Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010655412022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
MONDAY, THE SECOND DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 513/2022
Between:
1. S.B.I.GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP BY ITS GENERAL
MANAGER, S.B.I.
UPSTAIRS, HERO HONDA SHOW ROOM,
RENIGUNTA ROAD, TIRUPATI, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. M DEVAGANAPATHI, S/O M.CHANDRASEKHAR NAIDU, HINDU,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS, RESIDENT OF D.NO.18-3-52, KHADHI
COLONY, MAIN ROAD, NEAR MUNICIPAL PARK, TIRUPATI TOWN
POST AND MANDAL, CHITTOOR DISTRICT
2. SAGAR MALAKAR, S/O KAPIL MALAKAR, HINDU, AGED ABOUT 33
YEARS, RESIDING AT DISHNUPUR VILLAGE, DEVAPURA POST,
BAGUSARAI DISTRICT, BIHAR STATE
3. M/S KAPOOR DIESELS GARAGE PVT LTD, REP BY ITS MANAGER
NANGALIPOONA, G.T.ROAD, NORTH WEST DELHI
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased tobegs to prefer this memorandum of appeal being aggrieved by the
decree and judgment passed in M.V.O.P.No.178 of 2015, dated 01-02-2022,
on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal -cum- Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal-cum IV Additional District Judge, Tirupati
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 116 days in filing the appeal against
M.V.O.P.No.178 of 2015, dated 01-02-2022 on the file of Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal -Cum- Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum IV Additional
District Judge, Tirupati and to pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased suspend of operation of the Judgment and Decree made in
M.V.O.P.No.178 of 2015dt 01-02¬2022 on the file of Chairman, Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum IV dditional District Judge, Tirupati pending
disposal of the above appeal in the interest of justice pending disposal of the
above appeal in the interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to extend the time to comply orders made in IA 2/2022 in MACMA
513/2022 dated 07-12-2022 on the file this Hon'ble Court by four weeks
enabling the petitioner to deposit the Amount in the interest of justice pending
disposal of the above appeal in the interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to vacate the interim order passed in IA.No. 2/2022 in MACMA No.
513/2022 Dt. 07-12-2022 in the interest of justice and to pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. AMANCHARLA SATISH BABU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. T C KRISHNAN
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
JUDGMENT:
The present appeal is filed by the appellant/insurance company
challenging
the
order
and
decree
dated
01.02.2022
passed
in
M.V.O.P.No.178 of 2015 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunalcum-IV Additional District Judge, Tirupati, wherein the Tribunal awarded
compensation of Rs.2,80,000/- (Rupees Two lakhs eighty thousand only) to
the petitioner, as against the claim of Rs.9,00,000/-, for the injuries sustained
and damages caused to his car in a motor accident that occurred on
07.05.2014.
2.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The case of the claimants is briefly as follows:
a) On 07.05.2014 at 12.30 p.m., the petitioner along with his mother
Rajeswari,
brother
Dilip
Chakravarthi,
friend
Balaji
and
one
A.Narasimhamurthy was proceeding in a TATA Indica car bearing No.AP-02P-1125 to his native village Eguvakaminayaapalli to cast his vote in A.P.
Assembly elections. At about 01.30 p.m., when they reached Kasipentla
village on the Tirupati-Chittoor Highway, while the petitioner was driving the
car on the extreme left side of the road, the 1st respondent driving a Container
lorry bearing No.HR-38-Q-6508 belonging to the 2nd respondent, in a rash and
negligent manner in opposite direction on the extreme right side of the road,
dashed the petitioner’s car on its front, went ahead and fell into a channel.
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
Due to that impact, the petitioner’s car was damaged beyond repairs and the
petitioner sustained fractures to left radius, left ulna, laceration on outer angle
of right eye besides other bodily injuries. Other persons in the car also
received simple and grievous injuries and were shifted to different hospitals.
The petitioner was shifted to BOTH Hospital, Tirupati in ambulance, where he
underwent surgery on 07.05.2014 and was discharged on 10.05.2014 with
advice to take bed rest for two months. A criminal case in Crime No.136 of
2014 was registered by the Station House Officer, Chandragiri Police Station
against the 1st respondent for the offences under Sections 337, 338 and 279
of I.P.C.
b) It is the contention of the petitioner that he is an engineering graduate
engaged in business under the name and style of “Elite Solutions” in Tirupati,
earning Rs.50,000/- per month and also deriving agricultural income of
Rs.2,00,000/- per annum. During the course of his treatment from 07.05.2014
to 10.05.2014, the petitioner incurred huge expenses. However, as he is
entitled to reimbursement from the Government of Andhra Pradesh, his wife
being a Government employee, he has not claimed any amount towards
medical expenses. It is further stated that, having been advised bed rest for a
period of two months, he was unable to attend to his business and agricultural
activities, thereby suffering loss of income for about one year. Therefore, he
sought compensation of Rs.9,00,000/- from the respondents.
4.
The 1st respondent/driver filed a counter, which was adopted by the 2nd
respondent/owner, denying the petition averments. It was contended that the
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
petition is not maintainable, that the petitioner failed to produce any evidence
in support of his alleged business and agricultural income, and that the claim
is excessive. It was further contended that, as the policy was in force at the
time of the accident, the 3rd respondent/Insurance Company alone is liable to
pay compensation.
5.
