Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.20
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 15 of 2019
Date of Decision :22.04.2024
1.
L/3500937, Hav/Elect,
S.Arnold Singh, ARASU.
2.
L/5002845, Rfn/ Elect,
Balaji Vaka, SM, HQ IGAR (N).
3.
L/5013343, Rfn/Elect,
Arpan Singh, 4 AR.
4.
L/5002857, Rfn/Elect,
P.Rajasekhara Reddy, 43 AR.
5.
L/5011096H, Rfn/Elect,
S N.Reddy, 8 AR.
6.
JC 390526, Nb/Sub (Elect),
Joginder Singh, No. 1 Wksp AR.
7.
L/390535, Hav/Elect,
Rakesh Kumar, 31 AR.
8.
L/390551, Hav/Elect,
U S Rawat, 19 AR.
9.
L/95921, Hav/Elect,
Shanker Lal, No. 2 Wksp AR.
10.
L/0111221, Hav/Elect,
Rajbir Singh, No. 2 Wksp AR.
11.
L/3201112, Hav/Elect,
Suresh Kumar, No. 3 Wksp AR.
12.
L/134919, Hav/Elect,
A K Chando, HQ 23 Sect Ar.
13.
L/104957, Hav/Elect,
Manoj Kumar Chhetri, 10 AR.
14.
L/9966686, Hav/Elect,
Ganeshi Kumar, No. 1 MGAR.
15.
L/358536, Hav/Elect,
Gopal Singh, 13 AR.
16.
L/154182, Hav/Elect,
Surjeet Kumar, HQ 7 Sect AR.
17.
L/2301893, Hav/Elect,
Ram Nath, 13 AR.
18.
L/2851801, Hav/Elect,
Debananda Saikia, 20 AR.
19.
L/5022934, Rfn/Elect,
Girver Singh, No. 1 Wksp AR.
20.
L/5022909, Rfn/Elect,
Ashutosh Kumar Singh, 23 AR.
21.
L/5022782, Rfn/Elect,
Vikas Prajapati, HQ 9 Sect AR.
22.
L/95963, Rfn/Elect,
James Mathew, 23 AR.
23.
L/5014176, Rfn/Elect,
Renjith Kumar, 30 AR.
24.
L/5008381, Rfn/Elect,
Rajendra Prasad, 36 AR.
25.
L/5011565, Rfn/Elect,
A Senthil Kumar, 43 AR.
26.
L/115345, Rfn/Elect,
Suresh Kumar. No. 4 Wksp AR.
27.
L/5010544, Rfn/Elect,
S Z Khan, No. 3 Wksp AR.
28.
L/3900998, Rfn/Elect,
Santosh Sharma, 35 AR.
29.
L/5011539, Rfn/Elect,
P.Balamurugan, No. 4 Wksp AR.
30.
L/214331, Rfn/Elect,
Narendra Singh, 19 AR.
31.
L/5009862, Rfn/Elect,
Mukesh Singh Yadav, No. 1 Wksp AR.
32.
L/0111265, Rfn/Elect,
Prem Prakash Yadav, 6 AR.
33.
L/5009048, Rfn/Elect,
Mangloo Ram, No. 4 Wksp AR.
34.
L/2301984, Rfn/Elect,
Amit Kumar, 37 AR.
35.
L/5004346, Rfn/Elect,
Ranojit Ghosh, HQ 22 Sect AR.
36.
L/135074, Rfn/Elect,
Arun Kumar Singh, No. 3 Wksp AR.
37.
L/5012856, Rfn/Elect,
M V Ramappa, 27 AR.
38.
L/76080, Rfn/Elect,
Mahesh M, 1 AR.
39.
L/105066, Rfn/Elect,
Susil Majhi, 14 AR.
40.
L/3900989, Rfn/Elect,
M D Abdul Helim SHaha, No. 4 Wksp AR.
41.
L/105299, Rfn/Elect,
Susheel Kumar Pandey, 40 AR.
42.
L/412159, Rfn/Elect,
Mubaraque Ali, No. 4 WKsp AR.
43.
L/214260, Rfn/Elect,
Manoj M, No. 1 MGAR.
44.
