Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:509
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRMP No. 3656 of 2025
Royden Harold Buthello S/o Harold Anthony Buthello Aged About 33 Years
R/o Flat No. 20, Arunodaya C H S Ltd. A Wing, Manipada, Sunder Nagar,
Kalina University, Near Buth Vihar, Kalina Santacruz East, Mumbai- 400098.
... Petitioner
-VersusState Of Chhattisgarh Through- Station House Officer, Thana / P.S. - City
Kotwali, Raipur, C.G.
... Respondent
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Dev. M. Galani, Advocate (through
virtual mode) along with Mr. Neeraj
Choubey, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Mr. Sumit Singh, Deputy A.G.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal
Order on Board
05/01/2026
VED
PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by VED PRAKASH
DEWANGAN
Date: 2026.02.25
13:49:56 +0530
1.
The present Criminal Miscellaneous Petition filed by the petitioner
under Section 528 of the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023,
against the order dated 12-11-2025, passed by learned Special Judge
(NDPS), Raipur, in Special Case No. 98/2020, whereby the
application under Section 294 of the Cr.P.C. filed by the petitioner has
been dismissed.
2.
The subject matter in brief is that the petitioner is an accused in
Special Case No. 98/2020, pending before the learned Special Judge
(NDPS), Raipur, for the offence under Section 22(b), 29 and 27 of the
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (in short “the
NDPS Act”). After recording the prosecution evidence, the statements
of the accused persons under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. (Section 351
of the BNSS, 2023) were recorded on 23-08-2025, and thereafter, the
accused persons, including the petitioner, pleaded that they did not
want to examine any defence witness. On 23-08-2025 itself, the
petitioner filed an application under Section 294 of the Cr.P.C. along
with the certified copies of certain documents obtained from the
Special Case No. 87/2020, pending before the learned Xth Special
Sessions Judge (NDPS), Raipur and prayed for a direction to the
prosecution either to admit the documents or to deny the same. On
10-09-2025, the prosecution filed its reply and thereafter, on 16-102025, the prosecution filed a supplementary reply to the application of
the petitioner. After hearing the parties, the learned trial court
dismissed the application of Section 294 of Cr.P.C. filed by the
petitioner vide order dated 12-11-2025. Hence, this petition.
3.
Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that the
petitioner was also arrested in Crime No. 232/2020, registered at the
police station Azad Chowk, Raipur, for the offence under the NDPS
Act, for which he is facing trial of Special Case (NDPS) No. 87/2020,
before the learned Special Judge (NDPS Act), Raipur. He has also
been falsely implicated in Crime No. 255/2020, registered at the
police station, Kotwali, Raipur, for which he is facing trial of Special
Case No. 98/2020, before the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Raipur.
In support of his defence, he filed certain certified copies of the
documents obtained from the Special Case (NDPS) No. 87/2020 and
filed in the Special Case No. 98/2020, along with an application under
Section 294 of the Cr.P.C. The prosecution is required to either admit
or deny the documents and in the absence thereof, the documents
submitted by the petitioner should be admitted in evidence from the
defence side without any formal proof. He would further submit that
the authenticity of the documents is admitted by the prosecution in
their reply, and therefore, the same should be admitted in evidence
and read as the evidence without any formal proof. He would further
submit that the prosecution, in its first reply filed on 10-09-2025,
admitted the genuineness of the documents, and in its second reply
filed on 16-10-2025, denied the documents on the ground that it
relates to another case. Directing for another reply to the prosecution
itself is violative of criminal procedure. The documents filed by the
petitioner are the certified copies of the exhibited documents filed in
Special Case No. 87/2020, pending before the learned Special Judge
(NDPS), Raipur. The learned trial Court, by invoking the powers under
Section 294 of the Cr.P.C., should have allowed the application and
dispensed with the petitioner/accused to prove the same. Once the
genuineness of the documents are not disputed, the documents
should be admitted in evidence without any formal proof, so that the
valuable time of the Court is not wasted. He would further submit that
there is no need to prove the certified copies of the documents by
summoning the witnesses from Odisha, which may delay the trial of
the case unnecessarily. Therefore, the impugned order may be setaside and the application of Section 294 of Cr.P.C. may be allowed.
