Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 26-02-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE N. ANAND VENKATESH
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
1. S Chandraprakash Jain
S/o.G.Sampath Raj
No 21/9, Cenotaph Road, Second
Lane, Alwarpet, Chennai
Applicant(s)
Vs
1. M/s GOD Pictures
rep by its Proprietor and Director,
Prabhu Solomon, No.57, 2nd
street, Valasaravakkam,
Chennai 600 093.
2.Gemini FX
Rep. By Its Authorized Signatory,
Having Office At No 28, New
Bangaru Colony, West K.K.
Nagar, Chennai.
3.Pen India Private Limited,
Represented By Its Authorised
Signatory Mr. Vishal Lahu Rane,
Having Its Reg Office At Pen
House, Asha Colony, Juhu Tara
Road, Juhu, Mumbai 400 049 (3rd
Respondent Impleaded As Per
Order Dt 14.11.2025 In
A.no.5656/2025)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
Respondent(s)
PRAYER
Arbitration Application filed under Section 9 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 praying to grant an ad interim injunction
restraining the respondents from distributing and releasing the
movie Kumki 2 pending determination of the final arbitration.
For Applicant(s): Mr. K.Vijayaragavan
For
Mr.K.Dhananjayan
Respondent(s):
ORDER
When the matter came up for hearing on 12.11.2025, this
Court passed the following order:-
This application has been filed under Section 9 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, [for brevity 'the
Act'] seeking an order of interim injunction restraining the
respondents from distributing and releasing the movie
“Kumki 2” pending determination of the final arbitration.
2. Heard Mr.Abudu Kumar Rajaratnam, learned Senior
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
Counsel for applicant and carefully perused the materials
available on record.
3. The applicant is doing finance business and mainly
providing finance towards film production. The first
respondent is the Director of the film, who had previously
directed the movie “Kumki” and he is presently producing
and directing the movie “Kumki 2”. The second respondent
is the visual effects company, which has given a
confirmation letter dated 23.07.2018 to the applicant in
respect of the movie.
4. The first respondent previously directed the Tamil
movie “Kumki” in the year 2012. Thereafter, the first
respondent started producing and directing the movie
“Kumki-2” for which the first respondent required
financial facilities. Hence, the first respondent approached
the applicant seeking for financial assistance to the tune of
Rs.1,50,00,000/- (One Crore and Fifty Lakhs only). They
entered into a finance agreement dated 25.07.2018 and as
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
per this agreement, the applicant had lent a sum of
Rs.1,50,00,000/-, which will carry interest at 24% p.a.
This amount is supposed to be repaid along with interest
on or before six months from the date of the agreement or 7
days prior to the general release of the movie, whichever is
earlier. The first respondent has also undertaken not to
release or commercially exploit the movie in any manner
without repaying the loan amount to the applicant. The
confirmation letter to that effect was also obtained from
the second respondent on 23.07.2018.
5. The first respondent failed to repay the loan within the
time stipulated under the agreement and ultimately, both
parties
arrived
at
a
settlement
whereby
the
first
respondent agreed to pay a sum of Rs.2,50,00,000/- for the
amount that was financed by the applicant and the first
respondent also reiterated that this amount will be settled
ten days before the release of the movie and gave a further
assurance that without settling the dues, the first
respondent will not release the movie nor will allow
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
anyone to release the movie prior to settling dues. The
Application No.1463 of 2025 grievance of the applicant is
that the first respondent, in complete disregard to the
agreement, is taking steps to release the movie “Kumki2”.
It is under these circumstances, the present application
came to be filed.
6. A prima facie case has been made out by the applicant
and the balance of convenience is in favour of the
applicant since if the applicant is not given interim
protection and the movie is released, the applicant will not
be able to recover the amount. If the movie is released, the
applicant will also be put to irreparable loss and
hardship. In view of the above, there shall be an order of
interim injunction as prayed for till 03.12.2025.
7. Notice to the respondent returnable by 03.12.2025.
Private notice is also permitted. The applicant shall
comply with Order XXXIX Rule 3 CPC. List this case on
03.12.2025.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
2.