L/115367, Rfn/Elect,
Kiran Kumar Singha, 9 AR.
45.
L/3201284, Rfn/Elect,
Harendra Singh Rawat, No. 4 Wksp AR.
46.
L/5011764, Rfn/Elect,
Amit Kumar, HQ 7 Sect AR.
47.
L/5018700, Rfn/Elect,
N K Jha, 36 AR.
48.
L/5017405, Rfn/Elect,
Balmukund Kumar, 10 AR.
49.
L/3701037, Rfn/Elect,
Norbu Tshering Lepcha, 40 AR.
50.
L/5005717, Rfn/Elect,
Ramesh D, No. 1 Wksp AR.
51.
L/5021261, Rfn/Elect,
Ullas Khrishnan, 27 AR.
52.
L/3002162, Rfn/Elect,
Kuldeep Singh, 7 AR.
53.
L/3201164, Rfn/Elect,
Prakash Sharma, 8 AR.
54.
L/3701003, Rfn/Elect,
Raja Ram Rai, 44 AR.
55.
L/390541, Rfn/Elect,
Vikram Singh Rawat, HQ 23 Sect AR.
56.
L/2103391, Rfn/Elect,
Vikram Singh, No. 3 MGAR.
57.
L/184561, Rfn/Elect,
Akash Sissodiya, 22 AR.
58.
L/390566, Rfn/Elect,
Sugreev Prasad, No. 4 Wksp AR.
59.
JC 390584, Nb/Sub (Elect)
Arjun Prasad Yadav, DGAR EME Br.
60.
L/5019537, Rfn/Elect,
Ajita Ranjan Swain, 46 AR.
61.
L/5000888, Rfn/Elect,
Jaibir Singh, 46 AR.
62.
L/412047, Hav/Elect,
Rajeev C P, HQ 9 Sect AR.
63.
L/75931, Hav/Elect,
Pramod P, 28 AR.
64.
L/105266, Rfn/Elect,
Anil Kumar Prasad, 24 AR.
65.
L/3200824, Hav/Elect,
Ashok Kumar, HQ 21 Sect AR.
66.
L/2502079, Rfn/Elect,
Rajkumar Tiwari, HQ 22 Sect AR.
67.
L/5004670, Rfn/Elect,
Balbir Singh, NSG 13 SGR.
68.
L/38478, Hav/Elect,
Surendra Singh, No. 2 Wksp AR.
69.
L/390689, Rfn/Elect,
B K Shah, No. 2 Wksp AR.
70.
L/38513, Hav/Elect,
T H Premkanta, No. 2 Wksp AR.
71.
L/5011134, Rfn/Elect,
N Surya Prakash, 42 AR.
72.
L/3800903, Rfn/Elect,
Santosh Kumar Thakur, ARC & MC.
73.
L/144560, Rfn/Elect,
Sunil Mistri, No. 1 Wksp AR.
74.
JC-390601, Nb/Sub (Elect),
Umesh Chandra Pathak, No. 3 Wksp AR.
75.
L/5000239, Rfn/Elect,
Sanasam Khoiba Singh, No. 1 Wksp AR.
76.
L/2201980, Hav/Elect,
Praveen Kumar, 5 AR.
77.
L/214333, Rfn/Elect,
M.K.Yadav, No. 1 Wksp AR.
78.
L/164265, Hav/Elect,
Jeevraj Singh, HQ 21 Sect AR.
79.
L/2901919, Rfn/Elect,
S K Gahan, 1 AR.
80.
L/390534, Hav/Elect,
S P Sajjan, HQ 21 Sect AR.
81.
L/3201141, Hav/Elect,
Samir Patary, HQ 26 Sect AR.
82.
L/5007768, Rfn/Elect,
Naresh Kumar, NSG 12 SRG.
83.
L/5012707, Hav/Elect,
Sudesh Pal, 3 AR.
84.
L/2701916, Hav/Elect,
Nemai Sil, No. 3 Wksp AR.
85.
L/5003095, Hav/Elect,
Manoj Kumar, HQ 28 Sect AR.
86.
L/184637, Hav/Elect,
Lokesh HS, HQ 10 Sect AR.
87.
L/124755, Hav/Elect,
Nipan Sharma, 45 AR.
