Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/29
GAHC010260512025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6694/2025
S.G.F. INFRA PRIVATE LIMITED
A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT, HAVING ITS
REGISTERED OFFICE AT H.NO. F-961 GURAH BAKSHI NAGAR, JAMMU,
THROUGH ITS AUTHORIZED SIGNATORY NAMELY SRI SANTOSH SAHANI,
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS, SON OF LATE SH. HARILAL SAHANI, RESIDENT
OF 46, SINDURIALI PATH, BATORI 24, NABIN NAGAR, ZOO ROAD, PO- ZOO
ROAD, DISTRICT- KAMRUP METRO, STATE ASSAM, PIN CODE- 781024
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 10 ORS
THROUGH SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF
DEFENCE, SOUTH BLOCK,NEW DELHI-110011
2:DIRECTOR GENERAL
BORDER ROADS ORGANIZATION SEEMA SADAK BHAVAN
RING ROAD
DELHI CANTT
NEW DELHI- 110010
3:ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL
BORDER ROADS ORGANIZATION (EAST)
GUWAHATI
ASSAM- 900885
C/O 99 APO
4:CHIEF ENGINEER
PROJECT UDAYAK
DOOM DOOMA
TINSUKIA
ASSAM
C/O 99 APO
Page No.# 2/29
PIN- 931715
5:THE TECHNICAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PROJECT UDAYAK
DOOM DOOMA
TINSUKIA
ASSAM
C/O 99 APO
PIN- 931715
6:THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (CIVIL) CUM PRESIDING OFFICER
TECHNICAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE
HQ CE(P) UDAYAK
DOOM DOOMA
TINSUKIA
ASSAM
C/O 99 APO
PIN- 931715
7:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (CIVIL) CUM MEMBER
TECHNICAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE
HQ CE(P) UDAYAK
DOOM DOOMA
TINSUKIA
ASSAM
C/O 99 APO
PIN- 931715
8:THE ASSISTANT ACCOUNTS OFFICER (AAO) CUM MEMBER
TECHNICAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE
HQ CE(P) UDAYAK
DOOM DOOMA
TINSUKIA
ASSAM
C/O 99 APO
PIN- 931715
9:COMMANDER
BRTF (BORDER ROADS TASK FORCE)
C/O 99 APO
PIN- 930048
10:OC
BCC C/O 99 APO
PIN- 931715
Page No.# 3/29
11:M/S GRRB ASSOCIATES
HOLDING NO.06/623
GYAN VILLA
MANAV KALYAN ROAD OPPOSITE BRAHMA KUMARI ASHRAM LANE
PO- TIUNSUKIA (ASSAM)- 78612
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. R. Pant, Senior Advocate
Mr. K. Kalita, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. H. Gupta, CGC
Ms. T. Gupta, Advocate
Mr. B. Pathak, Advocate
Date on which judgment is reserved
: NA
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 12.03.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. R. Pant, the learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr.
K. Kalita, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Petitioner. Mr. H. Gupta, the learned CGC appears on behalf of
the official Respondents and Ms. T. Gupta and Mr. B. Pathak, the
learned counsels appear on behalf of the Respondent No.11.
Page No.# 4/29
PREFACE
2.
The present writ petition has been filed challenging the
rejection of the Petitioner’s technical bid vide the approval of the
Competent Authority dated 07.11.2025. The Petitioner also
assails the declaration of the Respondent No.11 as the L1 bidder
and seeks for a writ of Mandamus directing the Respondent
Nos.1 to 8 to declare the Petitioner as technically qualified and
open the financial bid of the Petitioner.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE
3.
The Director (Contracts) of the Respondent Organization
issued a Notice Inviting Tender for design and construction of
120 (80+40) meter span major permanent bridge with
intermediate pier with steel superstructure (through type) on
open foundation over Peepani-II Nallah at Km.32.200 (including
casting of deck slab, wearing coat, kerbs and hand rails,
drainage spout, procurement and fixing of bearing and expansion
joints, painting, load testing completed in all respects) on
Hayuliang-Metaliang-Chaglohagam Road under 1444 BCC/48
BRTF under Project Udayak in Arunachal Pradesh. Various dates
were mentioned in the Notice Inviting Tender. In terms with the
said Critical Date Sheet incorporated in the Notice Inviting
Tender, the submission of the bid started on 2nd of July, 2025 at
Page No.# 5/29
1200 hours and the last date for submission of the bid was 16 th
of July, 2025 at 1200 hours. The Technical Bid was to open on
17th of July, 2025 at 1200 hours and the opening of the Financial
Bid was to be informed subsequently.