The matter was once again listed for hearing on
14.11.2025 and the following order came to be passed by this Court:Mr.Vijay Narayan and Mr.ARL.Sundaresan, learned
Senior counsels appearing for the applicant-Pen India
Private
Limtied
in
the
Impleading
Application
in
Arb.Appl.No.1463 of 2025, seek permission of this court to
get impleaded and to vacate the interim injunction ordered
by this court dated..12.11.2025 in Arbitration No.1463 of
2025.
2. This Impleading Petition is ordered as prayed for. Pen
India Private Limited shall be impleaded as 3rd
respondent in Arb.Appln.No.1463 of 2025.
3. The contentions advanced by Mr.Vijay Narayan,
learned Senior counsel appearing for the newly impleaded
respondent/Respondent No.3 are as follows:
(A) The applicant who is a Financier for the movie “Kumki
2” entered into an agreement viz., Film Line-Production
and Direction Agreement
dated 10.06.2017 with GOD
pictures, Proprietor viz., Prabhu Solomon who is the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
Director of film Kumki 2.
(B) In the Finance Agreement dated 25.07.2018 entered
into between the 1st respondent viz., M/s.GOD Pictures
rep by its Proprietor and Director Prabhu Solomon and
the applicant viz., Chandraprakash Jain [Applicant in
Arb.Appl.No.1463/2025], the 1st respondent has stated
that he is the Director and Producer of the Movie Kumki 2
(Production No.3) which is found in the typed set of papers
filed in the application. In the said agreement, the 1st
respondent in clause 13 had invoked the clause of referring
any dispute arising from and out of the said agreement to
arbitration under a sole arbitrator to be mutually
appointed under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 and the venue of arbitration is fixed at Chennai.
Therefore, a Personal Guarantee was given by the 1st
respondent -Prabhu Solomon, Director, on behalf of GOD
Pictures
Director,
Arb.App.No.1463
who
of
is
the
2nd
respondent
2025.
The
personal
in
guarantee
executed by the 2nd respondent acknowledges that the
agreement may be amended from time to time by the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
parties thereto without recourse to him and was agreed
that no such amendment shall release the Guarantor from
his liability under the Guarantee either in whole or in
part.
(C) Based on such guarantee given by the 1st respondent
and thereafter, by a letter dated 17.12.2020 issued by the
1st
respondent
in
favour
of
the
applicant
in
Arb.Appl.No.1463 of 2025 viz., Chandraprakash Jain,
a
sum of Rs.1,50,00,000/- was advanced. Thereafter on
15.04.2023, the applicant -Film producer and financier
addressed a letter to the 1st respondent Prabhu Solomon,
informing that based on a mutual agreement entered into
between them, a sum of Rs.1,50,00,000/- was paid to the
1st respondent. Again, by a letter dated 18.04.2023, the 1st
respondent addressed to the applicant and reiterated that
he will settle the amount as agreed between them before
the release the movie Kumki 2 and that he will settle the
amount as agreed and further assure that without settling
the dues, he will not release the movie nor allow anyone to
release the movie prior to settling the dues.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
(D) Based on the above communications, the advertisement
came to be published on November 5, 2024 that Kumki 2
will be released on November 14, 2025.
(E) It is further represented that Jayantilal V.Gada is the
Chairman and Managing Director for Pen India Limited
and advertised for release on November 14, 2025 world
wide. The said advertisement would go to show that 9
days to go for release of Kumki 2.
(F) Mr.Vijaya Narayan and Mr.ARL.Sundaresan, learned
senior counsels contended that the 1st respondent was
made to believe that the applicant who is the Director and
producer of the movie, received a sum of Rs.1,50,00,000/by way of various arrangements and settlements are due
between the applicant and the 1st respondent.
(G) Learned Senior counsel further submitted
that on
10.06.2017, an agreement was entered into between the
PEN India Limited who are the producers of the film
(Impleading applicant) and GOD Pictures/1st respondent.
In the said agreement, in Clause 2, the 1st respondent was
referred
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
as
GP/Director/Line-Producer.
Mr.Vijay
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
Narayan, learned Senior counsel explained to the court
that Line-Producer will coordinate and facilitate all the
arrangements for the smooth shooting of the film and so
the term is classified as Line-Producer.