He would rely on the judgments, reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC
2988 (Shyam Narayan Ram v. State of U.P. and Others), 1981 SCC
OnLine
Bom.
(Shaikh
Farid
Hussainsab
v.
State
of
Maharashtra) and 2017 (8) SCC 570 (Sonu @ Amar v. State of
Haryana).
4.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent/state opposes the
submissions of the petitioner and submits that the powers conferred
under Section 294 of the Cr.P.C. are not mandatory but discretionary
and do not override the principles of relevancy and admissibility. The
documents filed by the petitioner in the present case are certified
copies of the exhibited documents of the Special Case No. 87/2020,
pending before the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Raipur. Though
the issuance of certified copies is not disputed, the same cannot be
considered in the present case, as the documents relate to the
defence taken by the petitioner in the Special Case (NDPS) No.
87/2020. The learned trial Court rightly exercised its jurisdiction and
disposed of the application of the petitioner, holding that the
petitioner/accused is required to prove the documents, which is in
accordance with the law and does not require interference.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
annexed with the petition.
6.
The issue for consideration in the present case would be whether the
learned trial Court committed illegality in rejecting the application filed
by the petitioner/accused under Section 294 of the Cr.P.C. seeking
admission of the certified copies of the documents obtained from
another criminal case without formal proof.
7.
It is necessary here to notice the provision of Section 294 of the
Cr.P.C., which reads as under:-
“294. No formal proof of certain documents.—
(1) Where any document is filed before any
Court by the prosecution or the accused,
the particulars of every such document
shall be included in a list and the
prosecution or the accused, as the case
may be, or the pleader for the prosecution
or the accused, if any, shall be called upon
to admit or deny the genuineness of each
such document.
(2) The list of documents shall be in such
form as be prescribed by the State
Government.
(3)
Where
the
genuineness
of
any
document is not disputed, such document
may be read in evidence in inquiry, trial or
other proceeding under this Code without
proof of the signature of the person to
whom it purports to be signed:
Provided that the Court may, in its
discretion, require such signature to be
proved.”
8.
The powers under Section 294 of the Cr.P.C. is enabling and
procedural. It does not curtail the judicial discretion of the Court to
examine the admissibility of the documents. The learned trial Court
held that the petitioner/accused is required to prove the documents in
accordance with the law. The certified copies of the document sought
to be produced are obtained from Special Case (NDPS) No. 87/2020,
pending before the learned Special Judge (NDPS), Raipur. A criminal
trial of the case is inherently case-specific. The evidence led in a
particular prosecution is confined to the adjudication of the charge in
that case alone. As a general rule, evidence recorded in one criminal
proceeding does not automatically become evidence in another
proceeding, even if it involves the same accused or arises out of
related transactions.
9.
Section 27 of Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (Section 33 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872) provides that-
“27.
Relevancy
of
certain
evidence
for
proving, in subsequent proceeding, truth of
facts therein stated. - Evidence given by a
witness in a judicial proceeding, or before any
person authorised by law to take it, is relevant for
the purpose of proving, in a subsequent judicial
proceeding, or in a later stage of the same judicial
proceeding, the truth of the facts which it states,
when the witness is dead or cannot be found, or
is incapable of giving evidence, or is kept out of
the way by the adverse party, or if his presence
cannot be obtained without an amount of delay or
expense which, under the circumstances of the
case, the Court considers unreasonable:
Provided that the proceeding was between the
same parties or their representatives in interest;
that the adverse party in the first proceeding had
the right and opportunity to cross-examine and
the questions in issue were substantially the
same in the first as in the second proceeding.