4.
This Court finds it pertinent to take note of Clause 11 of the
Notice Inviting Tender which is reproduced herein under:“11. Earnest money is not required to be attached with tender by
the valid enlisted contractor with BRO who have submitted standing
security deposit and MSME registered firms as per Rule 170 (i) of
GFR 2017, but it is required from other contractors to be attached
(Scanned copy) with Technical Bid for Rs.15,00,000.00 (Rupees
Fifteen Lakh Only) in the shape of call Receipt/Term Deposit
Receipt/Special Term Deposit Receipt in favour of Chief Engineer
Project
Udayak,
C/o
APO
obtained
from
any
Nationalized/Scheduled Bank and having maturity/validity period 90
days more than the validity period of his offer.”
5.
From a perusal of the above quoted Clause, it is seen that
the earnest money is not required to be attached with tender by
a valid enlisted contractor with BRO who has submitted standing
security deposit and MSME registered firm as per Rule 170 (i) of
the GFR, 2017. However, for other bidders, they are required to
attach with the Technical Bid the Earnest Money Deposit for
Rs.15,00,000/- in the shape of call receipt / term deposit
Page No.# 6/29
receipt / special term deposit receipt favouring the Chief
Engineer Project Udayak, C/o 99 APO obtained from a
Nationalized / Scheduled Bank and having maturity / validity
period of 90 days more than the validity period of his offer.
6.
This Court also finds it pertinent to take note of Clause 20 of
the Notice Inviting Tender which stipulates that the scan copy of
the original instrument in respect of earnest money, integrity
pact duly signed on each page by the bidders as well as other
are required to be uploaded along with the Technical Bid. The
hard copies of all such documents should reach the Tender
Inviting Authority in the sealed envelope within five days of the
bid submission end date i.e. on or before 21 st July, 2025. In
other words, the hard copies of the documents which are
uploaded are required to be submitted within five days of the bid
submission end date.
7.
At this stage, this Court finds it relevant to refer to Rule
170(i) of the GFR, 2017 which is in relation to Bid Security:Rule 170 Bid Security
(i) To safeguard against a bidder's withdrawing or altering its bid
during the bid validity period in the case of advertised or limited
tender enquiry, Bid Security (also known as Earnest Money) is to be
obtained from the bidders except Micro and Small Enterprises
(MSEs) as defined in MSE Procurement Policy issued by Department
Page No.# 7/29
of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) or are registered
with the Central Purchase Organisation or the concerned Ministry or
Department [or Startups as recognized by Department for
Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT)]. The bidders
should be asked to furnish bid security along with their bids.
Amount of bid security should ordinarily range between two percent
to five percent of the estimated value of the goods to be procured.
The amount of bid security should be determined accordingly by the
Ministry or Department and indicated in the bidding documents. The
bid security may be accepted in the form of [Insurance Surety
Bonds] Account Payee Demand Draft, Fixed Deposit Receipt,
Banker's Cheque or Bank Guarantee [including e-Bank Guarantee]
from any of the Commercial Banks or payment online in an
acceptable form, safeguarding the purchaser's interest in all
respects. The bid security is normally to remain valid for a period of
forty-five days beyond the final bid validity period.”
8.
A perusal of the above quoted Rule 170(i) of the GFR, 2017
would reveal that exemption from submission of the Bid Security
also known as the Earnest Money is only available to Micro and
Small Enterprises as defined in MSE Procurement Policy issued by
the Department of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises or are
registered with the Central Purchase Organization or concerned
Ministry or Department (or Startups as recognized by the
Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade). In
other words, a Medium Enterprise in terms with Rule 170(i) of
Page No.# 8/29
the GFR, 2017 cannot avail the benefit of EMD exemption. This
aspect is important as would be seen in the later stages of the
present judgment.
9.
In the backdrop of the above, it is relevant to take note of
that the Petitioner along with 11 other bidders submitted bids
pursuant to the Notice Inviting Tender. The Board of Officers of
the Respondent Organization prepared a comparative statement
of the Technical Bids submitted by the Bidders after making
necessary evaluation and recommended that only two bidders,
i.e. the Respondent No.11 and one M/S Bhartia Infra Projects
Limited were technically competent to participate in Stage 2
bidding, i.e. for opening of the Financial Bid. The remaining 9
bidders were not recommended which included the Petitioner.