(H) In the said agreement dated 10.06.2017, the producer
in Clause 5 has specifically state that PEN is the sole
Producer of the Film and will hold all rights in the Film to
be produced hereunder and will be the author
in Arb.
Appln. No.1463 of 2025 thereof and first owner of
copyright therein. GP (God Pictures) will carry out the
line-production for the Film for Pen and will direct the
Film. GP will have no rights in the Film whatsoever,
except the right to receive remuneration for its services as
Line Producer and Director for the Film, as provided
herein.
(I) Learned Senior counsel further pointed out that as per
the agreement, in Clause 5 speaks about Intellectual
Property Rights stating that the Film shall be owned solely
by Pen and Pen shall be the sole owner of the Intellectual
Property
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Rights
and
all
other
Rights,
including
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
underlying rights in the Film and all future rights as the
author of the Film and the first owner of copyright therein
in perpetuity throughout the world.
(J) The learned Senior counsel would further point out
that under Clause 3 Direction and Production Services,
under sub-clause 3.3, 3.4 and 3.5, it is stated that GP
hereby agrees that PEN shall have a right to appoint one
Executive Producer (“Pen EP”) on the Film and the EP
shall at all times have access to the sets. The said
agreement was signed by Jayantilal Gada For PEN and
by Prabu Solomon Producer for GP.
(K) In the above said agreement, First amendment
agreement was entered into with the producer Pen India
Limited and the 1st respondent GOD Pictures and further
the impleading applicant Pen India Limited is the
Producers of the film.
(L) The learned senior counsel further contended that the
Censor Certificate was issued to film Kumki 2 for which
application was filed by M/s.PEN India Limited, Mumbai
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
and Censor Certificate was issued on 20.06.2025. The
production from thereafter only reflects the name of the
producer viz.,PEN India Pvt Ltd, Mumbai.
(M) The learned senior counsel pointed out that when the
Censor certificate was issued in the name of PEN India
Limited, which is the important factor for the film, it is
clear that the impleaded applicant is the producer of the
film and the certificate reflects the name of the impleading
applicant only. When the Producers name reflected in the
Censor Certificate, any other claim or issues are to be
adjudicated before the Arbitration Authority at the time of
Arbitration Proceedings.
4. Mr.Abudu Kumar Rajartnam, learned Senior counsel
for the applicant
in Arb.App.No.1463 of 2025 submits
that everything emanated only from 2nd respondent who
had
entered
into
agreement
with
the
applicant
-Chandraprakash Jain on 25.07.2018, where he has
projected himself as Producer/Director for the Film and
thereby, the applicant parted Rs.1,50,00,000/- with 24%
interest and thereafter, a Personal Guarantee was given by
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
the 2nd respondent-GOD Pictures.
Based on the said
Personal Guarantee, Gemini FX, the 2nd respondent in
Arb.App.1463 of 2025 communicated a letter to Applicant
(Chandraprakash Jain) dated 23.07.2018 with reference to
Kumki 2 (Production No.3). The contents of the said letter
is as follows:
“ We are in receipt of a letter dated 23/07/2018 from
M/s.God Pictures
.........................informing us therein
that they have entered into a finance arrangement with
you by creating the first and paramount charge over
Negatives (both Picture and Sound) of the above film with
Commercial, Theatrical exhibition rights throughout the
World including India in all dimensions of Scope, 35mm,
16mm, 8 mm, Audio, Video, VCD, DVD, DTH, LCD, LD,
CD,
Cable
TV,
Internet,
SMS
(audio
and
video
messaging), portal, terrestrial, airborne, sea, surface,
railborne, transport, telephony, mobile phone, Blueray,
satelite broadcasing, Doordarshan channels, electronic
and electric media rights and remaking and dubbing
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
rights in all other languages as security in your favour.
Therefore they thereby have irrevocably requested us to
confirm the above charges in your favour and also to
confirm.
..... We hereby confirm that we have made a note of the
above
and
would
act
accordingly.
However,
this
confirmation is subject to our first and paramount charge
and possessory lien with absolute rights of alienation over
the Negatives, Positives including all Broadcasting
Rights...... .........”