88.
L/390582, Hav/Elect,
Kulpati Singh, No. 2 Wksp AR.
89.
L/5009985, Rfn/Elect,
Somendra Kumar, 32 AR.
90.
L/173958, Hav/Elect,
Diveshan P, No. 1 Wksp AR.
91.
L/2402003, Hav/Elect,
Amrit Deka, No. 1 Wksp AR.
92.
L/3900453, Hav/Elect,
Jitender Singh, HQ 6 Sect AR.
93.
L/95716, Hav/Elect,
Praveen S, 15 AR.
94.
L/5000873, Rfn/Elect,
Rajkumar Yadav, No. 2 Wksp AR.
95.
L/124583, Hav/Elect,
Bantu Singh, 6 AR.
96.
L/5013868, Hav/Elect,
Kanshi Ram, 26 AR.
97.
L/390540, Hav/Elect,
Mohan Singh, No. 3 Wksp AR.
98.
L/390591, Hav/Elect,
Bhobulal, No. 3 Wksp AR.
99.
L/3900542, Hav/Elect,
Manoj Kumar, 45 AR.
100.
L/390573, Hav/Elect,
Radha Krishnan Nair, No. 3 Wksp AR.
101.
L/2901916, Rfn/Elect,
Bal Gopal Mishra, HQ 28 Sect AR.
102.
L/390554, Hav/Elect,
Abraham George, No. 4 MGAR.
103.
L/390565, Hav/Elect,
Kewal Krishnan, 28 AR.
104.
L/76226, Hav/Elect,
Raj Kishor Singh, No. 2 MGAR.
105.
L.3400884, Hav/Elect,
Siyaram, No. 1 Wksp AR.
106.
L/3002067, Hav/Elect,
Sanju Gogoi, No. 3 Wksp AR.
107.
L/184587, Rfn/Elect,
Kamal Kishor, 41 AR.
108.
L/184498, Hav/Elect,
Gurdev Singh, 41 AR.
109.
L/2501849, Hav/Elect,
Thiyam Bacha Singh, HQ IGAR (S).
110.
L/154266, Rfn/Elect,
Sudesh Kumar, HQ 28 Sect AR.
111.
L/193933, Hav/Elect,
Tarjan Chintey, No. 3 MGAR.
112.
L/3700826, Rfn/Elect,
Balwan Singh, 21 AR.
113.
L/412295, Hav/Elect,
Deepak Raj, HQ 5 Sect AR.
114.
L/57733, Hav/Elect,
Pawan Kumar Singh, No. 2 Wksp AR.
115.
L/67145, Hav/Elect,
Santosh Kumar Yadav, No. 2 Wksp AR.
116.
L/115314, Hav/Elect,
Girish Kumar V R , 26 AR.
117.
L/104888, Hav/Elect,
Rajesh Kumar, HQ 26 Sect AR.
118.
L/5009745, Rfn/Elect,
Sanjay Kumar, 12 AR.
119.
L/3600880, Hav/Elect,
S S Neogi, 18 AR.
120.
L/67193, Rfn/Elect,
Pradeep Kumar Pradhan, 39 AR.
121.
L/2103472, Hav/Elect,
Santan Singh Rawat, 39 AR.
122.
L/57638, Hav/Elect,
Bhupendra Singh, No. 3 Wksp AR.
123.
L/2003521, Hav/Elect,
Gabbar Singh, 21 AR.
124.
L/3700583, Hav/Elect,
Anil Kumar G, 24 AR.
125.
JC 390517, Nb/Sub (Elect),
C B Joshi.
126.
L/84845, Hav/Elect,
Sanjay Barman, 30 AR.
127.
L/2601860, Hav/Elect,
S H Barbhuiya, No. 2 Wksp AR.
128.
L/184586, Hav/Elect,
Vijay Kumar, HQ 22 Sect AR.
129.
L/5014482, Rfn/Elect,
Rajesh M. HQ 10 Sect AR.
130.
L/5007850, Rfn/Elect,
Mandeep, 29 AR.
131.
L/5007548, Rfn/Elect,
Amardeep Singh, No. 3 Wksp AR.
132.
L/3400968, Rfn/Elect,
Dharmender Kumar, 33 AR.