The reason for not recommending the bid of the Petitioner by
the Board of Officers and opining that the Petitioner’s firm was
disqualified was for the following reasons:“EMD
exemption limitation is Rs.11,00,000.00 only as the Firm
Enlisted with BRO vide Index No.S-68 at HQ DGBR. In this tender
EMD sought for Rs.15,00,000.00. The firm has not submitted that
additional Security amount against EMD. Hence the firm is
disqualified.”
10.
The reason therefore for the Board of Officers to hold the
Petitioner’s bid not technically competent was that the Petitioner
Page No.# 9/29
had already a standing security deposit of Rs.11,00,000/-, and as
such the Petitioner’s Earnest Money Deposit was short by Rs.
4,00,000/- inasmuch as Rs. 15,00,000 was the Earnest Money
Deposit which was required to be submitted.
11. This Court also finds it pertinent to take note of that for the
same reason, there were two other bidders who were rejected,
i.e. M/s
Garg & Garg Co. and M/s Mech Fab Engineering
Industries Pvt. Ltd.
12. Before proceeding further, it is pertinent to take note of the
Bid Document which was submitted by the Petitioner. The bid
which was required to be submitted online had a specific column
for “EMD Exemption”. The Petitioner while submitting the online
bid insofar as the EMD Exemption only referred to the BRO
enlistment. This aspect is apparent from Annexure-1 to the
affidavit-in-opposition
filed
by
the
Respondents
dated
27.01.2026.
13.
The record further reveals that the Petitioner on coming to
learn that its technical bid was not recommended by the Board
of Officers on 09.09.2025, submitted a representation on
12.09.2025 stating inter alia that the Petitioner's firm is
registered with the MSME under relevant category and their
MSME registration certificate was attached at Pages 30 & 31 with
Page No.# 10/29
the file named "2Alldocuments1_compressed.pdf" and also at
Pages 13 and 14 of the file named "1_certificates.pdf". The
Petitioner requested by the representation dated 12.09.2025 that
this document was overlooked by the Respondent Organization,
and therefore, requested that the Petitioner's firm should be
declared technically qualified and eligible for Financial Bid
opening.
14.
On the receipt of the said communication as would appear
from the additional affidavit filed by the Respondent No.4 on
20.02.2026, the Q-bid was not opened which was otherwise
fixed on 16.09.2025. It is also seen that on 22nd of September,
2025, the Director (Contracts) had issued a communication to
the Petitioner stating inter alia that during the scrutiny of the Qbid, it was found that the Petitioner's firm had not submitted the
declaration as per Rule 170 (iii) of the GFR, 2017 and as per
Clause 11 of the NIT regarding exemption sought due to MSME
registration against EMD for Rs.15,00,000/-. It was also
mentioned that as per the Rule 170(i) of the GFR, 2017, the Bid
Security also known as the Earnest Money, is to be obtained
from the bidders, except micro and small enterprises. However,
the uploaded MSME certificate by the Petitioner's firm was for
medium enterprise; hence, exemption of the EMD was not
applicable. It was further mentioned that the firm of the
Page No.# 11/29
Petitioner was therefore disqualified for the subject bid.
15.
The record further reveals that the Petitioner again
submitted another representation on 23.09.2025 stating inter alia
that the Government of India Notification No.1346 dated
21.03.2025
in
the
Gazette
of
India
had
changed
the
categorization of the medium, micro and small enterprises and
as per the revised Notification and the change in the guidelines,
the categorization of the Petitioner Company as per the MSME is
now small and not medium. It was further mentioned that the
same could be verified on the portal of the MSME. The Petitioner
therefore requested that in order to avoid unnecessary wastage
of time, the Petitioner's firm should be declared technically
responsive, otherwise the Petitioner would have no other option
but to seek legal recourse. The Petitioner enclosed the
Notification dated 21.03.2025 issued by the Ministry of Micro,
Small and Medium Enterprises.
