Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-69158--2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH
H
COURT OF PUNJAB
JAB A
AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
ARH
(234)
CRM-M-69158-2025 (O&M)
M)
Date of decision : 17.02.2026
... Petitioner
RUPESH @ NAMAN
NAM
Versus
STATE OF HARYANA
HAR
...Respondent
CORAM: HON'BLE
HON
MRS. JUSTICE MANIS
ANISHA BATRA
Present:
Mr. Bhaag Singh Suhag, Advocate
cate fo
for the petitioner
Mr. Neeraj Poswal, AAG, Haryana
****
MANISHA BATR
BATRA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The instant one is the second petitio
petition preferred by the petitioner
ioner
under Section
on 48
483 of Bharatiya Nagarik Surak
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short
“BNSS”) forr gran
grant of regular bail in casee arisi
arising out of FIR No.114 dated
ated
10.05.2024 registered
regist
under Sections 386, 384, 506, 120B of the IPC and
Sections 25, 25(1-B)a,
25(1
25(6), 25(1)a and 29(B)
9(B) oof Arms Act at Police Station
ation
Farukhnagar,
r, Distr
District Gurugram.
2.
As per
pe the allegations, on 10.05.2024
.2024, ASI Sanjay Kumar, posted
ed at
the aforementione
entioned police station, received
ed a ssecret information that some
members off Lawrence
Law
Bishnoi gang, namely
ely R
Rohit Godara, Naveen Boxer,
oxer,
Lipan Nehra and Pawan
P
Nehra, were active in the city of Gurugram for extorting
rting
money from businessmen
busin
and rich people. The
he main members of the group
roup
were operating
ing fro
from foreign countries, somee of the
them were lodged in jails and
d all
of them were
re into contact with each other throug
through different social media apps.
It was also informed
inform that they had even gott murd
murdered one businessman Sachin
chin
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.18 10:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-69158--2025 (O&M)
Goda in Rohtak.
htak. One of the members of this ga
gang namely Rohit Godara had
raised demand
nd of rransom money of Rs.2 crores
res fro
from owner of Maniram Grocery
cery
Store, Gurugram.
gram. It was informed that if thee abov
above mentioned persons and other
members off the gang were apprehended and in
interrogated, huge quantity
ty of
contraband, ransom money and weapons could
uld be recovered from them. On
n the
basis of this inform
information, the aforementioned FIR was registered. Investigation
ation
proceedings were initiated. During investigation,
gation, accused Dinesh @ Dinu was
arrested on 10.05
10.05.2024.
Recovery of two
wo m
mobile phones, one .30 bore
countrymade pistol
pisto alongwith five live cartridges
idges w
was effected from him. On
n his
identification,
n, co
co-accused Jagdish @ Jaggu,
u, Pard
Pardeep, Sagar and Vishnu were
arrested on 12.05.2024,
12.05.
from whom also, differen
ifferent arms and ammunitions were
recovered. Accuse
Accused Ritesh @ Arya and Himanshu
anshu were arrested on 18.05.2024.
024.
One vehicle used by accused Himanshu at the tim
time of committing offences had
been recovered.
ered.
Subsequently, the petitioner,
tioner, co-accused Ashis @ Deva,
eva,
Harpal, Karan
an @ Kannu and Iqbal Singh @ Billa were arrested. The petitioner
ioner
suffered disclosur
sclosure statement admitting his inv
involvement in the crime and
disclosed that
at on 06.04.2024, on the asking
king oof co-accused Himanshu,, he
alongwith the
he form
former had collected ransom mone
money of Rs.2 lakhs from a person
rson
at Village Luhari
uhari and had given the same too the cco-accused Himanshu and had
transferred an
n amount
amo
of Rs.50,000/- in the bank account of co-accused Arya
ya @
Ritesh .
3.
As per
pe the further allegations, subse
subsequently some other additional
ional
accused were
re nominated
nom
and arrested. Investigat
estigation now stands concluded and
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.18 10:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-69158--2025 (O&M)
the petitioner
er alo
alongwith the co-accused is fac
facing trial for commission
n of
aforementioned
ned offences.
of
4.
It is argued
a
by learned counsell for tthe petitioner that he has been
falsely implicated
icated in this case. He is in custody
tody ssince 19.05.2024. No recovery
very
has been effected
ected from him. He is on bail in anoth
another case registered against him.
m.
The trial will
ll take considerable time to conclude.
clude. The accused Vidhyadharr and
Himanshu have aalready been extended benefit
enefit of bail.
On parity, he too
deserves to be extended
ext
the same benefit. Each day spent by the petitioner
er in
custody gives
es him a ground to move for bai
bail afresh.
With these broad
road
submissions,, it is u
urged that the petition deserves
erves tto be allowed.
5.
Per contra,
c
learned State counsel
sel wh
while referring to the contents
ts of
the status report
port has
h vehemently argued thatt there are serious allegations against
ainst
the petitioner. There
Th
is no substantive change
ange iin the circumstances from his
earlier petition
ion fi
filed.
He was member off the gang operated by Lawrence
ence
Bishnoi which
ich is involved in extorting money from rich businessmen and
professionals
ls by eextending threats to them.. On 06.04.2024, he had received
ived
ransom money
ney to the tune of Rs.2 lakhs and ha
had given the same to the co-accused thereby
reby ac
actively participating in the crime
crime. His complicity in the crime
rime
stands established
lished. There are chances of his co
committing similar offences
es or
absconding, if ext
extended benefit of bail. It is, the
therefore, argued that the petition
tition
does not deserve
erve to be allowed.