5. Based on the above letter dated 23.07.2018, the
applicant claimed that the assurance given by the 2nd
respondent-GOD Pictures should repay the amount with
interest and that unless repayment of the loan is
forthcoming, he will ensure that the movie will not be
released.
6. Mr.P.V.Balasubramanian, learned Senior counsel for
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
the 2nd respondent-M/s.GOD Pictures contended that
firstly, the documents relied on by the Applicant is
disputed. Secondly, the agreement dated 25.07.2018
entered into between the applicant and the 2nd respondent
and also the Personal Guarantee dated 25.07.2018 and the
letters of correspondence between the applicant and the
2nd respondent dated 17.12.2020, 15.04.2023, 18.04.2023
are also disputed. He would further contend that as the
dispute is raised with regard to agreement entered into
between the applicant and the 2nd
respondent with
regard to false claim made by the applicant saying
is
parted only at the instance of the 1st respondent and based
on the Personal Guarantee entered into between them, the
said amount was given to the 1st respondent in the
capacity of the Director and producer of the said movie.
7. Mr.P.V.Balasubramanian, learned Senior counsel for
the 2nd respondent/GOD Pictures further contended that
there is no necessity for him to enter into the agreement
with the applicant when the entire movie is financed by the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
proposed impleaded applicant viz., Pen India Limited.
The 1st respondent has not disputed the agreement dated
10.06.2017 who is the Producer of the Film Kumki 2 and
coupled with the fact that the Censor Certificate stands in
the name of the Producer Pen India Limited. The learned
Senior counsel would further state that the above said
disputed facts are to be proved only during arbitral
proceedings.
8. Heard the submissions made on both sides and perused
the records.
9. The 1st respondent, without going into the agreement
dated 10.06.2017 entered into between him and the Pen
India Limited (now impleaded 3rd respondent) disputed
the agreements entered into with applicant. In such
circumstances, this court, by order dated 12.11.2025 in the
Arb.Application moved by the applicant granted interim
injunction from distributing and release the movie “Kumki
2.” Therefore, the 2nd respondent-M/s.GOD Pictures shall
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
deposit a sum of Rs.1,00,00,000/- [Rupees One crore only]
to the credit of Arbitration Application No.1463 of 2025
before the Registry, within three weeks from today.
10. The 2nd Respondent specifically admitted that he has
entered into agreement with the impleaded applicant
producer
viz.,
Pen
India
Limited\
impleaded
3rd
respondent in Arb.App. dated 10.06.2017 and also
admitted that the movie was about to be released on
14.11.2025.
11.
Mr.Abudu
Kumar
Rajaratnam,
learned
Senior
Counsel and Mr.M.Suresh, are concerned only in respect of
the pending payment issue with regard to the 1st
respondent.
12. Further, the 2nd respondent-GOD Pictures had written
a letter dated 23.07.2018 to the 3rd respondent-Gemini
stating that he had received payment from the Financier
(Applicant) and therefore, the Negative rights will be
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
withheld by him.
13. It is made clear, that the Producer viz., the newly
impleaded 3rd respondent is the Producer of the film
Kumki 2 and the Censor Certificate also stands in the
name of the said producer viz., Pen India Private Limited
(Respondent No.3).
Therefore, the impleaded 3rd
respondent-PEN India Private Limited shall not give effect
to the letter dated 23.07.2018 given by the 1st respondent
-Chandraprakash Jain.
14. In the light of the above observations, I am of the
considered view that there is no impediment for the release
of the said movie.
15. Post the Arbitration Application for hearing on
08.12.2025.
3.
The matter was thereafter listed for hearing under the
caption for reporting compliance since it was informed to this Court
that the 1st respondent is making necessary arrangement for funds.
When the matter was taken up for hearing
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
today, a joint
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
memorandum was filed by the applicant and the 1 st respondent,
which has been signed by both parties and their respective counsel.
4.
The
relevant
terms
of
agreement
are
extracted
hereunder:-
(a) The Ist Respondent has paid a sum of Rs. 10,00,000/(Rupees Ten Lakhs only) on 08.01.2025 and a further sum
of Rs.5,00,000/-(Rupees Five Lakhs only) on 26.01.2025,
which amounts have been duly received and acknowledged
by the Applicant.