A perusal of the said Notification reveals that the
categorization of micro, small and medium enterprises which
existed as on 26th of June, 2020 was changed. For example, an
enterprise where the investment in plant and machinery or
equipment does not exceed Rs.2 crores 50 lakhs and turnover
does not exceed Rs.10 crores was brought within the ambit of a
Page No.# 12/29
“micro enterprise”; an enterprise where the investment in plant
and machinery or equipment does not exceed Rs.25 crores and
the turnover does not exceed Rs.100 crores were brought within
the ambit of a “small enterprise”. It is also pertinent to mention
that an enterprise where the investment in plant and machinery
or equipment does not exceed Rs.125 crores and turnover does
not exceed Rs.500 crores was brought within the ambit of a
“medium enterprise”.
16.
This Court further finds it pertinent to take note of that on
7th of October, 2025, another communication was issued by the
Director
(Contracts)
in
reference
to
the
Petitioner's
representation dated 23.09.2025 and it was categorically
mentioned that as per the Government of India Gazette
Notification S.O.1364E dated 21.03.2025 and upon verification of
the Petitioner's MSME on the Udyam registration portal, the
Petitioner's certificate was showing as “small enterprise”. It was
further mentioned that to be eligible for MSME renewal, the
business must meet the criteria, i.e. annual update required and
what were the consequences for not updating.
17.
The said communication dated 07.10.2025 is relevant
inasmuch as, it appears that the Respondent Organization have
sought from the Petitioner certain additional documents which
Page No.# 13/29
were not conceivable as per Clause 20 of the Notice Inviting
Tender. The Petitioner was asked to submit proof of the annual
update details, i.e. latest Income Tax details duly verified by the
CA and GST filing information uploaded in the Udyam registration
portal for the financial year 2024-25 along with all supporting
documents uploaded before the date of the NIT and also submit
the hard copy of the MSME certificate issued to the Petitioner by
the Udyam Registration Authority by 10th of October, 2025 for
further needful action. The said communication dated 07.10.2025
is reproduced herein under:“SGF Infra Pvt Ltd
Gurha Bakshi Nagar Jammu
Birpur, Purmandal Morh Road,
Bari Brahmana
Email - sgfjammu@gmail.com
NAME OF WORK: DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OF 120 (80+40) METER SPAN
MAJOR PERMANENT BRIDGE WITH INTERMEDIATE PIER WITH STEEL
SUPERSTRUCTURE (THROUGH TYPE) ON OPEN FOUNDATION OVER
PEEPANI-II NALLAH AT KM 32.200 (INCLUDING CASTING OF DECK SLAB,
WEARING COAT, KERBS AND HAND RAILS, DRAINAGE SPOUT, PROCUREMENT
AND FIXING OF BEARING AND EXPANSION JOINTS, PAINTING, LOAD TESTING
COMPLETED IN ALL RESPECT) ON HAYULIANG-METALIANG-CHAGLOHAGAM
ROAD UNDER 1444 BCC/48 BRTF UNDER PROJECT UDAYAK IN ARUNACHAL
PRADESH STATE : TENDER ID 2025_BRO_716414_1
Dear Sir,
1.
Reference your letter No SGF/7728 dated 12 Sep 2025.
2.
In this connection, it is intimated that as per Govt of India, Gazette
Notification S.O. 1364 (E) dated 21 Mar 2025 and on verification of your
MSME on Udyam Registration Portal, your certificate is showing as 'Small'
Page No.# 14/29
enterprises.
3.
But, as per norms of MSME regulations, to be eligible for MSME renewal,
your business must meet the following criteria updated every year:(a) Annual update required:
You must update your registration detail, including your latest Income Tax
and GST filing information, on the Udyam portal at the end of every financial
year. The update process is done online on the official Udyam Registration
Portal.
(b) Consequences of Not Updating:
Failure to update your details can lead to the loss of access to benefits,
schemes and tenders available to MSMEs.
In view of above, it is requested to submit the proof of annual update
details i.e. latest income tax details duly signed by CA and GST filing
information uploaded on Udyam Registration Portal for the F/Y 2024-25 along
with all supporting docs uploaded before the date of NIT and also submit the
hard copy of MSME certificate issued to you by Udyam Registration Authority by
10 Oct 2025 for our further needful action please.”
18.
The Petitioner vide a communication dated 09.10.2025
referred to Point No.2 of the MSME Certificate which was issued
to the Petitioner wherein it was mentioned that after completion
of the process of registration, a certificate would be issued
online. This communication was to indicate that the MSME
Certificate is only issued online.
19.
The Petitioner further to the above, issued another
communication dated 10.10.2025 thereby enclosing the latest
MSME/Udyam Certificate for the year 2025-26, downloaded from
Page No.# 15/29
the Udyam registration portal. A perusal of the said certificate
reveals that for the year 2025-26, the Petitioner's enterprise was
classified as “small” and the date of classification was on
01.04.2025.