The 3rd respondent/Insurance Company filed a counter denying all the
petition averments and contended that the injuries sustained by the petitioner
are simple in nature and do not affect his normal life. It was further contended
that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the
petitioner himself, who lost control of the car and dashed against the lorry, and
that a false complaint was lodged, leading to filing of the charge sheet without
proper investigation. It was also contended that the driver of the lorry did not
possess a valid driving licence, the vehicle lacked a valid fitness certificate,
and that the vehicle was not insured with the 3rd respondent. Therefore, it is
not liable to pay compensation. It was further contended that there was
contributory negligence on the part of the petitioner, and that the owner and
insurer of the petitioner’s car are necessary parties; in their absence, the
petition is not maintainable. The 3rd respondent also claimed protection under
Sections 147 to 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act and contended that the
compensation and interest claimed are excessive, and sought dismissal of the
petition.
6.
trial:
Basing on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
“1. Whether the accident in question was occurred on account of
rash and negligent driving of Container Lorry bearing No.HR.38-Q6508 by its driver resulting in injuries to the petitioner?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled for compensation: If so to what
amount and from which of the respondents?
3. To what relief?”
7.
On behalf of the petitioner, P.W.1 and P.W.2 were examined Exs.A1 to
A8 were marked. On behalf of the 3rd respondent R.W.1 was examined and
Exs.B1 to B5 were marked.
8.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal partly allowed the claim
petition, awarding compensation of Rs.2,80,000/- with interest @7.5% per
annum from the date of the petition till the date of realization, along with costs.
Respondents No.1 to 3 were jointly and severally liable to pay the said amount
within one month from the date of the order.
9.
Aggrieved by the same, the Insurance Company preferred this appeal,
contending that the driver possessed a fake driving licence and thus there was
a breach of policy conditions, and therefore, the insurer is not liable to pay
compensation.
10.
Heard Mr.Amancharla Satish Babu, learned Standing Counsel for the
appellant and Mr.T.C.Krishnan, learned counsel for the petitioner/respondent
No.1 herein.
11.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
POINT:
12.
The main contention of the learned counsel for the appellant/Insurance
Company is that, as on the date of the accident, the driver of the offending
vehicle did not possess a valid driving licence and that the licence produced is
a fake one. Hence, there is a clear violation of the policy conditions and,
therefore, no liability can be fastened on the appellant/Insurance Company. To
substantiate the said contention, the appellant examined R.W.1, the Senior
Legal Executive of the Insurance Company, and relied upon Exs.B1 to B5. As
per the evidence of R.W.1, the accident that occurred on 07.05.2014 fell within
the period covered under Ex.B1 policy issued in favour of the 2nd respondent
in respect of the commercial goods vehicle bearing No. HR-38-Q-6508. He
further deposed that, upon verification through the Transport Department
website, no driving licence in the name of the 1st respondent was found.
Further, as per the information furnished by the District Transport Officer and
Public Information Officer, the driving licence of the 1st respondent was not
issued by their office, which is marked as Ex.B5. Therefore, it is evident that
the driver of the offending vehicle did not possess a valid driving licence,
resulting in violation of the policy conditions.
13.
It is to be noted that under similar circumstances, where there is a
violation of the policy conditions, the Hon’ble Apex Court in National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh & Ors., 1has held that if the insurer
successfully proves a breach of policy condition, the insurance company may
(2004) 3 SCC 297
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
still be directed to pay compensation to the claimantsand then recover the
amount from the insured (owner of the vehicle). This ensures that the rights of
the third-party victim are protected and it was emphasized that insurance
policies are statutorily required to protect third parties, and even in cases of
breach by the insured, the insurer's liability towards third-party victims does
not vanish immediately.
14.
In view of the above, and following the settled principles of law as held
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the decisions referred supra, this Court is of
the opinion that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal in the instant case
has to be first paid by the insurance company, and thereafter the insurance
company can recover the same from the owner of the offending vehicle.
15.
Coming to the quantum of compensation, as seen from the impugned
award, the petitioner relied upon Ex.A8, the estimation report issued by Vaca
Cars, which shows that the car was extensively damaged; however, if the
petitioner had removed the damaged vehicle from the accident spot and sold it
as scrap, he would have realized an amount of about Rs.40,000/-; therefore,
after deducting the said amount, the Tribunal rightly assessed the loss
towards vehicle damage at Rs.1,60,000/-, which is just and reasonable.
Further, though the petitioner claimed that he was earning Rs.50,000/- per
month from business and Rs.2,00,000/- per annum from agriculture, no
documentary
evidence
was
produced
except
Ex.A4/VAT
registration
certificate, which is insufficient to establish his income; hence, in the absence
of proper proof, the Tribunal reasonably assessed a sum of Rs.10,000/-
VS,J
MACMA No.513 of 2022
towards loss of income. Moreover, the petitioner sustained fractures to the
radius and ulna of his left hand; therefore, considering the nature of injuries
and the treatment undergone, the Tribunal awarded Rs.50,000/- towards pain
and suffering. In addition, an amount of Rs.5,000/- towards transport charges,
Rs.50,000/- towards attendant charges and extra nourishment, and Rs.5,000/towards other damages were awarded, which are just and reasonable and do
not warrant interference. Thus, in total, the Tribunal awarded a sum of
Rs.2,80,000/- towards compensation, which cannot be said to be excessive
and requires no interference by this Court.
16.
In view of the above discussion, while confirming the quantum of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal, this Court deems it appropriate to
partly allow this appeal by directing the 3rd respondent/insurance company to
deposit the compensation amount at the first instance and thereafter recover
the same from the 2nd respondent/owner of the offending vehicle i.e., the
container lorry bearing No.HR-38-Q-6508.
17.
With the above direction, this appeal is allowed in part. No costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
__________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Date: 02.03.2026
KGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review