6.
This Court
C
has heard the rival submi
ubmissions made by both the parties
rties
at considerable
ble length.
len
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.18 10:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-69158--2025 (O&M)
7.
The petitioner is alleged to have bbeen a member of notorious
rious
gangster and
d in conspiracy
co
with them is alleged
leged tto have received an amount
nt of
Rs.2 lakhs, which was ransom money and then too have given the same to the co-accused Himanshu
manshu and Ritesh @ Arya. He wa
was nominated as an additional
ional
accused on the basis
bas of the disclosure statement
ent oof the co-accused. It is only
ly on
thorough assessm
ssessment of the evidence to be pr
produced at the trial thatt his
complicity in
n the crime
c
and exact part playedd by hhim can be determined and
d not
at this stage.. He iis in custody since 19.05.2024.. T
The trial will take considerable
rable
time to conclude
lude ssince none out of 49 prosecution
cution witnesses has been examined.
ined.
The well settled
ettled proposition of law is that
at the Court, while considering
g an
application for grant
gra of bail, has to keep certain
tain fa
factors in mind such as whether
ether
there is a prima
ima facie
fa case or reasonable ground
ound tto believe that the accused has
committed the o
offence, circumstances which
hich aare peculiar to the accused,
used,
likelihood of the offence being repeated,
d, the nature and gravity of the
accusation, severity
severit of the punishment in thee even
event of conviction, the danger
er of
the accused
d absconding
absc
or fleeing if release
released on bail, and reasonable
able
apprehension
n of th
the witnesses being threatened,
ned, et
etc. However, at the same time,
the period of incarceration
inc
is also a relevant
vant ffactor to be considered while
hile
deciding whether
ether bail should be granted to an acc
accused charged with an offence.
ence.
The Hon’blee Ape
Apex Court has observed in a cat
catena of cases that an accused
used
cannot be kept in
i custody for an indefinite
inite pperiod of time, and the bail
application can be considered on its own merits
erits eeven if it is filed repeatedly.
ly. It
has also been
n held that every day spent in custod
custody can provide a new cause
se of
action for filing
ling a bail application under certain
rtain ci
circumstances. This principle
le is
a part of the broad
broader approach emphasizing that la
law prefers bail over jail, aiming
ming
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.18 10:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-69158--2025 (O&M)
to balance the
he rights
righ of the accused with the requi
requirements of the criminal justice
stice
system. Reliance
liance in this regard can be placed
ed on the observations made by
y the
Hon’ble Apex
ex Court
Co
in Mohd. Muslim @ Huss
Hussain v. State (NCT of Delhi),
hi),
2023 SCC OnLi
nLine SC 352, wherein itt was observed that the jails are
overcrowded
d and their
t
living conditions are,, more often than not, appalling.. The
danger of unjustified
unjusti
imprisonment is that
at inm
inmates are more likely to
o be
hardened rather
ther th
than reformed. Reliance cann also be placed upon Manmandal
dal
and Another v. S
State of West Bengal, Special
ial L
Leave Petition (Criminal) No.
8656 of 2023 deci
decided on 14.09.2023 and Rabii Pra
Prakash v. State of Odisha, 2023
LiveLaw (SC)) 53
533, wherein bail was granted
nted tto the accused who had been
incarcerated for a period of almost two to three
hree yyears and the trial was likely
ly to
take considerable
erable time, by observing thatt prolo
prolonged incarceration generally
rally
militates against
ainst tthe most precious fundamental
ental rright guaranteed under Article
rticle
21 of the Constitut
nstitution.
8.
On analyzing
an
the peculiar facts
ts and circumstances of the present
esent
case in the light of
o the aforementioned principle
nciples of law, it transpires thatt the
petitioner has
as suffered
suff
prolonged incarceration
tion fo
for a period of 01 year and
d 08
months and 28 days.
day The trial is not likely to be concluded in near future. The
continued detentio
etention of the petitioner is not likely to serve any fruitful purpose
pose
and there is nothin
nothing on record to show that if relea
released on bail, the petitioner will
not participate
ate in the trial or will abscond. It is w
well settled proposition off law
that bail is the rul
rule and jail is an exception and th
that pre-trial incarceration shall
not be a replica
lica of post-conviction sentencing. Th
The object of the jail is to secure
cure
appearance of the accused during trial, and it can
cannot be preventive or punitive.
itive.
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.18 10:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-69158--2025 (O&M)
Taking into consideration
consid
the above discussed
ed fac
facts, this Court is of the opinion
inion
that a case is made
m
out for grant of bail
ail to the petitioner at this stage.
tage.
Accordingly,, the p
petition is allowed and thee petiti
petitioner is ordered to be released
ased
on bail subject
ject tto his furnishing personal
al as well as surety bonds to the
satisfaction of the learned trial Court/Chief Judici
Judicial Magistrate/Duty Magistrate
trate
concerned.
9.
In the event of there being anyy FIR
FIR/complaint lodged againstt the
petitioner, itt shall be open to the respondent-State
State to seek redressal by filing
g an
application seeking
seekin cancellation of bail.
10.
It is, however, clarified that thee obse
observations made above shalll not
be construed
d as an expression of opinion of this C
Court on the merits of the case
and shall nott influ
influence the outcome of the trial
ial in aany manner.
11.
Since the main petition has been
een all
allowed, pending application,
n, if
any, is rendered
ered in
infructuous.
(MA
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE
17.02.2026
Amit Sharma
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.18 10:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
Whether speaking/reasoned:- Yes
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review