Explanation.—A criminal trial or inquiry shall be
deemed to be a proceeding between the
prosecutor and the accused within the meaning of
this Section.”
10.
Section 33 of the evidence act provides that the evidence given by a
witness in a judicial proceeding may be relevant in a subsequent
proceeding if the proceeding was between the same parties or their
representatives in interest, the opposite party has a right to cross
examine the witness, the issue were substantially the same and the
witness cannot be found or incapable to give evidence. The
admission of genuineness under Section 294 of the Cr.P.C. dispenses
only with formal proof, not with proof of relevance or substantive
admissibility. The documents sought to be produced are certified
copies and are public documents as defined under Sections 74 and
76 of the Evidence Act, 1872 {Sections 74(1) and 75 of the Bhartiya
Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023}. The certified copies of the public
documents may be admissible to prove the contents of those
documents; however, the admissibility of a certified copy does not
automatically establish its relevance to the issue in the new case. The
petitioner/accused must establish the relevance and the admissibility
of the documents. Unless these requirements are satisfied, evidence
from one criminal proceeding cannot be imported into another merely
by filing certified copies or invoking Section 294 of the Cr.P.C.
11.
Accordingly, while Section 294 Cr.P.C. enables the Court to dispense
with formal proof where genuineness is admitted, it does not obviate
the necessity of establishing relevance and substantive admissibility
under the Evidence Act. The petitioner/accused must lay the
foundational basis showing how the documents are relevant to the
facts in issue and legally admissible in the present proceeding. Unless
these twin requirements are satisfied, evidence from one criminal
case cannot be imported into another merely by filing certified copies
or invoking Section 294 Cr.P.C.
12.
Under Sections 74 and 76 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
(corresponding to Sections 74(1) and 75 of the Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023), judicial records of Courts are public documents
and certified copies thereof may be produced in proof of their
contents. Such certified copies are admissible without calling the
original record. However, the admissibility of a certified copy as
secondary evidence of a public document does not, by itself, establish
that the contents are relevant in a different proceeding. In “Kaliya v.
State of Madhya Pradesh”, 2013 (10) SCC 758, the Supreme Court
reiterated that admissibility and proof are distinct from relevancy; a
document may be proved in accordance with law, yet remain
irrelevant to the matter in issue.
“13. Section 65(c) of the 1872 Act provides that
secondary evidence can be adduced relating to a
document when the original has been destroyed
or lost, or when the party offering evidence of its
contents cannot, for any other reason, not arising
from his own default, or neglect, produce it in
reasonable time. The court is obliged to examine
the probative value of documents produced in the
court or their contents and decide the question of
admissibility
of
a
document
in
secondary
evidence. (Vide H. Siddiqui (Dead) By Lrs. v. Α.
Ramalingam. (2011) 4 SCC 240 and Rasiklal
Manikchand Dhariwal v. M.S.S Food Products
(2012) 2 SCC 196.) However, the secondary
evidence of an ordinary document is admissible
only and only when the party desirous of
admitting it has proved before the court that it
was not in his possession or control of it and
further, that he has done what could be done to
procure the production of it. Thus, the party has to
account for the non-production in one of the ways
indicated in the section. The party further has to
lay down the factual foundation to establish the
right to give secondary evidence where the
original document cannot be produced. When the
party gives in evidence a certified copy/secondary
evidence without proving the circumstances
entitling him to give secondary evidence, the
opposite party must raise an objection at the time
of ad-mission. In case, an objection is not raised
at that point of time, it is precluded from being
raised
at
a
belated
stage.
Further,
mere
admission of a document in evidence does not
amount to its proof. Nor mere marking of exhibit
on a document does not dispense with its proof,
which is otherwise required to be done in
accordance with law. (Vide Roman Catholic
Mission v. State of Madras AIR 1966 SC 1457,
Marwari
Kumhar
v.