20. Pursuant thereto, the Respondents issued the impugned
approval of the Competent Authority whereby the Petitioner was
again held to be disqualified, but for different reasons from the
reasons which were mentioned in the recommendation made by
the Board of Officers dated 09.09.2025. The reasons for
disqualification, as per the impugned Approval of the Competent
Authority dated 07.11.2025 were:“(a)
Due to non producing hard copy MSME certificate of ‘Small’
Category.
(b) Non submission of proof for uploading of updation of MSME
Registration Authority. Hence disqualified.”
21.
The Petitioner, being aggrieved, therefore approached this
Court by filing the present writ petition.
22.
The records reveal that vide an order dated 26.11.2025, this
Court issued notice, but was not inclined to pass any interim
direction. Be that as it may, it was observed at Paragraph No.16
of the order dated 26.11.2025 that any agreement entered into
by the Respondent Authorities with the Respondent No.11 during
Page No.# 16/29
the pendency of the writ petition, the same shall be subject to
the outcome of the writ petition and the fact that this Court was
not inclined to grant any interim directions on 26.11.2025, shall
not create any equitable interest in favour of the Respondent
No.11.
23. The records further reveal that the Respondent No. 4 has filed
an affidavit-in-opposition. The Respondent No.11 has also filed
an affidavit-in-opposition. Various other pleadings have also been
exchanged. It is however pertinent to take note of that the
affidavit filed by the Respondent No.4 on 20.02.2026 wherein the
reasons for disqualification of the Petitioner’s bid was elaborated.
A perusal of paragraph No.3 of the said affidavit filed by the
Respondent No.4 reveals that the Technical Bid was opened on
31.07.2025 and the Technical Evaluation Summary was uploaded
on 09.09.2025. It is also mentioned that though the Schedule
date of the Q-Bid opening date was on 16.09.2025, but the same
was postponed on account of submission of the representation
by the Petitioner and it was only on 07.11.2025 the Final
Technical Evaluation Summary was uploaded and the Financial
Bid was opened. It was further mentioned at paragraph No.4
that the Petitioner was disqualified on two independent and
objective grounds, i.e. (i) failure to submit the prescribed EMD of
Rs.15,00,000/-; and (ii) ineligibility to claim MSME exemption as
Page No.# 17/29
the MSME certificate uploaded with the bid classified the
Petitioner as “medium enterprise” which is not exempted under
Rule 171 of the GFR, 2017. The Petitioner thereupon submitted a
reply to the said additional affidavit on 25.02.2026.
SUBMISSIONS MADE BY THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR THE
PARTIES
24.
Mr. R. Pant, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf
of the Petitioner submitted that a perusal of the impugned
approval of the Competent Authority reveals that the Petitioner
was disqualified on the ground of non-submission of the hard
copy that the Petitioner was a small enterprise. The learned
Senior Counsel submitted that the Petitioner was granted an
opportunity by the Respondent Authorities vide a communication
dated 07.10.2025 to submit the hard copy on or before 10 th of
October, 2025. The Petitioner duly submitted on 09.10.2025 a
reply stating inter-alia that even as per the Udyam Registration
Authority and as mentioned in the MSME certificate, the
certificate is issued online. The original MSME certificate
downloaded from the portal on 5th of March, 2021 and
subsequent qua registration on 17th of March, 2021 was
enclosed. The Petitioner further mentioned that for the year
2024-25, the returns were not required to be submitted at that
Page No.# 18/29
relevant point of time. Be that as it may, a clarification was
issued on 28th of September, 2021 by the Ministry of Micro, Small
and Medium Enterprises wherein it was mentioned that as to
which of the financial years are required to be taken for the
purpose of registration in the Udyam Portal. The learned Senior
Counsel for the Petitioner further submitted that on 10.10.2025,
the Petitioner had downloaded a copy of the MSME Udyam
certificate of the Petitioner for the year 2025- 26 and had also
submitted the same. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that
in that view of the matter, the reasons for which the Petitioner's
bid was held to be technically disqualified appears to be a case
of malice in law and non-application of mind. He further
submitted that under such circumstances, this Court in exercise
of the powers under Article 226 of the Constitution ought to
interfere as it violates the mandate of Article 14 of the
Constitution.