(b). The 1st Respondent on 25.02.2026 has paid a further
sum of Rs.85,00,000/- (Rupees Eighty-Five Lakhs only) to
the Applicant by way of Demand Draft vide DD No:
166502, dated: 19.02.2026, drawn on State Bank of India,
Koyambedu Branch, Chennai, towards part satisfaction of
the agreed settlement amount.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
(c). The Ist Respondent hereby agrees and undertakes to
pay the outstanding sum of Rs. 1,50,00,000/- (Rupees One
Crore and Fifty Lakhs only) to the Applicant. Whereas,
such payment shall be made on or before one (1) week from
the date fixed for the theatrical release of the forthcoming
movie tentatively titled as "Mambo", directed by Mr. X
Prabhu @Prabusolomon, produced by Kaja Mydeen under
the banner of Roja Combines, starring Vijay Sri Hari and
Yogi Babu, with music composed by D. Imman, whichever
is earlier.
d. The said payment shall be made without any default or
delay, and time shall be of the essence in respect of the
aforesaid obligation.
e. The 1st Respondent has, on this day, issued a signed
post-dated cheque in favour of the Applicant, bearing
Cheque No..
f. 783950, for a sum of Rs. 1,50,00,000/-(Rupees One
Crore and fifty Lakhs only drawn on State Bank of India,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
Koyambedu Branch, Chennai, towards discharge of the
outstanding liability under this Memorandum. Wherein,
the I st
Respondent hereby expressly authorises and
empower the Applicant to fill in the date in the cheque,
corresponding to the date fixed for the theatrical release of
the forthcoming movie tentatively titled as "Mambo", and
to present the cheque for encashment and collection.
g. The 1st Respondent hereby assures and undertakes that
the said post-dated cheque shall be duly honoured on
presentation on their respective cheque dates, without any
default or delay and also undertakes that sufficient funds
shall be maintained in the 1 Respondent's concerned bank
account for the aforesaid purpose.
h. In the event of dishonour of any of the aforesaid cheques
or failure to comply with the payment terms stipulated
herein, the 1st Respondent shall be solely liable for the
legally enforceable debt, and the Applicant shall be at
liberty to initiate appropriate civil and/or criminal, any
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
legal
proceedings
against
the
1st
Respondent
in
accordance with law, without any further reference to the
1st Respondent.
i. It is mutually agreed between the Applicant and 1 st
Respondent that the above payment terms and conditions
shall be strictly complied with, without any deviation or
violation. In case of any default in payment of the Cheque
bearing Cheque No. 783950, for a sum of Rs. 1,50,00,000/(Rupees One Crore and Fifty Lakhs only), drawn on State
Bank of India, Koyambedu Branch, Chennai. The
Applicant shall be entitled to claim and recover forthwith
the entire outstanding sum of Rs. 1,50,00,000/- (Rupees
One Crore and Fifty Lakhs only) from the 1st Respondent,
together with interest at the rate of 24% p.a., from the date
hereof until the date of full and final realisation, without
prejudice to any other remedies available in law.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
J. The parties agree that this compromise is entered into
voluntarily, without coercion or undue influence, and shall
be binding on all parties and their successors and assigns.
5.
Recording the above, this application is disposed of in
terms of the joint Memorandum dated 26.02.2026. No costs.
26-02-2026
rka
Index:Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Internet:Yes
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
To
1.M/s GOD Pictures
rep by its Proprietor and Director,
Prabhu Solomon, no.57, 2nd
street, Valasaravakkam, Chennai
600 093.
2.Gemini FX
Rep. By Its Authorized Signatory,
Having Office At No 28, New
Bangaru Colony, West K.K.
Nagar, Chennai.
3.Pen India Private Limited,
Represented By Its Authorised
Signatory Mr. Vishal Lahu Rane,
Having Its Reg Office At Pen
House, Asha Colony, Juhu Tara
Road, Juhu, Mumbai 400 049 (3rd
Respondent Impleaded As Per
Order Dt 14.11.2025 In
A.no.5656/2025)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Arb Appln No. 1463 of 2025
N.ANAND VENKATESH J.
rka
Arb Appln No. 1463
of 2025
26-02-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review