Bhagwanpuri
Guru
Ganeshpuri (2000) 6 SCC 735, AIR 2000 SC
2629, R.V.E Venkatachala Gounder v. Arulmigu
Viswesaraswami and V.P Temple (2003) 8 SCC
752, AIR 2003 SC 4548, Dayamathi Bai (Smt) v.
K.M Shaffi. (2004) 7 SCC 107, AIR 2004 SC 4082
and LIC v. Ram Pal Singh Bisen (2010) 4 SCC
491)
14. In M. Chandra v. M. Thangamuthu (2010) 9
SCC 712 this Court considered this aspect in
detail and held as under:
"47. We do not agree with the reasoning of
the High Court. It is true that a party who
wishes to rely upon the contents of a
document must adduce primary evidence
of the contents, and only in the exceptional
cases
will
secondary
evidence
admissible.
However,
if
be
secondary
evidence is admissible, it may be adduced
in any form in which it may be available,
whether by production of a copy, duplicate
copy of a copy, by oral evidence of the
contents or in another form. The secondary
evidence
must
be
authenticated
by
foundational evidence that the alleged copy
is in fact a true copy of the original. It
should be emphasised that the exceptions
to the rule requiring primary evidence are
designed to provide relief in a case where a
party is genuinely unable to produce the
original through no fault of that party."
A similar view has been reiterated in J.
Yashoda v. K. Shobha Rani. (2007) 5 SCC
730, AIR 2007 SC 1721.”
13.
In the case of Shyam Narayan Ram (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court was dealing with a situation where certain documents were filed
during trial, and their genuineness was not disputed by the
prosecution. The controversy before the Court primarily concerned
the effect of Section 294 Cr.P.C. and whether, once genuineness is
admitted, the party tendering the document is still required to formally
prove it by examining a witness. The Court reiterated the settled
principle that when the opposite party does not dispute the
genuineness of a document, formal proof can be dispensed with in
order to avoid unnecessary delay in trial. The emphasis was on
preventing procedural technicalities from defeating substantive
justice; however, the present case stands on a materially different
footing. Here, the documents sought to be relied upon are certified
copies of documents from another criminal case. The prosecution has
objected not merely to the mode of proof, but to the relevance and
applicability of those documents in the present trial. In Shyam
Narayan Ram (supra), there was no dispute regarding the relevance
of the documents to the case in which they were produced. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court did not lay down any proposition that
documents from one criminal proceeding automatically become
admissible in another merely upon admission of genuineness. The
judgment does not dilute the settled distinction between dispensing
with formal proof and establishing relevance and substantive
admissibility. Accordingly, the ratio of Shyam Narayan Ram (supra) is
confined to cases where the document is otherwise relevant and
admissible in the same proceeding, and therefore, it does not
advance the petitioner’s case in the present factual matrix.
14.
In the case of Shaikh Farid Hussainsab (supra), the Bombay High
Court was concerned with the scope and object of Section 294
Cr.P.C. and emphasised that where the genuineness of a document is
not disputed, the Court should ordinarily dispense with formal proof to
avoid unnecessary delay in trial. The controversy in that case
pertained to documents produced within the same proceeding, whose
authenticity was not in question, and the objection, if any, related
merely to formal proof. However, the present case stands on a
different footing for the following reasons: the documents were part of
the same prosecution and were directly connected to the issues under
adjudication. In contrast, the documents sought to be relied upon here
are certified copies of records from an entirely separate criminal case.
Their mere existence as judicial records does not establish their
relevance to the present trial, and they did not hold that admission of
genuineness under Section 294 Cr.P.C. automatically renders a
document relevant or admissible irrespective of its nexus to the facts
in issue. Section 294 only dispenses with formal proof of a document
whose genuineness is admitted; it does not override the foundational
requirement that the document must be legally relevant under the
Evidence Act. Shaikh Farid Hussainsab’s case (supra) did not deal
with such a situation, nor did it authorise the automatic transposition
of evidence from one criminal case into another.