25. Mr. H. Gupta, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondent Authorities submitted that the Petitioner herein at
the time of submission of the bid did not claim exemption of the
EMD on the basis of being an MSME enterprise. Apart from that
at the time when the bid documents were uploaded and hard
copy of the same were submitted, the Petitioner also knew that
the Petitioner could not avail the EMD exemption inasmuch as,
Page No.# 19/29
the certificate which was uploaded was a MSME Registration
showing the Petitioner as a Medium Enterprise. Referring to Rule
170(i) of the GFR, 2017, the learned CGC submitted that the
Earnest Money exemption is only available to micro and small
enterprise and as the Petitioner herein was not a micro or small
or claimed to be a micro or a small enterprise at that relevant
point of time, the Petitioner therefore was disqualified. He further
submitted that the Petitioner cannot be permitted to submit any
further documents pursuant to the bid being submitted as the
same would violate the mandate of the equality Clause. The
learned CGC further submitted that the opportunity so given vide
the communication dated 07.10.2025 was not in accordance with
Clause 20 of the Notice Inviting Tender.
26.
Ms. T. Gupta, the learned counsel who appears on behalf of
the Respondent No.11 submitted that the Petitioner having not
claimed EMD exemption as an MSME and having only submitted
an MSME certificate as a medium enterprise, the Respondent
Authorities were justified in disqualifying the Petitioner as
technically non-responsive. The learned counsel submitted that a
conjoint reading of Clauses 11 & 20 of the Notice Inviting Tender
would clearly show that not only the bidder has to be an enlisted
contractor under the BRO, but also has to be a MSME as per Rule
170 (i) of the GFR, 2017 to be entitled to exemption. The learned
Page No.# 20/29
counsel submitted that to be entitled to exemption as a MSME,
there should be a claim for exemption which the Petitioner did
not do so in as much as the Petitioner’s bid document which is at
Page No.367 of the Paper Book would clearly show that the
Petitioner only claimed EMD exemption on the basis of BRO
enlistment and not on the basis of the MSME certificate. Apart
from that, the learned counsel for the Respondent No.11
submitted the Petitioner knew very well that the Petitioner was
not entitled to claim exemption and this aspect would be
apparent from the fact that the Petitioner did not submit the
MSME certificate showing it to be a small enterprise, rather
submitted a certificate showing the Petitioner as a medium
enterprise. The learned counsel submitted that the Petitioner at a
later stage is trying to develop a case of exemption as a Small
Enterprise by taking advantage of certain communications issued
by the Director (Contracts) of the Respondent Organization. The
learned counsel for the Respondent No.11 therefore submitted
that the Respondent Authorities cannot deviate from essential
conditions of the tender documents and more particularly Clause
20 of the Notice Inviting Tender whereby the bidders were to
submit all documents through the online mode prior to the
closing of the bid submission date and hard copies within 5 (five)
days from the last date of submission of the bid. The learned
Page No.# 21/29
counsel therefore submitted that the reasons for disqualification
may not seem to be proper at the first glance, but the Petitioner
under no circumstances can be permitted to be qualified as the
Petitioner never claimed exemption under the MSME category at
the first instance.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
27.
This Court has given anxious consideration to the respective
submissions and has also perused the materials on record.
28. In the previous segments of the instant judgment, this Court
had quoted Clause No.11 of the Notice Inviting Tender. This
Court finds it pertinent to reproduce Clause 20 of the said Notice
Inviting Tender herein under:“20. The scanned copy of original instruments in respect of earnest
money, Integrity Pact duly signed on each page by the bidder(s),
and under taking regarding acceptance of tender conditions,
Enlistment letter if firm is enlisted in BRO, EPFO, Registration letter,
GST Registration and any other documents required to be submitted
with respect to various conditions mentioned in the tender
documents must be uploaded along with the technical bid. The Hard
copies of all the documents should reach the tender Inviting
Authority in the sealed envelope within 05 days of bid submission
end date.”
29.
