair.
[(q) to any transport vehicle having been issued a licence
under a scheme, under sub-section (3) of section 67 or sub-section
(1) of section 88A, or plying under such orders as may be issued by
the Central Government or by the State Government.]
(4)Subject to the provisions of sub-section (3), sub-section (1)
shall, if the State Government by rule made under section 96 so
prescribes, apply to any motor vehicle adapted to carry more than
nine persons excluding the driver.
Therefore, a through perusal of Section 149(2) of Act shows that the
insurer can avoid its liability on the statutory defences expressly provided in
Sub Section (2) of Section 149 of the Act. Plying of vehicle without permit is
clear infraction.
14. The said details have been pleaded by the Insurance Company. As
__________
Page12 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
regards the proof, the Insurance Company has examined one Tvl. Srinivasan,
Staff of RTO Office, Cuddalore.
15. Ex.X4 is the Motor Vehicles Inspection Report in respect of the 1 st
respondent bus (PY 01 K 6685). In Column No.10, period of validity of permit,
no detail is mentioned. Temporary permit dated 09.12.2019 has been marked
as Ex.R5.
Wherein, temporary permit was obtained on 09.12.2019 for a
period of seven days. Accident took place on 09.12.2019 at 8.45 a.m. At
about 3.00 p.m. soon after the accident, the said temporary permit has been
obtained. The aforesaid documents would explicate in clear terms that at the
time of accident, bus was plied without permit. Plying of a vehicle without
permit is an infraction. Therefore, in terms of Section 149(2) of the Act, the
Insurance Company is permitted to take defence on this aspect. As the said
defence is permitted to be taken in terms of Section 149(2) of the Act and the
said defence having been proved through R.W2, Ex.X4 and Ex.R5, the
second respondent/Insurance Company shall pay the compensation at the
first instances and to recover the same at a later point of time from the first
respondent.
16. On quantum, it has come on record through the evidence of P.W.1
that the deceased was 41 years of age at the relevant point of time was
working as Mason and was earning a sum of Rs.25,000/- per month. To
__________
Page13 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
substantiate the same, no concrete proof is marked by the claimants.
17. P.W2 Mr.Ramu, Assistant, of Labour Welfare Board and P.W3
G.Ramu, Assistant Commissioner of Labour Social Security Schemes have
been examined. From their evidence, it is inferable that the deceased was a
registered member of the Tamil Nadu Construction Workers Welfare Board.
In the absence of substantial proof relating to the monthly income of the
deceased, this Court deems fit to fix the monthly income of the deceased at
Rs.17,000/-. To prove the age of the deceased Ex.P11-Aadhar card, Ex.R6,
Driving License of the deceased are available. As per the said details, date of
birth found in the driving license, age of the deceased is taken as 41 years at
the relevant point of time. The claimants are the wife, two minor children and
mother of the deceased. As per the guidelines of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
issued in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and others, 2017
(2) TN MAC 609 (SC), a standard addition is required to be added with the
notional income while computing loss of dependency. No doubt deceased
was a self-employed. For the age group of persons between 40 - 49, 25% of
income to be added as future prospectus. Claimants are four in number.
Therefore, 1/4th is to be deducted for personal and living expenses. As held in
Sarla Verma and others v. Delhi Transport Corporation and another,
2009 (2) TN MAC 1 (SC), the relevant multiplier to be invoked is ‘14m’.
Based on the aforesaid details, for computing loss of dependency, the
__________
Page14 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
following formula emerges.
Rs.17,000/- + 25%- ¼ x 12 x 14 m = Rs.26,77,416/-
18. For loss of consortium, an amount of Rs.16,000/-is granted in
addition to the amount already granted by the Tribunal. As regards the other
heads, the amounts awarded by the Tribunal appears to be acceptable and
reasonable and it does not call for any interference by this Court.
The
amounts awarded by this Court as mentioned supra is reworked and tabulated
hereunder:
Sl.
No.
Description
Amount
awarded by
Tribunal
Award
Amount
confirmed or
awarded by this enhanced or
Court
granted or
reduced
For loss of income
Rs.17,01,000/- Rs.26,77,416/-
Enhanced
For loss of
consortium
Rs.48,000/+ Rs.96,000/-
Rs.1,60,000/-
Enhanced
Towards funeral
expenses and loss of
estate
Rs.36,000/-
Rs.36,000/-
Confirmed
Towards
transportation
expenses
Rs.10,000/-
Rs.10,000/-
Confirmed
Rs.18,91,000/- Rs.28,83,416/-
Enhanced
Total
Rounded off as Rs.28,83,000/-
19. Thus, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from
Rs.18,91,000/- to Rs.28,83,000/- which would carry interest at the rate of
__________
Page15 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
7.5% per annum from the date of petition till the date of realisation.
20. In the result,
(i) The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal stands partly allowed. There is no
order as to costs.
(ii) The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from
Rs.18,91,000/- to Rs.28,83,000/-.
(iii) The Insurance Company / second respondent is directed to deposit
the enhanced compensation amount determined by this Court, i.e.,
Rs.28,83,000/- (less the amount already deposited, if any), together with
interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition till
the date of deposit, excluding the period of delay, and with costs, to the credit
of MCOP.No.93 of 2020 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal /
Special District Court No.II, Cuddalore, within a period of six weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of this Judgment. The second respondent/Insurance
Company shall pay the compensation at the first instance and to recover the
same at a later point of time from the first respondent.
(iv) On such deposit being made, the
claimants no.1 and 4 are
permitted to withdraw the amount, as per the apportionment fixed by the
Tribunal, along with the interest and costs, after adjusting the amount, if any
already withdrawn, by filing necessary application before the Tribunal.
(v)The share of the minors / claimants no.2 and 3 shall be
deposited in any one of the nationalized bank till the minors attains
__________
Page16 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
majority and the 1st appellant, mother of the minors Ms.S.Karpagam is
permitted to withdraw quarterly interest from the said amount.
(vi) The claimants are directed to pay the Court fee for the enhanced
compensation amount, if required.
(vii) The Tribunal below shall disburse the amount upon production of
the certified copy showing proof of payment of Court fee by the claimants.
2-04-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
MAC
To
1. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal/Special District Court II, Cuddalore.
2. Acharya Arts and Science College
Acharyapuram, Villiyanur,
Puducherry 605 010.
3. The Manager, Future General India Ins. Co. Ltd.,
9th Floor, VBC Solitair,
47 and 49, Buzullar Road,
T.Nagar,
Chennai- 600 017.
4. The Section Officer,
VR Section,
High Court, Madras.
__________
Page17 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 56 of 2026
R.KALAIMATHI, J.
MAC
CMA No. 56 of 2026
2-04-2026
__________
Page18 of 18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review