15.
In Sonu @ Amar (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court was primarily
concerned with the admissibility of electronic evidence and the effect
of failure to object to the mode of proof at the appropriate stage of
trial. The objection raised before the Hon’ble Supreme Court related
to non-compliance with the requirement of a certificate under Section
65B of the Evidence Act. The Court held that an objection regarding
the mode or method of proof must be taken at the time the evidence
is tendered, and if not so raised, such objection may be treated as
waived. The ruling thus clarified the distinction between (i) objections
relating to the mode of proof and (ii) objections relating to inherent
admissibility.
16.
The controversy in the present case, however, is not about waiver of
objection to the mode of proof. Here, the prosecution has objected to
the very relevance and substantive admissibility of the documents
sought to be introduced from another criminal proceeding. The issue
is whether certified copies of judicial records from a separate trial can
automatically be read as evidence in the present case merely
because their genuineness is not disputed. This raises a question of
substantive admissibility and relevance, not merely of procedural
proof. Further, in Sonu @ Amar (supra), the evidence in question was
tendered in the same trial in which it was relied upon. The Court did
not deal with a situation involving the transposition of evidence from
one criminal case into another without satisfying statutory conditions
such as those contemplated under Section 33 of the Evidence Act.
The judgment does not lay down that admission of genuineness or
absence of objection under Section 294 Cr.P.C. dispenses with the
foundational requirement of proving relevance.
17.
In the present case, the prosecution had admitted in its reply dated
10-09-2025 that the certified copies of the documents were obtained
from the Special Case No. 87/2020. In its reply dated 16-10-2025, the
prosecution/state has denied the documents as it relates to another
case. It is the documents on which the defence relied his case and
marked as a defence document in another criminal case. Para 3 of
the reply dated 16-10-2025 is relevant to be reproduced here, which
reads as under:-
“3- यह कि , अभि यक्त
कि
04 ेሰ वेቓኌ त
कि , आवेद
ओर से ्ቚस्तत आवेदन प्ቔ
थन
सेबंध ेሰ ्ቢ्ቖ कि य जा त ह&
अभि यक्त ቛኋ र ्ቚस्तत उक्त आवेदन अन्य ्ቚ र
से सेबंधिधत ह+न
18.
र स्वे,
र य+ग्य नह. ह&।”
From the foregoing discussion, it is clear that Section 294 of the
Cr.P.C. is procedural in nature and its scope is limited to dispensing
with
the formal
proof
of
genuineness of
a
document
whose
authenticity is not disputed. It does not dispense with the foundational
requirement
that
the
document
must
be relevant
and
admissible under the Evidence Act. Even if certified copies of public
documents
are
filed,
the petitioner/accused
and
must
their
still
genuineness
establish
the
is
admitted,
relevance
and
admissibility of those documents in the context of the issues in the
present trial. Documents from another criminal proceeding cannot
automatically be treated as substantive evidence merely because
Section 294 Cr.P.C. is invoked; their admissibility depends on
compliance with statutory requirements and proof of their connection
to the facts in issue.
19.
The judgments relied upon by the petitioner—Shyam Narayan Ram,
Shaikh Farid Hussainsab, and Sonu @ Amar (supra) deal with
situations
where
documents
were
tendered
in
the same
proceeding and their genuineness was not disputed. None of these
judgments permits the automatic importation of evidence from one
criminal trial to another without establishing relevance and compliance
with statutory safeguards.
20.
Therefore, the learned trial Court rightly exercised its discretion in
requiring the petitioner to prove the documents in accordance with the
law. Section 294 Cr.P.C. cannot be invoked to bypass the essential
principles of relevancy and admissibility, and the impugned order
rejecting the application under Section 294 Cr.P.C. does not warrant
interference.
21.
Accordingly,
the
present
Criminal
Miscellaneous
Petition
dismissed.
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
ved
is
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review