A conjoint reading of Clauses 11 & 20 of the Notice Inviting
Page No.# 22/29
Tender would show that the earnest money is not required to be
attached with the tender by a valid enlisted contractor with the
BRO who had submitted standing security deposit and MSME
registered firm as per Rule 170(i) of the GFR, 2017. However, in
respect to others, there is a requirement of submission of the
security deposit of Rs.15,00,000/-A further perusal of Clause 20
in the context of Clause 11 would show that the documents
pertaining to the earnest money or the original instruments
pertaining to the earnest money had to be uploaded and hard
copies of the same are required to be submitted within five days
from the bid submission end date. The bid submission end date
was on 16th of July, 2025. Under such circumstances, all bidders
including the Petitioner, if they claim for exemption from deposit
of the Earnest Money Deposit were required to submit the
documents claiming for exemption of the Earnest Money Deposit
by uploading the same along with the bid and further within five
days thereafter, the hard copy/copies of such documents are
required to be submitted. Further to that, those bidders who do
not claim for exemption are required to submit the Earnest
Money Deposit in the form stipulated at Clause 11 of the Notice
Inviting Tender by uploading the same and thereupon within five
days from the bid submission end date to submit the hard copy.
30.
The bid documents of the Petitioner which have been placed
Page No.# 23/29
before this Court by Mr. H Gupta, the learned CGC clearly shows
that at the time of submission of the bid, the Petitioner though
claimed EMD exemption, but did so on the basis of the BRO
enlistment as the same is apparent from the column relating to
EMD Exemption and with the file name '3-BRO-Enlistment.pdf'. It
is also seen that various other documents were also uploaded by
the Petitioner under the heading 'Bidders other important
documents'.
31. A perusal of the representation submitted by the Petitioner on
12.09.2025 reveals that the Petitioner had uploaded the MSME
registration certificate under the headings “Bid document” and
“Bidders other important documents”. It is an admitted case of
the Petitioner that the MSME certificate which was uploaded
would show that the Petitioner as a medium enterprise. Applying
Rule 170(i) of the GFR, 2017 as quoted hereinabove, a medium
enterprise would not be entitled to claim exemption of the
Earnest Money Deposit in as much as it is only a micro enterprise
or a small enterprise who would be entitled to the exemption of
the Earnest Money Deposit in terms with Rule 170 (i) of the GFR,
2017.
32.
This Court finds it very relevant to take note of that in the
recommendations which were made by the Board of Officers on
09.09.2025, the Petitioner along with two other bidders, namely
Page No.# 24/29
M/s Garg & Garg Co. and M/s Mech Fab Engineering Industries
Pvt. Ltd. were disqualified on the same ground that the Petitioner
along with the said two firms claimed EMD exemption of
Rs.15,00,000/- but as per their BRO enlistment the limit was
Rs.11,00,000/- and they did not submit the additional security
amount. The Petitioner thereafter on coming to learn that the
Petitioner was not recommended to be qualified by the Board of
Officers in the compilation made of the Bidders on 09.09.2025,
submitted a representation dated 12.09.2025 stating inter alia
that the Petitioner being an MSME was entitled to EMD
exemption. At that stage also the Petitioner did not inform that it
was a small enterprise and not a medium enterprise.
33.
This Court at this stage finds it very relevant to take note of
the Notice Inviting Tender wherein the Critical Date Sheet was
incorporated. The Critical Date Sheet reveals that the Notice
Inviting Tender was issued on 24.06.2025 and on the very date,
the clarification could have been sought for. The clarification was
permissible uptil 1st of July, 2025. There was also a scope for a
pre-bid meeting to be held on 2 nd of July, 2025 uptil 1200 hours
and the bid submission date also started on 2 nd of July, 2025
after 1200 hours. Nothing has been placed before the Court to
show
that
the
Respondent
Authorities
can
entertain
Page No.# 25/29
representations subsequent to the submission of the closing date
of the bid. Be that as it may, the Respondent Authorities
entertained not only one representation, but two representations
from the Petitioner and further permitted the Petitioner to submit
further documents in addition to what was permissible in terms
with Clause 20 of the Notice Inviting Tender.
34.
It further appears from the records that the Respondent
Authorities initially on 22.09.2025 rejected the Petitioner's
representation on the ground of non-compliance to Rule 170(iii)
of the GFR, 2017 and further in terms with Clause 11 of the
Notice Inviting Tender on the ground that the Petitioner had
uploaded the MSME Certificate claiming itself as medium
enterprise and as such, the question of permitting EMD
exemption was not permissible.
35.