133.
L/390571, Hav/Elect,
Alok Kumar, No. 2 Wksp AR.
134.
L/2502077, Rfn/Elect,
Habibul Shaikh, 17 AR.
135.
L/330958, Hav/Elect,
Arbind Singh, 11 AR.
136.
L/3900992, Rfn/Elect,
Tejendra Chhetri, 33 AR.
137.
L/76006, Hav/Elect,
Govind Singh, No. 4 Wksp AR.
138.
L/95989, Rfn/Elect,
Gulshan Singh, No. 2 Wksp AR.
139.
L/3201091, Rfn/Elect,
Shibilian Hemrom, 4 AR.
140.
L/174144, Hav/Elect,
Surender Kumar, HQ 25 Sect AR.
141.
JC 390550, Sub Elect,
Gurdial Singh, No. 4 Wksp AR.
142.
L/3901009, Rfn/Elect,
S B Singha, 37 AR.
143.
L/5002292, Rfn/Elect,
Ramesh Chand, (Sector 5 H.Q.).
…Writ Petitioners.
-Versus-
1.
The Union of India
Represented by the Secretary,
Govt. of India,
Ministry of Home Affiars,
North Block, New Delhi – 110 001.
2.
The Directorate General of Assam Rifles,
Directorate of Assam Rifles, Shillong,
Meghalaya – 79 3011.
…Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. M.Chanda, Adv.
Mr. M.L.Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N.Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A.Pradhan, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The petitioners in the instant writ petition numbering 143 in Nos.
who
are
stated
to
be
serving
as
Rifleman/Electrician
and
Havildar/Electrician, are before this Court praying for grant of appropriate
rank, status and pay scales of Havildar/Electrician (MV) at the entry grade
as per the recommendations of the 5th Central Pay Commission and Office
Memorandum dated 22-01-1998, read with Ministry of Home Affair’s
letter dated 28-07-1998, DGAR’s order dated 21-02-2017, and also in the
light of the judgment and order dated 22-09-2011, passed in WA. No. 50
(SH) of 2010, judgment and order passed in 23-05-2014, passed in WP(C).
No. 218 of 2013, and also the most recent judgment dated 20-04-2023,
passed in WA. No. 10 of 2022 and other connected matters.
2.
A perusal of the pleadings, and on hearing the submission of the
learned counsel for the petitioners, it is evident that the petitioners who
were initially recruited as Riflemen Electrician following due selection
process, constitute one of the trades for which exercise of remusteration
had been undertaken by the respondents, pursuant to policy decisions and
fortified later by orders of the earlier jurisdictional High Court, and also
the present High Court.
3.
With respect to the most recent judgment passed by this Court dated
20-04-2022, this Court at para 19 and 20 had observed as follows:
“19. However, for reasons that do not require
to be looked into at this stage, the issues have
attained finality by virtue of the appeal from the
order dated May 8, 2014 being dismissed on
March 1, 2016 and such appellate order not
being assailed. In view of the principle of issue
estoppel, it is no longer open to the Assam Rifles
to urge to the contrary; at least not at this level.
This Court is bound by its previous order of
March 1, 2016 and the matter cannot be
permitted to be agitated for being adjudicated
afresh. The finality of an order does not depend
on its correctness; the principle of finality is
based on the larger public policy of giving
quietus to a decision that could have been
questioned but was not, or that was questioned
but the challenge failed. The reasons for not
assailing the decision or the reasons why the
challenge failed are irrelevant, only the result is
material.
20. Considering that the issues remained
settled from about 2011, it appears extremely
unlikely that there may be any cheer for the
appellants herein at any other level.”
This Court had concluded the judgment by extending the entire
benefits to similarly situated personnel of the Assam Rifles.
4.
The applicability, and the need for compliance of the said judgment
and order is not disputed by Dr. N.Mozika, learned DSGI, who however,
submitted that an SLP has been preferred against this judgment, which is
pending consideration.
5.
Be that as it may, as similar benefits had been extended to other
trades, this writ petition is also accordingly disposed of by affording
identical relief as given in WA. No. 10 of 2022 to the petitioners herein.
6.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands closed and disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
22.04.2024
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review