The records also show that the Petitioner filed another
representation was on 23.09.2025. However, surprisingly, the
Director (Contracts) of the Respondent Organization not only
permitted the Petitioner to submit further documents beyond
what was permissible in terms with Clause 20 of the Notice
Inviting Tender but also mentioned that the Petitioner was shown
as a Small Enterprise in the Udhayam Portal. This communication
dated 07.10.2025 issued by the Director (Contracts) of the
Respondent Organization led the Petitioner to submit two
Page No.# 26/29
communications. One on 09.10.2025 stating inter alia that the
MSME Certificate is issued online and the second communication
dated 10.10.2025 whereby the Petitioner submitted the hard
copy of the MSME Certificate wherein for the year 2025-26, the
Petitioner was shown as a Small Enterprise.
36.
The records reveal that though the Director (Contracts)
permitted the Petitioner to submit additional documents and the
Petitioner submitted the MSME Certificate but the Competent
Authority did not accept the same resulting in rejection of the
Petitioner’s technical bid for not producing the hard copy of the
Petitioner’s MSME Certificate as Small Enterprise and that the
Petitioner did not submit the proof for uploading of updation of
the MSME Authority.
37.
Two aspects therefore come to light from the conduct of the
Respondents. One, the Director (Contracts) of the Respondent
Authorities had permitted the Petitioner to submit additional
documents vide the communication dated 07.10.2025 and the
Petitioner having submitted the same was not accepted by the
Competent Authority. The said aspect shows that there appears
to be some form of inconsistency amongst the Respondent
Organization inasmuch as the Director (Contracts) permits the
Petitioner
to
submit
additional
documents
whereas
the
Competent Authority do not consider the same and holds that
Page No.# 27/29
the Petitioner did not submit the hard copy of the document of
MSME registration as Small Enterprise.
The second aspect is that the Respondent Organization or
more particularly, the Director (Contracts) have changed the
Rules of the game at a subsequent stage thereby permitting the
Petitioner to file additional documents though the same was
contrary to Clause 20 of the Notice Inviting Tender. In the
previous segments of the instant judgment, this Court had taken
note of that the Petitioner along with two other bidders were
held to be not qualified on the same ground that they claimed
EMD exemption on the basis of BRO Enlistment and they were
short by Rs. 4,00,000/- as their security was only Rs. 11,00,000/and the required EMD was Rs. 15,00,000/-. Under such
circumstances, to permit only the Petitioner to file additional
documents renders such action violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
38. It is the opinion of this Court that the present lis is on account
of the inconsistent stands taken by the officers of the
Respondent Organization i.e. the Director (Contracts) permitting
the Petitioner
to file additional documents whereas the
Competent Authority who took the decision on 07.11.2025 not
accepting the documents. It is also the opinion of this Court that
if the Respondent Organization had permitted the Petitioner to
Page No.# 28/29
submit the additional documents and thereupon the Petitioner
had submitted the documents i.e. the MSME Certificate that the
Petitioner was a Small Enterprise, the impugned approval dated
07.11.2025 rejecting the Petitioner’s bid cannot stand the
scrutiny of law. At the same breath, it is also pertinent to
mention that permitting the Petitioner only to submit additional
documents violates the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution
of India.
39.
The impugned approval dated 07.11.2025 is therefore
required to be interfered with.
40.
Accordingly, this Court therefore disposes of the instant writ
petition with the following observations and directions:(i) The impugned approval of the Competent Authority
dated 07.11.2025 is set aside and quashed.
(ii) The Respondent Authorities are directed to re-evaluate
the Technical Bids of the bidders who submitted their bids
pursuant to the Notice Inviting Tender dated 24.06.2025
from the stage of the recommendation made by the Board
of Officers on 09.09.2025.
(iii) The Respondent Organization is directed to take steps
for removing the inconsistent stand amongst the officials of
the Respondent Organization.
Page No.# 29/29
(iv) In the circumstances, the Respondent Organization is
of the opinion that further opportunities should be given to
the bidders who have not been recommended for opening
of their financial bids, then opportunities have to be
provided
to
all
the
bidders
who
have
not
been
recommended by the Board of Officers. Picking only one
bidder to submit additional documents thereby not granting
opportunity to the others would be violation of Article 14 of
the Constitution of India.
(v) This Court further observes and directs that all
consequential actions so taken on the basis of the
impugned approval of the Competent Authority dated
07.11.2025 are also set aside and quashed thereby leaving
the Respondent Organization to act in terms with Clauses
(ii), (iii) and (iv) herein above.
(vi) There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
signed by Pradip Kumar Kalita
Pradip Kumar Kalita Digitally
Date: 2026.03.19 10:50:54 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review